Pressurisation Systems in residential and commercial buildings
Pressurisation Systems CPD
Approved Document B to the Building Regulations requires smoke ventilation to escape stairs and, under some circumstances, common lobbies and/or corridors in residential buildings. Pressurisation is one way of meeting this requirement.
This seminar covers:
An explanation of the basic legislative requirements and how these are achieved
The various design approaches
Specifying the equipment
2. “I J O’Hea.
Colt Founder”
I J O’Hea OBE (1897 - 1984)
2009 Group Turnover £170 million
Manufactures in the UK, Holland, Saudi Arabia, China and Singapore
Private Company founded in 1931
A brief history of Colt
3. Current UK Business markets
Solar Shading
Natural Ventilation
Louvre
Environmental Comfort Control
Smoke Control
4.
5. WHY PRESSURISE?
• Approved Document B to the Building Regulations
requires smoke ventilation to escape stairs and, under
some circumstances, common lobbies and/or corridors
in residential buildings.
• Pressurisation is one way of meeting this requirement
• Alternatives to pressurisation are:
– Natural AOV’s
– Natural Shafts
– Mechanical ColtShaft
6. • Alternative to natural ventilation when escape stairs or
fire fighting stairs are landlocked
• A requirement for some fire fighting stairs
• Provides much better protection than natural
ventilation of stairs
• Note: BRE shaft and Colt Shaft have significantly
reduced the market for pressurisation of fire fighting
stairs
• Pressurisation systems should conform to the
requirements of EN 12101-6:2005
WHY PRESSURISE?
7. BS 9999: 2008 recommends Pressurisation (designed to EN12101-6)
to:
• Replace separation of dead end corridors with a fire door
• Replace protected lobbies in single stair buildings, buildings over
18m, buildings with phased evacuation and buildings where a stair
has not been discounted in the sizing of escape widths
• Allow a single stair to extend down to a basement
• fire fighting shafts over 10m deep and over 30m tall (Class B)
WHY PRESSURISE?
10. System Class Application Typical Building Type
A Means of Escape
Defend in Place
Residential
B MoE and
Fire fighting
Where fire fighting core is
required
C MoE
Simultaneous Evac.
Commercial
D MoE
Sleeping Risk
Hotels/Hospitals
E MoE
Phased Evacuation
High rise offices
EN 12101- 6 BUILDING CLASSIFICATION
11. BASIC PRINCIPLES
• The system must protect against smoke entering the
stairs or travelling between storeys via lifts accessed
from protected lobbies
• The intent is to have the highest pressure in the stairs
and a reducing pressure gradient through to the
accommodation
• All ‘pressures’ described are actually pressure
differentials to the accommodation
12. BASIC PRINCIPLES
• All pressurisation systems require 3 basic components:
• A means of supplying clean air to pressurised areas
• A means of ensuring excessive pressure differentials
do not occur
• A means of relieving pressure from the accommodation
13. WHICH AREAS DO WE PRESSURISE?
The first decision to make for any system
• Depends upon class of pressurisation
• Depends upon building layout
– Is there a lift?
– Where is suitable for accommodation air release
14. STAIRS (WITH SIMPLE LOBBY)
Pressurise the stairs only. Only used where the staircase is entered via a
simple lobby (i.e. a lobby without lifts or other possible escape route) or
directly from the accommodation.
Accommodation
Stairs
Simple
lobby
Air supply
+ve
15. STAIRS, LOBBY & LIFT
Pressurise stairs and lobbies. Used to extend protection to lobbies:
Stairs
Lift
Accommodation
Air supply
+ve
+ve
16. STAIRS, LOBBY & LIFT
Pressurise stairs, lobby and lift.
Generally only used in fire fighting – Class B
Stairs
Lift
Accommodation
Air supply
+ve
+ve
+ve
Lobby
17. WHAT PERFORMANCE IS REQUIRED?
Depending upon the class of system we have set criteria
to achieve:
• Pressure differentials – all doors closed: 45 – 50 Pa
• Velocity through open door on fire floor: 0.75 – 2.0 m/s
• Pressure differential – doors open on floors other than
fire floor: 10 Pa
18. CLASS A - DOORS CLOSED
Automatic air release
ventilator
Smoke detector
Pressure relief damperDuty
/standby
fan
Ductwork
system
FIRE FLOOR
(LOBBY/CORR)
Stairs
50Pa
(above
accomm
odation)
Ground floor
First floor
Door opening
force not to
exceed 100N
19. CLASS A - DOOR OPEN
Accommodation air release
ventilator
Smoke detector
Pressure relief damperDuty
/standby
fan
Ductwork
system
FIRE FLOOR
(LOBBY/CORR)
Stairs
Ground floor
First floor
0.75 m/s average velocity
20. CLASS A: MoE - Defend in Place
• Do not attempt to pressurise the corridors up to
dwelling front doors
• Provide air release from the corridor or lobby
• Long corridors will be fitted with smoke seal doors - air
release needs to be on stairs side of nearest doors
21. CLASS A
Air release via
ventilator
Air release via
shaft
Accommodation
CLASS A
22. CLASS B: FIRE FIGHTING STAIRS
• Requirement for stairs set by ADB BS 5588-5 or BS
9999
• Pressurised lobbies essential
• Lobbies may contain fire fighting lift, which also needs
to be pressurised
23. CLASS B - DOORS CLOSED
Accommodation air release
ventilator
Smoke detector
Pressure relief damperDuty
/standby
fan
Ductwork
system
FIRE FLOOR
Stairs
Ground floor
First floor
50 Pa
above
accomm
odation
45 Pa
above
accomm
odation
Supply to
stair, lift and
lobby
Door opening force
not to exceed 100N
24. CLASS B - DOORS OPEN
Accommodation air release
ventilator
Smoke detector
Pressure relief damperDuty
/standby
fan
Ductwork
system
FIRE FLOOR
Stairs
Ground floor
First floor
2 m/s average velocity
Lift door
open if
fitted
25. Closed Door Requirements Open Door Requirement
Class Stair
(Pa)
Lift Shaft
(Pa)
Lobby
(Pa)
Velocity
(m/s)
Open Doors
A 50 50* 45* 0.75 Stair door on fire floor
B 50 50 45 2.0 Stair door on fire floor
Stair door on floor below
Lobby door on fire floor
Lift door on floor below
Final exit door
C 50 50* 45* 0.75 Stair door on fire floor + 10Pa pressure difference
with final exit door open only
D 50 50* 45* 0.75 Stair door on fire floor and final exit door + 10 Pa
pressure difference with final exit door open and
one stair door other than the fire floor
E 50 50* 45* 0.75 Stair door on fire floor and another floor and final
exit door + 10 Pa pressure difference with final exit
door and two stair doors open other than the fire
floor
* Pressurising these spaces is at the discretion of the system designer
26. CLASS C - DOORS CLOSED
Accommodation air release
ventilator
Smoke detector
Pressure relief damperDuty
/standby
fan
Ductwork
system
FIRE FLOOR
Stairs
50Pa
above
accomm
odation
Ground floor
First floor
Door opening force
not to exceed 100N
27. CLASS C – EXIT DOOR OPEN
Accommodation aor release
ventilator
Smoke detector
Pressure relief damperDuty
/standby
fan
Ductwork
system
FIRE FLOOR
Stairs
Ground floor
First floor
10 Pa
above
accomm
odation
28. Accommodation air release
ventilator
Smoke detector
Pressure relief damperDuty
/standby
fan
Ductwork
system
FIRE FLOOR
Stairs
Ground floor
First floor
0.75 m/s average velocity
CLASS C - DOOR OPEN
29. EQUIPMENT
• Fans
– ambient rated
– duty + standby (or standby motor) if only one MOE
route; usually in series to save space
– One fan set may supply stairs, lobbies and lift shaft
– not usually attenuated unless needed for test periods
– In 1 hour fire rated enclosure or roof
• Power supplies
– primary + secondary
– Mains + generator or separate mains supply
• Pressure relief
– usually gravity damper in stair
– inverter control of fans possible but difficult due to
response speed requirement
30. EQUIPMENT
• Ductwork
– separate vertical ducts for stair, lobbies, lift shaft
– ambient rated unless breaching fire compartmentation
– Builders work shafts are suitable if well sealed
– VCD required at each tee and grille for balancing
– Two separate inlets facing different directions with
smoke detector operated inlet dampers if at roof level
– 5m away from any smoke exhaust
• Grilles
– one per 3 storeys in stair
– one per lobby
– one per 30m in lift shaft
31. EQUIPMENT
Twin air intakes on separate
facades of the building with
motorised dampers and smoke
detector control
Volume control dampers on
each section of ducting
32. EQUIPMENT
• Accommodation air release
– by leakage, ventilators, natural or mechanical shaft
– leakage can be from building fabric, HVAC ductwork,
permanent trickle vents, but not window breakage
– ventilators must be provided on at least 2 sides,
discount the side with the largest vent area (2.5m/s)
– Natural shaft terminations need to be located to
minimise adverse wind effects (2m/s)
– Mechanical shafts should operate whenever the
pressurisation system does and should not cause
excess pressure differentials
33. CONTROLS
• Initiation – From automatic fire detection system
– Needs to identify fire floor
– Locate detector close to door to pressurised space
• Class B initiation
– Can be manual switch from MOE state or direct from
automatic fire detection system
• Accommodation air release
– only opened on fire floor (to prevent risk of fire/smoke
spread)
• Fire fighter controls
– provided at base of stair
34. BASIC PRINCIPLE
• Pump air into a ball or a tyre and we have a positive
pressure inside
• If there is a puncture then to maintain a positive
pressure we need to keep pumping air in
• For a given pressure and a given puncture size we will
require a fixed rate of air input to balance the air lost
through the puncture
35. BASIC PRINCIPLE
• From Bernoulli’s equation:
• ∆P = 0.5 ρ ∑ ( Q2
/A2
)
• Rewriting and correcting for effective area
• Q = 0.83 ∑ (A ∆P0.5
)
• Q is the leakage rate from the pressurised space that
we need to balance with supply air
36. BASIC PRINCIPLE
• Easy in principle but we have a complex network of
leaks and conditions to fulfil
• Therefore the calculation becomes complex
• EN 12101-6 devotes a 12 page annex to this
37. DUCT SIZING
• Select duct layout and dimensions
• Calculate resistance of ductwork
• The operating pressure of the system should be added
to the ductwork resistance
• Size fans to provide the design flow rate at the total
pressure
38. PROBLEMS
Design process requires:
– an assessment of the build quality and an allowance for
additional unidentified leakage – this is in effect a ‘guess’
– Loose, average or tight construction will affect the leakage rates
used in calculation
– add 50% safety margin + 15% margin for duct leakage + 20%
duct pressure loss margin
There is often a temptation to reduce the allowances at design stage –
this can lead to problems at completion of the project when
pressures/velocities cannot be achieved.
39. COMMISSIONING
1. Check equipment is installed as per design
2. Carry out normal mechanical and electrical checks
3. Carry out performance tests, but first:
• All doors must be fitted and close properly
• All finishes must be complete - carpets laid etc
• All false ceilings must be in place
• There must be no temporary openings or
unsealed service penetrations
40. EQUIPMENT CHECKLIST
- Main power supply and standby supply
- Duty and standby fan
- Automatic change over
- Fan located in protected area
- Fan Inlet protected from effects of smoke
- Smoke detection provided adjacent to lobby/accommodation door
- Manual override provided
- Supply point located at every 3 floor levels
- Pressure relief damper provided in stair
- Venting provided from accommodation
- No smoke seals provided on doors
41. PERFORMANCE TESTING
• While the test method aims to neutralise the effects of wind, testing
on windy (and especially blustery) days should be avoided if
possible
• A pre-test inspection is recommended to identify potential problems
that can be rectified prior to actual test
• Out of hours testing is highly recommended
• On day of test, ensure all other H&V systems are shut down
42. MEASUREMENT TECHNIQUES
• PRESSURE DIFFERENTIAL
• Requires a manometer and 2
long flexible tubes
• Locate end of one tube in the
accommodation and the other in
the pressurised space, both away
from draughts and at least 50mm
above floor
• Manometer then reads pressure
differential directly
51
43. PERFORMANCE TESTING
Pressures
• On each floor in turn open all doors, allow them to close and then
measure the pressure differential across each relevant door
• Measure the opening force required on each relevant door at the
door handle
44. MEASUREMENT TECHNIQUESAIR VELOCITY
• Requires a rotating vane
anemometer
• Standing to one side (out of
air stream) place
anemometer in the plane of
the door
• Measure flow rate at 8
locations spread evenly
• Do not move the
anemometer during readings
• Take arithmetic average of
readings
45. PERFORMANCE TESTING
Velocities
• On each floor in turn open doors as specified in EN 12101-6 and
measure average air velocity
• For classes C, D, E on each floor in turn open doors as specified in
EN 12101-6 and measure pressure differential between stair and
accommodation
• Adjust system as necessary and retest until all pressures and
velocities are correct
46. PERFORMANCE TESTING
• The procedure is simple, but in practice:
– Excessive leakage is often a problem and can lead to a
need for multiple commissioning visits and arguments with
the builder
– Testing and balancing large systems can be very time
consuming, especially with pressurised lobbies
47. THE FUTURE
• A CEN committee is currently revising EN 12101-6
• Proposals are:
– Delete ‘kit’ references and CE marking
– Simplify system requirements
– Reduce costs
– Not likely to be published until 2011
Smoke control is Colt’s largest market sector in the UK and Colt have been involved in the development of smoke control since we installed the UK’s first modern industrial smoke ventilation system in the mid 1950s.
By investing in innovation, products, services and people, Colt International has established itself as an international leader in the fields of: Smoke Control Solar Shading Natural Ventilation Louvre Environmental Comfort Control (HVAC) Air Handling Systems
This second part of the seminar will look at the development of shaft ventilation for protection of common escape routes, particularly in high rise residential buildings.
Pressurisation can be used for various applications, although in a lot of cases there are a number of options available to designers
While these other methods often meet the requirements of the building codes, none of these are quite as effective as pressurisation for keeping a space smoke free. Where pressurisation is selected, it should be designed to the EN standard
The latest fire safety standard, BS 9999 also refers to pressurisation for specific applications
Colt have experience in the design of systems for all varieties of buildings from apartments to high rise offices
To fire fighting stairs to basements and hotels
Press. Systems are classified into 5 groups, each with different design criteria, depending on the risk/application
Press. Systems work by maintaining a higher ‘differential’ pressure in the protected space than in the surrounding spaces where fires could possibly occur. The pressures achieved are all relative to the reference point, that is, the room containing the fire.
Press. Systems must have a means of getting clean air into the building, a means of preventing too much pressure occurring and a means of getting the air out of the unpressurised space.
The class of press. System will depend on the type of building, the buildings use, the type of stair to be pressurised and why it is being pressurised.
The simplest systems require only the staircase to be pressurised. In which case, air is supplied direct into the staircase and allowed to leak from the adjacent lobby
Where the layout is more complex it may be necessary to supply air to both the stair and the lobby.
Fire fighting cores will usually contain a protected stair, protected lobby and fire fighting lift – all 3 need pressurising the lobby should be slightly lower than the stairs and lift.
The different classifications of system have different criteria to meet, but the basic requirements are a pressure differential in the stair/lobby/lift and a velocity through the door when open to the accommodation space. The different classifications will specify what pressures/velocities should be achieved when certain doors or combinations of doors are open/closed
Class A should achieve 50Pa in the staircase when all the stair doors are closed. the door opening force should not exceed 100N – this is of particular importance to doors opening into the pressurised space.
When the door to the accommodation is open, the system should achieve an average velocity of 0.75m/s across the door
Class A applies to residential buildings, but the air relief path cannot be through the occupants apartment – this would rely on the owner of the apartment maintaining components of the system and not tampering with them. The air relief system must be kept in common areas.
Where an outside wall is available, a natural vent can be used, although to comply with the standard completely, this should be on two separate facades. Alternatively a common shaft system may be used.
A fire fighting stair has the most onerous design criteria and all associated areas must be protected.
When all doors are closed, the system must achieve 50Pa in the staircase and lift and 45Pa in the lobby, relative to the accommodation rooms. In addition, the door opening force should not exceed 100N – this is of particular importance to doors opening into the pressurised space.
In the open door condition, the system must achieve an average velocity of 2m/s across the door into the accommodation space with the lobby door and stair door open on the fire floor, the stair door and the lift door open on the floor below and the final exit door open at the bottom of the staircase. If the stair has a lobby at the fire service access level and an external rising main inlet point, then this final open door may be discounted
In the open door condition, the system must achieve an average velocity of 2m/s across the door into the accommodation space with the lobby door and stair door open on the fire floor, the stair door and the lift door open on the floor below and the final exit door open at the bottom of the staircase. If the stair has a lobby at the fire service access level and an external rising main inlet point, then this final open door may be discounted
Class C applies to commercial buildings and should achieve 50Pa in the staircase when all the stair doors are closed. Door opening force should again not exceed 100N
When the final exit door is open, the pressure in the stair should be at least 10 Pa above the accommodation space
When the door to the fire floor only is open, an average velocity of 0.75m/s must be achieved across the door.
Class D applies to buildings where occupants may be asleep, e.g. hotels. System should achieve 50Pa in the staircase when all the stair doors are closed. Door opening force should again not exceed 100N
When the final exit door is open, the pressure in the stair should be at least 10 Pa above the accommodation space
When the both the final exit door and the door to the fire floor only is open, an average velocity of 0.75m/s must be achieved across the door.
Class E applies to buildings designed with phased evacuation, i.e. where the building is not all evacuated at once. System should achieve 50Pa in the staircase when all the stair doors are closed. Door opening force should again not exceed 100N
System should achieve 10Pa between stair and fire floor when doors on two floors remote from the fire floor, plus the final exit door are open
In the open door condition, the system must achieve an average velocity of 0.75m/s across the door into the accommodation space with the stair door open on the fire floor, the stair door on another floor and the final exit door open at the bottom of the staircase.
Run and standby fans are required along with standby power supplies – pressure relief is required in the staircase to relieve excess air between the door open and door closed scenarios. EN 12101-6 has a stringent limitation on the response time of the system which makes the use of inverters very difficult although in some instances, there is little choice.
If multiple pressurised spaces are required e.g. stair/lobby/lift, there should be separate ducts serving each. For systems being fed from high level, two inlets are required, facing onto differing facades of the building, with a smoke detector on the primary intake. If smoke is detected. The primary should close and hopefully the other intake will be on a smoke free façade. For systems fed at low level, only one intake is required – if smoke is detected, then the whole system shuts down. It is advisable to provide VCDS on every supply duct and at each branch/level, to make the system as flexible as possible for balancing purposes. The staircase should have input grilles on every third level.
Accommodation air release is required to keep the fire floor at a neutral pressure. This can be provided by fixed or automatic vents to outside in which case these should be on two facades, to prevent wind pressures affecting the system – sized to allow air to be relieved at no more than 2.5m/s. A common shaft serving several levels – only the fire floor opens – sized at 2m/s Mechanical ventilation – again only form the fire floor and should not cause excess pressure differentials
Generally activation should be from an AFD system which identifies which floor the fire is on – class B systems can operate as another class (e.g. A or C) during escape phase and then be manually switched to FF mode. Acc air release should only operate on the fire floor itself.
A simple analogy to explain the principle
The science behind the design is relatively simple
However the more complex the building is the more complicated the calculations become – EN 12101-6 gives a detailed explanation of the process.
The resistance of the supply duct system is also required to make the system operate at the calculated duty
To compensate, a number of safety factors are added into the design process, but often there are still issues on site
The design process makes numerous assumptions regarding leakage rates for walls, doors, windows, etc. The problem comes when the building doesn’t meet up to the rates specified. Often a poor understanding of the system by the architect or builder can lead to inadvertent leakage routes being left, causing the installation to fall short of the design criteria.
Once the installation is complete, a complex commissioning process is then required
First check that the system has been installed correctly
Once the system is up and running the system will need to be balanced and the performance verified
A manometer is used to measure the pressure differences
Then measure the pressure on each level with the system running
A rotating vane anemometer is used to measure the air velocity across the doors and calculate the average.
Then measure the open door velocities as required by the system design
The final commissioning procedure is often problematic – it is only at the final stage that it can be established that the pressure cannot be achieved and frantic sealing of building joints takes place. This final testing is best done out of hours as during normal hours, the stairs are generally in constant use by trades people
There are moves to simplify EN12101-6 but this will not be published until 2011 at the earliest.