1. Career Mobility: Talent and Career
Management Strategy in a Knowledge Based
Economy
Internationally Trained Professionals Conference
June 8th, 2011, Douglas College, New Westminster, BC
Prepared by Victoria Pazukha, CHRP, CCDP
Principal, Career Mobility Group
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
2. Session Overview
KBE forces & characteristics
What is… & Why Career Mobility
Facts and figures
Global labour and HR trends
Local labour and HR trends
ITP-s : careers and human capital
Career Development in organizations
Career mobility obstacles &
opportunities
Questions
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
3. Knowledge-Based Economy
Knowledge as a tool
Ideas as commodity
Increased number of knowledge workers
Information technology and communications
Enhanced connectivity-knowledge growth &
exchange
Globalization of markets and products
Growth of service industries
New organizational
structures/policies/practices
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
4. What is Career Mobility
The upward or downward mobility in an occupation or the
change from one occupation to another.
The lateral mobility in an occupation due to
business expansion and/or restructuring
Intercompany assignments
Intra company assignments
International assignments
The international mobility of an occupation due
to globalization, outsourcing & immigration
Boundaryless careers and the mobility of
knowledge workers
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
5. Why Career Mobility
Extrinsic Factors Intrinsic Factors
Change happens faster Adaptation to change
Globalization & multinationals
Search for competitive positions
Pursuit of a good career match
Knowledge transfer & sharing
More focus on work-life balance
Integration of product markets
Interest in intellectual challenge
Demographics/aging population
Search for personal satisfaction
Increased population migration Desire for reward/recognition
Emerged markets and labour force Connectedness
Changing organizational structure Preference for team work
Multigenerational workforce Search for meaningful work
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
6. Facts and figures
The average U.S. worker changes
careers up to 5-6 times during
their lifetime (U.S. Department of Labor)
10 percent of the work force switches
jobs every year (Labor Statistic, Henkoff, 1996)
Majority of employers report skilled workers shortages ( The War for Talent Research
Mc Kinsey, 1997, 2001, 2007)
Increased number of knowledge workers and migration for high paying jobs
Increased number of educated „new entrants‟ - 2006 college graduates - 1.65
Million in US, 3.1 million in India, 3.3 million in China
Global competition for talent is on the rise - Canada attracts around 250,000
immigrants per year and competes for talent with U.S., Australia, New Zealand
and other countries
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
7. World’s foreign born population Migrants per region
Source: BBC News
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/spl/hi/world/04/migration/html/migration_boom.stm
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
8. Facts and figures
1 in 5 people in Canada is an immigrant - 19.8% of the total population
1991 - 2006 the proportion of male immigrants with a university degree
in jobs with low educational requirements increased from 12% to 21%
for established immigrants, while the proportion remained stable at
about 10% for native-born men.
1991 - 2006, the proportion of established female immigrants with a
university degree in jobs with low educational requirements increased
more modestly from 24% to 29%, while remaining stable at around
12% for native-born women.
For recent immigrants, the proportion of university graduates in low-
skill jobs increased between 1991 and 2006: 25% for men and ~ 40%
for women
(Canada Census, 2006)
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
9. Foreign and foreign-born labour force, 2001
Source: BBC News,
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/spl/hi/world/04/migration/html/migrant_labour.stm
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
10. Global labour and HR trends
The War for Talent never ended
Demographics, globalization, the rise of the knowledge worker
Expansion into new international markets
Executives that are able to work abroad
Talented local people
Gen Y challenges (born after 1980)
12% of US workforce
Employment demands and expectations
Interprovincial migration
Knowledge workers
The fastest growing talent pool in most organizations
Create up to 3 times more profit than other employees
Their work requires minimum oversight
Emerging markets & a surplus of young talent – Solution or Challenge?
Wide variation in suitability ( see Table)
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
11. Engineer Finance Generalist
Hungary 50 50 30
Central and Czech Republic 50 40 20
Eastern Europe Poland 50 30 15
Russia 10 20 10
Malaysia 35 25 20
Asia India 25 15 10
Philippines 20 30 25
China 10 15 3
Mexico 20 25 11
Latin America Brazil 13 13 8
The Talent Challenge
% of candidates considered suitable for hire
Source: Interview with HR Managers, Hr Agencies and Heads of Global Resourcing Centres,
McKinsey Global Institute analysis
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
12. Canada labour and HR trends
Current and future labour market shortages (national level)
Occupations under demand: health sector, management occupations, oil and gas sector, some trades
occupations, IT, science and technology
Growing numbers of retirement opening up many jobs
2 of every 3 job opening on average
Most shortages are expected to persist over the next 10 years
Challenges to increase supply for shortage
Sources: unemployed, college grads, immigrants
Growth of a knowledge-based economy
Labour surplus
Mainly low-skilled occupations specific to primary sector and to processing, manufacturing and utilities
Balance of labour demand/supply, but shortage of broad skill level
2/3 of all job openings over the next 10 years will be in occupations requiring a post
Uncertainties of labour markets
Better LMI on future shortages
Greater responsiveness of the post-secondary education
Better allocation of existing human resources (career mobility, re-training, re-deployment, immigrant
integration)
Source: Statistic Canada
http://www.hrsdc.gc.ca/eng/publications_resources/research/categories/labour_market_e/sp_615_10_06/shortages.shtml
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
13. Source Statistics Canada:
Annual factors of demographic growth, 1971/1972 to 2009/2010, Canada
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
14. Immigration Patterns
Source: Citizenship and Immigration Canada. Fact and Figures. 2002. Immigration Overview.
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
16. ITP-s : career success
INPUT OUTPUT
Higher level of education Less value for local market
Range of global experience “transition penalty”
Mobility across country and Stress related outcomes in
organizational borders achieving career success
Face major life and career Often underemployed
changes
Often focus on acquiring
Alter and internationalize labour additional human capital
pool
Subjective vs. objective career
Able to integrate and leverage the and career success
international expertise, language
knowledge and global networks Some level of disintegration
Motivation and desire to succeed Lack of “belonging” feeling
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
17. ITP- s : stock and flow of human capital
Stock component:
Credentials, KSA-s at a
certain point in time
Not valued, not recognized
Flow component:
Conscious investment in training and
development of new competencies
Increases chances for career success
Employers’ role in increasing ITP-s human capital:
HR policies and practices that govern training, development, team work, job
rotation
Can influence the transition of ITP-s into the new labour market through
recruitment, selection, socialization, and other practices
Will invest in ITP-s‟ integration if have relevant HR metrics
Value of international experience
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_EokVMpllT8
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
18. ITP-s: career research and findings
Most likely Less likely
Older, married with dependants Work as a union member
More than 40% speak at an Work as a manager
unofficial language at home
Get a promotion
Have more years of experience
Stay longer with current
Work in a smaller organizations employer
Work at jobs below their skill level
Be satisfied with current job
Earn less
Be satisfied with current pay
Be on incentive pay
Be on job rotation
Benefit from programs based on
teamwork that are generally
Benefit more from reward evaluated more subjectively
programs that are based on
objective performance Get credits for out of country
* Career success of immigrant professional (2) experience
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
19. Career mobility & organizations
Workforce management OLDT
Attraction & Retention Culture, values, goals
Learning needs/gaps analysis
Succession planning & Talent
Work rotation/skills dev-t
management
Change management
Motivation & engagement
Industry CD practices
Productivity & effectiveness
Mentorship/direct/reverse
Individual & organizational goals
Core competencies dev-t
Methods of training & dev-t http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=
Methods of matching skills and HOzPiAhcmEA – rotation
people http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4
Employer Branding vZYgD_L2aY – advancement
http://www.kpmgcampus.com/whyk
Effective workforce practices Career pmg/careermobility.shtml
Team/Belonging mobility
program
Employee-employer units
Org
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved Employee
structure
20. Career mobility
Obstacles Opportunities
Professional accreditation Resourcefulness
Adaptability/Flexibility
Local professional Continuous learning/Innovation
standards protection Productivity
Labour mobility laws and Risk reduction
regulations Business growth
Workforce planning/alignment
Assessment & evaluation http://www.employment.gov.bc.ca/career
_mobility
Language competencies http://www.cvh.on.ca/hr/career-
Global competencies mobility.php
http://careermobility.citigroup.com/Mobil
Biases ity/Mobility/Mobility.jsp?lang=en
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
21. Keys to career mobility
success
Positive Attitude
develop a mindset for adapting to change
Understand concept of career continuum
develop new skills and competencies
Conduct self-assessment
engage in career exploration
Continue building strong competencies
technical, business, interpersonal, global
Compromise
Making sense of LMI
Plan B
Be creative
Strengthen skills in personal branding
Seek advice/second opinion/ask for help
build support network
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
22. References
1. Surendra Gera(Industry Canada) Samuel A. Laryea (HRSDC) Thitima
Songsakul (Industry Canada), “International Mobility of Skilled
Labour: Analytical and Empirical Issues, and Research Priorities”,
Working Paper 2004 D-01. Skills Research Initiative.
2. Tony Fang and Jelena Zikic, Milorad Novicevic, “ Career success of
immigrant professionals: stock and flow of their career capital” ,York
University, Toronto, Canada, University of Mississippi, USA.
3. Matthew Guthridge, Asmus B.Komm, and Emily Lawson, “Making
talent a strategic priority”, McKinsey Quarterly, November 2008
4. Bettina Lankard Brown, “Career Mobility: A Choice or Necessity?”
Educational Resources Information Centre, Digest no. 191, 1998
5. www.statcan.gc.ca,
http://www.hrsdc.gc.ca/eng/publications_resources/research/categori
es/labour_market_e/sp_615_10_06/page00.shtml
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved
23. Thank You!
Questions?
Copyright by Victoria Pazukha 2011. All rights reserved