SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 10
Indonesia Railway Reform SuyonoDikun, PhD Professor in Transport Planning and Policy University of Indonesia at Depok IndII Wrap-up Conference 14thJune 2011
NationalRailwayMaster Plan - 2030 Projections
Indonesian railway ata crossroads Legal Path following Law no. 23/2007  Future Railway System Current  Railway System Revitalisation “De-Facto” Path staying  at current vertical integration Can acompromise or an interim solution be worked out between the regulator and operator?
No compromise: Regulator Legal Path  Full compliance with Law no. 23/2007
No compromise: Incumbent Operator Stay at current vertical integration PT KAI will still operate the existing railway system under vertical integration but has more freedom to invest on both infrastructure and rolling stocks.
IndII assistance IndII has made a lot of policy recommendations on these studies
Lessons learned: The good news Railway stakeholders (DGR, Bappenas, CMEA, MOF) have agreed on the urgent need to revise the current PSO-IMO-TAC scheme. The new framework would make the existing scheme work better. The new framework would enable multi operators and private special railways to become a reality in future railways. IndII’s next involvement would probably include assistance with establishing new framework for the PSO-IMO-TAC scheme.
Lessons learned: Pending matters Revitalisation and restructuring agenda for Jabodetabek Metropolitan Railway is yet to be confirmed by the government. The agenda includes: the enhancement of PT KCJ to be an independent urban railway company; asset separation; network statement; and financial support. The corresponding issue of raising ridership up to three million passengers per day in 2015 and beyond has been endorsed by the government. DGR has to be strengthened institutionally to be able to make a rapid delivery.
Lessons learned: The bad news The NRMP has been formally issued as a long-term planning document but failed to incorporate many strategic issues that had been reported in two IndII’s papers. The NRMP lacks a sound investment plan for the next one or two decades. The NRMP has no mention on the investment strategy, financing, and the role of private involvement including PPP and PFI for special railways. Even for government investment and public sector spending the NRMP has not described the future configuration of APBN funding.
Proposals IndII would probably embark on the second stage of infrastructure agenda beginning July or August 2011. Despite the good news described above, it is strongly suggested that government takes a strong lead and ownership in any program of railway revitalisation ahead. It is a developed and modern Indonesian railway that government would like to see in the years ahead as a backbone for economic mobility, especially freight movement. Good enough is no longer enough. Indonesia needs a rapid change towards a developed economy.

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Impact of Infrastructure Development Project: A Study of Growth and Poverty i...
Impact of Infrastructure Development Project: A Study of Growth and Poverty i...Impact of Infrastructure Development Project: A Study of Growth and Poverty i...
Impact of Infrastructure Development Project: A Study of Growth and Poverty i...Md. Abdul Munem
 
Public Private Partnership
Public Private PartnershipPublic Private Partnership
Public Private PartnershipDeepti Mahajan
 
Metro Rail Policy, 2017
Metro Rail Policy, 2017Metro Rail Policy, 2017
Metro Rail Policy, 2017Aman Kudesia
 
India's relationship with world in infrastructre and opportunities in fdi
India's relationship with world in infrastructre and opportunities in fdiIndia's relationship with world in infrastructre and opportunities in fdi
India's relationship with world in infrastructre and opportunities in fdiJinto Cv
 
Energy and power sector development in Bangladesh
Energy and power sector development in BangladeshEnergy and power sector development in Bangladesh
Energy and power sector development in BangladeshNaim Ebna Rahman
 
Public Private Partnership in Railways - A New Approach_IMR March 2008
Public Private Partnership in Railways - A New Approach_IMR March 2008Public Private Partnership in Railways - A New Approach_IMR March 2008
Public Private Partnership in Railways - A New Approach_IMR March 2008Anil Kumar Gupta
 
Indian budget 2018 19 ire perspective
Indian budget 2018 19 ire perspectiveIndian budget 2018 19 ire perspective
Indian budget 2018 19 ire perspectiveCMA .Pankaj Jain
 
I am young india green and carbon free road transportation
I am young india green and carbon free road transportationI am young india green and carbon free road transportation
I am young india green and carbon free road transportationMahesh Chandra Manav
 
P.M. Gatishakti master project
P.M.  Gatishakti master project P.M.  Gatishakti master project
P.M. Gatishakti master project ShreySarabhai1
 
SECOND high level commitie report ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT
SECOND high level commitie report ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTSECOND high level commitie report ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT
SECOND high level commitie report ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTMANI SHANKAR DWIVEDI
 
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan hong kong
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan hong kong[Urban transportation policy program] action plan hong kong
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan hong kongshrdcinfo
 

La actualidad más candente (19)

Impact of Infrastructure Development Project: A Study of Growth and Poverty i...
Impact of Infrastructure Development Project: A Study of Growth and Poverty i...Impact of Infrastructure Development Project: A Study of Growth and Poverty i...
Impact of Infrastructure Development Project: A Study of Growth and Poverty i...
 
PM Gatishakti scheme
PM Gatishakti schemePM Gatishakti scheme
PM Gatishakti scheme
 
Public Private Partnership
Public Private PartnershipPublic Private Partnership
Public Private Partnership
 
Union budget
Union budgetUnion budget
Union budget
 
New metro rail policy 2017
New metro rail policy 2017New metro rail policy 2017
New metro rail policy 2017
 
Metro Rail Policy, 2017
Metro Rail Policy, 2017Metro Rail Policy, 2017
Metro Rail Policy, 2017
 
India's relationship with world in infrastructre and opportunities in fdi
India's relationship with world in infrastructre and opportunities in fdiIndia's relationship with world in infrastructre and opportunities in fdi
India's relationship with world in infrastructre and opportunities in fdi
 
Energy and power sector development in Bangladesh
Energy and power sector development in BangladeshEnergy and power sector development in Bangladesh
Energy and power sector development in Bangladesh
 
Public Private Partnership in Railways - A New Approach_IMR March 2008
Public Private Partnership in Railways - A New Approach_IMR March 2008Public Private Partnership in Railways - A New Approach_IMR March 2008
Public Private Partnership in Railways - A New Approach_IMR March 2008
 
Indian budget 2018 19 ire perspective
Indian budget 2018 19 ire perspectiveIndian budget 2018 19 ire perspective
Indian budget 2018 19 ire perspective
 
I am young india green and carbon free road transportation
I am young india green and carbon free road transportationI am young india green and carbon free road transportation
I am young india green and carbon free road transportation
 
P.M. Gatishakti master project
P.M.  Gatishakti master project P.M.  Gatishakti master project
P.M. Gatishakti master project
 
Cir 37 2014
Cir  37 2014Cir  37 2014
Cir 37 2014
 
SECOND high level commitie report ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT
SECOND high level commitie report ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTSECOND high level commitie report ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT
SECOND high level commitie report ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT
 
Indygo budget 2013
Indygo budget 2013Indygo budget 2013
Indygo budget 2013
 
CII Policy Watch July 2015
CII Policy Watch July 2015CII Policy Watch July 2015
CII Policy Watch July 2015
 
Status Infrastructure in Zimbabwe
Status Infrastructure in ZimbabweStatus Infrastructure in Zimbabwe
Status Infrastructure in Zimbabwe
 
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan hong kong
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan hong kong[Urban transportation policy program] action plan hong kong
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan hong kong
 
Roads to Go Green
Roads to Go GreenRoads to Go Green
Roads to Go Green
 

Similar a Suyono dikun indonesia railway reform june 14 2011

Budget FY16-17 : An opportunity to revitalise the infrastructure sector
Budget FY16-17 : An opportunity to revitalise the infrastructure sectorBudget FY16-17 : An opportunity to revitalise the infrastructure sector
Budget FY16-17 : An opportunity to revitalise the infrastructure sectorZubin Poonawalla
 
PM-Gati-Shakti-Master-Plan 1.pptx
PM-Gati-Shakti-Master-Plan 1.pptxPM-Gati-Shakti-Master-Plan 1.pptx
PM-Gati-Shakti-Master-Plan 1.pptxaparnadasari3
 
Sectoral Infrastructure Development
Sectoral Infrastructure DevelopmentSectoral Infrastructure Development
Sectoral Infrastructure DevelopmentGAURAV. H .TANDON
 
Infrastructure a critical public policy issue that faces the kenyan nation ...
Infrastructure   a critical public policy issue that faces the kenyan nation ...Infrastructure   a critical public policy issue that faces the kenyan nation ...
Infrastructure a critical public policy issue that faces the kenyan nation ...Beatrice Amollo
 
New Microsoft Office PowerPoint Presentation
New Microsoft Office PowerPoint PresentationNew Microsoft Office PowerPoint Presentation
New Microsoft Office PowerPoint PresentationAdam Smith
 
Infrastructure Developments In Indonesia - Key Improvements and Priority Proj...
Infrastructure Developments In Indonesia - Key Improvements and Priority Proj...Infrastructure Developments In Indonesia - Key Improvements and Priority Proj...
Infrastructure Developments In Indonesia - Key Improvements and Priority Proj...Lynn Aziz
 
Logistics Industry - Present Scenario & Expectations
Logistics Industry -  Present Scenario & Expectations  Logistics Industry -  Present Scenario & Expectations
Logistics Industry - Present Scenario & Expectations Zubin Poonawalla
 
ESG Development Overview.pdf
ESG Development Overview.pdfESG Development Overview.pdf
ESG Development Overview.pdfAHRP Law Firm
 
Study on Public-Private Partnerships with Reference to Indian Infrastructural...
Study on Public-Private Partnerships with Reference to Indian Infrastructural...Study on Public-Private Partnerships with Reference to Indian Infrastructural...
Study on Public-Private Partnerships with Reference to Indian Infrastructural...inventionjournals
 
Analysis of Sources of Finances for Indian Railways and Futureroadmap
Analysis of Sources of Finances for Indian Railways and FutureroadmapAnalysis of Sources of Finances for Indian Railways and Futureroadmap
Analysis of Sources of Finances for Indian Railways and FutureroadmapSudiksha Joshi
 
Open for Private Investment in Vietnam Railways
Open for Private Investment in Vietnam RailwaysOpen for Private Investment in Vietnam Railways
Open for Private Investment in Vietnam RailwaysEsther Nguyen
 
Public Private Partnership: Specific Characteristics in Different Sectors
Public Private Partnership: Specific Characteristics in Different Sectors Public Private Partnership: Specific Characteristics in Different Sectors
Public Private Partnership: Specific Characteristics in Different Sectors SilvaSuvahRaisa
 

Similar a Suyono dikun indonesia railway reform june 14 2011 (20)

Lect 03 ppp kppip
Lect 03 ppp kppipLect 03 ppp kppip
Lect 03 ppp kppip
 
Budget FY16-17 : An opportunity to revitalise the infrastructure sector
Budget FY16-17 : An opportunity to revitalise the infrastructure sectorBudget FY16-17 : An opportunity to revitalise the infrastructure sector
Budget FY16-17 : An opportunity to revitalise the infrastructure sector
 
PM-Gati-Shakti-Master-Plan 1.pptx
PM-Gati-Shakti-Master-Plan 1.pptxPM-Gati-Shakti-Master-Plan 1.pptx
PM-Gati-Shakti-Master-Plan 1.pptx
 
Sectoral Infrastructure Development
Sectoral Infrastructure DevelopmentSectoral Infrastructure Development
Sectoral Infrastructure Development
 
PPP Book 2013
PPP Book 2013PPP Book 2013
PPP Book 2013
 
C0362021025
C0362021025C0362021025
C0362021025
 
Infrastructure a critical public policy issue that faces the kenyan nation ...
Infrastructure   a critical public policy issue that faces the kenyan nation ...Infrastructure   a critical public policy issue that faces the kenyan nation ...
Infrastructure a critical public policy issue that faces the kenyan nation ...
 
National monetisation pipeline
National monetisation pipelineNational monetisation pipeline
National monetisation pipeline
 
Boot model
Boot modelBoot model
Boot model
 
New Microsoft Office PowerPoint Presentation
New Microsoft Office PowerPoint PresentationNew Microsoft Office PowerPoint Presentation
New Microsoft Office PowerPoint Presentation
 
Infrastructure Developments In Indonesia - Key Improvements and Priority Proj...
Infrastructure Developments In Indonesia - Key Improvements and Priority Proj...Infrastructure Developments In Indonesia - Key Improvements and Priority Proj...
Infrastructure Developments In Indonesia - Key Improvements and Priority Proj...
 
Logistics Industry - Present Scenario & Expectations
Logistics Industry -  Present Scenario & Expectations  Logistics Industry -  Present Scenario & Expectations
Logistics Industry - Present Scenario & Expectations
 
ESG Development Overview.pdf
ESG Development Overview.pdfESG Development Overview.pdf
ESG Development Overview.pdf
 
Study on Public-Private Partnerships with Reference to Indian Infrastructural...
Study on Public-Private Partnerships with Reference to Indian Infrastructural...Study on Public-Private Partnerships with Reference to Indian Infrastructural...
Study on Public-Private Partnerships with Reference to Indian Infrastructural...
 
Analysis of Sources of Finances for Indian Railways and Futureroadmap
Analysis of Sources of Finances for Indian Railways and FutureroadmapAnalysis of Sources of Finances for Indian Railways and Futureroadmap
Analysis of Sources of Finances for Indian Railways and Futureroadmap
 
JnNURM Guidelines
JnNURM GuidelinesJnNURM Guidelines
JnNURM Guidelines
 
Open for Private Investment in Vietnam Railways
Open for Private Investment in Vietnam RailwaysOpen for Private Investment in Vietnam Railways
Open for Private Investment in Vietnam Railways
 
TF 0571723.pdf
TF 0571723.pdfTF 0571723.pdf
TF 0571723.pdf
 
Spicing Up
Spicing UpSpicing Up
Spicing Up
 
Public Private Partnership: Specific Characteristics in Different Sectors
Public Private Partnership: Specific Characteristics in Different Sectors Public Private Partnership: Specific Characteristics in Different Sectors
Public Private Partnership: Specific Characteristics in Different Sectors
 

Más de Indonesia Infrastructure Initiative

Indonesian railways revitalisation bambang susantono, vice minister for tra...
Indonesian railways revitalisation   bambang susantono, vice minister for tra...Indonesian railways revitalisation   bambang susantono, vice minister for tra...
Indonesian railways revitalisation bambang susantono, vice minister for tra...Indonesia Infrastructure Initiative
 
Railway function in developing multimodal transportation in java
Railway function in developing multimodal transportation in javaRailway function in developing multimodal transportation in java
Railway function in developing multimodal transportation in javaIndonesia Infrastructure Initiative
 
Development of multimodal transportation and inter regional connectivitiy
Development of multimodal transportation and inter regional connectivitiyDevelopment of multimodal transportation and inter regional connectivitiy
Development of multimodal transportation and inter regional connectivitiyIndonesia Infrastructure Initiative
 

Más de Indonesia Infrastructure Initiative (20)

Presentasi Sanitasi INDII
Presentasi Sanitasi INDIIPresentasi Sanitasi INDII
Presentasi Sanitasi INDII
 
Balikpapan Public Diplomacy 25 May 2015
Balikpapan  Public Diplomacy 25 May 2015Balikpapan  Public Diplomacy 25 May 2015
Balikpapan Public Diplomacy 25 May 2015
 
World experience-in-railway-restructuring
World experience-in-railway-restructuringWorld experience-in-railway-restructuring
World experience-in-railway-restructuring
 
Indonesian railways revitalisation bambang susantono, vice minister for tra...
Indonesian railways revitalisation   bambang susantono, vice minister for tra...Indonesian railways revitalisation   bambang susantono, vice minister for tra...
Indonesian railways revitalisation bambang susantono, vice minister for tra...
 
WS2 Infrastructure Issues
WS2 Infrastructure IssuesWS2 Infrastructure Issues
WS2 Infrastructure Issues
 
Development of multimodal transport in north java corridor
Development of multimodal transport in north java corridorDevelopment of multimodal transport in north java corridor
Development of multimodal transport in north java corridor
 
Railway function in developing multimodal transportation in java
Railway function in developing multimodal transportation in javaRailway function in developing multimodal transportation in java
Railway function in developing multimodal transportation in java
 
The role of ipc in developing multimodal transportation in java
The role of ipc in developing multimodal transportation in javaThe role of ipc in developing multimodal transportation in java
The role of ipc in developing multimodal transportation in java
 
Government strategy in developing multimodal transportation
Government strategy in developing multimodal transportationGovernment strategy in developing multimodal transportation
Government strategy in developing multimodal transportation
 
The role of ferry in developing multimodal transportation
The role of ferry in developing multimodal transportationThe role of ferry in developing multimodal transportation
The role of ferry in developing multimodal transportation
 
Development of multimodal transportation and inter regional connectivitiy
Development of multimodal transportation and inter regional connectivitiyDevelopment of multimodal transportation and inter regional connectivitiy
Development of multimodal transportation and inter regional connectivitiy
 
Ws3 safe system approach (bahasa version)
Ws3 safe system approach (bahasa version)Ws3 safe system approach (bahasa version)
Ws3 safe system approach (bahasa version)
 
Ws3 safe system supporting vru (english version)
Ws3 safe system supporting vru (english version)Ws3 safe system supporting vru (english version)
Ws3 safe system supporting vru (english version)
 
Ws3 safe system supporting vru (bahasa version)
Ws3 safe system supporting vru (bahasa version)Ws3 safe system supporting vru (bahasa version)
Ws3 safe system supporting vru (bahasa version)
 
Ws3 presentation
Ws3 presentationWs3 presentation
Ws3 presentation
 
Ws3 me
Ws3 meWs3 me
Ws3 me
 
Ws3 infrastructure related to pedestrian safety
Ws3 infrastructure related to pedestrian safetyWs3 infrastructure related to pedestrian safety
Ws3 infrastructure related to pedestrian safety
 
Ws3 gender and disability presentation
Ws3 gender and disability presentationWs3 gender and disability presentation
Ws3 gender and disability presentation
 
Ws2 introduction
Ws2 introductionWs2 introduction
Ws2 introduction
 
Workshop #2 safe system approach
Workshop #2 safe system approachWorkshop #2 safe system approach
Workshop #2 safe system approach
 

Suyono dikun indonesia railway reform june 14 2011

  • 1. Indonesia Railway Reform SuyonoDikun, PhD Professor in Transport Planning and Policy University of Indonesia at Depok IndII Wrap-up Conference 14thJune 2011
  • 2. NationalRailwayMaster Plan - 2030 Projections
  • 3. Indonesian railway ata crossroads Legal Path following Law no. 23/2007 Future Railway System Current Railway System Revitalisation “De-Facto” Path staying at current vertical integration Can acompromise or an interim solution be worked out between the regulator and operator?
  • 4. No compromise: Regulator Legal Path Full compliance with Law no. 23/2007
  • 5. No compromise: Incumbent Operator Stay at current vertical integration PT KAI will still operate the existing railway system under vertical integration but has more freedom to invest on both infrastructure and rolling stocks.
  • 6. IndII assistance IndII has made a lot of policy recommendations on these studies
  • 7. Lessons learned: The good news Railway stakeholders (DGR, Bappenas, CMEA, MOF) have agreed on the urgent need to revise the current PSO-IMO-TAC scheme. The new framework would make the existing scheme work better. The new framework would enable multi operators and private special railways to become a reality in future railways. IndII’s next involvement would probably include assistance with establishing new framework for the PSO-IMO-TAC scheme.
  • 8. Lessons learned: Pending matters Revitalisation and restructuring agenda for Jabodetabek Metropolitan Railway is yet to be confirmed by the government. The agenda includes: the enhancement of PT KCJ to be an independent urban railway company; asset separation; network statement; and financial support. The corresponding issue of raising ridership up to three million passengers per day in 2015 and beyond has been endorsed by the government. DGR has to be strengthened institutionally to be able to make a rapid delivery.
  • 9. Lessons learned: The bad news The NRMP has been formally issued as a long-term planning document but failed to incorporate many strategic issues that had been reported in two IndII’s papers. The NRMP lacks a sound investment plan for the next one or two decades. The NRMP has no mention on the investment strategy, financing, and the role of private involvement including PPP and PFI for special railways. Even for government investment and public sector spending the NRMP has not described the future configuration of APBN funding.
  • 10. Proposals IndII would probably embark on the second stage of infrastructure agenda beginning July or August 2011. Despite the good news described above, it is strongly suggested that government takes a strong lead and ownership in any program of railway revitalisation ahead. It is a developed and modern Indonesian railway that government would like to see in the years ahead as a backbone for economic mobility, especially freight movement. Good enough is no longer enough. Indonesia needs a rapid change towards a developed economy.