SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
Your Candidates Are Underpaid – A Look
at the Latest Compensation Data
Robin Mee robin@meederby.com
Kim Whiteley kim@meederby.com
THE COMPETITION IS FIERCE
Quote from a recent reference: “Your client
should put the best offer forward because
when the market finds out he’s looking there
will be offers lined up at his door.”
May 4, 2017
RECORD GROWTH Temporary and Contract Staffing Sales
Staffing Sales Totaled $128.5 Billion in 2016—Up 1.7%
Total Annual Temporary and Contract Staffing Sales (in Billions)
SIA 2017 PROJECTIONS
• SIA projects the U.S. temporary staffing market to grow 4% in
2017 and 5% in 2018.
Education:12%
Clinical & Scientific: 5%
Healthcare: 7%
Search: 4%
Marketing: 7%
Industrial: 2%
IT: 5%
Engineering: 1%
F&A: 5%
Office: -1%
Legal: -1%
ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN
Sales Director National Accounts, top 5 commercial
staffing firm, 5 years in industry, Midwest:
• $125k base + quarterly bonus
• Q1 2017 quarterly bonus: $35k
• 2016 W-2: $227k
ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN
Director of Business Development, RPO, top 5 RPO
firm, 3 years in industry, Southeast:
• $132k base
• Quarterly commission
• 2016 W-2: $247k
ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN
Senior Account Executive IT, top 10 IT staffing firm, 6
years in industry, DC/Metro:
• $43k base
• Bi-weekly commissions
• 2016 W-2: $220k
ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN
Region Vice President, top 5 light industrial staffing
company, 18 years in industry, Midwest:
• $165k base, plus bonus based on market
performance
• 2016 W-2: $300k
ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN
F&A Direct Hire Recruiter, F&A staffing firm, 6 years in
industry, DC/Metro:
• $68k non-recoverable draw plus commission tied to
cash in
• 2016 W-2: $120k
ATTRACTION USING COMPENSATION
• Craft a compensation plan that increases their
earnings and creates excitement.
• Get creative.
• Make your best offer first.
WHY A JOB CHANGE?
• Elevating in career
• Better opportunity
• Money
• Culture
• Flexibility
• Leadership
• Organization
STAFFING COMPENSATION TRENDS
• Base salaries are on the rise
• Multiple ways to bonus
• Long term incentive/stock/equity
• Cars
• Senior-level deferred comp plans
COMPENSATION DATA SETS
• The 2016 SIA Compensation Estimator was
comprised of 10,099 staffing industry professionals
surveyed across 184 U.S. staffing firms from 4th
Quarter 2016.
• Mee Derby dataset was based on actual
placement data for 2016 and 2017 YTD.
COMPENSATION DRIVERS
• Industry vertical matters - median total compensation is
highest in IT, followed by Clinical, Education, Engineering,
Finance & Accounting, and Creative/Marketing, then
Healthcare, and finally Office and Industrial.
• Size of company - companies with 21-50 employees paid the
highest across all positions and verticals in total compensation.
Base averaged the exact same for all size companies except
over 1,000 employees, which was lower.
• Experience matters - the more experience, the higher the
average compensation.
COMPENSATION
SIA data is base salary/total compensation using the median across all
locations, size of company, industry vertical, and years of experience.
Title Mee Derby SIA Bonus as a % base salary
Branch Manager 57k 70k/105k 40%
Recruiter, Direct Hire 55k 45k/65k 33%
Recruiter, Temp 67,500 40k/60k 33%
Area/Region/Division
Manager/Director/VP
108,750 110k/165k 33%
Recruiting Manager 83k 65k/105k 49%
Sales 95k 75k/120k 50%
Account Manager 115k 50k/85k 44%
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION
Title SIA Bonus as % of base
salary
CEO 200k/300K 37% bonus
COO 160k/200k 25% bonus
Chief Sales Officer 175k/275k 50% bonus
Chief Marketing Officer 105k/105k 18% bonus
Chief Information
Officer
138k/165k 13% bonus
Chief Financial Officer 150k/178k 19% bonus
MEE DERBY RECOMMENDATIONS
• Review compensation plans regularly.
• Benchmark your compensation plan to your friendly
competitors - get involved with ASA and local councils.
• Track candidates compensation as you interview.
• Be flexible on compensation.
• Talk compensation several times when interviewing.
• Understand W-2 history for last 3 years base vs. variable
compensation and how it was paid out.
• Consider asking for W-2 verification.
• Communicate your compensation plan clearly and in
writing.
• Hire stretch candidates.
MEE DERBY WORDS OF WISDOM
• Consider hiring recent college graduates and
professionals from other industries using ASA’s
“Staffing As A Career” resources.
• https://americanstaffing.net/industry-
professionals/promoting-the-profession/
• https://americanstaffing.net/staffing-as-a-
career-a-world-of-opportunity-awaits/
• Hire a rookie with recruiter training through Career
Builder’s Right Skill program: https://rightskill.com/
• There are 751,000 staffing and recruiting
professionals on LinkedIn - co make some great
hires!
Your Candidates Are Underpaid - A Look at the Latest Compensation Data - Robin Mee & Kim Whiteley

More Related Content

What's hot

True Wind Consulting Pitch For Linked In
True Wind Consulting Pitch For Linked InTrue Wind Consulting Pitch For Linked In
True Wind Consulting Pitch For Linked In
ojacque
 

What's hot (20)

Csd presentation
Csd presentationCsd presentation
Csd presentation
 
Hidden Talent
Hidden TalentHidden Talent
Hidden Talent
 
Stand out, stay ahead, and showcase your expertise with LinkedIn Recruiter Ce...
Stand out, stay ahead, and showcase your expertise with LinkedIn Recruiter Ce...Stand out, stay ahead, and showcase your expertise with LinkedIn Recruiter Ce...
Stand out, stay ahead, and showcase your expertise with LinkedIn Recruiter Ce...
 
Talent Engagement Summit 2019 - Kelsea Gibson
Talent Engagement Summit 2019 - Kelsea GibsonTalent Engagement Summit 2019 - Kelsea Gibson
Talent Engagement Summit 2019 - Kelsea Gibson
 
Hiring Practices That Build Powerfully Diverse Teams
Hiring Practices That Build Powerfully Diverse TeamsHiring Practices That Build Powerfully Diverse Teams
Hiring Practices That Build Powerfully Diverse Teams
 
True Wind Consulting Pitch For Linked In
True Wind Consulting Pitch For Linked InTrue Wind Consulting Pitch For Linked In
True Wind Consulting Pitch For Linked In
 
Talent Engagement Summit 2019 - Bryan Lick
Talent Engagement Summit 2019 - Bryan LickTalent Engagement Summit 2019 - Bryan Lick
Talent Engagement Summit 2019 - Bryan Lick
 
What Really Drives Employee Performance
What Really Drives Employee PerformanceWhat Really Drives Employee Performance
What Really Drives Employee Performance
 
The playbook 2.0: Tactical tips for ‘committing' to a social media recruitmen...
The playbook 2.0: Tactical tips for ‘committing' to a social media recruitmen...The playbook 2.0: Tactical tips for ‘committing' to a social media recruitmen...
The playbook 2.0: Tactical tips for ‘committing' to a social media recruitmen...
 
The unified brand: Aligning your consumer, corporate, and employer brands | T...
The unified brand: Aligning your consumer, corporate, and employer brands | T...The unified brand: Aligning your consumer, corporate, and employer brands | T...
The unified brand: Aligning your consumer, corporate, and employer brands | T...
 
Talent Branding
Talent BrandingTalent Branding
Talent Branding
 
Using Assessments for Hiring and Retaining Good People
Using Assessments for Hiring and Retaining Good PeopleUsing Assessments for Hiring and Retaining Good People
Using Assessments for Hiring and Retaining Good People
 
Green business group
Green business groupGreen business group
Green business group
 
Under the talent-acquisition hood: What’s happening with cost, quality, and s...
Under the talent-acquisition hood: What’s happening with cost, quality, and s...Under the talent-acquisition hood: What’s happening with cost, quality, and s...
Under the talent-acquisition hood: What’s happening with cost, quality, and s...
 
7 HR and Recruiting Metrics To Develop a Strategic Business Advantage
7 HR and Recruiting Metrics To Develop a Strategic Business Advantage7 HR and Recruiting Metrics To Develop a Strategic Business Advantage
7 HR and Recruiting Metrics To Develop a Strategic Business Advantage
 
Hypergrowth and beyond: How to navigate hiring during rapid expansion while s...
Hypergrowth and beyond: How to navigate hiring during rapid expansion while s...Hypergrowth and beyond: How to navigate hiring during rapid expansion while s...
Hypergrowth and beyond: How to navigate hiring during rapid expansion while s...
 
The Future of Work
The Future of WorkThe Future of Work
The Future of Work
 
7 HR & Recruiting Metrics You Can't Live Without
7 HR & Recruiting Metrics You Can't Live Without 7 HR & Recruiting Metrics You Can't Live Without
7 HR & Recruiting Metrics You Can't Live Without
 
Recruiting for Values
Recruiting for ValuesRecruiting for Values
Recruiting for Values
 
Toronto Best Places to Work Roadshow | Earl's Kitchen + Bar
Toronto Best Places to Work Roadshow | Earl's Kitchen + BarToronto Best Places to Work Roadshow | Earl's Kitchen + Bar
Toronto Best Places to Work Roadshow | Earl's Kitchen + Bar
 

Similar to Your Candidates Are Underpaid - A Look at the Latest Compensation Data - Robin Mee & Kim Whiteley

Pitch Deck - Spring 2016
Pitch Deck - Spring 2016Pitch Deck - Spring 2016
Pitch Deck - Spring 2016
Nilay Rego
 
Chi Sigma Consulting Pitch Deck
Chi Sigma Consulting Pitch DeckChi Sigma Consulting Pitch Deck
Chi Sigma Consulting Pitch Deck
Tyler Cohen
 
Boardroom recruiting report webinar
Boardroom recruiting report webinar Boardroom recruiting report webinar
Boardroom recruiting report webinar
Recruitment Process Outsourcing Association
 
OT Salary Guide 2017
OT Salary Guide 2017OT Salary Guide 2017
OT Salary Guide 2017
Gisela White
 
Why It Takes 7-13+ Touches to Generate a Qualified B2B Sales Lead Today
Why It Takes 7-13+ Touches to Generate a Qualified B2B Sales Lead TodayWhy It Takes 7-13+ Touches to Generate a Qualified B2B Sales Lead Today
Why It Takes 7-13+ Touches to Generate a Qualified B2B Sales Lead Today
Vivastream
 

Similar to Your Candidates Are Underpaid - A Look at the Latest Compensation Data - Robin Mee & Kim Whiteley (20)

California Compensation Trends and Pay Practices
California Compensation Trends and Pay PracticesCalifornia Compensation Trends and Pay Practices
California Compensation Trends and Pay Practices
 
Lateral Due Diligence and Integration
Lateral Due Diligence and IntegrationLateral Due Diligence and Integration
Lateral Due Diligence and Integration
 
Pitch Deck - Spring 2016
Pitch Deck - Spring 2016Pitch Deck - Spring 2016
Pitch Deck - Spring 2016
 
Chi Sigma Consulting Pitch Deck
Chi Sigma Consulting Pitch DeckChi Sigma Consulting Pitch Deck
Chi Sigma Consulting Pitch Deck
 
Delivering Growth and Profitability in 2017: Insights from over 500 CFOs
Delivering Growth and Profitability in 2017: Insights from over 500 CFOsDelivering Growth and Profitability in 2017: Insights from over 500 CFOs
Delivering Growth and Profitability in 2017: Insights from over 500 CFOs
 
It’s all in how you package it
It’s all in how you package itIt’s all in how you package it
It’s all in how you package it
 
Women In Automotive 2017 - Donna Wagner
Women In Automotive 2017 - Donna WagnerWomen In Automotive 2017 - Donna Wagner
Women In Automotive 2017 - Donna Wagner
 
Annual PAR Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Annual PAR Powerpoint Presentation SlidesAnnual PAR Powerpoint Presentation Slides
Annual PAR Powerpoint Presentation Slides
 
How to increase your business with a strong marketing plan
How to increase your business with a strong marketing planHow to increase your business with a strong marketing plan
How to increase your business with a strong marketing plan
 
How to Build a Business Case for ABM
How to Build a Business Case for ABMHow to Build a Business Case for ABM
How to Build a Business Case for ABM
 
Boardroom recruiting report webinar
Boardroom recruiting report webinar Boardroom recruiting report webinar
Boardroom recruiting report webinar
 
Sbdc services description 2014
Sbdc services description 2014Sbdc services description 2014
Sbdc services description 2014
 
OT Salary Guide 2017
OT Salary Guide 2017OT Salary Guide 2017
OT Salary Guide 2017
 
Business plan for consulting and e learning
Business plan for consulting and e learningBusiness plan for consulting and e learning
Business plan for consulting and e learning
 
Key Performance Indicators webinar Smith & Gesteland
Key Performance Indicators webinar    Smith & GestelandKey Performance Indicators webinar    Smith & Gesteland
Key Performance Indicators webinar Smith & Gesteland
 
Why It Takes 7-13+ Touches to Generate a Qualified B2B Sales Lead Today
Why It Takes 7-13+ Touches to Generate a Qualified B2B Sales Lead TodayWhy It Takes 7-13+ Touches to Generate a Qualified B2B Sales Lead Today
Why It Takes 7-13+ Touches to Generate a Qualified B2B Sales Lead Today
 
New England Compensation Trends & Pay Practices
New England Compensation Trends & Pay PracticesNew England Compensation Trends & Pay Practices
New England Compensation Trends & Pay Practices
 
UGBA 100 - Unicard capstone project
UGBA 100 - Unicard capstone projectUGBA 100 - Unicard capstone project
UGBA 100 - Unicard capstone project
 
Most important organizational performance metrics
Most important organizational performance metricsMost important organizational performance metrics
Most important organizational performance metrics
 
David Ninowski Resume
David Ninowski ResumeDavid Ninowski Resume
David Ninowski Resume
 

More from Jeremy Ott

More from Jeremy Ott (20)

M&A: Pursuing a Profitable Exit
M&A: Pursuing a Profitable ExitM&A: Pursuing a Profitable Exit
M&A: Pursuing a Profitable Exit
 
Coaching Your Team to Success in the Here and Now
Coaching Your Team to Success in the Here and NowCoaching Your Team to Success in the Here and Now
Coaching Your Team to Success in the Here and Now
 
Building your External Agency Brand to Appeal to Distracted Buyers
Building your External Agency Brand to Appeal to Distracted BuyersBuilding your External Agency Brand to Appeal to Distracted Buyers
Building your External Agency Brand to Appeal to Distracted Buyers
 
The Science of Stress: Cultivating Recruiter Resilience
The Science of Stress: Cultivating Recruiter ResilienceThe Science of Stress: Cultivating Recruiter Resilience
The Science of Stress: Cultivating Recruiter Resilience
 
Leveraging Inbound Marketing for Candidate and Client Engagement
Leveraging Inbound Marketing for Candidate and Client EngagementLeveraging Inbound Marketing for Candidate and Client Engagement
Leveraging Inbound Marketing for Candidate and Client Engagement
 
The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on the World of Work
The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on the World of WorkThe Impact of Artificial Intelligence on the World of Work
The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on the World of Work
 
Engage London Marketplace Speed Pitch
Engage London Marketplace Speed PitchEngage London Marketplace Speed Pitch
Engage London Marketplace Speed Pitch
 
The Human Side of Hiring - Daniel Fellows
The Human Side of Hiring - Daniel FellowsThe Human Side of Hiring - Daniel Fellows
The Human Side of Hiring - Daniel Fellows
 
The Era of Talent Intelligence: Elevating Your Business Strategy with Data-Dr...
The Era of Talent Intelligence: Elevating Your Business Strategy with Data-Dr...The Era of Talent Intelligence: Elevating Your Business Strategy with Data-Dr...
The Era of Talent Intelligence: Elevating Your Business Strategy with Data-Dr...
 
The Staffing Industry Has the (Bad) Reputation It Deserves: A Crossfire Debat...
The Staffing Industry Has the (Bad) Reputation It Deserves: A Crossfire Debat...The Staffing Industry Has the (Bad) Reputation It Deserves: A Crossfire Debat...
The Staffing Industry Has the (Bad) Reputation It Deserves: A Crossfire Debat...
 
M&A and Exit Strategies for Recruitment Firms - Paul Staples
M&A and Exit Strategies for Recruitment Firms - Paul StaplesM&A and Exit Strategies for Recruitment Firms - Paul Staples
M&A and Exit Strategies for Recruitment Firms - Paul Staples
 
The Impact of AI on the Workforce - Stacey Force
The Impact of AI on the Workforce - Stacey ForceThe Impact of AI on the Workforce - Stacey Force
The Impact of AI on the Workforce - Stacey Force
 
Brexit Mythbustin' - David Slater and Mark Essex
Brexit Mythbustin' - David Slater and Mark EssexBrexit Mythbustin' - David Slater and Mark Essex
Brexit Mythbustin' - David Slater and Mark Essex
 
Technology as a servant: Neuroscience, Machine Learning, and the Future of Re...
Technology as a servant: Neuroscience, Machine Learning, and the Future of Re...Technology as a servant: Neuroscience, Machine Learning, and the Future of Re...
Technology as a servant: Neuroscience, Machine Learning, and the Future of Re...
 
Millennials, Messaging, and Recruiting: Opportunity or Risk - Simon Cleaver
Millennials, Messaging, and Recruiting: Opportunity or Risk - Simon CleaverMillennials, Messaging, and Recruiting: Opportunity or Risk - Simon Cleaver
Millennials, Messaging, and Recruiting: Opportunity or Risk - Simon Cleaver
 
Engage, Attract, Retain: Building Candidate Relationships in a Skills Shortag...
Engage, Attract, Retain: Building Candidate Relationships in a Skills Shortag...Engage, Attract, Retain: Building Candidate Relationships in a Skills Shortag...
Engage, Attract, Retain: Building Candidate Relationships in a Skills Shortag...
 
Reporting with Bullhorn Canvas: A 360 Degree View - Ben Carter
Reporting with Bullhorn Canvas: A 360 Degree View - Ben CarterReporting with Bullhorn Canvas: A 360 Degree View - Ben Carter
Reporting with Bullhorn Canvas: A 360 Degree View - Ben Carter
 
The Mind of The Practical Leader - Mark Nussbaum
The Mind of The Practical Leader - Mark NussbaumThe Mind of The Practical Leader - Mark Nussbaum
The Mind of The Practical Leader - Mark Nussbaum
 
Relationships Above All Else: Creating a Culture that Builds Long-Term Trust ...
Relationships Above All Else: Creating a Culture that Builds Long-Term Trust ...Relationships Above All Else: Creating a Culture that Builds Long-Term Trust ...
Relationships Above All Else: Creating a Culture that Builds Long-Term Trust ...
 
Millennials Will Lead You: What Do You Do? - Wes Gay
Millennials Will Lead You: What Do You Do? - Wes GayMillennials Will Lead You: What Do You Do? - Wes Gay
Millennials Will Lead You: What Do You Do? - Wes Gay
 

Your Candidates Are Underpaid - A Look at the Latest Compensation Data - Robin Mee & Kim Whiteley

  • 1. Your Candidates Are Underpaid – A Look at the Latest Compensation Data Robin Mee robin@meederby.com Kim Whiteley kim@meederby.com
  • 2. THE COMPETITION IS FIERCE Quote from a recent reference: “Your client should put the best offer forward because when the market finds out he’s looking there will be offers lined up at his door.” May 4, 2017
  • 3. RECORD GROWTH Temporary and Contract Staffing Sales Staffing Sales Totaled $128.5 Billion in 2016—Up 1.7% Total Annual Temporary and Contract Staffing Sales (in Billions)
  • 4. SIA 2017 PROJECTIONS • SIA projects the U.S. temporary staffing market to grow 4% in 2017 and 5% in 2018. Education:12% Clinical & Scientific: 5% Healthcare: 7% Search: 4% Marketing: 7% Industrial: 2% IT: 5% Engineering: 1% F&A: 5% Office: -1% Legal: -1%
  • 5. ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN Sales Director National Accounts, top 5 commercial staffing firm, 5 years in industry, Midwest: • $125k base + quarterly bonus • Q1 2017 quarterly bonus: $35k • 2016 W-2: $227k
  • 6. ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN Director of Business Development, RPO, top 5 RPO firm, 3 years in industry, Southeast: • $132k base • Quarterly commission • 2016 W-2: $247k
  • 7. ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN Senior Account Executive IT, top 10 IT staffing firm, 6 years in industry, DC/Metro: • $43k base • Bi-weekly commissions • 2016 W-2: $220k
  • 8. ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN Region Vice President, top 5 light industrial staffing company, 18 years in industry, Midwest: • $165k base, plus bonus based on market performance • 2016 W-2: $300k
  • 9. ANATOMY OF A COMPENSATION PLAN F&A Direct Hire Recruiter, F&A staffing firm, 6 years in industry, DC/Metro: • $68k non-recoverable draw plus commission tied to cash in • 2016 W-2: $120k
  • 10. ATTRACTION USING COMPENSATION • Craft a compensation plan that increases their earnings and creates excitement. • Get creative. • Make your best offer first.
  • 11. WHY A JOB CHANGE? • Elevating in career • Better opportunity • Money • Culture • Flexibility • Leadership • Organization
  • 12. STAFFING COMPENSATION TRENDS • Base salaries are on the rise • Multiple ways to bonus • Long term incentive/stock/equity • Cars • Senior-level deferred comp plans
  • 13. COMPENSATION DATA SETS • The 2016 SIA Compensation Estimator was comprised of 10,099 staffing industry professionals surveyed across 184 U.S. staffing firms from 4th Quarter 2016. • Mee Derby dataset was based on actual placement data for 2016 and 2017 YTD.
  • 14. COMPENSATION DRIVERS • Industry vertical matters - median total compensation is highest in IT, followed by Clinical, Education, Engineering, Finance & Accounting, and Creative/Marketing, then Healthcare, and finally Office and Industrial. • Size of company - companies with 21-50 employees paid the highest across all positions and verticals in total compensation. Base averaged the exact same for all size companies except over 1,000 employees, which was lower. • Experience matters - the more experience, the higher the average compensation.
  • 15. COMPENSATION SIA data is base salary/total compensation using the median across all locations, size of company, industry vertical, and years of experience. Title Mee Derby SIA Bonus as a % base salary Branch Manager 57k 70k/105k 40% Recruiter, Direct Hire 55k 45k/65k 33% Recruiter, Temp 67,500 40k/60k 33% Area/Region/Division Manager/Director/VP 108,750 110k/165k 33% Recruiting Manager 83k 65k/105k 49% Sales 95k 75k/120k 50% Account Manager 115k 50k/85k 44%
  • 16. EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION Title SIA Bonus as % of base salary CEO 200k/300K 37% bonus COO 160k/200k 25% bonus Chief Sales Officer 175k/275k 50% bonus Chief Marketing Officer 105k/105k 18% bonus Chief Information Officer 138k/165k 13% bonus Chief Financial Officer 150k/178k 19% bonus
  • 17. MEE DERBY RECOMMENDATIONS • Review compensation plans regularly. • Benchmark your compensation plan to your friendly competitors - get involved with ASA and local councils. • Track candidates compensation as you interview. • Be flexible on compensation. • Talk compensation several times when interviewing. • Understand W-2 history for last 3 years base vs. variable compensation and how it was paid out. • Consider asking for W-2 verification. • Communicate your compensation plan clearly and in writing. • Hire stretch candidates.
  • 18. MEE DERBY WORDS OF WISDOM • Consider hiring recent college graduates and professionals from other industries using ASA’s “Staffing As A Career” resources. • https://americanstaffing.net/industry- professionals/promoting-the-profession/ • https://americanstaffing.net/staffing-as-a- career-a-world-of-opportunity-awaits/ • Hire a rookie with recruiter training through Career Builder’s Right Skill program: https://rightskill.com/ • There are 751,000 staffing and recruiting professionals on LinkedIn - co make some great hires!