SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
Download to read offline
customer service
                               what’s the big deal?
CUSTOMER SERVICE. TWO SIMPLE                 where. They’re captive customers—            company with five employees in one
words hold a lot of meaning. Taken           you’ve got their applications, their         tiny room can compete with a much
literally, the phrase merely means           money, and the answers to their ques-        larger company, provided the small
“serving the customer,” and that can         tions, so does it matter what kind of        company has the right technology—and
be accomplished without so much as a         experience they have in your office?         good customer service. If both Company
“hello,” “thank you,” or even eye con-       You know they have to come back.             A and Company B offer the same prod-
tact. Combining the definitions of “cus-           It might not matter, to a point. But   uct at the same price, where will you
tomer” and “service” from Funk &             you still face competition. And the fact     shop? Most likely, you will shop where
Wagnalls Dictionary, one gets: “The          that they may “have to” come back may        you are treated as though you are the
manner in which one who buys some-           make your next interaction with them         most important person in the world—
thing is waited upon or served.”             all the more stressful.                      which you are, at that point in the cus-
Intrinsically, however, customer service                                                  tomer service experience. The compa-
implies satisfying customers and provid-                                                  nies and organizations that outshine
ing them with a positive, memorable          A New Trend Toward                           everyone else in customer service earn
experience. That means a lot more than       Customer Service                             satisfied, loyal customers.
any dictionary definition.
     In the financial aid field, how often   As society moves beyond the industrial
do you focus your efforts on customer        age, new technologies are leveling the       Your Competition
service? After all, by the time students     playing field for businesses and organi-
are in your office, they don’t really have   zations. With that shift comes a refocus     For financial aid professionals, the com-
much choice—they can’t “shop” else-          on customer service. Nowadays, a             petition you have to outshine includes

                                      VOL. 15, NO. 1, 2004      19       NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
your co-workers, other schools, and            ing the interview process who excel in        students and their parents are discrimi-
other organizations inside and outside         customer service. We will also look at        nating shoppers. They know what feels
your industry. Not too tall an order, huh?     ways to work with current team mem-           right; they know what brings them back.
                                               bers who may not be willing or able to
Your co-workers. Nearly every office,          be a Millie.
company, or department has one—you                                                           Creating Loyal Customers
know, “that jerk in accounting,” or “that      Other schools. Students are looking for
pain-in-the-neck at the front desk.”           three things in a school: a reasonable        As I travel across the country meeting
These are employees who may perform            cost, a worthwhile education, and a           with financial aid professionals, I am
the technical aspects of their jobs            quality experience. No matter how rea-        struck by several points:
exceedingly well, but lack interpersonal       sonable the tuition, or how valuable the      • The enormity of your responsibility.
skills. Their negative approach colors         potential degree, if a student is uncom-         You literally control the purse
the way everyone—customers, co-                fortable or unhappy at the school, he or         strings on your campus.
workers, and supervisors— interacts            she may leave before graduating.              • The challenges you face each day,
with them. There’s a popular television        Granted, if students want to go to your          but especially during your peak time,
ad with the tagline: “Don’t be that guy.”      school, they have to deal with you. By           when everyone’s expectations are
Better yet, don’t be that person. If stu-      the time students receive their financial        heightened.
dents dread visiting the financial aid         aid funds, you’ve got them for that           • Your incredible opportunity to help
office because they might get stuck with       term. Hopefully it won’t be their last           your school create loyal customers.
you and are grateful when they get to          with you.
deal with someone else in your office,               Financial aid professionals can’t do    Never forget that your job is important.
chances are it is because you don’t pro-       much about tuition or curricula, but          By helping students finance their col-
vide good customer service, even if you        they can certainly help or hurt students’     lege education, you are helping people
give the students what they “need.” Be         school experiences. A caring, supportive      achieve their dreams. Success can come
the employee that everyone enjoys              atmosphere in the financial aid and           from realizing that, and enjoying your
working with, not the one that everyone        other administrative offices can go a         role.
tries to avoid.                                long way in making a student feel good
      During my undergraduate years at         about his or her educational choice. As           This is the first in a series of upcom-
the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire,        the job market continues to tighten and       ing articles examining the many facets of
one person stood out as the epitome of         tuitions continue to rise, the determin-      customer service relevant to the finan-
customer service. Sadly, she didn’t work       ing factor in school choice may ulti-         cial aid professional—understanding the
in financial aid; that would have been         mately be customer service.                   customer’s viewpoint, dealing with the
too perfect for this series. Instead,                Think about it: Does your financial     difficult customer, building customer
“Millie” worked in the student union.          aid office create the kind of experience      loyalty, and stress management for the
She was the cashier who had a smile for        where your graduates return to say            financial aid professional. Hopefully, it
everyone, and an infectious laugh that         hello, looking for Millie? I sure hope so.    will also help some of you put passion
lifted the room. Everyone knew and             Remember, they come back with their           back in your job.
respected her. I now look back on the          memories, but they also bring their fam-          To make this series as personal
Millies at UWEC and realize they are a         ilies, their friends, and their checkbooks.   and pertinent as possible, I ask you
major reason for my loyalty. When we           Alumni give money, money builds               to look for examples of outstanding
returned to the campus for homecom-            buildings, buildings house classrooms,        customer service in your life over the
ing each year, we all headed to the stu-       classrooms are filled with students, and      next few months. Determine what peo-
dent union to say hello to Millie. As we       students—well, they need financial aid.       ple are doing around you to create that
aged, Millie remained young—at heart.                                                        memorable customer service experi-
She was always upbeat, always positive,        Other companies and businesses. While         ence. Please forward the most memo-
always laughing and having fun sitting         your school might not be in direct com-       rable positive moments to me at
on her stool at the cash register in the       petition with the local grocery store or      teverson@glhec.org, so we can build
Blugold Room.                                  bank, these institutions can and do           them into our series.
      The year we returned to find             influence each other. If a student gets
Millie had passed away, homecoming             terrific customer service at the bank
changed. But the memories pull us              only to be treated poorly in your office,     Terry Everson is vice president for training,
back. That is customer loyalty, not just       by contrast that experience will reflect      and Laura Gallagher is marketing
customer satisfaction. Who are the             on your office. Students might excuse         communications specialist, for corporate
Millies in your life? And are you the          mediocre service once or twice, but not       communications, at Great Lakes
Millie to your students?                       if they’re consistently treated better at     Educational Loan Services, Inc. They may
      In a future article in this series, we   Store X or Bank Y than they are at            be reached at teverson@glhec.org or
will introduce ways to spot people dur-        your school’s financial aid office. Your      lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively.


                   NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT                 20       VOL. 15, NO. 1, 2004
steps to customer loyalty:
                          your secret to success
                                                EVERY DAY, WE EXPERIENCE THE GOOD AND THE BAD OF CUSTOMER
This is the second article in                   service. We deliver service, we receive service. Think about your recent cus-
                                                tomer service experiences, as a receiver. The bad jumps out and lingers for
                                                weeks.
Transcript’s series on customer                      Recently I experienced a case study in bad customer service. I purchased a
                                                light fixture and prepaid the bill because I understand that small businesses
                                                always face a cash-flow issue. When I picked up the fixture two weeks later,
service in the student aid office.              the store had posted “20 percent off” signs all over the place. I had paid the full
                                                price for the first fixture and was considering two or three additional ones to
                                                complement the new one in the dining room.
                                                     When the clerk brought out the fixture, I had to ask about the discount.
                                                Besides putting me off with her look and attitude, she explained that I “proba-
                                                bly got a break” on the first fixture so I “should be happy” with the price I had
                                                paid. When I later checked the receipt, I discovered no price break whatsoev-
                                                er. Zip, zero, zilch.
                                                     Price: fair. Quality: very nice. Customer service: miserable.
                                                     No loyalty here—I bought the rest of my lighting elsewhere. Probably, so
                                                will everyone else I tell.

                                                Who Are Our Customers ?
                                                To talk customer service, we first must define who our customers are. It sounds
                                                easy enough. For instance your customers may include:
                                                • Current students                         • Faculty at the school
                                                • Students’ parents                        • Staff members
                                                • Former students (alumni)                 • Prospective students



                                VO L . 1 5 , N O. 2 , 2 0 0 4   9      NA S FA A’s S tu d en t A i d T R A N S C R I P T
Each population is unique, but they share several common                   Customer Satisfaction vs. Loyalty
needs. They are all looking for a “professional” environ-
ment, with service that is timely, thorough, respectful, and               Years ago, we were just happy to get our needs met,
courteous. These expectations don’t seem unrealistic consid-               regardless of the delivery method. But things started chang-
ering the dollars involved. Next to a home, an education is                ing in the 1970s. Driven by the auto industry and the hi g h -
probably the most expensive “product” we will ever pur-                    tech evolution, the notion of “quality” started to appear in ads,
chase.                                                                     then prices started to fall, and finally customer service became a
                                                                           strategic selling focus. Your competition may have been a
The Competition                                                            leader in this push.
                                                                                Three elements—quality, price and service—are the cor-
Before we go any further, l e t ’stalk about your organization.            nerstones needed to create customer loyalty, according to a
Who is your major competition? Is it the school down the                   classic Harvard Business Review article (Jan./Feb. 1993).
street? Is it the lender with all the branches across the city?
Is it the guarantor you always go up against for new and                   Customer Service Triangle
existing business?
     The answer to these questions is yes and no. Of course,
these groups compete for your business. Surprisingly, how-                                  price              quality
ever, your real competition comes from the neighborhood
convenience store, the street vendor who always has a smile,                                      service
the national chain that prides itself on creating “wow” cus-
tomer service experiences. These are the folks you have to                 For a long time, “customer satisfaction” was the goal. As
compete against every day when it comes to customer serv-                  long as your “product” fell within acceptable range for the
ice. They keep raising the bar for everyone, including you.                three cornerstones, the customer would be satisfied. Then a
     Consider this: On a recent flight from Chicago to                     few rebels decided that they could enhance one of the cor-
Orlando, the flight                                                        nerstones and blow away the competition, providing they
attendant handed me According to Professor Jon Anton of                    kept the other two within a reasonable range.
a business card from Purdue University’s Center for
the pilot with the fol-
lowing hand-written Customer-Driven Quality, the most                                       WalMart: Focus on price.
note on the back:           commonly cited reasons that
Mr.Everson,                 customers leave a vendor are:                                   Lexus: Focus on q u a l i t y.
     Thanks for flying
                                          p e rcent for better
with us today and for all
your flights on UAL.
                               68%        customer service
                                                                                            Nordstrom: Focus on s e rv i c e.

I personally appreciate
your business and look         13%        for better price                 More recently, the concept of customer satisfaction has
                                                                           evolved into customer loyalty—that is, the qualities that
forward to serving you                                                     keep you in high regard with your customers, and keep the
again.                          9%        for better quality
                                                                           customers coming back to you. Why should you even worry
     Gary Rogeliner,                                                       about customer loyalty for your organization? Market
Captain, 1/13/04                7%        for other reasons                research confirms that it costs six times more money to
                                                                           attract new customers than it does to retain your existing
                             American Association of Insurance
This knocked my socks Services Annual Conference, April 1997               customer base. And loyal customers tend to promote your
off. I will keep that card                                                 organization through one of the most potent forms of adver-
for years to come. (Oh, These numbers prove one very important             tising: word-of-mouth.
by the way, Captain point. Once in the fold, customers are yours                Loyalty! We see it all over the place. School bumper
Rogeliner is also your to keep or lose: it is up to you.                   stickers shout out school pride. My former boss even carries
competition.)                                                              a coffee cup with the inscription, “My kid and my money go
      Lest we forget, your co-workers are also your competi-               to the University of Minnesota.” Oh, by the way, he too is a
tion. If I come into your office and “Sally” makes the finan-              Gopher alum.
cial aid experience personal, positive, and professional, she                   Loyalty goes hand in hand with personal pride. I am a
raises the bar for everyone else in the office. Remember                   University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire “Blugold” and darned
Millie from our first article, who was the staff member that               proud of it. Both my kids are Blugolds. My grandkids? Too
alums always sought out year after year during homecoming                  soon to tell. But our most recent alumni publication intro-
week? The bar she raised is still up there even though she                 duced a new program to attract out-of-state students whose
has been gone for 10 years.                                                parents are alumni. Loyalty works!

                  NA S FA A’s S tu d en t A i d T R A N S C R I P T   10       VO L . 1 5 , N O. 2 , 2 0 0 4
How strong is this loyalty effect? Think about it—are                        Too often we present the options from our side of the
there any products, services, or vendors that have your loy-               fence—how it will make our job easier. But the customer does
alty? My guess is that by now you return to them by a                      not (and should not) care about our side of the fence.We need
deeply ingrained habit, but it did not just happen: they                   to scrap the old adage of “meet me in the middle on this one.”
earned your loyalty.                                                       We need to be squarely on the customer’s side of the fence.

Five Steps to Customer Loyalty                                             Step 4. The customer is now asking, “Okay, so what do I
                                                                           have to do to get this benefit?” When the customer starts ask-
In every customer service opportunity there are five basic steps           ing what has to be done, the door is open. It is time for you
when you have the chance to strengthen customer loyalty.                   to walk through. But be sure to present the action from the
                                                                           customer’s side of the fence.
Step 1. The customer thinks, “I am important and want to be
respected.” There is no logic and reason to this first step. It is         Step 5. Wrap-up. In most customer service situations, this
100 percent emotion. Our challenge is to put our own “I am                 phase is sorely overlooked. You are so happy to be done with
important” attitude aside and be willing to open ourselves                 the person, especially a challenging customer, that you just
to the wants and needs of the customer. And at that                        want them to leave the office. You may miss a real “wow”
moment, who is the most important person in the world in                   opportunity. When you wrap up your interaction, you sum-
the eyes of the customer? We need to drop our self-focus                   marize the agreed-to action steps that everyone involved
and put the customer on the pedestal. The best of the best in              needs to take. Review what you will do, what they will do, and
customer service do this naturally and have no problem                     by when. Close the interaction with a sincere thank you. Even
abdicating personal power for the good of the customer.                    if they complained, acted out, or had an “attitude,” thank
                                                                           them for bringing the situation to your attention.Without that
Step 2. The customer then thinks, “Consider my viewpoint.”                 knowledge, you couldn’t have helped them. Be honest and
This may is an extension of Step 1, but it also addresses the              sincere when thanking them. They really did you a favor by
reality that each person is an individual and we need to be                being open about their concerns.
willing to personalize the customer service we provide. Each
person has unique wants and needs. We must be first willing                Excelling at Customer Service
to listen to the customer, then ask informed and helpful
questions in such a way that we show that we are willing to                Loyalty returns customers to you, brings in new customers,
treat that person with respect and dignity.                                and often makes future customer service easier as people
      Early in a customer service interaction, you may face                begin to expect a positive reaction and are thus more
heightened negative emotion. The person may just be look-                  relaxed from the start. To be strong in customer service,
ing for someone to pick on.Treat this situation as an oppor-               remember the Customer Service Triangle and do what it
tunity to open yourself up and be the one who can create a                 takes to excel on the side of service.
loyal customer, instead of reacting to negative emotions
with negative emotions.                                                    The next article in this series will deal with the challenge of negative
                                                                           emotion in the customer service interaction. We will introduce a com-
Step 3. The customer thinks,“What’s in it for me?” Basically,              mon-sense model that should help you remain in control, even in the
all of us are selfish. Once we reach this point in the interac-            face of unrealistic or demanding customers. Believe it or not, they can be
                                                                           fun to serv e — h o n e s t !
tion, the customer is weighing the value of what we have to
                                                                           About the authors:
offer against what he or she needs to do to receive this ben-
                                                                           Te rry Everson is vice president for training, and Laura Gallagher is the
efit. If we can show the customer that the benefit is worth                marketing communications specialist, for corporate communications at
the necessary actions, we have a far better chance of moving               Great Lakes Educational Loan Services, Inc. They may be reached at tever -
to the next stage.                                                         son@glhec.org or lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively.




did you know?
  The NASFAA Web site has everything you need to conduct a financial aid night presentation. The guide
  and accompanying slideshow are available at www.NASFAA.org/FinancialAidNight.asp.


  The NASFAA Web site also includes basic information on state-sponsored savings and prepaid tuition
  p rograms. Check it out at www.NASFAA.org/prepaid.asp.




                                      VO L . 1 5 , N O. 2 , 2 0 0 4   11       NA S FA A’s S tu den t A i d T R A N S C R I P T
Everybody’s Got Them:
                        Tough Customers
                The first two installments of our customer service series focused on
           traditional customer service issues—how to provide quality products at a fair
                 cost through exceptional customer service. All along, we assumed
                 that the customers we were dealing with were willing, cooperative,
                             mature partners in the financial aid process.

             But guess what? Some customers aren’t so nice. In fact, some of them
          can be downright nasty, casting a pall over the entire financial aid experience.
                 Here are a few ideas on how to handle your Tough Customers.

AS I TRAVEL THE STUDENT-LOAN TRAINING CIRCUIT,                         the Direct Lending community, please remember this ad-
attending state, regional, and national conferences to ex-             age: You need them more than they need you. One of the
amine customer service offerings, the one topic that con-              key concepts we teach in the Great Lakes Customer Ser-
sistently arises is “dealing with the difficult person.” I call        vice Training model states: “The customer isn’t always
them “Tough Customers.” The Tough Customer comes in                    right, but hopefully this customer will remain our cus-
all shapes and sizes, and can hail from any age group,                 tomer.”
race, or gender. However, they do exhibit some remark-                      Consider this theory: It costs considerably more to go
ably consistent tendencies. In this article, we will discover          out and attract new customers than it does to retain, ser-
how to diagnose the situation, how to put a name to the                vice, and delight the ones you already have. This may be a
behavior, and how to apply the “Three Ps” of customer                  tough pill to swallow, especially if you are naturally com-
service to a Tough Customer.                                           petitive and enter every encounter with an “I must win”
     But first we need to spend some time studying the                 attitude. Then you realize you are in a classic “no-win”
Tough Customer. We also need to look in the mirror and                 situation. You use all the tools of customer service—lis-
admit—horror of horrors—that we may actually be con-                   tening, empathizing, understanding—and all the while the
tributing to the Tough Customer situation.                             Tough Customer is tap dancing on your forehead. The
                                                                       Tough Customer is winning big time and knows it.
Who Is the Tough Customer?                                                  But are they really winning?

The Tough Customer can ruin your otherwise peaceful day                The Tough Customer in Action
with a nasty look, a bad attitude, a mean word, or inappro-
priate behavior. Why is it that people who walk into your              If you assume the role of interested observer, you can put
office—people who need your service—can treat you with                 much of this Tough Customer behavior into perspective.
such disrespect? Whether you find yourself working for                 We have all seen the Tough Customer in action. Hard as it
an institution, lender, servicer, guarantor, or as a part of           is to admit, sometimes we even fall into the role ourselves.


                                    VOL. 15, NO. 3, 2004          26        NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
When I travel, I often get to play the role of interested        his welcome and unfortunately I was seated next him for
observer, as there are Tough Customers all over the air-              the entire flight. The most telling comment came from one
ports. Airline travel seems to attract Tough Customer be-             of the lucky 19 who got a seat. He asked the flight atten-
havior. Trust me, when a Tough Customer unloads on an                 dant to thank the rest of us for our patience and apolo-
unsuspecting airline staffer, it makes all the other travel-          gized for the inconvenience. He was rushing home that
ers embarrassed, uncomfortable, and concerned for the cus-            night to be with his sick daughter. All I could do was
tomer-service person.                                                 smile; all was right with the world.
     I began the initial draft for this article while trapped
on the tarmac at the De-                                                                                The Few, the
troit airport in a small                                                                                Tough…
commuter plane. We
were held up for more                                                                                   To better understand the
than two hours because                                                                                  Tough Customer, let’s
the connecting flight was                                                                               take a look at some sig-
late, and airline officials                                                                             nificant numbers. In my
chose to delay our depar-                                                                               customer service train-
ture so that the other                                                                                  ing programs I often
travelers could make it to                                                                              conduct informal sur-
Dayton that same night.                                                                                 veys of the participants
Unfortunately, there                                                                                    to determine how many
were 26 connecting pas-                                                                                 customers fall into each
sengers and only 19 seats                                                                               of one of three catego-
left on our plane. For two                                                                              ries:
hours airline officials                                                                                 ☺ = 75%
debated ways to rectify                                                                                   = 20%
the situation.                                                                                            = 5%
     Most passengers
took the opportunity to                                                                                  Your numbers may vary
doze, read, or watch the                                                                                 with your job duties, the
discussions through the                                                                                  time of the year, or sim-
windows. But the resi-                                                                                   ply the phase of the
dent Tough Customer fi-                                                                                  moon.
nally started bellowing.                                                                                     The breakdown is re-
“How perfect for this ar-                                                                                vealing. Ninety-five per-
ticle,” I thought. He was                                                                               cent of customers are
loud, young, totally self-                                                                              either in a good or neu-
absorbed, and he wanted                                                                                 tral mood when they start
to be heard.                                                                                            the customer-service ex-
     The flight attendant                                                                               perience. And that other
did a great job with this guy. She listened to his comments,          five percent? Not all unhappy customers are certifiable
stayed calm, and ignored his inappropriate comments about             Tough Customers. Of the five percent who are unhappy,
her and the airline as he ranted to his buddies over his cell         only about one in five is a hardened Tough Customer. For-
phone. The attendant followed the Three Ps of customer                tunately for the financial aid professional, the other four
service. Specifically:                                                can be made happy through good customer service. It takes
She remained Positive,                                                work but it can be done. That leaves just one in 100 truly
She treated everyone in a Personal manner, and                        difficult customers.
She was Professional at all times.                                         Now the more difficult question: What about the other
     When we finally departed, everyone was relieved, but             half of the equation? That’s you. Remember our 75/20/5
no one more than me. The Tough Customer had worn out                  breakdown? Well, guess what? If you are unwilling or


                                   VOL. 15, NO. 3, 2004          27        NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
unable to abide by the Three Ps, you might personally be          from an emotional gut-level. For example, this might hap-
responsible for driving a large percentage of your custom-        pen when a student walks in and demeans a staff member
ers to the dark side.                                             because someone made a mistake on the student’s paper-
                                                                  work—scolding, like a parent. The staff member then
Two Tough-Customer Categories                                     responds with anger and emotion, taking on the child
                                                                  role.
The Tough Customer usually falls into two general cat-
egories of inappropriate behavior—“parent” or “child”—       Customers Assuming a “Child” Role: The other extreme
which can be understood through a communication model        is just as dysfunctional in a customer-service setting.
developed by psychologist Eric Berne in the 1950s. His       What is your normal reaction when a Tough Customer
Transactional Analysis model, taught in every Introduc-      exhibits child behavior, such as whining, blaming oth-
tion to Psychology class through the early 1970s, said that  ers, crying, or throwing tantrums? Admit it—you want
when interacting, people tend to fall                                                  to tell them to grow up and stop
into one of three ego states: parent,                                                  acting like a child. Your tendency
adult, or child. Briefly, the parent                                                   to act out the parent role is in-
role tends to speak from values and           The customer-service                     creased. Sadly, these parenting re-
judgments, the adult role from logic                                                   actions are often so ingrained, we
and reasoning, and the child role              person must always                      get hooked into responding to the
from emotions.                                                                         customer with corresponding inap-
     As a trained counselor, I had               stay in the “adult”                   propriate behavior. It may only be
always found this model always too                                                     a condescending look or demean-
simple, so I shoved it into my men-                role... Don’t get                   ing sigh, but it all has the same ef-
tal “junk drawer.” Now the K.I.S.S.                                                    fect. For example, have you ever
approach (Keep it Simple, Stupid)                                                      seen this in your office? A student
is gaining traction, and I find it is           pulled into childlike                  walks in whining about a problem
time to resurrect Transactional                                                        with his or her aid. The staff mem-
Analysis and apply it to customer              emotional responses                     ber sighs, then “retaliates” by point-
service.                                                                               ing out the errors the student made
     Here is how it works. In any                   or parent-like                     on the FAFSA. The result isn’t
customer-service setting there are                                                     pretty.
two players, you and the customer.            judgmental reactions.
The customer comes to you with                                                         Responding as an Adult
behavior that fits nicely into the par-
ent, adult, or child category. Your                                                    So what can you do? Here’s where
response can be from the parent, child, or adult category    the fun begins. The customer-service person must always
as well. In fact, people can even shift roles during an in-  stay in the “adult” role—rational, logical, and friendly.
teraction. Effective customer service, however, responds     Don’t get pulled into child-like emotional responses or
from the adult role (logical, reasonable), regardless of the parent-like judgmental reactions. Even when the Tough
role presented by the customer.                              Customer plays all their cards, use the Three P’s to stay
                                                             clear.
Customers Assuming a “Parent” Role: If the Tough Cus-             I equate it to this scenario: You are a five-pound bass
tomer exhibits condescending, critical, sarcastic, or de-    swimming in a lake during a bass tournament. There are
meaning behavior, or attempts to establish him or herself    many opportunities to get hooked, but for your own good,
as someone who should be feared or respected, the cus-       let the bait slide on by.
tomer is playing out the parent role.                             The Tough Customer is—intentionally or unintention-
     These customers have a tendency to talk down to you;    ally—baiting you. Just smile sincerely and let the Tough
they need to let you know how important they are. When       Customer know you are there to help. If you try to fight
dealing with a Tough Customer in parent mode, our natu-      back, you are taking the bait and you are going to lose—
ral tendency is to revert back to child behavior—reacting    putting the Tough Customer back in charge.


                                   VOL. 15, NO. 3, 2004      28       NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
If you use the Transactional Analysis model, dealing               Now, some final good news: When faced with this one
with a Tough Customer almost becomes fun because he                percent, you don’t have to take them personally! Give it
or she can become so wound up or irrational, while you             your best shot and know that you used the Three Ps and
remain in control of yourself and the situation.                   you stayed in the “adult” role. If it doesn’t work, recog-
                                                                   nize that maybe nothing could satisfy this customer.
It Works! (Most of the Time…)                                          When you see a colleague facing this type of person—
                                                                   doing all the right things but still feeling terrible after the
Now, for the good news and bad news. The good news:                interaction—take a moment to congratulate that colleague
Using these techniques, you can turn 99 percent of the             on a good effort. Ninety-nine out of 100 percent is darned good.
customers to your side. They may not leave as your bo-                 You can even take it one step further. When you are
som buddy, but at least they know you care and you handled         out and about—in a restaurant, in an airport—and you
them in a positive manner.                                         witness a customer-service representative doing all the
    Bad news: You may not be able to turn that final one           right things, regardless of outcome, acknowledge their
percent. Despite your best customer-service efforts, de-           efforts. They were simply facing that one percent.
spite the best training, despite your desire to make every-
                                                                   By Terry Everson, vice president for training, and Laura
one a satisfied customer, there are some who pride                 Gallagher, marketing communications specialist, for
themselves on being the worst of the worst. Their job is to        Corporate Communications at Great Lakes Educational
make everyone around them miserable and no matter what             Loan Services, Inc. They may be reached at
you say, or how you say it, they will remain miserable.            teverson@glhec.org or lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively.
These folks seriously want to remain this way and noth-
                                                                   Please send us your examples of outstanding—or unbeliev-
ing you can do in a short customer-service interaction is          ably bad—customer service. We will build them into our
going to change them. So be it.                                    upcoming articles.




                                  VOL. 15, NO. 3, 2004        29        NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
76748_pg24-27   3/2/05   8:18 AM   Page 24




                we need to delight
                taking customer
                service to the                By Terry Everson and Laura Gallagher

                                             Hello folks—here we are again, talk-




                highest
                                             ing about customer service and what it
                                             takes to create memorable customer
                                             service moments. The first article in
                                             this six-part series introduced the
                                             importance of customer service in the
                                             student aid field. Remarkably, after
                                             that article was published, some read-




                level
                                             ers responded asking whether students
                                             are really “customers.” Well, not only
                                             are they customers, but so are their par-
                                             ents, their co-signers, your co-workers,
                                             your faculty, your vendors, and guar-
                                             antors/servicers. Add to that list any-
                                             one else who you interact with on
                                             a daily basis, and the importance of cus-
                                             tomer service should be apparent.
                                               In the second article, we stressed the
                                             importance of creating loyal cus-
                                             tomers. These are the customers that
         24       STUDENT AID TRANSCRIPT
76748_pg24-27   3/2/05   8:18 AM   Page 25




      use your “product”—in the case of          my house in Madison, Wisconsin, or           asked that I give him a call at his new
      financial aid, the services you provide    one in the Tucson, Arizona, or Spokane,      job to let him know the bag had been
      to students and families—and literal-      Washington, the store’s processes, look      repaired to my satisfaction. That was
      ly become walking testimonials for the     and feel, and product selection are pret-    five years ago, but he still came to mind
      value, quality, and the related customer   ty much the same. But Judy is not stan-      recently when I gave that same bag to
      service associated with the “product.”     dardized. Judy isn’t found in every          a new high school golfer.
      Loyal customers will stay with             store. Judy is found at my store.
      you even if there is an occasional            Just last week, I walked into the store   “Bill Murray” Thinks Ahead
      small glitch in the customer service       to pick up some hay fever medication.        The Walt Disney Company has long
      experience.                                As I walked past the cosmetics section,      been recognized for creating memo-
         In the third and most recent article,   I heard a friendly voice ask if I would      rable guest experiences. They train their
      we acknowledged that difficult             like to try a sample of Antonio              staff to look for memorable customer
      customers exist and must be dealt with     Banderas’ new men’s cologne, “AB.”           service opportunities. I can recall one
      in a positive manner. We pointed out       Judy has a huge smile, a kind word for       particular personal event that exempli-
      that in some cases, your behavior may      all customers, and an infectious laugh       fies this “A” attitude.
      be a contributing factor to some           that warms the entire store. She seemed         When our family assembled for the
      of those challenging customer service      so proud of this new cologne, I              umpteenth “Kodak Moment” in front
      situations.                                humored her with a trial “splash on,”        of the 50-foot silver golf tee at one of
         Today we want to discuss how to take    and found I had to have it. Not because      Disney’s golf courses, a groundskeep-
      your customer service to the “Wow!”        it smelled good—I really didn’t like it      er—who looked a lot like Bill Murray
      level—that is, how to create memorable     that much. And not because it came           in the movie “Caddyshack”—
      customer service. In any customer serv-    with a free AB golf hat. The last thing      approached us as we stood on his per-
      ice situation, you can do a decent job     I need was another golf hat. I had to        fectly mowed lawn. I knew we were in
      and receive a “C” grade. Keeping with      have it because Judy just created a          trouble. To my surprise, instead of
      the academic theme, an even better job     memorable          customer       service    shooing us away, he asked if he could
      that exceeds the average performance       moment—a personal connection                 take the family picture so that I could
      will earn you a “B.” The greater chal-     between me, the product, the process,        be included. We would have a photo of
      lenge is how to earn an “A” in customer    and the store.                               the whole family, dad included! Since
      service. Today I’d like to describe the       When I sheepishly walked into my          that time, I’ve volunteered to take hun-
      steps to creating a memorable customer     condo, cologne in one hand, AB hat in        dreds of pictures for people all over the
      service experience.                        another, my wife looked up from her          world, giving them a chance to include
                                                 book and smiled when she saw the             the entire family in the family album.
      Creating Memorable Customer                Walgreen’s bag. “I see you met Judy,”        Why? Because it meant so much to me
      Service                                    she said. “Isn’t she the most wonder-        to receive the same kind of offer.
      Think about the last time someone sim-     ful clerk?”
      ply blew your socks off with incredi-                                                   “The S’sence of Customer Service”
      ble customer service. My guess is that     Eric’s Extra Mile                            What makes these memorable customer
      it didn’t cost the organization anything   Then there is Eric at my golf shop. Eric     service experiences? In researching,
      more than it would have cost them for      faithfully fed my golf habit for years,      experiencing, and observing them, I’ve
      “C” service. Memorable customer serv-      but he also sold me the “golf bag from       coined the phrase “The ‘S’sence of
      ice is about the people who do the job;    hell.” It broke four times. Each time,       Customer Service.” Here is some of that
      the people that bring smiles to our        Eric worked with me and the supplier         “S”sence:
      faces. It is not simply a process that     to ensure that I was a happy camper.
      has been re-engineered or continually      On the fifth collapse, Eric laughed as       Smiles Abound
      improved. Let’s look at three shining      I lugged it into the store. The good         Student aid can be a dehumanizing
      examples of people who give memo-          news, he said, was that he would again       process, involving with a combination
      rable customer service: Judy, Eric, and    send the bag out for repairs. The bad        of sensitive, sometimes complex finan-
      “Bill Murray.”                             news was he was leaving the store later      cial information; intimidating paper-
                                                 that week to take a new job in the cell      work; and the educational hopes and
      Judy’s Smile                               phone industry.                              dreams of a family among other things.
      First there is Judy. Judy works for a        It was then that he hit me with a          Definitions that apply in other settings,
      national drug store chain, Walgreens.      memorable customer service moment.           such as dependency, family, and assets,
      Whether you are in the Walgreens near      He gave me his new business card and         don’t always apply the same way in
                                                             NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS            25
76748_pg26    2/16/05   7:56 AM   Page 26




         student aid. Your customers may come          customers were as organized and                There is enough mystery
         into your office mad, confused, or con-       informed about student aid policy as
         cerned about paying for college. Your         you are, but guess what? They aren’t.          in the student aid process
         smile—the “Judy” smile—creates an             You are the expert. Student aid is just
                                                                                                      without adding to it with
         environment where students and fam-           one of hundreds of new experiences
         ilies feel welcome. They know that you        they are dealing with as they navigate         poorly marked directions.
         are there for them at that moment, you        through the higher education process.
         care about their circumstances, and you       They will appreciate you treating them         Walk to, and then
         are willing to help them understand.          according to the three P’s—in a                through, your work area.
         Help is at hand.                              Positive, Personal, Professional man-
                                                       ner—giving simple, clear, practical            Can new students
         Signage Is a Must                             instructions that will help them accom-        navigate it without a
         Have you ever tried to find your way          plish their goals. And when you think
         in a city that has poor signage? It is dis-   about it, this will help you accomplish        special understanding of
         concerting. There is enough mystery in        your goals as well.
         the student aid process without adding
                                                                                                      “college-speak”?
         to it with poorly marked directions.          Sales Opportunities at Every
         Walk to, and then through, your work          Juncture                                       en out a processing problem on cam-
         area. Can new students navigate it with-      Judy did it. Eric did it. My Bill Murray       pus or with a guarantor. Other times it
         out a special understanding of “college-      look-alike did it. Top shelf customer          may mean sending a quick note to
         speak”? (Just what is a “bursar”?) Are        service staff look for opportunities to        someone who had to drop out, encour-
         directions and offices well labeled? (If      cross-sell their organization, their           aging them to recognize that a dream
         I have financial aid, where do I go to        department and their product. The              postponed may not be a dream ended.
         pay my bill? Do I have to stand in a          offices of financial aid, the registrar, the   When you receive this type of service,
         special “financial aid” line at the book-     bursar, admissions, and student servic-        you feel a sense of appreciation and joy.
         store?) Are the waiting areas user-           es all contribute to a series of independ-     When you give this level of service,
         friendly and self-explanatory, prevent-       ent, yet very interrelated events. Look        your self-pride and occasional recog-
         ing students and families from wasting        for ways to ensure that everyone at all        nition from the customer will earn you
         time in the wrong place? Do the stu-          critical touch points—within your office       your daily “A” grade.
         dents know where they are at any given        and throughout the campus—works for               These key points will help you and
         moment, to whom they are talking, and         the good of the student and sells the full     your office staff be better prepared to
         where they go next?                           value of your institution. Instead of          deliver those Memorable Customer
                                                       looking for ways to make the financial         Service moments to your varied cus-
         Secrets to Cleanliness                        aid office look better at the expense of       tomer groups: students, parents, co-
         Your mom probably told you cleanli-           other offices and departments, work            workers, and business partners.
         ness is next to godliness. I don’t know       with those other departments to ensure            With the “S”sence of service now
         about that, but a pleasant, welcoming         that you are all focused on creating a         firmly affixed in your office plan, we
         office space creates an air of comfort        complete, positive customer service            are ready to find ways to mentally pre-
         and relaxation and has a calming effect       experience for the student.                    pare for each day. The next installment
         on your customers. A flower here, a                                                          in this series will deal with the issue of
         magazine there, a humorous quote or a         Snapshots at the Seventh Hole                  stress, stress management, relaxation
         fun picture can help. But bear in mind        The “best of the best” at customer serv-       techniques, and tools that you and your
         the types of messages your décor may          ice look for ways to go the extra yard,        staff can use to refresh your mind, your
         send. Some staff post cartoons or             exceed the customers’ expectations,            body, your spirit.
         quotes that actually make fun of the stu-     reach out with a kind gesture or offer
         dents—the very people they serve.             a kind word, and be a bright spot in the       Terry Everson is vice president for
         What kind of message do you think that        day. In student aid, this may mean not         training, and Laura Gallagher is the
         sends? Remember, you need them more           only answering the questions students          marketing communications specialist
         than they need you.                           ask, but anticipating the ones they’ll         for corporate communications at Great
                                                       need to know three stages down the             Lakes Educational Loan Services, Inc.
         Simple Instructions                           line. Sometimes it is as simple as pick-       They may be reached at teverson@
         Please remember, you are the subject          ing up the phone and clearing the way          glhec.org or lgallagher@glhec.org,
         matter expert. You may wish that all          for a student who is trying to straight-       respectively.

         26        STUDENT AID TRANSCRIPT
77788_44_47   7/25/05   3:17 PM   Page 44




                                                T


         Stress
             for
         Success
         By Terry Everson and Laura Gallagher
77788_44_47   7/25/05    3:17 PM    Page 45




T     he first four articles in our customer
      service series focused on understand-
      ing why customers do what they do,
      and finding ways to adapt to their
      needs. This installment addresses the
      natural reaction to all of these chal-
      lenges: stress.
         In his 1960’s rock classic, War,
      Edwin Starr asks: “War! What is it good
                                                     direction. They can range from the jerks
                                                     who blow through the neighborhood stop
                                                     sign to the clown who tries to check out
                                                     47 items in the “10 or less” lane at the
                                                     local grocery store. Stressors may be the
                                                     tough co-worker, the broken photocopi-
                                                     er, the family computer that eats your
                                                     data, or the confused incoming fresh-
                                                     man with condescending, angry parents
                                                                                                  ■
                                                                                                  ■
                                                                                                  ■
                                                                                                      cynical
                                                                                                      a sense of inner emptiness
                                                                                                      morbid fear of death

                                                                                                  What Is Stress Good For?
                                                                                                  All of these symptoms seem to imply
                                                                                                  that stress really is good for “absolute-
                                                                                                  ly nothing.” We’d like to challenge that
                                                                                                  thought, however. We believe that
      for?” His rhetorical response was              in tow. Not sabertooth tigers, but they’re   stress, when managed in a healthy man-
      “Absolutely NOTHING!”                          also stressors nonetheless.                  ner, can be a real plus in our lives.
         I’d like to twist that question a bit and                                                   Anyone who ever played competitive
      ask, “Stress: What is it good for?” Well       The Effects of Stress                        games or sports knows when the pres-
      it turns out that stress is good for some-     How do you know if stress is having a        sure is on. Whether it is softball, bowl-
      thing, despite the bad rap its received        negative affect on you? Here are five        ing, croquet in the yard, poker with
      over the years. Stress can add value to        general stress-symptom categories:           friends, or ice hockey at the rink, our
      your office, and when channeled prop-                                                       stress responses kick in to help us pre-
      erly, can create positive results.             PHYSICAL                                     pare for the challenge.
                                                     ■ frequent backaches                            The same holds true for you in your
      What Is Stress?                                ■ fatigue                                    office setting. That heightened aware-
      First, let’s first spend a few minutes         ■ indigestion                                ness, that sharpened vision, that sense
      better understanding the origins of            ■ grinding teeth                             of urgency—all are driven by the good
      stress and its impact on our daily lives.      ■ accident prone                             kind of stress. Let’s call it eustress.
      We’ll use an example familiar to many          ■ chest pains                                Webster's New Millennium™ Dictionary
      readers: golf. Consider the young golf         ■ drinking too much caffeine                 of English defines eustress as “stress that
      pro from Florida who also spends his           ■ smoking                                    is deemed healthful or giving one a sense
      free time sky diving, extreme skiing,          ■ tension in the back and shoulders          of fulfillment.” Do a Google search on
      and sheer cliff mountain climbing.             ■ prone to illness                           eutress and you will find articles actu-
      Asked when stress and fear most affect-                                                     ally praising the value of stress in our
      ed him, he replied without hesitation,         MENTAL                                       lives. The secret is managing the stress
      “On the first tee every time I play golf.”     ■ easily confused                            to remain positive.
      Stress is very personal and relative.          ■ lethargic                                     Eustress kicks in when the end-of-the-
         In a recent Golfline.com article, Neil      ■ negative self image                        month report is due and you are three
      Morrison compared the stress that play-        ■ few friends or hobbies                     days behind in your work. It kicks in
      ers face on the green to the early cave-       ■ forgetful                                  when the staff has to ramp up for the
      man “fight or flight” response. Of course,                                                  upcoming semester, or a major disburse-
      it’s been sometime since any of us went        EMOTIONAL                                    ment needs to get out by 8 p.m. tonight.
      nose-to-nose with Mr. Sabertooth Tiger,        ■ anxious                                    Eustress sharpens, it energizes, it stim-
      but I’ll bet some of your most difficult       ■ unhappy most of the time                   ulates, and it creates the office rush.
      students can produce the same fight or         ■ constantly worrying                           So why do we think of stress as neg-
      flight reaction in you. Do you run to the      ■ irritable                                  ative? Left unchecked, or unmanaged,
      back office to avoid the impending             ■ easily frustrated                          even the good stress—your eustress—
      doom, or do you stoke up the engines                                                        can evolve into the bad stuff: distress.
      and get ready for the upcoming conflict?       SOCIAL                                       When distress takes over, the varied
         What goes through our minds and             ■ feeling isolated, lonely                   symptoms like those listed under our
      bodies during a fight-or-flight reaction?      ■ little contact with friends                five categories begin to appear.
      Some of the major changes include              ■ poor relations with coworkers              Needless to say, distress is not good.
      dilated pupils, sweaty palms, pounding         ■ distrusting
      heart muscles, numb or trembling legs,         ■ using people only for selfish gains        What Causes Stress?
      and rapid breathing. All of this can take                                                   Stressors come in all shapes and sizes.
      place when the campus problem child            SPIRITUAL                                    When I work with financial aid profes-
      just comes into the office.                    ■ feeling like a martyr                      sionals, I find it interesting how similar
         Stress inducers can come from every         ■ unforgiving                                the office stressors are across the coun-
                                                                 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS              45
77788_44_47   7/25/05   3:17 PM     Page 46




         try. Personal stressors may vary with         You may want to hold onto them—                house, create a filing system with
         each individual, however, so getting a        stressors can become so familiar, they         pockets for each month’s receipts,
         clear picture of the nature of your stres-    are like lifelong family members—but           compile a central phone and
         sors can help put everything into per-        they need to be jettisoned to alleviate        address directory, post a family
         spective. Try using the matrix below to       and prevent the stress-related symp-           dry-erase calendar—these all are
         capture your personal stressors.              toms in our five categories.                   easily accomplished.
            To really do this right, you should                                                     ■ Drink water—lots of it: Water
         first devote an entire evening to creat-      Managing Stress                                helps your body operate at optimal
         ing a “stressor list.” (For those of us       That leaves us with Box 1. Once you            levels. Reduce or eliminate
         who aren’t list makers, this in itself        have completed Box 1, your real work           caffeine, alcohol, and nicotine.
         could be a stressor.) This list should        begins. This is where you need to focus        You may not be the life of the
         include the things that cause you stress      your efforts for minimizing the nega-          party, but you sure will feel better
         symptoms.                                     tive effects of stress. There must be          every morning.
            Once you have completed your list,         thousands of stress management tech-         ■ Get a pet: Dogs, cats, iguanas,
         you will need to do some serious soul         niques out there, from exercising to           parakeets, hamsters all provide the
         searching; the next step may be the           dietary changes, from organizational           chance to love, and be loved,
         most important. Using the matrix pro-         skills to “journaling,” and everything         unconditionally.
         vided, categorize each of your stressors      in between. The following are a few we       ■ Communicate: Find a friend, a
         into one of the four boxes.                   find especially helpful.                       family member, or perhaps a coun-
         Box 1: Stressors that are important and       ■ Sleep: Try to establish a set sleep          selor who will listen to you about
         you have some control over them                 routine and keep it                          your stressors and possibly offer
         Box 2: Stressors that are important but       ■ Breathe/meditate: The calming                a different perspective on your
         you have no control over them                   effect of meditation and controlled          situation.
         Box 3: Stressors that are unimportant           breathing can have a huge impact           ■ Reach out: Taking a moment to
         but you have control over them                  on your responses to stress.                 assist a neighbor, do volunteer
         Box 4: Stressors that are unimportant         ■ Exercise: In addition to general             work, or just help a stranger can
         and you do not have control over them           health benefits, aerobic exercise            reduce stress and increase your
            Be honest. Is it a big deal that the         triggers endorphins in your brain,           sense of personal well-being.
         driver in front of you is going three           generating positive feelings. You            A great Web site dealing with stress
         miles an hour under the posted speed            don’t need a gym or expensive              is www.stresstips.com. This site con-
         limit, won’t pull over even though you          equipment to exercise. A 30-minute         tains a wealth of information and, best
         have flipped them off (with your lights,        walk at lunchtime or a brisk walk          of all, it is free.
         of course), and only allows you to pass         in the evening before or after din-          As our lives become more stressful
         at seven miles over the posted speed            ner is a great start. Make your goal       and our family, friends, children, part-
         limit? Will you really capture that one         “SMART”—Specific, Measurable,              ners, and co-workers experience simi-
         important car-length at the next light?         Achievable, a Reach, and Time-             lar pressures, we need to recognize
            When you finish completing the               focused—and you are on your way.           when stress is a positive motivator, and
         matrix, look at the stressors in Box 4        ■ Be nice to yourself: Try positive          when it is “good for absolutely noth-
         and let them go. They’re unimportant            self-talk. Give yourself credit, even      ing.” When stress arises from some-
         and you have no control over them. The          if others won’t.                           thing unimportant or out of your con-
         same holds true for all of those stres-       ■ Try to become more organized:              trol, find a safe place to let it go. Find
         sors in Boxes 2 and 3—not important             Always put your keys on the same           that safe place for you.
         and you control them or, important but          hook, keep a couple of extra pairs           Stress is all around us, but Smokey
         you can’t control them. Let them go.            of reading glasses around the              Bear was right: Only you…

          STRESS MATRIX LIST EACH OF YOUR PERSONAL STRESSORS WITHIN THE APPROPRIATE CATEGORY.       Terry Everson is vice president for
          BOX 1: IMPORTANT AND YOU HAVE SOME CONTROL   BOX 3: UNIMPORTANT BUT YOU HAVE
                                                                                                    training, and Laura Gallagher is the
                                                       SOME CONTROL                                 marketing communications specialist
                                                                                                    for corporate communications at Great
                                                                                                    Lakes Educational Loan Services, Inc.
          BOX 2: IMPORTANT BUT YOU HAVE NO CONTROL     BOX 4: UNIMPORTANT AND YOU HAVE NO CONTROL
                                                                                                    They may be reached at teverson@
                                                                                                    glhec.org or lgallagher@glhec.org,
                                                                                                    respectively.

         46       STUDENT AID TRANSCRIPT | VOL 16 | NO 2 | 2005
78660.50-55   11/2/05   10:21 AM   Page 50




         50       STUDENT AID TRANSCRIPT
78660.50-55   11/2/05   10:21 AM     Page 51




                                             CUSTOMER SERVICE

                   It’s the People
                  and the Process                    By Terry Everson and Laura Gallagher




                       uring this six-article       ner that create an output, result, or          your dream home on a prime piece of




    D
                       series, we have focused      deliverable. Examples of processes             real estate. It will be a funky little
                       on the human aspect of       within the student aid environment             prairie-style home, much in the image
                       customer service. But        include:                                       of Frank Lloyd Wright’s work. You
                       one     critical    piece    • Information dissemination                    meet with the builder, he meets with
                       remains. According to        • Application                                  the architect, everything is finalized,
                       W. Edwards Deming—           • Verification and documentation               and construction begins.
      who is often credited with being the          • Loan processing                                Soon you discover your builder is a
      father of Statistical Process Control         • Due diligence                                free spirit and prides himself on keep-
      (SPC) and with turning around Japan’s         • Awarding funds                               ing everything in his head, with little
      manufacturing industry in the 1950s           • Appeals                                      formal documentation. Nothing is writ-
      and 1960s—85% of problems in the              • Audits                                       ten down. Still, you don’t worry. All
      work environment are caused by the            • Reporting                                    the subcontractors are dedicated, hard-
      process that people are working with-           To be an effective process manager,          working and take great pride in their
      in—not the people. Staff do not nor-          you must first ensure that your process-       respective crafts. Sounds like your
      mally come to work each day trying to         es are well-documented and under con-          financial aid office, right? Let’s see
      make errors.                                  trol, with little variability. To illustrate   what happens.
         What is a process? From a manufac-         this point, let’s leave the financial aid        Once the utilities are installed and
      turing and utility standpoint, a process      sphere for a moment and use an exam-           the foundation is poured, the rough car-
      is a series of interrelated activities con-   ple from everyday life.                        penters arrive. They follow the lead of
      ducted in a regular and successive man-         Suppose you have decided to build            the builder and believe they have a
                                                                 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS            51
78660.50-55   11/2/05   10:21 AM   Page 53




      clear understanding of the final prod-     (SMEs), when they instead often end         ator ends up in the master bedroom of
      uct. As they begin construction, they      up as the single point of failure (SPOF).   your new home.
      decide to make a few changes in an           This type of inefficiency can quick-        So what is a team to do? What is a
      effort to improve the final product.       ly turn into chaos when the boss comes      leader to do?
      They decide that a second story will be    back from a training session on improv-
      a nice touch and a large garage will       ing department productivity and             You’re Part of a Process
      make storage much easier. They also        decides that some of the processes need     The first step toward improving cus-
      decide that by turning the floor plan      to be upgraded. If the boss forgets to      tomer service is realizing that you are
      around a bit they can capture valuable     discuss these changes with the regis-       not an isolated entity within your organ-
      solar heat and save on utility costs.      trar, bursar, student services staff, and   ization. Changes made by one office
         The only problem is, the plumber        admissions team, then the financial aid     affect other offices. We need to stop
      wasn’t told of the changes. He installs    staff members are making the changes        thinking of our team as a solitary unit
      the soaking tub in the middle of the       in a vacuum. This is how the refriger-      that we control, but rather as a series
      kitchen and the stove finds its way into                                               of interconnected processes. Even with-
      the master bath.                                                                       in the aid office, changes in one area
         The electrician also is in the dark                                                 can have a negative impact on other
      about the changes, so he overlooks
      wiring for the second floor. These are      What is a team                             financial aid processes. When your
                                                                                             process feeds into another team, or they
      two big problems, wouldn’t you say?                                                    feed into your team, cooperation and
         Now remember, all these people take
      great pride in their work. They even
                                                  to do? What is                             collaboration become critical.

      pride themselves on “continuous                                                        Understanding Process
      improvement” by looking for ways
      to meet and exceed the customers’
                                                  a leader to do?                            Management
                                                                                             There is a wealth of information on the
      expectations. Here is some of what’s                                                   Internet relating to process manage-
      going wrong:                                                                           ment. A Google search on the phrase
      • Because of a lack of documentation,
         everyone is doing their own thing,
         and end up either complementing the
         efforts of others or causing severe      Keep Your Process Management
         hardships.
      • As changes are made in the name of        Tools Handy
         continuous improvement, one team
         looks great, the other team looks        There are many valuable tools to help you achieve your process manage-
         foolish, and ultimately the construc-    ment goals. Be sure the following tools are in your tool box:
         tion process is a mess.                  • Gantt Charts depict a project schedule at a glance, identifying the key
         Now let’s draw some parallels in the       phases in a project life cycle and their sequence and time requirements.
      aid office. Many offices are currently      • Affinity Diagrams organize random ideas into similar groups and helps
      working within processes that are not         create visual groupings of like ideas under a header or theme.
      well-documented. The way things are         • Control/Run Charts plot variable activity over a specific period, mak-
      now done is eerily similar to the             ing it easier to visualize what is happening in a process.
      processes used 5-10 years ago. When         • Fishbone Charts show, in diagram form, relationships between causal
      asked why something is done in a par-         factors and their resulting effects.
      ticular manner, the common response         • Scatter Diagrams show how process variables are related. They can be
      among aid office staff is “We’ve always       used to discover and document possible cause-and-effect relationships.
      done it that way.”                          • Pareto Charts use a simple bar-graph format to rank the cause, source,
         Worse yet, certain staff members           types, or reasons for problems and/or opportunities.
      have become “resident experts” who
      believe their value within the team           All of these tools will help you document your processes, the critical first
      increases when they are the only one        step in any improvement initiative.
      who can accomplish a certain task.
      These type of employees often believe
      themselves to be subject matter experts
                                                             NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS           53
78660.50-55   11/2/05   10:21 AM     Page 55




         As an old training
                                                       Rarely is there a single, simple
        adage advises, “If it                          cause-and-effect relationship; to
         isn’t nailed down,                            get good ideas, be sure to include
                                                       all of your staff.
        take it. If it is nailed                    6. Create action steps assigning tar-
          down, adapt it!”                             get responsibilities and target dates.
                                                       Be sure to get everyone actively
          Find the process                             involved in the planning and imple-
         management tools                              mentation process. Involvement
                                                       increases commitment.
           that best meet                           7. Create a master plan to ensure that
             your needs.                               everyone knows their responsibil-
                                                       ities and deadline dates, and under-
                                                       stands the interrelationship be-
      “process management” generated more              tween all activities. This will raise
      than 17 million hits. As an old training         consciousness and increase ac-
      adage advises, “If it isn’t nailed down,         countability.
      take it. If it is nailed down, adapt it!”     8. Follow through to bring your plan
      Find the process management tools that           to completion. Unless it is man-
      best meet your needs.                            aged well, the best-laid plan can
         One of the best tools for speeding up         fall into disrepair without consis-
      your learning curve and implementa-              tent attention.
      tion cycle is a publication from GOAL
      QPC titled “The Memory Jogger II.” It         Customer Service and You
      is a wonderful compilation of data col-       In the six articles of this series, we hope
      lection and process management tools.         we have planted many seeds for growth
      Possibly the best starting tool is Process    in your approach to customer service.
      Mapping, which can be used on inter-            Perhaps the best summary for this
      and intra-department processes. It            series is an example that brings home
      details which employee does what, and         the critical nature of customer service.
      in what sequence, thereby providing a         As we were finishing this article, as if
      working snapshot of key processes             on cue, a shipment arrived in the office
         There are eight key steps in GOAL          with the following message stamped
      QPC’s Process Mapping tool:                   across the box: Remember, the next
      1. Select a process that needs to be          inspector in the process is the customer!
           improved. Your staff can be espe-          Enough said.
           cially helpful in choosing the right       We are constantly being evaluated by
           one. Start with a process that is eas-   our customers, our co-workers, our
           ily defined and has produced its         employers, and our employees. Even
           share of speed bumps for the team.       our business partners and community
      2. Assemble a team. Sometimes it              leaders are watching. Be sure your staff
           helps to bring in someone from           and processes “wow” your customers.
           another team to serve as a sound-        That’s customer service.
           ing board and an “unbiased”
           observer.                                Terry Everson is senior vice president
      3. Map out the present application.           of training and sales for Student Loan
           Pictures and images are worth a          Xpress. Laura Gallagher is the mar-
           thousand words. List in detail who       keting communications specialist for
           does what tasks, and in what order.      corporate communications at Great
      4. Define the day-to-day problem              Lakes Educational Loan Services,
           areas that slow down customer            Inc. They may be reached at
           service delivery.                        terry.everson@slxpress.com or
      5. Brainstorm to find solutions.              lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively.

                                                                 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS   55

More Related Content

What's hot

Customer Service Manual
Customer Service ManualCustomer Service Manual
Customer Service Manualavoelzke
 
Maintain Positive Attitude in Customer Service Using These Tips
Maintain Positive Attitude in Customer Service Using These TipsMaintain Positive Attitude in Customer Service Using These Tips
Maintain Positive Attitude in Customer Service Using These TipsTentacle Cloud
 
Customer Service Nst
Customer Service NstCustomer Service Nst
Customer Service NstLFrasca
 
Customer Service Training
Customer Service TrainingCustomer Service Training
Customer Service Trainingmdubois2010
 
customerservicetraining_101_PRESENTATION 2017_for employees
customerservicetraining_101_PRESENTATION 2017_for employeescustomerservicetraining_101_PRESENTATION 2017_for employees
customerservicetraining_101_PRESENTATION 2017_for employeesErnie Casas
 
The Edge Customer Services Module 2
The Edge Customer Services  Module 2The Edge Customer Services  Module 2
The Edge Customer Services Module 2Leo Appleton
 
CONSUMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT ASIGNMENT
CONSUMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT ASIGNMENTCONSUMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT ASIGNMENT
CONSUMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT ASIGNMENTASHISHPANDIT
 
Customer Service
Customer ServiceCustomer Service
Customer Servicehankmoore
 
Customer Care
Customer CareCustomer Care
Customer Caresdettc
 
Customer Service Skills - Retail
Customer Service Skills - RetailCustomer Service Skills - Retail
Customer Service Skills - RetailChinnu Thilakan
 
Customer complain 1
Customer complain 1Customer complain 1
Customer complain 1kainatq
 
Customer First
Customer FirstCustomer First
Customer FirstDon Harmon
 
How to provide excellent customer service in your leisure centre
How to provide excellent customer service in your leisure centreHow to provide excellent customer service in your leisure centre
How to provide excellent customer service in your leisure centreSports Marketing Network
 
28 tips patent and trade mark attorneys can use to win more work from existin...
28 tips patent and trade mark attorneys can use to win more work from existin...28 tips patent and trade mark attorneys can use to win more work from existin...
28 tips patent and trade mark attorneys can use to win more work from existin...Douglas McPherson
 
Meet Customers Where They Are: Incorporating Social Media Into Your Customer ...
Meet Customers Where They Are: Incorporating Social Media Into Your Customer ...Meet Customers Where They Are: Incorporating Social Media Into Your Customer ...
Meet Customers Where They Are: Incorporating Social Media Into Your Customer ...Salesforce Marketing Cloud
 
Lessons from the coffee shop to boost sales and seal deals
Lessons from the coffee shop to boost sales and seal dealsLessons from the coffee shop to boost sales and seal deals
Lessons from the coffee shop to boost sales and seal dealsGUY FLEMMING
 
The power of thank you in business
The power of thank you in businessThe power of thank you in business
The power of thank you in businessChelse Benham
 

What's hot (20)

Customer Service Manual
Customer Service ManualCustomer Service Manual
Customer Service Manual
 
Maintain Positive Attitude in Customer Service Using These Tips
Maintain Positive Attitude in Customer Service Using These TipsMaintain Positive Attitude in Customer Service Using These Tips
Maintain Positive Attitude in Customer Service Using These Tips
 
Customer Champions
Customer ChampionsCustomer Champions
Customer Champions
 
Customer Service Nst
Customer Service NstCustomer Service Nst
Customer Service Nst
 
Customer Service Training
Customer Service TrainingCustomer Service Training
Customer Service Training
 
customerservicetraining_101_PRESENTATION 2017_for employees
customerservicetraining_101_PRESENTATION 2017_for employeescustomerservicetraining_101_PRESENTATION 2017_for employees
customerservicetraining_101_PRESENTATION 2017_for employees
 
The Edge Customer Services Module 2
The Edge Customer Services  Module 2The Edge Customer Services  Module 2
The Edge Customer Services Module 2
 
CONSUMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT ASIGNMENT
CONSUMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT ASIGNMENTCONSUMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT ASIGNMENT
CONSUMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT ASIGNMENT
 
Customer Service
Customer ServiceCustomer Service
Customer Service
 
Customer Care
Customer CareCustomer Care
Customer Care
 
Customer Service Skills - Retail
Customer Service Skills - RetailCustomer Service Skills - Retail
Customer Service Skills - Retail
 
Customer complain 1
Customer complain 1Customer complain 1
Customer complain 1
 
Customer Service Training by NHS
Customer Service Training by NHSCustomer Service Training by NHS
Customer Service Training by NHS
 
Customer Service Skills
Customer Service SkillsCustomer Service Skills
Customer Service Skills
 
Customer First
Customer FirstCustomer First
Customer First
 
How to provide excellent customer service in your leisure centre
How to provide excellent customer service in your leisure centreHow to provide excellent customer service in your leisure centre
How to provide excellent customer service in your leisure centre
 
28 tips patent and trade mark attorneys can use to win more work from existin...
28 tips patent and trade mark attorneys can use to win more work from existin...28 tips patent and trade mark attorneys can use to win more work from existin...
28 tips patent and trade mark attorneys can use to win more work from existin...
 
Meet Customers Where They Are: Incorporating Social Media Into Your Customer ...
Meet Customers Where They Are: Incorporating Social Media Into Your Customer ...Meet Customers Where They Are: Incorporating Social Media Into Your Customer ...
Meet Customers Where They Are: Incorporating Social Media Into Your Customer ...
 
Lessons from the coffee shop to boost sales and seal deals
Lessons from the coffee shop to boost sales and seal dealsLessons from the coffee shop to boost sales and seal deals
Lessons from the coffee shop to boost sales and seal deals
 
The power of thank you in business
The power of thank you in businessThe power of thank you in business
The power of thank you in business
 

Viewers also liked

Wagons Ho!! 2012
Wagons Ho!! 2012Wagons Ho!! 2012
Wagons Ho!! 2012blugolds
 
Board Transition Training
Board Transition TrainingBoard Transition Training
Board Transition Trainingblugolds
 
Pat Schulz Linked In Pp
Pat Schulz Linked In PpPat Schulz Linked In Pp
Pat Schulz Linked In Pppschulz2
 
Agent Technology Pkg Public
Agent Technology Pkg PublicAgent Technology Pkg Public
Agent Technology Pkg PublicJoanne Miner
 
Road map For Change Script For Fa 2012
Road map For Change Script For Fa 2012Road map For Change Script For Fa 2012
Road map For Change Script For Fa 2012blugolds
 
Ipe23 1306366634-vania mariska putri-ltm i
Ipe23 1306366634-vania mariska putri-ltm iIpe23 1306366634-vania mariska putri-ltm i
Ipe23 1306366634-vania mariska putri-ltm iVania Mariska
 
Roadmap snapshot for higher education
Roadmap snapshot for higher educationRoadmap snapshot for higher education
Roadmap snapshot for higher educationblugolds
 
Expat Ease Managing An International Workforce V6.8
Expat Ease Managing An International Workforce  V6.8Expat Ease Managing An International Workforce  V6.8
Expat Ease Managing An International Workforce V6.8expatease
 
3 GREAT Tech Tools To Consider
3 GREAT Tech Tools To Consider3 GREAT Tech Tools To Consider
3 GREAT Tech Tools To ConsiderJohn Mayfield
 
Top 2012 Tech Tips, Tools and Apps for Real Estate Brokers and Agents
Top 2012 Tech Tips, Tools and Apps for Real Estate Brokers and AgentsTop 2012 Tech Tips, Tools and Apps for Real Estate Brokers and Agents
Top 2012 Tech Tips, Tools and Apps for Real Estate Brokers and AgentsJohn Mayfield
 
Why you should know the data
Why you should know the dataWhy you should know the data
Why you should know the dataJohn Mayfield
 
How to Live an Exceptional Life
How to Live an Exceptional LifeHow to Live an Exceptional Life
How to Live an Exceptional LifeJohn Mayfield
 
Characteristics of Successful Salespeople
Characteristics of Successful SalespeopleCharacteristics of Successful Salespeople
Characteristics of Successful SalespeopleJohn Mayfield
 
A Good Web Site Guide
A Good Web Site GuideA Good Web Site Guide
A Good Web Site GuideJohn Mayfield
 

Viewers also liked (15)

Wagons Ho!! 2012
Wagons Ho!! 2012Wagons Ho!! 2012
Wagons Ho!! 2012
 
Board Transition Training
Board Transition TrainingBoard Transition Training
Board Transition Training
 
Pat Schulz Linked In Pp
Pat Schulz Linked In PpPat Schulz Linked In Pp
Pat Schulz Linked In Pp
 
Agent Technology Pkg Public
Agent Technology Pkg PublicAgent Technology Pkg Public
Agent Technology Pkg Public
 
Road map For Change Script For Fa 2012
Road map For Change Script For Fa 2012Road map For Change Script For Fa 2012
Road map For Change Script For Fa 2012
 
Ipe23 1306366634-vania mariska putri-ltm i
Ipe23 1306366634-vania mariska putri-ltm iIpe23 1306366634-vania mariska putri-ltm i
Ipe23 1306366634-vania mariska putri-ltm i
 
Roadmap snapshot for higher education
Roadmap snapshot for higher educationRoadmap snapshot for higher education
Roadmap snapshot for higher education
 
Expat Ease Managing An International Workforce V6.8
Expat Ease Managing An International Workforce  V6.8Expat Ease Managing An International Workforce  V6.8
Expat Ease Managing An International Workforce V6.8
 
3 GREAT Tech Tools To Consider
3 GREAT Tech Tools To Consider3 GREAT Tech Tools To Consider
3 GREAT Tech Tools To Consider
 
Top 2012 Tech Tips, Tools and Apps for Real Estate Brokers and Agents
Top 2012 Tech Tips, Tools and Apps for Real Estate Brokers and AgentsTop 2012 Tech Tips, Tools and Apps for Real Estate Brokers and Agents
Top 2012 Tech Tips, Tools and Apps for Real Estate Brokers and Agents
 
Back up tips
Back up tipsBack up tips
Back up tips
 
Why you should know the data
Why you should know the dataWhy you should know the data
Why you should know the data
 
How to Live an Exceptional Life
How to Live an Exceptional LifeHow to Live an Exceptional Life
How to Live an Exceptional Life
 
Characteristics of Successful Salespeople
Characteristics of Successful SalespeopleCharacteristics of Successful Salespeople
Characteristics of Successful Salespeople
 
A Good Web Site Guide
A Good Web Site GuideA Good Web Site Guide
A Good Web Site Guide
 

Similar to Customer Service Series For Everson Consulting

The Rise of Great Customer Experiences in the Fashion Sector
The Rise of Great Customer Experiences in the Fashion SectorThe Rise of Great Customer Experiences in the Fashion Sector
The Rise of Great Customer Experiences in the Fashion SectorWe Teach Fashion
 
Marketing yourself and Customer Service
Marketing yourself and Customer ServiceMarketing yourself and Customer Service
Marketing yourself and Customer ServiceRodolfo Ybañez
 
10 DO's and DON'Ts in Customer Service for Hotels and Restaurants
10 DO's and DON'Ts in Customer Service for Hotels and Restaurants10 DO's and DON'Ts in Customer Service for Hotels and Restaurants
10 DO's and DON'Ts in Customer Service for Hotels and RestaurantsBam Ramirez
 
Premier EPOS Staff training manual
Premier EPOS Staff training manualPremier EPOS Staff training manual
Premier EPOS Staff training manualPremier EPOS
 
A to Z of Customer Experience
A to Z of Customer ExperienceA to Z of Customer Experience
A to Z of Customer ExperienceMark Conway
 
mcs 429 writing assignment 2
mcs 429 writing assignment 2mcs 429 writing assignment 2
mcs 429 writing assignment 2Courtnei Dunn
 
Customer Service New
Customer Service NewCustomer Service New
Customer Service Newguest665fc089
 
Educating The Customer – Leading To Better Sales
Educating The Customer – Leading To Better SalesEducating The Customer – Leading To Better Sales
Educating The Customer – Leading To Better SaleseTailing India
 
Marketing To Employers
Marketing To EmployersMarketing To Employers
Marketing To Employersamyliz325
 
Newsletter Publisherfl
Newsletter PublisherflNewsletter Publisherfl
Newsletter PublisherflJasmine Mosby
 
No customer no glory
No customer no gloryNo customer no glory
No customer no gloryIKeizer
 
Customer Service - Appearance
Customer Service - AppearanceCustomer Service - Appearance
Customer Service - AppearanceKen Barnes, DBA
 
Customer service techniques for pharmacists.ppt
Customer service techniques for pharmacists.pptCustomer service techniques for pharmacists.ppt
Customer service techniques for pharmacists.pptDr. Vir Vikram
 

Similar to Customer Service Series For Everson Consulting (20)

March2011MAN-
March2011MAN-March2011MAN-
March2011MAN-
 
What is customer service
What is customer serviceWhat is customer service
What is customer service
 
Customer contact skill
Customer contact skillCustomer contact skill
Customer contact skill
 
The Rise of Great Customer Experiences in the Fashion Sector
The Rise of Great Customer Experiences in the Fashion SectorThe Rise of Great Customer Experiences in the Fashion Sector
The Rise of Great Customer Experiences in the Fashion Sector
 
Top 10 Customer Service Tips For 2015
Top 10 Customer Service Tips For 2015Top 10 Customer Service Tips For 2015
Top 10 Customer Service Tips For 2015
 
Marketing yourself and Customer Service
Marketing yourself and Customer ServiceMarketing yourself and Customer Service
Marketing yourself and Customer Service
 
10 DO's and DON'Ts in Customer Service for Hotels and Restaurants
10 DO's and DON'Ts in Customer Service for Hotels and Restaurants10 DO's and DON'Ts in Customer Service for Hotels and Restaurants
10 DO's and DON'Ts in Customer Service for Hotels and Restaurants
 
Premier EPOS Staff training manual
Premier EPOS Staff training manualPremier EPOS Staff training manual
Premier EPOS Staff training manual
 
Career Skills - Do it now
Career Skills - Do it nowCareer Skills - Do it now
Career Skills - Do it now
 
A to Z of Customer Experience
A to Z of Customer ExperienceA to Z of Customer Experience
A to Z of Customer Experience
 
mcs 429 writing assignment 2
mcs 429 writing assignment 2mcs 429 writing assignment 2
mcs 429 writing assignment 2
 
Customer Service New
Customer Service NewCustomer Service New
Customer Service New
 
Educating The Customer – Leading To Better Sales
Educating The Customer – Leading To Better SalesEducating The Customer – Leading To Better Sales
Educating The Customer – Leading To Better Sales
 
Marketing To Employers
Marketing To EmployersMarketing To Employers
Marketing To Employers
 
newhire
newhirenewhire
newhire
 
Newsletter Publisherfl
Newsletter PublisherflNewsletter Publisherfl
Newsletter Publisherfl
 
No customer no glory
No customer no gloryNo customer no glory
No customer no glory
 
Customer Service - Appearance
Customer Service - AppearanceCustomer Service - Appearance
Customer Service - Appearance
 
Customer service techniques for pharmacists.ppt
Customer service techniques for pharmacists.pptCustomer service techniques for pharmacists.ppt
Customer service techniques for pharmacists.ppt
 
Customer Classification
Customer Classification Customer Classification
Customer Classification
 

Customer Service Series For Everson Consulting

  • 1. customer service what’s the big deal? CUSTOMER SERVICE. TWO SIMPLE where. They’re captive customers— company with five employees in one words hold a lot of meaning. Taken you’ve got their applications, their tiny room can compete with a much literally, the phrase merely means money, and the answers to their ques- larger company, provided the small “serving the customer,” and that can tions, so does it matter what kind of company has the right technology—and be accomplished without so much as a experience they have in your office? good customer service. If both Company “hello,” “thank you,” or even eye con- You know they have to come back. A and Company B offer the same prod- tact. Combining the definitions of “cus- It might not matter, to a point. But uct at the same price, where will you tomer” and “service” from Funk & you still face competition. And the fact shop? Most likely, you will shop where Wagnalls Dictionary, one gets: “The that they may “have to” come back may you are treated as though you are the manner in which one who buys some- make your next interaction with them most important person in the world— thing is waited upon or served.” all the more stressful. which you are, at that point in the cus- Intrinsically, however, customer service tomer service experience. The compa- implies satisfying customers and provid- nies and organizations that outshine ing them with a positive, memorable A New Trend Toward everyone else in customer service earn experience. That means a lot more than Customer Service satisfied, loyal customers. any dictionary definition. In the financial aid field, how often As society moves beyond the industrial do you focus your efforts on customer age, new technologies are leveling the Your Competition service? After all, by the time students playing field for businesses and organi- are in your office, they don’t really have zations. With that shift comes a refocus For financial aid professionals, the com- much choice—they can’t “shop” else- on customer service. Nowadays, a petition you have to outshine includes VOL. 15, NO. 1, 2004 19 NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
  • 2. your co-workers, other schools, and ing the interview process who excel in students and their parents are discrimi- other organizations inside and outside customer service. We will also look at nating shoppers. They know what feels your industry. Not too tall an order, huh? ways to work with current team mem- right; they know what brings them back. bers who may not be willing or able to Your co-workers. Nearly every office, be a Millie. company, or department has one—you Creating Loyal Customers know, “that jerk in accounting,” or “that Other schools. Students are looking for pain-in-the-neck at the front desk.” three things in a school: a reasonable As I travel across the country meeting These are employees who may perform cost, a worthwhile education, and a with financial aid professionals, I am the technical aspects of their jobs quality experience. No matter how rea- struck by several points: exceedingly well, but lack interpersonal sonable the tuition, or how valuable the • The enormity of your responsibility. skills. Their negative approach colors potential degree, if a student is uncom- You literally control the purse the way everyone—customers, co- fortable or unhappy at the school, he or strings on your campus. workers, and supervisors— interacts she may leave before graduating. • The challenges you face each day, with them. There’s a popular television Granted, if students want to go to your but especially during your peak time, ad with the tagline: “Don’t be that guy.” school, they have to deal with you. By when everyone’s expectations are Better yet, don’t be that person. If stu- the time students receive their financial heightened. dents dread visiting the financial aid aid funds, you’ve got them for that • Your incredible opportunity to help office because they might get stuck with term. Hopefully it won’t be their last your school create loyal customers. you and are grateful when they get to with you. deal with someone else in your office, Financial aid professionals can’t do Never forget that your job is important. chances are it is because you don’t pro- much about tuition or curricula, but By helping students finance their col- vide good customer service, even if you they can certainly help or hurt students’ lege education, you are helping people give the students what they “need.” Be school experiences. A caring, supportive achieve their dreams. Success can come the employee that everyone enjoys atmosphere in the financial aid and from realizing that, and enjoying your working with, not the one that everyone other administrative offices can go a role. tries to avoid. long way in making a student feel good During my undergraduate years at about his or her educational choice. As This is the first in a series of upcom- the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire, the job market continues to tighten and ing articles examining the many facets of one person stood out as the epitome of tuitions continue to rise, the determin- customer service relevant to the finan- customer service. Sadly, she didn’t work ing factor in school choice may ulti- cial aid professional—understanding the in financial aid; that would have been mately be customer service. customer’s viewpoint, dealing with the too perfect for this series. Instead, Think about it: Does your financial difficult customer, building customer “Millie” worked in the student union. aid office create the kind of experience loyalty, and stress management for the She was the cashier who had a smile for where your graduates return to say financial aid professional. Hopefully, it everyone, and an infectious laugh that hello, looking for Millie? I sure hope so. will also help some of you put passion lifted the room. Everyone knew and Remember, they come back with their back in your job. respected her. I now look back on the memories, but they also bring their fam- To make this series as personal Millies at UWEC and realize they are a ilies, their friends, and their checkbooks. and pertinent as possible, I ask you major reason for my loyalty. When we Alumni give money, money builds to look for examples of outstanding returned to the campus for homecom- buildings, buildings house classrooms, customer service in your life over the ing each year, we all headed to the stu- classrooms are filled with students, and next few months. Determine what peo- dent union to say hello to Millie. As we students—well, they need financial aid. ple are doing around you to create that aged, Millie remained young—at heart. memorable customer service experi- She was always upbeat, always positive, Other companies and businesses. While ence. Please forward the most memo- always laughing and having fun sitting your school might not be in direct com- rable positive moments to me at on her stool at the cash register in the petition with the local grocery store or teverson@glhec.org, so we can build Blugold Room. bank, these institutions can and do them into our series. The year we returned to find influence each other. If a student gets Millie had passed away, homecoming terrific customer service at the bank changed. But the memories pull us only to be treated poorly in your office, Terry Everson is vice president for training, back. That is customer loyalty, not just by contrast that experience will reflect and Laura Gallagher is marketing customer satisfaction. Who are the on your office. Students might excuse communications specialist, for corporate Millies in your life? And are you the mediocre service once or twice, but not communications, at Great Lakes Millie to your students? if they’re consistently treated better at Educational Loan Services, Inc. They may In a future article in this series, we Store X or Bank Y than they are at be reached at teverson@glhec.org or will introduce ways to spot people dur- your school’s financial aid office. Your lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively. NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT 20 VOL. 15, NO. 1, 2004
  • 3. steps to customer loyalty: your secret to success EVERY DAY, WE EXPERIENCE THE GOOD AND THE BAD OF CUSTOMER This is the second article in service. We deliver service, we receive service. Think about your recent cus- tomer service experiences, as a receiver. The bad jumps out and lingers for weeks. Transcript’s series on customer Recently I experienced a case study in bad customer service. I purchased a light fixture and prepaid the bill because I understand that small businesses always face a cash-flow issue. When I picked up the fixture two weeks later, service in the student aid office. the store had posted “20 percent off” signs all over the place. I had paid the full price for the first fixture and was considering two or three additional ones to complement the new one in the dining room. When the clerk brought out the fixture, I had to ask about the discount. Besides putting me off with her look and attitude, she explained that I “proba- bly got a break” on the first fixture so I “should be happy” with the price I had paid. When I later checked the receipt, I discovered no price break whatsoev- er. Zip, zero, zilch. Price: fair. Quality: very nice. Customer service: miserable. No loyalty here—I bought the rest of my lighting elsewhere. Probably, so will everyone else I tell. Who Are Our Customers ? To talk customer service, we first must define who our customers are. It sounds easy enough. For instance your customers may include: • Current students • Faculty at the school • Students’ parents • Staff members • Former students (alumni) • Prospective students VO L . 1 5 , N O. 2 , 2 0 0 4 9 NA S FA A’s S tu d en t A i d T R A N S C R I P T
  • 4. Each population is unique, but they share several common Customer Satisfaction vs. Loyalty needs. They are all looking for a “professional” environ- ment, with service that is timely, thorough, respectful, and Years ago, we were just happy to get our needs met, courteous. These expectations don’t seem unrealistic consid- regardless of the delivery method. But things started chang- ering the dollars involved. Next to a home, an education is ing in the 1970s. Driven by the auto industry and the hi g h - probably the most expensive “product” we will ever pur- tech evolution, the notion of “quality” started to appear in ads, chase. then prices started to fall, and finally customer service became a strategic selling focus. Your competition may have been a The Competition leader in this push. Three elements—quality, price and service—are the cor- Before we go any further, l e t ’stalk about your organization. nerstones needed to create customer loyalty, according to a Who is your major competition? Is it the school down the classic Harvard Business Review article (Jan./Feb. 1993). street? Is it the lender with all the branches across the city? Is it the guarantor you always go up against for new and Customer Service Triangle existing business? The answer to these questions is yes and no. Of course, these groups compete for your business. Surprisingly, how- price quality ever, your real competition comes from the neighborhood convenience store, the street vendor who always has a smile, service the national chain that prides itself on creating “wow” cus- tomer service experiences. These are the folks you have to For a long time, “customer satisfaction” was the goal. As compete against every day when it comes to customer serv- long as your “product” fell within acceptable range for the ice. They keep raising the bar for everyone, including you. three cornerstones, the customer would be satisfied. Then a Consider this: On a recent flight from Chicago to few rebels decided that they could enhance one of the cor- Orlando, the flight nerstones and blow away the competition, providing they attendant handed me According to Professor Jon Anton of kept the other two within a reasonable range. a business card from Purdue University’s Center for the pilot with the fol- lowing hand-written Customer-Driven Quality, the most WalMart: Focus on price. note on the back: commonly cited reasons that Mr.Everson, customers leave a vendor are: Lexus: Focus on q u a l i t y. Thanks for flying p e rcent for better with us today and for all your flights on UAL. 68% customer service Nordstrom: Focus on s e rv i c e. I personally appreciate your business and look 13% for better price More recently, the concept of customer satisfaction has evolved into customer loyalty—that is, the qualities that forward to serving you keep you in high regard with your customers, and keep the again. 9% for better quality customers coming back to you. Why should you even worry Gary Rogeliner, about customer loyalty for your organization? Market Captain, 1/13/04 7% for other reasons research confirms that it costs six times more money to attract new customers than it does to retain your existing American Association of Insurance This knocked my socks Services Annual Conference, April 1997 customer base. And loyal customers tend to promote your off. I will keep that card organization through one of the most potent forms of adver- for years to come. (Oh, These numbers prove one very important tising: word-of-mouth. by the way, Captain point. Once in the fold, customers are yours Loyalty! We see it all over the place. School bumper Rogeliner is also your to keep or lose: it is up to you. stickers shout out school pride. My former boss even carries competition.) a coffee cup with the inscription, “My kid and my money go Lest we forget, your co-workers are also your competi- to the University of Minnesota.” Oh, by the way, he too is a tion. If I come into your office and “Sally” makes the finan- Gopher alum. cial aid experience personal, positive, and professional, she Loyalty goes hand in hand with personal pride. I am a raises the bar for everyone else in the office. Remember University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire “Blugold” and darned Millie from our first article, who was the staff member that proud of it. Both my kids are Blugolds. My grandkids? Too alums always sought out year after year during homecoming soon to tell. But our most recent alumni publication intro- week? The bar she raised is still up there even though she duced a new program to attract out-of-state students whose has been gone for 10 years. parents are alumni. Loyalty works! NA S FA A’s S tu d en t A i d T R A N S C R I P T 10 VO L . 1 5 , N O. 2 , 2 0 0 4
  • 5. How strong is this loyalty effect? Think about it—are Too often we present the options from our side of the there any products, services, or vendors that have your loy- fence—how it will make our job easier. But the customer does alty? My guess is that by now you return to them by a not (and should not) care about our side of the fence.We need deeply ingrained habit, but it did not just happen: they to scrap the old adage of “meet me in the middle on this one.” earned your loyalty. We need to be squarely on the customer’s side of the fence. Five Steps to Customer Loyalty Step 4. The customer is now asking, “Okay, so what do I have to do to get this benefit?” When the customer starts ask- In every customer service opportunity there are five basic steps ing what has to be done, the door is open. It is time for you when you have the chance to strengthen customer loyalty. to walk through. But be sure to present the action from the customer’s side of the fence. Step 1. The customer thinks, “I am important and want to be respected.” There is no logic and reason to this first step. It is Step 5. Wrap-up. In most customer service situations, this 100 percent emotion. Our challenge is to put our own “I am phase is sorely overlooked. You are so happy to be done with important” attitude aside and be willing to open ourselves the person, especially a challenging customer, that you just to the wants and needs of the customer. And at that want them to leave the office. You may miss a real “wow” moment, who is the most important person in the world in opportunity. When you wrap up your interaction, you sum- the eyes of the customer? We need to drop our self-focus marize the agreed-to action steps that everyone involved and put the customer on the pedestal. The best of the best in needs to take. Review what you will do, what they will do, and customer service do this naturally and have no problem by when. Close the interaction with a sincere thank you. Even abdicating personal power for the good of the customer. if they complained, acted out, or had an “attitude,” thank them for bringing the situation to your attention.Without that Step 2. The customer then thinks, “Consider my viewpoint.” knowledge, you couldn’t have helped them. Be honest and This may is an extension of Step 1, but it also addresses the sincere when thanking them. They really did you a favor by reality that each person is an individual and we need to be being open about their concerns. willing to personalize the customer service we provide. Each person has unique wants and needs. We must be first willing Excelling at Customer Service to listen to the customer, then ask informed and helpful questions in such a way that we show that we are willing to Loyalty returns customers to you, brings in new customers, treat that person with respect and dignity. and often makes future customer service easier as people Early in a customer service interaction, you may face begin to expect a positive reaction and are thus more heightened negative emotion. The person may just be look- relaxed from the start. To be strong in customer service, ing for someone to pick on.Treat this situation as an oppor- remember the Customer Service Triangle and do what it tunity to open yourself up and be the one who can create a takes to excel on the side of service. loyal customer, instead of reacting to negative emotions with negative emotions. The next article in this series will deal with the challenge of negative emotion in the customer service interaction. We will introduce a com- Step 3. The customer thinks,“What’s in it for me?” Basically, mon-sense model that should help you remain in control, even in the all of us are selfish. Once we reach this point in the interac- face of unrealistic or demanding customers. Believe it or not, they can be fun to serv e — h o n e s t ! tion, the customer is weighing the value of what we have to About the authors: offer against what he or she needs to do to receive this ben- Te rry Everson is vice president for training, and Laura Gallagher is the efit. If we can show the customer that the benefit is worth marketing communications specialist, for corporate communications at the necessary actions, we have a far better chance of moving Great Lakes Educational Loan Services, Inc. They may be reached at tever - to the next stage. son@glhec.org or lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively. did you know? The NASFAA Web site has everything you need to conduct a financial aid night presentation. The guide and accompanying slideshow are available at www.NASFAA.org/FinancialAidNight.asp. The NASFAA Web site also includes basic information on state-sponsored savings and prepaid tuition p rograms. Check it out at www.NASFAA.org/prepaid.asp. VO L . 1 5 , N O. 2 , 2 0 0 4 11 NA S FA A’s S tu den t A i d T R A N S C R I P T
  • 6. Everybody’s Got Them: Tough Customers The first two installments of our customer service series focused on traditional customer service issues—how to provide quality products at a fair cost through exceptional customer service. All along, we assumed that the customers we were dealing with were willing, cooperative, mature partners in the financial aid process. But guess what? Some customers aren’t so nice. In fact, some of them can be downright nasty, casting a pall over the entire financial aid experience. Here are a few ideas on how to handle your Tough Customers. AS I TRAVEL THE STUDENT-LOAN TRAINING CIRCUIT, the Direct Lending community, please remember this ad- attending state, regional, and national conferences to ex- age: You need them more than they need you. One of the amine customer service offerings, the one topic that con- key concepts we teach in the Great Lakes Customer Ser- sistently arises is “dealing with the difficult person.” I call vice Training model states: “The customer isn’t always them “Tough Customers.” The Tough Customer comes in right, but hopefully this customer will remain our cus- all shapes and sizes, and can hail from any age group, tomer.” race, or gender. However, they do exhibit some remark- Consider this theory: It costs considerably more to go ably consistent tendencies. In this article, we will discover out and attract new customers than it does to retain, ser- how to diagnose the situation, how to put a name to the vice, and delight the ones you already have. This may be a behavior, and how to apply the “Three Ps” of customer tough pill to swallow, especially if you are naturally com- service to a Tough Customer. petitive and enter every encounter with an “I must win” But first we need to spend some time studying the attitude. Then you realize you are in a classic “no-win” Tough Customer. We also need to look in the mirror and situation. You use all the tools of customer service—lis- admit—horror of horrors—that we may actually be con- tening, empathizing, understanding—and all the while the tributing to the Tough Customer situation. Tough Customer is tap dancing on your forehead. The Tough Customer is winning big time and knows it. Who Is the Tough Customer? But are they really winning? The Tough Customer can ruin your otherwise peaceful day The Tough Customer in Action with a nasty look, a bad attitude, a mean word, or inappro- priate behavior. Why is it that people who walk into your If you assume the role of interested observer, you can put office—people who need your service—can treat you with much of this Tough Customer behavior into perspective. such disrespect? Whether you find yourself working for We have all seen the Tough Customer in action. Hard as it an institution, lender, servicer, guarantor, or as a part of is to admit, sometimes we even fall into the role ourselves. VOL. 15, NO. 3, 2004 26 NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
  • 7. When I travel, I often get to play the role of interested his welcome and unfortunately I was seated next him for observer, as there are Tough Customers all over the air- the entire flight. The most telling comment came from one ports. Airline travel seems to attract Tough Customer be- of the lucky 19 who got a seat. He asked the flight atten- havior. Trust me, when a Tough Customer unloads on an dant to thank the rest of us for our patience and apolo- unsuspecting airline staffer, it makes all the other travel- gized for the inconvenience. He was rushing home that ers embarrassed, uncomfortable, and concerned for the cus- night to be with his sick daughter. All I could do was tomer-service person. smile; all was right with the world. I began the initial draft for this article while trapped on the tarmac at the De- The Few, the troit airport in a small Tough… commuter plane. We were held up for more To better understand the than two hours because Tough Customer, let’s the connecting flight was take a look at some sig- late, and airline officials nificant numbers. In my chose to delay our depar- customer service train- ture so that the other ing programs I often travelers could make it to conduct informal sur- Dayton that same night. veys of the participants Unfortunately, there to determine how many were 26 connecting pas- customers fall into each sengers and only 19 seats of one of three catego- left on our plane. For two ries: hours airline officials ☺ = 75% debated ways to rectify = 20% the situation. = 5% Most passengers took the opportunity to Your numbers may vary doze, read, or watch the with your job duties, the discussions through the time of the year, or sim- windows. But the resi- ply the phase of the dent Tough Customer fi- moon. nally started bellowing. The breakdown is re- “How perfect for this ar- vealing. Ninety-five per- ticle,” I thought. He was cent of customers are loud, young, totally self- either in a good or neu- absorbed, and he wanted tral mood when they start to be heard. the customer-service ex- The flight attendant perience. And that other did a great job with this guy. She listened to his comments, five percent? Not all unhappy customers are certifiable stayed calm, and ignored his inappropriate comments about Tough Customers. Of the five percent who are unhappy, her and the airline as he ranted to his buddies over his cell only about one in five is a hardened Tough Customer. For- phone. The attendant followed the Three Ps of customer tunately for the financial aid professional, the other four service. Specifically: can be made happy through good customer service. It takes She remained Positive, work but it can be done. That leaves just one in 100 truly She treated everyone in a Personal manner, and difficult customers. She was Professional at all times. Now the more difficult question: What about the other When we finally departed, everyone was relieved, but half of the equation? That’s you. Remember our 75/20/5 no one more than me. The Tough Customer had worn out breakdown? Well, guess what? If you are unwilling or VOL. 15, NO. 3, 2004 27 NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
  • 8. unable to abide by the Three Ps, you might personally be from an emotional gut-level. For example, this might hap- responsible for driving a large percentage of your custom- pen when a student walks in and demeans a staff member ers to the dark side. because someone made a mistake on the student’s paper- work—scolding, like a parent. The staff member then Two Tough-Customer Categories responds with anger and emotion, taking on the child role. The Tough Customer usually falls into two general cat- egories of inappropriate behavior—“parent” or “child”— Customers Assuming a “Child” Role: The other extreme which can be understood through a communication model is just as dysfunctional in a customer-service setting. developed by psychologist Eric Berne in the 1950s. His What is your normal reaction when a Tough Customer Transactional Analysis model, taught in every Introduc- exhibits child behavior, such as whining, blaming oth- tion to Psychology class through the early 1970s, said that ers, crying, or throwing tantrums? Admit it—you want when interacting, people tend to fall to tell them to grow up and stop into one of three ego states: parent, acting like a child. Your tendency adult, or child. Briefly, the parent to act out the parent role is in- role tends to speak from values and The customer-service creased. Sadly, these parenting re- judgments, the adult role from logic actions are often so ingrained, we and reasoning, and the child role person must always get hooked into responding to the from emotions. customer with corresponding inap- As a trained counselor, I had stay in the “adult” propriate behavior. It may only be always found this model always too a condescending look or demean- simple, so I shoved it into my men- role... Don’t get ing sigh, but it all has the same ef- tal “junk drawer.” Now the K.I.S.S. fect. For example, have you ever approach (Keep it Simple, Stupid) seen this in your office? A student is gaining traction, and I find it is pulled into childlike walks in whining about a problem time to resurrect Transactional with his or her aid. The staff mem- Analysis and apply it to customer emotional responses ber sighs, then “retaliates” by point- service. ing out the errors the student made Here is how it works. In any or parent-like on the FAFSA. The result isn’t customer-service setting there are pretty. two players, you and the customer. judgmental reactions. The customer comes to you with Responding as an Adult behavior that fits nicely into the par- ent, adult, or child category. Your So what can you do? Here’s where response can be from the parent, child, or adult category the fun begins. The customer-service person must always as well. In fact, people can even shift roles during an in- stay in the “adult” role—rational, logical, and friendly. teraction. Effective customer service, however, responds Don’t get pulled into child-like emotional responses or from the adult role (logical, reasonable), regardless of the parent-like judgmental reactions. Even when the Tough role presented by the customer. Customer plays all their cards, use the Three P’s to stay clear. Customers Assuming a “Parent” Role: If the Tough Cus- I equate it to this scenario: You are a five-pound bass tomer exhibits condescending, critical, sarcastic, or de- swimming in a lake during a bass tournament. There are meaning behavior, or attempts to establish him or herself many opportunities to get hooked, but for your own good, as someone who should be feared or respected, the cus- let the bait slide on by. tomer is playing out the parent role. The Tough Customer is—intentionally or unintention- These customers have a tendency to talk down to you; ally—baiting you. Just smile sincerely and let the Tough they need to let you know how important they are. When Customer know you are there to help. If you try to fight dealing with a Tough Customer in parent mode, our natu- back, you are taking the bait and you are going to lose— ral tendency is to revert back to child behavior—reacting putting the Tough Customer back in charge. VOL. 15, NO. 3, 2004 28 NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
  • 9. If you use the Transactional Analysis model, dealing Now, some final good news: When faced with this one with a Tough Customer almost becomes fun because he percent, you don’t have to take them personally! Give it or she can become so wound up or irrational, while you your best shot and know that you used the Three Ps and remain in control of yourself and the situation. you stayed in the “adult” role. If it doesn’t work, recog- nize that maybe nothing could satisfy this customer. It Works! (Most of the Time…) When you see a colleague facing this type of person— doing all the right things but still feeling terrible after the Now, for the good news and bad news. The good news: interaction—take a moment to congratulate that colleague Using these techniques, you can turn 99 percent of the on a good effort. Ninety-nine out of 100 percent is darned good. customers to your side. They may not leave as your bo- You can even take it one step further. When you are som buddy, but at least they know you care and you handled out and about—in a restaurant, in an airport—and you them in a positive manner. witness a customer-service representative doing all the Bad news: You may not be able to turn that final one right things, regardless of outcome, acknowledge their percent. Despite your best customer-service efforts, de- efforts. They were simply facing that one percent. spite the best training, despite your desire to make every- By Terry Everson, vice president for training, and Laura one a satisfied customer, there are some who pride Gallagher, marketing communications specialist, for themselves on being the worst of the worst. Their job is to Corporate Communications at Great Lakes Educational make everyone around them miserable and no matter what Loan Services, Inc. They may be reached at you say, or how you say it, they will remain miserable. teverson@glhec.org or lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively. These folks seriously want to remain this way and noth- Please send us your examples of outstanding—or unbeliev- ing you can do in a short customer-service interaction is ably bad—customer service. We will build them into our going to change them. So be it. upcoming articles. VOL. 15, NO. 3, 2004 29 NASFAA’s Student Aid TRANSCRIPT
  • 10. 76748_pg24-27 3/2/05 8:18 AM Page 24 we need to delight taking customer service to the By Terry Everson and Laura Gallagher Hello folks—here we are again, talk- highest ing about customer service and what it takes to create memorable customer service moments. The first article in this six-part series introduced the importance of customer service in the student aid field. Remarkably, after that article was published, some read- level ers responded asking whether students are really “customers.” Well, not only are they customers, but so are their par- ents, their co-signers, your co-workers, your faculty, your vendors, and guar- antors/servicers. Add to that list any- one else who you interact with on a daily basis, and the importance of cus- tomer service should be apparent. In the second article, we stressed the importance of creating loyal cus- tomers. These are the customers that 24 STUDENT AID TRANSCRIPT
  • 11. 76748_pg24-27 3/2/05 8:18 AM Page 25 use your “product”—in the case of my house in Madison, Wisconsin, or asked that I give him a call at his new financial aid, the services you provide one in the Tucson, Arizona, or Spokane, job to let him know the bag had been to students and families—and literal- Washington, the store’s processes, look repaired to my satisfaction. That was ly become walking testimonials for the and feel, and product selection are pret- five years ago, but he still came to mind value, quality, and the related customer ty much the same. But Judy is not stan- recently when I gave that same bag to service associated with the “product.” dardized. Judy isn’t found in every a new high school golfer. Loyal customers will stay with store. Judy is found at my store. you even if there is an occasional Just last week, I walked into the store “Bill Murray” Thinks Ahead small glitch in the customer service to pick up some hay fever medication. The Walt Disney Company has long experience. As I walked past the cosmetics section, been recognized for creating memo- In the third and most recent article, I heard a friendly voice ask if I would rable guest experiences. They train their we acknowledged that difficult like to try a sample of Antonio staff to look for memorable customer customers exist and must be dealt with Banderas’ new men’s cologne, “AB.” service opportunities. I can recall one in a positive manner. We pointed out Judy has a huge smile, a kind word for particular personal event that exempli- that in some cases, your behavior may all customers, and an infectious laugh fies this “A” attitude. be a contributing factor to some that warms the entire store. She seemed When our family assembled for the of those challenging customer service so proud of this new cologne, I umpteenth “Kodak Moment” in front situations. humored her with a trial “splash on,” of the 50-foot silver golf tee at one of Today we want to discuss how to take and found I had to have it. Not because Disney’s golf courses, a groundskeep- your customer service to the “Wow!” it smelled good—I really didn’t like it er—who looked a lot like Bill Murray level—that is, how to create memorable that much. And not because it came in the movie “Caddyshack”— customer service. In any customer serv- with a free AB golf hat. The last thing approached us as we stood on his per- ice situation, you can do a decent job I need was another golf hat. I had to fectly mowed lawn. I knew we were in and receive a “C” grade. Keeping with have it because Judy just created a trouble. To my surprise, instead of the academic theme, an even better job memorable customer service shooing us away, he asked if he could that exceeds the average performance moment—a personal connection take the family picture so that I could will earn you a “B.” The greater chal- between me, the product, the process, be included. We would have a photo of lenge is how to earn an “A” in customer and the store. the whole family, dad included! Since service. Today I’d like to describe the When I sheepishly walked into my that time, I’ve volunteered to take hun- steps to creating a memorable customer condo, cologne in one hand, AB hat in dreds of pictures for people all over the service experience. another, my wife looked up from her world, giving them a chance to include book and smiled when she saw the the entire family in the family album. Creating Memorable Customer Walgreen’s bag. “I see you met Judy,” Why? Because it meant so much to me Service she said. “Isn’t she the most wonder- to receive the same kind of offer. Think about the last time someone sim- ful clerk?” ply blew your socks off with incredi- “The S’sence of Customer Service” ble customer service. My guess is that Eric’s Extra Mile What makes these memorable customer it didn’t cost the organization anything Then there is Eric at my golf shop. Eric service experiences? In researching, more than it would have cost them for faithfully fed my golf habit for years, experiencing, and observing them, I’ve “C” service. Memorable customer serv- but he also sold me the “golf bag from coined the phrase “The ‘S’sence of ice is about the people who do the job; hell.” It broke four times. Each time, Customer Service.” Here is some of that the people that bring smiles to our Eric worked with me and the supplier “S”sence: faces. It is not simply a process that to ensure that I was a happy camper. has been re-engineered or continually On the fifth collapse, Eric laughed as Smiles Abound improved. Let’s look at three shining I lugged it into the store. The good Student aid can be a dehumanizing examples of people who give memo- news, he said, was that he would again process, involving with a combination rable customer service: Judy, Eric, and send the bag out for repairs. The bad of sensitive, sometimes complex finan- “Bill Murray.” news was he was leaving the store later cial information; intimidating paper- that week to take a new job in the cell work; and the educational hopes and Judy’s Smile phone industry. dreams of a family among other things. First there is Judy. Judy works for a It was then that he hit me with a Definitions that apply in other settings, national drug store chain, Walgreens. memorable customer service moment. such as dependency, family, and assets, Whether you are in the Walgreens near He gave me his new business card and don’t always apply the same way in NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS 25
  • 12. 76748_pg26 2/16/05 7:56 AM Page 26 student aid. Your customers may come customers were as organized and There is enough mystery into your office mad, confused, or con- informed about student aid policy as cerned about paying for college. Your you are, but guess what? They aren’t. in the student aid process smile—the “Judy” smile—creates an You are the expert. Student aid is just without adding to it with environment where students and fam- one of hundreds of new experiences ilies feel welcome. They know that you they are dealing with as they navigate poorly marked directions. are there for them at that moment, you through the higher education process. care about their circumstances, and you They will appreciate you treating them Walk to, and then are willing to help them understand. according to the three P’s—in a through, your work area. Help is at hand. Positive, Personal, Professional man- ner—giving simple, clear, practical Can new students Signage Is a Must instructions that will help them accom- navigate it without a Have you ever tried to find your way plish their goals. And when you think in a city that has poor signage? It is dis- about it, this will help you accomplish special understanding of concerting. There is enough mystery in your goals as well. the student aid process without adding “college-speak”? to it with poorly marked directions. Sales Opportunities at Every Walk to, and then through, your work Juncture en out a processing problem on cam- area. Can new students navigate it with- Judy did it. Eric did it. My Bill Murray pus or with a guarantor. Other times it out a special understanding of “college- look-alike did it. Top shelf customer may mean sending a quick note to speak”? (Just what is a “bursar”?) Are service staff look for opportunities to someone who had to drop out, encour- directions and offices well labeled? (If cross-sell their organization, their aging them to recognize that a dream I have financial aid, where do I go to department and their product. The postponed may not be a dream ended. pay my bill? Do I have to stand in a offices of financial aid, the registrar, the When you receive this type of service, special “financial aid” line at the book- bursar, admissions, and student servic- you feel a sense of appreciation and joy. store?) Are the waiting areas user- es all contribute to a series of independ- When you give this level of service, friendly and self-explanatory, prevent- ent, yet very interrelated events. Look your self-pride and occasional recog- ing students and families from wasting for ways to ensure that everyone at all nition from the customer will earn you time in the wrong place? Do the stu- critical touch points—within your office your daily “A” grade. dents know where they are at any given and throughout the campus—works for These key points will help you and moment, to whom they are talking, and the good of the student and sells the full your office staff be better prepared to where they go next? value of your institution. Instead of deliver those Memorable Customer looking for ways to make the financial Service moments to your varied cus- Secrets to Cleanliness aid office look better at the expense of tomer groups: students, parents, co- Your mom probably told you cleanli- other offices and departments, work workers, and business partners. ness is next to godliness. I don’t know with those other departments to ensure With the “S”sence of service now about that, but a pleasant, welcoming that you are all focused on creating a firmly affixed in your office plan, we office space creates an air of comfort complete, positive customer service are ready to find ways to mentally pre- and relaxation and has a calming effect experience for the student. pare for each day. The next installment on your customers. A flower here, a in this series will deal with the issue of magazine there, a humorous quote or a Snapshots at the Seventh Hole stress, stress management, relaxation fun picture can help. But bear in mind The “best of the best” at customer serv- techniques, and tools that you and your the types of messages your décor may ice look for ways to go the extra yard, staff can use to refresh your mind, your send. Some staff post cartoons or exceed the customers’ expectations, body, your spirit. quotes that actually make fun of the stu- reach out with a kind gesture or offer dents—the very people they serve. a kind word, and be a bright spot in the Terry Everson is vice president for What kind of message do you think that day. In student aid, this may mean not training, and Laura Gallagher is the sends? Remember, you need them more only answering the questions students marketing communications specialist than they need you. ask, but anticipating the ones they’ll for corporate communications at Great need to know three stages down the Lakes Educational Loan Services, Inc. Simple Instructions line. Sometimes it is as simple as pick- They may be reached at teverson@ Please remember, you are the subject ing up the phone and clearing the way glhec.org or lgallagher@glhec.org, matter expert. You may wish that all for a student who is trying to straight- respectively. 26 STUDENT AID TRANSCRIPT
  • 13. 77788_44_47 7/25/05 3:17 PM Page 44 T Stress for Success By Terry Everson and Laura Gallagher
  • 14. 77788_44_47 7/25/05 3:17 PM Page 45 T he first four articles in our customer service series focused on understand- ing why customers do what they do, and finding ways to adapt to their needs. This installment addresses the natural reaction to all of these chal- lenges: stress. In his 1960’s rock classic, War, Edwin Starr asks: “War! What is it good direction. They can range from the jerks who blow through the neighborhood stop sign to the clown who tries to check out 47 items in the “10 or less” lane at the local grocery store. Stressors may be the tough co-worker, the broken photocopi- er, the family computer that eats your data, or the confused incoming fresh- man with condescending, angry parents ■ ■ ■ cynical a sense of inner emptiness morbid fear of death What Is Stress Good For? All of these symptoms seem to imply that stress really is good for “absolute- ly nothing.” We’d like to challenge that thought, however. We believe that for?” His rhetorical response was in tow. Not sabertooth tigers, but they’re stress, when managed in a healthy man- “Absolutely NOTHING!” also stressors nonetheless. ner, can be a real plus in our lives. I’d like to twist that question a bit and Anyone who ever played competitive ask, “Stress: What is it good for?” Well The Effects of Stress games or sports knows when the pres- it turns out that stress is good for some- How do you know if stress is having a sure is on. Whether it is softball, bowl- thing, despite the bad rap its received negative affect on you? Here are five ing, croquet in the yard, poker with over the years. Stress can add value to general stress-symptom categories: friends, or ice hockey at the rink, our your office, and when channeled prop- stress responses kick in to help us pre- erly, can create positive results. PHYSICAL pare for the challenge. ■ frequent backaches The same holds true for you in your What Is Stress? ■ fatigue office setting. That heightened aware- First, let’s first spend a few minutes ■ indigestion ness, that sharpened vision, that sense better understanding the origins of ■ grinding teeth of urgency—all are driven by the good stress and its impact on our daily lives. ■ accident prone kind of stress. Let’s call it eustress. We’ll use an example familiar to many ■ chest pains Webster's New Millennium™ Dictionary readers: golf. Consider the young golf ■ drinking too much caffeine of English defines eustress as “stress that pro from Florida who also spends his ■ smoking is deemed healthful or giving one a sense free time sky diving, extreme skiing, ■ tension in the back and shoulders of fulfillment.” Do a Google search on and sheer cliff mountain climbing. ■ prone to illness eutress and you will find articles actu- Asked when stress and fear most affect- ally praising the value of stress in our ed him, he replied without hesitation, MENTAL lives. The secret is managing the stress “On the first tee every time I play golf.” ■ easily confused to remain positive. Stress is very personal and relative. ■ lethargic Eustress kicks in when the end-of-the- In a recent Golfline.com article, Neil ■ negative self image month report is due and you are three Morrison compared the stress that play- ■ few friends or hobbies days behind in your work. It kicks in ers face on the green to the early cave- ■ forgetful when the staff has to ramp up for the man “fight or flight” response. Of course, upcoming semester, or a major disburse- it’s been sometime since any of us went EMOTIONAL ment needs to get out by 8 p.m. tonight. nose-to-nose with Mr. Sabertooth Tiger, ■ anxious Eustress sharpens, it energizes, it stim- but I’ll bet some of your most difficult ■ unhappy most of the time ulates, and it creates the office rush. students can produce the same fight or ■ constantly worrying So why do we think of stress as neg- flight reaction in you. Do you run to the ■ irritable ative? Left unchecked, or unmanaged, back office to avoid the impending ■ easily frustrated even the good stress—your eustress— doom, or do you stoke up the engines can evolve into the bad stuff: distress. and get ready for the upcoming conflict? SOCIAL When distress takes over, the varied What goes through our minds and ■ feeling isolated, lonely symptoms like those listed under our bodies during a fight-or-flight reaction? ■ little contact with friends five categories begin to appear. Some of the major changes include ■ poor relations with coworkers Needless to say, distress is not good. dilated pupils, sweaty palms, pounding ■ distrusting heart muscles, numb or trembling legs, ■ using people only for selfish gains What Causes Stress? and rapid breathing. All of this can take Stressors come in all shapes and sizes. place when the campus problem child SPIRITUAL When I work with financial aid profes- just comes into the office. ■ feeling like a martyr sionals, I find it interesting how similar Stress inducers can come from every ■ unforgiving the office stressors are across the coun- NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS 45
  • 15. 77788_44_47 7/25/05 3:17 PM Page 46 try. Personal stressors may vary with You may want to hold onto them— house, create a filing system with each individual, however, so getting a stressors can become so familiar, they pockets for each month’s receipts, clear picture of the nature of your stres- are like lifelong family members—but compile a central phone and sors can help put everything into per- they need to be jettisoned to alleviate address directory, post a family spective. Try using the matrix below to and prevent the stress-related symp- dry-erase calendar—these all are capture your personal stressors. toms in our five categories. easily accomplished. To really do this right, you should ■ Drink water—lots of it: Water first devote an entire evening to creat- Managing Stress helps your body operate at optimal ing a “stressor list.” (For those of us That leaves us with Box 1. Once you levels. Reduce or eliminate who aren’t list makers, this in itself have completed Box 1, your real work caffeine, alcohol, and nicotine. could be a stressor.) This list should begins. This is where you need to focus You may not be the life of the include the things that cause you stress your efforts for minimizing the nega- party, but you sure will feel better symptoms. tive effects of stress. There must be every morning. Once you have completed your list, thousands of stress management tech- ■ Get a pet: Dogs, cats, iguanas, you will need to do some serious soul niques out there, from exercising to parakeets, hamsters all provide the searching; the next step may be the dietary changes, from organizational chance to love, and be loved, most important. Using the matrix pro- skills to “journaling,” and everything unconditionally. vided, categorize each of your stressors in between. The following are a few we ■ Communicate: Find a friend, a into one of the four boxes. find especially helpful. family member, or perhaps a coun- Box 1: Stressors that are important and ■ Sleep: Try to establish a set sleep selor who will listen to you about you have some control over them routine and keep it your stressors and possibly offer Box 2: Stressors that are important but ■ Breathe/meditate: The calming a different perspective on your you have no control over them effect of meditation and controlled situation. Box 3: Stressors that are unimportant breathing can have a huge impact ■ Reach out: Taking a moment to but you have control over them on your responses to stress. assist a neighbor, do volunteer Box 4: Stressors that are unimportant ■ Exercise: In addition to general work, or just help a stranger can and you do not have control over them health benefits, aerobic exercise reduce stress and increase your Be honest. Is it a big deal that the triggers endorphins in your brain, sense of personal well-being. driver in front of you is going three generating positive feelings. You A great Web site dealing with stress miles an hour under the posted speed don’t need a gym or expensive is www.stresstips.com. This site con- limit, won’t pull over even though you equipment to exercise. A 30-minute tains a wealth of information and, best have flipped them off (with your lights, walk at lunchtime or a brisk walk of all, it is free. of course), and only allows you to pass in the evening before or after din- As our lives become more stressful at seven miles over the posted speed ner is a great start. Make your goal and our family, friends, children, part- limit? Will you really capture that one “SMART”—Specific, Measurable, ners, and co-workers experience simi- important car-length at the next light? Achievable, a Reach, and Time- lar pressures, we need to recognize When you finish completing the focused—and you are on your way. when stress is a positive motivator, and matrix, look at the stressors in Box 4 ■ Be nice to yourself: Try positive when it is “good for absolutely noth- and let them go. They’re unimportant self-talk. Give yourself credit, even ing.” When stress arises from some- and you have no control over them. The if others won’t. thing unimportant or out of your con- same holds true for all of those stres- ■ Try to become more organized: trol, find a safe place to let it go. Find sors in Boxes 2 and 3—not important Always put your keys on the same that safe place for you. and you control them or, important but hook, keep a couple of extra pairs Stress is all around us, but Smokey you can’t control them. Let them go. of reading glasses around the Bear was right: Only you… STRESS MATRIX LIST EACH OF YOUR PERSONAL STRESSORS WITHIN THE APPROPRIATE CATEGORY. Terry Everson is vice president for BOX 1: IMPORTANT AND YOU HAVE SOME CONTROL BOX 3: UNIMPORTANT BUT YOU HAVE training, and Laura Gallagher is the SOME CONTROL marketing communications specialist for corporate communications at Great Lakes Educational Loan Services, Inc. BOX 2: IMPORTANT BUT YOU HAVE NO CONTROL BOX 4: UNIMPORTANT AND YOU HAVE NO CONTROL They may be reached at teverson@ glhec.org or lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively. 46 STUDENT AID TRANSCRIPT | VOL 16 | NO 2 | 2005
  • 16. 78660.50-55 11/2/05 10:21 AM Page 50 50 STUDENT AID TRANSCRIPT
  • 17. 78660.50-55 11/2/05 10:21 AM Page 51 CUSTOMER SERVICE It’s the People and the Process By Terry Everson and Laura Gallagher uring this six-article ner that create an output, result, or your dream home on a prime piece of D series, we have focused deliverable. Examples of processes real estate. It will be a funky little on the human aspect of within the student aid environment prairie-style home, much in the image customer service. But include: of Frank Lloyd Wright’s work. You one critical piece • Information dissemination meet with the builder, he meets with remains. According to • Application the architect, everything is finalized, W. Edwards Deming— • Verification and documentation and construction begins. who is often credited with being the • Loan processing Soon you discover your builder is a father of Statistical Process Control • Due diligence free spirit and prides himself on keep- (SPC) and with turning around Japan’s • Awarding funds ing everything in his head, with little manufacturing industry in the 1950s • Appeals formal documentation. Nothing is writ- and 1960s—85% of problems in the • Audits ten down. Still, you don’t worry. All work environment are caused by the • Reporting the subcontractors are dedicated, hard- process that people are working with- To be an effective process manager, working and take great pride in their in—not the people. Staff do not nor- you must first ensure that your process- respective crafts. Sounds like your mally come to work each day trying to es are well-documented and under con- financial aid office, right? Let’s see make errors. trol, with little variability. To illustrate what happens. What is a process? From a manufac- this point, let’s leave the financial aid Once the utilities are installed and turing and utility standpoint, a process sphere for a moment and use an exam- the foundation is poured, the rough car- is a series of interrelated activities con- ple from everyday life. penters arrive. They follow the lead of ducted in a regular and successive man- Suppose you have decided to build the builder and believe they have a NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS 51
  • 18. 78660.50-55 11/2/05 10:21 AM Page 53 clear understanding of the final prod- (SMEs), when they instead often end ator ends up in the master bedroom of uct. As they begin construction, they up as the single point of failure (SPOF). your new home. decide to make a few changes in an This type of inefficiency can quick- So what is a team to do? What is a effort to improve the final product. ly turn into chaos when the boss comes leader to do? They decide that a second story will be back from a training session on improv- a nice touch and a large garage will ing department productivity and You’re Part of a Process make storage much easier. They also decides that some of the processes need The first step toward improving cus- decide that by turning the floor plan to be upgraded. If the boss forgets to tomer service is realizing that you are around a bit they can capture valuable discuss these changes with the regis- not an isolated entity within your organ- solar heat and save on utility costs. trar, bursar, student services staff, and ization. Changes made by one office The only problem is, the plumber admissions team, then the financial aid affect other offices. We need to stop wasn’t told of the changes. He installs staff members are making the changes thinking of our team as a solitary unit the soaking tub in the middle of the in a vacuum. This is how the refriger- that we control, but rather as a series kitchen and the stove finds its way into of interconnected processes. Even with- the master bath. in the aid office, changes in one area The electrician also is in the dark can have a negative impact on other about the changes, so he overlooks wiring for the second floor. These are What is a team financial aid processes. When your process feeds into another team, or they two big problems, wouldn’t you say? feed into your team, cooperation and Now remember, all these people take great pride in their work. They even to do? What is collaboration become critical. pride themselves on “continuous Understanding Process improvement” by looking for ways to meet and exceed the customers’ a leader to do? Management There is a wealth of information on the expectations. Here is some of what’s Internet relating to process manage- going wrong: ment. A Google search on the phrase • Because of a lack of documentation, everyone is doing their own thing, and end up either complementing the efforts of others or causing severe Keep Your Process Management hardships. • As changes are made in the name of Tools Handy continuous improvement, one team looks great, the other team looks There are many valuable tools to help you achieve your process manage- foolish, and ultimately the construc- ment goals. Be sure the following tools are in your tool box: tion process is a mess. • Gantt Charts depict a project schedule at a glance, identifying the key Now let’s draw some parallels in the phases in a project life cycle and their sequence and time requirements. aid office. Many offices are currently • Affinity Diagrams organize random ideas into similar groups and helps working within processes that are not create visual groupings of like ideas under a header or theme. well-documented. The way things are • Control/Run Charts plot variable activity over a specific period, mak- now done is eerily similar to the ing it easier to visualize what is happening in a process. processes used 5-10 years ago. When • Fishbone Charts show, in diagram form, relationships between causal asked why something is done in a par- factors and their resulting effects. ticular manner, the common response • Scatter Diagrams show how process variables are related. They can be among aid office staff is “We’ve always used to discover and document possible cause-and-effect relationships. done it that way.” • Pareto Charts use a simple bar-graph format to rank the cause, source, Worse yet, certain staff members types, or reasons for problems and/or opportunities. have become “resident experts” who believe their value within the team All of these tools will help you document your processes, the critical first increases when they are the only one step in any improvement initiative. who can accomplish a certain task. These type of employees often believe themselves to be subject matter experts NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS 53
  • 19. 78660.50-55 11/2/05 10:21 AM Page 55 As an old training Rarely is there a single, simple adage advises, “If it cause-and-effect relationship; to isn’t nailed down, get good ideas, be sure to include all of your staff. take it. If it is nailed 6. Create action steps assigning tar- down, adapt it!” get responsibilities and target dates. Be sure to get everyone actively Find the process involved in the planning and imple- management tools mentation process. Involvement increases commitment. that best meet 7. Create a master plan to ensure that your needs. everyone knows their responsibil- ities and deadline dates, and under- stands the interrelationship be- “process management” generated more tween all activities. This will raise than 17 million hits. As an old training consciousness and increase ac- adage advises, “If it isn’t nailed down, countability. take it. If it is nailed down, adapt it!” 8. Follow through to bring your plan Find the process management tools that to completion. Unless it is man- best meet your needs. aged well, the best-laid plan can One of the best tools for speeding up fall into disrepair without consis- your learning curve and implementa- tent attention. tion cycle is a publication from GOAL QPC titled “The Memory Jogger II.” It Customer Service and You is a wonderful compilation of data col- In the six articles of this series, we hope lection and process management tools. we have planted many seeds for growth Possibly the best starting tool is Process in your approach to customer service. Mapping, which can be used on inter- Perhaps the best summary for this and intra-department processes. It series is an example that brings home details which employee does what, and the critical nature of customer service. in what sequence, thereby providing a As we were finishing this article, as if working snapshot of key processes on cue, a shipment arrived in the office There are eight key steps in GOAL with the following message stamped QPC’s Process Mapping tool: across the box: Remember, the next 1. Select a process that needs to be inspector in the process is the customer! improved. Your staff can be espe- Enough said. cially helpful in choosing the right We are constantly being evaluated by one. Start with a process that is eas- our customers, our co-workers, our ily defined and has produced its employers, and our employees. Even share of speed bumps for the team. our business partners and community 2. Assemble a team. Sometimes it leaders are watching. Be sure your staff helps to bring in someone from and processes “wow” your customers. another team to serve as a sound- That’s customer service. ing board and an “unbiased” observer. Terry Everson is senior vice president 3. Map out the present application. of training and sales for Student Loan Pictures and images are worth a Xpress. Laura Gallagher is the mar- thousand words. List in detail who keting communications specialist for does what tasks, and in what order. corporate communications at Great 4. Define the day-to-day problem Lakes Educational Loan Services, areas that slow down customer Inc. They may be reached at service delivery. terry.everson@slxpress.com or 5. Brainstorm to find solutions. lgallagher@glhec.org, respectively. NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT FINANCIAL AID ADMINISTRATORS 55