To ensure optimal accuracy AND protect the sensitive electronics inside the gimbals (aka pods, pan-tilt systems) they design, engineers must strike a balance between low friction operation and sealing effectiveness. This presentation explains the relationship between seals and gimbal performance. It also offers tips on how to leverage jacket materials, geometries, and energizer forces to reduce stiction while meeting IPX, MIL-STD, SWaP, and other strict requirements. If you want to build a better gimbal, this deck is really a must-see.
2. • Housings that contain sensitive
electronic instruments for scanning,
radar detecting, weapons targeting
& other uses
• At work in air, on land, at sea
• Must deliver optimal performance –
failure can impact mission success,
& even cost lives
GIMBALS
2
B A L S E A L . C O M
PHOTO: UNITED STATES NAVY
3. • Aircraft
Fighter/helicopter/UAV
High vibration, fast moving,
demand for more accuracy
• Shipboard
Environmental factors such as
moisture & corrosion
• Land-based
High rotational/speed
requirements
COMMON GIMBAL ENVIRONMENTS
B A L S E A L . C O M 3
4. • C4ISR gimbals/pods
• High Energy laser turrets
• LaserComm gimbals
COMMON GIMBAL APPLICATIONS
B A L S E A L . C O M 4
5. TOP GIMBAL OPERATING REQUIREMENTS
• Extreme precision
Perform high-speed bi-
directional rotation with
great accuracy,
consistency
▸ At longer distances,
even tiny pointing
variances = large target
deviations
• Survivability
Exposed to extreme
temps, pressure
variations
May be subject to:
▸ IPX standards for air,
sand, dust
▸ MIL-STD for vibration,
other conditions
5
B A L S E A L . C O M
• SWaP-readiness
Rotate with minimal
torque, using smallest
motors to meet strict
size, weight & power
requirements
1 2 3
6. • Protect sensitive
electronics in harsh
environments
• Must not impede
precision targeting,
regardless of conditions
(high speed, high
vibration, adverse
weather)
GIMBAL SEALS: A CRITICAL ELEMENT
B A L S E A L . C O M 6
7. Gimbal System Goals Sealing Challenges
Targeting, tracking, acquiring accuracy Stick-slip & dynamic friction
Minimize power consumption Optimize size, weight & agility (SWaP)
Meet ingress protection rating (IPXX)
Sealing ability against
environmental contamination
Survive under extreme conditions Speed, thermal cycling, pressure differentials
Comply w/MIL-STD specs E.g. Mechanical vibrations
GIMBAL SEALING: GOALS VS. CHALLENGES
7
B A L S E A L . C O M
8. THE FRICTION FACTOR
• In gimbals, friction …
Exhibits highly non-linear
behavior
Is a function of rate
Is dramatic when transitioning
through zero rate (stiction)
Can compromise precision
pointing/stability
Impacts max slew rates and
acceleration
Is influenced by temp, pressure,
surface finish, condition of
materials
Affects power consumption
8
B A L S E A L . C O M
Model showing irregularities in surface finish
9. • Low friction and low stiction
Necessary for precision pointing and stability
Drives the selection of other system components
• Sealing efficiency
Sealing while still meeting friction requirements is
critical
Prevention of environmental contamination
Sealing moisture, dirt, salt, dust, etc.
• Survivability
Large temperature range (from -40 °C to 60 °C),
vibration conditions, rotation, high speed
• Seal life
Meet field maintenance requirements
KEY SEAL PERFORMANCE CONSIDERATIONS
9
B A L S E A L . C O M
10. • Jacket material choice
Polymers, such as filled PTFE, with low friction
coefficient
• Energizer choice
Controllable force for optimal balance of sealing
effectiveness
• Profile/geometry
Minimal contact without compromising sealing
performance
• Size/diameter
Low cross-section to diameter ratio
• Additional factors
Media type (dry, abrasive, lubricating)
Seal usage after thermal cycling
Pressure and speed
KEY SEAL DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
B A L S E A L . C O M 10
Seal in naval-based
IRST
11. • Using a canted coil spring
energizer can:
Promote seal lip contact &
consistency in operation
Compensate for tolerance
variations, misalignment &
vibration
Ensure effective sealing force is
maintained under adverse
conditions
▸Weather, speed, elevation,
extreme temperatures
• Controlled force of spring coils
helps balance friction & sealing
performance
THE ENERGIZER: A CLOSER LOOK
11
B A L S E A L . C O M
12. CASE STUDY: AIRBORNE LASER-OPTICAL SYSTEM
Features Requirements
Pressurized Yes
Inner diameter 125 mm
Speed 30 to 40 RPM
Service type Rotary, oscillating
Media Nitrogen + air, particles
Temp range -90 to +90 °C
Seal pressure 0 to 1.4 Bars
Back pressure 0 to 1.4 Bars
Ingress protection IP67
Frictional torque 0.9 Nm
B A L S E A L . C O M 12
13. SOLUTION: AIRBORNE LASER-OPTICAL SYSTEM SEAL
Provided in-depth frictional torque analysis
Met low-friction rate in specification
Protected optics to specification
Dynamic lip
geometry to
minimize friction
Canted coil spring
applying consistent
light force to minimize
friction
Locking ring to easily
press into hardware
Engineered
polymer material Thin, flexible
hinge point
B A L S E A L . C O M 13
14. • To achieve optimal accuracy and durability while meeting SWaP, IPX, and other requirements, look for
these seal characteristics:
SEALING SUCCESS FACTORS
14
B A L S E A L . C O M
15. • To eliminate costly mistakes and delays,
consider sealing requirements as part of
overall system design
• In early design stages, collaborate with
Bal Seal Engineering to:
Custom design a seal that meets all your
system/application requirements
Produce high-quality seal prototypes
Perform seal testing to verify performance
▸ Friction testing
▸ Dynamic leak vs. friction testing
▸ Pressure
▸ Spray-down
Transition successful prototype to full production -
100 to 1M+ units
SUMMARY & RECOMMENDATIONS
B A L S E A L . C O M 15