SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 3
Descargar para leer sin conexión
ADVERTISEMENT
Sign In | Register 0
Subscription Center
Subscribe to All Access »
Subscribe to Print »
Give a Gift »
View the Latest Issue »
Subscribe News & Features Topics Blogs Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Books SA en español
Courtesy of Simbol Materials
Energy & Sustainability » News
Geothermal Power Plants Could Help
Produce Lithium for Electric Cars
A new process aims to extract lithium from the brines used to generate electricity in a
geothermal power plant
By David Biello | September 29, 2011
An industrial add-on to geothermal power
plants near the Salton Sea in California
could one day produce the lithium that is
required for electric car batteries. Already,
Simbol Materials, the company behind the
process, has begun purifying lithium from
conventional mining operations in
Argentina, Chile and elsewhere for the
global battery market at a demonstration
facility in Brawley, Calif.
"We developed the technology and the
process to take the brines coming out of
geothermal power plants' post–power
production and harvest lithium, manganese,
zinc and, maybe in the future, some other
materials, and we convert those into usable
compounds," says Simbol CEO Luka Erceg.
"We're essentially leveraging the best
renewable resource and co-producing
strategic materials."
After geothermal power plants pump up a hot brine—water and dissolved salts from
underground—and use its heat to make steam to spin a turbine and generate
electricity, Simbol would borrow the still warm fluid for roughly 90 minutes. A
pipeline would carry the brine through a series of processes that remove the silica in
the brine (it would otherwise foul the works) and then use a series of membranes,
filters and adsorption materials to extract valuable elements like lithium. The
extraction method was developed at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, which
is primarily funded by the U.S. Department of Energy. Simbol then adds water to
make up for the lost material and sends it back to the geothermal power plant for
re-injection underground.
The company plans to expand its initial lithium purification facility in 2012 as well as
begin construction on the geothermal-tied version as an addition to such power plants
being built in the region by EnergySource. Already, there are 10 geothermal power
plants in the Imperial Valley. "You can produce 16,000 metric tons of lithium
carbonate for every 50-megawatt geothermal power plant," Erceg notes.
As a result of re-injection, the company will not be left with the residue from
traditional lithium mining. Plus, instead of relying on hard rock mining as is typical of
production today, Simbol lets the hot water of the subsurface Salton Sea do the work
of leaching the materials out of the rock as well as purifying them into salts—a process
that involves evaporating water from lithium ponds for other producers around the
world, including in the U.S.
Also, the company would not need to purchase soda ash to enable production of
5 :: Email :: Print
Follow Us:
More from Scientific American
ADVERTISEMENT
More to Explore
Stop Mining for Oil (and Coal), Start Drilling for
Heat
How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's
Resources
Hot Rocks: Tapping an Underutilized Renewable
Resource
Salt 'n Power: A First Look at the Lithium Flats
of Bolivia [Slide Show]
How National Security Depends on Better
Lithium Batteries
    
More on this Topic
Electric Cars and Peak Lithium
Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Elect... http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/geothermal-power-pl...
1 of 3 5/28/15, 9:56 AM
Share this Article:
lithium carbonate, as is typically done today. Instead, Simbol will take advantage of
waste carbon dioxide from the geothermal power plant itself to create the material.
Another economic advantage of Simbol's lithium process is its location: a mere 320
kilometers from southern California's three major ports and not thousands of meters
above sea level, as are the major mines in South America that provide most of the
world's lithium today. It remains to be seen, however, if Simbol's product can compete
with that generated by the big producers in Argentina, Australia, Chile and, in the
future, Bolivia.
The Salton Sea brine contains a host of other elements, and Simbol hopes to extend
the extraction process to manganese and zinc—also used in batteries and metal
alloys—as well as potassium, which is a vital nutrient and fertilizer, among other
applications. "This brine has got half the periodic table in it and that's a good
news–bad news situation," Erceg says, noting that cesium, rubidium and silver might
also be produced the same way. The company is also exploring options for using the
process's waste silica—more commonly known as sand—in the cement industry.
But the 500 metric tons per year of lithium from this initial purification facility will
not be going to U.S.-based battery-makers, at least not yet. Instead, the ITOCHU
Corp., a Japanese partner of Simbol, will sell the purified lithium to battery-makers on
the other side of the Pacific Ocean. "The initial output of this plant, we expect to go to
Asia," Erceg notes. "The reality is, today, for lithium ion batteries, manufacturing still
means Asia."
See Also:
1. Fact or Fiction?: A "Base Tan" Can Protect against Sunburn 6 days ago
Rights & Permissions
Recommended For You
1. Where Is Human Evolution Taking Us? 8 months ago
scientificamerican.com ScientificAmerican.com Features
2.
Can You Solve a Puzzle Unsolved Since 1996? 7 months ago scientificamerican.com
ScientificAmerican.com Web Exclusives
3. Fact or Fiction?: A "Base Tan" Can Protect against Sunburn 6 days
ago scientificamerican.com ScientificAmerican.com WELLNESS
Comments
Oldest - Newest
       
September 29, 2011, 3:15 PMJamesDavis
Why can't America build that purification plant at each geothermal plant and use the lithium and
other minerals to make batteries here and pay for it with the other minerals extracted from the
brine? It seems it would be a win win for both geothermal and lithium batteries in this country.
And that seems to be a very easy way to mine lithium. Why can't America think of these things
first?
Report as Abuse | Link to This
September 29, 2011, 3:16 PMJamesDavis
Why can't America build that purification plant at each geothermal plant and use the lithium and
other minerals to make batteries here and pay for it with the other minerals extracted from the
brine? It seems it would be a win win for both geothermal and lithium batteries in this country.
And that seems to be a very easy way to mine lithium. Why can't America think of these things
first?
Report as Abuse | Link to This
Most Popular
Cuteness Inspires
Aggression
Fact or Fiction?: A "Base
Tan" Can Protect against
Sunburn
How Smart Should the
President Be?
Giant Black Holes May Be
on a Collision Course
Moore's Law Keeps Going,
Defying Expectations
Solve Innovation Challenges
Create Accessories to Enhance the Driving
Experience
Deadline: Jun 14 2015
Reward: $$1155,,000000UUSSDD
Vehicles traveling in remote regions or through
rugged terrain have unique durability requirements
and often experience delays in obtain
UKWIR Challenge: Detecting the Build-up of
Blockages in Complex Fluid Networks
Deadline: Jun 11 2015
Reward: $$1155,,000000UUSSDD
The United Kingdom Water Industry Research
(UKWIR) is seeking innovative solutions to detect the
formation of blockages on the networks
Powered By:
ADVERTISEMENT
Latest from SA Blog Network
Climate Change Low Among Our Keystone
Pipeline Concerns
Plugged In | 1 hour ago
Black Hole "Blazars" Reveal Hidden Side of the
Universe [Video]
Observations | 1 hour ago
The Essentials of Energy
Plugged In | May 27, 2015
Mysterious Disease Threatens Australian Turtle
with Immediate Extinction
Extinction Countdown | May 27, 2015
Solar Start-Ups Focus on Soft-Costs at SunShot
Catalyst Competition
Plugged In | May 27, 2015
News From Our Partners
Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Elect... http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/geothermal-power-pl...
2 of 3 5/28/15, 9:56 AM
YYEESS!!Send me a free issue of Scientific
American with no obligation to continue
the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed
for the one-year subscription.
Advertise
Special Ad Sections
SA Custom Media and
Partnerships
Science Jobs
Partner Network
International Editions
Travel
Use of Cookies
About Scientific American
Press Room
Site Map
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Contact Us
Subscribe
Renew Your Print Subscription
Print Subscriber Customer
Service
Buy Back Issues
FAQs
© 2015 Scientific American, a Division of Nature America, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
October 2, 2011, 9:35 PMGord Davison  JamesDavis
Because america's government is manipulated by powerful industries that work for their own
profitability.
Report as Abuse | Link to This
October 19, 2011, 9:19 AMhamidsadeghipour
Take the periodic table as columns of 2,8,816,16,…with the H, Li, Na, K, Rb, on the top of The
columns respectively. You have on the second diagonal Li, Mg, Sc, and what the exploratory
organizations didn’t say Zr,…
On the first diagonal you have: H, Be, Al, Ti, Nb,..
On the third: Na, Ca, Y, Hf….
Nobody is to say which one appear after digging the wells.
Report as Abuse | Link to This
October 19, 2011, 9:20 AMhamidsadeghipour
sorry for mistake of 816
Take the periodic table as columns of 2,8,8,16,16,…with the H, Li, Na, K, Rb, on the top of The
columns respectively. You have on the second diagonal Li, Mg, Sc, and what the exploratory
organizations didn’t say Zr,…
On the first diagonal you have: H, Be, Al, Ti, Nb,..
On the third: Na, Ca, Y, Hf….
Nobody is to say which one appear after digging the wells.
Report as Abuse | Link to This
Doctors' Leave Cancelled as Heat Wave Kills
1,100 in India
New Human Ancestor Discovered Near Fossil of
“Lucy”
Weightlessness Tackled in New Research
Journal
What Australia Can Teach the World about
Surviving Drought
We Create Chemistry......sponsored by BASF
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Solar Energy
Go Solar for $0 Down with
Sunrun. Save 20% On Your
Home Energy Bill.
Subscribe Now
Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Elect... http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/geothermal-power-pl...
3 of 3 5/28/15, 9:56 AM

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Electric Cars - Scientific American

Lithium Mining Investment Issues
Lithium Mining Investment IssuesLithium Mining Investment Issues
Lithium Mining Investment IssuesInvestingTips
 
SQM Lithium OverSupply Scare 2.0
SQM Lithium OverSupply Scare 2.0SQM Lithium OverSupply Scare 2.0
SQM Lithium OverSupply Scare 2.0Kirill Klip
 
Simon Moores Testimony US Senate Energy Committee - Feb 2019
Simon Moores Testimony US Senate Energy Committee - Feb 2019Simon Moores Testimony US Senate Energy Committee - Feb 2019
Simon Moores Testimony US Senate Energy Committee - Feb 2019Roger Atkins
 
Tesla Mission Statement
Tesla Mission StatementTesla Mission Statement
Tesla Mission StatementKaren Thompson
 
Lithium Supply & Markets 2010 Chairman\'s Opening Speech
Lithium Supply & Markets 2010 Chairman\'s Opening SpeechLithium Supply & Markets 2010 Chairman\'s Opening Speech
Lithium Supply & Markets 2010 Chairman\'s Opening SpeechSimon Moores
 
Future Trends - Recycling - Batteries
Future Trends - Recycling - BatteriesFuture Trends - Recycling - Batteries
Future Trends - Recycling - BatteriesBruce LaCour
 
The lithium market is growing here is a very interesting commentary from cana...
The lithium market is growing here is a very interesting commentary from cana...The lithium market is growing here is a very interesting commentary from cana...
The lithium market is growing here is a very interesting commentary from cana...Christopher R Anderson
 
International Lithium at Wentworth Presentation.
International Lithium at Wentworth Presentation.International Lithium at Wentworth Presentation.
International Lithium at Wentworth Presentation.Kirill Klip
 
China's State Grid Is Getting Ready For 100 Million Electric Cars By 2030 In ...
China's State Grid Is Getting Ready For 100 Million Electric Cars By 2030 In ...China's State Grid Is Getting Ready For 100 Million Electric Cars By 2030 In ...
China's State Grid Is Getting Ready For 100 Million Electric Cars By 2030 In ...Kirill Klip
 
Objective Capital Rare Earth and Minor Metals Investment Summit: Where will f...
Objective Capital Rare Earth and Minor Metals Investment Summit: Where will f...Objective Capital Rare Earth and Minor Metals Investment Summit: Where will f...
Objective Capital Rare Earth and Minor Metals Investment Summit: Where will f...Objective Capital Conferences
 
New Wave of Electrical Vehicles - April 2018
New Wave of Electrical Vehicles - April 2018New Wave of Electrical Vehicles - April 2018
New Wave of Electrical Vehicles - April 2018paul young cpa, cga
 
Tesla Motors, Panasonic J-V for Gigafactory - Simon Moores Research Note
Tesla Motors, Panasonic J-V for Gigafactory - Simon Moores Research NoteTesla Motors, Panasonic J-V for Gigafactory - Simon Moores Research Note
Tesla Motors, Panasonic J-V for Gigafactory - Simon Moores Research NoteSimon Moores
 
Electrical Vehicles| All you need to know| March 2019
Electrical Vehicles| All you need to know| March 2019Electrical Vehicles| All you need to know| March 2019
Electrical Vehicles| All you need to know| March 2019paul young cpa, cga
 

Similar a Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Electric Cars - Scientific American (20)

Lithium Mining Investment Issues
Lithium Mining Investment IssuesLithium Mining Investment Issues
Lithium Mining Investment Issues
 
SQM Lithium OverSupply Scare 2.0
SQM Lithium OverSupply Scare 2.0SQM Lithium OverSupply Scare 2.0
SQM Lithium OverSupply Scare 2.0
 
Simon Moores Testimony US Senate Energy Committee - Feb 2019
Simon Moores Testimony US Senate Energy Committee - Feb 2019Simon Moores Testimony US Senate Energy Committee - Feb 2019
Simon Moores Testimony US Senate Energy Committee - Feb 2019
 
Tesla Mission Statement
Tesla Mission StatementTesla Mission Statement
Tesla Mission Statement
 
Lithium Supply & Markets 2010 Chairman\'s Opening Speech
Lithium Supply & Markets 2010 Chairman\'s Opening SpeechLithium Supply & Markets 2010 Chairman\'s Opening Speech
Lithium Supply & Markets 2010 Chairman\'s Opening Speech
 
Future Trends - Recycling - Batteries
Future Trends - Recycling - BatteriesFuture Trends - Recycling - Batteries
Future Trends - Recycling - Batteries
 
Lithium oversupply?
Lithium oversupply?Lithium oversupply?
Lithium oversupply?
 
The lithium market is growing here is a very interesting commentary from cana...
The lithium market is growing here is a very interesting commentary from cana...The lithium market is growing here is a very interesting commentary from cana...
The lithium market is growing here is a very interesting commentary from cana...
 
CYP Investor Presentation
CYP Investor PresentationCYP Investor Presentation
CYP Investor Presentation
 
Energy (Krems)
Energy (Krems)Energy (Krems)
Energy (Krems)
 
Lithium market report -Dundee Securities--102809
Lithium market report -Dundee Securities--102809Lithium market report -Dundee Securities--102809
Lithium market report -Dundee Securities--102809
 
International Lithium at Wentworth Presentation.
International Lithium at Wentworth Presentation.International Lithium at Wentworth Presentation.
International Lithium at Wentworth Presentation.
 
Scientific Metals Corp Presentation 2017
Scientific Metals Corp Presentation 2017  Scientific Metals Corp Presentation 2017
Scientific Metals Corp Presentation 2017
 
China's State Grid Is Getting Ready For 100 Million Electric Cars By 2030 In ...
China's State Grid Is Getting Ready For 100 Million Electric Cars By 2030 In ...China's State Grid Is Getting Ready For 100 Million Electric Cars By 2030 In ...
China's State Grid Is Getting Ready For 100 Million Electric Cars By 2030 In ...
 
Objective Capital Rare Earth and Minor Metals Investment Summit: Where will f...
Objective Capital Rare Earth and Minor Metals Investment Summit: Where will f...Objective Capital Rare Earth and Minor Metals Investment Summit: Where will f...
Objective Capital Rare Earth and Minor Metals Investment Summit: Where will f...
 
New Wave of Electrical Vehicles - April 2018
New Wave of Electrical Vehicles - April 2018New Wave of Electrical Vehicles - April 2018
New Wave of Electrical Vehicles - April 2018
 
Tesla Motors, Panasonic J-V for Gigafactory - Simon Moores Research Note
Tesla Motors, Panasonic J-V for Gigafactory - Simon Moores Research NoteTesla Motors, Panasonic J-V for Gigafactory - Simon Moores Research Note
Tesla Motors, Panasonic J-V for Gigafactory - Simon Moores Research Note
 
Energy 5 09
Energy 5 09Energy 5 09
Energy 5 09
 
Conserving Energy and Going Green Class 5 Gulf Coast Community College Encore
Conserving Energy and Going Green Class 5 Gulf Coast Community College EncoreConserving Energy and Going Green Class 5 Gulf Coast Community College Encore
Conserving Energy and Going Green Class 5 Gulf Coast Community College Encore
 
Electrical Vehicles| All you need to know| March 2019
Electrical Vehicles| All you need to know| March 2019Electrical Vehicles| All you need to know| March 2019
Electrical Vehicles| All you need to know| March 2019
 

Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Electric Cars - Scientific American

  • 1. ADVERTISEMENT Sign In | Register 0 Subscription Center Subscribe to All Access » Subscribe to Print » Give a Gift » View the Latest Issue » Subscribe News & Features Topics Blogs Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Books SA en español Courtesy of Simbol Materials Energy & Sustainability » News Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Electric Cars A new process aims to extract lithium from the brines used to generate electricity in a geothermal power plant By David Biello | September 29, 2011 An industrial add-on to geothermal power plants near the Salton Sea in California could one day produce the lithium that is required for electric car batteries. Already, Simbol Materials, the company behind the process, has begun purifying lithium from conventional mining operations in Argentina, Chile and elsewhere for the global battery market at a demonstration facility in Brawley, Calif. "We developed the technology and the process to take the brines coming out of geothermal power plants' post–power production and harvest lithium, manganese, zinc and, maybe in the future, some other materials, and we convert those into usable compounds," says Simbol CEO Luka Erceg. "We're essentially leveraging the best renewable resource and co-producing strategic materials." After geothermal power plants pump up a hot brine—water and dissolved salts from underground—and use its heat to make steam to spin a turbine and generate electricity, Simbol would borrow the still warm fluid for roughly 90 minutes. A pipeline would carry the brine through a series of processes that remove the silica in the brine (it would otherwise foul the works) and then use a series of membranes, filters and adsorption materials to extract valuable elements like lithium. The extraction method was developed at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, which is primarily funded by the U.S. Department of Energy. Simbol then adds water to make up for the lost material and sends it back to the geothermal power plant for re-injection underground. The company plans to expand its initial lithium purification facility in 2012 as well as begin construction on the geothermal-tied version as an addition to such power plants being built in the region by EnergySource. Already, there are 10 geothermal power plants in the Imperial Valley. "You can produce 16,000 metric tons of lithium carbonate for every 50-megawatt geothermal power plant," Erceg notes. As a result of re-injection, the company will not be left with the residue from traditional lithium mining. Plus, instead of relying on hard rock mining as is typical of production today, Simbol lets the hot water of the subsurface Salton Sea do the work of leaching the materials out of the rock as well as purifying them into salts—a process that involves evaporating water from lithium ponds for other producers around the world, including in the U.S. Also, the company would not need to purchase soda ash to enable production of 5 :: Email :: Print Follow Us: More from Scientific American ADVERTISEMENT More to Explore Stop Mining for Oil (and Coal), Start Drilling for Heat How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources Hot Rocks: Tapping an Underutilized Renewable Resource Salt 'n Power: A First Look at the Lithium Flats of Bolivia [Slide Show] How National Security Depends on Better Lithium Batteries      More on this Topic Electric Cars and Peak Lithium Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Elect... http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/geothermal-power-pl... 1 of 3 5/28/15, 9:56 AM
  • 2. Share this Article: lithium carbonate, as is typically done today. Instead, Simbol will take advantage of waste carbon dioxide from the geothermal power plant itself to create the material. Another economic advantage of Simbol's lithium process is its location: a mere 320 kilometers from southern California's three major ports and not thousands of meters above sea level, as are the major mines in South America that provide most of the world's lithium today. It remains to be seen, however, if Simbol's product can compete with that generated by the big producers in Argentina, Australia, Chile and, in the future, Bolivia. The Salton Sea brine contains a host of other elements, and Simbol hopes to extend the extraction process to manganese and zinc—also used in batteries and metal alloys—as well as potassium, which is a vital nutrient and fertilizer, among other applications. "This brine has got half the periodic table in it and that's a good news–bad news situation," Erceg says, noting that cesium, rubidium and silver might also be produced the same way. The company is also exploring options for using the process's waste silica—more commonly known as sand—in the cement industry. But the 500 metric tons per year of lithium from this initial purification facility will not be going to U.S.-based battery-makers, at least not yet. Instead, the ITOCHU Corp., a Japanese partner of Simbol, will sell the purified lithium to battery-makers on the other side of the Pacific Ocean. "The initial output of this plant, we expect to go to Asia," Erceg notes. "The reality is, today, for lithium ion batteries, manufacturing still means Asia." See Also: 1. Fact or Fiction?: A "Base Tan" Can Protect against Sunburn 6 days ago Rights & Permissions Recommended For You 1. Where Is Human Evolution Taking Us? 8 months ago scientificamerican.com ScientificAmerican.com Features 2. Can You Solve a Puzzle Unsolved Since 1996? 7 months ago scientificamerican.com ScientificAmerican.com Web Exclusives 3. Fact or Fiction?: A "Base Tan" Can Protect against Sunburn 6 days ago scientificamerican.com ScientificAmerican.com WELLNESS Comments Oldest - Newest         September 29, 2011, 3:15 PMJamesDavis Why can't America build that purification plant at each geothermal plant and use the lithium and other minerals to make batteries here and pay for it with the other minerals extracted from the brine? It seems it would be a win win for both geothermal and lithium batteries in this country. And that seems to be a very easy way to mine lithium. Why can't America think of these things first? Report as Abuse | Link to This September 29, 2011, 3:16 PMJamesDavis Why can't America build that purification plant at each geothermal plant and use the lithium and other minerals to make batteries here and pay for it with the other minerals extracted from the brine? It seems it would be a win win for both geothermal and lithium batteries in this country. And that seems to be a very easy way to mine lithium. Why can't America think of these things first? Report as Abuse | Link to This Most Popular Cuteness Inspires Aggression Fact or Fiction?: A "Base Tan" Can Protect against Sunburn How Smart Should the President Be? Giant Black Holes May Be on a Collision Course Moore's Law Keeps Going, Defying Expectations Solve Innovation Challenges Create Accessories to Enhance the Driving Experience Deadline: Jun 14 2015 Reward: $$1155,,000000UUSSDD Vehicles traveling in remote regions or through rugged terrain have unique durability requirements and often experience delays in obtain UKWIR Challenge: Detecting the Build-up of Blockages in Complex Fluid Networks Deadline: Jun 11 2015 Reward: $$1155,,000000UUSSDD The United Kingdom Water Industry Research (UKWIR) is seeking innovative solutions to detect the formation of blockages on the networks Powered By: ADVERTISEMENT Latest from SA Blog Network Climate Change Low Among Our Keystone Pipeline Concerns Plugged In | 1 hour ago Black Hole "Blazars" Reveal Hidden Side of the Universe [Video] Observations | 1 hour ago The Essentials of Energy Plugged In | May 27, 2015 Mysterious Disease Threatens Australian Turtle with Immediate Extinction Extinction Countdown | May 27, 2015 Solar Start-Ups Focus on Soft-Costs at SunShot Catalyst Competition Plugged In | May 27, 2015 News From Our Partners Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Elect... http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/geothermal-power-pl... 2 of 3 5/28/15, 9:56 AM
  • 3. YYEESS!!Send me a free issue of Scientific American with no obligation to continue the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed for the one-year subscription. Advertise Special Ad Sections SA Custom Media and Partnerships Science Jobs Partner Network International Editions Travel Use of Cookies About Scientific American Press Room Site Map Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us Subscribe Renew Your Print Subscription Print Subscriber Customer Service Buy Back Issues FAQs © 2015 Scientific American, a Division of Nature America, Inc. All Rights Reserved. You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment. October 2, 2011, 9:35 PMGord Davison  JamesDavis Because america's government is manipulated by powerful industries that work for their own profitability. Report as Abuse | Link to This October 19, 2011, 9:19 AMhamidsadeghipour Take the periodic table as columns of 2,8,816,16,…with the H, Li, Na, K, Rb, on the top of The columns respectively. You have on the second diagonal Li, Mg, Sc, and what the exploratory organizations didn’t say Zr,… On the first diagonal you have: H, Be, Al, Ti, Nb,.. On the third: Na, Ca, Y, Hf…. Nobody is to say which one appear after digging the wells. Report as Abuse | Link to This October 19, 2011, 9:20 AMhamidsadeghipour sorry for mistake of 816 Take the periodic table as columns of 2,8,8,16,16,…with the H, Li, Na, K, Rb, on the top of The columns respectively. You have on the second diagonal Li, Mg, Sc, and what the exploratory organizations didn’t say Zr,… On the first diagonal you have: H, Be, Al, Ti, Nb,.. On the third: Na, Ca, Y, Hf…. Nobody is to say which one appear after digging the wells. Report as Abuse | Link to This Doctors' Leave Cancelled as Heat Wave Kills 1,100 in India New Human Ancestor Discovered Near Fossil of “Lucy” Weightlessness Tackled in New Research Journal What Australia Can Teach the World about Surviving Drought We Create Chemistry......sponsored by BASF ADVERTISEMENT ADVERTISEMENT Home Solar Energy Go Solar for $0 Down with Sunrun. Save 20% On Your Home Energy Bill. Subscribe Now Geothermal Power Plants Could Help Produce Lithium for Elect... http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/geothermal-power-pl... 3 of 3 5/28/15, 9:56 AM