TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
Literature review
1. Review of the Related
Literature
Organizing & Writing a Literature
Review
2. The Literature Review is…
• A discussion of your
knowledge about the
topic under study
• A discussion of your
knowledge that is
supported by the
research literature
• A foundation for the
study
3. The Literature Review is not…
• A study-by-study, or
article-by-article,
description of studies
previously done
• A re-statement of the
studies previously
done
• A brief overview of
articles
4. Reviewing the Literature
Begin with a search of
the available literature
Critically analyze each
article (study) you select
Organize the review
with an outline
Write the review
Summarize the review
Using the literature,
present a rationale for
your study
5. Critically Analyzing the Literature
Abstract
the author’s description of
the study
related to your area of
interest?
conclusions relevant?
Statement of the
Problem
restate the topic
problem stated clearly?
purpose?
significance?
Hypothesis or
Research Question(s)
Clearly stated?
Relevant?
Related to your area of
interest?
Assumptions
Explicit assumptions?
Implicit assumptions
Similar to yours?
6. Critically Analyzing the Literature
Delimitations
How was the study
narrowed?
Which considerations
are relevant to your
study?
Definitions
Key concepts &
terms?
7. Critically Analyzing the Literature
Method
research design?
population & sample?
measurement?
procedures?
Findings
make sense?
what do they say about
your area of interest?
Discussion
Presented clearly?
Meaningful interpretations?
Implications discussed?
Suggestions or
recommendations?
Limits to practical
application?
Conclusion
What did you learn?
Re-state your new knowledge
8. Organizing the Literature Search:
the Tree Diagram
subtopic
Topic
subtopic
subtopic
subtopic
subtopic
subtopic
subtopic
9. Tree Diagram Example
Home visits
Academic
achievement
Homework
assistance
Home-school
communication
Parent
involvement
volunteerism
barriers
Teachers’ beliefs
Involvement in
decision making
10. Tree to Outline Format:
Home Visits
I. Home-school
Communication
II. Academic
Achievement
III. Parent Involvement
A. Barriers to parent
involvement
IV. Volunteerism
A. Barriers to
volunteerism
Look! An
example!
11. Writing the Literature ReviewWriting the Literature Review
Always begin with an
introduction to the
review & end with a
summary
Make the connection
for the reader between
the subtopics & the
topic
Use direct quotations
infrequently
Always cite your
sources
Present your
knowledge on the
topics & subtopics
Summarize each
subtopic
Include a transition
paragraph from one
subtopic to the next
12. •Reiterate the
research problem
•Introduce the sub-
topics
Introduction
Example
paragraph 1
The purpose of this
study is to determine
the effect of poor
coordination on the
effective delivery of
consultant services.
•Effective organiza-
tional structures
•Service coordination
practices
•Consultants’ profes-
sional support needs
Example
paragraph 2
Organizing the Literature Review
13. First Subtopic
Discussion should in-
clude:
• How is the subtopic
connected to the
problem?
• Your knowledge,
based on the literature
you have studied
• Specify subtopics (if
any)
• Summary & transition
•Mission & Pur-
pose
•Goals &
objectives
(planning)
•Task units
So, given all that,
yaddah, yaddah, it
is important to
note the role of…
Effective
Organizational
Structures
In order for the coor-
dination of services to
be effective, a struc-
ture must exist within
which service units are
organized and can
operate. Yaddah,
yaddah, yaddah…
Long range strategic
planning characterizes
organizations with ef-
fective internal struc-
tures (Brown, 1997).
Key to such an effort is
the identification of…
14. Writing
Use APA style & format
Have your work proofread before
submitting
Follow all format guidelines
Must be a thorough review, reflected by the
depth of the discussion
Should begin prior to the implementation
of the study
Notas del editor
The Literature Review is a discussion of your knowledge of the research related to your topic of study. It is not a study-by-study, or article-by-article, rendering! The Literature Review should provide the reader with a foundation for the study.