2. Joe El Rady
X 430.611 CREDIT:
COMMERCIAL, PERSONAL, AND
GLOBAL
3. Class Content
X 430.611 will provide students:
An overview of the macroeconomics of credit.
Details of firm level economics , finance, and accounting of leverage.
Knowledge about various credit instruments, their behavior, and
pricing.
Focus on both credit markets (primary as well as secondary) and firm-
level credit decisions.
Examination of consumer credit both from the standpoint of markets
and individual level credit decisions.
Analysis of bubbles, bank runs, liquidity crises and default (both
corporate and consumer/individual).
The following slides present a sampling of class content.
5. Credit – Why Is It
Important?
Firm has ability to lend / invest.
Opportunity to generate income and create
long-term value for the firm.
Business dependent on credit – Trade,
Operations, Capital Raising, M&A and
Restructuring.
5
6. What is Bank
Capital Debt
Structure? Other
Loans
Bonds
Mezzanine
Preferred Equity
Common Equity
8. How are different credit
instruments prioritized in
capital structure?
9. Who provides the various
credit instruments in the
capital structure?
Banks (BofA, Wells Fargo, Citibank, JP Morgan)
Senior, Second Lien, Limited Mezzanine
Focus: Relationship focused, preservation of principal, cross-selling of services
Financial Services Firms (G.E., CIT)
Senior, Second Lien, Mezzanine and Minority Equity
Focus: Relationship minded but transaction oriented; focus on lending
Second Lien Funds (Canyon Capital, Contrarian Capital)
Second Lien and Limited Mezzanine
Focus: Transaction oriented
Mezzanine Funds (Caltius Mezzanine, Key Mezzanine, Blackstone Mezzanine)
Mezzanine and Minority Equity
Focus: Relationship minded but transaction oriented
Hedge Funds (Cerberus, Silver Point, Fortress)
Senior, Second Lien, Mezzanine, Structured Equity, Minority Equity and Control Equity
Focus: Transaction oriented
Private Equity Funds (Centre Partners, Kirtland Capital, Summit Partners)
Minority and Control Equity
Focus: Relationship minded
9
10. How do the broad categories
of loans differ?
Asset Based
Extend credit based on underlying value of assets
% of Receivables and inventory
% of Net “Orderly Liquidation Value” of equipment
Potential advance against intangibles
Multiple of cash flow and P&L performance of secondary importance
Cash Flow
Based on multiple of cash flow – EBITDA
Influenced by (i) level of free cash flow, (ii) stability and predictability of
cash flow, (iii) nature of business and industry, (iv) cyclicality, (v)
enterprise value, (vi) size of company
Greater perceived risk than ABL given that cash flow can evaporate
Enterprise Value
Approach is closely aligned to cash flow
Level of debt is geared to enterprise value and level of equity cushion
required
Ability to potentially provide more capital than cash flow approach
10
20. What is the syndicated loan
market?
What is a loan?
How do we define different loan segments?
How large is the loan market?
What are the differences between loans and
bonds?
How do the primary and secondary markets
differ?
21. What is a syndicated loan?
Large loan that is sold in pieces to lenders
Floating rate, senior debt in borrower’s
capital structure
Senior, secured debt sold to non-bank
investors
Senior debt which moves in tandem with the
bond market
24. What is a Syndicated Loan?
Generally a senior debt instrument
Dominant types include revolvers, term loans
Revolvers can be undrawn, partially drawn or fully drawn
Term loans usually are fully drawn at close
Generally syndicated by a lead bank to a group of
banks and/or institutional investors
Usually floating rate
Tenor can range from several months to 10+ years
Generally have more covenants than a bond issue
FOUR KEY LOAN MARKET SEGMENTS
25. There are four key large
corporate loan market U.S. Syndicated Loan Market 10
September 24, 2007 Slide 1
segments corporate loan market segments
4 key large
Investment grade loan market Leveraged loan market
• Loans to companies rated >= BBB-/Baa3 • Loans to companies rated < BBB-/Baa3 or
AND with a relatively low LIBOR spread unrated
• Investment grade issuance totaled roughly • AND with a spread >= LIB+150 bps
$667 billion in LTM ending 2Q07 • Leveraged loan issuance totaled roughly
$753 billion in LTM 2Q07
Institutional loan market Secondary loan market
• Loans structured to be sold to institutional • Market in which loans “trade” following the
investors (which include mutual funds, close of primary syndication
CLOs, insurance companies, hedge • Most U.S. loan trading involves leveraged
funds, etc) loans
• Institutional issuance totaled roughly $474 • Loan trading totaled nearly $278 billion in
billion in LTM 2Q07 LTM 2Q07
26. What is syndication?
Generally syndicated–
broken into pieces and
sold to lenders
Lead arranger–
arranges loan and
theoretically holds the
biggest piece
Syndicates remainder
28. Investment returns compensate
risks
What is Risk?
How is Risk related to
Return
Return?
What is the risk –
return tradeoff?
How is Risk measured?
How is Risk calculated?
Risk
29. Risk measures the precise
probability and impact of
specific outcomes
Risk measures both the likelihood of a hazardous
event and the harm of that event
Risk Prob of Event Amt of Event
Does a “risk free” investment exist?
How is risk compensated?
30. How is risk measured or
calculated in finance?
Financial risk is defined as the statistically
unexpected variability or volatility of returns (an
outcome different from the expectation)
In statistics the expectation is called the “Mean”
The variability about the expectation is called the
“Standard Deviation”
In life, science, math and the universe all data
exhibit a central tendency. The distance from the
center defines the variability
32. Corporate Bonds and their
issuers have credit ratings
Quality Moody’s S&P
Investment Grade
Highest Aaa AAA
High Aa AA
Tier-1 Medium A-1, A A
Tier-2 Medium Baa-1, Baa BBB
Noninvestment Grade (Junk)
Speculative Ba BB
Extremely Speculative B, Caa B, CCC, CC
In Default Ca, C D
39. Premium and Discount Bonds
Premium bonds: price > par value
YTM < coupon rate
Discount bonds: price < par value
YTM > coupon rate
Par bonds: price = par value
YTM = coupon rate
10-39
40. Relationships among Yield
Measures
for premium bonds:
coupon rate > current yield > YTM
for discount bonds:
coupon rate < current yield < YTM
for par value bonds:
coupon rate = current yield = YTM
10-40
42. Duration
Bondholders know that the price of their bonds change when
interest rates change. But,
How big is this change?
How is this change in price estimated?
Macaulay Duration, or Duration, is the name of concept that helps
bondholders measure the sensitivity of a bond price to changes in
bond yields.
Change in YTM
Pct. Change in Bond Price Duration
1 YTM
2
10-42
43. Duration Basics
Duration measures how long, in years, it
takes for the price of the bond to be repaid by
its internal cash flows.
55. Leverage!
1. Reversal of Glass-Steagall in 1999 set off a leverage race on
Wall Street
2. Leverage outside the banking system largely unregulated /
misunderstood
3. Explosion of credit markets allowed each segment of risk to
be isolated… and further leveraged
4. Tiering of risk allowed for multiple layers of leverage with
limited transparency
5. Investors became complacent while regulators became
overwhelmed
56. Extent of Leverage is a Differentiating
Feature of this Particular Cycle
Federal and
Government Debt 1 Consumer Debt
as % of GDP 2
$10,000 300%
$9,000
$8,000 250%
Federal Debt ($ bil)
$7,000 200%
Percent of GDP
$6,000
$5,000 150%
$4,000
100%
$3,000
$2,000 50%
$1,000
$0 0%
Total Consumer Debt Total Federal Debt
(1) Office of Management and Budget, Budget of the United States, FY 2007
(2) U.S. Chamber of Commerce as of 8/27/08
57. Extent of Leverage is a Differentiating
Feature of this Particular Cycle
Share of Intermediation Through
Bank Leverage 2
Banks & Securities Markets 1
60%
55% % 7% 6.4%
50% 6
5 5.2%
45%
40% 4
35% 3
30% 2 1.8%
1.2%
25% 1
20% 0
Reserves/Loans TCE/TA
Intermediated Through Securities Markets
Intermediated Through Depository Institutions
(1) Morgan Stanley. “Levered Losses: Lessons Learned from the Mortgage Market Meltdown” 2/08
(2) SNL Financial. Data as of 7/31/08
58. Extent of Leverage is a Differentiating
Feature of this Particular Cycle
Total Assets of Top 5 Brokers 1 Global Issuance of
($ tril) Structured Finance Products 2
$5
1,000
$3.9 900
$4
800
(in 700
$3 $ bil) 600
500
$2 400
$1.4 300
$0.9 200
$1
100
-
$0
4Q1992 4Q2000 4Q2007
Total CDO Total ABS
(1) SNL Financial. Top brokers traded on the NYSE and NASDAQ
(2) Source: Lehman Brothers. Data provided 8/28/08
59. Anecdotes of Leverage
~$2.3 tril in “AAA” guarantees supported by six monolines with less
than $20 bil in equity (0.8%)(1)
In June 2007, financials made up 20.9% of S&P 500
Implies that approximately 30% of every dollar earned by an S&P 500
company was earned by a financial services firm
Total assets of the top 5 brokerage houses in the U.S. equaled
approximately 35% of the total U.S. annual GDP. Balance sheets were
levered on average 30:1(3)
In 1998, failure of Long Term Capital brought markets to their knees,
based on a loss of $4.6 bil.(4) To-date system has incurred
approximately 75x(5) this amount. Industry’s capital base increased by
only 2.5x that during this time(6)
(1) Pershing Square Capital Management. “How to Save the Bond Insurers,” 11/07
(2) Company Reports. Data as of Q4 2007
(3) SNL Financial. Data as of Q4 2007
(4) Financial Times. “Bank bailout shows need to intervene,” 6/08
(5) Loss estimate to-date of $460 bil provided by Goldman Sachs. Data provided on 8/28/08.
Inflation data provided by the U.S. department of Labor.
(6) SNL Financial. As measured by tangible capital base of top 25 U.S.
financial institutions (excluding insurance companies, from 1998 to Q2 2008)
60. The Leverage Game
Notwithstanding the existing underlying leverage, banks
could lever AAA securities by over 100:1!
Consumer 10 to 1
Mortgages Cash
50 to 1
Loan Origination (Warehouse)
Mortgages Cash
Wall Street 50 to 1
Mortgages Cash & Fees
Structured ABS 15 to 1
Ratings Agencies
AA
Cash AAA Below Cash
70% 30% Bank
FNMA Insurance CDOs Wall Street
FHLMC Companies
Notes Cash
AAA’s, AA, A,
BBB, BB
Equity 30 to 1 400 to 1
Leverage
Source: Wachovia Securities, “Lifestyles of the Rich and Living Rich,
A Tale of Two Consumers,” 2005
61. Risk vs. Information
Those who knew the most held the least amount of the risk…
Most Originator
Warehouse
Underlying Collateral
Provider
Senior Bonds
Knowledge
Mezzanine
Bonds
Sub Bonds
Residual
Notes
Least
CDO Equity
Least Most
Performance Risk
…while those who knew the least ended up holding the most risk
Source: Wachovia Securities, “Lifestyles of the Rich and Living Rich,
A Tale of Two Consumers,” 2005
66. intrinsic value of an in-the-money American call option is determined by the difference between the current
market price of the underlying instrument and the option strike price. Let F denote the underlying futures
price and K the option strike price. Then, the intrinsic value of a futures call option is F - K if F > K and zero if
F < K, which can be written as
What is the role of options max(0, F - K).
Figure 4a illustrates the payoff to a long call option held to expiration. Let C 0 denote the call premium
in the credit markets?
Page 227
paid at the time the option was first purchased. If F < K, the option will expire out-of-the-money and the
FIGURE 5
buyer will lose the call premium. But the call premium is the most the option holder can lose, so that the
payoff diagram has a floor at -C on the vertical Unhedged Put underlying futures price is above the option
0
Payoffs for axis. When the Options
strike price, the call holder can earn a marginal profit of F - K by exercising the option, so the payoff line is
kinked at F = K, the point where the option goes in-the-money. The total net profit accruing to a long call
option position when the option expires in-the-money is F - K - C0. The payoff line intersects the horizontal
axis at the break-even price F = K + C 0.
To illustrate, consider the payoff to a call option on September Treasury bill futures with a strike price of
96.00 bought at a premium of 30 basis points ($750). If the underlying futures contract is priced below 96.00
when the option expires, the option expires out-of-the-money and the buyer loses the entire $750 premium.
At any futures price above 96.00 the option is in-the-money, so a holder can exercise the option and
liquidate the resulting futures position to
FIGURE 4
Payoffs for Unhedged Call Options
Principles of Option Pricing
The Time Value of an Option An out-of-the-money option typically will sell for a positive premium before
the contract expiration date because there is always some chance that the option will go in-the-money
before it expires. The excess of an option premium over its intrinsic value is termed its time value, or
speculative value. All other things equal, the time value of an option tends to increase with the time to
expiration because a longer-lived option has a greater chance of going deeper in-the-money before it
expires. At expiration time value is zero and the only value the option has is its intrinsic value. The rate at
which an option premium changes over time, with all other things held equal, is known as the "theta" of the
option. Option pricing theory predicts that theta should be negative, reflecting the fact that time value is
expected to fall as the expiration date draws nearer.