1. Housing Market
and
Economic Outlook
Lawrence Yun, Ph.D.
Chief Economist
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS®
Presentation at Ohio Association of REALTORS®
Columbus, OH
January 14, 2013
2. Forecast #1: Inflation will be Notably
Higher by 2015
• No Threatening Inflation Signs for 2013
• But Inflation rises to 4% to 6% in 2015
• Well above Fed’s preferred rate of 2%
• But not in double‐digits as in 1970s
3. 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
‐4
‐2
1970 ‐ Jan
1972 ‐ Jan
1974 ‐ Jan
1976 ‐ Jan
1978 ‐ Jan
1980 ‐ Jan
1982 ‐ Jan
1984 ‐ Jan
1986 ‐ Jan
Core
1988 ‐ Jan
1990 ‐ Jan
1992 ‐ Jan
1994 ‐ Jan
1996 ‐ Jan
Overall
1998 ‐ Jan
(% change from one year ago)
2000 ‐ Jan
2002 ‐ Jan
2004 ‐ Jan
Consumer Price Inflation
2006 ‐ Jan
2008 ‐ Jan
2010 ‐ Jan
2012 ‐ Jan
4. ‐1
0
1
2
3
4
5
2000 ‐ Jan
2000 ‐ Jul
2001 ‐ Jan
2001 ‐ Jul
2002 ‐ Jan
2002 ‐ Jul
2003 ‐ Jan
2003 ‐ Jul
2004 ‐ Jan
2004 ‐ Jul
2005 ‐ Jan
2005 ‐ Jul
2006 ‐ Jan
2006 ‐ Jul
Owners' Equivalent Rent
2007 ‐ Jan
2007 ‐ Jul
2008 ‐ Jan
2008 ‐ Jul
2009 ‐ Jan
2009 ‐ Jul
2010 ‐ Jan
2010 ‐ Jul
(the biggest weight to Consumer Price Index)
Renters' Rent
2011 ‐ Jan
2011 ‐ Jul
2012 ‐ Jan
2012 ‐ Jul
Rising Renters’ and Homeowners’ Rent Growth
5. Percent of REALTORS® Reporting Changing
Rent Levels as Compared to 12 Months Ago
60%
Sept '12: Rising rent: 57%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Higher Rents Lower Rents Constant rents
7. Federal Reserve Balance Sheet from
Quantitative Easing
Total Assets
3500000
$ million
3000000
2500000
2000000
1500000
1000000
500000
0
1‐Aug‐07 1‐Aug‐08 1‐Aug‐09 1‐Aug‐10 1‐Aug‐11 1‐Aug‐12
8. 500000
0
1000000
1500000
2000000
2500000
3000000
3500000
4000000
1970 ‐ Jan
1972 ‐ Jan
1974 ‐ Jan
1976 ‐ Jan
1978 ‐ Jan
1980 ‐ Jan
1982 ‐ Jan
1984 ‐ Jan
12‐month tally in $ million
1986 ‐ Jan
Revenue
1988 ‐ Jan
1990 ‐ Jan
1992 ‐ Jan
1994 ‐ Jan
1996 ‐ Jan
Spending
1998 ‐ Jan
2000 ‐ Jan
Federal Government
2002 ‐ Jan
2004 ‐ Jan
Tax Revenue and Spending
2006 ‐ Jan
2008 ‐ Jan
2010 ‐ Jan
2012 ‐ Jan
9. Huge Federal Budget Deficit
… Will Push Up Borrowing Cost and/or Ignite Inflation
4
Deficit in relation to GDP
2
0
1960 1964 1968 1972 1976 1980 1984 1988 1992 1996 2000 2004 2008 2012
‐2‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan
‐4
‐6
‐8
‐10
‐12
11. 0
5
10
15
20
‐5
1971 ‐ Jan
1973 ‐ Jan
1975 ‐ Jan
1977 ‐ Jan
1979 ‐ Jan
1981 ‐ Jan
1983 ‐ Jan
1985 ‐ Jan
1987 ‐ Jan
1989 ‐ Jan
1991 ‐ Jan
30‐year Mortgage Rate
1993 ‐ Jan
1995 ‐ Jan
1997 ‐ Jan
1999 ‐ Jan
Mortgage Rates
2001 ‐ Jan
2003 ‐ Jan
2005 ‐ Jan
Inflation Rate
2007 ‐ Jan
2009 ‐ Jan
Declining Inflation Helped Lower
2011 ‐ Jan
12. Mortgage Rate Forecast
(Average Rate of 5.5% in 2015 ?)
30‐year Mortgage
%
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Modestly higher rates could help home sales as banks re‐staff mortgage
work for home purchase applications and less refinance applications.
13. Forecast #2: Meaningfully Higher
Home Prices
• Demand is Up … Supply is Down
• 4% to 5% in 2012 (Case‐Shiller, FHFA)
• 5% to 7% in 2012 (Median Home Price)
• Home price growth could slow or accelerate … all
depends on housing starts
• Probably 15% cumulative growth over 3 years
14. 0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
70.0
2008 ‐ Jan
2008 ‐ Apr
2008 ‐ Jul
2008 ‐ Oct
2009 ‐ Jan
2009 ‐ Apr
2009 ‐ Jul
2009 ‐ Oct
Buyer
2010 ‐ Jan
2010 ‐ Apr
2010 ‐ Jul
2010 ‐ Oct
Seller
2011 ‐ Jan
2011 ‐ Apr
2011 ‐ Jul
from REALTOR® Survey
Buyer and Seller Traffic
2011 ‐ Oct
2012 ‐ Jan
2012 ‐ Apr
2012 ‐ Jul
15. 70
75
80
85
90
95
100
105
110
115
2007 ‐ Jan
2007 ‐ Apr
2007 ‐ Jul
Source: NAR
2007 ‐ Oct
2008 ‐ Jan
2008 ‐ Apr
2008 ‐ Jul
2008 ‐ Oct
2009 ‐ Jan
2009 ‐ Apr
Homebuyer Tax Credit
2009 ‐ Jul
2009 ‐ Oct
2010 ‐ Jan
2010 ‐ Apr
2010 ‐ Jul
(Seasonally Adjusted)
2010 ‐ Oct
2011 ‐ Jan
2011 ‐ Apr
2011 ‐ July
2011 ‐ Oct
2012 ‐ Jan
2012‐Apr
2012 ‐ Jul
2012 ‐ Oct
Monthly Pending Home Sales Index
16. Annual Existing Home Sales Closings:
U‐Shaped Recovery
8
In million units
7 7.08
6 6.52
5 5.7
5.4
5.02 5.1
4 4.69
4.12 4.34 4.18 4.26
3
2
1
0
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2013
2014
2015
2012 est.
19. 124000
126000
128000
130000
132000
134000
136000
138000
2000 ‐ Jan
2000 ‐ Jul
2001 ‐ Jan
2001 ‐ Jul
140000 In thousands
2002 ‐ Jan
2002 ‐ Jul
2003 ‐ Jan
2003 ‐ Jul
2004 ‐ Jan
2004 ‐ Jul
2005 ‐ Jan
2005 ‐ Jul
2006 ‐ Jan
2006 ‐ Jul
2007 ‐ Jan
2007 ‐ Jul
2008 ‐ Jan
2008 ‐ Jul
2009 ‐ Jan
U.S. Total Payroll Jobs
2009 ‐ Jul
2010 ‐ Jan
2010 ‐ Jul
(Recovered 63% of jobs lost)
2011 ‐ Jan
2011 ‐ Jul
2012 ‐ Jan
2012 ‐ Jul
20. 5000
5100
5200
5300
5400
5500
5600
5700
5800
2000 ‐ Jan
2000 ‐ Jul
2001 ‐ Jan
2001 ‐ Jul
2002 ‐ Jan
In thousands
2002 ‐ Jul
2003 ‐ Jan
2003 ‐ Jul
2004 ‐ Jan
2004 ‐ Jul
2005 ‐ Jan
2005 ‐ Jul
2006 ‐ Jan
2006 ‐ Jul
2007 ‐ Jan
2007 ‐ Jul
2008 ‐ Jan
(Lost Decade)
2008 ‐ Jul
2009 ‐ Jan
2009 ‐ Jul
Ohio Total Payroll Jobs
2010 ‐ Jan
2010 ‐ Jul
2011 ‐ Jan
2011 ‐ Jul
2012 ‐ Jan
2012 ‐ Jul
21. Ohio Total Payroll Jobs
Long‐term since 1939
6000 In thousands
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
1939 1945 1951 1957 1963 1969 1975 1981 1987 1993 1999 2005 2011
‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan
22. 54%
56%
58%
60%
62%
64%
66%
2000 ‐ Jan
2000 ‐ Jul
2001 ‐ Jan
2001 ‐ Jul
2002 ‐ Jan
2002 ‐ Jul
2003 ‐ Jan
2003 ‐ Jul
2004 ‐ Jan
2004 ‐ Jul
2005 ‐ Jan
2005 ‐ Jul
2006 ‐ Jan
2006 ‐ Jul
2007 ‐ Jan
2007 ‐ Jul
2008 ‐ Jan
2008 ‐ Jul
2009 ‐ Jan
2009 ‐ Jul
2010 ‐ Jan
2010 ‐ Jul
(How many of the civilian population is working?)
2011 ‐ Jan
Employment Rate … No Progress
2011 ‐ Jul
2012 ‐ Jan
2012 ‐ Jul
23. Visible Existing Home Inventory
(Existing home inventory at 8‐year low)
4,500,000
4,000,000
3,500,000
3,000,000
2,500,000
2,000,000
1,500,000
1,000,000
500,000
0
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan
24. 100
200
300
400
500
600
700
0
1964 ‐ Jan
1966 ‐ Jan
1968 ‐ Jan
1970 ‐ Jan
1972 ‐ Jan
1974 ‐ Jan
1976 ‐ Jan
1978 ‐ Jan
1980 ‐ Jan
1982 ‐ Jan
1984 ‐ Jan
1986 ‐ Jan
1988 ‐ Jan
1990 ‐ Jan
1992 ‐ Jan
1994 ‐ Jan
1996 ‐ Jan
1998 ‐ Jan
2000 ‐ Jan
2002 ‐ Jan
2004 ‐ Jan
Visible New Home Inventory
2006 ‐ Jan
2008 ‐ Jan
(Newly Constructed Homes Inventory at 50‐year low)
2010 ‐ Jan
2012 ‐ Jan
25. Housing Starts
(Well Below 50‐year average of 1.5 million each year)
multifamily single‐family
Thousand units (annualized)
2500
2000
Long‐term Average
1500
1000
500
0
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan ‐ Jan
31. Home Prices
Metric % change from one year ago Comment
NAR + 10.1% (November) Mix of homes impact price …
Median Price fewer distressed sales recently …
Case‐Shiller +4.3% (Aug, Sep, Oct average) Lagging indicator
Near double‐digit on an
annualized basis in recent months
FHFA + 5.6% (October) 9 straights months of gain
National
FHFA +3.0% (Third Quarter) 3 straight quarters of gain
Connecticut
33. State Variations in Price Appreciation
(% change from 2011 Q3 to 2012 Q3)
25
20
Many in Rocky Mountain States
15
10
5
Mostly in Northeast
0
Utah
Nevada
Michigan
New Jersey
Maine
North Dakota
Colorado
Arizona
Florida
Illinois
California
Connecticut
New Hampshire
Idaho
New York
Rhode Island
DC
‐5
Source: FHFA Repeat Price Index
34. Forecast #3: More Unequal Wealth
Distribution
• Renters do not accumulate wealth
• Renter population rising
• Homeowners build wealth after buying at low
prices
• Stagnant homeowner population
• Tight Credit hinders ‘good’ renters from
becoming homeowners
• Investors becoming increasing share of property
owners
44. Risks to Forecast
• Upside … Credit Availability
– Housing recovery so far even with tight credit
– What happens if mortgage accessibility opens up?
– Counter‐cyclical housing policy … lower FHA
premiums and lower GSE g‐fees
• Downside … Washington Policy
– QRM 20% down payment requirement?
– Basel 3 … capital rule that punishes private mortgage
with low down payment and commercial loans
– Trim mortgage interest deduction?
– Capital gains tax on home sale?
45. Forecast
(If Prolonged Fiscal Cliff is Avoided)
2011 2012 2013 2014
Forecast Forecast
GDP Growth +1.8% +2.1% +2.3% 3.0%
Existing Home 4.3 million 4.7 million 5.1 million 5.3 million
Sales
Housing Starts 610 K 780 K 1.1 million 1.3 million
Existing Home ‐ 4% + 7% + 5% + 4%
Price Growth
30‐yr Mortgage 4.7% 3.7% 4.1% 4.8%
Rate