Riskilaste konverents 2012: Tonje Holt: Treating traumatized children
Riskilaste konverents 2012: Maire Riis: Emdr and children
1. EMDR with traumatized
children
3.October 2012
1
Maire Riis
Crisis Program for Children and Youth
Laste ja Noorte Kriisiprogramm MTÜ
maire@lastekriis.ee
2. Crisis Program for Children and Youth
since 1994 (ferry “Estonia” disaster)
Supporting children and families traumatized by
the death of the close family member
Working in individual and group settings
With other childhood traumas
Acute crisis intervention
Teaching
2
3. Trauma in Childhood has long effects
Adverse Childhood Experience Study (ACE)
(n=17,000) (Felitti, et al., 1998)
Divorce
Not just emotional distress
Death of parent
4 or more ACE
Yelling
more likely cancer, heart disease,
Neglect
more likely drugs, alcohol, suicide
Parent using alcohol / drugs
Parent with mental health problem
(e.g.bipolar, PTSD)
7 or more ACE
Sexual abuse even if no drinking, smoking, overeating
Physical punishment 360% higher heart disease than 0
Domestic violence
Verbal abuse + witnessing violence > sexual abuse
without verbal abuse & witnessing violence
(Teicher et al. (2006). Sticks, Stones, and Hurtful Words: Relative Effects of
Various Forms of Childhood Maltreatment)
4. Eye movement desensitization and
reprocessing (EMDR) overview
Trauma-focused psychoterapeutic approach
originated by Francine Shapiro (first study 1989)
Integrative psychotherapeutic model
elements of many psychotherapeutic schools as
psychodynamic, cognitive behavioural, client-centered, body-
centered
Treatment follows structured protocol
Often limited amount of sessions
Length of treatment depends on complexity of clinical
picture
Originally developed for adults but is easily adjusted for
children 4
5. EMDR for whom
Adults and children – for both
Adjust according to the developmental level of the child !
Painful memories from
Traumatizing experiences
After disasters and terror attacks
Traumatic memories after bereavement
Other disturbing memories that have not been
processed
Recent research has also revealed that other, less dramatic
life experiences can cause even more symptoms of PTSD than
major traumas (F.Shapiro, 2012)
Individual- and group setting
Good results for children groups while adding drawing 5
F.Shapiro, in press, 2012
6. International treatment guidelines
Effective Treatments for PTSD
The European Network of Traumatic Stress Studies - TENTS (2010)
International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies – ISTSS (2009)
EMDR and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) equivalent efficacy
– Level A rating
American Psychiatric Association – APA (2004)
Department of Veterans Affairs & Department of Defense (2010)
NICE - National Institute for Clinical Excellence,UK(2005)
National Institute of Health and Medical Research, France (2004)
National Board of Health and Welfare, Sweden (2010)
www.emdr-europe.org 6
7. Research
Many randomized controlled trials for EMDR during 20
years
The first-line psychological treatment for chronic PTSD should
be trauma-focused CBT or EMDR” (Bisson et al, 2007)
“EMDR is an effective treatment for PTSD, and equally
effective as exposure-based therapies” (Spates, et al, 2009).
For children fewer studies – Level B rating (ISTSS)
Rodenburg, G., Benjamin, A., de Roos, C., Meijer, A.N., &
Stams, G.J, (November 2009). Efficacy of EMDR with children:
A meta-analysis. In Clinical Psychology Review Issue 7 599 –
606.
More studies need to be completed for EMDR adapted for use
with children and adolescents.
7
http://consults.blogs.nytimes.com/references-on-e-m-d-r/
8. EMDR approach
Adaptive Information Processing Model:
The cornerstone of the EMDR approach:
memory networks are the basis of clinical
symptoms and of mental health
The goal is to let the brain’s information
processing system make new internal
connections as the client focuses on the
thoughts, emotions, memories and other
associations that are freely made during the
sets of bilateral stimulation.
8
9. EMDR as a therapeutic method
Treatment focuses on how trauma affects present
functioning
Processing includes working on one trauma memory
at a time
Bilateral stimulation accompanies the client’s
processing
Therapist guides client through the process
Children reprocess their traumas more quickly
Parents are involved in the process
9
10. An eight phase approach
Phase 4 – 6 unique to EMDR treatment
1. History taking phase
2. Preparation phase
3. Assessment phase
4. Desensitization phase
5. Installation phase
6. Body scan phase
7. Closure phase
8. Re-evaluation phase
10
11. What happens during EMDR?
Traumatic memory EMDR Memory
Less disturbing
Associated with disturbing Image
Image Positive Cognition
Cognitions Appropriate Affect
Affect without disturbing
Physical Sensations Physical Sensations
(fragmented, not integrated)
The past is present The past is past
11
12. What does EMDR session look like
Phase 3 Assessment: (in connection to the memory)
Memory:
Father and grandmother fighting
Worst part of the memory (image):
I get scared, ´cause I don´t see my dad anymore
Negative thoughts about oneself I can´t stand it
(for child: mixed-up thoughts):
(a “way out”)
Positive thoughts
(for child: good thoughts about yourself) I can handle it
Emotions and body sensations:
(for child: feeling-detector)
I feel depressed, sad
in my head, heart and stomach 12
Certain scales are added to measure disturbance...
13. Phase 4: Desensitization
The information processing system of the brain is
stimulated so the memory can be transformed into an
adaptive learning experience.
Reprocessing (appropriate for the age) using bilateral
stimulation until memory feels completely neutral:
Eye movements (fingers, puppet)
Tapping
Tones
After processing linking neutral memory to a psotive
statement a positive sense of self can emerge
It´s not my fault, I am strong
It doesn´t bother me anymore
13
14. EMDR and children in Europe
EMDR is being used in Europe to help children and
adolescents with a wide range of anxiety-related
problems, including single trauma, phobias,
nightmares, school-related anxieties, bullying,
medical problems, enuresis, social anxieties and
fears, attachment problems, sexual and physical
abuse, bonding, bereavement and depression.
(J.Morris-Smith, 2007)
14
J.Morris-Smith, 2007. EMDR and children: Europe leads the way, Therapy for today, Vol8, 3.