SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 12
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Executing a
Total Solutions Strategy
And Other Complex Selling and Pricing Structures

A CIT White Paper
Contents:
Part 1: Abstract and Introduction
Part 2: The Evolution of Product Strategy
Part 3: Product Structure and Administrative Considerations
Part 4: Summary & Implications

A CIT White Paper

—1—
Part 1 Abstract
In nearly every industry, the effects of globalization and rapid advances
in technology have delivered hyper-competition resulting in product
commoditization and an inability for companies to sustain long-term
competitive advantages. In this environment, companies in highly
competitive markets face additional headwinds from clients who have
become more discriminating and less interested in acquiring standard, onesize-fits-all products. Instead, clients demand products and services with
greater customization to better fit their needs. In response, many companies
have attempted to shift away from traditional product-focused strategies
and have moved to a “Total Solutions” strategy and a customer-centric
orientation.
Much has been written in business literature and academia about how
companies and entire industries are reinventing themselves through a Total
Solutions strategy. Despite all the in-depth explorations, little can be found
on key product structures and administrative requirements necessary for
any Total Solutions offering.
Following a brief review of the evolution from standalone products to
Total Solutions, this white paper will explore the following requirements
and provide considerations for companies who are pursuing a Total
Solutions strategy.

Product Structure Requirements
•	

Maximizing margins and customer appeal of an offering through a
combination of usage-based, variable and fixed pricing structures.

•	

Partnering with third-party suppliers to fill gaps in a company’s offering
to create true Total Solutions that address the entire spectrum of
customer needs.

Administrative Requirements
•	

Creating billing systems that customers can trust and invoices that clearly
show how costs were determined for every charged item.

•	

Ensuring that the accounts receivable/payable system can receive and
identify charges due and allocate payments to the company’s internal
divisions and third-party suppliers.

—2—
Introduction
A recent in-depth survey of 2,700 executives and managers from 50 countries
revealed that 80% of companies are facing increased pricing pressure from
customers and competitors.1 Further, the survey found that profits rise sharply
when C-level executives take an active role in pricing. Similarly, higher profits
and revenues can occur when C-level executives get engaged in product
strategy. Failing to defend product differentiation on values critical to
customers is a path to commoditization. No matter the industry, product or
service, commoditization is a constant threat to margins as well as
revenue growth.
One strategy to combat commoditization is to change the rules of engagement
in your industry by innovating on the product structure: what you sell, who you
partner with and how you address the larger needs of customers.

Part 2 The Evolution of Product Strategy
Historically, most companies were product-centered, meaning they focused
more on making the perfect product to maximize their profit rather than the
perfect product to maximize customer needs. Until fairly recently, the product
lifecycle consisted of three predictable phases.

Phase I: Innovation
You introduce a new product that fits a unique niche in the market.
Competition is limited. Customers are abundant and margins are rich.

Phase II: Competition
New entrants enter your space, putting pressure on sales and margins by
making improvements along the value chain (e.g., low-cost, low-benefit
offerings that target the mass market; or new combinations of price and
unique benefits that target specific customer segments) or by investing
in such areas as distribution network, sales resources, promotions and
advertising.

Phase III: Reinvention
You attempt to reinvent your product—usually by playing catch-up with
me-too features and benefits or by leap-frogging competitors in some
manner. However, pressure to innovate and maintain a sustainable
competitive advantage continues.
In the 1990s, more companies realized that the traditional product lifecycle
failed to break their offerings out of a state of continuous commoditization.
At some point during the Competition or Reinvention phases, successful
companies made the strategic switch from being product-centered to being
customer-centered. This shift led to the creation of a new strategy for the
Reinvention phase: Total Solutions.

1

—3—

Global Pricing Study, Nov. 2012, Simon-Kucher & Partners
Customer Centricity & Total Solutions
In conjunction with the product lifecycle, companies have shifted their
strategy from standalone products and services… to product “plus”
complementary products or services… to Total Solutions.

Standalone Sales
Initially, companies typically sell a standalone product, which is standardized
to appeal to the broadest number of customers. The simplicity of this
product makes it easier for competitors to replicate. Products are sold
individually to address a single-purpose customer need. For example,
purchases of copiers, medical devices, computers, telecommunication
systems, trucks, cranes, machinery and so forth are often one-time events.
Related in-house products and services may be sold to the same customer.
Fundamentally, however, no meaningful additional revenue will be earned from
the original sale until the core product needs to be replaced.

“Product Plus” Sales
As competition heats up, companies attempt to differentiate their offerings
with a “Product Plus” strategy of bundling additional features, products
and services. They may acquire other companies to enhance their product
offerings, for example. Despite the broadening of the offering, the product
structure remains relatively simple, comprising almost exclusively in-house
offerings, and fails to provide a sustainable competitive advantage.

Total Solutions Sales
When the “Product Plus” strategy fails to slow down the competition, some
companies and sometimes entire industries decide to embrace a Total
Solutions strategy (e.g., nearly all copier manufacturers have attempted to
move to managed print services in recent years). This product structure
is customer-centric, complex and customized for each client, making it
difficult for competitors to displace the incumbent.
Customers usually are deeply engaged in defining the product need and
shaping the solution. The product is characterized by multiple components,
from hardware and software to services and supplies. Each component
may have a unique pricing structure: fixed or variable, consumption/usagebased, subscription-based, one-time or reoccurring charges.
For instance, an IT managed service provider may structure its Total
Solutions to include hardware, applications and systems management,
supplemented by third-party solutions for web hosting, cloud storage,
application development and network services.

“True” Total Solutions Sales
A more recent trend in Total Solutions is made possible through
sophisticated invoicing and accounts receivable/payable systems. In what
is being called “True” Total Solutions, this sales strategy is differentiated by
its inclusiveness of third-party companies whose capabilities and existing
—4—
customer relationships are leveraged to form synergistic offerings and
pricing options competitors cannot match.
A historic challenge of such structures has been the lack of capabilities of
traditional sales origination, accounting, receivable/payable and invoicing
systems to process a multi-faceted, multi-partner offering. Despite this
challenge, companies eager to realize the revenues proceed with the strategy.
In such cases, these companies find that the only way to manage
transactions is through manual processes, which eat into profitability
through higher operating expenses. Further, the manual workarounds are
inherently error prone and negatively impact internal controls as well as
customer satisfaction.

Standalone Product

Product Plus

Total Solutions
Customer Centered

Strategic Focus

Product Centered

Product Centered

Competitor Imitation

Easy

Easy

Hard

Product Sophistication

Standardized

Standardized Bundles

Customized

Product Structure

Simple

Simple

Complex

Third-Party Solutions

No

No

Yes

Sales Structure

Simple

Simple

Highly Complex

Invoice Requirements

Simple

Simple

Highly Complex

Receivable/Payables

Simple

Simple

Highly Complex

As the chart above shows, Total Solutions introduce complexity to the
product structure (i.e., sale elements and suppliers of those elements); sales
structure (i.e., charges that are fixed or variable, usage-based, reoccurring);
invoice requirements and receivable/payable requirements. Not included in
the chart above but particularly important is accurate and timely handling
of applicable taxes. Determining a solution’s tax qualifying activities in
multi-state and multi-national accounts is particularly daunting for any
organization.
The investment required to overhaul a company’s systems to support Total
Solutions is so significant that few venture into it until the ROI is compelling.
But companies do have an option. By offering financing as part of the Total
Solution, they can engage their finance partner to address some or all of the
process and system requirements of complex product offerings. Moreover, a
compelling financing solution can be critical to winning new business.
Whether your company is selling complex structures today, such as usagebased, complex bundles of products and services, managed services or
Total Solutions, the following considerations may be helpful as your product
offering evolves and your company seeks to build a sustainable competitive
advantage.

—5—
Part 3 Product Structure and
Administrative Considerations
As indicated earlier, the scope of this paper is to provide insight and
direction on four key requirements of complex pricing structures. The
first two requirements relate to product structure. The second two are
administrative capabilities.

Product Structure Considerations
•	 Maximizing margins and customer appeal of an offering through a
combination of usage-based, variable and fixed pricing structures.

•	 Partnering with third-party suppliers to fill gaps in a company’s offering
to create “True” Total Solutions that address the entire spectrum of
customer needs.
For most companies, a critical transforming aspect of building pricing
structures is developing deep customer insight through discussions with
multiple stakeholders at different levels. This knowledge provides you with
guidance on selecting sales structures and pricing that you can propose
with confidence.
Usage-based pricing structures are popular in complex solutions. These
consumption-based, variable pricing structures can be adjusted to
accommodate nearly any situation and provide opportunities to capture
unrealized revenue through higher margins or sales of additional products,
services or supplies.
Three usage-based systems are common:
Tiered: Customers agree to a certain usage level each period and pay more
if that level is exceeded.
	

Options include:

•	 Customers may or may not get rollover credit for unused usage.
•	 Each usage tier is priced separately. Customers may pay the full
price of each tier as they progress through the tiers; or only pay
the price of the highest tier achieved, which is priced lower than
earlier tiers.
Unlimited: Customers agree to a fixed price for unlimited usage.
Pay As You Go: Customers pay only for what they use and may or may not
have a minimum purchase requirement during each period.
As the “Usage Factor Examples” sidebar on page 8 shows, usage can be
based on any measurable factor—providing you with exceptional ability to
build customized pricing structures difficult for competitors to uncover and
sell against.
The challenge of delivering a complete total solution is having the full arsenal of
—6—
required products and services. A company can only develop so many of those
resources organically or through acquisition. By contrast, however, partnering
for the purpose of fulfilling the solution is a simple strategy.
While the strategy may be simple, administrative execution typically is difficult
and requires manual operations and the creation of new processes. Your
partners need clarity and transparency on how their offering is being consumed,
charged and paid. That requirement will be explored next.

Administrative Considerations
Complex selling structures have two key administrative objectives:

•	 Creating billing systems that customers can trust and invoices that clearly
show how costs were determined for every charged item.

•	 Ensuring that the accounts receivable/payable system can receive and
identify charges due and allocate payments to the company’s internal
divisions and third-party suppliers.
Billing systems for complex solutions must start with profiles of each billable
item. These profiles identify the provider of the product/service, asset/charge
type, asset/charge description, pricing matrix and tax status/rate, and may
include information such as contracted usage amount/charge, overage usage
rate, serial number, location and/or customer cost center. Non-assets such as
services, shipping and handling charges, supplies and fees also require profiles.
Invoice rules need to be created for each customized selling structure.
These rules attempt to account for every possible situation that can occur in
determining amounts due. Usage-based structures require a number of rules
such as the number of days early or late that usage can be reported for an
invoice cycle and how to process questionable reported and non-reported levels.
Your partners may also require certain invoicing rules related to their charges.
Invoice messaging also ties in to the rules and should automatically appear to
explain non-standard charges.
Other invoicing requirements include:
One Invoice: Customers need the simplicity of a single invoice that provides
both a summary of all major components of the solution along with the
detail behind the charges.
Content & Design: Invoices should be designed so customers can easily
understand the charges and how they were calculated. They should
allow for segmentation according to customer preference and the ability
to include messaging for special explanations or helpful information.
Clear and intuitive invoice design increases timely payment from the
customer, which can help your cash flow.
Marketing & Notices: Invoices should include the option to provide unlimited
1:1 or “one to many” messaging, advertising, policy/regulatory notices and
other communications to invoice recipients.
Electronic Invoices: Electronic invoices should be available for clients who
prefer paperless documents.
—7—
Consolidated Invoices: Customers should have the option to consolidate other
contracts into a single invoice.
Cost Allocation Splits: Customers should have the ability to apply internal
cost center codes directly to their invoices whether for single, multiple
or permanent frequency.
Charge Dispute and Resolution: Systems should provide real-time
adjustments to invoices that indicate disputed items and remove
those charges from the bill until they are resolved. This encourages
timely payment for the undisputed charges and increases customer
satisfaction.
Customer Invoice Inquiries: Systems should be able to produce reports
that indicate the names and frequency of customer inquiries on
specific topics.
Spreadsheet Invoicing: Some customers require invoices in spreadsheet
format to allow them to organize the charges for their own purposes.
Mark for Review: For times when the customer disputes certain charges
or when you want to view “what if” scenarios should components of
the current offering change, the system should produce an invoice and
release it upon confirmation from the customer or you.

Usage Factor Examples
•	 Device Based: Charges vary depending on the
equipment, devices or methods employed to use
the product/service.

Usage can be based on any measurable factor,
such as:
•	 Meter Based: Charges based on count.
•	 Location Based: Charges vary depending on
location.

•	 User Based: Charges based on the number of
users that are entitled to use or actually use the
product or service.

•	 Time Based: Charges vary depending on the
time of day, day of the week, season, etc. (e.g.,
lower rates when use is during off-peak hours).

•	 Performance Based: Charges based on how
well the product/service meets contracted
performance/service levels or outcomes/results.

•	Product or Application Based: Charges based
on usage of distinct products, applications,
performance (e.g., high bandwidth vs. low
bandwidth) or other categories/segments (e.g.,
Internet access: social networking sites, streaming
music, streaming movies).

•	 Promotion Based: Charges may be lower during
a designated period during the contract term.
•	 Asymmetric Price Transmission: Charges vary
with upstream price changes (i.e., inputs for
processing or manufacturing) that increase or
decrease downstream prices. This approach is
attractive to sellers when their cost to deliver
their offering is unstable and out of their control.

•	 Unit of Work (UoW) Based: A pricing schedule
identifies the price for each unit of work
consumed (e.g., in a simple two-part UoW
structure, the customer pays an initial fixed fee
for the first set of units then a different price for
each subsequent unit or bundles of units).

•	 Combinations: Charges may be combinations of
methods with certain activities being unlimited
or usage-based and others with usage caps.

—8—
Accounts Receivable/Payable Systems
Even with the best invoicing capabilities, companies selling complex product
structures require sophisticated accounts receivable/payable systems.
These systems must have the capability to accurately capture usage data
each period, create a receivable on each asset, apply complete and partial
payments, and accurately allocate payment to other internal divisions and to
third-party companies.
A challenge for structures with usage-based attributes is automating
the capturing and registering of actual usage levels each invoice period.
Fortunately, many software companies have solutions to address this
challenge.
Another challenge is determining how to handle incomplete, missing or
questionable usage data. Again, systematic solutions are required to avoid
the cost of manual intervention. Below are sample business rules for these
situations that the accounts receivable/payable system should incorporate.
Usage Prorated: When usage levels are not submitted on time, estimates
are calculated based on averages of previous use and credits or debits
are applied.
Rollover Until Full: All excess calculations are performed against the total
pool allowance, notwithstanding missing usage updates. Any unused
allowance is rolled over to the next billing cycle. The rollover resets each
time a full set of usage reads is received.
Bill on Complete Usage: No usage charges are included in the invoice until
all assets with usage levels are submitted; this could result in $0 invoices
and extraordinarily large dollar amounts due, which also delays client
receipt of their monies for services rendered.

Traps to Avoid When Building Total Solutions
Total Solutions require in-depth knowledge of the
customer objectives, strategies, market and internal
situations.
The first trap to avoid when building Total Solutions
is relying too heavily on one level of the customer’s
organization to validate the need and value of your
offering. Your sales people must be consultative sellers
and pursue building a network of contacts within the
prospective client’s organization. Sales people should
involve multiple functional organizations within the
customer as well as multiple levels within those groups
to validate the need and construct the solution and
pricing. The more they learn and understand about
the client’s pain points, needs and opportunities, the
stronger the value of your company’s recommended
solution.

Another potential misstep is not actively helping customers
during the decision-making process. In addition to working
broadly and deeply inside the customer’s organization, you
should provide your customer with a comprehensive list of
questions they should ask you and other potential suppliers.
These objective questions should provide an avenue for
you to ensure the customer’s awareness and understanding
of the nature of their need and the specific values of your
solution.
Lastly, it’s important to understand how your solution
impacts the customer’s bottom line. You should attempt
to quantify this figure and validate it with the customer’s
finance leadership. Bringing the customer’s finance team
into the decision making process provides the credibility
and confidence the company needs to move ahead with
your solution.

—9—
Leverage Your
Finance Provider’s Systems
Ask your finance provider how they can assist you in building and administering
complex structures like Total Solutions. Specifically, find out:
•	

Can they support the product and pricing structures or combination of
structures that you are considering?

•	

Do they have a limit on the number of usage items their systems
can process?

•	

What elements do they include in creating profiles of each
itemized charge?

•	

How do they determine whether an item is taxable and at what rate, and
how do they handle taxes due in states that charge taxes up-front versus in
arrears?

•	

What type of IT assistance do they provide to map data flows with each
division of your company involved in the sale, your partners and the finance
company itself?

•	

What are their ideas to increase revenues and margins on financed
transactions?

•	

What reporting and analytics do they provide to you, your partners and
your customers?

•	

Are there any limitations in their invoicing capabilities that would restrict the
product structure you want to sell?

•	

Can they provide 1:1 messages, situational messages or advertising into the
invoices?

•	

Do customers have the control to assign cost centers to the invoices?

•	

How do they handle customer disputes on invoice charges?

•	

What are your options for determining charges on usage-based items when
the usage is not reported?

•	

How are major accounts serviced (i.e., single point of contact or
larger team)?

•	

How are finance documents modified to best explain the sales and pricing
structure and the contract terms and conditions?

— 10 —
Part 4 Summary & Implications
•	

The global economy and technological advances are making it
increasingly difficult to maintain defensible margins and product
differences.

•	

80% of companies are facing increased pricing pressure from
customers and competitors.

•	

Traditional pricing and selling strategies force companies into a state
of “continuous commoditization.”

•	

Total Solutions sales structures break the commoditization cycle
through the customization of the offering and by addressing broader
customer needs.

•	

“True” Total Solutions are being made possible by advances in
invoicing and accounts receivable/payable systems, allowing
companies to more easily incorporate the offerings of other companies
to fill gaps in their own offerings.

•	

Significant capabilities are required of invoicing and accounts
receivable/payable systems when offering complex sales structures
like Total Solutions. These capabilities can make or break the success
of the offering and must be addressed prior to product launch.

•	

Companies considering a Total Solution or complex sales offering
should consider engaging a finance company to determine if they
can provide the systems and process capabilities for the offering.
By leveraging the finance provider’s experience and systems, a
company can be better positioned to meet the sales structuring and
administrative needs of a complex offering.

Total Solution Platforms,
combined with C-Suite direction,
enhance profitability by up to
50%, according to the MIT Sloan
Management Review.

— 11 —
FlexAbility products from CIT provide clients with unlimited options to
structure what they sell, how they charge for it and who they partner
with. Companies that go to market with complex sales structures such
as managed services, bundling and usage-based should talk to CIT to
understand:

•	 How FlexAbility, combined with a financed offering from CIT, makes
it possible for them to be more innovative in their sales and pricing
structures; and

•	 How FlexAbility makes administration of these structures easier, more
accurate and at lower operational expense from order entry through
accounts receivable.
FlexAbility is designed for manufacturers, software developers, service
companies, managed service providers, systems integrators, distributors,
dealers, resellers and end-user companies who use financing to sell
or acquire products. FlexAbility makes it possible for CIT clients to
maximize revenues, improve customer experience and build competitive
differentiation.
By simplifying the initial funding process and lifetime payables
administration of a financed offering, CIT removes the primary operational
roadblock that prevents companies from implementing Total Solutions and
other complex sales structures. Using FlexAbility, clients can confidently
expand their offering to include products and services of other internal
business units as well as third-party companies.
For additional information on FlexAbility:
Call: 888-365-FLEX (3539)  
Email: FlexAbility@cit.com
Visit: cit.com/flexability
CIT Equipment Finance
10201 Centurion Parkway N., Suite 100
Jacksonville, FL 32256

© Copyright 2014 CIT Group Inc., CIT and the CIT logo are registered service marks of CIT Group Inc.

— 12 —

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

STR 581 & STR 581 Capstone Final Examination Part Three - Questions and Answe...
STR 581 & STR 581 Capstone Final Examination Part Three - Questions and Answe...STR 581 & STR 581 Capstone Final Examination Part Three - Questions and Answe...
STR 581 & STR 581 Capstone Final Examination Part Three - Questions and Answe...UOP E Help
 
Business Strategy
Business StrategyBusiness Strategy
Business StrategyDetikBet
 
Channeldecisionandalternatives 130419093545-phpapp02
Channeldecisionandalternatives 130419093545-phpapp02Channeldecisionandalternatives 130419093545-phpapp02
Channeldecisionandalternatives 130419093545-phpapp02ANSHU TIWARI
 
Buyer supplier relationship
Buyer supplier relationshipBuyer supplier relationship
Buyer supplier relationshipGAURAV SHARMA
 
Information System Management
Information System ManagementInformation System Management
Information System ManagementMayank Kashyap
 
Strategies in action (lower version)
Strategies in action (lower version)Strategies in action (lower version)
Strategies in action (lower version)Twinkle Constantino
 
Topic2 Str Analysis
Topic2 Str AnalysisTopic2 Str Analysis
Topic2 Str Analysisguest8fdbdd
 
Topic 2 Corporate Strategy
Topic 2 Corporate StrategyTopic 2 Corporate Strategy
Topic 2 Corporate StrategyJutka Czirok
 
Purchasing Organization and Sourcing Strategy.
Purchasing Organization and Sourcing Strategy.Purchasing Organization and Sourcing Strategy.
Purchasing Organization and Sourcing Strategy.Divyanshu Dayal
 
Internal analysis
Internal analysisInternal analysis
Internal analysisroudha88
 
Lecture 4 industry studies v2 student
Lecture 4   industry studies v2 studentLecture 4   industry studies v2 student
Lecture 4 industry studies v2 studentmoduledesign
 
Topic5 Tailoring Strtgs
Topic5 Tailoring StrtgsTopic5 Tailoring Strtgs
Topic5 Tailoring Strtgsguest8fdbdd
 
Strategic management and competitive dynamics
Strategic management and competitive dynamics Strategic management and competitive dynamics
Strategic management and competitive dynamics Hamzah Rehail
 
A Value-Based connection: Aligning Commercial Strategy with Sales Execution
A Value-Based connection: Aligning Commercial Strategy with Sales ExecutionA Value-Based connection: Aligning Commercial Strategy with Sales Execution
A Value-Based connection: Aligning Commercial Strategy with Sales ExecutionAlex Rumble
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

STR 581 & STR 581 Capstone Final Examination Part Three - Questions and Answe...
STR 581 & STR 581 Capstone Final Examination Part Three - Questions and Answe...STR 581 & STR 581 Capstone Final Examination Part Three - Questions and Answe...
STR 581 & STR 581 Capstone Final Examination Part Three - Questions and Answe...
 
Chap005
Chap005Chap005
Chap005
 
Ch02 (1)
Ch02 (1)Ch02 (1)
Ch02 (1)
 
Business Strategy
Business StrategyBusiness Strategy
Business Strategy
 
Channeldecisionandalternatives 130419093545-phpapp02
Channeldecisionandalternatives 130419093545-phpapp02Channeldecisionandalternatives 130419093545-phpapp02
Channeldecisionandalternatives 130419093545-phpapp02
 
Buyer supplier relationship
Buyer supplier relationshipBuyer supplier relationship
Buyer supplier relationship
 
Information System Management
Information System ManagementInformation System Management
Information System Management
 
Strategies in action (lower version)
Strategies in action (lower version)Strategies in action (lower version)
Strategies in action (lower version)
 
Topic2 Str Analysis
Topic2 Str AnalysisTopic2 Str Analysis
Topic2 Str Analysis
 
Topic 2 Corporate Strategy
Topic 2 Corporate StrategyTopic 2 Corporate Strategy
Topic 2 Corporate Strategy
 
Purchasing Organization and Sourcing Strategy.
Purchasing Organization and Sourcing Strategy.Purchasing Organization and Sourcing Strategy.
Purchasing Organization and Sourcing Strategy.
 
Internal analysis
Internal analysisInternal analysis
Internal analysis
 
Lecture 4 industry studies v2 student
Lecture 4   industry studies v2 studentLecture 4   industry studies v2 student
Lecture 4 industry studies v2 student
 
Chapter 8 management
Chapter 8 managementChapter 8 management
Chapter 8 management
 
Strategies in Action
Strategies in ActionStrategies in Action
Strategies in Action
 
Industry and competitor analysis lec 5
Industry and competitor analysis lec 5Industry and competitor analysis lec 5
Industry and competitor analysis lec 5
 
Topic5 Tailoring Strtgs
Topic5 Tailoring StrtgsTopic5 Tailoring Strtgs
Topic5 Tailoring Strtgs
 
Chap002
Chap002Chap002
Chap002
 
Strategic management and competitive dynamics
Strategic management and competitive dynamics Strategic management and competitive dynamics
Strategic management and competitive dynamics
 
A Value-Based connection: Aligning Commercial Strategy with Sales Execution
A Value-Based connection: Aligning Commercial Strategy with Sales ExecutionA Value-Based connection: Aligning Commercial Strategy with Sales Execution
A Value-Based connection: Aligning Commercial Strategy with Sales Execution
 

Destacado

National Aviation Day
National Aviation DayNational Aviation Day
National Aviation DayCIT Group
 
The Los Angeles Area Fashion Industry Profile
The Los Angeles Area Fashion Industry ProfileThe Los Angeles Area Fashion Industry Profile
The Los Angeles Area Fashion Industry ProfileCIT Group
 
Aviation Industry Infographic
Aviation Industry InfographicAviation Industry Infographic
Aviation Industry InfographicCIT Group
 
CIT Case Study: Canpotex Limited
CIT Case Study: Canpotex LimitedCIT Case Study: Canpotex Limited
CIT Case Study: Canpotex LimitedCIT Group
 
CIT Healthcare Industry Outlook
CIT Healthcare Industry OutlookCIT Healthcare Industry Outlook
CIT Healthcare Industry OutlookCIT Group
 
2014 mmo-report
2014 mmo-report2014 mmo-report
2014 mmo-reportCIT Group
 
UCD14 Talk - Anna Dahlstrom - Device Agnostic Design: How to get your content...
UCD14 Talk - Anna Dahlstrom - Device Agnostic Design: How to get your content...UCD14 Talk - Anna Dahlstrom - Device Agnostic Design: How to get your content...
UCD14 Talk - Anna Dahlstrom - Device Agnostic Design: How to get your content...UCD UK Ltd
 
CIT Retail Industry Outlook - 2015
CIT Retail Industry Outlook - 2015CIT Retail Industry Outlook - 2015
CIT Retail Industry Outlook - 2015CIT Group
 
Manufacturing Industry Infographic
Manufacturing Industry InfographicManufacturing Industry Infographic
Manufacturing Industry InfographicCIT Group
 

Destacado (11)

National Aviation Day
National Aviation DayNational Aviation Day
National Aviation Day
 
The Los Angeles Area Fashion Industry Profile
The Los Angeles Area Fashion Industry ProfileThe Los Angeles Area Fashion Industry Profile
The Los Angeles Area Fashion Industry Profile
 
Greater Cleveland Middle Market Forum Polling Results
Greater Cleveland Middle Market Forum Polling ResultsGreater Cleveland Middle Market Forum Polling Results
Greater Cleveland Middle Market Forum Polling Results
 
Aviation Industry Infographic
Aviation Industry InfographicAviation Industry Infographic
Aviation Industry Infographic
 
CIT Case Study: Canpotex Limited
CIT Case Study: Canpotex LimitedCIT Case Study: Canpotex Limited
CIT Case Study: Canpotex Limited
 
CIT Healthcare Industry Outlook
CIT Healthcare Industry OutlookCIT Healthcare Industry Outlook
CIT Healthcare Industry Outlook
 
2014 mmo-report
2014 mmo-report2014 mmo-report
2014 mmo-report
 
UCD14 Talk - Anna Dahlstrom - Device Agnostic Design: How to get your content...
UCD14 Talk - Anna Dahlstrom - Device Agnostic Design: How to get your content...UCD14 Talk - Anna Dahlstrom - Device Agnostic Design: How to get your content...
UCD14 Talk - Anna Dahlstrom - Device Agnostic Design: How to get your content...
 
CIT Retail Industry Outlook - 2015
CIT Retail Industry Outlook - 2015CIT Retail Industry Outlook - 2015
CIT Retail Industry Outlook - 2015
 
Manufacturing Industry Infographic
Manufacturing Industry InfographicManufacturing Industry Infographic
Manufacturing Industry Infographic
 
Hathrone experiments
Hathrone experimentsHathrone experiments
Hathrone experiments
 

Similar a Executing a Total Solutions Strategy - And Other Complex Selling and Pricing Structures

Stategic management
Stategic managementStategic management
Stategic managementemildasamuel
 
Innovative competitive advantages in business notes
Innovative competitive advantages in business notesInnovative competitive advantages in business notes
Innovative competitive advantages in business notesAylya B.S
 
Top 10 Questions : Chapter 2 : Ansay
Top 10 Questions : Chapter 2 : AnsayTop 10 Questions : Chapter 2 : Ansay
Top 10 Questions : Chapter 2 : Ansaycatansay
 
STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT-TOPIC 5 (1).ppt
STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT-TOPIC 5 (1).pptSTRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT-TOPIC 5 (1).ppt
STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT-TOPIC 5 (1).pptRenvic
 
B2B value Proposition toolkit
B2B value Proposition toolkitB2B value Proposition toolkit
B2B value Proposition toolkitCharuDixit5
 
Strategic Management:Business Level Strategies, Corporate level Analysis,
Strategic Management:Business Level Strategies, Corporate level Analysis,Strategic Management:Business Level Strategies, Corporate level Analysis,
Strategic Management:Business Level Strategies, Corporate level Analysis,Kishor Deka
 
Customer profitability analysis crm ppt
Customer profitability analysis crm pptCustomer profitability analysis crm ppt
Customer profitability analysis crm pptJaswinder Singh
 
Marketing Strategy.pptx
Marketing Strategy.pptxMarketing Strategy.pptx
Marketing Strategy.pptxMubeenNavaz1
 
Strategic Marketing PPT.pptx
Strategic Marketing PPT.pptxStrategic Marketing PPT.pptx
Strategic Marketing PPT.pptxBereketDesalegn5
 
Strategic management
Strategic managementStrategic management
Strategic managementShipra Yeeshu
 
ROLE OF IT IN BUSINESS
ROLE OF IT IN BUSINESSROLE OF IT IN BUSINESS
ROLE OF IT IN BUSINESShuma sh
 
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a ThreatMarch 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a ThreatJohn Edmunds
 
Cost Management A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Blocher Solutions Manual
Cost Management A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Blocher Solutions ManualCost Management A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Blocher Solutions Manual
Cost Management A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Blocher Solutions ManualAyannaban
 
MKT 571 TUTOR Begins Education / www.mkt571edu.com
MKT 571 TUTOR Begins Education / www.mkt571edu.comMKT 571 TUTOR Begins Education / www.mkt571edu.com
MKT 571 TUTOR Begins Education / www.mkt571edu.comSpencerLStuart
 
The Golden Triangle of Value Creation - Paul Lim
The Golden Triangle of Value Creation - Paul LimThe Golden Triangle of Value Creation - Paul Lim
The Golden Triangle of Value Creation - Paul LimPaul Lim
 
[Case Study] Launching Innocent + Developing a new product for the teeth whit...
[Case Study] Launching Innocent + Developing a new product for the teeth whit...[Case Study] Launching Innocent + Developing a new product for the teeth whit...
[Case Study] Launching Innocent + Developing a new product for the teeth whit...Riri Kusumarani
 

Similar a Executing a Total Solutions Strategy - And Other Complex Selling and Pricing Structures (20)

Stategic management
Stategic managementStategic management
Stategic management
 
Operations strategy
Operations strategyOperations strategy
Operations strategy
 
Innovative competitive advantages in business notes
Innovative competitive advantages in business notesInnovative competitive advantages in business notes
Innovative competitive advantages in business notes
 
Top 10 Questions : Chapter 2 : Ansay
Top 10 Questions : Chapter 2 : AnsayTop 10 Questions : Chapter 2 : Ansay
Top 10 Questions : Chapter 2 : Ansay
 
STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT-TOPIC 5 (1).ppt
STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT-TOPIC 5 (1).pptSTRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT-TOPIC 5 (1).ppt
STRATEGIC COST MANAGEMENT-TOPIC 5 (1).ppt
 
CHAPTER-3.pptx
CHAPTER-3.pptxCHAPTER-3.pptx
CHAPTER-3.pptx
 
B2B value Proposition toolkit
B2B value Proposition toolkitB2B value Proposition toolkit
B2B value Proposition toolkit
 
SCM
SCMSCM
SCM
 
Strategic Management:Business Level Strategies, Corporate level Analysis,
Strategic Management:Business Level Strategies, Corporate level Analysis,Strategic Management:Business Level Strategies, Corporate level Analysis,
Strategic Management:Business Level Strategies, Corporate level Analysis,
 
Customer profitability analysis crm ppt
Customer profitability analysis crm pptCustomer profitability analysis crm ppt
Customer profitability analysis crm ppt
 
Marketing Strategy.pptx
Marketing Strategy.pptxMarketing Strategy.pptx
Marketing Strategy.pptx
 
Strategic Marketing PPT.pptx
Strategic Marketing PPT.pptxStrategic Marketing PPT.pptx
Strategic Marketing PPT.pptx
 
Strategic management
Strategic managementStrategic management
Strategic management
 
ROLE OF IT IN BUSINESS
ROLE OF IT IN BUSINESSROLE OF IT IN BUSINESS
ROLE OF IT IN BUSINESS
 
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a ThreatMarch 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
March 2015 Infinity Gaming Magazine - Is Commoditization a Threat
 
Cost Management A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Blocher Solutions Manual
Cost Management A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Blocher Solutions ManualCost Management A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Blocher Solutions Manual
Cost Management A Strategic Emphasis 8th Edition Blocher Solutions Manual
 
MKT 571 TUTOR Begins Education / www.mkt571edu.com
MKT 571 TUTOR Begins Education / www.mkt571edu.comMKT 571 TUTOR Begins Education / www.mkt571edu.com
MKT 571 TUTOR Begins Education / www.mkt571edu.com
 
The Golden Triangle of Value Creation - Paul Lim
The Golden Triangle of Value Creation - Paul LimThe Golden Triangle of Value Creation - Paul Lim
The Golden Triangle of Value Creation - Paul Lim
 
[Case Study] Launching Innocent + Developing a new product for the teeth whit...
[Case Study] Launching Innocent + Developing a new product for the teeth whit...[Case Study] Launching Innocent + Developing a new product for the teeth whit...
[Case Study] Launching Innocent + Developing a new product for the teeth whit...
 
Strategic KAM
Strategic KAMStrategic KAM
Strategic KAM
 

Más de CIT Group

The Value of New-Technology Single-Aisles
The Value of New-Technology Single-AislesThe Value of New-Technology Single-Aisles
The Value of New-Technology Single-AislesCIT Group
 
Fast Facts in Five: The Maritime Industry
Fast Facts in Five: The Maritime IndustryFast Facts in Five: The Maritime Industry
Fast Facts in Five: The Maritime IndustryCIT Group
 
Commercial Real Estate Outlook Infographic
Commercial Real Estate Outlook InfographicCommercial Real Estate Outlook Infographic
Commercial Real Estate Outlook InfographicCIT Group
 
CIT Commercial Real Estate Outlook
CIT Commercial Real Estate OutlookCIT Commercial Real Estate Outlook
CIT Commercial Real Estate OutlookCIT Group
 
Impacts of a New Lease Accounting Standard for the Mid Sized Business
Impacts of a New Lease Accounting Standard for the Mid Sized BusinessImpacts of a New Lease Accounting Standard for the Mid Sized Business
Impacts of a New Lease Accounting Standard for the Mid Sized BusinessCIT Group
 
Why Residential Solar is Having a Powerful Impact
Why Residential Solar is Having a Powerful ImpactWhy Residential Solar is Having a Powerful Impact
Why Residential Solar is Having a Powerful ImpactCIT Group
 
CIT Aerospace Outlook Report
CIT Aerospace Outlook ReportCIT Aerospace Outlook Report
CIT Aerospace Outlook ReportCIT Group
 
Fast Facts in Five: Manufacturing
Fast Facts in Five: ManufacturingFast Facts in Five: Manufacturing
Fast Facts in Five: ManufacturingCIT Group
 
Fast Facts in Five: The Internet of Things
Fast Facts in Five: The Internet of ThingsFast Facts in Five: The Internet of Things
Fast Facts in Five: The Internet of ThingsCIT Group
 
Capital Equipment Finance: The Lifeblood of Growth
Capital Equipment Finance: The Lifeblood of GrowthCapital Equipment Finance: The Lifeblood of Growth
Capital Equipment Finance: The Lifeblood of GrowthCIT Group
 
Fueling Your Company’s Growth
Fueling Your Company’s GrowthFueling Your Company’s Growth
Fueling Your Company’s GrowthCIT Group
 
Business Aviation in China – Enormous Potential, Serious Obstacles
Business Aviation in China –  Enormous Potential, Serious ObstaclesBusiness Aviation in China –  Enormous Potential, Serious Obstacles
Business Aviation in China – Enormous Potential, Serious ObstaclesCIT Group
 
What is the Internet of Things?
What is the Internet of Things?What is the Internet of Things?
What is the Internet of Things?CIT Group
 
2015 healthcare-outlook-report
2015 healthcare-outlook-report2015 healthcare-outlook-report
2015 healthcare-outlook-reportCIT Group
 
Philanthropy… It’s About Giving and Receiving
Philanthropy… It’s About Giving and ReceivingPhilanthropy… It’s About Giving and Receiving
Philanthropy… It’s About Giving and ReceivingCIT Group
 
National Philanthropy Day
National Philanthropy DayNational Philanthropy Day
National Philanthropy DayCIT Group
 
Middle Market Economic Outlook: At a Glance
Middle Market Economic Outlook: At a GlanceMiddle Market Economic Outlook: At a Glance
Middle Market Economic Outlook: At a GlanceCIT Group
 
CIT: Voice of the Middle Market
CIT: Voice of the Middle MarketCIT: Voice of the Middle Market
CIT: Voice of the Middle MarketCIT Group
 
National Manufacturing Day
National Manufacturing DayNational Manufacturing Day
National Manufacturing DayCIT Group
 
Why The Middle Market Matters
Why The Middle Market MattersWhy The Middle Market Matters
Why The Middle Market MattersCIT Group
 

Más de CIT Group (20)

The Value of New-Technology Single-Aisles
The Value of New-Technology Single-AislesThe Value of New-Technology Single-Aisles
The Value of New-Technology Single-Aisles
 
Fast Facts in Five: The Maritime Industry
Fast Facts in Five: The Maritime IndustryFast Facts in Five: The Maritime Industry
Fast Facts in Five: The Maritime Industry
 
Commercial Real Estate Outlook Infographic
Commercial Real Estate Outlook InfographicCommercial Real Estate Outlook Infographic
Commercial Real Estate Outlook Infographic
 
CIT Commercial Real Estate Outlook
CIT Commercial Real Estate OutlookCIT Commercial Real Estate Outlook
CIT Commercial Real Estate Outlook
 
Impacts of a New Lease Accounting Standard for the Mid Sized Business
Impacts of a New Lease Accounting Standard for the Mid Sized BusinessImpacts of a New Lease Accounting Standard for the Mid Sized Business
Impacts of a New Lease Accounting Standard for the Mid Sized Business
 
Why Residential Solar is Having a Powerful Impact
Why Residential Solar is Having a Powerful ImpactWhy Residential Solar is Having a Powerful Impact
Why Residential Solar is Having a Powerful Impact
 
CIT Aerospace Outlook Report
CIT Aerospace Outlook ReportCIT Aerospace Outlook Report
CIT Aerospace Outlook Report
 
Fast Facts in Five: Manufacturing
Fast Facts in Five: ManufacturingFast Facts in Five: Manufacturing
Fast Facts in Five: Manufacturing
 
Fast Facts in Five: The Internet of Things
Fast Facts in Five: The Internet of ThingsFast Facts in Five: The Internet of Things
Fast Facts in Five: The Internet of Things
 
Capital Equipment Finance: The Lifeblood of Growth
Capital Equipment Finance: The Lifeblood of GrowthCapital Equipment Finance: The Lifeblood of Growth
Capital Equipment Finance: The Lifeblood of Growth
 
Fueling Your Company’s Growth
Fueling Your Company’s GrowthFueling Your Company’s Growth
Fueling Your Company’s Growth
 
Business Aviation in China – Enormous Potential, Serious Obstacles
Business Aviation in China –  Enormous Potential, Serious ObstaclesBusiness Aviation in China –  Enormous Potential, Serious Obstacles
Business Aviation in China – Enormous Potential, Serious Obstacles
 
What is the Internet of Things?
What is the Internet of Things?What is the Internet of Things?
What is the Internet of Things?
 
2015 healthcare-outlook-report
2015 healthcare-outlook-report2015 healthcare-outlook-report
2015 healthcare-outlook-report
 
Philanthropy… It’s About Giving and Receiving
Philanthropy… It’s About Giving and ReceivingPhilanthropy… It’s About Giving and Receiving
Philanthropy… It’s About Giving and Receiving
 
National Philanthropy Day
National Philanthropy DayNational Philanthropy Day
National Philanthropy Day
 
Middle Market Economic Outlook: At a Glance
Middle Market Economic Outlook: At a GlanceMiddle Market Economic Outlook: At a Glance
Middle Market Economic Outlook: At a Glance
 
CIT: Voice of the Middle Market
CIT: Voice of the Middle MarketCIT: Voice of the Middle Market
CIT: Voice of the Middle Market
 
National Manufacturing Day
National Manufacturing DayNational Manufacturing Day
National Manufacturing Day
 
Why The Middle Market Matters
Why The Middle Market MattersWhy The Middle Market Matters
Why The Middle Market Matters
 

Executing a Total Solutions Strategy - And Other Complex Selling and Pricing Structures

  • 1. Executing a Total Solutions Strategy And Other Complex Selling and Pricing Structures A CIT White Paper Contents: Part 1: Abstract and Introduction Part 2: The Evolution of Product Strategy Part 3: Product Structure and Administrative Considerations Part 4: Summary & Implications A CIT White Paper —1—
  • 2. Part 1 Abstract In nearly every industry, the effects of globalization and rapid advances in technology have delivered hyper-competition resulting in product commoditization and an inability for companies to sustain long-term competitive advantages. In this environment, companies in highly competitive markets face additional headwinds from clients who have become more discriminating and less interested in acquiring standard, onesize-fits-all products. Instead, clients demand products and services with greater customization to better fit their needs. In response, many companies have attempted to shift away from traditional product-focused strategies and have moved to a “Total Solutions” strategy and a customer-centric orientation. Much has been written in business literature and academia about how companies and entire industries are reinventing themselves through a Total Solutions strategy. Despite all the in-depth explorations, little can be found on key product structures and administrative requirements necessary for any Total Solutions offering. Following a brief review of the evolution from standalone products to Total Solutions, this white paper will explore the following requirements and provide considerations for companies who are pursuing a Total Solutions strategy. Product Structure Requirements • Maximizing margins and customer appeal of an offering through a combination of usage-based, variable and fixed pricing structures. • Partnering with third-party suppliers to fill gaps in a company’s offering to create true Total Solutions that address the entire spectrum of customer needs. Administrative Requirements • Creating billing systems that customers can trust and invoices that clearly show how costs were determined for every charged item. • Ensuring that the accounts receivable/payable system can receive and identify charges due and allocate payments to the company’s internal divisions and third-party suppliers. —2—
  • 3. Introduction A recent in-depth survey of 2,700 executives and managers from 50 countries revealed that 80% of companies are facing increased pricing pressure from customers and competitors.1 Further, the survey found that profits rise sharply when C-level executives take an active role in pricing. Similarly, higher profits and revenues can occur when C-level executives get engaged in product strategy. Failing to defend product differentiation on values critical to customers is a path to commoditization. No matter the industry, product or service, commoditization is a constant threat to margins as well as revenue growth. One strategy to combat commoditization is to change the rules of engagement in your industry by innovating on the product structure: what you sell, who you partner with and how you address the larger needs of customers. Part 2 The Evolution of Product Strategy Historically, most companies were product-centered, meaning they focused more on making the perfect product to maximize their profit rather than the perfect product to maximize customer needs. Until fairly recently, the product lifecycle consisted of three predictable phases. Phase I: Innovation You introduce a new product that fits a unique niche in the market. Competition is limited. Customers are abundant and margins are rich. Phase II: Competition New entrants enter your space, putting pressure on sales and margins by making improvements along the value chain (e.g., low-cost, low-benefit offerings that target the mass market; or new combinations of price and unique benefits that target specific customer segments) or by investing in such areas as distribution network, sales resources, promotions and advertising. Phase III: Reinvention You attempt to reinvent your product—usually by playing catch-up with me-too features and benefits or by leap-frogging competitors in some manner. However, pressure to innovate and maintain a sustainable competitive advantage continues. In the 1990s, more companies realized that the traditional product lifecycle failed to break their offerings out of a state of continuous commoditization. At some point during the Competition or Reinvention phases, successful companies made the strategic switch from being product-centered to being customer-centered. This shift led to the creation of a new strategy for the Reinvention phase: Total Solutions. 1 —3— Global Pricing Study, Nov. 2012, Simon-Kucher & Partners
  • 4. Customer Centricity & Total Solutions In conjunction with the product lifecycle, companies have shifted their strategy from standalone products and services… to product “plus” complementary products or services… to Total Solutions. Standalone Sales Initially, companies typically sell a standalone product, which is standardized to appeal to the broadest number of customers. The simplicity of this product makes it easier for competitors to replicate. Products are sold individually to address a single-purpose customer need. For example, purchases of copiers, medical devices, computers, telecommunication systems, trucks, cranes, machinery and so forth are often one-time events. Related in-house products and services may be sold to the same customer. Fundamentally, however, no meaningful additional revenue will be earned from the original sale until the core product needs to be replaced. “Product Plus” Sales As competition heats up, companies attempt to differentiate their offerings with a “Product Plus” strategy of bundling additional features, products and services. They may acquire other companies to enhance their product offerings, for example. Despite the broadening of the offering, the product structure remains relatively simple, comprising almost exclusively in-house offerings, and fails to provide a sustainable competitive advantage. Total Solutions Sales When the “Product Plus” strategy fails to slow down the competition, some companies and sometimes entire industries decide to embrace a Total Solutions strategy (e.g., nearly all copier manufacturers have attempted to move to managed print services in recent years). This product structure is customer-centric, complex and customized for each client, making it difficult for competitors to displace the incumbent. Customers usually are deeply engaged in defining the product need and shaping the solution. The product is characterized by multiple components, from hardware and software to services and supplies. Each component may have a unique pricing structure: fixed or variable, consumption/usagebased, subscription-based, one-time or reoccurring charges. For instance, an IT managed service provider may structure its Total Solutions to include hardware, applications and systems management, supplemented by third-party solutions for web hosting, cloud storage, application development and network services. “True” Total Solutions Sales A more recent trend in Total Solutions is made possible through sophisticated invoicing and accounts receivable/payable systems. In what is being called “True” Total Solutions, this sales strategy is differentiated by its inclusiveness of third-party companies whose capabilities and existing —4—
  • 5. customer relationships are leveraged to form synergistic offerings and pricing options competitors cannot match. A historic challenge of such structures has been the lack of capabilities of traditional sales origination, accounting, receivable/payable and invoicing systems to process a multi-faceted, multi-partner offering. Despite this challenge, companies eager to realize the revenues proceed with the strategy. In such cases, these companies find that the only way to manage transactions is through manual processes, which eat into profitability through higher operating expenses. Further, the manual workarounds are inherently error prone and negatively impact internal controls as well as customer satisfaction. Standalone Product Product Plus Total Solutions Customer Centered Strategic Focus Product Centered Product Centered Competitor Imitation Easy Easy Hard Product Sophistication Standardized Standardized Bundles Customized Product Structure Simple Simple Complex Third-Party Solutions No No Yes Sales Structure Simple Simple Highly Complex Invoice Requirements Simple Simple Highly Complex Receivable/Payables Simple Simple Highly Complex As the chart above shows, Total Solutions introduce complexity to the product structure (i.e., sale elements and suppliers of those elements); sales structure (i.e., charges that are fixed or variable, usage-based, reoccurring); invoice requirements and receivable/payable requirements. Not included in the chart above but particularly important is accurate and timely handling of applicable taxes. Determining a solution’s tax qualifying activities in multi-state and multi-national accounts is particularly daunting for any organization. The investment required to overhaul a company’s systems to support Total Solutions is so significant that few venture into it until the ROI is compelling. But companies do have an option. By offering financing as part of the Total Solution, they can engage their finance partner to address some or all of the process and system requirements of complex product offerings. Moreover, a compelling financing solution can be critical to winning new business. Whether your company is selling complex structures today, such as usagebased, complex bundles of products and services, managed services or Total Solutions, the following considerations may be helpful as your product offering evolves and your company seeks to build a sustainable competitive advantage. —5—
  • 6. Part 3 Product Structure and Administrative Considerations As indicated earlier, the scope of this paper is to provide insight and direction on four key requirements of complex pricing structures. The first two requirements relate to product structure. The second two are administrative capabilities. Product Structure Considerations • Maximizing margins and customer appeal of an offering through a combination of usage-based, variable and fixed pricing structures. • Partnering with third-party suppliers to fill gaps in a company’s offering to create “True” Total Solutions that address the entire spectrum of customer needs. For most companies, a critical transforming aspect of building pricing structures is developing deep customer insight through discussions with multiple stakeholders at different levels. This knowledge provides you with guidance on selecting sales structures and pricing that you can propose with confidence. Usage-based pricing structures are popular in complex solutions. These consumption-based, variable pricing structures can be adjusted to accommodate nearly any situation and provide opportunities to capture unrealized revenue through higher margins or sales of additional products, services or supplies. Three usage-based systems are common: Tiered: Customers agree to a certain usage level each period and pay more if that level is exceeded. Options include: • Customers may or may not get rollover credit for unused usage. • Each usage tier is priced separately. Customers may pay the full price of each tier as they progress through the tiers; or only pay the price of the highest tier achieved, which is priced lower than earlier tiers. Unlimited: Customers agree to a fixed price for unlimited usage. Pay As You Go: Customers pay only for what they use and may or may not have a minimum purchase requirement during each period. As the “Usage Factor Examples” sidebar on page 8 shows, usage can be based on any measurable factor—providing you with exceptional ability to build customized pricing structures difficult for competitors to uncover and sell against. The challenge of delivering a complete total solution is having the full arsenal of —6—
  • 7. required products and services. A company can only develop so many of those resources organically or through acquisition. By contrast, however, partnering for the purpose of fulfilling the solution is a simple strategy. While the strategy may be simple, administrative execution typically is difficult and requires manual operations and the creation of new processes. Your partners need clarity and transparency on how their offering is being consumed, charged and paid. That requirement will be explored next. Administrative Considerations Complex selling structures have two key administrative objectives: • Creating billing systems that customers can trust and invoices that clearly show how costs were determined for every charged item. • Ensuring that the accounts receivable/payable system can receive and identify charges due and allocate payments to the company’s internal divisions and third-party suppliers. Billing systems for complex solutions must start with profiles of each billable item. These profiles identify the provider of the product/service, asset/charge type, asset/charge description, pricing matrix and tax status/rate, and may include information such as contracted usage amount/charge, overage usage rate, serial number, location and/or customer cost center. Non-assets such as services, shipping and handling charges, supplies and fees also require profiles. Invoice rules need to be created for each customized selling structure. These rules attempt to account for every possible situation that can occur in determining amounts due. Usage-based structures require a number of rules such as the number of days early or late that usage can be reported for an invoice cycle and how to process questionable reported and non-reported levels. Your partners may also require certain invoicing rules related to their charges. Invoice messaging also ties in to the rules and should automatically appear to explain non-standard charges. Other invoicing requirements include: One Invoice: Customers need the simplicity of a single invoice that provides both a summary of all major components of the solution along with the detail behind the charges. Content & Design: Invoices should be designed so customers can easily understand the charges and how they were calculated. They should allow for segmentation according to customer preference and the ability to include messaging for special explanations or helpful information. Clear and intuitive invoice design increases timely payment from the customer, which can help your cash flow. Marketing & Notices: Invoices should include the option to provide unlimited 1:1 or “one to many” messaging, advertising, policy/regulatory notices and other communications to invoice recipients. Electronic Invoices: Electronic invoices should be available for clients who prefer paperless documents. —7—
  • 8. Consolidated Invoices: Customers should have the option to consolidate other contracts into a single invoice. Cost Allocation Splits: Customers should have the ability to apply internal cost center codes directly to their invoices whether for single, multiple or permanent frequency. Charge Dispute and Resolution: Systems should provide real-time adjustments to invoices that indicate disputed items and remove those charges from the bill until they are resolved. This encourages timely payment for the undisputed charges and increases customer satisfaction. Customer Invoice Inquiries: Systems should be able to produce reports that indicate the names and frequency of customer inquiries on specific topics. Spreadsheet Invoicing: Some customers require invoices in spreadsheet format to allow them to organize the charges for their own purposes. Mark for Review: For times when the customer disputes certain charges or when you want to view “what if” scenarios should components of the current offering change, the system should produce an invoice and release it upon confirmation from the customer or you. Usage Factor Examples • Device Based: Charges vary depending on the equipment, devices or methods employed to use the product/service. Usage can be based on any measurable factor, such as: • Meter Based: Charges based on count. • Location Based: Charges vary depending on location. • User Based: Charges based on the number of users that are entitled to use or actually use the product or service. • Time Based: Charges vary depending on the time of day, day of the week, season, etc. (e.g., lower rates when use is during off-peak hours). • Performance Based: Charges based on how well the product/service meets contracted performance/service levels or outcomes/results. • Product or Application Based: Charges based on usage of distinct products, applications, performance (e.g., high bandwidth vs. low bandwidth) or other categories/segments (e.g., Internet access: social networking sites, streaming music, streaming movies). • Promotion Based: Charges may be lower during a designated period during the contract term. • Asymmetric Price Transmission: Charges vary with upstream price changes (i.e., inputs for processing or manufacturing) that increase or decrease downstream prices. This approach is attractive to sellers when their cost to deliver their offering is unstable and out of their control. • Unit of Work (UoW) Based: A pricing schedule identifies the price for each unit of work consumed (e.g., in a simple two-part UoW structure, the customer pays an initial fixed fee for the first set of units then a different price for each subsequent unit or bundles of units). • Combinations: Charges may be combinations of methods with certain activities being unlimited or usage-based and others with usage caps. —8—
  • 9. Accounts Receivable/Payable Systems Even with the best invoicing capabilities, companies selling complex product structures require sophisticated accounts receivable/payable systems. These systems must have the capability to accurately capture usage data each period, create a receivable on each asset, apply complete and partial payments, and accurately allocate payment to other internal divisions and to third-party companies. A challenge for structures with usage-based attributes is automating the capturing and registering of actual usage levels each invoice period. Fortunately, many software companies have solutions to address this challenge. Another challenge is determining how to handle incomplete, missing or questionable usage data. Again, systematic solutions are required to avoid the cost of manual intervention. Below are sample business rules for these situations that the accounts receivable/payable system should incorporate. Usage Prorated: When usage levels are not submitted on time, estimates are calculated based on averages of previous use and credits or debits are applied. Rollover Until Full: All excess calculations are performed against the total pool allowance, notwithstanding missing usage updates. Any unused allowance is rolled over to the next billing cycle. The rollover resets each time a full set of usage reads is received. Bill on Complete Usage: No usage charges are included in the invoice until all assets with usage levels are submitted; this could result in $0 invoices and extraordinarily large dollar amounts due, which also delays client receipt of their monies for services rendered. Traps to Avoid When Building Total Solutions Total Solutions require in-depth knowledge of the customer objectives, strategies, market and internal situations. The first trap to avoid when building Total Solutions is relying too heavily on one level of the customer’s organization to validate the need and value of your offering. Your sales people must be consultative sellers and pursue building a network of contacts within the prospective client’s organization. Sales people should involve multiple functional organizations within the customer as well as multiple levels within those groups to validate the need and construct the solution and pricing. The more they learn and understand about the client’s pain points, needs and opportunities, the stronger the value of your company’s recommended solution. Another potential misstep is not actively helping customers during the decision-making process. In addition to working broadly and deeply inside the customer’s organization, you should provide your customer with a comprehensive list of questions they should ask you and other potential suppliers. These objective questions should provide an avenue for you to ensure the customer’s awareness and understanding of the nature of their need and the specific values of your solution. Lastly, it’s important to understand how your solution impacts the customer’s bottom line. You should attempt to quantify this figure and validate it with the customer’s finance leadership. Bringing the customer’s finance team into the decision making process provides the credibility and confidence the company needs to move ahead with your solution. —9—
  • 10. Leverage Your Finance Provider’s Systems Ask your finance provider how they can assist you in building and administering complex structures like Total Solutions. Specifically, find out: • Can they support the product and pricing structures or combination of structures that you are considering? • Do they have a limit on the number of usage items their systems can process? • What elements do they include in creating profiles of each itemized charge? • How do they determine whether an item is taxable and at what rate, and how do they handle taxes due in states that charge taxes up-front versus in arrears? • What type of IT assistance do they provide to map data flows with each division of your company involved in the sale, your partners and the finance company itself? • What are their ideas to increase revenues and margins on financed transactions? • What reporting and analytics do they provide to you, your partners and your customers? • Are there any limitations in their invoicing capabilities that would restrict the product structure you want to sell? • Can they provide 1:1 messages, situational messages or advertising into the invoices? • Do customers have the control to assign cost centers to the invoices? • How do they handle customer disputes on invoice charges? • What are your options for determining charges on usage-based items when the usage is not reported? • How are major accounts serviced (i.e., single point of contact or larger team)? • How are finance documents modified to best explain the sales and pricing structure and the contract terms and conditions? — 10 —
  • 11. Part 4 Summary & Implications • The global economy and technological advances are making it increasingly difficult to maintain defensible margins and product differences. • 80% of companies are facing increased pricing pressure from customers and competitors. • Traditional pricing and selling strategies force companies into a state of “continuous commoditization.” • Total Solutions sales structures break the commoditization cycle through the customization of the offering and by addressing broader customer needs. • “True” Total Solutions are being made possible by advances in invoicing and accounts receivable/payable systems, allowing companies to more easily incorporate the offerings of other companies to fill gaps in their own offerings. • Significant capabilities are required of invoicing and accounts receivable/payable systems when offering complex sales structures like Total Solutions. These capabilities can make or break the success of the offering and must be addressed prior to product launch. • Companies considering a Total Solution or complex sales offering should consider engaging a finance company to determine if they can provide the systems and process capabilities for the offering. By leveraging the finance provider’s experience and systems, a company can be better positioned to meet the sales structuring and administrative needs of a complex offering. Total Solution Platforms, combined with C-Suite direction, enhance profitability by up to 50%, according to the MIT Sloan Management Review. — 11 —
  • 12. FlexAbility products from CIT provide clients with unlimited options to structure what they sell, how they charge for it and who they partner with. Companies that go to market with complex sales structures such as managed services, bundling and usage-based should talk to CIT to understand: • How FlexAbility, combined with a financed offering from CIT, makes it possible for them to be more innovative in their sales and pricing structures; and • How FlexAbility makes administration of these structures easier, more accurate and at lower operational expense from order entry through accounts receivable. FlexAbility is designed for manufacturers, software developers, service companies, managed service providers, systems integrators, distributors, dealers, resellers and end-user companies who use financing to sell or acquire products. FlexAbility makes it possible for CIT clients to maximize revenues, improve customer experience and build competitive differentiation. By simplifying the initial funding process and lifetime payables administration of a financed offering, CIT removes the primary operational roadblock that prevents companies from implementing Total Solutions and other complex sales structures. Using FlexAbility, clients can confidently expand their offering to include products and services of other internal business units as well as third-party companies. For additional information on FlexAbility: Call: 888-365-FLEX (3539) Email: FlexAbility@cit.com Visit: cit.com/flexability CIT Equipment Finance 10201 Centurion Parkway N., Suite 100 Jacksonville, FL 32256 © Copyright 2014 CIT Group Inc., CIT and the CIT logo are registered service marks of CIT Group Inc. — 12 —