1. Image: GSMA – M Ticketing Whitepaper
Sustainable Integrated Transport
Transport Forum
Thursday 6 August 2015
Presenter:
Neil Frost

2. 2
Content Page
2
Sustainable Transport
Definition
Sustainability Issues
Sustainability and Economic growth
Transport for Canada's Vision for Sustainable Transport
Transportation Impacts on Sustainability
Urban Transport & Sustainability
Overview
Urban Transport and Technology
Digital-Age Transportation system
Monitoring & Evaluation and Impact Evaluation
Definition
Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E): Results-Based Management
M&E Answers to Management
Overarching picture of M&E to improve management
Measurement for Sustainable Transport
Conclusion
Image: NFC Forum

3. 3
Ref: The centre for Sustainable Transportation, Definition and vision of Sustainable Transportation, October 2002
Definition
Sustainable Transport System is one that:
SOCIAL
SUSTAINABILITY
Allows the basic access needs of individuals
and societies to be met safely and in a
manner consistent with human and
ecosystem health, and with equity within and
between generations
ECONOMIC Is affordable, operates efficiently, offers choice
of transport mode, and supports a vibrant
economy
ENVIRONMENT Limits emissions and waste within the planet’s
ability to absorb them, minimizes consumption
of non-renewable resources, limits
consumption of renewable resources to
sustainable yield level, reuses and recycles its
components, and minimizes the use of land
and the production of noise
What is Sustainable Transport?

4. 4
Sustainability Issues
Ref: Litman and Burwell; Issues in Sustainable Transport; 2006
EnvironmentSocial
Economic
SUSTAINIBILTY
Productivity
Business Activity
Employment
Tax Burden
Trade
Equity
Human Health
Community Liveability
Cultural and Historic
Values
Public Involvement
Pollution Emissions
Climate Change
Biodiversity
Habitat preservation
Aesthetics

5. 5
Sustainability and Economic growth
As Cities expand resources are placed under pressure
Congestion becomes a major issue
Cities therefore invest in numerous Transport and PT solutions that could
include; Commuter Heavy Rail, Commuter Light Rail, Trams, Ferries, Bus
Rapid Transport, Bus services, Mini-bus services and others.
To ensure economic growth and sustainability these services need to be
delivered as efficiently as possible with a focus on commuter convenience.
Image: NFC ForumImage: Rea Vaya

6. 6
Ref: Defining Sustainable Transport; Richard Gilbert, March 31, 2005
Principles guiding Transport Canada’s vision for
sustainable transport are:
Highest practicable safety and security of life and property
Efficient movement of people and goods to support economic
prosperity and a sustainable quality of life
Respect for the environmental legacy of future generations
User pricing that better reflects the full costs of transportation activity
and transportation infrastructure decisions that meet user needs
Reasonable access to the national transportation system by remote
regions
Accessibility in the national network without undue obstacles for
persons with disabilities
Coordinated and harmonized actions across all modes of transport
Partnerships and collaboration among governments and with private
sector for an integrated, coherent transportation policy framework.
Transport for Canada's Vision

7. 7
Sustainable Transport
Transportation impacts on sustainability
Ref: Litmann and Burwell 2006
Transportation impacts on sustainability
SOCIAL
SUSTAINABILITY
• Inequity of impacts
• Mobility disadvantaged
• Human health impacts
• Community interaction and liveability
• Aesthetics
ECONOMIC • Transport Congestion
• Mobility Barriers
• Accident damages
• Facility costs
• Consumer costs
ENVIRONMENT • Air and water pollution
• Habitat loss
• Hydrologic impacts

8. 8
Urban Transport
Overview
Transport is the backbone of our economy and society. It enables trade, which is essential
for growth and development. Every day we move ourselves through means of transport, be
it for work or pleasure, or to freight goods between companies, countries and continents.
The challenge is not to curb transportation but make it sustainable.
Sustainability reflects a parallel model, which assumes that each mode can be useful,
and strives to create balanced transport systems that use each mode for what it does
best. Transport progress therefore involves improving all useful modes, not just the
newest mode, as illustrated below. For example in many cities, the most beneficial
strategies may involve improving walking and cycling, more support for public transit, and
restrict automobile travel in congested urban areas. This does not assume that improved
transport necessarily means faster travel or more mileage, improvements may
increase comfort and safety, provide cost savings, or even reduce the total ned for
travel.
Walk Improved walking conditions
Bicycle Improved cycling conditions
Trains/Bus Improved public transit
Automobile Improved automobile travel
conditions

9. 9
Urban Transport
Overview
Transport Authority
Source: http://dupress.com/articles/digital-age-transportation/
All Public Transport
Operators
Public Transport
Metro’s
BRT’s
Taxi’s
Control
Centres

10. 10
Urban Transport and Technology
The arrival of the “information everywhere” world has opened up new opportunities to
make the existing transportation network far more efficient and user friendly. The
Intelligent, Digital and Smart City, all contribute to “information everywhere”.
Coupled with new transportation and information capacity, the changes spurred by
technological change and the innovations it inspires will help preserve freedom of
mobility in the Transport Sector. The mobility field and use of technology will enable
stakeholders to become:
• Massively networked, with ubiquitous connectivity throughout the system;
• User centred, taking into account users’ needs, priorities, data flows, and dynamic
responses to conditions;
• Integrated, so that users can move easily from point A to point B, regardless of mode,
service provider, or time of day; and
• Information, access to real time planning and management information
The next generation integrated or intelligent urban transportation systems will
connect all transportation modes, services and technologies together in innovative ways
that pragmatically address a seemingly intractable problem. This also provides a
seamless transport experience for all commuters.

11. 11
Digital-Age Transportation system
Source: http://dupress.com/articles/digital-age-transportation/

12. 12
Monitoring & Evaluation and Impact Evaluation
What is Monitoring & Evaluation and Impact Evaluation
Monitoring
Regular systemic collection and analysis of information to
track progress of program implementation against pre-set
targets and objectives
Did we deliver?
• Clarifies program objectives
• Link activities and resources to objectives
• Translates objectives into performance indicators and sets
targets
• Reports progress to managers and alerts them to
problems
Evaluation
Objective assessment of an ongoing or recently completed
project, program or policy, its design, implementation and
results
What has happened as a result?
• Analyses why intended results were or were not achieved
• Assesses specific casual contributions of activities to
results
• Examines implementation process
• Explores unintended results
• Provides lessons, highlights significant accomplishments,
recommendations for improvement
Impact Assessment
Assesses what has happened as a result of the intervention
and what may have happened without it – from a future point
in time
Have we made a difference and achieved our goal?
• Seeks to capture and isolate the outcomes that are
attributable (or caused by) the program
• Will review all fore-going M&E activities, processes,
reports and analysis
• Provides an in-depth understanding of the various causal
relationships and mechanisms through which they operate

13. 13
Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E)
Results-Based Management
Monitoring
Stakeholder
Participation
Setting the
Vision
Implementing
and using
Monitoring
Planning for
M&E
Managing and
using
Evaluation
Defining
Results Map &
Framework

14. 14
M&E Answers to Management
Proving
Are we achieving the desired benefits
of the right target groups
Are we achieving these benefits as
efficiently and effectively as we can?
Improving
Are we doing things right? Are we doing the right things?
Could we do things better? Could we do better things

15. 15
Impacts
Outcomes
Outputs
Activities
Inputs
Overarching picture of the M&E
To improve management of projects, programs, business activities
Manage towards achieving
results
Plan, Budget,
Implement &Monitor
What do we aim to change?
What do we wish to achieve?
What we produce or deliver
What we do
What we use to do the work
The development results of
achieving specific outcomes
Medium-term results for specific
beneficiaries that are the
consequence of specific outputs
The final products, goods, services
produced for delivery
Processes or Actions using a range
of inputs that produce the desired
outputs and outcomes
Resources that contribute to the
production and delivery of outputs

16. 16
Measurement for Sustainable Transport
TERM Program has developed and monitored 40 indicators under seven headings:
Environmental consequences of transport
Transport Demand and Intensity
Spatial planning and accessibility
Supply of transport infrastructure and services
Transport costs and prices
Source: SAP Public Transport Ticketing – Short overview
Transport and Environment Reporting Mechanism (TERM)
Technology and utilization efficiency
Management Integration
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

17. 17
Sustainability requires more comprehensive and integrated planning, which
accounts for a broad set of economic, social and environmental impacts,
including those that are difficult to measure.
Sustainability tends to support transportation planning and market reforms
that result in more diverse and economically efficient transportation systems,
and more compact land use patterns that reduce automobile dependency.
These reforms help increase economic efficiency, reduce resource
consumption and harmful environmental impacts, and improve mobility for
non-drivers.
Conclusion

18. 18
Thank You
Reference: INRIX; http://www.inrix.com/products/