SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 56
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Information Media for Water Supply and
                                                  From the Editor                                                                                                1
         Environmental Sanitation
                                                  Your Voice                                                                                                    2
            Published by:
   Working Group for Water Supply and             Main Feature
               Sanitation                                    WSS in the Hands of SBY-JK                                                                         3
                Advisor:                                     Portrait of WSS Working in 2006                                                                    8
      Director General for Urban and              Interview
            Rural Development,
        Department of Public Works                           Assistant to the Deputy for Domestic and Small Industry
                                                             Pollution Control, Misitry of Environment                                                          9
            Board of Trustee:
Director of Human Settlement and Housing,         Study
  National Development Planning Agency
            Republic of Indonesia                            Study on Public Funding for WSS Development in Indonesia                                          12
    Director of Environmental Sanitation,         Reportase
              Ministry of Health
  Director of Water Supply Development,                      Guarding Sustainability by Imposing Strict Regulation                                             15
         Department of Public Works               Regulation
     Director of Natural Resources and
Appropriate Technology, Director General on                  Settlement of State Loan by PDAM                                                                  17
  Village and Community Empowerment,
         Department of Home Affairs
                                                  Insight
 Director for Facilitation of Special Planning               Review of Waste Management Indonesia in 2006                                                      19
         Environment Management,
         Department of Home Affairs               Teropong
                                                             ProAir wates Strarts Flowing                                                                      23
             Chief Editor:
             Oswar Mungkasa                                  Chairman of Bappeda of W. Sumba                                                                   25
                                                  Our Guest
            Board of Editor:
       Supriyanto, Johan Susmono,                            Lula Kamal: Social Responsibility                                                                 26
      Indar Parawansa, Poedjastanto
                                                  Innovation
                 Editor:                                     Bio-Toilet, Environmentally Friendly Dry Toilet                                                   28
  Maraita Listyasari, Rewang Budiyana,
   Rheidda Pramudhy, Joko Wartono,                Story
Essy Asiah, Mujiyanto, Andre Kuncoroyekti                    Waste Brings Blessing                                                                             30
           Design/Illustrator:                    Around Plan
              Rudi Kosasih
                                                             Towards Child Friendly School                                                                     32
               Production:                        ISSDP Corner
                Machrudin
                                                             Study on Sanitation Condition in Indonesia                                                        35
              Distribution:                       Around WASPOLA                                                                                               37
              Agus Syuhada
                                                  Around WSS                                                                                                   40
                  Address:                        IATPI Clinic                                                                                                 47
 Jl. Cianjur No. 4, Menteng, Jakarta Pusat
        Phone/Fax.: 62-21-31904113                CD Info                                                                                                      48
            http://www.ampl.or.id
     e-mail: redaksipercik@yahoo.com
                                                  BOOK Info                                                                                                    49
             redaksi@ampl.or.id                   WEBSITE Info                                                                                                 50
           oswar@bappenas.go.id
                                                  Agenda                                                                                                       51
     Unsolicited article or opinion items         WSS Bibliography                                                                                             52
 are welcome. Please send to our address
   or e-mail. Don't forget to be brief and
         accompanied by identity.
                                                          Percik magazine can be accessed through WSS website http://www.ampl.or.id
  This magazine can be accessed at Water
   Supply and Environmental Sanitation           Percik Magazine in December Edition is published on partnership activity between WSS Working Group and Plan Indonesia
       Website at www.apml.or.id
F R O M T H E E D I TO R




W
           ithout fully aware of it we are                                                  inspite of limitations. WSS projects are
           coming into the end of 2006.                                                     beginning to get on the move though
           Several notable events have                                                      they are rated slow. Take a look at
happened during the year. Some were                                                            ProAir in NTT that is beginning to
some successes, some failures and                                                                   wriggle, WSLIC-2 is nearing its
semi failures. Have we provided                                                                        completion, CWSH is clearing
the best service to the communi-                                                                          its way into several other
ty? It might be that we have                                                                                 regions, SANIMAS are
forgotten our task for being                                                                                   being replicated to seve-
too busy thinking about our                                                                                     ral kabupatens/cities,
own rights. We are only                                                                                          and CLTS. Sociali-
thinking of our own fate,                                                                                         zation of the natio-
position, status, interest                                                                                         nal policy for com-
and do not have the                                                                                                 munity based WSS
slightest care to the                                                                                               development       is
community who has for                                                                                               going on in various
nearly 8 years depressed                                                                                           regions though it
in a valley of prolonged                                                                                           still does vover the
crisis. Maybe we have                                                                                             whole country. Ob-
forgotten that we are only                                                                                       viously, one cannot
public servants being paid                                                                                      deny all this just that
by the community and                                                                                          way.
instead we have the heart to                                                                                    Dear readers, in this
become indifferent to them                                                                               end of the year edition
though our incompetence? Let's                                                                        Percik in cooperation with
contemplate and do self introspection.                                                             Plan Indonesia presents Per-
    Dear readers, time is rolling contin-                                                     cik Junior. It is planned that
uously. It never moves back. For us              WSS Working Group Secretariat Staff        this supplement will become regular.
moving forward into the future is              the buraucracies and the community           And in terms of column, we present to
unavoidable. Will we greet the dawn of         either. If any, the quantity does not rep-   new columns namely Our Guest. We
2007 with glory? Or, are we going to           resent the larger entity. It comes locally   have never presented it to you be-
repeat the mistake of the past and             and partially. The cases that have been      fore.Our guest this time is Lula Kamal, a
unable to take lessons from it? Let's          happening time after after time seem to      physician cum celebrity. We hope that
hope for a bright future.                      repeat again this year. Last year            with the appearance of certain public
    In this end of the year, Percik wish to    Lewigajah slid down carrying with it         fugure, Percik's human interest value is
review several subjects related to WSS.        scores of human lives, this year it was      increasing. However, Percik should not
We hope what has happened in this sec-         Bantar Gebang to take the turn. The          be too "heavy" and maintains its con-
tor will become valuable lessons for us        waste hilltop tumbled down burying a         nection with WSS.
to learn. Isn't that we can learn from         number of scavengers then in operation.          Lastly, we hope that the present
both successes and failures? Our suc-          Water shortage hit vast areas in the         Percik in this year end will serve as trig-
cesses may be replicated in 2007, if pos-      country. The same is flood water, pollu-     ger -- borrowing the term used by CLTS-
sible at a higher level. While if we failed,   tion, etc. everything seems to be annual     for us to do better especially in enhanc-
we can move into success by studying           routine                                      ing WSS development. We are antici-
the causes of the failure and avoid them.          In the midst of this gloomy situa-       pating your comment and suggestion
    Speaking in general, the path led by       tion, believe or not, a dot of hopeful ray   for improvement of this magazine in
WSS sector has not made any significant        is visible in the horizon. Several WSS       2007. Have a nice reading.
leap. It is natural because the level of       related activities are continuing in             Best regards.
care has not yet improved, in all levels of




                                               Percik        December 2006                                                          1
Y O U R VO I C E



     Pokmair Experience in                   use, improvement of village income and       have failed to meet PAM DKI target in
         East Lombok                         community welfare.                           bringing down water leakage level. The
                                                                   Lalu Maksum, S.Sos     average leakage is still standing around
                                                    Head of Environmental Management      50 percent. Imagine how much is the burden
    In general, WSS management in Ka-                      Health Agency Kabupaten of
bupaten E.Lombok is run a community                                    E. Lombok, NTB     that must be borne by the consumers.
management team. In this way the                                                          It's heavy and objectionable of course.
community is responsible for the safety        Poor Performance, Tariff Is                     Apparently, privatization does not
                                                 Increased. How Come?                     bring an improvement as expected.
of the facility. In E.Lombok such a team
                                                                                          Especially one that relates to vital public
is called Water Users' Group (Pokmair).
                                                 In the coming January the Provicial      sector. The consumers remain helpless,
The Pokmair concept was introduced in
                                             Government of Jakarta (DKI) will             should the tariff be increased. The com-
1980s and was organized under several
                                             increase water tariff. According to the      munity no has choice. Drinking water
different names: Management, Supervi-
                                             Regulatory Body the tariff is adjusted in    directly from the Ciliwung is unlikely.
sory, Clean Water Maintenance Team
                                             accordance with the contract. The rate            This is the lessons learned from the
(P3SAB). At the moment only 25 per-
                                             will be up by 13-25 percent.                 fact that private sector does not consi-
cent of the initial number is really func-
                                                 From the busines side, i.e to the for-   der the social factor, everything is for
tioning (some 200 plus teams out of an                                                    the sake of business. Consequently, the
                                             eign companies PT Palyja and PT TPJ,
initial number of 830). The teams were                                                    people can not do much. This is a mis-
                                             this is obviously a good news. Their
given a training by the regional govern-                                                  take that must be corrected. Privatiza-
                                             income will jump upwards. But from
ment (Pemda) agency to build their                                                        tion of public property causes damages
                                             the community side, this plan is
capacity in organization, administra-                                                     to the people. Are we aware of this?
                                             extremely objectionable. To cite a fact,
tion, technical aspects and how to                                                             In the future, public property must
                                             up to now the companies are unable to
explore financial source from the com-                                                    be managed by the state. It does not
                                             improve their service. Complains are
munity.                                      heard out from everywhere. How could         mean the property cannot be sold. It
    Several Pokmairs have installed wa-      the tariff be increased?                     may be all right. If it is profitable, the
ter meter to measure water use by the con-       From the news in the media, one can      profit will go back to the public. What
sumers.They are Pokmairs of Ledang           barely say that the companies have           really happen now is the state is stupe-
Nangka of Kecamatan Masbagik, Wana-          made any acceptable performance.             fied, the people being squeezed, while
saba of Kec. Wanasaba, Montong of Kec.       Since the contract was signed in 1998,       the private sector harvests the juice.
Montong Gading, Layar Berkembang of          the two world class water providers                                                Puput
Pijot Village in the Kecamatan Keruak.                                                                                          Bekasi

    To motivate Pokmair performance
the Pemda developed a competitive              Cartoon Percik                                                        created by RUDIKOZ

approach through prizes and awards to
the best performing teams. The win-
ning Pokmair is recommended to follow
similar competition at provincial level.
Pokmair of E. Lombok have won first
place 4 times, second place 3 times and
third place once.
    Some of the advantages of Pokmair
is in building sense of belongingness of
the community members so that the
facility is well maintained, good water
quality, prevention of wasteful water




 2                                           Percik        December 2006
M A I N F E AT U R E




          Last October the SBY-JK administration marked its two years in office.
         What role the administration has played in water supply and enviromental
                    sanitation (WSS) sector? Has it met the expectation
                                And what will be done next?



A
        blue book is in press for publi-   statement that for the rest of his tenure   Action Planning) Project. In this year
        cation by the end of the year.     in office he will be more concretely con-   the National Policy for Community
        This book that is entitled         cerned in development implementation        Based WSS Develepment is implement-
"Struggle to rebuild Indonesia" will       than he was in the earlier period. This     ed in nine provinces, namely W.
serve as a report of SBY-JK administra-    means, during the first two years he was    Sumatra, Bangka Belitung, Banten, C.
tion performance for the two years. As     concentrating more on laying the foun-      Java, West Nusa Tenggara (NTB), S.
for the contents, you must have been       dation, in other words less concrete.       Sulawesi, Gorontalo, and E. Nusa
aware of. There is nothing spectacular                                                 Tenggara (NTT). The last two are new
during this time frame. The reason is,     National Policy                             provinces in joining the project. There
the complexity of problems and chal-          The year 2006 is the third year of       are in total 49 kabupatens/kotas cur-
lenges.                                    WASPOLA-II (Indonesia Water Supply          rently taking part in the project imple-
    This fact is admitted from SBY's       and Sanitation Policy Formulation and       mentation. Compare it with only 28




                                           Percik        December 2006                                                     3
M A I N F E AT U R E



kabupatens/kotas the previous year.                                                                                        SOURCE: MAWARDI

     This year has been a success year for
WASPOLA intervention. This is eviden-
ced from all the participating kabu-
patens/kotas each has had the working
group established. Some even have for-
mulated the strategy plan for their
respective communities. While attend-
ing WASPOLA facilitated training the
Kabupatens showed an excellent parti-
cipation. All of the kabupatens tried
their best to get involved. Approval for
budget commitment for FY 2007 is
noted in one region after the
other. This is perhaps because of
the better involvement of the re-
gional leaders, whether the bupati,
head of Bappeda, or DPRD. Some
of      the regions, particularly the
Kabupatens of Pekalongan, Ke-
bumen and Lebak have even
implemented the policy further                                                                   Drinking water
down to physical construction. The                                                                   In general, the increase of drinking
province of Banten is committed to                       In general, the increase                water service is too very un-significant.
put the policy into implementation
                                                        of drinking water service                Regional Water Supply Company
in FY 2007. All of those indicate                                                                (PDAM) as the responsible company for
that WASPOLA intervention has
                                                          is very un-significant.
                                                                                                 regional provider fails to perform as
been successful in changing the local                     Regional Water Supply
                                                                                                 expected. The level of water quality as
goverment’s paradigm to develop                          Company (PDAM) as the                   mandated by the Letter of Decision of
their region using their own                            responsible company for                  Health Minister No. 907/Men-
resources and capability. Unfortu-                      regional provider fails to               kes/SK/VII/2002 has not been
nately this policy implementation does                    perform as expected.                   achieved.
not spread to the majority of provinces                                                              Insufficient water service is eviden-
in Indonesia. What has been reached is                                                           ced from low service coverage area (only
in less than the third of them. If we                                                            53,4 percent in 2004), high rate of water
count in terms of kabupatens, the pro-            PDAM credit restructuring is being placed.
                                                                                                 loss from leakage (37 percent), and
portion will certainly be much smaller.                Apart from the above fact, this
                                                                                                 management inefficiency. This ineffi-
     In the meantime, the formulation of          national policy has been treading on
                                                                                                 ciency is indicated from expansion of
Institutionally Based WSS Development             bumpy roads. This is because the policy
                                                                                                 management unit at the kabupa-
Policy is stuck somewhere all this year. It       has not been fully disseminated to the
                                                                                                 ten/kota level. In addition, increase of
seems that the draft that was prepared in         line ministries nor even the president
                                                                                                 production cost due to lowering raw
2005 has been kept entirely untouched.            and legislative members. The highest
                                                                                                 water quality from environmental de-
There is no news of its official approval.        recognition it could get is from the eche-
                                                                                                 gradation.
We must admit that it is not easy to issue a      lon 1 officials. Even then, not all of them.
                                                                                                     In such a condition in seral areas,
policy on institutionally based policy after      If it were the overall commitment from
                                                                                                 especially of C. Java PDAM is suffering
everything is already in place.                   all levels of the government the WSS
                                                                                                 from long dry season. Almost 70 per-
     According to one source, it is said that     development may be able to run much
                                                                                                 cent of areas on Java are suffering from
the institutionally based policy will be offi-    faster. This is the challenge that has not
                                                                                                 similar condition. To overcome lack of
cially put into effect after the regulation for   been resolved.




  4                                               Percik         December 2006
M A I N F E AT U R E


water because of this dry season taking      account of the PDAM. This regulation is      construction in 2007. Three others will
into consideration the service to the        revision to the earlier DG Treasury          follow in 2008. Up to the end of 2006
community, the government took the           Regulation No. 43/PB/2006. It is             the project has reached 2,5 users in 35
following steps:                             hoped that with this new regulation it       kabupatens. In 2008 when the project
  1. Construction of 17 underground          could effectively enhance an optimum         is completed the coverage will be 3,5
     water extraction installations.         state loan settlement by PDAM. This in       users. At this moment the project is
  2. Consolidation of raw water con-         essence is a step towards PDAM loan          doing various other activities including
     veyance system connecting Klambu        restructuring.                               completion of undone activities from
     Kudu to Semarang and Service                In this condition the government         the previous phases, pushing harder
     Conveyance of the city of Surabaya.     launched Pansimas (Community Based           hygiene behaviour program, expansion
  3. Construction of 7 dams for raw          Water Supply Provision) Program in           of CLTS approaches beyond 10 kabu-
     water supply in the provinces of        approximately 100 kabupatens/kotas.          patens of the WSLIC-2 projects sites,
     Banten, W. Java, and Aceh.              Through this program it is hoped the         and improving the performance of the
  4. Construction of 18 reservoirs for       service coverage will increase signifi-      constructed facilities. In terms of num-
     raw water supply in the provinces of    cantly and at the same time building         ber the expansion of service coverage is
     W. Java, C. Java, E. Java, C.           community contribution and active par-       insignificant. However, all the efforts
     Kalimantan, E. Kalimantan, S.           ticipation. The program puts it as           are accountable.
     Sulawesi, and Aceh. Digging wells       requirement that the regional govern-
     to extract groundwater is effected in   ment provides a counterpart budget. At       Solid waste
     consideration of the principles of      a glance the program looks like WSLIC-           This year is marked with waste hill
     conjuntive use for isolated areas       2 or we may call it WSLIC-3 with an          tragedy. Last year TPA Leuwigajah of
     and isolated islands of the province    addition of income generating compo-         Bandung slid downhill, this year it was
     of Riau Islands and the Sangihe         nent and division of responsibility          TPA Bantar Gebang that toppled down
     Talaud Islands.                         among involved sectors and Dept.             causing several death tolls. Although
    The government also provides             Public Works instead of Dept. Health is      the number of death was less than the
PDAM a nice present. Last October the        named the leading sector.                    Leuwigajah case, this again is the reflec-
government issued a new regulation on            In the meantime WSLIC-2 Project          tion how poor is waste management in
the guidelines for settlement by PDAM        implementation activities are nearing        Indonesia. In general the waste is
of state loan originating from transfer-     completion.      Four other provinces        dumped just that way day after day
ence of foreign loan, investment fund        namely NTB, E.Java, S.Sumatra, and           without any further treatment. The
account, and regional development            W.Sumatra will finish with the physical      requirement for sanitary landfill is dis-
                                                                                          regarded. Almost all TPAs in Indonesia
                                                                      SOURCE: MUJIYANTO
                                                                                          are of open dumping type.
                                                                                              As a TPA gets into trouble, the
                                                                                          respective Pemda (Regional Govern-
                                                                                          ment) dithers. This was evident in Ban-
                                                                                          dung. Waste hills were developing all
                                                                                          over the place in the city because there
                                                                                          were no alternative TPAs to keep
                                                                                          bussines going on. As we all know fin-
                                                                                          ding a new TPA is never easy. Finally,
                                                                                          after the national government officials
                                                                                          lent their hands, the problem was
                                                                                          momentarily resolved because up to
                                                                                          now a place that meets the requirements
                                                                                          is not found yet.
                                                                                              The effort to reduce waste from its
                                                                                          very origin has not been successful. The
                                                                                          community has not adopted 3R (reduce,
                                                                                          reuse, recycle) principle into daily prac-




                                             Percik       December 2006                                                         5
M A I N F E AT U R E


tice. This is probably because the com-                                                                               SOURCE: MUJIYANTO

munity is still ignorant or because of the
long time habit of collect, transport and
dump practice without any necessity for
the community to get involved. The
campaign towards this direction is
never heard of.
    During the tenure of SBY-JK admi-
nistration the tangible result in this area
has been the procurement of 131 dump
trucks, 111 arm rolls, 8 bulldozers, 267
containers, 4 excavators, 20 garbage
transport trucks. As for disposal sites,
the government builds 15 new TPAs,
and expansion of 2 existing ones. In
addition, an improvement has been             most notorious causes of deaths of chil-     ture for waste water management for
made to 3 old TPAs so that they are now       dren under 5 years old, 46 per 1.000         710.931 people. Similar facilities are bu-
capable of providing service to 3,61 mil-     childbirths, and is ranked first for cau-    ilt in post disaster/conflict areas serving
lion people.                                  ses of infant mortality, 32 per 1.000        904.260 people. In addition the go-
    The community is now waiting for          childbirths. This indicates that govern-     vernment is providing technical assis-
Waste Management Law to become                ment care in this sector in wanting, let     tance and socialization/dissemination
effective. The Draft been forwarded to        alone the level of investment. Whereas,      of wastewater management related pro-
DPR for deliberation and official             investment in this sector can bring eco-     grams
approval. Yet up to now there is no indi-     nomic benefit, indirectly. Economic
cation that the draft is being discussed.     loss from water pollution is estimated at    Drainage
The existence of the law is very impor-       US$4,6 billion a year or approximately           An attention to this sector is perhaps
tant for national level waste manage-         2 percent of Indonesian GDP. Therefore       the least of all. Statistical data on
ment so that waste is clearly positioned      last year the government launched            drainage is difficult to find. Let alone
and an there is umbrella for legal action     Indonesia Sanitation Sector Develop-         what a comprehesive drainage system
accordingly.                                  ment Program. This program is funded         looks like. Drainage system develop-
                                              from grant fund provided by the Dutch        ment is a partial undertaking and is
Wastewater                                    Government and administratively ma-          meant to serve local or casuistical
    Liquid waste problem is no less           naged by Water and Sanitation Program        demand. It is far from being integrated.
complicated than solid waste. This con-       (WSP) of the World Bank. At this time        Up to this time it is not clear whether a
cern is not limited only to industrial        the program is in preparation stage.         drainage system in Indonesia is
wastewater but also to human waste.               Before that the government has           designed to do away with rainwater
The existing regulations are futile in        implemented SANIMAS (Sanitation by           inundation or it also includes draining
bringing down environmental pollution         the community) program. This was             wastewater. In reality a drainage canal
caused by wastewater. With regard sa-         tried directly in 86 sites involving the     is used for everything.
nitation, most of Indonesian popula-          community participation from plan-               It is of no surprise that speaking of
tion, 67,1 percent, has had access to         ning, development, up to maintenance.        drainage development one can only ex-
basic sanitation. However, there are          Through this program which was speci-        plain in terms of bigger ditches such as
only 11 cities in Indonesia that have sa-     fically directed to thickly populated        primary canals. During SBY-JK admi-
nitation network (conventional sewe-          areas, the program has provided service      nistration the government has laid
rage and shallow sewer system) that           to 48 thousand people. Considering the       347.879 m long primary canals to ease
provide service to a small fraction of        success made by the program the go-          inundation of several urban and strate-
urban population, i.e 14,8 percent.           vernment is now replicating it in 100        gically located areas at a total 2.690 ha
    It is not surprising, that the preva-     kabupatens/kotas.                            and inhabited by 595.996 people. In
lence of diarrhoel diseases in Indonesia          Simultaneously, the government is        addition the government also built
is very high. Diarrhoe is the second          also developing facilities and infrastruc-   34.161 m long primary drainage net-




 6                                            Percik        December 2006
M A I N F E AT U R E


works for flat houses inhabited by            effort for the target achievement is a        spearhead in achieving MDGs target.
59.837 people consisting of government        compelling demand.                            Besides, pursuant to PP No. 16 of 2005 on
employess and armed forces servicemen             The basic philosophy underlying           the Development of Drinking Water
in 22 kabupatens/kotas. The govern-           MDG is cooperation between the deve-          Supply System it is clearly stipulated that
ment will take a serious attention only if    loped and developing nations in fighting      by 2008 PDAM has to supply drinkable
a major consequence is to be avoided.         poverty and one of the means is through       water beyond clean water as it stands
                                              expansion of improved water supply            today. Therefore the presence of a definite
Challenges and Agenda for the Fu-             and basic sanitation service coverage.        action plan for producing potable water
ture                                          As time progresses, MDGs are then             quality is absolutely a must.
    Indonesia is one of the countries         translated into mere target figures to            The National Policy for Community
that signs MDG’s agreement. In the            achieve. The expansion of service cover-      Based WSS Development has been
agreement,         particularly       with    age is no more connected to poverty           translated into implementation in 49
regard to water supply and sanitation,        reduction idea. Actually, the expansion       kabupatens/kotas of 9 provinces. An
all nations must reduce by half, in 2015,     of service coverage particularly for the      active involvement of regional govern-
the proportion of population currently        poor is the soul of MDGs. How MDGs            ments has produced positive results.
without access to water supply and basic      could be achieved that at the same time       Some of the results can be seen from the
sanitation facility. For this purpose, all    leads to a gate towards reduction of          increase in number and amount of fund
involved parties, and not only limited to     poor families is our own agenda.              allocated for community based WSS
the government, must contribute in the            The cooperation of developed and          development. It'd take a long time, pro-
target achievement.                           developing nations is the main key to         bably up to 50 years before all kabupa-
    The responsibility for water supply       MDGs target achievement. If we fully          tens/kotas adopt this policy. It would
and sanitation provision has been trans-      realize this then the road map towards        take new breakthrough and commit-
ferred to the regional government. On         achieving MDG targets could serve as a        ment from the national government to
the contrary, the action plan for MDGs        binding cooperation between the deve-         make the national policy a regional pri-
target achievement is echoing more            loped and developing nations. The ab-         ority. At the time when we admit that
loudly at the national level. As of now       sence of such a road map makes us             water and sanitation is human's basic
there is no indication, of significance, on   seemingly working alone without assis-        need, it is but natural if the President
the part of the Pemdas (regional govern-      tance from the developed nations.             were to announce it the top priority.
ments) to take any movement in                Instead of a trigger it becomes a new             Waste management is still engaged
response to MDGs targets. MDGs target         weight in addition to the numerous            to the idea of building more TPAs.
achievement is considered as the na-          other heavy burdens already existing.         Apart from the success made in the
tional task. If this happens then the tar-        PDAM is one of water supply               application of 3R principle in several
gets will never be achieved. A common         providers, and at the same time the           locations, in reality the principle is still
                                                                        SOURCE: MUJIYANTO   more of a discourse than a practice. The
                                                                                            mindset in the realm of waste manage-
                                                                                            ment should have changed from end
                                                                                            pipe approach to reducing production.
                                                                                            Reducing production must be placed as
                                                                                            the main agenda when we speak of
                                                                                            waste management. The government
                                                                                            and the community working together in
                                                                                            reducing waste is prerequsite in waste
                                                                                            problem resolution.
                                                                                                It is a gigantic challenge and a tight
                                                                                            agenda. Probably an advice from a wel-
                                                                                            known figure should be taken in order
                                                                                            to prevent us from frustration, i.e 3R
                                                                                            formula, start from small, start from
                                                                                            oneself, and right now. Let's move.
                                                                                            Why not? OM and MJ




                                              Percik       December 2006                                                            7
M A I N F E AT U R E



     The Portrait of WSS Working
           Group in 2006
I
      n 2006, WSS Working Group has                                                       translated into various activities in-
      focused its activities on the opera-     Public campaign is intended to             cluding Coordination of Development
      tionalization of national policy for      build the stakeholders under-             Strategy of Community Led Total Sani-
community based WSS development                standing, care and involvement             tation (CLTS), Socialization of Law and
including coordinating the national                                                       Regulation related to WSS development
                                                to performance improvement
level implementation, public campaign                                                     and so on.
and capacity improvement of WSS
                                                 of WSS development related                   As it is in 2006 public campaign
development activists.                                      efforts                       plays an important part in achieving
    In the series of activities that were                                                 WSS development target. This cam-
intended to improve multistakeholder         improvement, such as Health Promo-           paign is the translation of the communi-
cooperation, several WSS development         tion Training, CLTS Training, MPA/-          cation stategy developed by WSS
efforts have been successfully brought       PHAST Orientation, WSS Technical             Working Group in order to make the
into close coordination, such as             Training, etc.                               stakeholders pay a bigger attention to
CWSHP, WSLIC-2, ProAir, and CLTS,                Along with the increase in its capaci-   WSS development. Because of its
in order to avoid overlapping of activi-     ty and capability the WSS Working            importance the public campaign will be
ties and that each follows the same          Group is now expanding its activity          intensified in 2007. Besides, continua-
development paradigm, i.e developing         through building cooperation with other      tion of all the activities and communica-
community based WSS facility.                party, i.e Plan Indonesia. Several coo-      tion results obtained in 2006, several
    The other focus is on public cam-        peration programs were developed             innovations to be implemented in
paign. This activity is intended to build    including publication of Percik Junior       2007 that will consist of development of
the stakeholders understanding, care         magazine, preparation of Approprite          communication network with WSS sec-
and involvement to performance im-           Technology Module for Community              tor journalist community, organization
provement of WSS development related         Based Water Supply Provision, Prepa-         of Media Gathering, Lunch Media, in-
efforts. For this purpose WSS Working        ration of Module for Health Promotion        viting various journalist communities
Group launch a series of campaign            for Schoolchildren Hygiene and Sani-         and WSS stakeholders and also con-
though Environmental Exhibition at the       tation, Facilitator Training for Commu-      ducting press tour.
Jakarta Convention Centre, Talk Show         nity Based Sanitation, Resource Centre,          In 2007 the WSS Working Group
at TPI Station, FM Radio 68 MHz,             Publication of a book on "Water Supply       will develop cooperation with other
Website www.ampl.or.id, and other pu-        and Sanitation Development in In-            donor institutions so that the activities
blication media such as poster, leaflet,     donesia: Lessons Learned from Succes-        will be more varied. The activities con-
and e-newsletter.                            ses and Failures," Regional Level MDGs       sist of water supply and environmental
    Through various contraints WSS           Implementation Communication Media           sanitation related multistakeholder net-
Working Group, national as well as           and Water Quality Monitoring.                work development, which represents
regional, considers it necessary to im-                                                   cooperation between WSS Working
prove its capacity through various trai-     Plan for 2007                                Group with Water Supply and Sanita-
ning, technical as well as managerial, in        In broad line the plan for 2007 con-     tion Network (JAS). Then water supply
order to be able to face the challenges.     sists of Coordination in the Implemen-       and sanitation baseline data manage-
Several training activities were held in     tation of National Policy for Community      ment which is the cooperation of WSS
order to meet the demand for such an         Based WSS Development, which is              Working Group with Unicef. (RSD)




 8                                           Percik        December 2006
I N T E RV I E W


   Mohammad Hilmi, Assistant to Deputy for Domestic and Small Business Waste
                  Pollution Control, Ministry of Environment

   There must be a change in paradigm
                                                                     SOURCE: MUJIYANTO
                                                                                           practice. The awareness towards this is
       Waste problem has not been fully resolved.                                          already growing. Next year we will la-
   Since our independence, this problem hasn't been                                        unch pilot projects in several cities who-
   given sufficient attention. Whereas waste mana-                                         se mayors are interested in 3R applicati-
   gement performance is closely related to environ-                                       on. Each city will exercise more than
   mental quality.                                                                         one method. Take for instance Ban-
       Perfuntory waste management can lead to dis-
                                                                                           dung, it practices collect, transport and
   aster. The Bandung case and Leuwigajah is the
                                                                                           dump only. Once the TPA is in trouble,
   most notorious example for careless waste mana-
   gement in Indonesia. How the government sees                                            the whole community gets angry. That's
   the waste management Percik held an interview                                           why there must be composting. If only
   with the Assistant to Deputy for Domestic and Small Industry Waste                      20-30 percent of the whole turns into
   Pollution Control, Ministry of Environment (KLH), who since the end of                  compost, the result is excellent. The
   December was transfered to a new position as the Assistant to the Deputy                rest is converted to energy. The experi-
   for Waste Pollution Cotrol from Manfacturing Industry. The following are                ence in Indonesia seems to be too far
   the excerpt of the interview:                                                           away from it. Too many influencing fac-
                                                                                           tors. The cheapest is composting, and at

W        hat is the domestic waste
         contribution to enviromen-
tal pollution?
                                             quent impact is uncontrolled leachate
                                             flow, unpleasnt smell, swarming flies
                                             and the worst of all is toppling down of
                                                                                           the same time it reduces methane gas
                                                                                           emission. We are still campaigning for
                                                                                           it. And that is quite in conformance
    Domestic waste is divided into two       the hill that may cause death tolls. In       with the Waste Management Law cur-
categories: wastewater and solid waste.      short, it is not well managed. Whereas        rently being deliberated in DPR.
In Indonesia both categories are not suf-    introduction to good waste manage-
ficiently managed. The community still       ment has been given long time ago. The             The campaign you just men-
consider waste material as something to      easiest method is controled landfill. But     tioned, where is it directed? To
be thrown away, the treatment consists       all the same, it is not practised either.     the source or something else?
of collect, transport and dump. There is     Specially with solid waste, we should              It is aimed simultaneously to two di-
no further treatment. Very little, if any.   learn from the disasters that we need         rections. The Pemda that is currently
Most of the waste causes environmental       change our way of thinking. Let's do          practicing collect, transport, dump sho-
pollution. The regional government           away with collect, transport and dump,        uld learn that it is strongly inrecommen-
(Pemda) has only limited capacity to         at least there must be separation from        dable and they should apply other ap-
transport all the waste. BPS record          its very origin, then followed by the next    proaches instead. Say for instance 3R.
mentions that Pemda can only remove          process. The green is processed into          It is expected that the Pemda will issue
40 percent of all the waste to TPA. This     compost. Metal/glass for recycling. All       whatever regulation or ruling to change
means more than half goes any possible       this time the materials are not so valu-      the operation scheme in addition to col-
way. Statistic of 2001 records that more     able because they look dirty. If it is cle-   lect, transport, and dump. At any rate,
than 30 percent is burned. From envi-        aned the value will increase. This            it is the Pemda that is accountable to the
ronmental aspect this is an obvious so-      process has been working in other coun-       public. Therefore a change in mindset
urce of pollution. And the amount is         tries. For instance in Mexico that by         and paradigm is extremely important.
quite significant. The transported porti-    2008 three fourths of her urban com-          The second aim is directed to the com-
on and is mostly dumped in an open           munity will have to separate their was-       munity as the source of waste. They are
area. Dumped from a truck then shovel-       tes. As for us, we have no target yet. We     stimulated to also participate. All this
led to position, that's all. The most fre-   are pushing the Pemdas to put 3R into         time there is the NIMBY (not in my




                                             Percik         December 2006                                                        9
I N T E RV I E W



backyard) syndrome. The mind is set          munity awareness. So the campaign is           of ways such as the packaging techno-
that way. A luxury car belonging to the      two-pronged: one directed to Pemda             logy or being responsible for the packag-
educated passes by, suddenly throws          and the other to the community.                ing in circulation. They take the respo-
away a waste into the street.                                                               sibility to reuse or recycle the packaging.
                                                 What about the companies? Do               That is stipulated in the Draft of Waste
    What is the model of the cam-            you not think they have their sha-             Management Law. In practice of course
paign?                                       re in producing waste?                         we cannot directly uphold in the form of
    It can be done through social cam-           Very good question. In the Draft of        instruction. In ecolabeling for example,
paign. It is accomodated in the Draft of     Waste Management Law there is a sti-           there were only 5 products in the initial
Waste Management Law. In the imple-          pulation called extended procedure res-        design. Once the draft has passed this
mentation the campaign is done as part       ponsibility (EPR). In other countries          we can push harder because the require-
of a pilot project. For domestic scale we    the corporations set targets and claim         ment becomes mandatory.
will combine it with a corporation with      that waste produced from their compa-
CSR program. This program has start-         ny will decrease by 10 percent, for                At this time the Waste Ma-
ed in Surabaya and Jakarta. It works         example. This is the waste produced            nagement Law hasn't taken effect.
nicely. A few hundreds of kelurahans         from its business unit. But there is also      What effort could be taken to
(village level) are doing this. Thus, cam-   waste produced from its packaging. For         endorse it?
paign in this case is not just preparing     instance a company producing bottled               Hopefully the voluntary approach
materials for information, but it is real    water together with its packaging.             through ecolabeling work continuously.
action. This is going to be pushed fur-      Things like that are done voluntarily          The second, through CSR we ask the in-
ther and we will take notes of the pluses    such as ecolabeling on 4 June 2004.            dustries to take a real action. Several in-
and minuses. The community should            The essence is to have the corporations        dustries have started with their pro-
not only be provided with information,       compete with each other in producing           gram. And also the Pemda. The Pemda
but also the garbage bins. The software      environmentally friendly products.             could persuade the community to re-
and hardware at the same time. The           That is voluntary approach. Admittedly         duce the use of plastic bags, for instan-
three apsects must be available at the       this is a more time consuming process.         ce. Several activites we can do while
same time. The role of motivator and         Secondly, imposing a requirement that          waiting for the Law. We push the
cadre is very important because in the       a corporation manufacturing Product X          Pemda to take action from the very
last two years it has been proven that       in packaging it must be environmentally        beginning. Once again, it is not easy to
they could significantly increase com-       friendly. This can be done in a number         change community's mindset, habit, life
                                                                        SOURCE: MUJIYANTO   style. I think in the Adipura program
                                                                                            there is the evaluation for reducing
                                                                                            waste.

                                                                                                Speaking of changing the com-
                                                                                            munity's mindset, it is a process
                                                                                            that takes time. While waste
                                                                                            growth acceleration goes beyond
                                                                                            awareness development. How can
                                                                                            garbage handling be accelerated?
                                                                                                From the experience gathered with-
                                                                                            in the last 6 months, the regional heads
                                                                                            have responded favourably. Some even
                                                                                            have taken the real action. What is nec-
                                                                                            essary is to provide them with technical
                                                                                            assistance. There are already 91 mayors
                                                                                            making contact with us. From that po-
                                                                                            int we are quite optimistic. Through
                                                                                            Pemda's positive movement, we hope
                                                                                            the regional policy is beginning to get




10                                           Percik        December 2006
I N T E RV I E W


                                                                                        SOURCE: MUJIYANTO
tinted with corrective measures at                                                                        There is the upper respiratory
their own initiatives. The com-                                                                           tract, diarrhoea, cholera, and oth-
munity through NGOs and schools                                                                           ers all are related to waste water
also resposd favourably. Maneu-                                                                           pollution. We have had an exten-
vers are taking place in campuses                                                                         sive campaign on this matter in
and schools. Some call it Clean                                                                           order to draw the Pemdas atten-
Development Mechanism (CDM).                                                                              tion. It is now that Adipura is
Many NGOs successfully provide                                                                            beginning to take a look at solid
assistance to Pemda in managing                                                                           waste. Wastewater and waste from
waste. This at the same time is the                                                                       small industries are still over-
spelling out of Kyoto Protocol i.e                                                                        looked. I am earnestly enhancing
reducing greenhouse effect by                                                                             environmentally sustainable city.
managing waste properly. If the                                                                           It is a long way to go. Let's look
Bupati/mayor is in short of money,                                                                        forward. In the beginning it is
financial assistance can be obtained               It is something around 300 - 500 mil-             solid waste. Time will come when we
from CDM mechanism. I think in less                lion in rupiah. This represents an actu-          speak of wastewater and air pollution.
than 5 years the community awareness               al touch for the regions to change their          Finally wastes from small industries.
will be widely spread within the com-              paradigm.
munity.                                                                                                  Speaking of waste from small
                                                       Let's shift to liquid waste. It               industries, how dangerous is it?
    What development program                       looks as if there were no manage-                     Waste produced by small industries
aimed at Pemda regarding TPA ma-                   ment pattern, doesn't it?                         activities, not all of it is dangerous. The
nagement?                                              Actually wastewater problem is current-       most dangerous ones are from leather
    We suggested regional TPA, in addition         ly being dealt with by our colleagues in Cipta    industry, electroplating. In general
to the right sanitary landfill practice. This is   Karya. But we must admit that in terms of         small industries are wasteful in water, in
more efficient so that in the future the num-      priority and how Pemdas or legislative body       energy. This is the most important. If
ber of TPA is getting less but the manage-         at the central as well as regional see it is      they can save up to 20 percent the
ment improves. Take Bandung for instance,          another problem. At the moment our col-           national impact will be quite significant.
it will involve the city of Bandung,               leagues from Bappenas and from Public             Secondly, wastewater and solid waste
Kabupaten Bandung and the city of Cimahi.          Works each have it in their own concept, we       are thrown away. Whereas actually they
The same is for Yogyakarta.                        have none yet. We are focusing more on set-       can be reused and recycled to produce
                                                   ting up the standards. The operational is         something of economic value. The total
    What could be done to enhance                  with Public Works while the general idea is       impact, frankly speaking, we are unable
TPA management from open                           with Basppenas. The three of us are coo-          to inform you, because there is no study
dumping to sanitary landfill?                      perating nicely. In general wastewater ma-        conducted along that line.
    We've introduced them with CDM                 nagement is still very little, the more so in
mechanism. If the Pemda has financial dif-         Jakarta. Some regions are already good, for           What is the fate of Waste
ficulties, there is the compensation. We           example Solo. Simulataneously with solid          Management draft bill?
can help them. Also in Waste Management            waste, we enhance wastewater management               From the technical aspect, we are
Law there is a stipulation about what              but at a lower intensity. I think it is not       already through. The draft is now with the
resposibility each level has to assume,            entirely true to say that nothing has been        DPR (People's Representatives). An en-
national, provincial, and kabupaten/kota.          done, because we already have a legal frame-      dorsement letter from the State Secretary
And there is the Special Allocation Fund           work to protect environment from pollution.       has also been sent to DPR. Let's pray and
(DAK) which used to be for environment,                                                              together enhance the DPR to take a good
now it is for waste management.                        How dangerous is it the liquid                look to the draft. At the same time we are
                                                   waste pollution?                                  also conducting maneuvers towards that
    How much is it in terms of                         There is a study that summarizes the          end. In no way that we neglect our role in
money?                                             real the burden carried on the commu-             enhancing, and the values contained in the
    The amount is reatively small. But             nity's shoulder is quite significant. Per         draft bill have been brought to implemen-
to the regions it could mean a great deal.         year it is more than Rp 40 trillion.              tation. mujiyanto




                                                   Percik          December 2006                                                           11
STUDY



   Study on Public Financing for Water Supply
    and Sanitation Development in Indonesia

T
         his public financing study con-     ces have relatively higher income per ca-          (see Chart 1).
         ducted in post decentralization     pita, it seems they do not feel responsi-              Approximately 50 percent of provin-
         (2003-2005) WSS sector opera-       ble in the provision of WSS service. The           cial and kabupaten WSS budget is
tion and investment is intended to get a     munipalities that participate in WAS-              intended for water supply, while for
better and clearer picture of the deve-      POLA provide the highest per capita                kota water supply is given less in pro-
lopment of funding strategy for this sec-    investment, while the province invest              portion, the bigger share goes to
tor. This study analyses fund allocation     the least amount compared to kabupat-              drainange development. Budget for
by Dept. Health and Dept. Public Works       en and kota.                                       solid waste gets a small proportion in all
at the national level, and to seven pro-         Most regional WSS allocation is                levels of the government, the highest
vinces, two kotas (municipalities), and      intended for physical construction. A              being 5 percent of the total municipal
19 kabupatens that participated in the       small amount is for technical assistance,          budget. Sanitation gets one fifth of the
Water Supply and Sanitation Policy For-      socialization, and capacity improvement            total budget for water supply, but the
mulation and Action Planning (WAS-                                                          Table 1
POLA) Project.                                      Average WSS Budget Allocation and Average Regional Revenue within WASPOLA Project Sites
    This study focuses only on budget
                                                                        Average WSS Budget                  Average Regional Revenue
allocation, and not on expenditure be-
cause there are not enough data to do
                                                                     In Million Rp    Rp per capita      In Million Rp          Rp per capita
so. The composition of sector allocation
is analysed through verification of budg-
                                                   Kabupaten                 1.689            6.162            748.804               475.790
et items with the support documents in
order to determine the validity of activi-
                                                    Province                 3.071              661          2,669.782             1.619.314
ty/expenditure. The allocations are
then classified based on sub-sector acti-      Kota (Municipality)           4.611           30.251            469.379             3.825.743
vity/expenditure: i) Physical; ii) Techni-
cal Assistance; iii) Project Support and
Maintenance; and iv) Socialization of
policy or capacity improvement and                                                                                    Chart 1
correlation of budget allocation within                                                                          Regional Budget
and at the different levels of the govern-
                                                           8%        0%                                         Allocation for WSS

ment and types of activity.
                                                    2%
    1. Budget Trend for WSS Service                                                                        Capital
                                                                                                           Capital
Provision 2003-2005
    1.1 Regional Investment for WSS                                                                        Technical Assistance
                                                                                                           Technical Assistance
    On average the regional investment
for WSS in Indonesia (water supply,
                                                                                                           Project Support and
                                                                                                           Maintenance and
sanitation, solid waste, and drainage
                                                                                                           Project Support
                                                                                                           Maintenance
system) in WASPOLA project sites is
highest in the urban sector and lowest at                                                                  Socialization and
                                                                                                           Socialization and
the provincial level, all in terms of the                                                                  Capacity Improvement
                                                                                                           Capacity Building
amount of fund. In spite of the provin-                                        90%




12                                           Percik            December 2006
STUDY

                                                                                        Table 2.
proportion varies n each level of the                    Sub-Sector Allocation in WASPOLA Location for Year 2003-2004 (in rupiah)
government.
    In the meantime, the correlation of                                 Ministry of Public         Local                 Local as
gross regional domestic product with                                          Works             Government          Percentage of Total
WSS budget allocation indicates a weak
correlation (0,14). Almost no correla-               Water Provision       49.292.425.000        91.008.643.356             65 persen
tion (0,05) between WSS and gross                         Sanitation          925.000.000        20.697.563.605             96 persen
regional domestic product.                              Solid Waste         4.379.282.000         3.660.089.006             46 persen
                                                      Water Channel         1.861.903.000        73.102.575.664             98 persen
    1.2 National Investment                                    Total       56.458.610.000       188.468.871.631             77 persen
    1.2.1 WSS Allocation by Dept.
Public Works
    The budget allocation by Dept Public     far smaller than that of Dept. Public           Conclusion and Recommendation
Works for the regional governments, at       Works.     During the last three years              1. Investment is at the moment be-
national level as well as for WASPOLA        Dept. Health budget allocation for water        low the level required for the govern-
project sites, is mainly for water supply.   supply and sanitation is less than 1 per-       ment to reach the target. On average,
At the national level, sanitation is only    cent from the total allocated by Dept.          the regional allocation for WSS devlop-
provided with approximately 15 percent       Public Works, and Dept. Health is con-          ment is less than 1 percent of the total
of the total Dept. Public Works alloca-      tinuously decreasing during the period          regional revenue and the annual alloca-
tion for water supply and for WASPOLA        of the study. On the other hand, Dept.          tion for this sector is approximately
sites combined. Two thirds of Dept           Health allocation for sanitation exceeds        US$0.40 or approximately US$0.03 of
Public Works allocation is for physical      that of Dept. Public Works. However             per capita GNP.
construction and almost all of the rest is   the larger portion of Dept. Health con-             2. The allocation composition and
for technical assistance, consisting of      tribution for water supply and sanita-          trend indicates an increase by the regio-
sector development for optimum per-          tion is provided by Water Supply for            nal government, but there is potential
formance, detailed technical design, and     Low Income Communities (WSLIC)                  for central government allocation. The
construction related feasibility study.      Project. In general the Dept. Health            shift of investmen sector from central to
    This study also examines the corre-      allocation related to WSLIC "dimi-              regional government has been visible
lation between allocation by Dept. of        nishes" their other allocations, because        within the study area, in which the
Public Works with allocation by the re-      the size of WSLIC related allocation is         regional governments provide 46 to 90
gional government. The relationship is       95 percent of the total Dept. Health sup-       percent of the total subsector activities.
found positive though insignificant          port to WSS sector.                             This indicates the Pemdas' willingness
(0,21). Compared to national allocation                                                      to invest in WSS development. Howe-
for WASPOLA sites, most of the fund for          1.3 Central and Regional Go-                ver, this study also reveals insignificant
this sector, with exception for solid        vernment Support to PDAM                        correlation between regional revenue
waste, has been provided by the the              Of all the Pemdas that participate in       and gross regional domestic product
regional government. The combination         WASPOLA only the province of N.                 with WSS budget allocation.
of the two observations indicates that       Sumatra and kabupaten Gorontalo that                3. The Pemdas are playing an incre-
there is an opportunity for national level   allocate fund for supporting and super-         asingly important role in sector finan-
institutions to take more benefit from       vising PDAM. On the other hand, cen-            cing, but they have a limited fund and
using fund provided by the regional go-      tral government support through Dept.           capacity. Although the pemdas may
vernment.                                    Public Works reaches on average 30              assume a bigger responsibiliy in the sec-
                                             percent during the last three years.            tor, there are only very few resources in-
   1.2.2 WSS Allocation by Dept.             Most of the support is in technical assis-      vested for WSS development and the
Health                                       tance for optimum performance and in            sector funding will continue to be
   Dept. Health provides the second          design preparation.                             restricted in favour of various other in-
biggest allocation for water supply, but                                                     terests.




                                             Percik         December 2006                                                               13
STUDY


    4.    The capacity of sector related                                                    who give strong indication of their pre-
institutions to develop realistic invest-                                                   paredness and responsibility.
ment plans can be improved by various
                                                        It is deemed
simple methods. Based on this study, as            necessary to have a                      Steps in Financial Strategy
well as from regional governments'                    clear division of                         The steps discussed below are de-
feedback it becomes apparent that the              responsibility in the                    signed to get the financial strategy pro-
basic parameter for financial planning             various levels of the                    cess into motion. The key activity must
for the sector is not available, the pa-                                                    be discussed and agreed by GOI and the
                                                        government,
rameter is unknown to them.                                                                 schedule and time frame be decided in
    5. At the national level GOI must fi-
                                                   particularly between                     the discussion.
nalise the process for development stra-             the province and
tegy through a wider scope agreement                 kabupaten/kota.                       Phase 1
(inter-department) on the basic service                                                             Consultation with Basppenas,
and priority reform package for the pur-                                                   Dept Finace, Dept Public Works and
pose of increasing the overall sector                                                      Dept Health on the findings of this
                                              may potentially decrease local capacity
budget and to improve effectiveness.                                                       study.
                                              in maintaining and supporting program
    6. It is deemed necessary to have a                                                            Discussion on formulation of MoU
                                              during implementation.
clear division of responsibility in the va-                                                on minimum sector service and reform
                                                  9.   It is necessary to allocate more
rious levels of the government, particu-                                                   package to be provided under Bappenas
                                              national resources for institutional and
larly between the province and kabupa-                                                     coordination.
                                              regional capacity building in sector
ten/kota. In spite of a relatively bigger                                                          Sharing the study findings with, and
                                              planning and programming.
revenue yet in terms of budget allocati-                                                   collecting inputs from, the Pemdas
                                                  10. Regional expenditure for ma-
on the province is lagging behind. This                                                    (regional governments) on their opinion
                                              intenance and 'software' must be incre-
pattern of funding reflects the confusion                                                  and type of support they expect from the
                                              ased proportionally to guarantee securi-
in what role the province is actually                                                      national government; sharing good prac-
                                              ty and effectiveness of the invested ca-
playing in WSS development.                                                                tices from the Pemdas in sector investment
                                              pital.
    7. The involved institutions must be                                                   and sector strategy development.
                                                  11. Various long term funding me-
given more responsibility to regularly                                                             Development of situation self as-
                                              chanisms must be made available to
submit, accumulate and analyse sector                                                      sessment and strategy direction notes
                                              Pemdas and regional public companies
financing and performance report and a                                                     and processes for Pemdas to be used as
need for resources to                                                                 SOURCE: MUJIYANTO    input for national WSS
support this activity                                                                                      program development.
including random audit.                                                                                          Development of sec-
    8. Provision of na-                                                                                    tor investment plan with
tional fund for WSS                                                                                        financing unit of each pol-
development at this time                                                                                   icy package.
involves a short term
(yearly) implementation                                                                                   Phase 2
period and there is no                                                                                          Simultaneously
assurance if it is avail-                                                                                 with the above matters,
able year after year. Mo-                                                                                 implementation of pha-
reover, except for Spe-                                                                                   se 2 to start with sector
cial Fund Allocation                                                                                      financing review thro-
(DAK) and grant fund,                                                                                     ugh regional public
in Pemdas' opinion as                                                                                     companies and level of
off budget deconcentra-                                                                                   tariff charged to cum-
tion fund. These factors                                                                                  sumers. MJ




14                                            Percik        December 2006
R E P O RTA G E



  ProAir Project at Praibakul - Taramanu NTT
    Guarding Sustainability Through
      Upholding Strict Regulation
                                                                                                                   SOURCE: MUJIYANTO




A
          t last the forty year long dream
          turns into reality. The commu-
          nity of the villages of Praibakul
and Taramanu of the Kecamatan
Wanokaka, W. Sumba, NTT can now
smile with satisfaction. The hardship
they have undergone all this time,
climbing up and down hill to take a pail
of water from a river or water spring, is
now repaid. The aura of happiness is
reflected in their faces.
    "We are very happy," said Kaledi
Dimo of Taramanu. Before this he and
his family used to take water from the
river for their family need. With a pillar
and water taps right in front of his
house, the middle aged man plans to
build a bathroom and toilet.
    The development of the gravitation-
al water supply system has not been an        and to make them also consider how          munity was willing to participate in the
easy thing. "It took time and patience,"      they can maintain the sustainability        project. It took more than one year to
said Soleman Djowa Rega, the                  after the project is completed. The         do that.
Chairman          of     Water      Supply    socialization was also intended to build        By the end of 2004 the community
Management Team 'Bebong Maradang'.            the sense of belongingness so that the      began depositing their money after for-
You can imagine, it took 2,5 years for        facility could last forever in their own    mation of a management team chaired
community preparation. It was so diffi-       hands.                                      by Soleman Djowa Rega, an evangelist
cult to convince the community to par-            Martalanda, village motivator who       of the village of Praibakul. It was com-
ticipate through providing in cash and        lives with the community, revealed that     monly agreed that the community
in kind contribution. This is because         the most difficult part of his job was in   would pay the amount in installments
there were in the past certain villages       convincing the community. "The most         for one year an amount of Rp 70.000
were supplied with water supply facility      difficult is to convince the community      per household. Collection is conducted
without any community participation.          that the 4 percent contribution will be     by team accompanied by village officers
According to Petrus Kanaf, the commu-         saved for O&M costs later on," said the     did not work as expected. Once there
nity still maintains the old way of think-    woman of Sumba origin. The reason is        was almost a bloodshed simply because
ing that without any contribution the         that the community has had never            of misunderstanding when a man mem-
commnity can improve itself.                  before and no similar experience has        ber of the community produced his
    For almost 2,5 years the time was         ever been met.         "The community       machete to threathen a deputy RT chief.
spent for socialization of ProAir project     thought the saving was for the officers's       For 11 months from 12 months
to make the community ready. The pur-         pocket," said Soleman.           Through    planned the fund amounted to Rp 18,3
pose was to change the way of thinking        patience and modesty finally the com-       million from 264 families was collected.




                                              Percik        December 2006                                                      15
R E P O RTA G E



In compliance with the requirement           denied the service. "Any non member              lity. They have formulated a regulation
from ProAir, namely development may          caught taking water from the tap will be         for guarding the sustainability of the
start as soon as the contribution has        fined Rp 500 thousand," said Martinus.           facility that was developed at a cost in
been fully paid, in early 2006 the devel-    For this purpose the members living              excess of Rp 1,6 billion. A socialization
opment started to take place, phase by       near the tap are given the responsibility        programme was launched in the com-
phase. Material procurement was con-         to guard it.                                     munity both to members and non mem-
ducted through tendering, while sup-             For minor damage each household is           bers of the group. The regulation in-
port materials and labour were provided      to contribute Rp 6.000/month. Pay-               volves imposition of fine. Whoever ta-
by the community.                            ment shall be made latest on the third           kes a bath in the pillar shall be fined Rp
    Unpaid labours were provided in vil-     day of each month. Any delay will be             100 thousand. Whoever inflicts any da-
lage, hamlet and zone levels. "Everyone      fined Rp 1.000. Monthly contribution             mage to pipe shall be fined Rp 250 thou-
above 17 years old, man and woman,           will start in January 2007. The month-           sand and shall face tribunal according to
must work together. Except those who         ly contribution will be used to pay for          adat law. The individual who inflict da-
are going to school and are being            minor damage and salary of the mana-             mage to pipe shall additionally be sub-
employed elsewhere," said Martinus           gement team. While the cash saving ac-           ject to adat law, i.e by presenting a offer-
Gali (45) of Praibakul. They gather and      count will be used for major breakdown.          ing consisting of a pig, 8 baskets of
carry rocks, digging soil, constructing          The fact that the water is flowing steadi-   cooked rice, 5 kgs coffee, 10 kgs sugar,
reservoir and water source catchment         ly many who used to refuse to participate        betel leaves and betel nuts each one
structure. Soleman told his story, that      are getting interested. "There are many          sack. "In terms of money everything
for the sake of self reliance, ProAir pro-   who wish to join," said Martinus. But the        will cost Rp 10 million," said Martinus.
hibited rock transport beinng done           requirements are heavier. The manage-            This of course is an extremely big amo-
using motor vehicle. "Finally we carried     ment has made it a requirement that for a        unt of money for villagers who are small
all the rocks," he said. Aboive all,         new member the initial contribution is Rp        farmers during the rainy season and col-
because such highspiritedness, the           250 thousand and maintenance contribu-           lecting rocks during the dry season.
number of workers were more than the         tion Rp 70 thousand and monthly contribu-             The community hopes that through the
requested. "If the project asked for 10      tion Rp 6.000 a month. According to Edi,         strict regulation the constructed facility can
labourers, 40 people came to volun-          there are 16 families are already requesting     be used effectively continuously. They do
teer," said Edy Bili, the secretary of       for membership.                                  not want to see the facility break down in
Bebong Maradang, added the state-                                                             the same way as the previous facilities built
ment.                                        Guarding sustainability                          in the past. "The community has under-
    Through hard work, the community             It seems that the community prepa-           stood that the facility must be maintained
was able to complete the laying of 11,5      ration process has been successful.              because it belongs to them and for their
km. long main conveyance pipe. The           They feel they have a water supply faci-         own good," said Edi. mujiyanto
water is supplied to 1 m high water tap                                                                                    SOURCE: MUJIYANTO
pillars. There are 28 pillars distributed
in 5 zones. Each pillar holds 2 water
taps. The community also protect the
Way Bakul water spring with barbed
wire fence and plant trees around it.
The official dedication of this water sup-
ply facility was made by Vice Bupati of
W. Sumba, Cofrnelis Kodimeta, on 25
November.
    Water has been flowing since last
November. The community has made
use of it, not only for drinking and MCK
but also for watering garden plants.
Even the livestock can drink from the
service. In the meantime, the villagers
who used to refuse to participate are




16                                           Percik          December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006
Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Indonesia Water and Sanitation Highlight 2005. PERCIK. Indonesia Water and Sa...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Highlight 2005. PERCIK. Indonesia Water and Sa...Indonesia Water and Sanitation Highlight 2005. PERCIK. Indonesia Water and Sa...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Highlight 2005. PERCIK. Indonesia Water and Sa...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 4 June 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 4  June 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 4  June 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 4 June 2004Oswar Mungkasa
 
Green School. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. August 2007
Green School. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. August 2007Green School. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. August 2007
Green School. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. August 2007Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 3 February 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 3 February 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 3 February 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 3 February 2004Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. October 2006. When Drought's Gone It...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. October 2006. When Drought's Gone It...Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. October 2006. When Drought's Gone It...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. October 2006. When Drought's Gone It...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 6 October 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 6  October 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 6  October 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 6 October 2004Oswar Mungkasa
 
Achieving MDGs Sanitation Target Through CLTS.Indonesia water and Sanitation ...
Achieving MDGs Sanitation Target Through CLTS.Indonesia water and Sanitation ...Achieving MDGs Sanitation Target Through CLTS.Indonesia water and Sanitation ...
Achieving MDGs Sanitation Target Through CLTS.Indonesia water and Sanitation ...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Small Scale Water Provider. Indonesian Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. ...
Small Scale Water Provider. Indonesian Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. ...Small Scale Water Provider. Indonesian Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. ...
Small Scale Water Provider. Indonesian Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. ...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Los Angeles Rainwater Harvesting Manual
Los Angeles Rainwater Harvesting ManualLos Angeles Rainwater Harvesting Manual
Los Angeles Rainwater Harvesting ManualSotirakou964
 
CA: Bay-Friendly Gardening Guide
CA: Bay-Friendly Gardening GuideCA: Bay-Friendly Gardening Guide
CA: Bay-Friendly Gardening GuideSotirakou964
 
MI: Michigan Technological University: Rain Garden Design and Construction
MI: Michigan Technological University: Rain Garden Design and ConstructionMI: Michigan Technological University: Rain Garden Design and Construction
MI: Michigan Technological University: Rain Garden Design and ConstructionSotirakou964
 
Green Market Press December 2012
Green Market Press December 2012Green Market Press December 2012
Green Market Press December 2012NapervilleNCEC
 
05 sustainable architecture
05 sustainable architecture05 sustainable architecture
05 sustainable architectureMike Hobson
 
National Games Village - Tungabhadra from Waste to Resource (220 Apartments)
National Games Village - Tungabhadra from Waste to Resource (220 Apartments)National Games Village - Tungabhadra from Waste to Resource (220 Apartments)
National Games Village - Tungabhadra from Waste to Resource (220 Apartments)ADDA
 
Advancing resource recovery to the left: how consumer information drives cons...
Advancing resource recovery to the left: how consumer information drives cons...Advancing resource recovery to the left: how consumer information drives cons...
Advancing resource recovery to the left: how consumer information drives cons...U.S. Water Alliance
 
S&C_S12_Team1_Final_Prez
S&C_S12_Team1_Final_PrezS&C_S12_Team1_Final_Prez
S&C_S12_Team1_Final_PrezParsonsDesisLab
 
LA: New Orleans: Bioswales in the Bayou
LA: New Orleans: Bioswales in the BayouLA: New Orleans: Bioswales in the Bayou
LA: New Orleans: Bioswales in the BayouSotirakou964
 
Denpasar Sewerage and Its Contribution to MDG Achievement
Denpasar Sewerage and Its Contribution to MDG Achievement Denpasar Sewerage and Its Contribution to MDG Achievement
Denpasar Sewerage and Its Contribution to MDG Achievement infosanitasi
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Indonesia Water and Sanitation Highlight 2005. PERCIK. Indonesia Water and Sa...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Highlight 2005. PERCIK. Indonesia Water and Sa...Indonesia Water and Sanitation Highlight 2005. PERCIK. Indonesia Water and Sa...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Highlight 2005. PERCIK. Indonesia Water and Sa...
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 4 June 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 4  June 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 4  June 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 4 June 2004
 
Green School. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. August 2007
Green School. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. August 2007Green School. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. August 2007
Green School. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. August 2007
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 3 February 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 3 February 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 3 February 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 3 February 2004
 
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. October 2006. When Drought's Gone It...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. October 2006. When Drought's Gone It...Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. October 2006. When Drought's Gone It...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. October 2006. When Drought's Gone It...
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 6 October 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 6  October 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 6  October 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 6 October 2004
 
Achieving MDGs Sanitation Target Through CLTS.Indonesia water and Sanitation ...
Achieving MDGs Sanitation Target Through CLTS.Indonesia water and Sanitation ...Achieving MDGs Sanitation Target Through CLTS.Indonesia water and Sanitation ...
Achieving MDGs Sanitation Target Through CLTS.Indonesia water and Sanitation ...
 
Small Scale Water Provider. Indonesian Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. ...
Small Scale Water Provider. Indonesian Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. ...Small Scale Water Provider. Indonesian Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. ...
Small Scale Water Provider. Indonesian Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. ...
 
Los Angeles Rainwater Harvesting Manual
Los Angeles Rainwater Harvesting ManualLos Angeles Rainwater Harvesting Manual
Los Angeles Rainwater Harvesting Manual
 
CA: Bay-Friendly Gardening Guide
CA: Bay-Friendly Gardening GuideCA: Bay-Friendly Gardening Guide
CA: Bay-Friendly Gardening Guide
 
MI: Michigan Technological University: Rain Garden Design and Construction
MI: Michigan Technological University: Rain Garden Design and ConstructionMI: Michigan Technological University: Rain Garden Design and Construction
MI: Michigan Technological University: Rain Garden Design and Construction
 
Green Market Press December 2012
Green Market Press December 2012Green Market Press December 2012
Green Market Press December 2012
 
05 sustainable architecture
05 sustainable architecture05 sustainable architecture
05 sustainable architecture
 
National Games Village - Tungabhadra from Waste to Resource (220 Apartments)
National Games Village - Tungabhadra from Waste to Resource (220 Apartments)National Games Village - Tungabhadra from Waste to Resource (220 Apartments)
National Games Village - Tungabhadra from Waste to Resource (220 Apartments)
 
Advancing resource recovery to the left: how consumer information drives cons...
Advancing resource recovery to the left: how consumer information drives cons...Advancing resource recovery to the left: how consumer information drives cons...
Advancing resource recovery to the left: how consumer information drives cons...
 
New Horizons V3 I37
New Horizons V3 I37New Horizons V3 I37
New Horizons V3 I37
 
S&C_S12_Team1_Final_Prez
S&C_S12_Team1_Final_PrezS&C_S12_Team1_Final_Prez
S&C_S12_Team1_Final_Prez
 
Showergy (139)
Showergy (139)Showergy (139)
Showergy (139)
 
LA: New Orleans: Bioswales in the Bayou
LA: New Orleans: Bioswales in the BayouLA: New Orleans: Bioswales in the Bayou
LA: New Orleans: Bioswales in the Bayou
 
Denpasar Sewerage and Its Contribution to MDG Achievement
Denpasar Sewerage and Its Contribution to MDG Achievement Denpasar Sewerage and Its Contribution to MDG Achievement
Denpasar Sewerage and Its Contribution to MDG Achievement
 

Destacado

Percik Yunior Edisi IX Tahun 2009
Percik Yunior Edisi IX Tahun 2009Percik Yunior Edisi IX Tahun 2009
Percik Yunior Edisi IX Tahun 2009Oswar Mungkasa
 
Membuat Pelayanan Bermanfaat bagi Masyarakat Miskin di Indonesia
Membuat Pelayanan Bermanfaat bagi Masyarakat Miskin di IndonesiaMembuat Pelayanan Bermanfaat bagi Masyarakat Miskin di Indonesia
Membuat Pelayanan Bermanfaat bagi Masyarakat Miskin di IndonesiaOswar Mungkasa
 
Menghijaukan lingkungan dan mengolah sampah di rumah
Menghijaukan lingkungan dan mengolah sampah di rumahMenghijaukan lingkungan dan mengolah sampah di rumah
Menghijaukan lingkungan dan mengolah sampah di rumahOswar Mungkasa
 
Percik Yunior Edisi X Tahun 2009
Percik Yunior Edisi X Tahun 2009Percik Yunior Edisi X Tahun 2009
Percik Yunior Edisi X Tahun 2009Oswar Mungkasa
 
Degradation of Ethanolamine by Fluidized-bed Fenton Process
Degradation of Ethanolamine by Fluidized-bed Fenton ProcessDegradation of Ethanolamine by Fluidized-bed Fenton Process
Degradation of Ethanolamine by Fluidized-bed Fenton ProcessOswar Mungkasa
 

Destacado (7)

Percik Yunior Edisi IX Tahun 2009
Percik Yunior Edisi IX Tahun 2009Percik Yunior Edisi IX Tahun 2009
Percik Yunior Edisi IX Tahun 2009
 
Membuat Pelayanan Bermanfaat bagi Masyarakat Miskin di Indonesia
Membuat Pelayanan Bermanfaat bagi Masyarakat Miskin di IndonesiaMembuat Pelayanan Bermanfaat bagi Masyarakat Miskin di Indonesia
Membuat Pelayanan Bermanfaat bagi Masyarakat Miskin di Indonesia
 
Menghijaukan lingkungan dan mengolah sampah di rumah
Menghijaukan lingkungan dan mengolah sampah di rumahMenghijaukan lingkungan dan mengolah sampah di rumah
Menghijaukan lingkungan dan mengolah sampah di rumah
 
Timbulan lindi
Timbulan lindiTimbulan lindi
Timbulan lindi
 
Percik Yunior Edisi X Tahun 2009
Percik Yunior Edisi X Tahun 2009Percik Yunior Edisi X Tahun 2009
Percik Yunior Edisi X Tahun 2009
 
Matinya sikap apatis
Matinya sikap apatisMatinya sikap apatis
Matinya sikap apatis
 
Degradation of Ethanolamine by Fluidized-bed Fenton Process
Degradation of Ethanolamine by Fluidized-bed Fenton ProcessDegradation of Ethanolamine by Fluidized-bed Fenton Process
Degradation of Ethanolamine by Fluidized-bed Fenton Process
 

Similar a Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006

International Year of Sanitation 2008. Indonesia water and Sanitation Magazin...
International Year of Sanitation 2008. Indonesia water and Sanitation Magazin...International Year of Sanitation 2008. Indonesia water and Sanitation Magazin...
International Year of Sanitation 2008. Indonesia water and Sanitation Magazin...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Networking. Indonesia water and Sanitation Mag...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Networking. Indonesia water and Sanitation Mag...Indonesia Water and Sanitation Networking. Indonesia water and Sanitation Mag...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Networking. Indonesia water and Sanitation Mag...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 5 August 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 5  August 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 5  August 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 5 August 2004Oswar Mungkasa
 
National Sanitation Conference 2007. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine....
National Sanitation Conference 2007. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine....National Sanitation Conference 2007. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine....
National Sanitation Conference 2007. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine....Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine 'PERCIK' vol. 8 May 2005
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine 'PERCIK' vol. 8 May 2005Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine 'PERCIK' vol. 8 May 2005
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine 'PERCIK' vol. 8 May 2005Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 7 December 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 7  December 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 7  December 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 7 December 2004Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' 2nd Edition October ...
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' 2nd Edition October ...Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' 2nd Edition October ...
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' 2nd Edition October ...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' First Edition August...
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' First Edition August...Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' First Edition August...
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' First Edition August...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Community-Based Solid Waste Management. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazi...
Community-Based Solid Waste Management. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazi...Community-Based Solid Waste Management. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazi...
Community-Based Solid Waste Management. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazi...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Multi Village Drinking water. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazine. 2nd Ed...
Multi Village Drinking water. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazine. 2nd Ed...Multi Village Drinking water. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazine. 2nd Ed...
Multi Village Drinking water. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazine. 2nd Ed...Oswar Mungkasa
 
ESP Media Round Table Juni 2008
ESP Media Round Table Juni 2008ESP Media Round Table Juni 2008
ESP Media Round Table Juni 2008Oswar Mungkasa
 
PA: Creating Sustainable Community Parks
PA: Creating Sustainable Community ParksPA: Creating Sustainable Community Parks
PA: Creating Sustainable Community ParksSotirakou964
 

Similar a Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006 (14)

International Year of Sanitation 2008. Indonesia water and Sanitation Magazin...
International Year of Sanitation 2008. Indonesia water and Sanitation Magazin...International Year of Sanitation 2008. Indonesia water and Sanitation Magazin...
International Year of Sanitation 2008. Indonesia water and Sanitation Magazin...
 
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Networking. Indonesia water and Sanitation Mag...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Networking. Indonesia water and Sanitation Mag...Indonesia Water and Sanitation Networking. Indonesia water and Sanitation Mag...
Indonesia Water and Sanitation Networking. Indonesia water and Sanitation Mag...
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 5 August 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 5  August 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 5  August 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 5 August 2004
 
National Sanitation Conference 2007. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine....
National Sanitation Conference 2007. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine....National Sanitation Conference 2007. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine....
National Sanitation Conference 2007. Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine....
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine 'PERCIK' vol. 8 May 2005
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine 'PERCIK' vol. 8 May 2005Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine 'PERCIK' vol. 8 May 2005
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine 'PERCIK' vol. 8 May 2005
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 7 December 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 7  December 2004Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 7  December 2004
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' Vol 7 December 2004
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' 2nd Edition October ...
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' 2nd Edition October ...Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' 2nd Edition October ...
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' 2nd Edition October ...
 
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' First Edition August...
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' First Edition August...Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' First Edition August...
Indonesia Water Supply and Sanitation Magazine. 'PERCIK' First Edition August...
 
Community-Based Solid Waste Management. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazi...
Community-Based Solid Waste Management. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazi...Community-Based Solid Waste Management. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazi...
Community-Based Solid Waste Management. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazi...
 
Multi Village Drinking water. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazine. 2nd Ed...
Multi Village Drinking water. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazine. 2nd Ed...Multi Village Drinking water. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazine. 2nd Ed...
Multi Village Drinking water. Indonesia Water and Sanitation magazine. 2nd Ed...
 
Dishaa Vol 2 Issue 3
Dishaa Vol 2 Issue 3Dishaa Vol 2 Issue 3
Dishaa Vol 2 Issue 3
 
Sustainable Agriculture Farming and Land
Sustainable Agriculture Farming and LandSustainable Agriculture Farming and Land
Sustainable Agriculture Farming and Land
 
ESP Media Round Table Juni 2008
ESP Media Round Table Juni 2008ESP Media Round Table Juni 2008
ESP Media Round Table Juni 2008
 
PA: Creating Sustainable Community Parks
PA: Creating Sustainable Community ParksPA: Creating Sustainable Community Parks
PA: Creating Sustainable Community Parks
 

Más de Oswar Mungkasa

Urun Rembuk. Permukiman dan Ketahanan Pangan
Urun Rembuk. Permukiman dan Ketahanan PanganUrun Rembuk. Permukiman dan Ketahanan Pangan
Urun Rembuk. Permukiman dan Ketahanan PanganOswar Mungkasa
 
Merengkuh kota ramah pejalan kaki dan Pesepeda. Pembelajaran Mancanegara dan ...
Merengkuh kota ramah pejalan kaki dan Pesepeda. Pembelajaran Mancanegara dan ...Merengkuh kota ramah pejalan kaki dan Pesepeda. Pembelajaran Mancanegara dan ...
Merengkuh kota ramah pejalan kaki dan Pesepeda. Pembelajaran Mancanegara dan ...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Pengembangan Wilayah Berkelanjutan. Konsep, Pra...
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Pengembangan Wilayah Berkelanjutan. Konsep, Pra...Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Pengembangan Wilayah Berkelanjutan. Konsep, Pra...
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Pengembangan Wilayah Berkelanjutan. Konsep, Pra...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Sudah saatnya mempopulerkan upcycling
Sudah saatnya mempopulerkan upcyclingSudah saatnya mempopulerkan upcycling
Sudah saatnya mempopulerkan upcyclingOswar Mungkasa
 
Green infrastructure in jakarta basic understanding and implementation effort...
Green infrastructure in jakarta basic understanding and implementation effort...Green infrastructure in jakarta basic understanding and implementation effort...
Green infrastructure in jakarta basic understanding and implementation effort...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Desain Kebijakan Publik. Studi Kasus Pelaksanaa...
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Desain Kebijakan Publik. Studi Kasus Pelaksanaa...Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Desain Kebijakan Publik. Studi Kasus Pelaksanaa...
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Desain Kebijakan Publik. Studi Kasus Pelaksanaa...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Fakta, Isu dan SAran Penyempurnaan BP TAPERA
Fakta, Isu dan SAran Penyempurnaan BP TAPERAFakta, Isu dan SAran Penyempurnaan BP TAPERA
Fakta, Isu dan SAran Penyempurnaan BP TAPERAOswar Mungkasa
 
Tata kelola kolaboratif. Menata Kolaborasi Pemangku Kepentingan
Tata kelola kolaboratif. Menata Kolaborasi Pemangku KepentinganTata kelola kolaboratif. Menata Kolaborasi Pemangku Kepentingan
Tata kelola kolaboratif. Menata Kolaborasi Pemangku KepentinganOswar Mungkasa
 
Pedoman kepemimpinan bersama
Pedoman kepemimpinan bersama Pedoman kepemimpinan bersama
Pedoman kepemimpinan bersama Oswar Mungkasa
 
Memudahkan upaya kolaborasi beragam pemangku kepentingan
Memudahkan upaya kolaborasi beragam pemangku kepentinganMemudahkan upaya kolaborasi beragam pemangku kepentingan
Memudahkan upaya kolaborasi beragam pemangku kepentinganOswar Mungkasa
 
MAKALAH. Bekerja dari Rumah (working from home). Menuju Tatanan Baru Era Covi...
MAKALAH. Bekerja dari Rumah (working from home). Menuju Tatanan Baru Era Covi...MAKALAH. Bekerja dari Rumah (working from home). Menuju Tatanan Baru Era Covi...
MAKALAH. Bekerja dari Rumah (working from home). Menuju Tatanan Baru Era Covi...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting/Working from home/WFH). Konsep-Penerapan-Pe...
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting/Working from home/WFH). Konsep-Penerapan-Pe...Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting/Working from home/WFH). Konsep-Penerapan-Pe...
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting/Working from home/WFH). Konsep-Penerapan-Pe...Oswar Mungkasa
 
PRESENTATION. Public Lecture "Jakarta's Response to COVID 19: Strategy-Lesson...
PRESENTATION. Public Lecture "Jakarta's Response to COVID 19: Strategy-Lesson...PRESENTATION. Public Lecture "Jakarta's Response to COVID 19: Strategy-Lesson...
PRESENTATION. Public Lecture "Jakarta's Response to COVID 19: Strategy-Lesson...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting). Konsep, penerapan dan pembelajaran
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting). Konsep, penerapan dan pembelajaranBekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting). Konsep, penerapan dan pembelajaran
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting). Konsep, penerapan dan pembelajaranOswar Mungkasa
 
LAPORAN. Memori Akhir Jabatan Koordinator Pelaksanaan Program Strategi Ketaha...
LAPORAN. Memori Akhir Jabatan Koordinator Pelaksanaan Program Strategi Ketaha...LAPORAN. Memori Akhir Jabatan Koordinator Pelaksanaan Program Strategi Ketaha...
LAPORAN. Memori Akhir Jabatan Koordinator Pelaksanaan Program Strategi Ketaha...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Pelaksana Tugas Deputi Gubernur DKI Jakarta bid...
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Pelaksana Tugas Deputi Gubernur DKI Jakarta bid...Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Pelaksana Tugas Deputi Gubernur DKI Jakarta bid...
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Pelaksana Tugas Deputi Gubernur DKI Jakarta bid...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Kedeputian Gubernur DKI Jakarta bidang Tata Rua...
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Kedeputian Gubernur DKI Jakarta bidang Tata Rua...Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Kedeputian Gubernur DKI Jakarta bidang Tata Rua...
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Kedeputian Gubernur DKI Jakarta bidang Tata Rua...Oswar Mungkasa
 
Presentation. Collaboration Towards A Resilient Jakarta
Presentation. Collaboration Towards A Resilient JakartaPresentation. Collaboration Towards A Resilient Jakarta
Presentation. Collaboration Towards A Resilient JakartaOswar Mungkasa
 
Pengenalan konsep saleh sosial dalam pembangunan sanitasi
Pengenalan konsep saleh sosial dalam pembangunan sanitasiPengenalan konsep saleh sosial dalam pembangunan sanitasi
Pengenalan konsep saleh sosial dalam pembangunan sanitasiOswar Mungkasa
 
Suplemen HUD Magz Edisi 5 /2015. Kota BATAM Menyongsong MEA 2015
Suplemen HUD Magz Edisi 5 /2015. Kota BATAM Menyongsong MEA 2015Suplemen HUD Magz Edisi 5 /2015. Kota BATAM Menyongsong MEA 2015
Suplemen HUD Magz Edisi 5 /2015. Kota BATAM Menyongsong MEA 2015Oswar Mungkasa
 

Más de Oswar Mungkasa (20)

Urun Rembuk. Permukiman dan Ketahanan Pangan
Urun Rembuk. Permukiman dan Ketahanan PanganUrun Rembuk. Permukiman dan Ketahanan Pangan
Urun Rembuk. Permukiman dan Ketahanan Pangan
 
Merengkuh kota ramah pejalan kaki dan Pesepeda. Pembelajaran Mancanegara dan ...
Merengkuh kota ramah pejalan kaki dan Pesepeda. Pembelajaran Mancanegara dan ...Merengkuh kota ramah pejalan kaki dan Pesepeda. Pembelajaran Mancanegara dan ...
Merengkuh kota ramah pejalan kaki dan Pesepeda. Pembelajaran Mancanegara dan ...
 
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Pengembangan Wilayah Berkelanjutan. Konsep, Pra...
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Pengembangan Wilayah Berkelanjutan. Konsep, Pra...Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Pengembangan Wilayah Berkelanjutan. Konsep, Pra...
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Pengembangan Wilayah Berkelanjutan. Konsep, Pra...
 
Sudah saatnya mempopulerkan upcycling
Sudah saatnya mempopulerkan upcyclingSudah saatnya mempopulerkan upcycling
Sudah saatnya mempopulerkan upcycling
 
Green infrastructure in jakarta basic understanding and implementation effort...
Green infrastructure in jakarta basic understanding and implementation effort...Green infrastructure in jakarta basic understanding and implementation effort...
Green infrastructure in jakarta basic understanding and implementation effort...
 
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Desain Kebijakan Publik. Studi Kasus Pelaksanaa...
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Desain Kebijakan Publik. Studi Kasus Pelaksanaa...Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Desain Kebijakan Publik. Studi Kasus Pelaksanaa...
Tata Kelola Kolaboratif dalam Desain Kebijakan Publik. Studi Kasus Pelaksanaa...
 
Fakta, Isu dan SAran Penyempurnaan BP TAPERA
Fakta, Isu dan SAran Penyempurnaan BP TAPERAFakta, Isu dan SAran Penyempurnaan BP TAPERA
Fakta, Isu dan SAran Penyempurnaan BP TAPERA
 
Tata kelola kolaboratif. Menata Kolaborasi Pemangku Kepentingan
Tata kelola kolaboratif. Menata Kolaborasi Pemangku KepentinganTata kelola kolaboratif. Menata Kolaborasi Pemangku Kepentingan
Tata kelola kolaboratif. Menata Kolaborasi Pemangku Kepentingan
 
Pedoman kepemimpinan bersama
Pedoman kepemimpinan bersama Pedoman kepemimpinan bersama
Pedoman kepemimpinan bersama
 
Memudahkan upaya kolaborasi beragam pemangku kepentingan
Memudahkan upaya kolaborasi beragam pemangku kepentinganMemudahkan upaya kolaborasi beragam pemangku kepentingan
Memudahkan upaya kolaborasi beragam pemangku kepentingan
 
MAKALAH. Bekerja dari Rumah (working from home). Menuju Tatanan Baru Era Covi...
MAKALAH. Bekerja dari Rumah (working from home). Menuju Tatanan Baru Era Covi...MAKALAH. Bekerja dari Rumah (working from home). Menuju Tatanan Baru Era Covi...
MAKALAH. Bekerja dari Rumah (working from home). Menuju Tatanan Baru Era Covi...
 
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting/Working from home/WFH). Konsep-Penerapan-Pe...
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting/Working from home/WFH). Konsep-Penerapan-Pe...Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting/Working from home/WFH). Konsep-Penerapan-Pe...
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting/Working from home/WFH). Konsep-Penerapan-Pe...
 
PRESENTATION. Public Lecture "Jakarta's Response to COVID 19: Strategy-Lesson...
PRESENTATION. Public Lecture "Jakarta's Response to COVID 19: Strategy-Lesson...PRESENTATION. Public Lecture "Jakarta's Response to COVID 19: Strategy-Lesson...
PRESENTATION. Public Lecture "Jakarta's Response to COVID 19: Strategy-Lesson...
 
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting). Konsep, penerapan dan pembelajaran
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting). Konsep, penerapan dan pembelajaranBekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting). Konsep, penerapan dan pembelajaran
Bekerja jarak jauh (telecommuting). Konsep, penerapan dan pembelajaran
 
LAPORAN. Memori Akhir Jabatan Koordinator Pelaksanaan Program Strategi Ketaha...
LAPORAN. Memori Akhir Jabatan Koordinator Pelaksanaan Program Strategi Ketaha...LAPORAN. Memori Akhir Jabatan Koordinator Pelaksanaan Program Strategi Ketaha...
LAPORAN. Memori Akhir Jabatan Koordinator Pelaksanaan Program Strategi Ketaha...
 
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Pelaksana Tugas Deputi Gubernur DKI Jakarta bid...
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Pelaksana Tugas Deputi Gubernur DKI Jakarta bid...Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Pelaksana Tugas Deputi Gubernur DKI Jakarta bid...
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Pelaksana Tugas Deputi Gubernur DKI Jakarta bid...
 
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Kedeputian Gubernur DKI Jakarta bidang Tata Rua...
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Kedeputian Gubernur DKI Jakarta bidang Tata Rua...Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Kedeputian Gubernur DKI Jakarta bidang Tata Rua...
Laporan. Pelaksanaan Kegiatan Kedeputian Gubernur DKI Jakarta bidang Tata Rua...
 
Presentation. Collaboration Towards A Resilient Jakarta
Presentation. Collaboration Towards A Resilient JakartaPresentation. Collaboration Towards A Resilient Jakarta
Presentation. Collaboration Towards A Resilient Jakarta
 
Pengenalan konsep saleh sosial dalam pembangunan sanitasi
Pengenalan konsep saleh sosial dalam pembangunan sanitasiPengenalan konsep saleh sosial dalam pembangunan sanitasi
Pengenalan konsep saleh sosial dalam pembangunan sanitasi
 
Suplemen HUD Magz Edisi 5 /2015. Kota BATAM Menyongsong MEA 2015
Suplemen HUD Magz Edisi 5 /2015. Kota BATAM Menyongsong MEA 2015Suplemen HUD Magz Edisi 5 /2015. Kota BATAM Menyongsong MEA 2015
Suplemen HUD Magz Edisi 5 /2015. Kota BATAM Menyongsong MEA 2015
 

Último

The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...Wes McKinney
 
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdfGenerative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdfIngrid Airi González
 
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxPasskey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
Decarbonising Buildings: Making a net-zero built environment a reality
Decarbonising Buildings: Making a net-zero built environment a realityDecarbonising Buildings: Making a net-zero built environment a reality
Decarbonising Buildings: Making a net-zero built environment a realityIES VE
 
Take control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test Suite
Take control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test SuiteTake control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test Suite
Take control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test SuiteDianaGray10
 
Assure Ecommerce and Retail Operations Uptime with ThousandEyes
Assure Ecommerce and Retail Operations Uptime with ThousandEyesAssure Ecommerce and Retail Operations Uptime with ThousandEyes
Assure Ecommerce and Retail Operations Uptime with ThousandEyesThousandEyes
 
Enhancing User Experience - Exploring the Latest Features of Tallyman Axis Lo...
Enhancing User Experience - Exploring the Latest Features of Tallyman Axis Lo...Enhancing User Experience - Exploring the Latest Features of Tallyman Axis Lo...
Enhancing User Experience - Exploring the Latest Features of Tallyman Axis Lo...Scott Andery
 
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24Mark Goldstein
 
From Family Reminiscence to Scholarly Archive .
From Family Reminiscence to Scholarly Archive .From Family Reminiscence to Scholarly Archive .
From Family Reminiscence to Scholarly Archive .Alan Dix
 
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demo
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demoSample pptx for embedding into website for demo
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demoHarshalMandlekar2
 
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptxThe State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
TeamStation AI System Report LATAM IT Salaries 2024
TeamStation AI System Report LATAM IT Salaries 2024TeamStation AI System Report LATAM IT Salaries 2024
TeamStation AI System Report LATAM IT Salaries 2024Lonnie McRorey
 
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platformsDevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platformsSergiu Bodiu
 
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance AuditManual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance AuditSkynet Technologies
 
Merck Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Merck Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxMerck Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Merck Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesHow to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesThousandEyes
 
Unleashing Real-time Insights with ClickHouse_ Navigating the Landscape in 20...
Unleashing Real-time Insights with ClickHouse_ Navigating the Landscape in 20...Unleashing Real-time Insights with ClickHouse_ Navigating the Landscape in 20...
Unleashing Real-time Insights with ClickHouse_ Navigating the Landscape in 20...Alkin Tezuysal
 
Time Series Foundation Models - current state and future directions
Time Series Foundation Models - current state and future directionsTime Series Foundation Models - current state and future directions
Time Series Foundation Models - current state and future directionsNathaniel Shimoni
 
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...panagenda
 
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxDigital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxLoriGlavin3
 

Último (20)

The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
 
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdfGenerative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
 
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxPasskey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
 
Decarbonising Buildings: Making a net-zero built environment a reality
Decarbonising Buildings: Making a net-zero built environment a realityDecarbonising Buildings: Making a net-zero built environment a reality
Decarbonising Buildings: Making a net-zero built environment a reality
 
Take control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test Suite
Take control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test SuiteTake control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test Suite
Take control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test Suite
 
Assure Ecommerce and Retail Operations Uptime with ThousandEyes
Assure Ecommerce and Retail Operations Uptime with ThousandEyesAssure Ecommerce and Retail Operations Uptime with ThousandEyes
Assure Ecommerce and Retail Operations Uptime with ThousandEyes
 
Enhancing User Experience - Exploring the Latest Features of Tallyman Axis Lo...
Enhancing User Experience - Exploring the Latest Features of Tallyman Axis Lo...Enhancing User Experience - Exploring the Latest Features of Tallyman Axis Lo...
Enhancing User Experience - Exploring the Latest Features of Tallyman Axis Lo...
 
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
 
From Family Reminiscence to Scholarly Archive .
From Family Reminiscence to Scholarly Archive .From Family Reminiscence to Scholarly Archive .
From Family Reminiscence to Scholarly Archive .
 
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demo
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demoSample pptx for embedding into website for demo
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demo
 
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptxThe State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
 
TeamStation AI System Report LATAM IT Salaries 2024
TeamStation AI System Report LATAM IT Salaries 2024TeamStation AI System Report LATAM IT Salaries 2024
TeamStation AI System Report LATAM IT Salaries 2024
 
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platformsDevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
 
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance AuditManual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
 
Merck Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Merck Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxMerck Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Merck Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
 
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesHow to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
 
Unleashing Real-time Insights with ClickHouse_ Navigating the Landscape in 20...
Unleashing Real-time Insights with ClickHouse_ Navigating the Landscape in 20...Unleashing Real-time Insights with ClickHouse_ Navigating the Landscape in 20...
Unleashing Real-time Insights with ClickHouse_ Navigating the Landscape in 20...
 
Time Series Foundation Models - current state and future directions
Time Series Foundation Models - current state and future directionsTime Series Foundation Models - current state and future directions
Time Series Foundation Models - current state and future directions
 
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
 
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxDigital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
 

Water and Sanitation in the hands of SBY-JK.Indonesia Water and Sanitation Magazine. December 2006

  • 1.
  • 2. Information Media for Water Supply and From the Editor 1 Environmental Sanitation Your Voice 2 Published by: Working Group for Water Supply and Main Feature Sanitation WSS in the Hands of SBY-JK 3 Advisor: Portrait of WSS Working in 2006 8 Director General for Urban and Interview Rural Development, Department of Public Works Assistant to the Deputy for Domestic and Small Industry Pollution Control, Misitry of Environment 9 Board of Trustee: Director of Human Settlement and Housing, Study National Development Planning Agency Republic of Indonesia Study on Public Funding for WSS Development in Indonesia 12 Director of Environmental Sanitation, Reportase Ministry of Health Director of Water Supply Development, Guarding Sustainability by Imposing Strict Regulation 15 Department of Public Works Regulation Director of Natural Resources and Appropriate Technology, Director General on Settlement of State Loan by PDAM 17 Village and Community Empowerment, Department of Home Affairs Insight Director for Facilitation of Special Planning Review of Waste Management Indonesia in 2006 19 Environment Management, Department of Home Affairs Teropong ProAir wates Strarts Flowing 23 Chief Editor: Oswar Mungkasa Chairman of Bappeda of W. Sumba 25 Our Guest Board of Editor: Supriyanto, Johan Susmono, Lula Kamal: Social Responsibility 26 Indar Parawansa, Poedjastanto Innovation Editor: Bio-Toilet, Environmentally Friendly Dry Toilet 28 Maraita Listyasari, Rewang Budiyana, Rheidda Pramudhy, Joko Wartono, Story Essy Asiah, Mujiyanto, Andre Kuncoroyekti Waste Brings Blessing 30 Design/Illustrator: Around Plan Rudi Kosasih Towards Child Friendly School 32 Production: ISSDP Corner Machrudin Study on Sanitation Condition in Indonesia 35 Distribution: Around WASPOLA 37 Agus Syuhada Around WSS 40 Address: IATPI Clinic 47 Jl. Cianjur No. 4, Menteng, Jakarta Pusat Phone/Fax.: 62-21-31904113 CD Info 48 http://www.ampl.or.id e-mail: redaksipercik@yahoo.com BOOK Info 49 redaksi@ampl.or.id WEBSITE Info 50 oswar@bappenas.go.id Agenda 51 Unsolicited article or opinion items WSS Bibliography 52 are welcome. Please send to our address or e-mail. Don't forget to be brief and accompanied by identity. Percik magazine can be accessed through WSS website http://www.ampl.or.id This magazine can be accessed at Water Supply and Environmental Sanitation Percik Magazine in December Edition is published on partnership activity between WSS Working Group and Plan Indonesia Website at www.apml.or.id
  • 3. F R O M T H E E D I TO R W ithout fully aware of it we are inspite of limitations. WSS projects are coming into the end of 2006. beginning to get on the move though Several notable events have they are rated slow. Take a look at happened during the year. Some were ProAir in NTT that is beginning to some successes, some failures and wriggle, WSLIC-2 is nearing its semi failures. Have we provided completion, CWSH is clearing the best service to the communi- its way into several other ty? It might be that we have regions, SANIMAS are forgotten our task for being being replicated to seve- too busy thinking about our ral kabupatens/cities, own rights. We are only and CLTS. Sociali- thinking of our own fate, zation of the natio- position, status, interest nal policy for com- and do not have the munity based WSS slightest care to the development is community who has for going on in various nearly 8 years depressed regions though it in a valley of prolonged still does vover the crisis. Maybe we have whole country. Ob- forgotten that we are only viously, one cannot public servants being paid deny all this just that by the community and way. instead we have the heart to Dear readers, in this become indifferent to them end of the year edition though our incompetence? Let's Percik in cooperation with contemplate and do self introspection. Plan Indonesia presents Per- Dear readers, time is rolling contin- cik Junior. It is planned that uously. It never moves back. For us WSS Working Group Secretariat Staff this supplement will become regular. moving forward into the future is the buraucracies and the community And in terms of column, we present to unavoidable. Will we greet the dawn of either. If any, the quantity does not rep- new columns namely Our Guest. We 2007 with glory? Or, are we going to resent the larger entity. It comes locally have never presented it to you be- repeat the mistake of the past and and partially. The cases that have been fore.Our guest this time is Lula Kamal, a unable to take lessons from it? Let's happening time after after time seem to physician cum celebrity. We hope that hope for a bright future. repeat again this year. Last year with the appearance of certain public In this end of the year, Percik wish to Lewigajah slid down carrying with it fugure, Percik's human interest value is review several subjects related to WSS. scores of human lives, this year it was increasing. However, Percik should not We hope what has happened in this sec- Bantar Gebang to take the turn. The be too "heavy" and maintains its con- tor will become valuable lessons for us waste hilltop tumbled down burying a nection with WSS. to learn. Isn't that we can learn from number of scavengers then in operation. Lastly, we hope that the present both successes and failures? Our suc- Water shortage hit vast areas in the Percik in this year end will serve as trig- cesses may be replicated in 2007, if pos- country. The same is flood water, pollu- ger -- borrowing the term used by CLTS- sible at a higher level. While if we failed, tion, etc. everything seems to be annual for us to do better especially in enhanc- we can move into success by studying routine ing WSS development. We are antici- the causes of the failure and avoid them. In the midst of this gloomy situa- pating your comment and suggestion Speaking in general, the path led by tion, believe or not, a dot of hopeful ray for improvement of this magazine in WSS sector has not made any significant is visible in the horizon. Several WSS 2007. Have a nice reading. leap. It is natural because the level of related activities are continuing in Best regards. care has not yet improved, in all levels of Percik December 2006 1
  • 4. Y O U R VO I C E Pokmair Experience in use, improvement of village income and have failed to meet PAM DKI target in East Lombok community welfare. bringing down water leakage level. The Lalu Maksum, S.Sos average leakage is still standing around Head of Environmental Management 50 percent. Imagine how much is the burden In general, WSS management in Ka- Health Agency Kabupaten of bupaten E.Lombok is run a community E. Lombok, NTB that must be borne by the consumers. management team. In this way the It's heavy and objectionable of course. community is responsible for the safety Poor Performance, Tariff Is Apparently, privatization does not Increased. How Come? bring an improvement as expected. of the facility. In E.Lombok such a team Especially one that relates to vital public is called Water Users' Group (Pokmair). In the coming January the Provicial sector. The consumers remain helpless, The Pokmair concept was introduced in Government of Jakarta (DKI) will should the tariff be increased. The com- 1980s and was organized under several increase water tariff. According to the munity no has choice. Drinking water different names: Management, Supervi- Regulatory Body the tariff is adjusted in directly from the Ciliwung is unlikely. sory, Clean Water Maintenance Team accordance with the contract. The rate This is the lessons learned from the (P3SAB). At the moment only 25 per- will be up by 13-25 percent. fact that private sector does not consi- cent of the initial number is really func- From the busines side, i.e to the for- der the social factor, everything is for tioning (some 200 plus teams out of an the sake of business. Consequently, the eign companies PT Palyja and PT TPJ, initial number of 830). The teams were people can not do much. This is a mis- this is obviously a good news. Their given a training by the regional govern- take that must be corrected. Privatiza- income will jump upwards. But from ment (Pemda) agency to build their tion of public property causes damages the community side, this plan is capacity in organization, administra- to the people. Are we aware of this? extremely objectionable. To cite a fact, tion, technical aspects and how to In the future, public property must up to now the companies are unable to explore financial source from the com- be managed by the state. It does not improve their service. Complains are munity. heard out from everywhere. How could mean the property cannot be sold. It Several Pokmairs have installed wa- the tariff be increased? may be all right. If it is profitable, the ter meter to measure water use by the con- From the news in the media, one can profit will go back to the public. What sumers.They are Pokmairs of Ledang barely say that the companies have really happen now is the state is stupe- Nangka of Kecamatan Masbagik, Wana- made any acceptable performance. fied, the people being squeezed, while saba of Kec. Wanasaba, Montong of Kec. Since the contract was signed in 1998, the private sector harvests the juice. Montong Gading, Layar Berkembang of the two world class water providers Puput Pijot Village in the Kecamatan Keruak. Bekasi To motivate Pokmair performance the Pemda developed a competitive Cartoon Percik created by RUDIKOZ approach through prizes and awards to the best performing teams. The win- ning Pokmair is recommended to follow similar competition at provincial level. Pokmair of E. Lombok have won first place 4 times, second place 3 times and third place once. Some of the advantages of Pokmair is in building sense of belongingness of the community members so that the facility is well maintained, good water quality, prevention of wasteful water 2 Percik December 2006
  • 5. M A I N F E AT U R E Last October the SBY-JK administration marked its two years in office. What role the administration has played in water supply and enviromental sanitation (WSS) sector? Has it met the expectation And what will be done next? A blue book is in press for publi- statement that for the rest of his tenure Action Planning) Project. In this year cation by the end of the year. in office he will be more concretely con- the National Policy for Community This book that is entitled cerned in development implementation Based WSS Develepment is implement- "Struggle to rebuild Indonesia" will than he was in the earlier period. This ed in nine provinces, namely W. serve as a report of SBY-JK administra- means, during the first two years he was Sumatra, Bangka Belitung, Banten, C. tion performance for the two years. As concentrating more on laying the foun- Java, West Nusa Tenggara (NTB), S. for the contents, you must have been dation, in other words less concrete. Sulawesi, Gorontalo, and E. Nusa aware of. There is nothing spectacular Tenggara (NTT). The last two are new during this time frame. The reason is, National Policy provinces in joining the project. There the complexity of problems and chal- The year 2006 is the third year of are in total 49 kabupatens/kotas cur- lenges. WASPOLA-II (Indonesia Water Supply rently taking part in the project imple- This fact is admitted from SBY's and Sanitation Policy Formulation and mentation. Compare it with only 28 Percik December 2006 3
  • 6. M A I N F E AT U R E kabupatens/kotas the previous year. SOURCE: MAWARDI This year has been a success year for WASPOLA intervention. This is eviden- ced from all the participating kabu- patens/kotas each has had the working group established. Some even have for- mulated the strategy plan for their respective communities. While attend- ing WASPOLA facilitated training the Kabupatens showed an excellent parti- cipation. All of the kabupatens tried their best to get involved. Approval for budget commitment for FY 2007 is noted in one region after the other. This is perhaps because of the better involvement of the re- gional leaders, whether the bupati, head of Bappeda, or DPRD. Some of the regions, particularly the Kabupatens of Pekalongan, Ke- bumen and Lebak have even implemented the policy further Drinking water down to physical construction. The In general, the increase of drinking province of Banten is committed to In general, the increase water service is too very un-significant. put the policy into implementation of drinking water service Regional Water Supply Company in FY 2007. All of those indicate (PDAM) as the responsible company for that WASPOLA intervention has is very un-significant. regional provider fails to perform as been successful in changing the local Regional Water Supply expected. The level of water quality as goverment’s paradigm to develop Company (PDAM) as the mandated by the Letter of Decision of their region using their own responsible company for Health Minister No. 907/Men- resources and capability. Unfortu- regional provider fails to kes/SK/VII/2002 has not been nately this policy implementation does perform as expected. achieved. not spread to the majority of provinces Insufficient water service is eviden- in Indonesia. What has been reached is ced from low service coverage area (only in less than the third of them. If we 53,4 percent in 2004), high rate of water count in terms of kabupatens, the pro- PDAM credit restructuring is being placed. loss from leakage (37 percent), and portion will certainly be much smaller. Apart from the above fact, this management inefficiency. This ineffi- In the meantime, the formulation of national policy has been treading on ciency is indicated from expansion of Institutionally Based WSS Development bumpy roads. This is because the policy management unit at the kabupa- Policy is stuck somewhere all this year. It has not been fully disseminated to the ten/kota level. In addition, increase of seems that the draft that was prepared in line ministries nor even the president production cost due to lowering raw 2005 has been kept entirely untouched. and legislative members. The highest water quality from environmental de- There is no news of its official approval. recognition it could get is from the eche- gradation. We must admit that it is not easy to issue a lon 1 officials. Even then, not all of them. In such a condition in seral areas, policy on institutionally based policy after If it were the overall commitment from especially of C. Java PDAM is suffering everything is already in place. all levels of the government the WSS from long dry season. Almost 70 per- According to one source, it is said that development may be able to run much cent of areas on Java are suffering from the institutionally based policy will be offi- faster. This is the challenge that has not similar condition. To overcome lack of cially put into effect after the regulation for been resolved. 4 Percik December 2006
  • 7. M A I N F E AT U R E water because of this dry season taking account of the PDAM. This regulation is construction in 2007. Three others will into consideration the service to the revision to the earlier DG Treasury follow in 2008. Up to the end of 2006 community, the government took the Regulation No. 43/PB/2006. It is the project has reached 2,5 users in 35 following steps: hoped that with this new regulation it kabupatens. In 2008 when the project 1. Construction of 17 underground could effectively enhance an optimum is completed the coverage will be 3,5 water extraction installations. state loan settlement by PDAM. This in users. At this moment the project is 2. Consolidation of raw water con- essence is a step towards PDAM loan doing various other activities including veyance system connecting Klambu restructuring. completion of undone activities from Kudu to Semarang and Service In this condition the government the previous phases, pushing harder Conveyance of the city of Surabaya. launched Pansimas (Community Based hygiene behaviour program, expansion 3. Construction of 7 dams for raw Water Supply Provision) Program in of CLTS approaches beyond 10 kabu- water supply in the provinces of approximately 100 kabupatens/kotas. patens of the WSLIC-2 projects sites, Banten, W. Java, and Aceh. Through this program it is hoped the and improving the performance of the 4. Construction of 18 reservoirs for service coverage will increase signifi- constructed facilities. In terms of num- raw water supply in the provinces of cantly and at the same time building ber the expansion of service coverage is W. Java, C. Java, E. Java, C. community contribution and active par- insignificant. However, all the efforts Kalimantan, E. Kalimantan, S. ticipation. The program puts it as are accountable. Sulawesi, and Aceh. Digging wells requirement that the regional govern- to extract groundwater is effected in ment provides a counterpart budget. At Solid waste consideration of the principles of a glance the program looks like WSLIC- This year is marked with waste hill conjuntive use for isolated areas 2 or we may call it WSLIC-3 with an tragedy. Last year TPA Leuwigajah of and isolated islands of the province addition of income generating compo- Bandung slid downhill, this year it was of Riau Islands and the Sangihe nent and division of responsibility TPA Bantar Gebang that toppled down Talaud Islands. among involved sectors and Dept. causing several death tolls. Although The government also provides Public Works instead of Dept. Health is the number of death was less than the PDAM a nice present. Last October the named the leading sector. Leuwigajah case, this again is the reflec- government issued a new regulation on In the meantime WSLIC-2 Project tion how poor is waste management in the guidelines for settlement by PDAM implementation activities are nearing Indonesia. In general the waste is of state loan originating from transfer- completion. Four other provinces dumped just that way day after day ence of foreign loan, investment fund namely NTB, E.Java, S.Sumatra, and without any further treatment. The account, and regional development W.Sumatra will finish with the physical requirement for sanitary landfill is dis- regarded. Almost all TPAs in Indonesia SOURCE: MUJIYANTO are of open dumping type. As a TPA gets into trouble, the respective Pemda (Regional Govern- ment) dithers. This was evident in Ban- dung. Waste hills were developing all over the place in the city because there were no alternative TPAs to keep bussines going on. As we all know fin- ding a new TPA is never easy. Finally, after the national government officials lent their hands, the problem was momentarily resolved because up to now a place that meets the requirements is not found yet. The effort to reduce waste from its very origin has not been successful. The community has not adopted 3R (reduce, reuse, recycle) principle into daily prac- Percik December 2006 5
  • 8. M A I N F E AT U R E tice. This is probably because the com- SOURCE: MUJIYANTO munity is still ignorant or because of the long time habit of collect, transport and dump practice without any necessity for the community to get involved. The campaign towards this direction is never heard of. During the tenure of SBY-JK admi- nistration the tangible result in this area has been the procurement of 131 dump trucks, 111 arm rolls, 8 bulldozers, 267 containers, 4 excavators, 20 garbage transport trucks. As for disposal sites, the government builds 15 new TPAs, and expansion of 2 existing ones. In addition, an improvement has been most notorious causes of deaths of chil- ture for waste water management for made to 3 old TPAs so that they are now dren under 5 years old, 46 per 1.000 710.931 people. Similar facilities are bu- capable of providing service to 3,61 mil- childbirths, and is ranked first for cau- ilt in post disaster/conflict areas serving lion people. ses of infant mortality, 32 per 1.000 904.260 people. In addition the go- The community is now waiting for childbirths. This indicates that govern- vernment is providing technical assis- Waste Management Law to become ment care in this sector in wanting, let tance and socialization/dissemination effective. The Draft been forwarded to alone the level of investment. Whereas, of wastewater management related pro- DPR for deliberation and official investment in this sector can bring eco- grams approval. Yet up to now there is no indi- nomic benefit, indirectly. Economic cation that the draft is being discussed. loss from water pollution is estimated at Drainage The existence of the law is very impor- US$4,6 billion a year or approximately An attention to this sector is perhaps tant for national level waste manage- 2 percent of Indonesian GDP. Therefore the least of all. Statistical data on ment so that waste is clearly positioned last year the government launched drainage is difficult to find. Let alone and an there is umbrella for legal action Indonesia Sanitation Sector Develop- what a comprehesive drainage system accordingly. ment Program. This program is funded looks like. Drainage system develop- from grant fund provided by the Dutch ment is a partial undertaking and is Wastewater Government and administratively ma- meant to serve local or casuistical Liquid waste problem is no less naged by Water and Sanitation Program demand. It is far from being integrated. complicated than solid waste. This con- (WSP) of the World Bank. At this time Up to this time it is not clear whether a cern is not limited only to industrial the program is in preparation stage. drainage system in Indonesia is wastewater but also to human waste. Before that the government has designed to do away with rainwater The existing regulations are futile in implemented SANIMAS (Sanitation by inundation or it also includes draining bringing down environmental pollution the community) program. This was wastewater. In reality a drainage canal caused by wastewater. With regard sa- tried directly in 86 sites involving the is used for everything. nitation, most of Indonesian popula- community participation from plan- It is of no surprise that speaking of tion, 67,1 percent, has had access to ning, development, up to maintenance. drainage development one can only ex- basic sanitation. However, there are Through this program which was speci- plain in terms of bigger ditches such as only 11 cities in Indonesia that have sa- fically directed to thickly populated primary canals. During SBY-JK admi- nitation network (conventional sewe- areas, the program has provided service nistration the government has laid rage and shallow sewer system) that to 48 thousand people. Considering the 347.879 m long primary canals to ease provide service to a small fraction of success made by the program the go- inundation of several urban and strate- urban population, i.e 14,8 percent. vernment is now replicating it in 100 gically located areas at a total 2.690 ha It is not surprising, that the preva- kabupatens/kotas. and inhabited by 595.996 people. In lence of diarrhoel diseases in Indonesia Simultaneously, the government is addition the government also built is very high. Diarrhoe is the second also developing facilities and infrastruc- 34.161 m long primary drainage net- 6 Percik December 2006
  • 9. M A I N F E AT U R E works for flat houses inhabited by effort for the target achievement is a spearhead in achieving MDGs target. 59.837 people consisting of government compelling demand. Besides, pursuant to PP No. 16 of 2005 on employess and armed forces servicemen The basic philosophy underlying the Development of Drinking Water in 22 kabupatens/kotas. The govern- MDG is cooperation between the deve- Supply System it is clearly stipulated that ment will take a serious attention only if loped and developing nations in fighting by 2008 PDAM has to supply drinkable a major consequence is to be avoided. poverty and one of the means is through water beyond clean water as it stands expansion of improved water supply today. Therefore the presence of a definite Challenges and Agenda for the Fu- and basic sanitation service coverage. action plan for producing potable water ture As time progresses, MDGs are then quality is absolutely a must. Indonesia is one of the countries translated into mere target figures to The National Policy for Community that signs MDG’s agreement. In the achieve. The expansion of service cover- Based WSS Development has been agreement, particularly with age is no more connected to poverty translated into implementation in 49 regard to water supply and sanitation, reduction idea. Actually, the expansion kabupatens/kotas of 9 provinces. An all nations must reduce by half, in 2015, of service coverage particularly for the active involvement of regional govern- the proportion of population currently poor is the soul of MDGs. How MDGs ments has produced positive results. without access to water supply and basic could be achieved that at the same time Some of the results can be seen from the sanitation facility. For this purpose, all leads to a gate towards reduction of increase in number and amount of fund involved parties, and not only limited to poor families is our own agenda. allocated for community based WSS the government, must contribute in the The cooperation of developed and development. It'd take a long time, pro- target achievement. developing nations is the main key to bably up to 50 years before all kabupa- The responsibility for water supply MDGs target achievement. If we fully tens/kotas adopt this policy. It would and sanitation provision has been trans- realize this then the road map towards take new breakthrough and commit- ferred to the regional government. On achieving MDG targets could serve as a ment from the national government to the contrary, the action plan for MDGs binding cooperation between the deve- make the national policy a regional pri- target achievement is echoing more loped and developing nations. The ab- ority. At the time when we admit that loudly at the national level. As of now sence of such a road map makes us water and sanitation is human's basic there is no indication, of significance, on seemingly working alone without assis- need, it is but natural if the President the part of the Pemdas (regional govern- tance from the developed nations. were to announce it the top priority. ments) to take any movement in Instead of a trigger it becomes a new Waste management is still engaged response to MDGs targets. MDGs target weight in addition to the numerous to the idea of building more TPAs. achievement is considered as the na- other heavy burdens already existing. Apart from the success made in the tional task. If this happens then the tar- PDAM is one of water supply application of 3R principle in several gets will never be achieved. A common providers, and at the same time the locations, in reality the principle is still SOURCE: MUJIYANTO more of a discourse than a practice. The mindset in the realm of waste manage- ment should have changed from end pipe approach to reducing production. Reducing production must be placed as the main agenda when we speak of waste management. The government and the community working together in reducing waste is prerequsite in waste problem resolution. It is a gigantic challenge and a tight agenda. Probably an advice from a wel- known figure should be taken in order to prevent us from frustration, i.e 3R formula, start from small, start from oneself, and right now. Let's move. Why not? OM and MJ Percik December 2006 7
  • 10. M A I N F E AT U R E The Portrait of WSS Working Group in 2006 I n 2006, WSS Working Group has translated into various activities in- focused its activities on the opera- Public campaign is intended to cluding Coordination of Development tionalization of national policy for build the stakeholders under- Strategy of Community Led Total Sani- community based WSS development standing, care and involvement tation (CLTS), Socialization of Law and including coordinating the national Regulation related to WSS development to performance improvement level implementation, public campaign and so on. and capacity improvement of WSS of WSS development related As it is in 2006 public campaign development activists. efforts plays an important part in achieving In the series of activities that were WSS development target. This cam- intended to improve multistakeholder improvement, such as Health Promo- paign is the translation of the communi- cooperation, several WSS development tion Training, CLTS Training, MPA/- cation stategy developed by WSS efforts have been successfully brought PHAST Orientation, WSS Technical Working Group in order to make the into close coordination, such as Training, etc. stakeholders pay a bigger attention to CWSHP, WSLIC-2, ProAir, and CLTS, Along with the increase in its capaci- WSS development. Because of its in order to avoid overlapping of activi- ty and capability the WSS Working importance the public campaign will be ties and that each follows the same Group is now expanding its activity intensified in 2007. Besides, continua- development paradigm, i.e developing through building cooperation with other tion of all the activities and communica- community based WSS facility. party, i.e Plan Indonesia. Several coo- tion results obtained in 2006, several The other focus is on public cam- peration programs were developed innovations to be implemented in paign. This activity is intended to build including publication of Percik Junior 2007 that will consist of development of the stakeholders understanding, care magazine, preparation of Approprite communication network with WSS sec- and involvement to performance im- Technology Module for Community tor journalist community, organization provement of WSS development related Based Water Supply Provision, Prepa- of Media Gathering, Lunch Media, in- efforts. For this purpose WSS Working ration of Module for Health Promotion viting various journalist communities Group launch a series of campaign for Schoolchildren Hygiene and Sani- and WSS stakeholders and also con- though Environmental Exhibition at the tation, Facilitator Training for Commu- ducting press tour. Jakarta Convention Centre, Talk Show nity Based Sanitation, Resource Centre, In 2007 the WSS Working Group at TPI Station, FM Radio 68 MHz, Publication of a book on "Water Supply will develop cooperation with other Website www.ampl.or.id, and other pu- and Sanitation Development in In- donor institutions so that the activities blication media such as poster, leaflet, donesia: Lessons Learned from Succes- will be more varied. The activities con- and e-newsletter. ses and Failures," Regional Level MDGs sist of water supply and environmental Through various contraints WSS Implementation Communication Media sanitation related multistakeholder net- Working Group, national as well as and Water Quality Monitoring. work development, which represents regional, considers it necessary to im- cooperation between WSS Working prove its capacity through various trai- Plan for 2007 Group with Water Supply and Sanita- ning, technical as well as managerial, in In broad line the plan for 2007 con- tion Network (JAS). Then water supply order to be able to face the challenges. sists of Coordination in the Implemen- and sanitation baseline data manage- Several training activities were held in tation of National Policy for Community ment which is the cooperation of WSS order to meet the demand for such an Based WSS Development, which is Working Group with Unicef. (RSD) 8 Percik December 2006
  • 11. I N T E RV I E W Mohammad Hilmi, Assistant to Deputy for Domestic and Small Business Waste Pollution Control, Ministry of Environment There must be a change in paradigm SOURCE: MUJIYANTO practice. The awareness towards this is Waste problem has not been fully resolved. already growing. Next year we will la- Since our independence, this problem hasn't been unch pilot projects in several cities who- given sufficient attention. Whereas waste mana- se mayors are interested in 3R applicati- gement performance is closely related to environ- on. Each city will exercise more than mental quality. one method. Take for instance Ban- Perfuntory waste management can lead to dis- dung, it practices collect, transport and aster. The Bandung case and Leuwigajah is the dump only. Once the TPA is in trouble, most notorious example for careless waste mana- gement in Indonesia. How the government sees the whole community gets angry. That's the waste management Percik held an interview why there must be composting. If only with the Assistant to Deputy for Domestic and Small Industry Waste 20-30 percent of the whole turns into Pollution Control, Ministry of Environment (KLH), who since the end of compost, the result is excellent. The December was transfered to a new position as the Assistant to the Deputy rest is converted to energy. The experi- for Waste Pollution Cotrol from Manfacturing Industry. The following are ence in Indonesia seems to be too far the excerpt of the interview: away from it. Too many influencing fac- tors. The cheapest is composting, and at W hat is the domestic waste contribution to enviromen- tal pollution? quent impact is uncontrolled leachate flow, unpleasnt smell, swarming flies and the worst of all is toppling down of the same time it reduces methane gas emission. We are still campaigning for it. And that is quite in conformance Domestic waste is divided into two the hill that may cause death tolls. In with the Waste Management Law cur- categories: wastewater and solid waste. short, it is not well managed. Whereas rently being deliberated in DPR. In Indonesia both categories are not suf- introduction to good waste manage- ficiently managed. The community still ment has been given long time ago. The The campaign you just men- consider waste material as something to easiest method is controled landfill. But tioned, where is it directed? To be thrown away, the treatment consists all the same, it is not practised either. the source or something else? of collect, transport and dump. There is Specially with solid waste, we should It is aimed simultaneously to two di- no further treatment. Very little, if any. learn from the disasters that we need rections. The Pemda that is currently Most of the waste causes environmental change our way of thinking. Let's do practicing collect, transport, dump sho- pollution. The regional government away with collect, transport and dump, uld learn that it is strongly inrecommen- (Pemda) has only limited capacity to at least there must be separation from dable and they should apply other ap- transport all the waste. BPS record its very origin, then followed by the next proaches instead. Say for instance 3R. mentions that Pemda can only remove process. The green is processed into It is expected that the Pemda will issue 40 percent of all the waste to TPA. This compost. Metal/glass for recycling. All whatever regulation or ruling to change means more than half goes any possible this time the materials are not so valu- the operation scheme in addition to col- way. Statistic of 2001 records that more able because they look dirty. If it is cle- lect, transport, and dump. At any rate, than 30 percent is burned. From envi- aned the value will increase. This it is the Pemda that is accountable to the ronmental aspect this is an obvious so- process has been working in other coun- public. Therefore a change in mindset urce of pollution. And the amount is tries. For instance in Mexico that by and paradigm is extremely important. quite significant. The transported porti- 2008 three fourths of her urban com- The second aim is directed to the com- on and is mostly dumped in an open munity will have to separate their was- munity as the source of waste. They are area. Dumped from a truck then shovel- tes. As for us, we have no target yet. We stimulated to also participate. All this led to position, that's all. The most fre- are pushing the Pemdas to put 3R into time there is the NIMBY (not in my Percik December 2006 9
  • 12. I N T E RV I E W backyard) syndrome. The mind is set munity awareness. So the campaign is of ways such as the packaging techno- that way. A luxury car belonging to the two-pronged: one directed to Pemda logy or being responsible for the packag- educated passes by, suddenly throws and the other to the community. ing in circulation. They take the respo- away a waste into the street. sibility to reuse or recycle the packaging. What about the companies? Do That is stipulated in the Draft of Waste What is the model of the cam- you not think they have their sha- Management Law. In practice of course paign? re in producing waste? we cannot directly uphold in the form of It can be done through social cam- Very good question. In the Draft of instruction. In ecolabeling for example, paign. It is accomodated in the Draft of Waste Management Law there is a sti- there were only 5 products in the initial Waste Management Law. In the imple- pulation called extended procedure res- design. Once the draft has passed this mentation the campaign is done as part ponsibility (EPR). In other countries we can push harder because the require- of a pilot project. For domestic scale we the corporations set targets and claim ment becomes mandatory. will combine it with a corporation with that waste produced from their compa- CSR program. This program has start- ny will decrease by 10 percent, for At this time the Waste Ma- ed in Surabaya and Jakarta. It works example. This is the waste produced nagement Law hasn't taken effect. nicely. A few hundreds of kelurahans from its business unit. But there is also What effort could be taken to (village level) are doing this. Thus, cam- waste produced from its packaging. For endorse it? paign in this case is not just preparing instance a company producing bottled Hopefully the voluntary approach materials for information, but it is real water together with its packaging. through ecolabeling work continuously. action. This is going to be pushed fur- Things like that are done voluntarily The second, through CSR we ask the in- ther and we will take notes of the pluses such as ecolabeling on 4 June 2004. dustries to take a real action. Several in- and minuses. The community should The essence is to have the corporations dustries have started with their pro- not only be provided with information, compete with each other in producing gram. And also the Pemda. The Pemda but also the garbage bins. The software environmentally friendly products. could persuade the community to re- and hardware at the same time. The That is voluntary approach. Admittedly duce the use of plastic bags, for instan- three apsects must be available at the this is a more time consuming process. ce. Several activites we can do while same time. The role of motivator and Secondly, imposing a requirement that waiting for the Law. We push the cadre is very important because in the a corporation manufacturing Product X Pemda to take action from the very last two years it has been proven that in packaging it must be environmentally beginning. Once again, it is not easy to they could significantly increase com- friendly. This can be done in a number change community's mindset, habit, life SOURCE: MUJIYANTO style. I think in the Adipura program there is the evaluation for reducing waste. Speaking of changing the com- munity's mindset, it is a process that takes time. While waste growth acceleration goes beyond awareness development. How can garbage handling be accelerated? From the experience gathered with- in the last 6 months, the regional heads have responded favourably. Some even have taken the real action. What is nec- essary is to provide them with technical assistance. There are already 91 mayors making contact with us. From that po- int we are quite optimistic. Through Pemda's positive movement, we hope the regional policy is beginning to get 10 Percik December 2006
  • 13. I N T E RV I E W SOURCE: MUJIYANTO tinted with corrective measures at There is the upper respiratory their own initiatives. The com- tract, diarrhoea, cholera, and oth- munity through NGOs and schools ers all are related to waste water also resposd favourably. Maneu- pollution. We have had an exten- vers are taking place in campuses sive campaign on this matter in and schools. Some call it Clean order to draw the Pemdas atten- Development Mechanism (CDM). tion. It is now that Adipura is Many NGOs successfully provide beginning to take a look at solid assistance to Pemda in managing waste. Wastewater and waste from waste. This at the same time is the small industries are still over- spelling out of Kyoto Protocol i.e looked. I am earnestly enhancing reducing greenhouse effect by environmentally sustainable city. managing waste properly. If the It is a long way to go. Let's look Bupati/mayor is in short of money, forward. In the beginning it is financial assistance can be obtained It is something around 300 - 500 mil- solid waste. Time will come when we from CDM mechanism. I think in less lion in rupiah. This represents an actu- speak of wastewater and air pollution. than 5 years the community awareness al touch for the regions to change their Finally wastes from small industries. will be widely spread within the com- paradigm. munity. Speaking of waste from small Let's shift to liquid waste. It industries, how dangerous is it? What development program looks as if there were no manage- Waste produced by small industries aimed at Pemda regarding TPA ma- ment pattern, doesn't it? activities, not all of it is dangerous. The nagement? Actually wastewater problem is current- most dangerous ones are from leather We suggested regional TPA, in addition ly being dealt with by our colleagues in Cipta industry, electroplating. In general to the right sanitary landfill practice. This is Karya. But we must admit that in terms of small industries are wasteful in water, in more efficient so that in the future the num- priority and how Pemdas or legislative body energy. This is the most important. If ber of TPA is getting less but the manage- at the central as well as regional see it is they can save up to 20 percent the ment improves. Take Bandung for instance, another problem. At the moment our col- national impact will be quite significant. it will involve the city of Bandung, leagues from Bappenas and from Public Secondly, wastewater and solid waste Kabupaten Bandung and the city of Cimahi. Works each have it in their own concept, we are thrown away. Whereas actually they The same is for Yogyakarta. have none yet. We are focusing more on set- can be reused and recycled to produce ting up the standards. The operational is something of economic value. The total What could be done to enhance with Public Works while the general idea is impact, frankly speaking, we are unable TPA management from open with Basppenas. The three of us are coo- to inform you, because there is no study dumping to sanitary landfill? perating nicely. In general wastewater ma- conducted along that line. We've introduced them with CDM nagement is still very little, the more so in mechanism. If the Pemda has financial dif- Jakarta. Some regions are already good, for What is the fate of Waste ficulties, there is the compensation. We example Solo. Simulataneously with solid Management draft bill? can help them. Also in Waste Management waste, we enhance wastewater management From the technical aspect, we are Law there is a stipulation about what but at a lower intensity. I think it is not already through. The draft is now with the resposibility each level has to assume, entirely true to say that nothing has been DPR (People's Representatives). An en- national, provincial, and kabupaten/kota. done, because we already have a legal frame- dorsement letter from the State Secretary And there is the Special Allocation Fund work to protect environment from pollution. has also been sent to DPR. Let's pray and (DAK) which used to be for environment, together enhance the DPR to take a good now it is for waste management. How dangerous is it the liquid look to the draft. At the same time we are waste pollution? also conducting maneuvers towards that How much is it in terms of There is a study that summarizes the end. In no way that we neglect our role in money? real the burden carried on the commu- enhancing, and the values contained in the The amount is reatively small. But nity's shoulder is quite significant. Per draft bill have been brought to implemen- to the regions it could mean a great deal. year it is more than Rp 40 trillion. tation. mujiyanto Percik December 2006 11
  • 14. STUDY Study on Public Financing for Water Supply and Sanitation Development in Indonesia T his public financing study con- ces have relatively higher income per ca- (see Chart 1). ducted in post decentralization pita, it seems they do not feel responsi- Approximately 50 percent of provin- (2003-2005) WSS sector opera- ble in the provision of WSS service. The cial and kabupaten WSS budget is tion and investment is intended to get a munipalities that participate in WAS- intended for water supply, while for better and clearer picture of the deve- POLA provide the highest per capita kota water supply is given less in pro- lopment of funding strategy for this sec- investment, while the province invest portion, the bigger share goes to tor. This study analyses fund allocation the least amount compared to kabupat- drainange development. Budget for by Dept. Health and Dept. Public Works en and kota. solid waste gets a small proportion in all at the national level, and to seven pro- Most regional WSS allocation is levels of the government, the highest vinces, two kotas (municipalities), and intended for physical construction. A being 5 percent of the total municipal 19 kabupatens that participated in the small amount is for technical assistance, budget. Sanitation gets one fifth of the Water Supply and Sanitation Policy For- socialization, and capacity improvement total budget for water supply, but the mulation and Action Planning (WAS- Table 1 POLA) Project. Average WSS Budget Allocation and Average Regional Revenue within WASPOLA Project Sites This study focuses only on budget Average WSS Budget Average Regional Revenue allocation, and not on expenditure be- cause there are not enough data to do In Million Rp Rp per capita In Million Rp Rp per capita so. The composition of sector allocation is analysed through verification of budg- Kabupaten 1.689 6.162 748.804 475.790 et items with the support documents in order to determine the validity of activi- Province 3.071 661 2,669.782 1.619.314 ty/expenditure. The allocations are then classified based on sub-sector acti- Kota (Municipality) 4.611 30.251 469.379 3.825.743 vity/expenditure: i) Physical; ii) Techni- cal Assistance; iii) Project Support and Maintenance; and iv) Socialization of policy or capacity improvement and Chart 1 correlation of budget allocation within Regional Budget and at the different levels of the govern- 8% 0% Allocation for WSS ment and types of activity. 2% 1. Budget Trend for WSS Service Capital Capital Provision 2003-2005 1.1 Regional Investment for WSS Technical Assistance Technical Assistance On average the regional investment for WSS in Indonesia (water supply, Project Support and Maintenance and sanitation, solid waste, and drainage Project Support Maintenance system) in WASPOLA project sites is highest in the urban sector and lowest at Socialization and Socialization and the provincial level, all in terms of the Capacity Improvement Capacity Building amount of fund. In spite of the provin- 90% 12 Percik December 2006
  • 15. STUDY Table 2. proportion varies n each level of the Sub-Sector Allocation in WASPOLA Location for Year 2003-2004 (in rupiah) government. In the meantime, the correlation of Ministry of Public Local Local as gross regional domestic product with Works Government Percentage of Total WSS budget allocation indicates a weak correlation (0,14). Almost no correla- Water Provision 49.292.425.000 91.008.643.356 65 persen tion (0,05) between WSS and gross Sanitation 925.000.000 20.697.563.605 96 persen regional domestic product. Solid Waste 4.379.282.000 3.660.089.006 46 persen Water Channel 1.861.903.000 73.102.575.664 98 persen 1.2 National Investment Total 56.458.610.000 188.468.871.631 77 persen 1.2.1 WSS Allocation by Dept. Public Works The budget allocation by Dept Public far smaller than that of Dept. Public Conclusion and Recommendation Works for the regional governments, at Works. During the last three years 1. Investment is at the moment be- national level as well as for WASPOLA Dept. Health budget allocation for water low the level required for the govern- project sites, is mainly for water supply. supply and sanitation is less than 1 per- ment to reach the target. On average, At the national level, sanitation is only cent from the total allocated by Dept. the regional allocation for WSS devlop- provided with approximately 15 percent Public Works, and Dept. Health is con- ment is less than 1 percent of the total of the total Dept. Public Works alloca- tinuously decreasing during the period regional revenue and the annual alloca- tion for water supply and for WASPOLA of the study. On the other hand, Dept. tion for this sector is approximately sites combined. Two thirds of Dept Health allocation for sanitation exceeds US$0.40 or approximately US$0.03 of Public Works allocation is for physical that of Dept. Public Works. However per capita GNP. construction and almost all of the rest is the larger portion of Dept. Health con- 2. The allocation composition and for technical assistance, consisting of tribution for water supply and sanita- trend indicates an increase by the regio- sector development for optimum per- tion is provided by Water Supply for nal government, but there is potential formance, detailed technical design, and Low Income Communities (WSLIC) for central government allocation. The construction related feasibility study. Project. In general the Dept. Health shift of investmen sector from central to This study also examines the corre- allocation related to WSLIC "dimi- regional government has been visible lation between allocation by Dept. of nishes" their other allocations, because within the study area, in which the Public Works with allocation by the re- the size of WSLIC related allocation is regional governments provide 46 to 90 gional government. The relationship is 95 percent of the total Dept. Health sup- percent of the total subsector activities. found positive though insignificant port to WSS sector. This indicates the Pemdas' willingness (0,21). Compared to national allocation to invest in WSS development. Howe- for WASPOLA sites, most of the fund for 1.3 Central and Regional Go- ver, this study also reveals insignificant this sector, with exception for solid vernment Support to PDAM correlation between regional revenue waste, has been provided by the the Of all the Pemdas that participate in and gross regional domestic product regional government. The combination WASPOLA only the province of N. with WSS budget allocation. of the two observations indicates that Sumatra and kabupaten Gorontalo that 3. The Pemdas are playing an incre- there is an opportunity for national level allocate fund for supporting and super- asingly important role in sector finan- institutions to take more benefit from vising PDAM. On the other hand, cen- cing, but they have a limited fund and using fund provided by the regional go- tral government support through Dept. capacity. Although the pemdas may vernment. Public Works reaches on average 30 assume a bigger responsibiliy in the sec- percent during the last three years. tor, there are only very few resources in- 1.2.2 WSS Allocation by Dept. Most of the support is in technical assis- vested for WSS development and the Health tance for optimum performance and in sector funding will continue to be Dept. Health provides the second design preparation. restricted in favour of various other in- biggest allocation for water supply, but terests. Percik December 2006 13
  • 16. STUDY 4. The capacity of sector related who give strong indication of their pre- institutions to develop realistic invest- paredness and responsibility. ment plans can be improved by various It is deemed simple methods. Based on this study, as necessary to have a Steps in Financial Strategy well as from regional governments' clear division of The steps discussed below are de- feedback it becomes apparent that the responsibility in the signed to get the financial strategy pro- basic parameter for financial planning various levels of the cess into motion. The key activity must for the sector is not available, the pa- be discussed and agreed by GOI and the government, rameter is unknown to them. schedule and time frame be decided in 5. At the national level GOI must fi- particularly between the discussion. nalise the process for development stra- the province and tegy through a wider scope agreement kabupaten/kota. Phase 1 (inter-department) on the basic service Consultation with Basppenas, and priority reform package for the pur- Dept Finace, Dept Public Works and pose of increasing the overall sector Dept Health on the findings of this may potentially decrease local capacity budget and to improve effectiveness. study. in maintaining and supporting program 6. It is deemed necessary to have a Discussion on formulation of MoU during implementation. clear division of responsibility in the va- on minimum sector service and reform 9. It is necessary to allocate more rious levels of the government, particu- package to be provided under Bappenas national resources for institutional and larly between the province and kabupa- coordination. regional capacity building in sector ten/kota. In spite of a relatively bigger Sharing the study findings with, and planning and programming. revenue yet in terms of budget allocati- collecting inputs from, the Pemdas 10. Regional expenditure for ma- on the province is lagging behind. This (regional governments) on their opinion intenance and 'software' must be incre- pattern of funding reflects the confusion and type of support they expect from the ased proportionally to guarantee securi- in what role the province is actually national government; sharing good prac- ty and effectiveness of the invested ca- playing in WSS development. tices from the Pemdas in sector investment pital. 7. The involved institutions must be and sector strategy development. 11. Various long term funding me- given more responsibility to regularly Development of situation self as- chanisms must be made available to submit, accumulate and analyse sector sessment and strategy direction notes Pemdas and regional public companies financing and performance report and a and processes for Pemdas to be used as need for resources to SOURCE: MUJIYANTO input for national WSS support this activity program development. including random audit. Development of sec- 8. Provision of na- tor investment plan with tional fund for WSS financing unit of each pol- development at this time icy package. involves a short term (yearly) implementation Phase 2 period and there is no Simultaneously assurance if it is avail- with the above matters, able year after year. Mo- implementation of pha- reover, except for Spe- se 2 to start with sector cial Fund Allocation financing review thro- (DAK) and grant fund, ugh regional public in Pemdas' opinion as companies and level of off budget deconcentra- tariff charged to cum- tion fund. These factors sumers. MJ 14 Percik December 2006
  • 17. R E P O RTA G E ProAir Project at Praibakul - Taramanu NTT Guarding Sustainability Through Upholding Strict Regulation SOURCE: MUJIYANTO A t last the forty year long dream turns into reality. The commu- nity of the villages of Praibakul and Taramanu of the Kecamatan Wanokaka, W. Sumba, NTT can now smile with satisfaction. The hardship they have undergone all this time, climbing up and down hill to take a pail of water from a river or water spring, is now repaid. The aura of happiness is reflected in their faces. "We are very happy," said Kaledi Dimo of Taramanu. Before this he and his family used to take water from the river for their family need. With a pillar and water taps right in front of his house, the middle aged man plans to build a bathroom and toilet. The development of the gravitation- al water supply system has not been an and to make them also consider how munity was willing to participate in the easy thing. "It took time and patience," they can maintain the sustainability project. It took more than one year to said Soleman Djowa Rega, the after the project is completed. The do that. Chairman of Water Supply socialization was also intended to build By the end of 2004 the community Management Team 'Bebong Maradang'. the sense of belongingness so that the began depositing their money after for- You can imagine, it took 2,5 years for facility could last forever in their own mation of a management team chaired community preparation. It was so diffi- hands. by Soleman Djowa Rega, an evangelist cult to convince the community to par- Martalanda, village motivator who of the village of Praibakul. It was com- ticipate through providing in cash and lives with the community, revealed that monly agreed that the community in kind contribution. This is because the most difficult part of his job was in would pay the amount in installments there were in the past certain villages convincing the community. "The most for one year an amount of Rp 70.000 were supplied with water supply facility difficult is to convince the community per household. Collection is conducted without any community participation. that the 4 percent contribution will be by team accompanied by village officers According to Petrus Kanaf, the commu- saved for O&M costs later on," said the did not work as expected. Once there nity still maintains the old way of think- woman of Sumba origin. The reason is was almost a bloodshed simply because ing that without any contribution the that the community has had never of misunderstanding when a man mem- commnity can improve itself. before and no similar experience has ber of the community produced his For almost 2,5 years the time was ever been met. "The community machete to threathen a deputy RT chief. spent for socialization of ProAir project thought the saving was for the officers's For 11 months from 12 months to make the community ready. The pur- pocket," said Soleman. Through planned the fund amounted to Rp 18,3 pose was to change the way of thinking patience and modesty finally the com- million from 264 families was collected. Percik December 2006 15
  • 18. R E P O RTA G E In compliance with the requirement denied the service. "Any non member lity. They have formulated a regulation from ProAir, namely development may caught taking water from the tap will be for guarding the sustainability of the start as soon as the contribution has fined Rp 500 thousand," said Martinus. facility that was developed at a cost in been fully paid, in early 2006 the devel- For this purpose the members living excess of Rp 1,6 billion. A socialization opment started to take place, phase by near the tap are given the responsibility programme was launched in the com- phase. Material procurement was con- to guard it. munity both to members and non mem- ducted through tendering, while sup- For minor damage each household is bers of the group. The regulation in- port materials and labour were provided to contribute Rp 6.000/month. Pay- volves imposition of fine. Whoever ta- by the community. ment shall be made latest on the third kes a bath in the pillar shall be fined Rp Unpaid labours were provided in vil- day of each month. Any delay will be 100 thousand. Whoever inflicts any da- lage, hamlet and zone levels. "Everyone fined Rp 1.000. Monthly contribution mage to pipe shall be fined Rp 250 thou- above 17 years old, man and woman, will start in January 2007. The month- sand and shall face tribunal according to must work together. Except those who ly contribution will be used to pay for adat law. The individual who inflict da- are going to school and are being minor damage and salary of the mana- mage to pipe shall additionally be sub- employed elsewhere," said Martinus gement team. While the cash saving ac- ject to adat law, i.e by presenting a offer- Gali (45) of Praibakul. They gather and count will be used for major breakdown. ing consisting of a pig, 8 baskets of carry rocks, digging soil, constructing The fact that the water is flowing steadi- cooked rice, 5 kgs coffee, 10 kgs sugar, reservoir and water source catchment ly many who used to refuse to participate betel leaves and betel nuts each one structure. Soleman told his story, that are getting interested. "There are many sack. "In terms of money everything for the sake of self reliance, ProAir pro- who wish to join," said Martinus. But the will cost Rp 10 million," said Martinus. hibited rock transport beinng done requirements are heavier. The manage- This of course is an extremely big amo- using motor vehicle. "Finally we carried ment has made it a requirement that for a unt of money for villagers who are small all the rocks," he said. Aboive all, new member the initial contribution is Rp farmers during the rainy season and col- because such highspiritedness, the 250 thousand and maintenance contribu- lecting rocks during the dry season. number of workers were more than the tion Rp 70 thousand and monthly contribu- The community hopes that through the requested. "If the project asked for 10 tion Rp 6.000 a month. According to Edi, strict regulation the constructed facility can labourers, 40 people came to volun- there are 16 families are already requesting be used effectively continuously. They do teer," said Edy Bili, the secretary of for membership. not want to see the facility break down in Bebong Maradang, added the state- the same way as the previous facilities built ment. Guarding sustainability in the past. "The community has under- Through hard work, the community It seems that the community prepa- stood that the facility must be maintained was able to complete the laying of 11,5 ration process has been successful. because it belongs to them and for their km. long main conveyance pipe. The They feel they have a water supply faci- own good," said Edi. mujiyanto water is supplied to 1 m high water tap SOURCE: MUJIYANTO pillars. There are 28 pillars distributed in 5 zones. Each pillar holds 2 water taps. The community also protect the Way Bakul water spring with barbed wire fence and plant trees around it. The official dedication of this water sup- ply facility was made by Vice Bupati of W. Sumba, Cofrnelis Kodimeta, on 25 November. Water has been flowing since last November. The community has made use of it, not only for drinking and MCK but also for watering garden plants. Even the livestock can drink from the service. In the meantime, the villagers who used to refuse to participate are 16 Percik December 2006