Aftab Hasan Speaking at Trade Credit Insurance Summit - 2014
1. “EMERGENCE OF TRADE CREDIT
INSURANCE IN THE MIDDLE EAST MARKET
– AVAILABILITY & PRACTICE”
Presented By:
AFTAB HASAN - CEO
‘Arya Insurance Brokerage CO. (LLC)’
Dubai - U.A.E.
2. PRESENTATION OUTLINE
Concept of Trade Credit Insurance
Origin of Trade Credit Insurance
Why to have Trade Credit Insurance?
Existing Global Underwriting Markets – Key Players
Availability & Practice by Insurers
Policy Structures, Coverages & Capacity
Current Market Prevailing Conditions
Regional Country Coverages
The Role of Broker / Advisor
Summary
Q & A
4. CONCEPT OF TRADE CREDIT
INSURANCE
Trade credit insurance, business credit insurance, export
credit insurance, or credit insurance is an insurance policy
and a risk management product offered by private insurance
companies and governmental export credit agencies to
business entities wishing to protect their accounts receivable
from loss due to credit risks such as protracted default,
insolvency or bankruptcy.
Trade Credit Insurance can include a component of political
risk insurance which is offered by the same insurers to insure
the risk of nonpayment by foreign buyers due to currency
issues, political unrest, expropriation etc.
5. ORIGIN OF TRADE CREDIT
INSURANCE
History:
Trade Credit Insurance was born at the end of
nineteenth century but it was mostly developed
in Western Europe between the First and
Second World Wars. Several companies were
founded in many countries; some of them also
managed the political risks of export on behalf
of their own state.
6. ORIGIN OF TRADE CREDIT
INSURANCE
History: (Cont.……)
It is documented that Issuance of first Credit Insurance
Policy was done in 1850 by a Government backed British
Commercial Insurance Company which was the first Specialist
Credit Insurer.
Trade Indemnity a privately owned insurance company
formed in 1918 was the First Private Insurer to issue Credit
Insurance Policy.
After the end of First World War UK established in 1919 a
separate Export Credit Agency reporting to the Secretary of
State for Trade and Industry called “Export Credit Guarantee
Department” (ECGD).
7. ORIGIN OF TRADE CREDIT
INSURANCE
History: (Cont.……)
In 1991 following the privatization of the short-term
side of the UK's Export Credit Guarantee
Department (ECGD), a concentration of the Trade
Credit Insurance market took place and three groups
namely Euler Hermes, Atradius & Coface now account
for over 80% of the global credit insurance market
emerged rapidly. These main players initially focused
on Western Europe but rapidly expanded towards
Eastern Europe, Asia and America.
8. WHY TO HAVE
TRADE CREDIT INSURANCE?
Protection Against Bad Debt
Comfort To Financers
Balance Sheet Protection
Expansion In New Market
Assist Debt Collection
Information & Due Diligence On Client
Proper Corporate Governance
Relaxation On Available Credit Conditions
9. EXISTING GLOBAL UNDERWRITING
MARKETS – KEY PLAYERS
Euler Hermes came into existence with the merger of the two credit insurance companies of
the Allianz Group. Euler Hermes is the world's number one credit insurance provider.
•Presence in 50 countries
•Part of Allianz Group
•AA-rating by Standard & Poor's (Feb. 2014)
•34% Global Market Share as at Dec 2013.
10. EXISTING GLOBAL UNDERWRITING
MARKETS – KEY PLAYERS
Atradius occurred with the merger between NCM and Gerling Kreditversicherung. Later
renamed Atradius after it was demerged from the Gerling insurance group.
•Presence in 50 countries
•Ownership: Grupo Compañía Espanõla de Crédito y Caución, S.L. (Grupo CyC) 64.23% &
34.95% Grupo Catalana Occidente S.A. (GCO)
•A rating by Standard & Poor's, A.M. Best is ‘A (excellent) outlook stable’ and ‘A3 outlook
stable’ by Moody’s
•22% Global Market Share as at Dec 2013.
11. EXISTING GLOBAL UNDERWRITING
MARKETS – KEY PLAYERS
Coface was formerly a French government sponsored institution established in 1946; this
company is now part of the a wholly-owned subsidiary of Natixis, the financing, asset
management and financial services arm of the BPCE Group, France’s second largest banking
group.
• Presence in 67 countries
• As of August 7th 2014, the shareholding is as follows: Public: 58.50%; Natixis: 41.24%;
Employees: 0.26%.
• AA-rating from S & P
•24% Global Market Share as at Dec 2013.
12. EXISTING GLOBAL UNDERWRITING
MARKETS – SOME OTHER PLAYERS
Trade credit insurance stimulates global trade specially after global
crisis. Here is a listing of some of other insurance companies
offering Trade Credit Insurance.
13. AVAILABILITY &
PRACTICE BY INSURERS
Trade credit insurance can help a company protect accounts
receivable from losses caused by the insolvency, protracted
default, or political events.
Most of the companies offer Coverage based on following
structure according to clients specific requirements, including:
Whole Turnover: A single contract to insure all of your firm’s
receivables;
Key Accounts: A contract designed to insure only your largest
customers or another defined band of customers; and
Single Debtor: A policy designed to insure exposures related to
one customer.
14. AVAILABILITY &
PRACTICE BY INSURERS
Each of these contracts can be designed for domestic sales, export
sales, or a combination and can be defined regionally or globally.
Trade credit insurance is applicable for companies that:
conduct business on open, unsecured credit terms or have
significant bad debt reserves;
have heavy export activity or international receivables;
want their enterprise risk management philosophy to be
applied to treasury and financial management;
have accounts receivable concentrations to only a few accounts;
seek asset-based lending arrangements with banks; and
may not collect sufficient credit information on their own
customers and value a credit partner to access credit risk.
15. POLICY STRUCTURES,
COVERAGES & CAPACITY
Whole turnover
Domestic
Export
Commercial
Political
Trade Specific
Special Risks
Anything else
Supplier default
Captives
Specific Account
Single Customer
Selection of Customers
Bonds
Niche Market
Specialist Underwriters
16. DISTINCTIVE POLICY
STRUCTURE
Multi buyer/obligor or single and specific risk
First loss/risk share/co-insurance
Endorsed buyers by credit limit
Tenor flexibility (i.e. terms)
Formula maximum liabilities, although negotiable
Comprehensive cover (TCI and PRI) in some instances
Currency flexibility within most policies
Point of Issue?
17. POLITICAL RISKS (PRI)
Contract Frustration
Confiscation
Expropriation
Nationalization
Deprivation
Strikes
Civil Commotion
Rebellion
Terrorism
War
Political Violence
What is covered ?
18. CURRENT MARKET PREVAILING
CONDITIONS
Underwriters are providing flexible and innovative products
Sober outlook of Reinsurance Capacity
Wide choice of underwriters available
Competitive pricing offered with key players
Supportive risk underwriting condition
Expansive international/global outlook
Profit margins continue to squeezed
Market is cyclical in nature and reactive
Increased divergence between those underwriters who are looking to build or
expand their accounts and those who may become increasingly defensive or
selective
This means a market place where it will be essential to employ a SOUND
BROKER!
19. REGIONAL COUNTRY COVERAGES
UNDERWRITERS DEAL FREQUENTLY
UAE
Saudi Arabia
Kuwait
Qatar
Oman
Bahrain
Egypt
Lebanon
Yemen
Jordan
Turkey
Algeria
USA
Canada
United Kingdom
Germany
France
Spain
Switzerland
India
China
Pakistan
Bangladesh
Srilanka
20. C0UNTRIES WHICH ARE UNSTABLE
OR ON SANCTION ARE OFF RISK
Iran – Iraq – Sudan – Libya – Afghanistan etc…..
Principal trade credit insurers are off risk for these
markets and have very less appetite or reservations by
most underwriters due to:
Restricted PRI interest/availability from Lloyds of
London
Although in certain cases they cover with:
Certain difficult exceptions
Obligor specific underwriting conditions
21. THE ROLE OF BROKER/ADVISOR
TO CLIENT
Advising client with experts tailor solutions to the
unique needs of each company or organization
Negotiate with Insurers / Underwriters on behalf of
client
Assist in understanding Policy Structure to client
Negotiating Competitive Price – new business or
renewals
Assisting Client in settlement of their legitimate Claims
Negotiating Credit limits to be approved per buyer
Manage smooth relationship between client and
underwriters
Training, Policy Compliance & Reviews
22. ARYA INSURANCE BROKERAGE
COMPANY (AIBC)PROFILE
Formed in UAE in 1988 replacing the name of Secure
Insurance Services
ISO 9001 Certified Company by TUV Germany
Full-fledged Trade Credit Insurance Division with
proficient team of experts with vast industry
knowledge
Strong associations with major key players of the
Trade Credit Insurance Market
Bespoke client service – team approach
Multi-national client portfolio
Negotiation on your behalf to provide a cost-effective
program
23. CONCLUSION
Plenty of options open for buyers, but beware of the long-term
implications.
Strong political risk (PRI) appetite for risks within region,
written for the most part from Underwriters in London
Major banks involved in trade finance which mandates
compulsory Trade Credit Insurance to lenders already have
substantial presence in the region.
Intelligent ‘INSURANCE BROKER’ can help identify and
quantify risks and bring them under control. They can create
and implement customized solutions employing the most
effective blend of risk mitigation, risk transfer, and advanced
risk financing.
24. CONCLUSION
Considering all above explanation I
do not anticipate a drastic increase
in rates particularly for 2015 rather
will expect each market to be rated
separately, taking into account their
exposure and experiences across
industry.