SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 44
Technology: driver, solution or symptom? Martin Oliver London Knowledge Lab,  Institute of Education, & Higher Education Academy
Overview ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What’s the problem? ,[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
So… the purpose of this talk  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Is technology driving change? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
And it’s not just universities that will change… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The changing nature of knowledge, too? ,[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object]
Let’s stretch that point ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What’s the line of argument? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Is there any evidence of this? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
“ If you can be replaced by a web page, perhaps you ought to be…” ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
So, technology as driver? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Technology as solution ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
45 years of technology in educational policy ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object]
Buy Blackboard! ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
WimbaPRONTO promotional materials ,[object Object],[object Object]
WimbaVOICE promotional materials ,[object Object],[object Object]
Scapegoating ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Technology as solution? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Technology as weathervane? ,[object Object],[object Object]
Technology as effect ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
An illustrative case ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The framework ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What happened? ,[object Object],[object Object]
At the same time… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What’s going on? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
So was there ‘transformation’? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What drives change? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The Trojan Mouse ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
So what weathervanes could we watch? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Where does this leave us? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Evidence of technology driving change? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
To what is this a challenge? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
So… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Convergence In Education-Education ERP Solution
Convergence In Education-Education ERP SolutionConvergence In Education-Education ERP Solution
Convergence In Education-Education ERP SolutionChirantan Ghosh
 
Deep Learning in the Age of Intelligent Machines
Deep Learning in the Age of Intelligent MachinesDeep Learning in the Age of Intelligent Machines
Deep Learning in the Age of Intelligent MachinesDaniel M Groenewald
 
Advocating for Educational Technologies
Advocating for Educational TechnologiesAdvocating for Educational Technologies
Advocating for Educational TechnologiesJason Seliskar
 
E-Learning trends & issues
E-Learning trends & issuesE-Learning trends & issues
E-Learning trends & issuesuzee85
 
Nhrhs 060211 share
Nhrhs 060211 shareNhrhs 060211 share
Nhrhs 060211 shareEdAdvance
 
Diffusion of Mobile Devices in Education
Diffusion of Mobile Devices in EducationDiffusion of Mobile Devices in Education
Diffusion of Mobile Devices in EducationKanelia Cannon
 
Trends in e-learning: Research & Practices by Ana Paula Correia PhD
Trends in e-learning: Research & Practices by Ana Paula Correia PhDTrends in e-learning: Research & Practices by Ana Paula Correia PhD
Trends in e-learning: Research & Practices by Ana Paula Correia PhDInês Araújo
 
ICT Specialism Essay - Seminar 1
ICT Specialism Essay - Seminar 1ICT Specialism Essay - Seminar 1
ICT Specialism Essay - Seminar 1Miles Berry
 
eTwinning A model for future schools, Marc Durando
eTwinning A model for future schools, Marc DurandoeTwinning A model for future schools, Marc Durando
eTwinning A model for future schools, Marc DurandoAnne Gilleran
 
The Digital Technologies Curriculum in Context: v4
The Digital Technologies Curriculum in Context: v4The Digital Technologies Curriculum in Context: v4
The Digital Technologies Curriculum in Context: v4Daniel M Groenewald
 
What is your district’s 2020 headline?
What is your district’s 2020 headline?What is your district’s 2020 headline?
What is your district’s 2020 headline?Julie Evans
 
Catch Up and Leap Forward: The 10 Year Evolution of the Learning Landscape
Catch Up and Leap Forward: The 10 Year Evolution of the Learning LandscapeCatch Up and Leap Forward: The 10 Year Evolution of the Learning Landscape
Catch Up and Leap Forward: The 10 Year Evolution of the Learning LandscapeAndy Petroski
 

La actualidad más candente (17)

Convergence In Education-Education ERP Solution
Convergence In Education-Education ERP SolutionConvergence In Education-Education ERP Solution
Convergence In Education-Education ERP Solution
 
Deep Learning in the Age of Intelligent Machines
Deep Learning in the Age of Intelligent MachinesDeep Learning in the Age of Intelligent Machines
Deep Learning in the Age of Intelligent Machines
 
Advocating for Educational Technologies
Advocating for Educational TechnologiesAdvocating for Educational Technologies
Advocating for Educational Technologies
 
E-Learning trends & issues
E-Learning trends & issuesE-Learning trends & issues
E-Learning trends & issues
 
Nhrhs 060211 share
Nhrhs 060211 shareNhrhs 060211 share
Nhrhs 060211 share
 
The Need for NOW !
The Need for NOW !The Need for NOW !
The Need for NOW !
 
Diffusion of Mobile Devices in Education
Diffusion of Mobile Devices in EducationDiffusion of Mobile Devices in Education
Diffusion of Mobile Devices in Education
 
M2 a7coxm
M2 a7coxmM2 a7coxm
M2 a7coxm
 
Trends in e-learning: Research & Practices by Ana Paula Correia PhD
Trends in e-learning: Research & Practices by Ana Paula Correia PhDTrends in e-learning: Research & Practices by Ana Paula Correia PhD
Trends in e-learning: Research & Practices by Ana Paula Correia PhD
 
ICT Specialism Essay - Seminar 1
ICT Specialism Essay - Seminar 1ICT Specialism Essay - Seminar 1
ICT Specialism Essay - Seminar 1
 
eTwinning A model for future schools, Marc Durando
eTwinning A model for future schools, Marc DurandoeTwinning A model for future schools, Marc Durando
eTwinning A model for future schools, Marc Durando
 
The Digital Technologies Curriculum in Context: v4
The Digital Technologies Curriculum in Context: v4The Digital Technologies Curriculum in Context: v4
The Digital Technologies Curriculum in Context: v4
 
eTernity
eTernityeTernity
eTernity
 
ETEC635 Paper
ETEC635 PaperETEC635 Paper
ETEC635 Paper
 
VLEs in UK Schools
VLEs in UK SchoolsVLEs in UK Schools
VLEs in UK Schools
 
What is your district’s 2020 headline?
What is your district’s 2020 headline?What is your district’s 2020 headline?
What is your district’s 2020 headline?
 
Catch Up and Leap Forward: The 10 Year Evolution of the Learning Landscape
Catch Up and Leap Forward: The 10 Year Evolution of the Learning LandscapeCatch Up and Leap Forward: The 10 Year Evolution of the Learning Landscape
Catch Up and Leap Forward: The 10 Year Evolution of the Learning Landscape
 

Destacado

Technology: driver, solution or symptom?
Technology: driver, solution or symptom?Technology: driver, solution or symptom?
Technology: driver, solution or symptom?Martin Oliver
 
Spaces, places and technologies: a sociomaterial perspective on students’ exp...
Spaces, places and technologies: a sociomaterial perspective on students’ exp...Spaces, places and technologies: a sociomaterial perspective on students’ exp...
Spaces, places and technologies: a sociomaterial perspective on students’ exp...Martin Oliver
 
Space, technology and the student experience
Space, technology and the student experienceSpace, technology and the student experience
Space, technology and the student experienceMartin Oliver
 
Educational Resilience in the Digital University
Educational Resilience in the Digital UniversityEducational Resilience in the Digital University
Educational Resilience in the Digital UniversityMartin Oliver
 
Current challenges for educational technology research
Current challenges for educational technology researchCurrent challenges for educational technology research
Current challenges for educational technology researchMartin Oliver
 
Spaces, places and technologies: can we know, value and shape policy to provi...
Spaces, places and technologies: can we know, value and shape policy to provi...Spaces, places and technologies: can we know, value and shape policy to provi...
Spaces, places and technologies: can we know, value and shape policy to provi...Martin Oliver
 
What shapes what? Technologies and their relationship to learning
What shapes what? Technologies and their relationship to learningWhat shapes what? Technologies and their relationship to learning
What shapes what? Technologies and their relationship to learningMartin Oliver
 
Technology, determinism and learning: exploring different ways of being digit...
Technology, determinism and learning: exploring different ways of being digit...Technology, determinism and learning: exploring different ways of being digit...
Technology, determinism and learning: exploring different ways of being digit...Martin Oliver
 
Myths and promises of blended learning
Myths and promises of blended learningMyths and promises of blended learning
Myths and promises of blended learningMartin Oliver
 
Un-defining digital literacies: students' day-to-day engagements with technol...
Un-defining digital literacies: students' day-to-day engagements with technol...Un-defining digital literacies: students' day-to-day engagements with technol...
Un-defining digital literacies: students' day-to-day engagements with technol...Martin Oliver
 
Invisible practices and the technologies of the curriculum: Exploring the ena...
Invisible practices and the technologies of the curriculum: Exploring the ena...Invisible practices and the technologies of the curriculum: Exploring the ena...
Invisible practices and the technologies of the curriculum: Exploring the ena...Martin Oliver
 
ALBUM DE FOTOS
ALBUM DE FOTOSALBUM DE FOTOS
ALBUM DE FOTOSmenfis12
 
Quem sou deixa_marca
Quem sou deixa_marcaQuem sou deixa_marca
Quem sou deixa_marcameridienclube
 
T@rget trust business intelligence bi - etl - fundamentos e aplicações
T@rget trust   business intelligence bi - etl - fundamentos e aplicaçõesT@rget trust   business intelligence bi - etl - fundamentos e aplicações
T@rget trust business intelligence bi - etl - fundamentos e aplicaçõesTargettrust
 
Resultado do Teste Diagnostico Curso web2
Resultado do Teste Diagnostico Curso web2Resultado do Teste Diagnostico Curso web2
Resultado do Teste Diagnostico Curso web2Gerson Valencio
 
Steve robbins Cultura Cap.18 y 19
Steve robbins Cultura Cap.18 y 19Steve robbins Cultura Cap.18 y 19
Steve robbins Cultura Cap.18 y 19Tengo Apellido
 
Liderlik videolari
Liderlik videolariLiderlik videolari
Liderlik videolarizeynep_zyn34
 

Destacado (20)

Technology: driver, solution or symptom?
Technology: driver, solution or symptom?Technology: driver, solution or symptom?
Technology: driver, solution or symptom?
 
Spaces, places and technologies: a sociomaterial perspective on students’ exp...
Spaces, places and technologies: a sociomaterial perspective on students’ exp...Spaces, places and technologies: a sociomaterial perspective on students’ exp...
Spaces, places and technologies: a sociomaterial perspective on students’ exp...
 
Space, technology and the student experience
Space, technology and the student experienceSpace, technology and the student experience
Space, technology and the student experience
 
Educational Resilience in the Digital University
Educational Resilience in the Digital UniversityEducational Resilience in the Digital University
Educational Resilience in the Digital University
 
Current challenges for educational technology research
Current challenges for educational technology researchCurrent challenges for educational technology research
Current challenges for educational technology research
 
Spaces, places and technologies: can we know, value and shape policy to provi...
Spaces, places and technologies: can we know, value and shape policy to provi...Spaces, places and technologies: can we know, value and shape policy to provi...
Spaces, places and technologies: can we know, value and shape policy to provi...
 
What shapes what? Technologies and their relationship to learning
What shapes what? Technologies and their relationship to learningWhat shapes what? Technologies and their relationship to learning
What shapes what? Technologies and their relationship to learning
 
Technology, determinism and learning: exploring different ways of being digit...
Technology, determinism and learning: exploring different ways of being digit...Technology, determinism and learning: exploring different ways of being digit...
Technology, determinism and learning: exploring different ways of being digit...
 
Myths and promises of blended learning
Myths and promises of blended learningMyths and promises of blended learning
Myths and promises of blended learning
 
Un-defining digital literacies: students' day-to-day engagements with technol...
Un-defining digital literacies: students' day-to-day engagements with technol...Un-defining digital literacies: students' day-to-day engagements with technol...
Un-defining digital literacies: students' day-to-day engagements with technol...
 
Invisible practices and the technologies of the curriculum: Exploring the ena...
Invisible practices and the technologies of the curriculum: Exploring the ena...Invisible practices and the technologies of the curriculum: Exploring the ena...
Invisible practices and the technologies of the curriculum: Exploring the ena...
 
deleteme
deletemedeleteme
deleteme
 
ALBUM DE FOTOS
ALBUM DE FOTOSALBUM DE FOTOS
ALBUM DE FOTOS
 
Quem sou deixa_marca
Quem sou deixa_marcaQuem sou deixa_marca
Quem sou deixa_marca
 
Salvador dali
Salvador daliSalvador dali
Salvador dali
 
T@rget trust business intelligence bi - etl - fundamentos e aplicações
T@rget trust   business intelligence bi - etl - fundamentos e aplicaçõesT@rget trust   business intelligence bi - etl - fundamentos e aplicações
T@rget trust business intelligence bi - etl - fundamentos e aplicações
 
Resultado do Teste Diagnostico Curso web2
Resultado do Teste Diagnostico Curso web2Resultado do Teste Diagnostico Curso web2
Resultado do Teste Diagnostico Curso web2
 
Steve robbins Cultura Cap.18 y 19
Steve robbins Cultura Cap.18 y 19Steve robbins Cultura Cap.18 y 19
Steve robbins Cultura Cap.18 y 19
 
Liderlik videolari
Liderlik videolariLiderlik videolari
Liderlik videolari
 
Cfaes apresentação.
Cfaes apresentação.Cfaes apresentação.
Cfaes apresentação.
 

Similar a Oliver writtle 2010

DS presenation at SSAT Raising Achievement event
DS presenation at SSAT Raising Achievement eventDS presenation at SSAT Raising Achievement event
DS presenation at SSAT Raising Achievement eventDannno
 
Farnoush davis 501 paper revised
Farnoush davis 501 paper revisedFarnoush davis 501 paper revised
Farnoush davis 501 paper revisednoonoosh
 
The pressure to engage with technology enhanced learning
The pressure to engage with technology enhanced learningThe pressure to engage with technology enhanced learning
The pressure to engage with technology enhanced learningTim Goodchild
 
Farnoush davis 501 paper revised
Farnoush davis 501 paper revisedFarnoush davis 501 paper revised
Farnoush davis 501 paper revisednoonoosh
 
Using the technology today, in the classroom today
Using the technology today, in the classroom todayUsing the technology today, in the classroom today
Using the technology today, in the classroom todayDr Lendy Spires
 
Games simssocnets edarcade
Games simssocnets edarcadeGames simssocnets edarcade
Games simssocnets edarcadeRungthip Sae-tae
 
ICT Reflective Practice Essay - Seminar 1
ICT Reflective Practice Essay - Seminar 1ICT Reflective Practice Essay - Seminar 1
ICT Reflective Practice Essay - Seminar 1Miles Berry
 
Immersive Technology Strategies June 2013 E-Newsletter
Immersive Technology Strategies June 2013 E-NewsletterImmersive Technology Strategies June 2013 E-Newsletter
Immersive Technology Strategies June 2013 E-NewsletterDavid Wortley
 
Future learners, future learning spaces
Future learners, future learning spacesFuture learners, future learning spaces
Future learners, future learning spacesDannno
 
Important of technology daisy
Important of technology daisyImportant of technology daisy
Important of technology daisyDianniecuera
 
Important of technology daisy
Important of technology daisyImportant of technology daisy
Important of technology daisyDianniecuera
 
Daisy Marie Cortes Oyao
 Daisy Marie Cortes Oyao Daisy Marie Cortes Oyao
Daisy Marie Cortes OyaoDianniecuera
 
Rethinking the Educational System - the Future of Education
Rethinking the Educational System - the Future of EducationRethinking the Educational System - the Future of Education
Rethinking the Educational System - the Future of EducationThomas Ryberg
 
Technology, Teaching and Learning: From the Frontline
Technology, Teaching and Learning: From the FrontlineTechnology, Teaching and Learning: From the Frontline
Technology, Teaching and Learning: From the FrontlineDavid Peter
 
All Black and Blended: Broken Promises and Serious Challenges
All Black and Blended: Broken Promises and Serious ChallengesAll Black and Blended: Broken Promises and Serious Challenges
All Black and Blended: Broken Promises and Serious ChallengesMark Brown
 
All Changing: The Social Web and the Future of Higher Education
All Changing: The Social Web and the Future of Higher EducationAll Changing: The Social Web and the Future of Higher Education
All Changing: The Social Web and the Future of Higher EducationSteve Wheeler
 

Similar a Oliver writtle 2010 (20)

DS presenation at SSAT Raising Achievement event
DS presenation at SSAT Raising Achievement eventDS presenation at SSAT Raising Achievement event
DS presenation at SSAT Raising Achievement event
 
Stratosphere learning in a connected world
Stratosphere learning in a connected world Stratosphere learning in a connected world
Stratosphere learning in a connected world
 
Learning in a connected world
Learning in a connected worldLearning in a connected world
Learning in a connected world
 
Farnoush davis 501 paper revised
Farnoush davis 501 paper revisedFarnoush davis 501 paper revised
Farnoush davis 501 paper revised
 
The pressure to engage with technology enhanced learning
The pressure to engage with technology enhanced learningThe pressure to engage with technology enhanced learning
The pressure to engage with technology enhanced learning
 
Farnoush davis 501 paper revised
Farnoush davis 501 paper revisedFarnoush davis 501 paper revised
Farnoush davis 501 paper revised
 
Using the technology today, in the classroom today
Using the technology today, in the classroom todayUsing the technology today, in the classroom today
Using the technology today, in the classroom today
 
Games simssocnets edarcade
Games simssocnets edarcadeGames simssocnets edarcade
Games simssocnets edarcade
 
ICT Reflective Practice Essay - Seminar 1
ICT Reflective Practice Essay - Seminar 1ICT Reflective Practice Essay - Seminar 1
ICT Reflective Practice Essay - Seminar 1
 
21st C Schooling Passion Based Hsnf
21st C Schooling Passion Based Hsnf21st C Schooling Passion Based Hsnf
21st C Schooling Passion Based Hsnf
 
Shifts In Learning
Shifts In LearningShifts In Learning
Shifts In Learning
 
Immersive Technology Strategies June 2013 E-Newsletter
Immersive Technology Strategies June 2013 E-NewsletterImmersive Technology Strategies June 2013 E-Newsletter
Immersive Technology Strategies June 2013 E-Newsletter
 
Future learners, future learning spaces
Future learners, future learning spacesFuture learners, future learning spaces
Future learners, future learning spaces
 
Important of technology daisy
Important of technology daisyImportant of technology daisy
Important of technology daisy
 
Important of technology daisy
Important of technology daisyImportant of technology daisy
Important of technology daisy
 
Daisy Marie Cortes Oyao
 Daisy Marie Cortes Oyao Daisy Marie Cortes Oyao
Daisy Marie Cortes Oyao
 
Rethinking the Educational System - the Future of Education
Rethinking the Educational System - the Future of EducationRethinking the Educational System - the Future of Education
Rethinking the Educational System - the Future of Education
 
Technology, Teaching and Learning: From the Frontline
Technology, Teaching and Learning: From the FrontlineTechnology, Teaching and Learning: From the Frontline
Technology, Teaching and Learning: From the Frontline
 
All Black and Blended: Broken Promises and Serious Challenges
All Black and Blended: Broken Promises and Serious ChallengesAll Black and Blended: Broken Promises and Serious Challenges
All Black and Blended: Broken Promises and Serious Challenges
 
All Changing: The Social Web and the Future of Higher Education
All Changing: The Social Web and the Future of Higher EducationAll Changing: The Social Web and the Future of Higher Education
All Changing: The Social Web and the Future of Higher Education
 

Oliver writtle 2010

  • 1. Technology: driver, solution or symptom? Martin Oliver London Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education, & Higher Education Academy
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.

Notas del editor

  1. Conole, G., Smith, J., &White, S. (2007) A critique of the impact of policy and funding. In Conole, G. & Oliver, M. (Eds), Contemporary Perspectives in e-Learning Research , 38-54. London: Routledge.
  2. Bradwell, P. (2009) The edgeless university. London: Demos. Available online: http://www.demos.co.uk/files/Edgeless_University_-_web.pdf
  3. Prensky, M. (2001) Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants, Part II: Do They Really Think Differently? On the Horizon, 9 (6). http://www.marcprensky.com/writing/Prensky%20-%20Digital%20Natives,%20Digital%20Immigrants%20-%20Part2.pdf
  4. Bradwell, P. (2009) The edgeless university. London: Demos. Available online: http://www.demos.co.uk/files/Edgeless_University_-_web.pdf
  5. Standish Allsop & Tompsett paper Latour
  6. Cuban L. (2001) Oversold and Underused: Computers in the Classroom, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Bennett, S.; Maton, K.; Kervin, L. (2008). "The ‘digital natives’ debate: A critical review of the evidence". British Journal of Educational Technology 39 (5): 775–786.
  7. Quote: Bahman Jamshidnejad
  8. Mayes, J T (1995) Learning Technology and Groundhog Day. In Strang W, Simpson V B, Slater D (Eds): 'Hypermedia at Work: Practice and Theory in Higher Education', University of Kent Press, Canterbury.
  9. http://www.blackboard.com/Teaching-Learning/Overview.aspx http://www.blackboard.com/Solutions-by-Market/Overview.aspx URLs last accessed 2 nd June, 2010
  10. Standish, P. (2000) Fetish for Effect. In Blake, N. & Standish, P. (Eds), Enquiries at the Interface: Philosophical problems of online education, 167-186. Oxford: Blackwell.
  11. Price, S., & Oliver, M. (2007). A Framework for Conceptualising the Impact of Technology on Teaching and Learning. Educational Technology & Society , 10 (1), 16-27. http://www.ifets.info/journals/10_1/3.pdf
  12. Oliver, M., Price, P., Boycheva, S., Dugstad Wake, J., Jones, C., Mjelstad, S., Kemp, B., Nikolov, R. and van der Meij, H. (2005) ‘Empirical studies of the impact of technology enhanced learning on roles and practices in higher education’, Kaleidoscope project report D30–03–01-F.
  13. Hammond, N. & Trapp A, (1992) CAL as a Trojan Horse for educational change: the case of psychology, Computers and Education, 19, 87-95. Soloway, E. (1997) Scaffolding Learnings and Addressing Diversity: Technology as the Trojan Mouse In Proceedings of CHI 1996 Sharpe, R., & Oliver, M. (2007). Designing courses for e-learning. In H. Beetham & R. Sharpe(Eds.), Rethinking Pedagogy for a Digital Age: Designing and delivering e-learning (pp. 41–51).London: Routledge.