Pitfalls in trying to figure out what consumers want
1. Center for Management Development
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out
What Consumers Really Want
John Patrick Finn, Ph.D.
Rutgers Business School
&
Cahill Finn Associates
Presented at ProductCamp NYC
November 6, 2010
held at Microsoft Offices, New York
2. Center for Management Development
“Rule #1 -- The Customer is Always Right”
“Rule #2 - If the Customer is Ever Wrong,
Re-Read Rule #1"
Stew Leonard’s Passionate Approach
to Customer Service:
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
3. Center for Management Development
Some Starting Assumptions
1. The consumer is the center of everything
2. No consumer ever buys a price
3. Every product/service purchased or used is a
solution to some aspect of daily life
4. As a consumer’s daily lives changes, products/services
are adapted, re-invented, or changed to fit new
circumstances
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
4. Center for Management Development
How Do We Find Out What Consumers
Need/Want ?
• Uncover Consumer Insights:
understand the “essence of something”
• In Practice, Consumer Insights
Extend along the continuum of consumer contact with a
product category, specific products, and Brands in a category
Pre- Purchase Purchase Consumption Post-Purchase
Range from the practical (i.e., functional) to the emotional
Reveal something about the consumer’s approach and beliefs
about the Brand or Category
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
5. Center for Management Development
• Well developed Consumer Insights depend upon
in-depth understanding of measurable facts
integrated with a well developed ability to ‘hear’ and ‘see’
the consumer
• Want to know how they approach selection of any
category/product, and this one in particular; e.g.
‘I only choose the highest quality’/’they are all the same’
‘I use the brand as guide’/‘I just read ingredient labels’
‘products are a reflection of me’
How Do We Find Out What Consumers
Need/Want ?
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
6. Center for Management Development
So How Do We Do It ?
We’re All Consumers, so What’s the Big Deal:
Just Ask the Right Questions, and
You’ll Get the Right Answers
Right ?
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
7. Center for Management Development
Truth is:
We Seldom Really Know
Why People Do the Things They Do
Because
We’re Usually Not Directly Aware of
What Influences Even Our Own Behavior
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
8. Center for Management Development
‘I‘ll KNOW IT WHEN I SEE IT’
But We May Not Realize We Saw it
The Strange Case of
Subliminal Perception
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
9. Center for Management Development
After viewing a brief film showing a car rear-ending a
stopped car, viewers were asked the following question:
“How fast was the car going when it smashed
into the rear of the car stopped at the STOP sign ?”
A second group viewed the same film and were asked
this question:
“How fast was the car going when it bumped into the
car stopped at the Stop sign ?”
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
10. Center for Management Development
Which Picture is More Appealing ?
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
11. Center for Management Development
How to Get College Students to Clean Up
…. Without Realizing Why They Did It !
Recent study demonstrated that
• When a dorm room was subtly infused with the aroma of a citrus
all-purpose cleanser
• More students cleaned up after themselves after eating in the
room than did a comparable group who smelled a product having
nothing to do with cleaning
• When questioned afterwards, the citrus group could not venture a
consistent reason for their behavior
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
12. Center for Management Development
Women Wearing Red Dresses
Judged More Attractive than the Same
Women Wearing a Black, Blue, or Any
Other Color Dress
The “Woman in Red”
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
13. Center for Management Development
We Humans
Can Tell You What
We Like or Dislike,
But
Cannot Reliably Tell You Why
We Like or Dislike Something
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
14. Center for Management Development
Why Words Often Fail Us
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
15. Center for Management Development
… But, There are Also Cognitive Illusions
that Can Be Barriers to Gaining Insights
• Most obstacles are in our heads, trapped in conventional
wisdom and accepted ways of making sense of a business
and the world around us
• These blinders of everyday ‘normalcy’ are the single biggest
impediment to developing true insights
We have lots of biases built into ways in which we try to
make sense of the world: They push us to explain away
things we see/hear from consumers because they don’t
conform to accepted wisdom
This leads us to fail to “connect the dots” (i.e., make obvious
connections), that only seem obvious after someone finally
does make the connection
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
16. Center for Management Development
What’s the One Sport That Does Not Belong with the
Rest ?
1. Football (American) ?
2. Field Hockey ?
3. Pocket Billiards ?
4. Baseball ?
5. Soccer ?
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
17. Center for Management Development
Some Cognitive Obstacles/Barriers to
Gaining Insights
Sometimes We See Things That Aren’t There
… And Sometimes We Miss Things That Are
There
Sometimes There’s More Than One Explanation
Sometimes What We See Doesn’t Make Any
Sense
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
18. Center for Management Development
SOMETIMES WE SEE THINGS THAT
AREN’T THERE
Ingrained societal expectations about people’s roles,
behaviors and expectations
‘women are passengers, not drivers’
‘men don’t color their hair’
‘everyone has kids’
‘older people don’t try new things’
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
19. Center for Management Development
Innovation
Hershey’s Dark Choc Kisses
Starbucks Coffee Cup Sleeve
Oreos 100 calorie packs
Ketchup in a squeeze bottle
Frosted Flakes
Coffee can with pullback seal
Panty Hose
Originally Insight
Introduced Introduced
1907 2003
1992 +/- 1999+/-
1920 2005
. . . A really long time
1924 1952
1920 2000
1800s 1960
… AND SOMETIMES WE MISS THINGS
THAT ARE THERE
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
20. Center for Management Development
SOMETIMES THERE’S MORE THAN ONE
EXPLANATION
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
21. Center for Management Development
SOMETIMES THERE’S MORE THAN ONE
EXPLANATION
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
22. Center for Management Development
SOMETIMES WHAT WE SEE DOESN’T
MAKE ANY SENSE
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates
23. Center for Management Development
• Often Results in a Dismissive Attitude by Marketers Toward
Things They See Consumers Do or Hear Them Say
‘WHY Don’t CONSUMERS Understand ?’
• Should really be
‘WHY Don’t MARKETERS Understand ?’
If consumers are product users, it means there
is something WE have missed, or
If consumers are not users, it’s because WE
may have failed to communicate or maybe even failed
to understand the brand/product well enough ourselves
SOMETIMES WHAT WE SEE DOESN’T
MAKE ANY SENSE
Pitfalls in Trying to Figure Out What
Consumers Want
John P. Finn
Rutgers Business School &
Cahill Finn Associates