SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 62
Descargar para leer sin conexión
PERMISSIONLESS INNOVATION
& THE CLASH OF VISIONS OVER
EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES
Adam Thierer
Senior Research Fellow
Last updated October 2016
www.permissionlessinnovation.org
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies
Some Questions about
Recent Tech Innovations
4
Where did all the modern info-tech
innovation we now take for granted
come from?
How did
all this area
develop so
quickly?
6
How did the U.S. become
a global digital innovation leader?
Source: Booz & Company
7
How many major European info-tech
innovators can you name?
Why so few?
8
How Did This US-EU Tech Imbalance Develop?
9
US tech firms are giant and are household names across the globe.
Why Are U.S. Firms Crushing E.U. Firms?
10
• Facebook’s market cap is twice as large as every billion dollar tech company in Europe combined.
• Airbnb is larger than all of Germany’s unicorns
• market capitalizations for US-based unicorns was almost $2 trillion in 2015, while market caps for the
handful of large European tech firms was just $120 billion
Where Are Europe’s Tech Innovators?
11
How Can Consumers Have Access
to All These at This Price?!
12
So… What Was the “Secret Sauce”
That Made All This Happen?
Tax code?
Education?
Labor market?
R&D spending?
VC market?
13
Answer = “Permissionless Innovation”
= the general freedom to experiment & learn
through trial-and-error
• openness to change, disruption, risk-taking
• willingness to accept possibility of failure
• avoid prior restraint
• find less restrictive solutions to hard problems
 The U.S. embraced this ethos & made it the basis of policy
for the digital economy in the 1990s and beyond.
14
Values, Attitudes & Innovation
(or, what we can learn from Deirdre McCloskey)
• Deirdre McCloskey – values & attitudes matter!
– an embrace of “bourgeois virtues” incentivizes innovation and
propels economies forward
• “A big change in the common opinion about markets and
innovation… caused the Industrial Revolution, and then
the modern world… The result was modern economic
growth.”
 The Internet & the Digital Revolution are the greatest
proof that social and political attitudes toward markets &
risk-taking are the key to innovation and prosperity.
15
In the old days, the Internet was “permissioned”
This warning to students appeared in a 1982 MIT handbook for the
use of ARPAnet, the progenitor of what would become the Internet:
16
“It is considered illegal to use the ARPAnet for
anything which is not in direct support of
government business... Sending electronic mail over
the ARPAnet for commercial profit or political purposes is
both anti-social and illegal. By sending such messages,
you can offend many people, and it is possible to get MIT
in serious trouble with the government agencies
which manage the ARPAnet.”
What Changed?
We opened the Net & digital revolution took off
• early 1990s: commercial opening of the Net
• 1997: Clinton admin. adopted “light touch” Framework for Global
Electronic Commerce:
1. “the private sector should lead. The Internet should develop as a
market driven arena not a regulated industry.”
2. “governments should avoid undue restrictions on electronic
commerce” & “parties should be able to enter into legitimate
agreements to buy and sell products and services across the Internet
with minimal government involvement or intervention.”
3. “where governmental involvement is needed,” the Framework
continued, “its aim should be to support and enforce a predictable,
minimalist, consistent and simple legal environment for
commerce.”
17
The Rest is History
o Permissionless innovation has driven the explosion
of Internet entreprenuerialism over past 2 decades,
esp. in U.S.
o No one needed a license or permission to launch the
great technological innovations of the digital age
• PCs, Net, servers, email, storage, websites, smartphones
o But Europe adopted opposite approach & floundered
A powerful real-world natural experiment in
comparative governance systems
18
But We’re Not Done!
We should extend the vision
19
What’s good for cyberspace
is good for meatspace
We need same general policy approach to
other sectors and technologies,
whether based on bits (digital economy) or
atoms (industrial economy).
Our policy default should be
Innovation Allowed
20
And that may be happening naturally…
21
“Software Is Eating the World”
- Marc Andreessen
22
Key Drivers of Modern Tech Disruption
 the digitization of all data
 massive increases in processing power
 exploding storage capacity
 ubiquitous networking capabilities
 steady miniaturization of everything
 increasing sensorization of the world
 falling cost of almost everything
23
“The Law of Disruption” That Governs Modern Life
Technology changes exponentially; Political systems change incrementally.
24
Pace of
Change
Time
Technological
Change
Political Change
Source: Larry Downes
Gap between=
the
“Pacing Problem”
25
Which Policy
Vision Will Govern
Our Future?
Transportation
Supersonic
Space
Hyperloop
Virtual / Aug.
Reality
Future Tech
Flashpoints
3-D Printing &
Add. Manuf.
Robotics
Smart cars
Private drones
A.I.
Sharing
Economy
Crypto
Bitcoin
Dark markets
Advanced Health
Mobile medical apps
Biohacking / Embeddables
Genetic issues
Personalized medicine
Food modification
3D-printed devices
Internet of
Things
Wearable Tech
Smart Homes
Smart Cities
Industrial Internet
26
Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
27
Technologies That are “Born Free” Will Have an Easier Time
than Those “Born in Regulatory Captivity”
“Born Captive”
(lots of law / existing agencies)
• Driverless cars (DOT)
• Medical tech / genetics
(FDA)
• Food tech (FDA, Ag.)
• Commercial drones (FAA)
• Supersonic (FAA)
• Space tech (FAA / NASA)
“Born Free”
(no law / no agencies)
• Most online services
• Smartphone apps
• Social networks
• 3D Printing
• Virtual Reality / AR
• General robotics
• Artificial intelligence
28
A Few “Born in Captivity” Broke Free
• The Internet (defied FCC + state & global regs)
• Sharing economy (defied state & local regs)
• Wearable health devices & Smartphone apps
(defied FDA regs)
• 3D-printed prosthetics (defied FDA regs)
Query: How’d that happen?
• enlightened policy choices?
• an end-run around regulation?
• technological civil disobedience?
• global innovation arbitrage?
But What about the Risks of New Tech?
Why some favor the “precautionary principle”
29
The “Precautionary Principle”
= Crafting public policies to control or limit new
innovations until their creators can prove that they
won’t cause any harms.
• “better to be safe than sorry” mentality
• “Mother, May I” (“permissioned”) policy
• preemptive regulation of tech
It is the antithesis of permissionless innovation
30
Modern Concerns Driving Calls for
Precautionary Tech Regulation
1. Privacy / Psychological
• reputation issues, fear of “profiling” & “discrimination”
• amorphous psychological / cognitive harms
2. Safety
• Health & physical safety, child safety
3. Security
• Hacking, cybersecurity, law enforcement issues
4. Economic
• Automation, job dislocation, sectoral disruptions
5. Intellectual Property
31
Technopanic!
Fear sells & drives policy
32
Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
33
Techno-Dystopianism Pervades Popular Culture
Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
The Conflict of Visions over Innovation Policy
Innovation must be carefully guided should be free-wheeling
Priority Stability / equilibrium Spontaneity / experimentation
Risk risk anticipation is preferred risk adaptation is preferred
Solutions
Preemptive (ex ante)
top-down controls/solutions
Reactive (ex post)
bottom-up remedies
Presumption
Innovators must ask,
“Mother, May I?”
Innovators are
“innocent until proven guilty”
Ethos “Better to be safe than sorry”
“Nothing ventured, nothing
gained”
34
What’s Wrong with Precaution?
35
General problem with
“permissioning” innovation
If we spend all our time living in constant
fear of worst-case scenarios—and premising
public policy upon such fears—it means that
best-case scenarios will never come about.
Wisdom and progress are born from experience,
including experiences that involve risk and the
possibility of occasional mistakes and failures.
36
“The Risk of Avoiding All Risks”
There can be no reward without some risk.
37
Specific problems with
“permissioning” innovation
o less entreprenurialism / lost opportunities
o diminished marketplace entry / rivalry
o stagnant markets & potential cronyism
o less economic growth
o potential loss of global competitive advantage
(esp. w/ rise of “global innovation arbitrage”)
o higher prices & fewer choices for consumers
38
The Atlantic “Silicon Valley Insiders Poll”
(surveying a panel of 50 executives, innovators, and thinkers)
39
Just How Important is Innovation?
• technological innovation “widely considered the main
source of economic progress” (Mokyr, et. al.)
• Obama Admin (2010):
o “technological innovation is linked to three-quarters of the
nation’s post-WWII growth rate”
o “innovation in capital goods is primary driver of increases
in real wages”
o “across countries, 75% of differences in income can be
explained by innovation-driven productivity differentials”
• Other “growth accounting” studies generally find that
technological progress accounts for 30 - 34% of
growth in Western countries
40
41
Technological Innovation Gave Us the
“Hockey Stick of Human Prosperity”
• If you care about human flourishing, then defending technological
innovation should be your #1 priority!
• Very little liberty-enhancing change comes through political process today.
– Hard to name many major legislative victories for freedom in recent decades.
– Most wins come in courts, but are slow & costly.
• Technological innovation does more to liberate us from oppression than
anything else.
– Each new innovation empowers us to live a life of our own choosing; makes us wealthier,
healthier & happier.
“Technologies of freedom” + permissionless innovation
= PROGESS & PROSPERITY!
42
Why You Should Really Care
But again, what about those risks?
Answer: We need constructive solutions for a
complex world.
43
When Might Precautionary Controls Make Sense?
… but most cases aren’t like this. We should first look to
more constructive, “bottom-up” solutions.
44Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
Precautionary Principle Approach
“Top down” / “Hard Law” Responses to Technological Risk
• Product or service prohibitions
• Information suppression / censorship
• Licensing & permitting processes
• Ongoing administrative regulation / oversight
• Product development guidance
• Restrictive defaults
• Nudges / informal guidelines
• “Bully pulpit” / “agency threats”
Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
Permissionless Innovation Approach
“Bottom Up” / “Soft Law” Responses to Technological Risk
• Education / etiquette / transparency
• Empowerment tools
• Self-regulation & new competition / choices
• Property rights & contracts
• Common law, torts, products liability
• other targeted & limited legal interventions
• Social pressure / media pressure
• Social norms, resiliency & adaptation
Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
The Familiar Cycle of Technological Adaptation
• Citizen attitudes about most emerging technologies typically
follow a familiar cycle:
initial resistance gradual adaptation eventual assimilation
• citizens have found ways to adapt to technological change by
employing a variety of coping mechanisms, new norms, or other
creative fixes.
• If nothing else, familiarity breeds comfort; resiliency.
• Lesson: Be patient and give social & economic norms a chance to
adjust.
47
Case Study: The Camera
Recall negative reaction to camera & photography in late
1800’s…
“Instantaneous photographs and newspaper enterprise have invaded
the sacred precincts of private and domestic life; and numerous
mechanical devices threaten to make good the prediction that ‘what is
whispered in the closet shall be proclaimed from the house-tops.’”
— Samuel D. Warren and Louis D. Brandeis, 1890
• But we our societal norms & personal expectations adjusted.
• Instead of rejecting cameras, we bought a lot of them!
• We learned how to use them respectfully, too.
48
• Telegraph
• Telephone
• Jazz, Rock & Rap
• Transistors
• Caller ID
• Video games
• Online porn
• RFID chips
• Gmail
• Wireless geolocation
49
Other Technopanics & Media “Moral Panics”
Somehow we got through it all!
Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
“Panic Cycles”
Source: Information Technology and Innovation Foundation
50
Transportation
Supersonic
Space
Hyperloop
Virtual / Aug.
Reality
Future Tech
Flashpoints
3-D Printing &
Add. Manuf.
Robotics
Smart cars
Private drones
A.I.
Sharing
Economy
Crypto
Bitcoin
Dark markets
Advanced Health
Mobile medical apps
Biohacking / Embeddables
Genetic issues
Personalized medicine
Food modification
3D-printed devices
Internet of
Things
Wearable Tech
Smart Homes
Smart Cities
Industrial Internet
51Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
Today’s Latest Panics
Source: Information Technology and Innovation Foundation
52
Recall the Concerns Driving Calls for
Precautionary Tech Regulation
1. Privacy / Psychological
• reputation issues, fear of “profiling” & “discrimination”
• amorphous psychological / cognitive harms
2. Safety
• Health & physical safety, child safety
3. Security
• Hacking, cybersecurity, law enforcement issues
4. Economic
• Automation, job dislocation, sectoral disruptions
5. Intellectual Property
53
Technology / Sector
Privacy &
Psychological
Safety Security
Economic
Disruption
Intellectual
Property
Data Innovation
Big Data
Online advertising
Internet of Things & Wearables
1 3 2 4 5
Robotics
Driverless Cars
Drones
Artificial Intelligence
4 1 3 2 5
Sharing Economy 3 2 4 1 5
Medical Innovation
Tele-med / Mobile medical apps
Genetic testing / editing
3 1 2 4 5
3D Printing
Additive Manuf. 5 1 4 3 2
Cypto
Bitcoin & Blockchain
Decentralized markets
5 1 3 2 4
VR / AR / Immersive Tech 1 2 3 4 5
Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
POLICY
BLUEPRINT
General Policy Lessons / Values
to Help Promote Innovation
 Forbearance (or “First, Do No Harm”): Don’t jump to regulate
new tech based on worst-case scenarios.
 Humility: Understand the limits of your knowledge & ability to
forecast the future.
 Patience: Wait to see how individuals & institutions adapt.
 Restraint: Limit & target interventions after exhausting all other
options
 Evaluate & reevaluate: Conduct strict cost-benefit analysis for all
new proposals & periodically sunset old rules before they hinder
future progress.
57
FTC’s Maureen Ohlhausen
on Big Data & IoT:
“approach new
technologies and new
business models with
regulatory humility.”
Sen. Kelly Ayotte on
Internet of Things:
”To stay on the cutting
edge, we need to make
sure that our regulatory
environment is conducive
to fostering innovation.”
CFTC’s Christopher
Giancarlo on Blockchain:
”It’s is time again to
remind regulators to ‘do
no harm.’”
Sen. Cory Booker on
Driverless Cars & Drones:
”America right now is the
net exporter of
technology and innovation
in the globe, and we can’t
lose that advantage.”
Many Policymakers Embrace Permissionless Innovation
Permissionless Innovation 10-Point Policy Blueprint
1) Articulate and defend permissionless innovation as the general policy
default.
2) Identify and remove barriers to entry and innovation.
3) Protect freedom of speech and expression.
4) Retain / expand immunities for intermediaries from liability associated with
3rd party uses.
5) Rely on common law / other existing legal solutions to solve problems.
6) Wait for insurance markets and competitive responses to develop.
7) Push for industry self-regulation and best practices.
8) Promote education and empowerment solutions and be patient as social
norms evolve to solve challenges.
9) Adopt targeted, limited legal remedies for truly hard problems.
10)Evaluate and reevaluate policy decisions to ensure they pass a strict benefit-
cost analysis.
58
The Precautionary Principle vs. Permissionless Innovation
A Range of Responses to Technological Risk
Prohibition
Censorship
Info suppression
Product bans
Anticipatory
Regulation
Administrative mandates
Restrictive defaults
Licensing & permits
Industry guidance
Resiliency
Education & Media Literacy
Labeling / Transparency
User empowerment
Self-regulation
Adaptation
Experience / Experiments
Learning / Coping
Social norms & pressure
Top-down
(ex ante)
Solutions
Bottom-up
(ex post)
Solutions
Precautionary Principle
Permissionless Innovation
59
Mercatus Center Tech Policy Program research
Books, Papers & Filings
• Book: Permissionless Innovation: The Continuing Case for Comprehensive Technological Freedom
• Paper: The Internet of Things and Wearable Technology: Addressing Privacy and Security Concerns without Derailing Innovation
• Paper: Removing Roadblocks to Intelligent Vehicles and Driverless Cars
• Paper: US Medical Devices: Choices and Consequences
• Paper: The Sharing Economy and Consumer Protection Regulation: The Case for Policy Change
• Testimony: Senate Testimony on Privacy, Data Collection & Do Not Track
• Filing to FAA on Unmanned Aircraft System Test Site Program
• Filing to FTC on Privacy and Security Implications of the Internet of Things
• Journal Article: Technopanics, Threat Inflation, and the Danger of an Information Technology Precautionary Principle
• Book: Bitcoin: A Primer for Policymakers
Articles & Blog Posts
• Who Really Believes in “Permissionless Innovation”?
• “Permissionless Innovation” Offline as Well as On
• The Third Industrial Revolution Has Only Just Begun
• The Next Internet-Like Platform for Innovation? Airspace (Think Drones)
• Muddling Through: How We Learn to Cope with Technological Change
• When It Comes to Information Control, Everybody Has a Pet Issue & Everyone Will Be Disappointed
www.PermissionlessInnovation.org
ADAM THIERER
athierer@mercatus.gmu.edu

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Current and Future Trends in Media and Information
Current and Future Trends in Media and InformationCurrent and Future Trends in Media and Information
Current and Future Trends in Media and InformationAngelo Delossantos
 
Compiler design presentaion
Compiler design presentaionCompiler design presentaion
Compiler design presentaionMdShahinAlam25
 
Internet of things executive overview
Internet of things executive overviewInternet of things executive overview
Internet of things executive overviewProsun Roy
 
Towards a Responsible Internet of Things
Towards a Responsible Internet of ThingsTowards a Responsible Internet of Things
Towards a Responsible Internet of ThingsJeff Katz
 
ITA Internet of Things Summit 2014
ITA Internet of Things Summit 2014ITA Internet of Things Summit 2014
ITA Internet of Things Summit 2014ILTechnologyAssoc
 
Internet of things New Version 2017 Document
Internet of things New Version 2017 DocumentInternet of things New Version 2017 Document
Internet of things New Version 2017 DocumentAjith Kumar Ravi
 
The Internet of Things: An Overview (IoT) ISOC SFO Chapter INET
The Internet of Things: An Overview (IoT) ISOC SFO Chapter INETThe Internet of Things: An Overview (IoT) ISOC SFO Chapter INET
The Internet of Things: An Overview (IoT) ISOC SFO Chapter INETKaren Rose
 
Jan 2018: IoT trends in silicon valley keynote at consumer electronics forum ...
Jan 2018: IoT trends in silicon valley keynote at consumer electronics forum ...Jan 2018: IoT trends in silicon valley keynote at consumer electronics forum ...
Jan 2018: IoT trends in silicon valley keynote at consumer electronics forum ...Sudha Jamthe
 
Internet of Things (IOT) - The Tipping Point
Internet of Things (IOT) - The Tipping PointInternet of Things (IOT) - The Tipping Point
Internet of Things (IOT) - The Tipping PointDr. Mazlan Abbas
 
All The Things: Security, Privacy & Safety in a World of Connected Devices
All The Things: Security, Privacy & Safety in a World of Connected DevicesAll The Things: Security, Privacy & Safety in a World of Connected Devices
All The Things: Security, Privacy & Safety in a World of Connected DevicesJohn D. Johnson
 
Wearable technologies
Wearable technologiesWearable technologies
Wearable technologiesVivian Motti
 
IoT & Big Data - A privacy-oriented view of the future
IoT & Big Data - A privacy-oriented view of the futureIoT & Big Data - A privacy-oriented view of the future
IoT & Big Data - A privacy-oriented view of the futureFacundo Mauricio
 
Quantified-Self and Lifelogging Meets Internet of Things (IOT)
Quantified-Self and Lifelogging Meets Internet of Things (IOT)Quantified-Self and Lifelogging Meets Internet of Things (IOT)
Quantified-Self and Lifelogging Meets Internet of Things (IOT)Dr. Mazlan Abbas
 
Trendcasting for 2018 what will the future of tech hold
Trendcasting for 2018   what will the future of tech holdTrendcasting for 2018   what will the future of tech hold
Trendcasting for 2018 what will the future of tech holdBrian Pichman
 
Internet of things - 2020
Internet of things - 2020Internet of things - 2020
Internet of things - 2020Deepak Mankotia
 
Future & Technology - What's Next?
Future & Technology - What's Next? Future & Technology - What's Next?
Future & Technology - What's Next? Massive Media
 
Iot internet-of-things-ppt
Iot internet-of-things-pptIot internet-of-things-ppt
Iot internet-of-things-pptSonalSharnam
 
Internet of things enabling tech - challenges - opportunities (2016)
Internet of things   enabling tech - challenges - opportunities (2016)Internet of things   enabling tech - challenges - opportunities (2016)
Internet of things enabling tech - challenges - opportunities (2016)Davor Dokonal
 
The ethics of cloud and mobile computing for lawyers
The ethics of cloud and mobile computing for lawyersThe ethics of cloud and mobile computing for lawyers
The ethics of cloud and mobile computing for lawyersNicole Black
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Current and Future Trends in Media and Information
Current and Future Trends in Media and InformationCurrent and Future Trends in Media and Information
Current and Future Trends in Media and Information
 
Compiler design presentaion
Compiler design presentaionCompiler design presentaion
Compiler design presentaion
 
Internet of things executive overview
Internet of things executive overviewInternet of things executive overview
Internet of things executive overview
 
Towards a Responsible Internet of Things
Towards a Responsible Internet of ThingsTowards a Responsible Internet of Things
Towards a Responsible Internet of Things
 
ITA Internet of Things Summit 2014
ITA Internet of Things Summit 2014ITA Internet of Things Summit 2014
ITA Internet of Things Summit 2014
 
Internet of things New Version 2017 Document
Internet of things New Version 2017 DocumentInternet of things New Version 2017 Document
Internet of things New Version 2017 Document
 
The Internet of Things: An Overview (IoT) ISOC SFO Chapter INET
The Internet of Things: An Overview (IoT) ISOC SFO Chapter INETThe Internet of Things: An Overview (IoT) ISOC SFO Chapter INET
The Internet of Things: An Overview (IoT) ISOC SFO Chapter INET
 
Jan 2018: IoT trends in silicon valley keynote at consumer electronics forum ...
Jan 2018: IoT trends in silicon valley keynote at consumer electronics forum ...Jan 2018: IoT trends in silicon valley keynote at consumer electronics forum ...
Jan 2018: IoT trends in silicon valley keynote at consumer electronics forum ...
 
Internet of Things (IOT) - The Tipping Point
Internet of Things (IOT) - The Tipping PointInternet of Things (IOT) - The Tipping Point
Internet of Things (IOT) - The Tipping Point
 
All The Things: Security, Privacy & Safety in a World of Connected Devices
All The Things: Security, Privacy & Safety in a World of Connected DevicesAll The Things: Security, Privacy & Safety in a World of Connected Devices
All The Things: Security, Privacy & Safety in a World of Connected Devices
 
Wearable technologies
Wearable technologiesWearable technologies
Wearable technologies
 
IoT & Big Data - A privacy-oriented view of the future
IoT & Big Data - A privacy-oriented view of the futureIoT & Big Data - A privacy-oriented view of the future
IoT & Big Data - A privacy-oriented view of the future
 
Quantified-Self and Lifelogging Meets Internet of Things (IOT)
Quantified-Self and Lifelogging Meets Internet of Things (IOT)Quantified-Self and Lifelogging Meets Internet of Things (IOT)
Quantified-Self and Lifelogging Meets Internet of Things (IOT)
 
Oscpa sept 2013
Oscpa sept 2013Oscpa sept 2013
Oscpa sept 2013
 
Trendcasting for 2018 what will the future of tech hold
Trendcasting for 2018   what will the future of tech holdTrendcasting for 2018   what will the future of tech hold
Trendcasting for 2018 what will the future of tech hold
 
Internet of things - 2020
Internet of things - 2020Internet of things - 2020
Internet of things - 2020
 
Future & Technology - What's Next?
Future & Technology - What's Next? Future & Technology - What's Next?
Future & Technology - What's Next?
 
Iot internet-of-things-ppt
Iot internet-of-things-pptIot internet-of-things-ppt
Iot internet-of-things-ppt
 
Internet of things enabling tech - challenges - opportunities (2016)
Internet of things   enabling tech - challenges - opportunities (2016)Internet of things   enabling tech - challenges - opportunities (2016)
Internet of things enabling tech - challenges - opportunities (2016)
 
The ethics of cloud and mobile computing for lawyers
The ethics of cloud and mobile computing for lawyersThe ethics of cloud and mobile computing for lawyers
The ethics of cloud and mobile computing for lawyers
 

Similar a “Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies

Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)Adam Thierer
 
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus CenterThe Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus CenterAdam Thierer
 
Future Tech: How should enterprise avoid the 'success trap' of the next big t...
Future Tech: How should enterprise avoid the 'success trap' of the next big t...Future Tech: How should enterprise avoid the 'success trap' of the next big t...
Future Tech: How should enterprise avoid the 'success trap' of the next big t...Livingstone Advisory
 
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)Adam Thierer
 
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Grand Tech Policy Clash of Visions to Come
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Grand Tech Policy Clash of Visions to Come“Permissionless Innovation” & the Grand Tech Policy Clash of Visions to Come
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Grand Tech Policy Clash of Visions to ComeMercatus Center
 
Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf main tent trends 2016
Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf  main tent trends 2016Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf  main tent trends 2016
Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf main tent trends 2016Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf
 
The Second Machine Age
The Second Machine AgeThe Second Machine Age
The Second Machine AgeCY N
 
LECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 4 - CybercultureLECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 4 - CybercultureKim Flintoff
 
Technology_Industry_Survey_2015
Technology_Industry_Survey_2015Technology_Industry_Survey_2015
Technology_Industry_Survey_2015Jenna Hughes-Gage
 
We Must Redraw the Map
We Must Redraw the MapWe Must Redraw the Map
We Must Redraw the MapTim O'Reilly
 
Securityand policing2015(2.05)
Securityand policing2015(2.05)Securityand policing2015(2.05)
Securityand policing2015(2.05)guest7227c5
 
Capitol Hill Campus: Drones, Bitcoin, and 3-D Printing: Regulating Emerging T...
Capitol Hill Campus: Drones, Bitcoin, and 3-D Printing: Regulating Emerging T...Capitol Hill Campus: Drones, Bitcoin, and 3-D Printing: Regulating Emerging T...
Capitol Hill Campus: Drones, Bitcoin, and 3-D Printing: Regulating Emerging T...Mercatus Center
 
Når computeren bliver kognitiv
Når computeren bliver kognitivNår computeren bliver kognitiv
Når computeren bliver kognitivKim Escherich
 
Idee diruptive per il Friuli Venezia Giulia
Idee diruptive per il Friuli Venezia GiuliaIdee diruptive per il Friuli Venezia Giulia
Idee diruptive per il Friuli Venezia GiuliaRoberto Siagri
 
Technology And The Impact Of Technology
Technology And The Impact Of TechnologyTechnology And The Impact Of Technology
Technology And The Impact Of TechnologyCourtney Peterson
 
Marsden #Regulatingcode MIT
Marsden #Regulatingcode MITMarsden #Regulatingcode MIT
Marsden #Regulatingcode MITChris Marsden
 
Carlos López Blanco-La nueva revolución de la producción: la transformación d...
Carlos López Blanco-La nueva revolución de la producción: la transformación d...Carlos López Blanco-La nueva revolución de la producción: la transformación d...
Carlos López Blanco-La nueva revolución de la producción: la transformación d...Fundación Ramón Areces
 
Impact Of IT on Society.
Impact Of IT on Society.Impact Of IT on Society.
Impact Of IT on Society.Monica Khatri
 
Atomico Need-to-Know 12 May 2017
Atomico Need-to-Know 12 May 2017Atomico Need-to-Know 12 May 2017
Atomico Need-to-Know 12 May 2017Atomico
 

Similar a “Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies (20)

Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
 
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus CenterThe Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
 
Future Tech: How should enterprise avoid the 'success trap' of the next big t...
Future Tech: How should enterprise avoid the 'success trap' of the next big t...Future Tech: How should enterprise avoid the 'success trap' of the next big t...
Future Tech: How should enterprise avoid the 'success trap' of the next big t...
 
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
 
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Grand Tech Policy Clash of Visions to Come
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Grand Tech Policy Clash of Visions to Come“Permissionless Innovation” & the Grand Tech Policy Clash of Visions to Come
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Grand Tech Policy Clash of Visions to Come
 
Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf main tent trends 2016
Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf  main tent trends 2016Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf  main tent trends 2016
Dr. Jimmy Schwarzkopf main tent trends 2016
 
The Second Machine Age
The Second Machine AgeThe Second Machine Age
The Second Machine Age
 
LECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 4 - CybercultureLECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
 
Tech 15
Tech 15Tech 15
Tech 15
 
Technology_Industry_Survey_2015
Technology_Industry_Survey_2015Technology_Industry_Survey_2015
Technology_Industry_Survey_2015
 
We Must Redraw the Map
We Must Redraw the MapWe Must Redraw the Map
We Must Redraw the Map
 
Securityand policing2015(2.05)
Securityand policing2015(2.05)Securityand policing2015(2.05)
Securityand policing2015(2.05)
 
Capitol Hill Campus: Drones, Bitcoin, and 3-D Printing: Regulating Emerging T...
Capitol Hill Campus: Drones, Bitcoin, and 3-D Printing: Regulating Emerging T...Capitol Hill Campus: Drones, Bitcoin, and 3-D Printing: Regulating Emerging T...
Capitol Hill Campus: Drones, Bitcoin, and 3-D Printing: Regulating Emerging T...
 
Når computeren bliver kognitiv
Når computeren bliver kognitivNår computeren bliver kognitiv
Når computeren bliver kognitiv
 
Idee diruptive per il Friuli Venezia Giulia
Idee diruptive per il Friuli Venezia GiuliaIdee diruptive per il Friuli Venezia Giulia
Idee diruptive per il Friuli Venezia Giulia
 
Technology And The Impact Of Technology
Technology And The Impact Of TechnologyTechnology And The Impact Of Technology
Technology And The Impact Of Technology
 
Marsden #Regulatingcode MIT
Marsden #Regulatingcode MITMarsden #Regulatingcode MIT
Marsden #Regulatingcode MIT
 
Carlos López Blanco-La nueva revolución de la producción: la transformación d...
Carlos López Blanco-La nueva revolución de la producción: la transformación d...Carlos López Blanco-La nueva revolución de la producción: la transformación d...
Carlos López Blanco-La nueva revolución de la producción: la transformación d...
 
Impact Of IT on Society.
Impact Of IT on Society.Impact Of IT on Society.
Impact Of IT on Society.
 
Atomico Need-to-Know 12 May 2017
Atomico Need-to-Know 12 May 2017Atomico Need-to-Know 12 May 2017
Atomico Need-to-Know 12 May 2017
 

Más de Adam Thierer

Privacy & the Internet: An Overview of Key Issues
Privacy & the Internet: An Overview of Key IssuesPrivacy & the Internet: An Overview of Key Issues
Privacy & the Internet: An Overview of Key IssuesAdam Thierer
 
The Challenge of Benefit-Cost Analysis As Applied to Online Safety & Digital ...
The Challenge of Benefit-Cost Analysis As Applied to Online Safety & Digital ...The Challenge of Benefit-Cost Analysis As Applied to Online Safety & Digital ...
The Challenge of Benefit-Cost Analysis As Applied to Online Safety & Digital ...Adam Thierer
 
The War on Vertical Integration in the Digital Economy
The War on Vertical Integration in the Digital EconomyThe War on Vertical Integration in the Digital Economy
The War on Vertical Integration in the Digital EconomyAdam Thierer
 
Cronyism: History, Costs, Case Studies and Solutions
Cronyism: History, Costs, Case Studies and SolutionsCronyism: History, Costs, Case Studies and Solutions
Cronyism: History, Costs, Case Studies and SolutionsAdam Thierer
 
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)Adam Thierer
 
Who Needs Parental Controls (Adam Thierer Pff)
Who Needs Parental Controls (Adam Thierer   Pff)Who Needs Parental Controls (Adam Thierer   Pff)
Who Needs Parental Controls (Adam Thierer Pff)Adam Thierer
 
First Amendment Twilight Zone (Adam Thierer Pff)
First Amendment Twilight Zone (Adam Thierer   Pff)First Amendment Twilight Zone (Adam Thierer   Pff)
First Amendment Twilight Zone (Adam Thierer Pff)Adam Thierer
 
Video Games Presentation At Penn State Univ (Adam Thierer Pff)
Video Games Presentation At Penn State Univ (Adam Thierer   Pff)Video Games Presentation At Penn State Univ (Adam Thierer   Pff)
Video Games Presentation At Penn State Univ (Adam Thierer Pff)Adam Thierer
 

Más de Adam Thierer (8)

Privacy & the Internet: An Overview of Key Issues
Privacy & the Internet: An Overview of Key IssuesPrivacy & the Internet: An Overview of Key Issues
Privacy & the Internet: An Overview of Key Issues
 
The Challenge of Benefit-Cost Analysis As Applied to Online Safety & Digital ...
The Challenge of Benefit-Cost Analysis As Applied to Online Safety & Digital ...The Challenge of Benefit-Cost Analysis As Applied to Online Safety & Digital ...
The Challenge of Benefit-Cost Analysis As Applied to Online Safety & Digital ...
 
The War on Vertical Integration in the Digital Economy
The War on Vertical Integration in the Digital EconomyThe War on Vertical Integration in the Digital Economy
The War on Vertical Integration in the Digital Economy
 
Cronyism: History, Costs, Case Studies and Solutions
Cronyism: History, Costs, Case Studies and SolutionsCronyism: History, Costs, Case Studies and Solutions
Cronyism: History, Costs, Case Studies and Solutions
 
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
Cyber Libertarianism - Real Internet Freedom (Thierer & Szoka)
 
Who Needs Parental Controls (Adam Thierer Pff)
Who Needs Parental Controls (Adam Thierer   Pff)Who Needs Parental Controls (Adam Thierer   Pff)
Who Needs Parental Controls (Adam Thierer Pff)
 
First Amendment Twilight Zone (Adam Thierer Pff)
First Amendment Twilight Zone (Adam Thierer   Pff)First Amendment Twilight Zone (Adam Thierer   Pff)
First Amendment Twilight Zone (Adam Thierer Pff)
 
Video Games Presentation At Penn State Univ (Adam Thierer Pff)
Video Games Presentation At Penn State Univ (Adam Thierer   Pff)Video Games Presentation At Penn State Univ (Adam Thierer   Pff)
Video Games Presentation At Penn State Univ (Adam Thierer Pff)
 

Último

Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check ForgeryJeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check ForgeryAbdul-Hakim Shabazz
 
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks FoundationPlanned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks FoundationP. Haans Mulder, JD, MST, CFP®
 
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdfCanada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdfvisa gurukul
 
The Concept of Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
The Concept of  Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.The Concept of  Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
The Concept of Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.legalpuja22
 
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark DisputeGS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark DisputeMike Keyes
 
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing AgreementsExploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing AgreementsFinlaw Consultancy Pvt Ltd
 
Biography Presentation of Manoj sharma [IPS]
Biography Presentation of Manoj  sharma [IPS]Biography Presentation of Manoj  sharma [IPS]
Biography Presentation of Manoj sharma [IPS]theunheardstories45
 
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...Dr. Oliver Massmann
 
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovkbhavenpr
 
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptxDoctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptxjanayana1
 
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractualtort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractualHananAmdemariam
 
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdflegal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdfE'ville Eye
 
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodkbhavenpr
 
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective Strategies and Challenges...
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective   Strategies and Challenges...Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective   Strategies and Challenges...
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective Strategies and Challenges...vijuchowbe
 
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...Finlaw Associates
 
Public Health and Intellectual Property Rights
Public Health and Intellectual Property RightsPublic Health and Intellectual Property Rights
Public Health and Intellectual Property RightsPratiksha Mishra
 
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptxUAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptxhrlestars
 

Último (20)

Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check ForgeryJeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
 
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks FoundationPlanned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
 
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdfCanada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
 
The Concept of Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
The Concept of  Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.The Concept of  Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
The Concept of Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
 
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark DisputeGS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
 
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing AgreementsExploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
 
Project Esther Qualifications for Kairos Capital
Project Esther Qualifications for Kairos CapitalProject Esther Qualifications for Kairos Capital
Project Esther Qualifications for Kairos Capital
 
Biography Presentation of Manoj sharma [IPS]
Biography Presentation of Manoj  sharma [IPS]Biography Presentation of Manoj  sharma [IPS]
Biography Presentation of Manoj sharma [IPS]
 
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
 
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
 
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptxDoctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
 
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractualtort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
 
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdflegal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
 
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
 
Aggressive Advocate for Assault Charges
Aggressive Advocate for Assault ChargesAggressive Advocate for Assault Charges
Aggressive Advocate for Assault Charges
 
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective Strategies and Challenges...
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective   Strategies and Challenges...Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective   Strategies and Challenges...
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective Strategies and Challenges...
 
Report Centre of Policy and Legal Reform 2022.pdf
Report Centre of Policy and Legal Reform 2022.pdfReport Centre of Policy and Legal Reform 2022.pdf
Report Centre of Policy and Legal Reform 2022.pdf
 
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
 
Public Health and Intellectual Property Rights
Public Health and Intellectual Property RightsPublic Health and Intellectual Property Rights
Public Health and Intellectual Property Rights
 
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptxUAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
 

“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies

  • 1. PERMISSIONLESS INNOVATION & THE CLASH OF VISIONS OVER EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES Adam Thierer Senior Research Fellow Last updated October 2016
  • 4. Some Questions about Recent Tech Innovations 4
  • 5. Where did all the modern info-tech innovation we now take for granted come from?
  • 6. How did all this area develop so quickly? 6
  • 7. How did the U.S. become a global digital innovation leader? Source: Booz & Company 7
  • 8. How many major European info-tech innovators can you name? Why so few? 8
  • 9. How Did This US-EU Tech Imbalance Develop? 9 US tech firms are giant and are household names across the globe.
  • 10. Why Are U.S. Firms Crushing E.U. Firms? 10 • Facebook’s market cap is twice as large as every billion dollar tech company in Europe combined. • Airbnb is larger than all of Germany’s unicorns • market capitalizations for US-based unicorns was almost $2 trillion in 2015, while market caps for the handful of large European tech firms was just $120 billion
  • 11. Where Are Europe’s Tech Innovators? 11
  • 12. How Can Consumers Have Access to All These at This Price?! 12
  • 13. So… What Was the “Secret Sauce” That Made All This Happen? Tax code? Education? Labor market? R&D spending? VC market? 13
  • 14. Answer = “Permissionless Innovation” = the general freedom to experiment & learn through trial-and-error • openness to change, disruption, risk-taking • willingness to accept possibility of failure • avoid prior restraint • find less restrictive solutions to hard problems  The U.S. embraced this ethos & made it the basis of policy for the digital economy in the 1990s and beyond. 14
  • 15. Values, Attitudes & Innovation (or, what we can learn from Deirdre McCloskey) • Deirdre McCloskey – values & attitudes matter! – an embrace of “bourgeois virtues” incentivizes innovation and propels economies forward • “A big change in the common opinion about markets and innovation… caused the Industrial Revolution, and then the modern world… The result was modern economic growth.”  The Internet & the Digital Revolution are the greatest proof that social and political attitudes toward markets & risk-taking are the key to innovation and prosperity. 15
  • 16. In the old days, the Internet was “permissioned” This warning to students appeared in a 1982 MIT handbook for the use of ARPAnet, the progenitor of what would become the Internet: 16 “It is considered illegal to use the ARPAnet for anything which is not in direct support of government business... Sending electronic mail over the ARPAnet for commercial profit or political purposes is both anti-social and illegal. By sending such messages, you can offend many people, and it is possible to get MIT in serious trouble with the government agencies which manage the ARPAnet.”
  • 17. What Changed? We opened the Net & digital revolution took off • early 1990s: commercial opening of the Net • 1997: Clinton admin. adopted “light touch” Framework for Global Electronic Commerce: 1. “the private sector should lead. The Internet should develop as a market driven arena not a regulated industry.” 2. “governments should avoid undue restrictions on electronic commerce” & “parties should be able to enter into legitimate agreements to buy and sell products and services across the Internet with minimal government involvement or intervention.” 3. “where governmental involvement is needed,” the Framework continued, “its aim should be to support and enforce a predictable, minimalist, consistent and simple legal environment for commerce.” 17
  • 18. The Rest is History o Permissionless innovation has driven the explosion of Internet entreprenuerialism over past 2 decades, esp. in U.S. o No one needed a license or permission to launch the great technological innovations of the digital age • PCs, Net, servers, email, storage, websites, smartphones o But Europe adopted opposite approach & floundered A powerful real-world natural experiment in comparative governance systems 18
  • 19. But We’re Not Done! We should extend the vision 19
  • 20. What’s good for cyberspace is good for meatspace We need same general policy approach to other sectors and technologies, whether based on bits (digital economy) or atoms (industrial economy). Our policy default should be Innovation Allowed 20
  • 21. And that may be happening naturally… 21
  • 22. “Software Is Eating the World” - Marc Andreessen 22
  • 23. Key Drivers of Modern Tech Disruption  the digitization of all data  massive increases in processing power  exploding storage capacity  ubiquitous networking capabilities  steady miniaturization of everything  increasing sensorization of the world  falling cost of almost everything 23
  • 24. “The Law of Disruption” That Governs Modern Life Technology changes exponentially; Political systems change incrementally. 24 Pace of Change Time Technological Change Political Change Source: Larry Downes Gap between= the “Pacing Problem”
  • 25. 25 Which Policy Vision Will Govern Our Future?
  • 26. Transportation Supersonic Space Hyperloop Virtual / Aug. Reality Future Tech Flashpoints 3-D Printing & Add. Manuf. Robotics Smart cars Private drones A.I. Sharing Economy Crypto Bitcoin Dark markets Advanced Health Mobile medical apps Biohacking / Embeddables Genetic issues Personalized medicine Food modification 3D-printed devices Internet of Things Wearable Tech Smart Homes Smart Cities Industrial Internet 26 Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 27. 27 Technologies That are “Born Free” Will Have an Easier Time than Those “Born in Regulatory Captivity” “Born Captive” (lots of law / existing agencies) • Driverless cars (DOT) • Medical tech / genetics (FDA) • Food tech (FDA, Ag.) • Commercial drones (FAA) • Supersonic (FAA) • Space tech (FAA / NASA) “Born Free” (no law / no agencies) • Most online services • Smartphone apps • Social networks • 3D Printing • Virtual Reality / AR • General robotics • Artificial intelligence
  • 28. 28 A Few “Born in Captivity” Broke Free • The Internet (defied FCC + state & global regs) • Sharing economy (defied state & local regs) • Wearable health devices & Smartphone apps (defied FDA regs) • 3D-printed prosthetics (defied FDA regs) Query: How’d that happen? • enlightened policy choices? • an end-run around regulation? • technological civil disobedience? • global innovation arbitrage?
  • 29. But What about the Risks of New Tech? Why some favor the “precautionary principle” 29
  • 30. The “Precautionary Principle” = Crafting public policies to control or limit new innovations until their creators can prove that they won’t cause any harms. • “better to be safe than sorry” mentality • “Mother, May I” (“permissioned”) policy • preemptive regulation of tech It is the antithesis of permissionless innovation 30
  • 31. Modern Concerns Driving Calls for Precautionary Tech Regulation 1. Privacy / Psychological • reputation issues, fear of “profiling” & “discrimination” • amorphous psychological / cognitive harms 2. Safety • Health & physical safety, child safety 3. Security • Hacking, cybersecurity, law enforcement issues 4. Economic • Automation, job dislocation, sectoral disruptions 5. Intellectual Property 31
  • 32. Technopanic! Fear sells & drives policy 32 Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 33. 33 Techno-Dystopianism Pervades Popular Culture Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 34. The Conflict of Visions over Innovation Policy Innovation must be carefully guided should be free-wheeling Priority Stability / equilibrium Spontaneity / experimentation Risk risk anticipation is preferred risk adaptation is preferred Solutions Preemptive (ex ante) top-down controls/solutions Reactive (ex post) bottom-up remedies Presumption Innovators must ask, “Mother, May I?” Innovators are “innocent until proven guilty” Ethos “Better to be safe than sorry” “Nothing ventured, nothing gained” 34
  • 35. What’s Wrong with Precaution? 35
  • 36. General problem with “permissioning” innovation If we spend all our time living in constant fear of worst-case scenarios—and premising public policy upon such fears—it means that best-case scenarios will never come about. Wisdom and progress are born from experience, including experiences that involve risk and the possibility of occasional mistakes and failures. 36
  • 37. “The Risk of Avoiding All Risks” There can be no reward without some risk. 37
  • 38. Specific problems with “permissioning” innovation o less entreprenurialism / lost opportunities o diminished marketplace entry / rivalry o stagnant markets & potential cronyism o less economic growth o potential loss of global competitive advantage (esp. w/ rise of “global innovation arbitrage”) o higher prices & fewer choices for consumers 38
  • 39. The Atlantic “Silicon Valley Insiders Poll” (surveying a panel of 50 executives, innovators, and thinkers) 39
  • 40. Just How Important is Innovation? • technological innovation “widely considered the main source of economic progress” (Mokyr, et. al.) • Obama Admin (2010): o “technological innovation is linked to three-quarters of the nation’s post-WWII growth rate” o “innovation in capital goods is primary driver of increases in real wages” o “across countries, 75% of differences in income can be explained by innovation-driven productivity differentials” • Other “growth accounting” studies generally find that technological progress accounts for 30 - 34% of growth in Western countries 40
  • 41. 41 Technological Innovation Gave Us the “Hockey Stick of Human Prosperity”
  • 42. • If you care about human flourishing, then defending technological innovation should be your #1 priority! • Very little liberty-enhancing change comes through political process today. – Hard to name many major legislative victories for freedom in recent decades. – Most wins come in courts, but are slow & costly. • Technological innovation does more to liberate us from oppression than anything else. – Each new innovation empowers us to live a life of our own choosing; makes us wealthier, healthier & happier. “Technologies of freedom” + permissionless innovation = PROGESS & PROSPERITY! 42 Why You Should Really Care
  • 43. But again, what about those risks? Answer: We need constructive solutions for a complex world. 43
  • 44. When Might Precautionary Controls Make Sense? … but most cases aren’t like this. We should first look to more constructive, “bottom-up” solutions. 44Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 45. Precautionary Principle Approach “Top down” / “Hard Law” Responses to Technological Risk • Product or service prohibitions • Information suppression / censorship • Licensing & permitting processes • Ongoing administrative regulation / oversight • Product development guidance • Restrictive defaults • Nudges / informal guidelines • “Bully pulpit” / “agency threats” Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 46. Permissionless Innovation Approach “Bottom Up” / “Soft Law” Responses to Technological Risk • Education / etiquette / transparency • Empowerment tools • Self-regulation & new competition / choices • Property rights & contracts • Common law, torts, products liability • other targeted & limited legal interventions • Social pressure / media pressure • Social norms, resiliency & adaptation Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 47. The Familiar Cycle of Technological Adaptation • Citizen attitudes about most emerging technologies typically follow a familiar cycle: initial resistance gradual adaptation eventual assimilation • citizens have found ways to adapt to technological change by employing a variety of coping mechanisms, new norms, or other creative fixes. • If nothing else, familiarity breeds comfort; resiliency. • Lesson: Be patient and give social & economic norms a chance to adjust. 47
  • 48. Case Study: The Camera Recall negative reaction to camera & photography in late 1800’s… “Instantaneous photographs and newspaper enterprise have invaded the sacred precincts of private and domestic life; and numerous mechanical devices threaten to make good the prediction that ‘what is whispered in the closet shall be proclaimed from the house-tops.’” — Samuel D. Warren and Louis D. Brandeis, 1890 • But we our societal norms & personal expectations adjusted. • Instead of rejecting cameras, we bought a lot of them! • We learned how to use them respectfully, too. 48
  • 49. • Telegraph • Telephone • Jazz, Rock & Rap • Transistors • Caller ID • Video games • Online porn • RFID chips • Gmail • Wireless geolocation 49 Other Technopanics & Media “Moral Panics” Somehow we got through it all! Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 50. “Panic Cycles” Source: Information Technology and Innovation Foundation 50
  • 51. Transportation Supersonic Space Hyperloop Virtual / Aug. Reality Future Tech Flashpoints 3-D Printing & Add. Manuf. Robotics Smart cars Private drones A.I. Sharing Economy Crypto Bitcoin Dark markets Advanced Health Mobile medical apps Biohacking / Embeddables Genetic issues Personalized medicine Food modification 3D-printed devices Internet of Things Wearable Tech Smart Homes Smart Cities Industrial Internet 51Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 52. Today’s Latest Panics Source: Information Technology and Innovation Foundation 52
  • 53. Recall the Concerns Driving Calls for Precautionary Tech Regulation 1. Privacy / Psychological • reputation issues, fear of “profiling” & “discrimination” • amorphous psychological / cognitive harms 2. Safety • Health & physical safety, child safety 3. Security • Hacking, cybersecurity, law enforcement issues 4. Economic • Automation, job dislocation, sectoral disruptions 5. Intellectual Property 53
  • 54. Technology / Sector Privacy & Psychological Safety Security Economic Disruption Intellectual Property Data Innovation Big Data Online advertising Internet of Things & Wearables 1 3 2 4 5 Robotics Driverless Cars Drones Artificial Intelligence 4 1 3 2 5 Sharing Economy 3 2 4 1 5 Medical Innovation Tele-med / Mobile medical apps Genetic testing / editing 3 1 2 4 5 3D Printing Additive Manuf. 5 1 4 3 2 Cypto Bitcoin & Blockchain Decentralized markets 5 1 3 2 4 VR / AR / Immersive Tech 1 2 3 4 5 Source: Adam Thierer, Mercatus Center at GMU
  • 56. General Policy Lessons / Values to Help Promote Innovation  Forbearance (or “First, Do No Harm”): Don’t jump to regulate new tech based on worst-case scenarios.  Humility: Understand the limits of your knowledge & ability to forecast the future.  Patience: Wait to see how individuals & institutions adapt.  Restraint: Limit & target interventions after exhausting all other options  Evaluate & reevaluate: Conduct strict cost-benefit analysis for all new proposals & periodically sunset old rules before they hinder future progress.
  • 57. 57 FTC’s Maureen Ohlhausen on Big Data & IoT: “approach new technologies and new business models with regulatory humility.” Sen. Kelly Ayotte on Internet of Things: ”To stay on the cutting edge, we need to make sure that our regulatory environment is conducive to fostering innovation.” CFTC’s Christopher Giancarlo on Blockchain: ”It’s is time again to remind regulators to ‘do no harm.’” Sen. Cory Booker on Driverless Cars & Drones: ”America right now is the net exporter of technology and innovation in the globe, and we can’t lose that advantage.” Many Policymakers Embrace Permissionless Innovation
  • 58. Permissionless Innovation 10-Point Policy Blueprint 1) Articulate and defend permissionless innovation as the general policy default. 2) Identify and remove barriers to entry and innovation. 3) Protect freedom of speech and expression. 4) Retain / expand immunities for intermediaries from liability associated with 3rd party uses. 5) Rely on common law / other existing legal solutions to solve problems. 6) Wait for insurance markets and competitive responses to develop. 7) Push for industry self-regulation and best practices. 8) Promote education and empowerment solutions and be patient as social norms evolve to solve challenges. 9) Adopt targeted, limited legal remedies for truly hard problems. 10)Evaluate and reevaluate policy decisions to ensure they pass a strict benefit- cost analysis. 58
  • 59. The Precautionary Principle vs. Permissionless Innovation A Range of Responses to Technological Risk Prohibition Censorship Info suppression Product bans Anticipatory Regulation Administrative mandates Restrictive defaults Licensing & permits Industry guidance Resiliency Education & Media Literacy Labeling / Transparency User empowerment Self-regulation Adaptation Experience / Experiments Learning / Coping Social norms & pressure Top-down (ex ante) Solutions Bottom-up (ex post) Solutions Precautionary Principle Permissionless Innovation 59
  • 60. Mercatus Center Tech Policy Program research Books, Papers & Filings • Book: Permissionless Innovation: The Continuing Case for Comprehensive Technological Freedom • Paper: The Internet of Things and Wearable Technology: Addressing Privacy and Security Concerns without Derailing Innovation • Paper: Removing Roadblocks to Intelligent Vehicles and Driverless Cars • Paper: US Medical Devices: Choices and Consequences • Paper: The Sharing Economy and Consumer Protection Regulation: The Case for Policy Change • Testimony: Senate Testimony on Privacy, Data Collection & Do Not Track • Filing to FAA on Unmanned Aircraft System Test Site Program • Filing to FTC on Privacy and Security Implications of the Internet of Things • Journal Article: Technopanics, Threat Inflation, and the Danger of an Information Technology Precautionary Principle • Book: Bitcoin: A Primer for Policymakers Articles & Blog Posts • Who Really Believes in “Permissionless Innovation”? • “Permissionless Innovation” Offline as Well as On • The Third Industrial Revolution Has Only Just Begun • The Next Internet-Like Platform for Innovation? Airspace (Think Drones) • Muddling Through: How We Learn to Cope with Technological Change • When It Comes to Information Control, Everybody Has a Pet Issue & Everyone Will Be Disappointed

Notas del editor

  1. 9 of the top 10 most innovative global companies are based in U.S. Majority are involved in computing, software & digital technology