What is Corporate Social Responsibility? Why CSR? How can you effectively deliver CSR...? etc. Enjoy this CSR Presentation we did in 2012 at le Bistro Latin in Douala.
1. Corporate Social Responsibility, business and society
source of wealth
RECOM
rgie, Infrastructures et Développement Durable
rgy, Infrastructure & Sustainable Development
Chief Frederic Nguime Ekollo, CEO Afrecom
Douala, Amcham - April 17, 2012
efnguime@yahoo.fr
Cell.: 77 09 70 00
2. Agenda
1. Why CSR?
2. What is CSR?
3.How to effectively deliver CSR ?
4.The virtue matrix & the local content challenge in developping economies
RECOM
ergie, Infrastructures et Développement Durable
ergy, Infrastructure & Sustainable Development
3. 1. Why CSR?
Corporate reputation is companie’s source wealth
Corporate reputations : strategic assets and sources of economic value
Profit, Sustainable development & Corporate social responsibility
are integrated business challenges
.
RECOM
ergie, Infrastructures et Développement Durable
ergy, Infrastructure & Sustainable Development
4. 1. Why CSR?
Corporate reputation is companie’s source of wealth
2010 Gulf of Mexico oil spill
BP at World National Oil Companies Congress
in London commented:
“Everyone at BP is devastated, and we deeply regret
what’s happened. Our hearts go out to those who have
lost loved ones. And we are profoundly aware of our
responsibilities to those people whose livelihoods and
neighborhoods have suffered… I’d also like to make it
clear this is not simply about fulfilling our legal
obligations ….We feel a huge moral responsibility….
For many years BP has been a part of those communities.
Thousands of our employees live in the region, as do
thousands more of our retirees. And caring about
the communities in which we operate is a core part
of what BP is about. As challenging as it may seem in
the current crisis, we intend to prove it here too.”
AFRECOM
5. 1. Why CSR?
Corporate reputation is companie’s source of wealth
1985 : Intel Corp’s new Pentium chip calculations limits
1995 : Motorola : cell phones and brain cancer.
According to global business executives surveyed, Reputation recovery takes approximately
three and one-half years.
“Any assault on the reputation of a company is a crisis and reputations are built on how
management responds to crises.”
Clarke Caywood, professor, Northwestern University.
AFRECOM
6. 1. Why CSR?
Corporate reputation is companie’s source of wealth
Business values & corporate reputation
Vision & values first
Corporate reputation
six categories
20 attributes
The Value cycle : from Shell, A better way to do business – External
affairs in the 21st
century
AFRECOM
Corporate
reputation
Profits &
prospects
Financial valueSupportive
stakeholders
Strategic
initiatives
7. 1. Why CSR?
Reputation management principles
Five principles
Distinctiveness
Focus
Consistency
Identity
Transparency
AFRECOM
Fortune’s most admired
companies have two things in
common – They have
performed well and their
performance has been noted.
Corporate reputation is a
combination of both
perception and reality.
Council of Public Remations Firms, US
8. 1. Why CSR?
Key benefits & opportunities
Intangible benefits
Improved image
Sounder license to operate
Increased credibility
Consumer and employee loyalty and trust
Key benefits & opportunities
Brand value & reputation
Improvement s in human capital
Revenue generation
.
AFRECOM
9. 2. What is CSR?
Sustainable Development : the basic paradigm
.
AFRECOM
Economic
performance
Environmental
performance
Social
performance
Sustainability
Socio
economic
Eco
development
Socio
Environ
mental
The 3 pillars of sustainability
Source : Shell
10. 2. What is CSR?
CSR is generally understood to be the way a company achieves a balance or
integration of economic, environmental and social performances (imperatives) while
at the same time addressing shareholder and stakeholders expectations . Canadian
government
CSR as business contribution to the sustainable development goals. It is all
about how business takes account of its economic, social and environmental
impact in the way it operates; maximizing the benefits and minimizing the
downsides. UK Government
CSR is a concept whereby companies integrate social and environmental
concerns in their business operations and in their interaction with their
stakeholders on a voluntary basis. European Union
CSR as business commitment to contribute to sustainable Economic
development, working with employees, their families, the local community,
and society at large to improve their quality of life - World Business Council
for Sustainable Development
AFRECOM
12. AFRECOM
Developping local
community
potential to bene-
fit from impact of
an activity.
PHILANTHROPY
SOCIAL
INVESTMENT
STRATEGIC
SOCIAL
INVESTMENT
SOCIAL IMPACT
MANAGEMENT
Communities
recognise they
benefit fairly from
the revenues
generated by the
industry
Social impact is
identified, planned
and addressed as
integral part of
project
management
Support for
programs /projects
related to corporate
responsibilities.
Grants and
Donations unrela-
ted to operations or
business objectives.
Helpful Desirable Essential Critical
ValuetoBusiness&Society
Type
of
CSR
3. How to effectively deliver CSR?
13. AFRECOM
3. How to effectively deliver CSR?
Rules for delivering social investment programs & projetcs
Adopt a Strategic approach including policy,
strategies, programmes & projects
3 main pillars of the approach
Stakeholder management
Issues identification & management
Strategic impact assessment
Projects/Programs Implementation on Strategic
Social Investment
Manage perceptions/expectations
Build Strategic MoUs with and put Delivery
Responsibility to Communities
Tell me, I will forget
Show me, I may remember
Involve me, and I will care
Measuring & monitoring CSR activities
performance
14. AFRECOM
3. How to effectively deliver CSR?
“When Prudential allowed people with AIDS
to tap into the death benefits in their Life
insurance policies to pay for medical expenses,
the move generated by so much goodwill that
competing insurers soon offered viatical
settlements as well. Very quickly, corporate
behaviour that had seemed radical became
business as usual”
Source: Roger L. Martin in Harvard Business Review on CSR, « The
virtue matrix: calculating the return on CSR »
15. AFRECOM
3. How to effectively deliver CSR?
Twelve lessons learnt from successful CSR activities
1.Inclusiveness
2.Be proactive
3.Be honest
4.Perception is reality
5.Philanthropy only if required
6.Philanthropy/ Social Investment projects cannot replace impact management.
7.Stakeholder views are what count
8. Know your audience:
9.Face to face communications are the most effective method of
communication
10. Utilise existing communication hooks and materials (tools)
11. Use people and resources across operations
12. Encourage external stakeholders to take ownership
16. 4. The virtue matrix & the local content challenge in develop-
ping economies
“In general, CSR in economically
advanced countries in generated by deep,
solid foundations supporting relatively
smaller strategic and structural frontiers.
The civil foundations of countries with
developing economies , by contrast, are
relatively shallow and weak, and their
strategic and structural frontiers are
Correspondingly large”…
“Nike, by running its Southeast Asian Plant
And paying its workers in accordance to local
Customs and practices was accused of
“averaging down” its level of CSR”.
AFRECOM
Frontier (Intrinsic)
Civil Foundation (instrumental)
Complianc
e
Source: Roger L. Martin in Harvard Business Review on CSR,
« The virtue matrix: calculating the return on CSR »
17. AFRECOM
• Value Creation
Value Added
Knowledge retention
Economic multiplier effect
• Economically Sound
Find an acceptable local content definition
• Equal or Better
Quality
Cost
Delivery
Safety & Environment
• Nurture not Subsidize
“What is the extra mile that you need to take?”
Key definition features Basic premises
Source: INSTOK, Willy Olsen in « Maximising benefits for the host nation , the role of local content »
4. The virtue matrix & the local content challenge in
developing economies
18. AFRECOM
Source: INSTOK, Willy Olsen in « Maximising benefits for the host nation , the role of local content »
4. The virtue matrix & the local content challenge in
developing economies
Technology
transfer
Research
technology
Focuson
skills
Looking for technology transfer - Getting to the core will take time
19. AFRECOM
Source: INSTOK, Willy Olsen in « Maximising benefits for the host nation , the role of local content »
4. The virtue matrix & the local content challenge in
developing economies
Qualification Industrial policy
Industry
performance
Industry
capacity
Technology
qualification
Professional
qualification
RegulationFinancing
Tax policy Foster SMEs
CompetitiveSustainable
HSE
Strategic issues
Challenge
Maximize local
content
Supplier
development
Funding
initiatives
Initiatives on
competitiveness
The strategic approach
20. AFRECOM
Source: INSTOK, Willy Olsen in « Maximising benefits for the host nation, the role of local content »
4. The virtue matrix & the local content challenge in
developing economies
Venezuela
Brazil
Nigeria
T&T
Libya
Saudi
Canada
Norway
Azerbaijan
Algeria
Tanzania
Ecuador
Bolivia
Ghana
UK
Mexico
Uganda
Kazakhstan
Russia
Iran
Australia
Timor Leste
Indonesia
PNG
Malaysia
Old timers New initiatives
Local content policies in more and more countries
Many are looking for more benefits
Angola
21. HSE & RSE
AFRECOM
Dialogue with communities
Horizontal & vertical Partneship
Local content
Protection of environment
(ecosystems & biodiversity)
Thank you
Notas del editor
Thank Amcham
Thanks to Charmain Penda for efforts to get me on board
Thanks to all of us for having a dialog on a topic that relates to all of us because we are all concerned :
first as business leaders
and second as part of the society and therefore as stakeholders
Introduction
The CSR paradigm is growing in our Cameroon business context. I attended the last GICAM conference on CSR and felt the need for replacing things into the right context. We have more SMEs than big corporations in the country but the latest are financially predominant and more visible as corporate businesses.
Mulinationals are mostly perceived through a marketing prism. Some are visible on philantropic and social investment activities. Many choose to ignore the challenges of the society in which they operate.
As a traditional ruler, I am supportive of local CEOs publicised donations in their villages even though it does not usually address the concerns of their host communities and real business societal issues. I have also witnessed some of them, albeit their small size, being really involved in societal challenges.
My purpose today is not to solve this confusion in 30 mns talk. But I believe, as a practitioner and professional, that CSR is a significant untaped reservoir of value, tangible and intangible, for business and society in our context.
I therefore suggest that we simplify the dialogue in 3 simple dimensions :
Why?
What ?
And How?
Answer 1 : Corporate reputation is company’s source of intangible wealth
Answer 2: Corporate reputations : strategic assets and sources of economic value
Answer 3 : Profit, Sustainable development & Corporate social responsibility
are integrated or inter-related business challenges
2010 BP oil spill in USA
The Deepwater Horizon oil spill (also referred to as the BP oil spill, the Gulf of Mexico oil spill, the BP oil disaster, or the Macondo blowout) is an oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico which flowed unabated for three months in 2010.
It is the largest accidental marine oil spill in the history of the petroleum industry.[
The explosion killed 11 men working on the platform and injured 17 others.[
On July 15, 2010, the leak was stopped by capping the gushing wellhead, after it had released about 4.9 million barrels (780,000 m3) of crude oil.
On September 19, 2010, the relief well process was successfully completed, and the federal government declared the well "effectively dead".
The spill caused extensive damage to marine and wildlife habitats and to the Gulf's fishing and tourism industries.[18][19] Skimmer ships, floating containment booms, anchored barriers, sand-filled barricades along shorelines, and dispersants were used in an attempt to protect hundreds of miles of beaches, wetlands, and estuaries from the spreading oil.
In June 2010 BP set up a $20 billion fund to compensate victims of the oil spill.
To July 2011, the fund has paid $4.7 billion to 198,475 claimants. In all, the fund has nearly 1 million claims and continues to receive thousands of claims each week.
These 2 cases simply portraite how business reputation and wealth can be seriously affected through social perceptions.
1985 :The discovery that Intel Corp’s new Pentium chip couldn’t handle some simple mathematical calculations knocked $ 3 billion, or 12% off Intel’s market value
1995 : Motorola saw its capitalization fall by $6 billion or 16% after scientists hinted at a link between cell phones and brain cancer.
Crisis situations generate:
Negatively affect perceptions of the company by :
current and potential customers,
employers
and communities.
losses of economic value
loss of reputation
Crisis recovery depends on crisis 3 factors :
Crisis management
Reputation management
CSR management
Some companies recover dissipated value from crisis quickly than others.
Research suggests that the difference lies on how companies handles the crisis
and how high or low was their reputation beforehand (au préalable).
Value & vision first
it is imperative that companies first determine :
what they stand for,
their vision and values,
in other words their “corporate magnetic north” .
a process to foster this ethic
Ethical behaviour helps with employee attraction and retention;
Trust with company’s shareholders is fostered;
Corporate reputation
A corporate reputation translates how people feel about a company
It can be good or bad, strong or weak
Research conducted by the Reputation Institute shows that people rate companies reputation on one of 20 attributes that can be classified in a set of six categories which is called “Reputation Quotient (RQ)”.
The value cycle suggests that :
Improved favourable perceptions of market valuations derived from better
perceptions of the company’s future prospects
These perceptions are developed from observations of supportive behaviour by stakeholders towards the company: growth in revenues, ability to attract more
Five principles : Distincveness, Focus, Consistency, Identity, Transparency
Distinctiveness
Distinctive position in the minds of resource-holders
Reflecting high quality ,excellence, environmentally friendly company)
Focus
focusing actions on a core theme (Standard Chartered: seeing is believing...)
Consistency
in actions and communications.
Strong coordination of all staff in charge of public relations, CSR, marketing is key to avoiding overlapping and conflicting communication which inhibites stakeholder loyalty to company’s products.
Identity
Genuine and authentic.
Genuine: manipulating external images are likely to fail if they rely purely on advertising and public relations and if disconnected from the company’s reality.
Authentic: rooted in the company’s authentic values, core purpose and behaviours
Transparency
Communications is crucial to enhance visibility , increase the perception of a
credible company and attract support and advocacy from stakeholders.
Key benefits & opportunities
Intangible benefits
Improved image
Sounder license to operate
Increased credibility
Consumer and employee loyalty and trust
Key benefits & opportunities
Brand value & reputation
Improvements in human capital
Revenue generation
.
Five principles : Distincveness, Focus, Consistency, Identity, Transparency
Distinctiveness
Distinctive position in the minds of resource-holders
Reflecting high quality ,excellence, environmentally friendly company)
Focus
focusing actions on a core theme (Standard Chartered: seeing is believing...)
Consistency
in actions and communications.
Strong coordination of all staff in charge of public relations, CSR, marketing is key to avoiding overlapping and conflicting communication which inhibites stakeholder loyalty to company’s products.
Identity
Genuine and authentic.
Genuine: manipulating external images are likely to fail if they rely purely on advertising and public relations and if disconnected from the company’s reality.
Authentic: rooted in the company’s authentic values, core purpose and behaviours
Transparency
Communications is crucial to enhance visibility , increase the perception of a
credible company and attract support and advocacy from stakeholders.
Five principles : Distincveness, Focus, Consistency, Identity, Transparency
Distinctiveness
Distinctive position in the minds of resource-holders
Reflecting high quality ,excellence, environmentally friendly company)
Focus
focusing actions on a core theme (Standard Chartered: seeing is believing...)
Consistency
in actions and communications.
Strong coordination of all staff in charge of public relations, CSR, marketing is key to avoiding overlapping and conflicting communication which inhibites stakeholder loyalty to company’s products.
Identity
Genuine and authentic.
Genuine: manipulating external images are likely to fail if they rely purely on advertising and public relations and if disconnected from the company’s reality.
Authentic: rooted in the company’s authentic values, core purpose and behaviours
Transparency
Communications is crucial to enhance visibility , increase the perception of a
credible company and attract support and advocacy from stakeholders.
2. Philanthropy and social investment are predominant in Cameroon and Africa in ganeral. They are necessary but not appropriate to fundamental requirements for development and emergence.
Effective delivery of CSR is a mix of philantropic and social activities that generates value for business and society
Strategic Impact management
Benefits for business
Supporting mitigation .
Addressing the “attribution factor” (helping to separate social & economic change from
specific company projects).
Leadership and competitive advantage (demonstrates leadership, position corporate
policy, provide competitive advantage and builds reputation).
Selection of partners (SIA can help for successful partnerships through dialogue with
stakeholders).
Benefits for communities
Early input from significant external stakeholders.
Early focus on key stakeholder concerns and identification of opportunities for local
engagement.
Anticipating employment issues.
Identification of constraints within the community (education, capacity, local planning and
infrastructure) which also affects operational performance.
Identification of conflicts between local, regional & national priorities.
2. Philanthropy and social investment are predominant in Cameroon and Africa in ganeral. They are necessary but not appropriate to fundamental requirements for development and emergence.
Rules for delivering social investments programs & projetcs
Adopt a Strategic approach including policy, strategies, programmes
& projects
3 main pillars of the approach : Stakeholder Management - Issues Identification
& management - Strategic impact assessment
Projects/Programs Implementation on Strategic Social Investment
Deliver SP value through projects/programs.
Ensure single company representation in the community.
Build strategic alliances/partnership with local & international development agencies
as well as the private sector for co-funding and program implementation of Strategic social
investment.
Manage perceptions/expectations
Avoid to be perceived as Government surrogate for the local development
Advocate for Government participation in economic development specially in
the host communities locations.
Build Strategic MoUs with and put Delivery Responsibility to Communities
Base actions on strategic Memorandum of Understanding (MoUs) at local level.
Project Implementation responsibility will be given to communities through Projects
Advisory Committee/Project Management Committee.
Rules for delivering social investments programs & projetcs
Adopt a Strategic approach including policy, strategies, programmes
& projects
3 main pillars of the approach : Stakeholder Management - Issues Identification
& management - Strategic impact assessment
Projects/Programs Implementation on Strategic Social Investment
Deliver SP value through projects/programs.
Ensure single company representation in the community.
Build strategic alliances/partnership with local & international development agencies
as well as the private sector for co-funding and program implementation of Strategic social
investment.
Manage perceptions/expectations
Avoid to be perceived as Government surrogate for the local development
Advocate for Government participation in economic development specially in
the host communities locations.
Build Strategic MoUs with and put Delivery Responsibility to Communities
Base actions on strategic Memorandum of Understanding (MoUs) at local level.
Project Implementation responsibility will be given to communities through Projects
Advisory Committee/Project Management Committee.
The virtue matrix highlights forces that generate CSR
Bottom quadrants :
Civil foundation: norms, customs, laws & regulations
Behaviour here does essentially meet society’s baseline expectations.
Companies guided by choice or compliance
It instrumental as it serves at maintaining or enhancing shareholder value
Upper quadrants
Frontier: