SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 11
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Making research relevant for policy and development
Enhancing the role and capacity of women scientists
                to influence change



                Training workshop
        The art of influencing policy change:
        Tools and strategies for researchers
               February 12-14, 2013
                        12-

                Margaret Kroma
Ag ricu ltu ra l Eco n o m ics

                             Ag ro n o m y

                                  An im a l

                            Bio d ive rs ity

                         C ro p S cie n ce

                                 E co lo g y

                           E n to m o lo g y

                              E xte n s io n

                              Fis h e rie s

                        Fo o d /N u tritio n

                                Fo re s try

                   Mo le cu la r B io lo g y

N a tu ra l R e s o u rce Ma n a g e m e n t

                          S o il S cie n ce

                      W a te r/Irrig a tio n

                                    Oth e r

                                               0%   20%   40%     60%    80%    100%

                                                      Fe m a le         Ma le
Distribution of Female shares of professional staff by discipline mix,
2007/08
      Agricultural economics
                    Agronomy
              Animal science
                 Biodiversity
                Crop science
                    Ecology
                 Entomology
                  Extension
                    Fisheries
     Food/nutritional science
                    Forestry
            Molecular biology
Natural resource management
                Soil science
              Water/irrigation
                        Other

                        Total

                                 0   5     10       15        20      25        30       35   40   45

                                         Female shares in total research staff (percentage)




                  Adapted from Beintema and DiMarcantino, 2010 based on ASTI/IFPRI
                  data
Why it matters: Women in science and technology


                                                  Shared cultural
Half human                                        location
capital
potential
              Representation                      Women scientists
underutilized   challenge                         Bring a unique
                                                  insights to
                                      Relevance   research
                                      challenge
                                                  Research problem
                          Science and             focused and
                      Technology Research          aligned to
 Need increase in                                  challenges women
 number of                                        routinely face in
 women                                            development
 scientists around        Sustainability
 policy table
                           challenge
Challenges women scientists face in science and
technology research

• Institutional challenges:
   – Exclusionary institutional networks
   – Review and promotion committees –The Gate-keeper
     challenge:

• Social and culturally nuanced challenges:
   – Social alienation
   – Work-life balance challenges:
Women scientists: The gap in Africa’s policy arena

• Policy is central to the capacity of countries and their public
  as well as private sectors to use science and technology for
  sustainable development;

• However, the effectiveness of the policy in driving
  sustainable change is directly correlated to the quality (both
  in terms of relevance, diversity and inclusiveness) of the
  knowledge and ideas supplied;

• The exclusion of African women scientists and practitioners
  from both the supply and demand side of policy making has
  until recently been glaring.
Shares of female students enrolled and female in professional staff, 2007/8
  ■ Proportion of women studying agricultural sciences is higher
    than the share of female agricultural scientists
  South Africa
 Mozambique
    Botswana
       Kenya
      Uganda
       Nigeria
      Burundi
      Zambia
      Senegal
       Ghana
       Malawi
      Ethiopia

                 0     10            20          30         40          50          60     70
                                                  Female share (%)

                            In total students enrolled       In total professional staff



                     Adapted from Beintema and DiMarcantino, 2010 based on ASTI/IFPRI
                     data
Shift in gender gap with career advancement (10 countries),
                                    2007/8
                                      100

                                                              Male           Female                   85%

                                      80                                                      72%
                                                   71%
          Female share (percentage)




                                                                     65%          65%


                                      60




                                      40

                                                    34%              35%           35%
                                                                                              27%
                                      20
                                                                                                         17%



                                       0
                                            Students (10)   Graduates (10)   PS/ST (10)   SPL (10)   M (10)


PS/TS indicates professional and technical support staff; SPL includes scientists, (assistant) professors, and
(senior) lecturers not in management positions; and M indicates management and includes directors, deans,
and department heads. When including all 15 countries, the female share in management positions is lower at
14 percent ( Adapted from Beintema and DiMarcantino, 2009 based on ASTI/IFPRI data)
Supply side implications for increase in women
                scientists and researchers

•    Types of knowledge produced and the relevance of that
    knowledge for particular groups in society;

• Linking scientific and local knowledge to decision making will
  ensure a more grounded policy making process;

• The nature of the research conducted; inclusive research
  methods that bridge knowledge domains

• Making science responsive to the needs of a more inclusive
  society; “local knowledge systems and innovation will more
  likely be enabled to inform decision making.
On the demand side, increasing the numbers of women scientists
around the policy table ensures that

  • Policy interests and priorities often missing from the
    policy debates and decisions can have “voice” around
    the policy table;

  • Policy options are made more gender responsive; e.g.
    Gender equity in science and technology education;
    Making the science and technology decision-making
    more gender responsive.
Closing the information and knowledge gap on African women in
S&T I

                                              Sample Ghana factsheet: 2008
  Track-Learn-Adjust
     Benchmarking study
                                              Distribution of l science researchers by discipline in
     on status of African                     the NARS
     women scientists in                A g r i c u l tu r a l E c o n o m i c s
     SSA (ASTI-IFPRI)                                          Ag ro n o m y

                                                                     A n im a l

                                                            B i o d i v e r s i ty

                                                        C ro p S c ie n c e

                                                                   E c o lo g y

                                                           E n to m o l o g y

                                                               E x te n s i o n

                                                                F is h e rie s

                                                       F o o d /N u tr i ti o n

                                                                   F o r e s tr y

                                                 M o le c u la r B io lo g y

                            N a tu r a l R e s o u r c e M a n a g e m e n t

                                                          S o il S c ie n c e

                                                     W a t e r /I r r i g a ti o n

                                                                        O th e r

                                                                                     0%   20%   40%      60%     80%    100%

                                                                                            F e m a le         M a le

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Influencing policy change: Strategies for women researchers

APS 2020 Challenges for women in physics
APS 2020 Challenges for women in physicsAPS 2020 Challenges for women in physics
APS 2020 Challenges for women in physicsAnne Marie Porter
 
ICWES15 - 100 Years Later: Has Anything Changed for Women in Science? Present...
ICWES15 - 100 Years Later: Has Anything Changed for Women in Science? Present...ICWES15 - 100 Years Later: Has Anything Changed for Women in Science? Present...
ICWES15 - 100 Years Later: Has Anything Changed for Women in Science? Present...Engineers Australia
 
Female Participation in African Agricultural Research and Higher Education
Female Participation in African Agricultural Research and Higher EducationFemale Participation in African Agricultural Research and Higher Education
Female Participation in African Agricultural Research and Higher EducationIFPRI Gender
 
ICWES15 - Good Practices to Promote Women in Science and Engineering: The Ind...
ICWES15 - Good Practices to Promote Women in Science and Engineering: The Ind...ICWES15 - Good Practices to Promote Women in Science and Engineering: The Ind...
ICWES15 - Good Practices to Promote Women in Science and Engineering: The Ind...Engineers Australia
 
Strategy and plan of action for mainstreaming gender in ILRI
Strategy and plan of action for mainstreaming gender in ILRIStrategy and plan of action for mainstreaming gender in ILRI
Strategy and plan of action for mainstreaming gender in ILRIILRI
 
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE) 2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE) CIARD
 
Focus on Gender Dimension in research at UniCA. State of the art and perspect...
Focus on Gender Dimension in research at UniCA. State of the art and perspect...Focus on Gender Dimension in research at UniCA. State of the art and perspect...
Focus on Gender Dimension in research at UniCA. State of the art and perspect...SUPERA project
 
Creating Your Best Future! The 7 Habits of Successful Science, Technology, En...
Creating Your Best Future! The 7 Habits of Successful Science, Technology, En...Creating Your Best Future! The 7 Habits of Successful Science, Technology, En...
Creating Your Best Future! The 7 Habits of Successful Science, Technology, En...Career Communications Group
 
The Tech Industry's Commitment to Youth
The Tech Industry's Commitment to YouthThe Tech Industry's Commitment to Youth
The Tech Industry's Commitment to YouthYTH
 
Diversity and Knowledge Production, by Jihane Lamouri, Diversity, Equity and ...
Diversity and Knowledge Production, by Jihane Lamouri, Diversity, Equity and ...Diversity and Knowledge Production, by Jihane Lamouri, Diversity, Equity and ...
Diversity and Knowledge Production, by Jihane Lamouri, Diversity, Equity and ...WiMLDSMontreal
 
Advancing women acadamics at Fiji National University
Advancing women acadamics at Fiji National UniversityAdvancing women acadamics at Fiji National University
Advancing women acadamics at Fiji National UniversityUniversity of Limerick
 
Implant Dentistry in the New Scientific Dental World Acceptance Rates
Implant Dentistry in the New Scientific Dental World Acceptance RatesImplant Dentistry in the New Scientific Dental World Acceptance Rates
Implant Dentistry in the New Scientific Dental World Acceptance Ratesijtsrd
 
Asti at award june2010
Asti at award june2010Asti at award june2010
Asti at award june2010IFPRI Gender
 

Similar a Influencing policy change: Strategies for women researchers (20)

APS 2020 Challenges for women in physics
APS 2020 Challenges for women in physicsAPS 2020 Challenges for women in physics
APS 2020 Challenges for women in physics
 
ICWES15 - 100 Years Later: Has Anything Changed for Women in Science? Present...
ICWES15 - 100 Years Later: Has Anything Changed for Women in Science? Present...ICWES15 - 100 Years Later: Has Anything Changed for Women in Science? Present...
ICWES15 - 100 Years Later: Has Anything Changed for Women in Science? Present...
 
Female Participation in African Agricultural Research and Higher Education
Female Participation in African Agricultural Research and Higher EducationFemale Participation in African Agricultural Research and Higher Education
Female Participation in African Agricultural Research and Higher Education
 
ICWES15 - Good Practices to Promote Women in Science and Engineering: The Ind...
ICWES15 - Good Practices to Promote Women in Science and Engineering: The Ind...ICWES15 - Good Practices to Promote Women in Science and Engineering: The Ind...
ICWES15 - Good Practices to Promote Women in Science and Engineering: The Ind...
 
Strategy and plan of action for mainstreaming gender in ILRI
Strategy and plan of action for mainstreaming gender in ILRIStrategy and plan of action for mainstreaming gender in ILRI
Strategy and plan of action for mainstreaming gender in ILRI
 
The Leaky Pipeline
The Leaky PipelineThe Leaky Pipeline
The Leaky Pipeline
 
abcv
abcvabcv
abcv
 
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE) 2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
2012 05 CIARD (Paper presented for III IAALD-AFRICA Chapter CONFERENCE)
 
011 rudgard
011   rudgard011   rudgard
011 rudgard
 
Focus on Gender Dimension in research at UniCA. State of the art and perspect...
Focus on Gender Dimension in research at UniCA. State of the art and perspect...Focus on Gender Dimension in research at UniCA. State of the art and perspect...
Focus on Gender Dimension in research at UniCA. State of the art and perspect...
 
Creating Your Best Future! The 7 Habits of Successful Science, Technology, En...
Creating Your Best Future! The 7 Habits of Successful Science, Technology, En...Creating Your Best Future! The 7 Habits of Successful Science, Technology, En...
Creating Your Best Future! The 7 Habits of Successful Science, Technology, En...
 
The Tech Industry's Commitment to Youth
The Tech Industry's Commitment to YouthThe Tech Industry's Commitment to Youth
The Tech Industry's Commitment to Youth
 
Gender inequities in science careers
Gender inequities in science careersGender inequities in science careers
Gender inequities in science careers
 
Diversity and Knowledge Production, by Jihane Lamouri, Diversity, Equity and ...
Diversity and Knowledge Production, by Jihane Lamouri, Diversity, Equity and ...Diversity and Knowledge Production, by Jihane Lamouri, Diversity, Equity and ...
Diversity and Knowledge Production, by Jihane Lamouri, Diversity, Equity and ...
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
 
Branum mla 2012
Branum mla 2012Branum mla 2012
Branum mla 2012
 
Advancing women acadamics at Fiji National University
Advancing women acadamics at Fiji National UniversityAdvancing women acadamics at Fiji National University
Advancing women acadamics at Fiji National University
 
Implant Dentistry in the New Scientific Dental World Acceptance Rates
Implant Dentistry in the New Scientific Dental World Acceptance RatesImplant Dentistry in the New Scientific Dental World Acceptance Rates
Implant Dentistry in the New Scientific Dental World Acceptance Rates
 
Asti at award june2010
Asti at award june2010Asti at award june2010
Asti at award june2010
 
Asti at award june2010
Asti at award june2010Asti at award june2010
Asti at award june2010
 

Más de The Scinnovent Centre

Industrial Property Landscape in Kenya: Facts, figures and trends
Industrial Property Landscape in Kenya: Facts, figures and trendsIndustrial Property Landscape in Kenya: Facts, figures and trends
Industrial Property Landscape in Kenya: Facts, figures and trendsThe Scinnovent Centre
 
Keynote presentation scientific revival day, 2014 maurice_bolo [compatibility...
Keynote presentation scientific revival day, 2014 maurice_bolo [compatibility...Keynote presentation scientific revival day, 2014 maurice_bolo [compatibility...
Keynote presentation scientific revival day, 2014 maurice_bolo [compatibility...The Scinnovent Centre
 
Engaging youth in bioaware through KYBNET
Engaging youth in bioaware  through KYBNETEngaging youth in bioaware  through KYBNET
Engaging youth in bioaware through KYBNETThe Scinnovent Centre
 
Science and Technology Role in Accelerated Socio-economic achievement of visi...
Science and Technology Role in Accelerated Socio-economic achievement of visi...Science and Technology Role in Accelerated Socio-economic achievement of visi...
Science and Technology Role in Accelerated Socio-economic achievement of visi...The Scinnovent Centre
 
Maximizing web 2.0 and other social media tools
Maximizing web 2.0 and other social media toolsMaximizing web 2.0 and other social media tools
Maximizing web 2.0 and other social media toolsThe Scinnovent Centre
 
From research to innovation university research chairs
From research to innovation university research chairsFrom research to innovation university research chairs
From research to innovation university research chairsThe Scinnovent Centre
 
Systems approach to university research chairs pre proposal workshop-mb [comp...
Systems approach to university research chairs pre proposal workshop-mb [comp...Systems approach to university research chairs pre proposal workshop-mb [comp...
Systems approach to university research chairs pre proposal workshop-mb [comp...The Scinnovent Centre
 
Influence mapping influencing policy change nairobi [compatibility mode]
Influence mapping influencing policy change nairobi [compatibility mode]Influence mapping influencing policy change nairobi [compatibility mode]
Influence mapping influencing policy change nairobi [compatibility mode]The Scinnovent Centre
 
The role of Networks in Policy Change: The case of AFRICALICS
The role of Networks in Policy Change: The case of AFRICALICSThe role of Networks in Policy Change: The case of AFRICALICS
The role of Networks in Policy Change: The case of AFRICALICSThe Scinnovent Centre
 
Communication tools for influencing policy
Communication tools for influencing policyCommunication tools for influencing policy
Communication tools for influencing policyThe Scinnovent Centre
 
Context mapping policy influencing: a framework for action [compatibility mode]
Context mapping policy influencing: a framework for action [compatibility mode]Context mapping policy influencing: a framework for action [compatibility mode]
Context mapping policy influencing: a framework for action [compatibility mode]The Scinnovent Centre
 
Bridgingg the research policy gap influencing policy change-nairobi
Bridgingg the research policy gap influencing policy change-nairobiBridgingg the research policy gap influencing policy change-nairobi
Bridgingg the research policy gap influencing policy change-nairobiThe Scinnovent Centre
 

Más de The Scinnovent Centre (12)

Industrial Property Landscape in Kenya: Facts, figures and trends
Industrial Property Landscape in Kenya: Facts, figures and trendsIndustrial Property Landscape in Kenya: Facts, figures and trends
Industrial Property Landscape in Kenya: Facts, figures and trends
 
Keynote presentation scientific revival day, 2014 maurice_bolo [compatibility...
Keynote presentation scientific revival day, 2014 maurice_bolo [compatibility...Keynote presentation scientific revival day, 2014 maurice_bolo [compatibility...
Keynote presentation scientific revival day, 2014 maurice_bolo [compatibility...
 
Engaging youth in bioaware through KYBNET
Engaging youth in bioaware  through KYBNETEngaging youth in bioaware  through KYBNET
Engaging youth in bioaware through KYBNET
 
Science and Technology Role in Accelerated Socio-economic achievement of visi...
Science and Technology Role in Accelerated Socio-economic achievement of visi...Science and Technology Role in Accelerated Socio-economic achievement of visi...
Science and Technology Role in Accelerated Socio-economic achievement of visi...
 
Maximizing web 2.0 and other social media tools
Maximizing web 2.0 and other social media toolsMaximizing web 2.0 and other social media tools
Maximizing web 2.0 and other social media tools
 
From research to innovation university research chairs
From research to innovation university research chairsFrom research to innovation university research chairs
From research to innovation university research chairs
 
Systems approach to university research chairs pre proposal workshop-mb [comp...
Systems approach to university research chairs pre proposal workshop-mb [comp...Systems approach to university research chairs pre proposal workshop-mb [comp...
Systems approach to university research chairs pre proposal workshop-mb [comp...
 
Influence mapping influencing policy change nairobi [compatibility mode]
Influence mapping influencing policy change nairobi [compatibility mode]Influence mapping influencing policy change nairobi [compatibility mode]
Influence mapping influencing policy change nairobi [compatibility mode]
 
The role of Networks in Policy Change: The case of AFRICALICS
The role of Networks in Policy Change: The case of AFRICALICSThe role of Networks in Policy Change: The case of AFRICALICS
The role of Networks in Policy Change: The case of AFRICALICS
 
Communication tools for influencing policy
Communication tools for influencing policyCommunication tools for influencing policy
Communication tools for influencing policy
 
Context mapping policy influencing: a framework for action [compatibility mode]
Context mapping policy influencing: a framework for action [compatibility mode]Context mapping policy influencing: a framework for action [compatibility mode]
Context mapping policy influencing: a framework for action [compatibility mode]
 
Bridgingg the research policy gap influencing policy change-nairobi
Bridgingg the research policy gap influencing policy change-nairobiBridgingg the research policy gap influencing policy change-nairobi
Bridgingg the research policy gap influencing policy change-nairobi
 

Influencing policy change: Strategies for women researchers

  • 1. Making research relevant for policy and development Enhancing the role and capacity of women scientists to influence change Training workshop The art of influencing policy change: Tools and strategies for researchers February 12-14, 2013 12- Margaret Kroma
  • 2. Ag ricu ltu ra l Eco n o m ics Ag ro n o m y An im a l Bio d ive rs ity C ro p S cie n ce E co lo g y E n to m o lo g y E xte n s io n Fis h e rie s Fo o d /N u tritio n Fo re s try Mo le cu la r B io lo g y N a tu ra l R e s o u rce Ma n a g e m e n t S o il S cie n ce W a te r/Irrig a tio n Oth e r 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Fe m a le Ma le
  • 3. Distribution of Female shares of professional staff by discipline mix, 2007/08 Agricultural economics Agronomy Animal science Biodiversity Crop science Ecology Entomology Extension Fisheries Food/nutritional science Forestry Molecular biology Natural resource management Soil science Water/irrigation Other Total 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 Female shares in total research staff (percentage) Adapted from Beintema and DiMarcantino, 2010 based on ASTI/IFPRI data
  • 4. Why it matters: Women in science and technology Shared cultural Half human location capital potential Representation Women scientists underutilized challenge Bring a unique insights to Relevance research challenge Research problem Science and focused and Technology Research aligned to Need increase in challenges women number of routinely face in women development scientists around Sustainability policy table challenge
  • 5. Challenges women scientists face in science and technology research • Institutional challenges: – Exclusionary institutional networks – Review and promotion committees –The Gate-keeper challenge: • Social and culturally nuanced challenges: – Social alienation – Work-life balance challenges:
  • 6. Women scientists: The gap in Africa’s policy arena • Policy is central to the capacity of countries and their public as well as private sectors to use science and technology for sustainable development; • However, the effectiveness of the policy in driving sustainable change is directly correlated to the quality (both in terms of relevance, diversity and inclusiveness) of the knowledge and ideas supplied; • The exclusion of African women scientists and practitioners from both the supply and demand side of policy making has until recently been glaring.
  • 7. Shares of female students enrolled and female in professional staff, 2007/8 ■ Proportion of women studying agricultural sciences is higher than the share of female agricultural scientists South Africa Mozambique Botswana Kenya Uganda Nigeria Burundi Zambia Senegal Ghana Malawi Ethiopia 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Female share (%) In total students enrolled In total professional staff Adapted from Beintema and DiMarcantino, 2010 based on ASTI/IFPRI data
  • 8. Shift in gender gap with career advancement (10 countries), 2007/8 100 Male Female 85% 80 72% 71% Female share (percentage) 65% 65% 60 40 34% 35% 35% 27% 20 17% 0 Students (10) Graduates (10) PS/ST (10) SPL (10) M (10) PS/TS indicates professional and technical support staff; SPL includes scientists, (assistant) professors, and (senior) lecturers not in management positions; and M indicates management and includes directors, deans, and department heads. When including all 15 countries, the female share in management positions is lower at 14 percent ( Adapted from Beintema and DiMarcantino, 2009 based on ASTI/IFPRI data)
  • 9. Supply side implications for increase in women scientists and researchers • Types of knowledge produced and the relevance of that knowledge for particular groups in society; • Linking scientific and local knowledge to decision making will ensure a more grounded policy making process; • The nature of the research conducted; inclusive research methods that bridge knowledge domains • Making science responsive to the needs of a more inclusive society; “local knowledge systems and innovation will more likely be enabled to inform decision making.
  • 10. On the demand side, increasing the numbers of women scientists around the policy table ensures that • Policy interests and priorities often missing from the policy debates and decisions can have “voice” around the policy table; • Policy options are made more gender responsive; e.g. Gender equity in science and technology education; Making the science and technology decision-making more gender responsive.
  • 11. Closing the information and knowledge gap on African women in S&T I Sample Ghana factsheet: 2008 Track-Learn-Adjust Benchmarking study Distribution of l science researchers by discipline in on status of African the NARS women scientists in A g r i c u l tu r a l E c o n o m i c s SSA (ASTI-IFPRI) Ag ro n o m y A n im a l B i o d i v e r s i ty C ro p S c ie n c e E c o lo g y E n to m o l o g y E x te n s i o n F is h e rie s F o o d /N u tr i ti o n F o r e s tr y M o le c u la r B io lo g y N a tu r a l R e s o u r c e M a n a g e m e n t S o il S c ie n c e W a t e r /I r r i g a ti o n O th e r 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% F e m a le M a le