NTSB Meteorologist, Donald Eick, talks about how important understanding weather is in safely planning and executing general aviation flight operations
3. 3
• Review Part 91 accident statisticsReview Part 91 accident statistics
– Main weather threat areasMain weather threat areas
– ThunderstormsThunderstorms
• Making weather wise decisionsMaking weather wise decisions
– Preflight weather briefingPreflight weather briefing
– Utilizing briefing sourcesUtilizing briefing sources
– UpdatesUpdates
– Weather in the cockpitWeather in the cockpit
Topics that will be discussed:Topics that will be discussed:
4. 4
NTSB Accident Statistics
• 4,958 accidents
• 1,641 fatalities
• Weather was
cited as a cause
or factor in over
20% of these
accidents
5. 5
NTSB Study 2007-2009
• > 60% Part 91 accidents involved
personal flights with fixed-wing aircraft
• Major CAST defining events:
– Loss of control in flight/ground (LOC)
– Abnormal runway contact
– Controlled flight into terrain
– Unintended flight into IMC
– Thunderstorms/Windshear
7. 7
Part 91 Weather Related Accidents
• Leading weather factors:
– Adverse winds
– Low ceilings & visibility
– High density altitude
– Aircraft icing; includes carburetor icing
– Turbulence
– Thunderstorms
– Windshear
– Precipitation; rain, snow, drizzle/mist, hail
8. 8
ADVERSE WINDS
ACCOUNTS FOR ~52% OF WEATHERACCOUNTS FOR ~52% OF WEATHER
RELATED ACCIDENTS:RELATED ACCIDENTS:
• HIGH WINDHIGH WIND
• CROSSWINDCROSSWIND
• TAILWINDTAILWIND
• GUSTSGUSTS
• WIND SHIFTSWIND SHIFTS
• VARIABLE WINDVARIABLE WIND
9. 9
Weather Related Accidents
Weather related accidents have one ofWeather related accidents have one of
the highest fatality rates!the highest fatality rates!
13. 13
Preflight Planning
NTSB study 41% of the weather relatedNTSB study 41% of the weather related
accidents the pilot did not obtain oraccidents the pilot did not obtain or
received an adequate weather briefingreceived an adequate weather briefing
14. 14
“I looked at the destination forecast and it
indicated VFR conditions?”
Departure Destination
• What about the en route conditions?
• When was the forecast issued?
• Any adverse weather predicted?
• What’s in the surrounding area?
15. 15
Say… what’s a mountain goat doingSay… what’s a mountain goat doing
way up here in a cloud bank?way up here in a cloud bank?
16. 16
FOG
Not a violent or dynamic weather eventNot a violent or dynamic weather event!!
Most common cause of Part 91 weather relatedMost common cause of Part 91 weather related
fatalities - VFR into IMC conditions.fatalities - VFR into IMC conditions.
Number 1 cause of ATC delaysNumber 1 cause of ATC delays
Common factor in runway incursion incidents &Common factor in runway incursion incidents &
accidents.accidents.
Common factor in Part 135/121 CFIT accidentsCommon factor in Part 135/121 CFIT accidents
Flight crew not adhering to standard instrumentFlight crew not adhering to standard instrument
approach procedures.approach procedures.
Low Ceilings & Visibility
18. 18
Worst Aircraft Accident in History
KLM Flight 4805/Pan Am Flight 1736KLM Flight 4805/Pan Am Flight 1736
Los Rodeos Airport, TenerifeLos Rodeos Airport, Tenerife
March 27, 1977March 27, 1977
21. 21
ERA09LA392
RV7A, N774US
Sanderson, FL
July 8, 2009
• Non-instrument rated pilot
• Departed VFR cross country to pickup friend
and fly back to Sun City, FL
• No flight plan or preflight briefing
• Departure/destination - VFR
22. 22
ERA09LA392 – Sanderson, FL
• Current conditions:
– Stationary front
– Convective activity
• Encountered area of
thunderstorms
• Low overcast ceilings,
rain and thunder
reported by witness
WX 240º 5KT 2 1/2SM TSRA BKN010 OVC020 23/22
A2990 RMK TSB14 OCNL LTGCG TS S MOV E
27. 27
Safety, better to think about itSafety, better to think about it
down here than worry about itdown here than worry about it
up there!up there!
28. 28
• Automated Flight Service Station (AFSS)Automated Flight Service Station (AFSS)
1-800-WX-BRIEF*1-800-WX-BRIEF*
• Direct User Access Terminal ServiceDirect User Access Terminal Service
(DUATS)*(DUATS)*
• Internet sourcesInternet sources
• Private VenderPrivate Vender
• * Only recognized official sources* Only recognized official sources
Weather Briefing SourcesWeather Briefing Sources
29. 29
• Adverse weatherAdverse weather
• SynopsisSynopsis
• Current conditionsCurrent conditions
• En route forecastEn route forecast
• Destination forecastDestination forecast
• Alternate planningAlternate planning
• Winds aloftWinds aloft
• Notice to AirmenNotice to Airmen
AFSS Standard Briefing
31. 31
Internet Sources
• Official NWS site
• Domestic &
International
products
• Text & graphical
products
http://aviationweather.gov/
Note chart – quick
indications of
IFR/MVFR/VFR areas,
turbulence, and icing
33. 33
Aviation Weather Services
AC 00-45GAC 00-45G
• Basic reference guide how to
read and interpret all NWS
weather products.
• Listed as required knowledge
in FAA Airmen test guides.
http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/
42. 42
Weather Watch (AWW)
WW 80 TORNADO FL CW 311000Z - 311700Z AXIS..75
STATUTE MILES EAST AND WEST OF LINE.. 20NE
OCF/OCALA FL/ - 55WSW PBI/WEST PALM BEACH FL/
..AVIATION COORDS.. 65NM E/W /46W OMN - 48NW MIA/
HAIL SURFACE AND ALOFT..2 INCHES. WIND GUSTS..60
KNOTS. MAX TOPS TO 550. MEAN STORM MOTION
VECTOR 25040.
Discussion..an ongoing Quasi-Linear ComplexDiscussion..an ongoing Quasi-Linear Complex
of strong/severe TSTMS including embeddedof strong/severe TSTMS including embedded
supercells and bow echoes moving eastwardsupercells and bow echoes moving eastward
across central Florida. Conditions favorable foracross central Florida. Conditions favorable for
damaging winds and a few tornadoes.damaging winds and a few tornadoes.
54. 54
• Forecasts are not always perfect!Forecasts are not always perfect!
• Weather conditions changeWeather conditions change – is there a– is there a
front expected in the vicinity, convectionfront expected in the vicinity, convection
expected, night or early morning arrival?expected, night or early morning arrival?
Get an update!Get an update!
• Flight WatchFlight Watch
• HIWAS & other weather broadcastsHIWAS & other weather broadcasts
In-flight Briefing
55. 55
Weather Update
• NWS products are updated at
regular intervals
– TAFs updated 6-hr, AMD as necessary
– Convective SIGMETs – hourly 55
– AIRMETs – every 6-hr, AMD
– SIGMETs - unscheduled
– Weather Watches
• PIREPs
57. 57
En Route Flight Advisory Service
(EFAS)
• EFAS radio call “Flight Watch”
• Available 0600-2200 local
• Below FL180 on 122.0 MHz
• Discrete frequencies above FL180
58. 58
Weather in the Cockpit
• Access to updated weather en route
• Increased situational awareness
• Caution with data lag (NEXRAD)
• Spatial resolution of data
60. 60
Conditions worst than expected?Conditions worst than expected?
Make a command decision – divert,Make a command decision – divert,
alter plan, turn backalter plan, turn back
Wait it out & take a breakWait it out & take a break
Consider: frontal position, prevailingConsider: frontal position, prevailing
wind, convection, time of daywind, convection, time of day
Don’t push a bad situation!
62. 62
Why is the Thunderstorm the most
Dangerous Aviation Weather
Hazard?
The greatest number of aviationThe greatest number of aviation
weather hazards are bundled up in oneweather hazards are bundled up in one
single source, the thunderstorm.single source, the thunderstorm.
68. 68
CEN09FA369
Cessna 182, N1826T
Dougherty, TX
June 18, 2009
• VFR cross country
• No weather briefing/flight
plan filed
• Witnesses reported
blowing dust & high
gusting winds at the time
• Loss of control in flight
after encountered
thunderstorm gust front
• Fatal 2
KLBB 26037G51KT 3/4SM BLDU SCT030 BKN070
24/14 A2990 RMK CB DSNT W-NW
Coding structure developed by the ICAO Commercial Aviation Safety Team (CAST) to describe the important circumstances of aviation accidents, rather than the probable cause.
Update to match March 31, 2011 thunderstorm event at 1800Z for Sun ‘n’ Fun