2. A Presentation by Robert Brosnan
Planning Director, Arlington County
ULI Fall Conference
October 15, 2010
40 Years of Smart Growth
Arlington County’s Experience with Transit Oriented
Development in the Rosslyn-Ballston Metro Corridor
3. PRESENTATION OVERVIEW
Review of Arlington’s
efforts to use transit
to both redevelop an
older commercial
corridor and ensure
future riders for the
system
How we planned
Identify some of the
successes and
lessons learned
4. Smart Growth
Smart growth represents the desire
for another form of growth
Well planned development
Convenient and walkable places
Transit accessible with a robust menu of
transportation options
Preserves open spaces
Efficiently uses existing infrastructure
Offers alternatives to automobiles
5. Smart Growth
Arlington has been in the forefront
of this trend for over 40 years
We used the opportunity of transit
to reshape an older, inner suburb
into a thriving urban village with
over 37 million sq. ft. of new
development and a reduction in
auto traffic
6. SETTING THE STAGE
Arlington is a 26 square
mile, urban county which
was a part of the original
District of Columbia
Population 212,200
Jobs 207,800
Housing units 105,428
Located in the core of a
rapidly growing
Washington region (over
5 million residents, 3
million jobs and 1,200
sq. miles of urbanized
area)
7. SETTING THE STAGE
1960 - 7.5 million sq. Ft.
Office
Declining retail corridors
Emerging market for
government office space
Strong single family
neighborhoods
Large number of garden
apartments, some of
which were beginning to
decline
97,505 jobs
71,230 housing units
1962
8. SETTING THE STAGE
Beginning of the planning
for a regional transit
system
Embarked on an ambitious
community planning effort
Debated the impacts of
development vs the
benefits of growth and
decided we wanted to
encourage growth as well
as encourage riders
9. PROPOSED ROUTE
Arlington lobbied strongly for an underground route along the old
commercial corridor vs along the median of future highway
Proposed
Route
Approved
Route
10. Development Concepts
Concentrate high and mid-
density redevelopment around
transit stations (highly
targeted) and taper down to
existing neighborhoods
Encourage a mix of uses and
services in station areas
Create high quality pedestrian
environments and enhanced
open space
Preserve and reinvest in
established residential
neighborhoods
11. SECTOR PLANS
Adopted a corridor-wide GLUP based on agreed-to
development goals
Then focused on developing sector plans to
create distinctive “urban villages”
Overall vision for each station area
Conceptual Plan
Development framework
Establish street network
Urban design standards
Densities and heights
12. KEY TO SUCCESS
Do the planning - Involve the community
Residents
Business community
Developers
Political will and support
Plans that result have community buy-in
Plans that set expectations for both the community
and developers – avoids the fights later
Continued outreach and education
15. MEASURING SUCCESS
1991
ROSSLYN
13,637
COURT HOUSE
5,561
CLARENDON
2,964
BALLSTON
9,482
2009
ROSSLYN
33,382
COURT HOUSE
14,636
CLARENDON
8,787
BALLSTON
24,751
METRO RIDERSHIP (Average daily entries and exits)
16. BALANCED DEVELOPMENT =
BALANCED RIDERSHIP
A M P e a kA M O f fP M P e a kP M O f f
T i m e P e r i o d s
0
5
1 0
1 5
2 0
2 5
3 0
3 5
Thousands
Passengers
E n t r i e s
E x i t s
Arlington Metrorail Stations
R id e r s h ip b y T im e P e r io d
MEASURING SUCCESS
17. PEDESTRIAN ACCESS
73% WALK TO STATION
5 R-B Corridor Stations
73.0%
7.5%
3.6%
12.9%
2.0%
1.0%
Walk
Metrobus
Other
Bus/Vanpool
Auto (incl. Drop-
off)
Other
No Response
18. MEASURING SUCCESS
Car ownership (vehicles per household)
Nationally, almost 90% have a car;
55% have 2 or more
Arlington: 12% have zero cars;
less than 40% have 2 or more
Metro Corridors: 17.9% have zero cars,
while less than 25% have 2 or more
Source – 2000 Census
21. MEASURING SUCCESS
Street
Segment
Street Type 1996 2001 2006 % Change
1996-2006
Lee Hwy -
Rosslyn
EW 6-lane
arterial
37,770 33,632 32,428 -14.1%
Wash. Blvd –
VA Sq.
EW 4-lane
arterial
20,469 19,478 18,069 -11.8%
Clarendon
Blvd.
EW 2-lane 1-
way arterial
13,980 14,199 14,539 4%
Wilson Blvd. -
Clarendon
EW 2-lane 1-
way arterial
16,368 16,265 13,797 -15.8%
Arlington Blvd. EW 6-lane
arterial
55,865 63,272 60,223 7.8%
Glebe Road -
Ballston
NS 6-lane
arterial
35,230 39,409 35,900 1.2%
G. Mason Drive
– west of
Ballston
NS 4-lane
arterial
20,002 22,578 23,386 16.9%
Traffic Trends on Arterial Streets
22. MEASURING SUCCESS
$27.5 billion of a total $57.5 billion in assessed
land and improvements value in the county is in
the metro corridors which is 11% of total land
Today Arlington has more office space than
downtown
Dallas
Los Angeles
Denver
Boston
23. LESSONS LEARNED
Transit investments can be used as a
catalyst to reshape communities
Multimodal transportation strategies can
result in substantial benefits – allowing
continued growth with less reliance on
autos
Establish the vision, design supportive
public policies/plans and tools and be
patient
Build community consensus
24. LESSON LEARNED
Ensure that transit is integrated with
development – not secondary
An attractive and functional pedestrian
environment is important
Develop public-private partnerships to continue
consensus building and assist in the
implementation
Integrity of plan – be consistent
Do the detailed planning at the sector area to
avoid the battles at development review time
33. View looking northeast from Randolph Street
Original Site
Liberty Center
Arlington, VA
Three 12- Story Office
Buildings
530,000 SF
Originally built in
1960’s
Leased to GSA
Fairfax Dr.
34. View looking northeast from Randolph Street
Liberty Center
Concept
Liberty Center
Arlington, VA
Transit- Oriented
Redevelopment
Mixed Use
2 Office Buildings and
2 Residential
Buildings
Open Space
Ground Floor Retail
with Streetscape
elements and seating
35. View looking northeast from Randolph Street
Liberty Center
Arlington, VA
One Liberty Center:
Secure facility
Total 316,000 SF
Thirteen stories
Two Liberty Center:
Total 180,000 SF
Nine stories
The Residences at Liberty
Center:
233 Condo units
Twenty one stories
Liberty Tower:
235 Rental units
Twenty one stories
38. Transit Oriented
Development
Pedestrian Environment
– Quincy Plan Linkage
Across Wilson Blvd.
from Liberty Center
LEED Goals
View looking southeast from Wilson Boulevard
Founders Square
Arlington, VA
Site Plan
39. View looking northeast from Randolph Street
Site Plan
Office South
Founders Square
Arlington, VA
Secure Facility – 82’ secure
perimeter
Total: 355,530 GSF
Parking – 517 Spaces
Thirteen Stories
LEED- Gold Core & Shell and
LEED- Platinum Commercial
Interiors
40. 18 stories (approved 15)
382,400 GSF
(approved 312,660)
374,730 SF office
(approved 299,760)
7,670 SF retail
(approved 8,000)
457 parking spaces
(approved 485)
LEED Gold Proposed
View looking southeast from Wilson Boulevard
Founders Square
Arlington, VA
Site Plan
Office North
41. View looking west along Wilson
Residential North
Founders Square
Arlington, VA
Site Plan
Density: 238,060 GSF
(approved 251,960)
Residential – 256 Units
(approved 198)
Retail – 9,035 GSF
(approved 8,900)
Parking – 272 Spaces
(approved 244)
LEED Silver
42. Founders Square
Arlington, VA
Residential South- Hotel
View looking south west along Wilson Boulevard
Site Plan
183 Room Marriott
Residence Inn
Parking – 106
Spaces
Ground Floor Retail
LEED Silver
43. Plaza
Features
Level central paved
space for events
Double row of trees
Continuous retail frontage
wrapping onto Wilson
Blvd.
Café seating flanking
central space
Founders Square
Arlington, VA
44. Mosaic Park
Founders Square
Arlington, VA
2.5 Acres
Funded by sale of TDR’s
Privately funded new
park
Overall Founders Square
and Mosaic Park – 66%
open space
4040
Wilson
DARPA
Reside
ntial
North
Hotel
Retail
Mosaic
Park
45. First LEED-Gold for
Neighborhood Development
in Arlington
Office South: LEED-CS
Gold & LEED-CI Platinum
Office North: LEED-NC
Gold
Residential North: LEED-
NC Silver
Residential South/Hotel:
LEED-NC Silver
View looking
southeast from
Wilson Blvd
Founders Square
Arlington, VA
LEED Goals
404
0
Wils
on
DAR
PA
Res.
Nort
h
Hote
l
Reta
il
Mosaic
Park
2LC
OLC
(ON
R)
Con
dos
Apartment
s
46. View looking northeast from Randolph Street
Ballston
Liberty
Center
Founders
Square
Future
Mosaic Park
Kettler
Capitals
Iceplex
Ballston
Commons
Mall
Harris Teeter
Grocery
Store
Quincy Park
Glebe Road
Arlington
County
Library
Liberty Center and
Founders Square
Over 2 Million SF of
mixed use transit-
oriented development
Approximately 5,000
office workers
Approximately 1,300
residents and guests
Approximately 60,000 SF
of retail
Approximately $1 Billion
of overall investment
49. Creating The Environment for Change
• BRAC – 17,000 Jobs Leaving
• Buildings at end-of-life
• A great moment in time
• Location, location, location
• Planes, Trains, and Autos
• Creating a Strong Urban Plan with Principles that Allow Change Over
Time
• 25,000,000 GSF
• Small # Land Owners
• Found Sites ( Land Use Efficiency)
• Redevelopment Incentivized (2 ½ Times Existing Density)
• An Open County Process
• Crystal City Plan Review Council
50. Creating an Economic Engine for Development
Proposed Heights for Redevelopment 40,000,000 GFA
Existing Allowed Heights by Zoning 25,000,000 GFA
51. • Former Railroad
Brownfield Site
• Started in1963
• Peak Construction
1970
• Full Build-Out
in the late 1980’s
• Market Driven Plan
• Developed Over
30+ Years by
Charles E. Smith Co.
• Metro Station - 1977
• VRE - 1992
• Existing - 25 Million SF
53. Today and Tomorrow
Existing Program
•Office: 10,797,705 SF
•Retail: 847,823 SF
•Hotel: 3,525,184 SF
•Residential: 9,339,021 SF
•Circulation/Plinth: 140,300 SF
•Service: 87,065 SF
TOTAL: 24,737,098 SF
Proposed Program
•Office: 16,073,254 SF
•Retail: 1,513,311 SF
•Hotel: 5,154,480 SF
•Residential: 16,835,902 SF
•Circulation/Plinth: 104,590 SF
•Service: 69,440 SF
TOTAL: 39,750,977 SF
55. After 40 Million GFA
Retained Buildings
Height and Replacement
Found Sites
18.3 mil sf
13.2 mil sf
8.2 mil sf
56. I. Community Process
• Crystal City Task Force Meetings
• The Camp Out
• The Crystal City Walking Tour
• Stakeholder Meetings - The Community Charrette
• Transportation Walking Tour
• Regional Partners Transportation Working
Sessions
• Task Force Transit Subcommittee
• Community Forums
• County Board Work Sessions
• Long Range Planning Committee
• Board Work Sessions and Hearings
• 4 Years-Over 90 Meetings
57. I. Who was at The Table?
• Arlington County Board
• Crystal City Task Force
• Planning Commission
• Transportation Commission
• Economic Development
Commission
• Parks and Recreation
Commission
• Commission for the Arts
• Housing Commission
• Environmental and Energy
Conservation Commission
• Stakeholders
– Crystal City BID
– Crystal City Residents
– Aurora Highlands Civil Association
– Arlington Ridge Civic Association
– Crystal City Property Owners/
Developers
• County and Staff Groups
– Department of Community
Planning, Housing and
Development: Planning Division,
Housing Division
– Arlington Economic Development
– Department of Environmental
Services- Transportation
– Department of Parks, Recreation
and Cultural Resources
• Consultants
– Torti Gallas and Partners, Inc.
– Kimley-Horn and Associates
– DMJM Harris | AECOM
– EDAW
– Economics Research Associates
– NelsonNygaard Consulting
Associates
– Robert Charles Lesser &
Company
– Vladislav Yeliseyev, Architectural
Illustrations
• 17 Citizen + County Staff Groups
• Over 700 Participants