Presentation made by Dr. Ralph Hoffman at the May 28, 2014 Live Webinar hosted by the Schizophrenia Forum - http://schizophreniaforum.org/for/live/detail.asp?liveID=92
1. Perceiving social salience: a research
domain linking normal and
pathological hallucination
Ralph Hoffman MD
Department of Psychiatry
Yale University School of Med
28 May 2014
ralph.hoffman@yale.edu
2. AVHs in Sz achieve high
“social salience”
• Acoustic “voiceprint” connotes specific speakers;
• particular sounding voices have distinctive
characteristics – “their own personality…”
• attributed to specific persons/agents, angels, God,
the dead, or the devil, often given names;
• typically patient has conversations with voices…
3. Normal AHs prompted by ↑
social salience
• Erroneously hearing one’s name in
public (57% college students; Posey
and Losch 1983);
• vibration and pager tone hallucinations
– 80-90% of medical interns, not
correlated with anxiety or depression
(Lin et al. 2013).
• Bereavement hallucinations, typically
AVHs; fills in for lost loved one
4. Social withdrawal precedes and is
possible risk factor for AVHs
• 87% of first-episode patients w/SZ reported prior
social withdrawal vs 3% for non-psychotic patients
(Tan 2001);
• 71% of SZ pts with AVHs report significant drop-off in
social involvement 1-6 month before first onset
• Move to new city, new school, solo travel in Europe or across
the US, peace corp duty, dissertation takes over…
5. • Phantom limb following amputation
• Charles Bonnet Syndrome
Sensory deafferentation:
hallucinations due to network
reorganization filling in for
absent percepts
6. What about “social
deafferentation?”
• Brain is dedicated to social meaning;
• high levels of plasticity in “social brain”
regions
• What happens when brain deprived of
social experience??
• Could AVHs with high social salience
“fill in” for absent social connection
7. Suggestive evidence
• Baseline active social avoidance (ASA)
during the prodrome correlated with
hallucinations (PRIME study, unpublished)
• at baseline, correlation = 0.18;
• at 1 year, correlation = 0.54.
• Prisoners in solitary confinement: 36%
had auditory/verbal hallucinations
(Grassian Am J Psychiatry 1983); mean
age 28, 11 days to 10 months SC
• What other factors besides social
disconnection might come into play???
25 minutes
Alternative mechanistic framework for AVHs, to consider processes reflecting the brain’s drive to discover, in the vast and complex world we live in, social salience and connection with others. We are alas group animals.
Brain and mind dedicated to discovering social salience