SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 4
Descargar para leer sin conexión
1
BOOK REVIEW
ON INTERPRETING JACQUES LACAN
Joseph H. Smith and William Kerrigan (Eds.) Interpreting Lacan, Forum on Psychiatry
and the Humanities Series, Vol. 6, The Washington School of Psychiatry (New
Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1983), ISBN 0-300-03039-8
INTRODUCTION
This anthology of essays on Lacanian psychoanalysis was put together in 1983 to
demonstrate the importance of Lacanian theory for clinical practitioners in the
United States. Most of these practitioners were ego psychologists by training. Many
of them had either read about or heard about Lacan from literary critics, but were
not aware of how to go actually about applying or using Lacan as clinicians. They
also needed to understand what the differences were between ego psychology and
the clinical techniques associated with Lacanian psychoanalysis. The editorial
intention in this volume then should be clear. It is an attempt to clear the space
necessary for the incorporation of Jacques Lacan into mainstream American
psychoanalysis under the auspices of the Washington School of Psychiatry. This
book is the sixth volume of essays in this series published by the Forum on
Humanities and Psychiatry that is affiliated to the Washington School. It brings
together clinicians, literary critics, and philosophers in order to integrate their
respective insights on the human sciences. The essays collected here fall into three
categories. It starts with the clinical essays before situating the clinical dimension in
relation to philosophy and psychoanalytic theory. The third and final part is about
applying Lacanian theory in the context of literary criticism. There are twelve essays
in this volume including the introduction and epilogue. The contributors are mainly
drawn from the ranks of clinicians, psychologists, and philosophers in the United
States and Europe. The editors, needless to say, will gauge the success of their efforts
in this volume mainly in terms of making Lacanian insights attractive for clinical
work. But, in order to make this possible, they have to explain the linguistic and
philosophical background that animates Lacanian theory. So while they start by
2
engaging with the clinical aspects, the better part of this volume is an attempt to
relate the structure of Lacanian theory to European philosophers like Hegel and
Heidegger. That is because Lacan takes for granted the reader’s familiarity with the
resonance of philosophical terms like ‘desire’ and ‘being’ in his seminars and
writings on psychoanalysis in France. But, as the editors know only too well, this
knowledge cannot be assumed outside the Parisian intellectual milieu in which
Lacan spent his entire career. An important editorial task for them is to find ways of
letting the philosophical knowledge that is necessary to situate Lacanian theory
percolate into the mainstream of American ego psychology without talking down to
their readers. Needless to say, this is not the only effort on the part of Smith and
Kerrigan to explain Lacanian theory to American audiences. Another important
aspect of their editorial efforts is to also provide a reception history of Lacanian
psychoanalysis in the United States. This they do in their comments in the
introduction and the epilogue by relating psychoanalysis to areas like biology, ego-
psychology, and the social sciences. The significance of this volume, we must note in
retrospect, is the fact that it met with considerable success. The editors did manage
to impress upon American clinicians that Lacanian theory is of interest to not only
linguists, literary critics, and philosophers; but has a lot to teach full-time clinicians
as well.
THE EDITORIAL INTENTION
The first part of this volume sets out some of the topics that were of immediate
interest to clinicians. These included but were not limited to terms like image,
language, the subject, the psychoses, the unconscious, the word, and the scope of the
‘talking cure.’ Another important analytic distinction is the difference between
empty speech and full speech since the cure depends on whether the patient is able
to go beyond the imaginary dimension of empty speech and embrace the symbolic
gains of full speech. I have not listed all the topics of interest to American clinicians
but mainly those which they felt the need to redefine in the light of the Lacanian
intervention. So, for instance, clinicians began to appreciate the ‘onto-theological’
dimensions of everyday terms like ‘image, language, and the word’ after reading
Lacan. It is important to remember that American theologians were as interested in
Lacan as were American philosophers teaching continental philosophy. While
describing the response of theologians to Lacanian theory is beyond the scope of this
review, we must at least note that learning to appreciate the onto-theological
dimensions of a theory of the subject made it easier for clinicians to appreciate that
while ‘the word’ is all that they really have to work with in the clinic, it is not
something that they should be ashamed of. The theoretical difference between the
neuroses and the psychoses was also important for the editors since most clinicians
who have a background in psychiatry (as opposed to psychoanalysis) have to take
3
on a number of psychotics and patients afflicted with borderline phenomena. So it
become important to know whether French clinicians trained in the Lacanian
tradition recognize borderline phenomena (like English clinicians do). And what the
relevant cultural differences might be between the clinician traditions in England,
France, and America in matters pertaining to ‘differential diagnosis.’ Furthermore,
there is an important difference between merely situating the roles that words and
images play in constituting the patient’s unconscious, like Sigmund Freud himself
does when he differentiates between word and thing presentations; and relating
them, as Lacan does, to theories of the symbolic and the imaginary. That is why it is
important to understand that in addition to his knowledge of structural linguistics;
Lacan’s religious background as a Catholic; his interest in patristics (as a possible
source for his theories of the ‘name-of-the-father’); and the theoretical controversies
that bear an interesting parallel between doctrinal squabbles in the Church and
within and between the different schools of psychoanalysis. In other words, the
history of analytic doctrine cannot be wished away in the attempts to make a science
or a clinical practice out of psychoanalysis in America or Europe.
PHILOSOPHY OF PSYCHOANALYSIS
The definition of the unconscious is also at stake in these editorial interventions
because invoking terms like the ‘discourse of the Other’ and the ‘desire of the Other’
have immediate theological implications; as does the relationship between the
Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit in the Catholic communion. So while we do not
expect ego-psychologists to be interested in literary criticism, philosophy, and
theology from a clinical point of view, these aspects of Lacanian theory occupy the
better part of what the contributors to this book are willing to engage with. That
then, briefly put, is the main challenge for the editors. There is a difference between
telling literary critics that they must brush up on philosophy and theology in order
to read Jacques Derrida and Jacques Lacan, but saying that with a straight face to
practical clinicians is another ball game altogether. And, as if that educational
challenge were not enough, the editors also make it clear that Lacan has his own
interpretation of the structural anthropology of Claude Lévi-Strauss and the
structural linguistics of Ferdinand de Saussure. In other words, the Lacanian theory
of the word, language, and the unconscious demands an understanding of the
linguistic dimensions of the unconscious. The main difficulty here is that ego-
psychologists had got used to conflating the id with the unconscious and would use
these terms as though they were synonyms or condense them into the ‘unconscious
id’ and the ‘conscious ego’ even though Freud explains that the better part of the ego
is itself unconscious. In other words, what was at stake for Lacan was the conflation
of the structural and descriptive models of the psyche in ego-psychology. If working
simultaneously with the structural, descriptive, and dynamic models was so difficult
4
for clinicians, how will they find the intellectual means necessary to grapple with the
theories of Jacques Lacan? While the answer to this question is still not clear to those
who would like to explain or teach Lacanian theory, it is a question that we must
face up to with brutal honesty. It would not be a stretch to point out that this is the
main question that haunts this volume of essays.
LACANIAN THEORY & AMERICAN PRACTICE
Will the incorporation of Lacanian theory into American practice demand so much?
Furthermore, will all these intellectual demands have to be addressed at once?
Should analysts attempt to ‘use Lacan’ in the American clinic only when they have
learnt this much theory? Or, is it possible to incorporate Lacanian theory in a more
modest way? The impression conveyed in this volume is that Lacanian theory
cannot be separated from Lacanian practice. It is therefore important to take in all of
Lacan or as much Lacan as possible. This however does not mean that clinicians who
have never read Hegel, Heidegger, or any of the continental philosophers should
stay away from Lacanian psychoanalysis. But, at the same time, clinicians who do
not even suspect the existence of such philosophers or any of the existential and
structural dimensions of analytic theory will probably not find Lacan important in
their intellectual or clinical lives. That, simply put, is the editorial quandary in this
volume and in other books in this series on ‘interpreting Lacan.’ An interest in
continental philosophy, or the French model of the human sciences, cannot be
legislated into the history of clinical work in America; but it is nonetheless necessary
to some extent to avoid clinical mishaps. And, finally, Lacan assumes that psychiatrists
and ego psychologists with a medical background will begin to engage sooner or
later with the theoretical dimensions of clinical practice. The burden of this book
review is to argue that those who do not do this will simply not derive adequate
value in becoming either full-fledged Lacanians or in even engaging with Lacanian
theory. They will at best read Lacan for his polemics rather than for his far reaching
clinical insights.
SHIVA KUMAR SRINIVASAN

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

Jacques Alain Miller on 'A and a in Clinical Structures'
Jacques Alain Miller on 'A and a in Clinical Structures'Jacques Alain Miller on 'A and a in Clinical Structures'
Jacques Alain Miller on 'A and a in Clinical Structures'Shiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
On the Transference and the Counter-Transference
On the Transference and the Counter-TransferenceOn the Transference and the Counter-Transference
On the Transference and the Counter-TransferenceShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Lacanians on 'Identity and Identification'
Lacanians on 'Identity and Identification'Lacanians on 'Identity and Identification'
Lacanians on 'Identity and Identification'Shiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Sigmund Freud's Autobiographical Study
Sigmund Freud's Autobiographical StudySigmund Freud's Autobiographical Study
Sigmund Freud's Autobiographical StudyShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Jacques Lacan on Naricissism and the Ego (October 2016)
Jacques Lacan on Naricissism and the Ego (October 2016)Jacques Lacan on Naricissism and the Ego (October 2016)
Jacques Lacan on Naricissism and the Ego (October 2016)Shiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Review of The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis
Review of The Four Fundamental Concepts of PsychoanalysisReview of The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis
Review of The Four Fundamental Concepts of PsychoanalysisShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
On Sigmund Freud's 'Outline of Psychoanalysis'
On Sigmund Freud's 'Outline of Psychoanalysis'On Sigmund Freud's 'Outline of Psychoanalysis'
On Sigmund Freud's 'Outline of Psychoanalysis'Shiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Jacques-Alain Miller on The Analytic Cure
Jacques-Alain Miller on The Analytic CureJacques-Alain Miller on The Analytic Cure
Jacques-Alain Miller on The Analytic CureShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
On Clinical Techniques in Freud and Lacan, Clinical Notes Series
On Clinical Techniques in Freud and Lacan, Clinical Notes SeriesOn Clinical Techniques in Freud and Lacan, Clinical Notes Series
On Clinical Techniques in Freud and Lacan, Clinical Notes SeriesShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Donald Winnicott on the Mirroring Function
Donald Winnicott on the Mirroring FunctionDonald Winnicott on the Mirroring Function
Donald Winnicott on the Mirroring FunctionShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
On Lacanian Literary Criticism (October 2016)
On Lacanian Literary Criticism (October 2016)On Lacanian Literary Criticism (October 2016)
On Lacanian Literary Criticism (October 2016)Shiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
TEDx Manchester: AI & The Future of Work
TEDx Manchester: AI & The Future of WorkTEDx Manchester: AI & The Future of Work
TEDx Manchester: AI & The Future of WorkVolker Hirsch
 

Destacado (18)

Review of 'Psychoanalysis as History'
Review of 'Psychoanalysis as History'Review of 'Psychoanalysis as History'
Review of 'Psychoanalysis as History'
 
Jacques Alain Miller on 'A and a in Clinical Structures'
Jacques Alain Miller on 'A and a in Clinical Structures'Jacques Alain Miller on 'A and a in Clinical Structures'
Jacques Alain Miller on 'A and a in Clinical Structures'
 
On the Transference and the Counter-Transference
On the Transference and the Counter-TransferenceOn the Transference and the Counter-Transference
On the Transference and the Counter-Transference
 
Lacanians on 'Identity and Identification'
Lacanians on 'Identity and Identification'Lacanians on 'Identity and Identification'
Lacanians on 'Identity and Identification'
 
Sigmund Freud's Autobiographical Study
Sigmund Freud's Autobiographical StudySigmund Freud's Autobiographical Study
Sigmund Freud's Autobiographical Study
 
Bruce Fink on Desire
Bruce Fink on DesireBruce Fink on Desire
Bruce Fink on Desire
 
On the Psychoanalysis of Conflict
On the Psychoanalysis of ConflictOn the Psychoanalysis of Conflict
On the Psychoanalysis of Conflict
 
Stanley Leavy on Jacques Lacan
Stanley Leavy on Jacques LacanStanley Leavy on Jacques Lacan
Stanley Leavy on Jacques Lacan
 
Bruce Fink on Phone Analysis
Bruce Fink on Phone AnalysisBruce Fink on Phone Analysis
Bruce Fink on Phone Analysis
 
Jacques Lacan on Naricissism and the Ego (October 2016)
Jacques Lacan on Naricissism and the Ego (October 2016)Jacques Lacan on Naricissism and the Ego (October 2016)
Jacques Lacan on Naricissism and the Ego (October 2016)
 
Review of The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis
Review of The Four Fundamental Concepts of PsychoanalysisReview of The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis
Review of The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis
 
On Sigmund Freud's 'Outline of Psychoanalysis'
On Sigmund Freud's 'Outline of Psychoanalysis'On Sigmund Freud's 'Outline of Psychoanalysis'
On Sigmund Freud's 'Outline of Psychoanalysis'
 
Jacques-Alain Miller on The Analytic Cure
Jacques-Alain Miller on The Analytic CureJacques-Alain Miller on The Analytic Cure
Jacques-Alain Miller on The Analytic Cure
 
On Clinical Techniques in Freud and Lacan, Clinical Notes Series
On Clinical Techniques in Freud and Lacan, Clinical Notes SeriesOn Clinical Techniques in Freud and Lacan, Clinical Notes Series
On Clinical Techniques in Freud and Lacan, Clinical Notes Series
 
On Resistances to Psychoanalysis
On Resistances to PsychoanalysisOn Resistances to Psychoanalysis
On Resistances to Psychoanalysis
 
Donald Winnicott on the Mirroring Function
Donald Winnicott on the Mirroring FunctionDonald Winnicott on the Mirroring Function
Donald Winnicott on the Mirroring Function
 
On Lacanian Literary Criticism (October 2016)
On Lacanian Literary Criticism (October 2016)On Lacanian Literary Criticism (October 2016)
On Lacanian Literary Criticism (October 2016)
 
TEDx Manchester: AI & The Future of Work
TEDx Manchester: AI & The Future of WorkTEDx Manchester: AI & The Future of Work
TEDx Manchester: AI & The Future of Work
 

Similar a Review of 'Interpreting Lacan'

J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part II'
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part II'J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part II'
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part II'Shiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Jacques-Alain Miller on 'Lacan's Clinical Perspectives'
Jacques-Alain Miller on 'Lacan's Clinical Perspectives'Jacques-Alain Miller on 'Lacan's Clinical Perspectives'
Jacques-Alain Miller on 'Lacan's Clinical Perspectives'Shiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part III'
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part III'J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part III'
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part III'Shiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Review of A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian Psychoanalysis
Review of A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian PsychoanalysisReview of A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian Psychoanalysis
Review of A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian PsychoanalysisShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Ewrt 1 a class 17
Ewrt 1 a class 17Ewrt 1 a class 17
Ewrt 1 a class 17kimpalmore
 
Patrick Mahony - Psychoanalysis & Discourse
Patrick Mahony - Psychoanalysis & DiscoursePatrick Mahony - Psychoanalysis & Discourse
Patrick Mahony - Psychoanalysis & DiscoursePatrick Mahony
 
BOOK REVIEWS 87psychoanalytic frame of reference and deal .docx
BOOK REVIEWS 87psychoanalytic frame of reference and deal .docxBOOK REVIEWS 87psychoanalytic frame of reference and deal .docx
BOOK REVIEWS 87psychoanalytic frame of reference and deal .docxhartrobert670
 
A History of Psychology in Letters, Second EditionLudy T.docx
A History of Psychology in Letters, Second EditionLudy T.docxA History of Psychology in Letters, Second EditionLudy T.docx
A History of Psychology in Letters, Second EditionLudy T.docxsleeperharwell
 
Paul Schimmel (2014). Sigmund Freud’s Discovery of Psychoanalysis: Conquistad...
Paul Schimmel (2014). Sigmund Freud’s Discovery of Psychoanalysis: Conquistad...Paul Schimmel (2014). Sigmund Freud’s Discovery of Psychoanalysis: Conquistad...
Paul Schimmel (2014). Sigmund Freud’s Discovery of Psychoanalysis: Conquistad...iosrjce
 
Essay Communication Skills.pdf
Essay Communication Skills.pdfEssay Communication Skills.pdf
Essay Communication Skills.pdfLaura Cappabianca
 
Review of Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic Technique
Review of Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic TechniqueReview of Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic Technique
Review of Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic TechniqueShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Ewrt 1a class 22
Ewrt 1a class 22Ewrt 1a class 22
Ewrt 1a class 22kimpalmore
 

Similar a Review of 'Interpreting Lacan' (20)

Marcelle Marini on Jacques Lacan
Marcelle Marini on Jacques LacanMarcelle Marini on Jacques Lacan
Marcelle Marini on Jacques Lacan
 
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part II'
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part II'J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part II'
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part II'
 
Review of The Language of the Self
Review of The Language of the SelfReview of The Language of the Self
Review of The Language of the Self
 
Jacques-Alain Miller on 'Lacan's Clinical Perspectives'
Jacques-Alain Miller on 'Lacan's Clinical Perspectives'Jacques-Alain Miller on 'Lacan's Clinical Perspectives'
Jacques-Alain Miller on 'Lacan's Clinical Perspectives'
 
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part III'
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part III'J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part III'
J-A Miller on 'Lacan's Orientation Prior to 1953, Part III'
 
Bruce Fink on Interpreting
Bruce Fink on InterpretingBruce Fink on Interpreting
Bruce Fink on Interpreting
 
Bruce Fink on Psychosis
Bruce Fink on PsychosisBruce Fink on Psychosis
Bruce Fink on Psychosis
 
Jacques Lacan on the Unconscious
Jacques Lacan on the UnconsciousJacques Lacan on the Unconscious
Jacques Lacan on the Unconscious
 
Review of The Lacanian Subject
Review of The Lacanian SubjectReview of The Lacanian Subject
Review of The Lacanian Subject
 
Review of A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian Psychoanalysis
Review of A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian PsychoanalysisReview of A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian Psychoanalysis
Review of A Clinical Introduction to Lacanian Psychoanalysis
 
On The First Freudians
On The First FreudiansOn The First Freudians
On The First Freudians
 
Ewrt 1 a class 17
Ewrt 1 a class 17Ewrt 1 a class 17
Ewrt 1 a class 17
 
Patrick Mahony - Psychoanalysis & Discourse
Patrick Mahony - Psychoanalysis & DiscoursePatrick Mahony - Psychoanalysis & Discourse
Patrick Mahony - Psychoanalysis & Discourse
 
BOOK REVIEWS 87psychoanalytic frame of reference and deal .docx
BOOK REVIEWS 87psychoanalytic frame of reference and deal .docxBOOK REVIEWS 87psychoanalytic frame of reference and deal .docx
BOOK REVIEWS 87psychoanalytic frame of reference and deal .docx
 
A History of Psychology in Letters, Second EditionLudy T.docx
A History of Psychology in Letters, Second EditionLudy T.docxA History of Psychology in Letters, Second EditionLudy T.docx
A History of Psychology in Letters, Second EditionLudy T.docx
 
Paul Schimmel (2014). Sigmund Freud’s Discovery of Psychoanalysis: Conquistad...
Paul Schimmel (2014). Sigmund Freud’s Discovery of Psychoanalysis: Conquistad...Paul Schimmel (2014). Sigmund Freud’s Discovery of Psychoanalysis: Conquistad...
Paul Schimmel (2014). Sigmund Freud’s Discovery of Psychoanalysis: Conquistad...
 
Essay Communication Skills.pdf
Essay Communication Skills.pdfEssay Communication Skills.pdf
Essay Communication Skills.pdf
 
Review of Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic Technique
Review of Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic TechniqueReview of Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic Technique
Review of Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic Technique
 
Ewrt 1a class 22
Ewrt 1a class 22Ewrt 1a class 22
Ewrt 1a class 22
 
D7-EWRT 1A-HP
D7-EWRT 1A-HPD7-EWRT 1A-HP
D7-EWRT 1A-HP
 

Más de Shiva Kumar Srinivasan

Más de Shiva Kumar Srinivasan (10)

Donald Winnicott on Playing
Donald Winnicott on PlayingDonald Winnicott on Playing
Donald Winnicott on Playing
 
Review of Winnicott
Review of WinnicottReview of Winnicott
Review of Winnicott
 
On Transitional Objects
On Transitional ObjectsOn Transitional Objects
On Transitional Objects
 
Review of The Literature Machine
Review of The Literature MachineReview of The Literature Machine
Review of The Literature Machine
 
Review of Roland Barthes's Image Music Text
Review of Roland Barthes's  Image Music TextReview of Roland Barthes's  Image Music Text
Review of Roland Barthes's Image Music Text
 
Review of Roland Barthes's Camera Lucida
Review of Roland Barthes's Camera LucidaReview of Roland Barthes's Camera Lucida
Review of Roland Barthes's Camera Lucida
 
Review of The Key Concepts in Nietzsche
Review of The Key Concepts in NietzscheReview of The Key Concepts in Nietzsche
Review of The Key Concepts in Nietzsche
 
Review of On Beauty
Review of On BeautyReview of On Beauty
Review of On Beauty
 
Review of The Mirror and the Lamp
Review of The Mirror and the LampReview of The Mirror and the Lamp
Review of The Mirror and the Lamp
 
Review of Harold Bloom's The American Religion
Review of Harold Bloom's The American ReligionReview of Harold Bloom's The American Religion
Review of Harold Bloom's The American Religion
 

Último

power point presentation of Clinical evaluation of strabismus
power point presentation of Clinical evaluation  of strabismuspower point presentation of Clinical evaluation  of strabismus
power point presentation of Clinical evaluation of strabismusChandrasekar Reddy
 
High-Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)
High-Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)High-Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)
High-Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)kishan singh tomar
 
SGK LEUKEMIA KINH DÒNG BẠCH CÂU HẠT HAY.pdf
SGK LEUKEMIA KINH DÒNG BẠCH CÂU HẠT HAY.pdfSGK LEUKEMIA KINH DÒNG BẠCH CÂU HẠT HAY.pdf
SGK LEUKEMIA KINH DÒNG BẠCH CÂU HẠT HAY.pdfHongBiThi1
 
Clinical Research Informatics Year-in-Review 2024
Clinical Research Informatics Year-in-Review 2024Clinical Research Informatics Year-in-Review 2024
Clinical Research Informatics Year-in-Review 2024Peter Embi
 
Bulimia nervosa ( Eating Disorders) Mental Health Nursing.
Bulimia nervosa ( Eating Disorders) Mental Health Nursing.Bulimia nervosa ( Eating Disorders) Mental Health Nursing.
Bulimia nervosa ( Eating Disorders) Mental Health Nursing.aarjukhadka22
 
The Importance of Mental Health: Why is Mental Health Important?
The Importance of Mental Health: Why is Mental Health Important?The Importance of Mental Health: Why is Mental Health Important?
The Importance of Mental Health: Why is Mental Health Important?Ryan Addison
 
Using Data Visualization in Public Health Communications
Using Data Visualization in Public Health CommunicationsUsing Data Visualization in Public Health Communications
Using Data Visualization in Public Health Communicationskatiequigley33
 
How to cure cirrhosis and chronic hepatitis naturally
How to cure cirrhosis and chronic hepatitis naturallyHow to cure cirrhosis and chronic hepatitis naturally
How to cure cirrhosis and chronic hepatitis naturallyZurück zum Ursprung
 
Physiotherapy Management of Rheumatoid Arthritis
Physiotherapy Management of Rheumatoid ArthritisPhysiotherapy Management of Rheumatoid Arthritis
Physiotherapy Management of Rheumatoid ArthritisNilofarRasheed1
 
Microbiology lecture presentation-1.pptx
Microbiology lecture presentation-1.pptxMicrobiology lecture presentation-1.pptx
Microbiology lecture presentation-1.pptxkitati1
 
blood bank management system project report
blood bank management system project reportblood bank management system project report
blood bank management system project reportNARMADAPETROLEUMGAS
 
Male Infertility Panel Discussion by Dr Sujoy Dasgupta
Male Infertility Panel Discussion by Dr Sujoy DasguptaMale Infertility Panel Discussion by Dr Sujoy Dasgupta
Male Infertility Panel Discussion by Dr Sujoy DasguptaSujoy Dasgupta
 
"Radical excision of DIE in subferile women with deep infiltrating endometrio...
"Radical excision of DIE in subferile women with deep infiltrating endometrio..."Radical excision of DIE in subferile women with deep infiltrating endometrio...
"Radical excision of DIE in subferile women with deep infiltrating endometrio...Sujoy Dasgupta
 
Moving Forward After Uterine Cancer Treatment: Surveillance Strategies, Testi...
Moving Forward After Uterine Cancer Treatment: Surveillance Strategies, Testi...Moving Forward After Uterine Cancer Treatment: Surveillance Strategies, Testi...
Moving Forward After Uterine Cancer Treatment: Surveillance Strategies, Testi...bkling
 
Role of Soap based and synthetic or syndets bar
Role of  Soap based and synthetic or syndets barRole of  Soap based and synthetic or syndets bar
Role of Soap based and synthetic or syndets barmohitRahangdale
 
ayurvedic formulations herbal drug technologyppt
ayurvedic formulations herbal drug technologypptayurvedic formulations herbal drug technologyppt
ayurvedic formulations herbal drug technologypptPradnya Wadekar
 
Different drug regularity bodies in different countries.
Different drug regularity bodies in different countries.Different drug regularity bodies in different countries.
Different drug regularity bodies in different countries.kishan singh tomar
 
Adenomyosis or Fibroid- making right diagnosis
Adenomyosis or Fibroid- making right diagnosisAdenomyosis or Fibroid- making right diagnosis
Adenomyosis or Fibroid- making right diagnosisSujoy Dasgupta
 
Trustworthiness of AI based predictions Aachen 2024
Trustworthiness of AI based predictions Aachen 2024Trustworthiness of AI based predictions Aachen 2024
Trustworthiness of AI based predictions Aachen 2024EwoutSteyerberg1
 

Último (20)

power point presentation of Clinical evaluation of strabismus
power point presentation of Clinical evaluation  of strabismuspower point presentation of Clinical evaluation  of strabismus
power point presentation of Clinical evaluation of strabismus
 
High-Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)
High-Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)High-Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)
High-Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)
 
SGK LEUKEMIA KINH DÒNG BẠCH CÂU HẠT HAY.pdf
SGK LEUKEMIA KINH DÒNG BẠCH CÂU HẠT HAY.pdfSGK LEUKEMIA KINH DÒNG BẠCH CÂU HẠT HAY.pdf
SGK LEUKEMIA KINH DÒNG BẠCH CÂU HẠT HAY.pdf
 
Clinical Research Informatics Year-in-Review 2024
Clinical Research Informatics Year-in-Review 2024Clinical Research Informatics Year-in-Review 2024
Clinical Research Informatics Year-in-Review 2024
 
Bulimia nervosa ( Eating Disorders) Mental Health Nursing.
Bulimia nervosa ( Eating Disorders) Mental Health Nursing.Bulimia nervosa ( Eating Disorders) Mental Health Nursing.
Bulimia nervosa ( Eating Disorders) Mental Health Nursing.
 
The Importance of Mental Health: Why is Mental Health Important?
The Importance of Mental Health: Why is Mental Health Important?The Importance of Mental Health: Why is Mental Health Important?
The Importance of Mental Health: Why is Mental Health Important?
 
Using Data Visualization in Public Health Communications
Using Data Visualization in Public Health CommunicationsUsing Data Visualization in Public Health Communications
Using Data Visualization in Public Health Communications
 
How to cure cirrhosis and chronic hepatitis naturally
How to cure cirrhosis and chronic hepatitis naturallyHow to cure cirrhosis and chronic hepatitis naturally
How to cure cirrhosis and chronic hepatitis naturally
 
Physiotherapy Management of Rheumatoid Arthritis
Physiotherapy Management of Rheumatoid ArthritisPhysiotherapy Management of Rheumatoid Arthritis
Physiotherapy Management of Rheumatoid Arthritis
 
Microbiology lecture presentation-1.pptx
Microbiology lecture presentation-1.pptxMicrobiology lecture presentation-1.pptx
Microbiology lecture presentation-1.pptx
 
blood bank management system project report
blood bank management system project reportblood bank management system project report
blood bank management system project report
 
Male Infertility Panel Discussion by Dr Sujoy Dasgupta
Male Infertility Panel Discussion by Dr Sujoy DasguptaMale Infertility Panel Discussion by Dr Sujoy Dasgupta
Male Infertility Panel Discussion by Dr Sujoy Dasgupta
 
Cone beam CT: concepts and applications.pptx
Cone beam CT: concepts and applications.pptxCone beam CT: concepts and applications.pptx
Cone beam CT: concepts and applications.pptx
 
"Radical excision of DIE in subferile women with deep infiltrating endometrio...
"Radical excision of DIE in subferile women with deep infiltrating endometrio..."Radical excision of DIE in subferile women with deep infiltrating endometrio...
"Radical excision of DIE in subferile women with deep infiltrating endometrio...
 
Moving Forward After Uterine Cancer Treatment: Surveillance Strategies, Testi...
Moving Forward After Uterine Cancer Treatment: Surveillance Strategies, Testi...Moving Forward After Uterine Cancer Treatment: Surveillance Strategies, Testi...
Moving Forward After Uterine Cancer Treatment: Surveillance Strategies, Testi...
 
Role of Soap based and synthetic or syndets bar
Role of  Soap based and synthetic or syndets barRole of  Soap based and synthetic or syndets bar
Role of Soap based and synthetic or syndets bar
 
ayurvedic formulations herbal drug technologyppt
ayurvedic formulations herbal drug technologypptayurvedic formulations herbal drug technologyppt
ayurvedic formulations herbal drug technologyppt
 
Different drug regularity bodies in different countries.
Different drug regularity bodies in different countries.Different drug regularity bodies in different countries.
Different drug regularity bodies in different countries.
 
Adenomyosis or Fibroid- making right diagnosis
Adenomyosis or Fibroid- making right diagnosisAdenomyosis or Fibroid- making right diagnosis
Adenomyosis or Fibroid- making right diagnosis
 
Trustworthiness of AI based predictions Aachen 2024
Trustworthiness of AI based predictions Aachen 2024Trustworthiness of AI based predictions Aachen 2024
Trustworthiness of AI based predictions Aachen 2024
 

Review of 'Interpreting Lacan'

  • 1. 1 BOOK REVIEW ON INTERPRETING JACQUES LACAN Joseph H. Smith and William Kerrigan (Eds.) Interpreting Lacan, Forum on Psychiatry and the Humanities Series, Vol. 6, The Washington School of Psychiatry (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1983), ISBN 0-300-03039-8 INTRODUCTION This anthology of essays on Lacanian psychoanalysis was put together in 1983 to demonstrate the importance of Lacanian theory for clinical practitioners in the United States. Most of these practitioners were ego psychologists by training. Many of them had either read about or heard about Lacan from literary critics, but were not aware of how to go actually about applying or using Lacan as clinicians. They also needed to understand what the differences were between ego psychology and the clinical techniques associated with Lacanian psychoanalysis. The editorial intention in this volume then should be clear. It is an attempt to clear the space necessary for the incorporation of Jacques Lacan into mainstream American psychoanalysis under the auspices of the Washington School of Psychiatry. This book is the sixth volume of essays in this series published by the Forum on Humanities and Psychiatry that is affiliated to the Washington School. It brings together clinicians, literary critics, and philosophers in order to integrate their respective insights on the human sciences. The essays collected here fall into three categories. It starts with the clinical essays before situating the clinical dimension in relation to philosophy and psychoanalytic theory. The third and final part is about applying Lacanian theory in the context of literary criticism. There are twelve essays in this volume including the introduction and epilogue. The contributors are mainly drawn from the ranks of clinicians, psychologists, and philosophers in the United States and Europe. The editors, needless to say, will gauge the success of their efforts in this volume mainly in terms of making Lacanian insights attractive for clinical work. But, in order to make this possible, they have to explain the linguistic and philosophical background that animates Lacanian theory. So while they start by
  • 2. 2 engaging with the clinical aspects, the better part of this volume is an attempt to relate the structure of Lacanian theory to European philosophers like Hegel and Heidegger. That is because Lacan takes for granted the reader’s familiarity with the resonance of philosophical terms like ‘desire’ and ‘being’ in his seminars and writings on psychoanalysis in France. But, as the editors know only too well, this knowledge cannot be assumed outside the Parisian intellectual milieu in which Lacan spent his entire career. An important editorial task for them is to find ways of letting the philosophical knowledge that is necessary to situate Lacanian theory percolate into the mainstream of American ego psychology without talking down to their readers. Needless to say, this is not the only effort on the part of Smith and Kerrigan to explain Lacanian theory to American audiences. Another important aspect of their editorial efforts is to also provide a reception history of Lacanian psychoanalysis in the United States. This they do in their comments in the introduction and the epilogue by relating psychoanalysis to areas like biology, ego- psychology, and the social sciences. The significance of this volume, we must note in retrospect, is the fact that it met with considerable success. The editors did manage to impress upon American clinicians that Lacanian theory is of interest to not only linguists, literary critics, and philosophers; but has a lot to teach full-time clinicians as well. THE EDITORIAL INTENTION The first part of this volume sets out some of the topics that were of immediate interest to clinicians. These included but were not limited to terms like image, language, the subject, the psychoses, the unconscious, the word, and the scope of the ‘talking cure.’ Another important analytic distinction is the difference between empty speech and full speech since the cure depends on whether the patient is able to go beyond the imaginary dimension of empty speech and embrace the symbolic gains of full speech. I have not listed all the topics of interest to American clinicians but mainly those which they felt the need to redefine in the light of the Lacanian intervention. So, for instance, clinicians began to appreciate the ‘onto-theological’ dimensions of everyday terms like ‘image, language, and the word’ after reading Lacan. It is important to remember that American theologians were as interested in Lacan as were American philosophers teaching continental philosophy. While describing the response of theologians to Lacanian theory is beyond the scope of this review, we must at least note that learning to appreciate the onto-theological dimensions of a theory of the subject made it easier for clinicians to appreciate that while ‘the word’ is all that they really have to work with in the clinic, it is not something that they should be ashamed of. The theoretical difference between the neuroses and the psychoses was also important for the editors since most clinicians who have a background in psychiatry (as opposed to psychoanalysis) have to take
  • 3. 3 on a number of psychotics and patients afflicted with borderline phenomena. So it become important to know whether French clinicians trained in the Lacanian tradition recognize borderline phenomena (like English clinicians do). And what the relevant cultural differences might be between the clinician traditions in England, France, and America in matters pertaining to ‘differential diagnosis.’ Furthermore, there is an important difference between merely situating the roles that words and images play in constituting the patient’s unconscious, like Sigmund Freud himself does when he differentiates between word and thing presentations; and relating them, as Lacan does, to theories of the symbolic and the imaginary. That is why it is important to understand that in addition to his knowledge of structural linguistics; Lacan’s religious background as a Catholic; his interest in patristics (as a possible source for his theories of the ‘name-of-the-father’); and the theoretical controversies that bear an interesting parallel between doctrinal squabbles in the Church and within and between the different schools of psychoanalysis. In other words, the history of analytic doctrine cannot be wished away in the attempts to make a science or a clinical practice out of psychoanalysis in America or Europe. PHILOSOPHY OF PSYCHOANALYSIS The definition of the unconscious is also at stake in these editorial interventions because invoking terms like the ‘discourse of the Other’ and the ‘desire of the Other’ have immediate theological implications; as does the relationship between the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit in the Catholic communion. So while we do not expect ego-psychologists to be interested in literary criticism, philosophy, and theology from a clinical point of view, these aspects of Lacanian theory occupy the better part of what the contributors to this book are willing to engage with. That then, briefly put, is the main challenge for the editors. There is a difference between telling literary critics that they must brush up on philosophy and theology in order to read Jacques Derrida and Jacques Lacan, but saying that with a straight face to practical clinicians is another ball game altogether. And, as if that educational challenge were not enough, the editors also make it clear that Lacan has his own interpretation of the structural anthropology of Claude Lévi-Strauss and the structural linguistics of Ferdinand de Saussure. In other words, the Lacanian theory of the word, language, and the unconscious demands an understanding of the linguistic dimensions of the unconscious. The main difficulty here is that ego- psychologists had got used to conflating the id with the unconscious and would use these terms as though they were synonyms or condense them into the ‘unconscious id’ and the ‘conscious ego’ even though Freud explains that the better part of the ego is itself unconscious. In other words, what was at stake for Lacan was the conflation of the structural and descriptive models of the psyche in ego-psychology. If working simultaneously with the structural, descriptive, and dynamic models was so difficult
  • 4. 4 for clinicians, how will they find the intellectual means necessary to grapple with the theories of Jacques Lacan? While the answer to this question is still not clear to those who would like to explain or teach Lacanian theory, it is a question that we must face up to with brutal honesty. It would not be a stretch to point out that this is the main question that haunts this volume of essays. LACANIAN THEORY & AMERICAN PRACTICE Will the incorporation of Lacanian theory into American practice demand so much? Furthermore, will all these intellectual demands have to be addressed at once? Should analysts attempt to ‘use Lacan’ in the American clinic only when they have learnt this much theory? Or, is it possible to incorporate Lacanian theory in a more modest way? The impression conveyed in this volume is that Lacanian theory cannot be separated from Lacanian practice. It is therefore important to take in all of Lacan or as much Lacan as possible. This however does not mean that clinicians who have never read Hegel, Heidegger, or any of the continental philosophers should stay away from Lacanian psychoanalysis. But, at the same time, clinicians who do not even suspect the existence of such philosophers or any of the existential and structural dimensions of analytic theory will probably not find Lacan important in their intellectual or clinical lives. That, simply put, is the editorial quandary in this volume and in other books in this series on ‘interpreting Lacan.’ An interest in continental philosophy, or the French model of the human sciences, cannot be legislated into the history of clinical work in America; but it is nonetheless necessary to some extent to avoid clinical mishaps. And, finally, Lacan assumes that psychiatrists and ego psychologists with a medical background will begin to engage sooner or later with the theoretical dimensions of clinical practice. The burden of this book review is to argue that those who do not do this will simply not derive adequate value in becoming either full-fledged Lacanians or in even engaging with Lacanian theory. They will at best read Lacan for his polemics rather than for his far reaching clinical insights. SHIVA KUMAR SRINIVASAN