Voting responses from both CaBA startup conferences. For each question, the first slide is the Yorkshire response, the second slide is London response.

1. Interac(ve
discussion
Chairman
–
Alistair
Maltby
The
Rivers
Trust
Ca tchment
B ased
A pproach
Partnerships
f or
Action

2. 1/12.
Who
are
you?
1. Catchment
partnership
lead
/
host
2. Partner
in
a
catchment
partnership
3. Would
like
to
be
in
a
catchment
partnership
4. Providing
support
to
catchment
partnerships
5. Another
interest
/
role
in
CaBA
Yorkshire

3. ou
l
An
ot
he
ri
to
be
nt
er
es
t
/r
ol
ei
.. .
C.
..
Ca
.. .
a
a
to
in
...
Le
..
tP
p
at
ch
m
en
tn
er
sh
i
Catchment
Su
pp
or
t
lik
e
aC
tP
ar
n
in
g
d
Pr
ov
id
W
ne
ri
ch
m
en
o be in a
Partnership
pport to a
Partnerships
erest / role in
Pa
rt
Ca
t
Partnership
56%
London
17% 19%
8%
0%

4. 2/12.
What
type
of
OrganisaEon
are
you
from?
(One
answer
only)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Rivers
Trust
Wildlife
Trust
Groundwork
Environment
Agency
Central
Government
Local
Government
Community
Group
Academic
Other
NGO
Private
Sector
Yorkshire

5. O
ctor
Ri
ve
W rs
ild Tru
lif s t
En
G eT
vi r
ro ou rus
Ce nm ndw t
nt en o
ra t A rk
lG g
Lo o en
ca ve cy
l G rn
Co o me
m ve nt
m rn
un m
it en
y t
G
ro
A up
ca
de
O m
th i
Pr er c
iv N
at G
e O
Se
ct
or
st
rust
ork
ent Agency
overnment
ernment
ty Group
43%
London
15%
13%
10%
6%
1%
5%
3%
3%
1%

6. 3/12.
Experience
of
Catchment
Management
(One
Answer
Only)
1. Ran
a
full
Defra
Assessed
Pilot
2. Ran
a
£5K
/
un-­‐assessed
Pilot
3. Not
involved
in
a
pilot
but
catchment
management
is
what
we
do
4. Some
prior
involvement
in
catchment
management
5. Catchment
management
is
a
new
acEvity
for
us
Yorkshire

7. (One Answer Only)
25%
Defra Assessed Pilot
/ un-assessed Pilot
ed in a pilot but
management is what
20%
11%
£5
K
a
Ra
n
a
fu
ll
De
fr
a
As
se
ss
/
ed
un
N
...
ot
-a
ss
in
es
vo
se
lv
d
ed
So
P.
in
..
m
a
e
pi
pr
lo
io
tb
ri
u.
nv
Ca
..
ol
tc
ve
hm
m
en
en
tm
ti
...
an
ag
em
en
ti
s..
involvement in
management
management is a new
us
Ra
n
19% 18%
London

8. 4/12.
Do
you
need
training
to
help
you
deliver
the
Catchment-­‐based
Approach?
(One
Answer
Only)
Yorkshire
1. Yes,
we
need
training
in
all
aspects
of
catchment
management
2. We
would
like
training
in
some
specialist
areas
3. We
don’t
need
any
training

9. Catchment-based Approach?
(One Answer Only)
57%
need training in all
of catchment
ement
uld like training in some
st areas
n’t need any training
London
17%
ou
ld
g
in
in
do
n’
tn
lik
ee
d
e
an
tr
a
y
in
in
ng
ni
tr
ai
ne
ed
e
W
W
e
w
w
e
Ye
s,
tr
a
g
in
i..
.
a.
.
13%

10. 5/12.
How
would
you
like
training
to
be
organised?
(One
Answer
Only)
1. Training
organised
centrally
based
on
user
requirements,
delivered
around
the
country,
and
open
to
all
catchment
partnerships
2. We
would
prefer
to
organise
our
own
training,
but
would
like
to
offer
this
to
other
catchment
partnerships
too.
3. We
will
do
our
own
internal
training
4. We
really
don’t
need
training
Yorkshire

11. 61%
centrally based on user
ivered at strategic locations
y, and open to all
rships
o organise our own
d like to offer this to other
rships too.
n internal training
ed training
London
19%
...
tr
a
do
n
’t
n
w
n
ro
ly
ou
re
al
do
W
e
ill
w
e
W
ee
d
or
ga
o
ef
er
t
pr
ou
ld
w
e
W
in
te
r. .
.
...
l..
ce
nt
ra
se
d
an
i
or
g
ng
ai
ni
Tr
1%
0%

12. 6/12.
What
subjects
in
parEcular
would
you
like
to
have
training
opportuniEes
for?
(Top
three)
1.
OrganisaEonal
&
administraEve
e.g.
governance
&
finance
2. Fundraising
3. CollaboraEve
working
in
general
4. Specific
stakeholder
engagement
&
facilitaEon
methods
5. Media
&
communicaEon
6. Water
Framework
DirecEve
interpretaEon
7. Catchment
science
e.g.
geomorphology,
hydrology,
specialist
ecology
8. Survey
methodologies
9. Data
handling
&
visualisaEon
e.g.
GIS,
mapping,
data
analysis
10. PracEcal
river
works
/
implementaEon
of
improvements
Yorkshire

13. rative matters like
57%
London
49%
47%
44%
42%
eneral
gement & facilitation
41%
38%
31%
27%
g
ki
n
or
w
M
ed
i
a
&
at
iv
bo
r
la
Co
l
O
rg
an
isa
tio
plementation of
e
na
l
&
ad
m
in
ion e.g. GIS,
in
. ..
co
Ca
m
tc
m
hm
un
ic
en
at
ts
io
Da
ci
n
ta
en
ha
ce
nd
su
lin
ch
g
..
&
vi
su
al
is
a.
..
is.
..
ve interpretation
s geomorphology,
ogy
32%

14. 7/12.
The
policy
framework
establishes
a
steering
group
made
up
of
naEonal
representaEve
bodies
to
support
the
catchment-­‐based
approach.
(One
Answer
Only)
1. Content
with
the
steering
group
and
have
affiliaEon
with
a
representaEve
2. Content
with
the
steering
group
but
do
not
have
affiliaEon
with
a
representaEve
3. Not
content
with
the
steering
group
4. Not
aware
of
the
steering
group
Yorkshire

15. ch. What do you know about the group?
(One Answer Only)
41%
he steering group and
with a representative
he steering group but
iliation with a
London
18%
...
.
st
ee
rin
st
..
th
e
w
ar
e
of
th
e
ith
ot
a
N
N
ot
c
on
te
nt
w
th
e
st
ee
rin
...
ith
w
te
nt
Co
n
te
nt
w
ith
th
e
st
ee
rin
...
8%
th the steering group
he steering group
Co
n
14%

16. 8/12.
The
steering
group
has
idenEfied
mapping
/
GIS
/
data
/
IPR
as
a
shared
issue
amongst
catchment
partnerships
and
has
created
a
Catchment
Data
Users
Group
to
work
up
a
shared
soluEon
that
will
work
for
all
catchment
partnerships
(One
Answer
Only)
1. We
recognise
this
issue
and
support
the
idea
of
a
shared
soluEon
2. We
recognise
this
issue
but
do
not
support
the
idea
of
a
shared
soluEon
3. We
have
not
come
across
this
issue
but
like
the
idea
of
a
shared
system
4. We
have
not
come
across
this
issue
and
don’t
support
a
shared
system
Yorkshire

17. (One Answer Only)
67%
his issue and support the
d solution
his issue but do not
ea of a shared solution
ome across this issue but
a shared system
ome across this issue and
a shared system
London
ro
ss
...
ac
no
t
ve
ha
W
e
W
e
ha
ve
no
t
co
m
e
co
m
e
ac
ss
ue
is
i
th
e
re
co
gn
is
e
W
0%
ro
ss
...
b.
.
.
a.
ss
ue
is
i
th
e
re
co
gn
is
e
W
8%
6%

18. 9/12.
Defra
has
provided
funds
for
the
steering
group
to
provide
central
support
to
the
partnerships
unEl
the
end
of
the
financial
year,
including
the
helpdesk,
forum
and
the
learning
workshops.
(One
Answer
Only)
1. I
expect
to
use
the
forum
and
ahend
the
learning
workshops
2. I
like
the
forum
but
don’t
think
I
will
ahend
the
learning
workshops
3. I
am
not
sure
I
will
use
the
forum
but
am
interested
in
the
learning
workshops
4. I
don’t
think
that
I
will
use
either
Yorkshire

19. (One Answer Only)
53%
e forum and attend the
ps
ut don’t think I will attend
shops
l use the forum but am
earning workshops
I will use either
London
16%
us
...
w
ill
us
e
tI
ill
th
a
Iw
Id
on
’t
t
hi
n
k
ts
ur
e
no
m
Ia
1%
th
...
’t.
..
do
n
bu
t
th
e
ik
e
Il
Ie
xp
ec
t
to
us
e
fo
ru
m
th
e
fo
ru
m
...
7%

20. 10/12.
What
other
centralised
support
do
you
think
will
be
needed
in
the
future?
(MulEple
Answers)
1. A
framework
to
integrate
with
second
cycle
WFD,
and
future
river
basin
planning
cycles
2. Networking
and
learning
between
catchment
partnerships
3. RepresentaEon
of
CaBA
partnerships
with
government
&
its
agencies
4. Training
opportuniEes
for
catchment
management
5. Fundraising
&
distribuEon
of
funds
6. FacilitaEng
acEviEes
where
there
are
economies
of
scale
from
catchment
partnerships
working
together
7. CommunicaEon
about
CaBA
8. Networking
with
naEonal
organisaEons
&
sectors
e.g.
Ofwat
9. Something
else
10. I
don’t
think
that
central
support
is
needed
Yorkshire

21. with second cycle
n planning cycles
etween catchment
63%
61%
49%
47%
40%
rtnerships with
42%
37%
31%
London
atchment
of funds
there are
tchment
her
A
rganisations &
fra
m
ew
or
k
Re
to
pr
in
es
te
en
gr
at
ta
.. .
tio
Fu
nd
n
of
ra
Ca
isi
ng
BA
&
Co
.. .
di
m
st
m
r ib
un
ut
ic a
io
tio
...
n
ab
ou
tC
aB
So
A
m
et
hi
ng
el
se
1%
A
pport is needed
6%

22. 11/12.
Which
stakeholders
do
you
think
are
going
to
be
most
important
in
your
catchment
and
challenging
to
engage?
(MulEple
Answers)
1. General
public
2. Water
industry
3. Flood
risk
managers
4. Environment
Agency
5. Natural
England
6. Local
authoriEes
7. Land
owners
and
managers
8. Media
9. Other
NGOs
10. Anglers
Yorkshire

23. 52%
Os
46%
36%
34% 34%
London
16%
13%
9%
8%
2%
Ge
ne
ra
lp
Fl
oo
ub
d
lic
ris
k
m
an
ag
N
er
La
at
s
nd
ur
al
ow
En
ne
gl
rs
an
an
d
d
m
an
ag
er
s
O
th
er
N
GO
s
ublic
dustry
managers
ent Agency
ngland
horities
ers and managers

24. 12/12.
What
is
your
posiEon
aier
today?
(One
Answer
Only)
1. I
am
clear
on
my
role,
and
the
role
of
others,
and
ready
to
start
/
conEnue
our
catchment
partnership
2. I
am
clear
on
my
role,
but
confused
as
to
others
roles,
but
apart
from
that
ready
to
start
/
conEnue
3. I
am
clear
on
my
role
but
have
some
preparaEon
to
do
before
I
am
ready
to
start
4. I
am
clear
on
my
role
now,
but
this
is
different
to
what
I
thought
it
was
5. I
am
not
clear
on
my
role
6. Let
me
out
of
here
Yorkshire

25. 33%
ole, and the role of
o start / continue
tnership
ole, but confused
but apart from
/ continue
ole but have some
before I am ready
London
13%
9%
7%
e
ou
t
of
ro
l
on
Le
tm
e
no
m
Ia
m
y
no
..
le
m
y
on
ea
r
cl
tc
le
ar
ro
le
ro
m
y
Ia
m
cl
m
Ia
bu
...
u.
..
le
,b
ea
r
on
ea
r
cl
m
Ia
on
m
y
ro
m
y
on
ea
r
cl
m
Ia
ro
le
,a
n.
..
ole now, but this is
thought it was
my role
he
re
2%
1%

26. Do
you
have
any
other
quesEons?
Ca tchment
B ased
A pproach
Partnerships
f or
Action

27. Concluding
remarks
Chris
Ryder
The
Rivers
Trust
Ca tchment
B ased
A pproach
Partnerships
f or
Action