Effective utilization of medical records in the evaluation of a case of sexual abuse, physical abuse, neglect (failure to thrive) or fatalities by a child abuse pediatrics expert can assist criminal (prosecution/defense) and civil (plaintiff/defense). Easy to understand breakdown of relevant records to request, used by child abuse pediatrician to educate protective service workers and referring attorneys for case reviews.
Relationship Between International Law and Municipal Law MIR.pdf
Slide share medical records in child abuse cases
1. Child Abuse Cases
Understanding Medical Records and
Role of Child Abuse Expert
Jennifer Canter MD MPH FAAP
Child Abuse Pediatrician
2. Sexual Abuse Case Records
• Primary Care
– Any prior disclosures, behaviors, signs or symptoms of potenial sexual
abuse
• Emergency Department and Inpatient Records
– Request any forensic nurse (SANE) exam records
– Photo or video documentation of injuries
– Complete medical chart including laboratories
• Child Abuse Pediatrics Specialist
– May be part of Child Advocacy Center record
– Photo or video documentation of injuries
– Medical History (statements from child)
– Complete medical chart including laboratories
• Consider Maternal Records
– If child presents with a sexually transmitted disease
Jennifer Canter MD MPH FAAP
Child Abuse Pediatrician
3. Physical Abuse Case Records
• Primary Care
– Any prior accidents, injuries, or indications of predisposing
conditions (easy bruising, previous non-abuse fractures)
• Emergency Department and Inpatient Records
– Radiology studies
– Photo or video documentation of injuries
– Complete medical chart including laboratories
• Child Abuse Pediatrics Specialist
– May be part of Child Advocacy Center record
– Medical History (statements from child)
– Complete medical chart including laboratories
• Possible Specialist Visits
– Examples - Genetics, Endocrine, Hematology, Orthopedics
Jennifer Canter MD MPH FAAP
Child Abuse Pediatrician
4. Neglect Case Records
• Primary Care
– Any prior indications of neglect
– Previous growth parameters (for failure to thrive)
• Emergency Department and Inpatient
– Complete medical chart including laboratories
• Child Abuse Pediatrics Specialist
– May be part of Child Advocacy Center record
– Complete medical chart including laboratories
• Possible Specialist Visits
– Examples – Genetics and Endocrine
Jennifer Canter MD MPH FAAP
Child Abuse Pediatrician
5. Fatality Case Records
• Primary Care Records
• Emergency Department and Inpatient Records for
All Visits
– All orders, notes, specialist visits
– Radiology and laboratory studies
• Child Abuse Pediatrics Specialist
– Reports, consults
• Autopsy
– Photos and labs
Jennifer Canter MD MPH FAAP
Child Abuse Pediatrician
6. Investigative Records
• Provide investigative records to the child
abuse medical expert to:
– Understand if mechanism is consistent with injury
– Understand statements of child/family/collateral
witnesses
– Understand timing of injuries
– Decipher medical facts as relayed by other experts
– Understand perspectives/opinions of other
medical providers involved in care
Jennifer Canter MD MPH FAAP
Child Abuse Pediatrician
7. Medical Research in Abuse Cases
• Review relevant literature related to the topic
of interest
• Understand strengths and limitation of
articles/studies
• Apply research to the case issues at hand
• Prepare and understand what a medical
witness may rely upon in generating an
opinion
Jennifer Canter MD MPH FAAP
Child Abuse Pediatrician
8. Fundamental Role of Expert
• A medical expert in a child abuse case is an
educator
• Opinions and testimony are identical whether
provided for prosecution/defense, or
plaintiff/defense
• Understanding research foundation to support
opinions
• Effective methods to break down complex
medical language for non-medical professionals
Jennifer Canter MD MPH FAAP
Child Abuse Pediatrician