SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 40
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Congressional Budget Office
The University of Chicago Booth School of Business
Chicago, Illinois
March 7, 2016
Wendy Edelberg
Associate Director for Economic Analysis
For additional information, see Congressional Budget Office, “Dynamic Analysis,” www.cbo.gov/topics/dynamic-analysis.
Dynamic Analysis at CBO
1CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Overview
■ New requirement for dynamic scoring
■ CBO’s approach to dynamic analysis
■ Case study: A dynamic estimate of repealing the Affordable
Care Act
2CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
The New Requirement for
Dynamic Scoring
3CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Main Points
■ Conventional cost estimates already incorporate behavioral
responses but not changes in broad economic variables.
■ The requirement to estimate the budgetary feedback of
macroeconomic effects applies to major legislation.
■ CBO has estimated the budgetary feedback of macroeconomic
effects but generally not for cost estimates for legislation.
4CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Behavioral Responses Addressed in Conventional
Cost Estimates
■ If proposed policies would affect people’s behavior in ways
that would affect the budget, those effects are incorporated in
CBO’s conventional estimates.
■ By long-standing convention, CBO’s cost estimates generally
have not reflected changes in behavior that would affect total
output in the economy, such as any changes in labor supply or
private investment resulting from changes in fiscal policy.
5CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
How CBO Complies With the 2016 Budget Resolution
■ To the greatest extent practicable, CBO and the staff of the
Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) incorporate the budgetary
effects of changes in macroeconomic variables resulting from
legislation with one of two characteristics.
– Has a gross budgetary effect of 0.25 percent of GDP (excluding
macroeconomic feedback) in any year over the next 10 years
(an amount equal to about $47 billion in 2016)
– Is designated by one of the Chairmen of the Budget Committees
■ CBO and JCT compute the gross budgetary effect by summing
the absolute values of the budgetary effects of the provisions
and their interactions.
6CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
How CBO Complies With the 2016 Budget Resolution
(Continued)
■ Estimates also include a qualitative assessment of the
budgetary effects (including macroeconomic effects) for the
subsequent 20-year period.
■ Appropriation acts are excluded.
■ CBO and JCT coordinate on legislation that significantly affects
both spending and tax policies.
7CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
The New Requirement Extends Previous Analyses by CBO
■ CBO has routinely produced estimates of the macroeconomic
effects of fiscal policies and of the feedback from those
macroeconomic changes to the federal budget.
– Analysis of the President’s budget
– Annual long-term budget and economic outlook
– Analyses of illustrative fiscal policy scenarios
■ CBO has generally not produced such estimates for specific
legislation prior to the 2016 budget resolution (one exception,
in 2013, was S. 744, the Border Security, Economic
Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act).
8CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
The New Requirement Extends Previous Analyses by CBO
(Continued)
■ Because S. 744 would have significantly increased the size of
the U.S. labor force, CBO and JCT incorporated in the cost
estimate their projections of the direct effects of the act on
the U.S. population, employment, and taxable compensation.
■ CBO separately published an analysis of additional economic
effects and their feedback to the budget.
9CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Some Recent Dynamic Analysis by CBO
■ Proposal to repeal the Affordable Care Act (June 2015)
■ Restoring Americans’ Healthcare Freedom Reconciliation
Act of 2015 (multiple estimates, October-December, 2015)
10CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
CBO’s Approach to Dynamic Analysis
11CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
CBO’s Approach to Analyzing Economic Effects of
Fiscal Policies
■ Short term: Changes in fiscal policies affect the overall
economy primarily by influencing the demand for goods and
services, which leads to changes in output relative to potential
(maximum sustainable) output.
■ Long term: Changes in fiscal policies affect output primarily by
altering national saving, foreign investment in the U.S., federal
investment, and people’s incentives to work and save, as well
as businesses’ incentives to invest—thereby changing
potential output.
12CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Central Estimates and Ranges
■ CBO’s estimates of effects are based on parameters such as
the extent to which national saving is altered by changes in
fiscal policies.
■ In most cases, CBO estimates economic effects (and feedback
to the budget) using a range of parameter estimates reflecting
the consensus in the economic literature.
■ To arrive at its estimate of the economic effects, CBO uses the
central estimates for those parameters.
13CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Short-Term Effects From Changes in Demand
■ Changes in purchases by federal agencies and by those who
receive federal payments and pay taxes directly contribute to
aggregate demand.
■ The change in output for each dollar of direct contribution to
demand (the “demand multiplier”) varies with the response of
monetary policy.
14CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Short-Term Effects From Changes in Demand:
CBO’s Estimates of the Demand Multiplier
■ When the monetary policy response is likely to be limited, the
demand multiplier over four quarters ranges from 0.5 to 2.5,
with a central estimate of 1.5.
■ When the monetary policy response is likely to be stronger,
the demand multiplier over four quarters ranges from 0.4 to
1.9, with a central estimate of 1.2; over eight quarters, it
ranges from 0.2 to 0.8, with a central estimate of 0.5.
15CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Short-Term Effects From Changes in Labor Supply
■ Effects on the supply of labor lead to changes in employment,
depending on the amount of slack in the labor market.
16CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Long-Term Effects
■ CBO uses two models of potential output to estimate the effects of
changes in fiscal policies on the overall economy over the long term.
– Solow-type growth model
– Life-cycle growth model
■ Potential output depends on three major factors.
– Amount and quality of labor and capital (which depend on work,
saving, and investment)
– Productivity of the labor and capital inputs (which depends in part on
federal investment)
– Amount of national saving (which depends in part on federal
borrowing)
17CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
The Role of Expectations About Fiscal Policy:
Solow-Type Growth Model
■ People base their decisions about working and saving primarily
on current economic conditions, including government policies.
■ Decisions reflect people’s anticipation of future policies in a
general way but not their responses to specific future
developments.
18CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
The Role of Expectations About Fiscal Policy:
Life-Cycle Growth Model
■ People make choices about working and saving in response to
both current economic conditions and their explicit
expectations of future economic conditions.
■ The model requires specification of future fiscal policies that
put federal debt on a sustainable path over the long run
because forward-looking households would not hold
government bonds if the households expected that debt as a
percentage of GDP would rise without limit.
19CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
How Labor Supply Responds to Changes in Fiscal
Policy in the Solow-Type Growth Model
■ The overall effects of a policy change on the labor supply can
be expressed as an elasticity, which is the percentage change
in the labor supply resulting from a 1 percent change in after-
tax income.
– Substitution effect: Increased after-tax compensation for an additional
hour of work makes work more valuable relative to other uses of a
person’s time.
– Income effect: Increased after-tax income from a given amount of work
allows people to maintain the same standard of living while working
fewer hours.
20CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
How Labor Supply Responds to Changes in Fiscal
Policy in the Solow-Type Growth Model (Continued)
■ CBO’s central estimate corresponds to an earnings-weighted
total wage elasticity for all earners of 0.19 (composed of a
substitution elasticity of 0.24 and an income elasticity of -0.05).
■ For some proposals, income and substitution effects may not
offset each other (for example, if the proposal would increase
after-tax wages but reduce income).
■ CBO estimates that the substitution elasticity could range from
a low estimate of about 0.16 to a high estimate of about 0.32;
the income elasticity could range from about -0.10 to about 0.
21CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Other Key Aspects of the Solow-Type Growth Model
■ When the deficit increases by one dollar, private saving is
estimated to rise by 43 cents (national saving falls by 57 cents),
and net capital inflows rise by 24 cents, ultimately leaving a
decline of 33 cents in investment.
– Range of estimates: The decline in investment ranges from 15 cents to
50 cents
■ Additional federal investment is estimated to yield half of the
typical return on investment completed by the private sector.
– The range of estimates goes from no return on investment to the
typical return on investment completed by the private sector.
22CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Key Aspects of the Life-Cycle Growth Model
■ Labor supply and private saving are influenced by the current
values and future anticipated values of the after-tax rate of
return on saving, the after-tax wage, and households’
disposable income, among other factors.
■ The elasticity with respect to a one-time temporary change in
wages (the so-called Frisch elasticity) is 0.40, according to
CBO’s central estimates, with a range from 0.27 to 0.53.
– Frisch elasticity is calibrated to be consistent with CBO’s estimate of the
total wage elasticity.
■ Because of the uncertainty that households face about their
future income, households in the life-cycle growth model take
the precaution of holding additional savings as a buffer against
potential drops in income.
23CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Range of Estimates Within the Life-Cycle Growth Model
■ Results are shown assuming a small open economy (in which
wages and interest rates are determined by world markets)
and assuming a closed economy (in which wages and interest
rates are determined domestically).
■ Because the model is forward-looking, it requires offsetting
policy changes that stabilize government debt.
■ Different specifications of future fiscal policies put federal debt
on a sustainable path; beginning in 15 years, those policies are
assumed to phase in over 10 years.
– Reduced spending (half from government purchases and half from transfers)
– Increased taxes(halffrommarginal rate changesandhalfinlump-sum amounts)
– Both of those closure rules are reported, and results generally are similar
24CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Uncertainty in Budgetary Outcomes
■ When practicable and informative, CBO will report the
estimated range of budgetary outcomes owing to the
uncertainty of macroeconomic effects.
■ Whether that range is informative depends in part on CBO’s
assessment of the uncertainty of the estimated feedback
relative to the uncertainty of the conventional cost estimate.
25CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
How CBO Reported the Range of Macroeconomic
Estimates in the Analysis of the President’s 2016 Budget
■ In its analysis of the President’s budget, CBO reported the
range of Solow-type growth model estimates.
■ Differences between Solow model and life-cycle model results
reflect model uncertainty rather than parameter uncertainty;
those differences complicate interpretation.
26CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
How CBO Reported the Range of Macroeconomic Estimates
in the Analysis of the President’s 2016 Budget (Continued)
■ The likelihood that all parameters would simultaneously be at
the ends of their ranges is smaller than the likelihood that any
single parameter would be at the end of its range.
– CBO focused on uncertainty about the two parameters that had the
largest budgetary effects.
– CBO examined estimates resulting from cases in which two parameters
were at the ends of their ranges and other parameters were equal to
central estimates.
■ The agency reported cases that showed the most favorable
and least favorable budgetary outcomes.
27CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Presentation of Macroeconomic Analyses in Cost Estimates
■ Presentation will probably evolve over time as CBO learns
what is most useful.
■ Estimates show all of the information that traditionally would
be included if macroeconomic effects were not incorporated
and identify the macroeconomic effects separately.
■ Estimates provide information related to the uncertainty of
the macroeconomic effects.
28CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Case Study: A Dynamic Estimate of
Repealing the Affordable Care Act
29CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
CBO’s Analysis of Repealing the Affordable Care Act
■ At the request of the Chairman of the Senate Budget
Committee, CBO and JCT analyzed the budgetary cost of
repealing the ACA, including macroeconomic feedback.
■ With that feedback, CBO and JCT estimate that repealing the
ACA would increase federal budget deficits by $137 billion
over the 2016–2025 period.
– Excluding feedback, deficits would increase by $353 billion.
– Feedback reduces projected deficits by $216 billion.
30CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
CBO’s Analysis of Repealing the Affordable Care Act
(Continued)
■ Over the 2026–2035 period, repealing the ACA would increase
deficits, with or without macroeconomic effects, CBO and JCT
estimate.
■ The estimates include a high degree of uncertainty.
– Over the 2016–2025 period, repeal could reduce deficits or increase
them by much more than estimated.
– Over the 2026–2035 period, repeal would probably not reduce deficits,
even given great uncertainty.
■ ACA repeal would cause large and partially offsetting changes
to spending and revenues.
31CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Effects of Repeal of the Affordable Care Act on
Labor Markets: The Six Most Significant Provisions
■ Subsidies that phase out with increasing income would be
eliminated, raising work incentives and therefore labor supply.
■ Eliminating subsidies and the Medicaid expansion would
reduce people’s available resources, increasing labor supply.
■ Repealing provisions that lower the cost of health insurance
plans offered to older workers outside the workplace would
cause some workers to delay retirement, increasing labor
supply.
32CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Effects of Repeal of the Affordable Care Act on
Labor Markets: The Six Most Significant Provisions (Continued)
■ Eliminating exchange subsidies would decrease the incentive
to work for many low-income people because of interactions
with Medicaid eligibility requirements, reducing labor supply.
■ Employer mandate would be eliminated, raising labor demand in
the short run and labor supply in the long run as wages adjust.
■ Increased HI payroll tax for high earners and high-premium
excise tax would be eliminated, increasing work incentives and
therefore labor supply.
33CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Estimated Effects of Repeal of the Affordable Care Act on
Labor Markets
■ Overall, repeal of the ACA is estimated to increase aggregate
hours worked by about 1.5 percent between 2021 and 2025.
– Previous estimate was about 1.5 percent to 2 percent
■ That increase in hours translates into an increase in aggregate
compensation of between 0.8 percent and 0.9 percent over
the same period.
– Previous estimate was about 1 percent
■ Hours worked would rise by more than compensation because
lower-wage workers would be most strongly affected by the
repeal, so they would change labor supply the most.
34CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Other Macroeconomic Effects of Repealing the
Affordable Care Act
■ Aggregate demand would be slightly lower in the short run.
– Redistribution from lower-income benefit recipients to higher-income
taxpayers and medical care providers
■ Larger labor supply would lead to increased investment and a
larger capital stock.
– Effect offset somewhat by increased deficits, which crowd out capital
– Longer-term effects estimated with the Solow-type growth model
■ Outputwouldberoughlyunchangedin2016buthigherinlateryears.
■ Interest rates would be higher.
– Capital-labor ratio would fall with larger labor supply, increasing the
marginal product of capital and therefore interest rates
35CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Macroeconomic Feedback Effects of Repealing the
Affordable Care Act
■ Higher output would increase revenues and modestly
increase primary spending.
– Revenues depend on taxable income of different types with different
effective marginal tax rates.
– Outlays depend more on prices than real output.
■ Higher interest rates would increase federal interest
payments on the national debt.
■ Feedback effects would lower deficits throughout the
2016–2025 period.
36CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Macroeconomic Feedback Effects of Repealing the
Affordable Care Act (Continued)
■ Feedback effects would increase for some time because the
effects of the ACA, and therefore repeal, phase in over time
but feedback effects would ultimately decline as the effects of
higher deficits became more important.
■ In CBO’s analyses of other policies, macroeconomic feedback
has been less significant relative to the estimated cost without
macroeconomic feedback.
37CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Summary of Estimated Effects on Direct Spending and
Revenues of Repealing the Affordable Care Act
Billions of Dollars, by Fiscal Year
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Total,
2016–
2020
Total,
2016–
2025
Estimated Changes Without Macroeconomic Feedback
Effects on Outlays -10 -107 -106 -100 -93 -88 -77 -71 -65 -43 -477 -821
Effects on Revenues -66 -79 -99 -107 -115 -123 -132 -142 -152 -161 -466 -1,174
Effects on the Deficit -5 -28 -7 7 21 35 55 70 87 118 -12 353
Estimated Budgetary Impact of Macroeconomic Feedback
Effects on Outlays * -2 -3 -2 -1 1 2 4 5 6 -8 9
Effects on Revenues 3 11 21 26 27 27 28 28 27 26 88 255
Effects on the Deficit -4 -13 -24 -29 -28 -26 -26 -24 -23 -20 -97 -216
Estimated Changes With Macroeconomic Feedback
Effects on Outlays -71 -109 -109 -103 -94 -87 -75 -68 -60 -37 -486 -812
Effects on Revenues -63 -67 -78 -81 -88 -96 -104 -114 -124 -135 -377 -949
Effects on the Deficit -8 -42 -31 -22 -6 9 29 46 64 98 -108 137
38CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Estimated Effects on Deficits of Repealing the
Affordable Care Act
Billions of Dollars, by Fiscal Year
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
-50
-25
0
25
50
75
100
125
150
Without
Macroeconomic
Feedback
With
Macroeconomic
Feedback
39CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Notes
For more information about CBO’s analysis of the Affordable
Care Act under current law and the effects of proposals to
change the law, see the following:
■ Congressional Budget Office, “Affordable Care Act,”
www.cbo.gov/topics/health-care/affordable-care-act.
■ Congressional Budget Office, Budgetary and Economic Effects
of Repealing the Affordable Care Act (June 2015),
www.cbo.gov/publication/50252.
■ Edward Harris and Shannon Mok, How CBO Estimates the
Effects of the Affordable Care Act on the Labor Market,
Working Paper 2015-09 (Congressional Budget Office,
December 7, 2015), www.cbo.gov/publication/51065.

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

CBO’s Long-Term Projections for Medicare and Medicaid Spending in the United ...
CBO’s Long-Term Projections for Medicare and Medicaid Spending in the United ...CBO’s Long-Term Projections for Medicare and Medicaid Spending in the United ...
CBO’s Long-Term Projections for Medicare and Medicaid Spending in the United ...Congressional Budget Office
 
CBO’s Assessment of the Long-Term Outlook for Interest Rates
CBO’s Assessment of the Long-Term Outlook for Interest RatesCBO’s Assessment of the Long-Term Outlook for Interest Rates
CBO’s Assessment of the Long-Term Outlook for Interest RatesCongressional Budget Office
 
How CBO Uses Data for Budget Projections and Cost Estimates
How CBO Uses Data for Budget Projections and Cost EstimatesHow CBO Uses Data for Budget Projections and Cost Estimates
How CBO Uses Data for Budget Projections and Cost EstimatesCongressional Budget Office
 
Anatomy of a Cost Estimate for Legislation Funding Transportation Programs
Anatomy of a Cost Estimate for Legislation Funding Transportation ProgramsAnatomy of a Cost Estimate for Legislation Funding Transportation Programs
Anatomy of a Cost Estimate for Legislation Funding Transportation ProgramsCongressional Budget Office
 
How the Congressional Budget Office Uses Demographic Data
How the Congressional Budget Office Uses Demographic DataHow the Congressional Budget Office Uses Demographic Data
How the Congressional Budget Office Uses Demographic DataCongressional Budget Office
 
The FAST Act and the Budgetary Treatment of Federal Financing Instruments
The FAST Act and the Budgetary Treatment of Federal Financing InstrumentsThe FAST Act and the Budgetary Treatment of Federal Financing Instruments
The FAST Act and the Budgetary Treatment of Federal Financing InstrumentsCongressional Budget Office
 
The Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of Federal Investment
The Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of Federal InvestmentThe Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of Federal Investment
The Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of Federal InvestmentCongressional Budget Office
 
Transportation Finance Proposals in the 113th Congress and Their Budgetary Im...
Transportation Finance Proposals in the 113th Congress and Their Budgetary Im...Transportation Finance Proposals in the 113th Congress and Their Budgetary Im...
Transportation Finance Proposals in the 113th Congress and Their Budgetary Im...Congressional Budget Office
 
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget Process
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget ProcessCBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget Process
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget ProcessCongressional Budget Office
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Dynamic Scoring at CBO
Dynamic Scoring at CBODynamic Scoring at CBO
Dynamic Scoring at CBO
 
CBO’s Long-Term Projections for Medicare and Medicaid Spending in the United ...
CBO’s Long-Term Projections for Medicare and Medicaid Spending in the United ...CBO’s Long-Term Projections for Medicare and Medicaid Spending in the United ...
CBO’s Long-Term Projections for Medicare and Medicaid Spending in the United ...
 
CBO’s Assessment of the Long-Term Outlook for Interest Rates
CBO’s Assessment of the Long-Term Outlook for Interest RatesCBO’s Assessment of the Long-Term Outlook for Interest Rates
CBO’s Assessment of the Long-Term Outlook for Interest Rates
 
CBO's Cost Estimates
CBO's Cost EstimatesCBO's Cost Estimates
CBO's Cost Estimates
 
Dynamic Scoring at CBO
Dynamic Scoring at CBODynamic Scoring at CBO
Dynamic Scoring at CBO
 
How CBO Uses Data for Budget Projections and Cost Estimates
How CBO Uses Data for Budget Projections and Cost EstimatesHow CBO Uses Data for Budget Projections and Cost Estimates
How CBO Uses Data for Budget Projections and Cost Estimates
 
Dynamic Scoring at CBO
Dynamic Scoring at CBODynamic Scoring at CBO
Dynamic Scoring at CBO
 
Anatomy of a Cost Estimate for Legislation Funding Transportation Programs
Anatomy of a Cost Estimate for Legislation Funding Transportation ProgramsAnatomy of a Cost Estimate for Legislation Funding Transportation Programs
Anatomy of a Cost Estimate for Legislation Funding Transportation Programs
 
CBO’s Approach to Dynamic Analysis
CBO’s Approach to Dynamic AnalysisCBO’s Approach to Dynamic Analysis
CBO’s Approach to Dynamic Analysis
 
Productivity and Growth in CBO's Forecasts
Productivity and Growth in CBO's ForecastsProductivity and Growth in CBO's Forecasts
Productivity and Growth in CBO's Forecasts
 
How CBO Promotes Integrity in Its Analyses
How CBO Promotes Integrity in Its AnalysesHow CBO Promotes Integrity in Its Analyses
How CBO Promotes Integrity in Its Analyses
 
How the Congressional Budget Office Uses Demographic Data
How the Congressional Budget Office Uses Demographic DataHow the Congressional Budget Office Uses Demographic Data
How the Congressional Budget Office Uses Demographic Data
 
The FAST Act and the Budgetary Treatment of Federal Financing Instruments
The FAST Act and the Budgetary Treatment of Federal Financing InstrumentsThe FAST Act and the Budgetary Treatment of Federal Financing Instruments
The FAST Act and the Budgetary Treatment of Federal Financing Instruments
 
Cbo, the Budget Process, and the Outlook
Cbo, the Budget Process, and the OutlookCbo, the Budget Process, and the Outlook
Cbo, the Budget Process, and the Outlook
 
The Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of Federal Investment
The Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of Federal InvestmentThe Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of Federal Investment
The Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of Federal Investment
 
Fiscal Policy and Automatic Stabilizers
Fiscal Policy and Automatic StabilizersFiscal Policy and Automatic Stabilizers
Fiscal Policy and Automatic Stabilizers
 
Dynamic Scoring at CBO
Dynamic Scoring at CBODynamic Scoring at CBO
Dynamic Scoring at CBO
 
CBO’s Recent Budget and Economic Projections
CBO’s Recent Budget and Economic ProjectionsCBO’s Recent Budget and Economic Projections
CBO’s Recent Budget and Economic Projections
 
Transportation Finance Proposals in the 113th Congress and Their Budgetary Im...
Transportation Finance Proposals in the 113th Congress and Their Budgetary Im...Transportation Finance Proposals in the 113th Congress and Their Budgetary Im...
Transportation Finance Proposals in the 113th Congress and Their Budgetary Im...
 
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget Process
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget ProcessCBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget Process
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget Process
 

Destacado (15)

How CBO Will Implement Dynamic Scoring
How CBO Will Implement Dynamic ScoringHow CBO Will Implement Dynamic Scoring
How CBO Will Implement Dynamic Scoring
 
The 2017 Budget and Economic Outlook
The 2017 Budget and Economic OutlookThe 2017 Budget and Economic Outlook
The 2017 Budget and Economic Outlook
 
The Role of Immigrants in the U.S. Labor Market: An Update
The Role of Immigrants in the U.S. Labor Market: An UpdateThe Role of Immigrants in the U.S. Labor Market: An Update
The Role of Immigrants in the U.S. Labor Market: An Update
 
Health Care and the Federal Budget
Health Care and the Federal BudgetHealth Care and the Federal Budget
Health Care and the Federal Budget
 
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget Process
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget ProcessCBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget Process
CBO’s Role in the Congressional Budget Process
 
Charts from CBO's August 2012 Budget and Economic Outlook
Charts from CBO's August 2012 Budget and Economic OutlookCharts from CBO's August 2012 Budget and Economic Outlook
Charts from CBO's August 2012 Budget and Economic Outlook
 
Understanding the 2016 Budget Outlook
Understanding the 2016 Budget OutlookUnderstanding the 2016 Budget Outlook
Understanding the 2016 Budget Outlook
 
Federal Investment
Federal InvestmentFederal Investment
Federal Investment
 
Game of Screens: Tech kingdoms creating the omni-channel experience
Game of Screens: Tech kingdoms creating the omni-channel experienceGame of Screens: Tech kingdoms creating the omni-channel experience
Game of Screens: Tech kingdoms creating the omni-channel experience
 
2. Ack,
2. Ack,2. Ack,
2. Ack,
 
Social Media Update 2010
Social Media Update 2010Social Media Update 2010
Social Media Update 2010
 
3. Body
3. Body3. Body
3. Body
 
Strategy Wars
Strategy WarsStrategy Wars
Strategy Wars
 
1. Cover Page
1. Cover Page1. Cover Page
1. Cover Page
 
A rare site of Cystic hygroma
A rare site of Cystic hygromaA rare site of Cystic hygroma
A rare site of Cystic hygroma
 

Similar a Dynamic Analysis at CBO

Dynamic Analysis at the U.S. Congressional Budget Office
Dynamic Analysis at the U.S. Congressional Budget OfficeDynamic Analysis at the U.S. Congressional Budget Office
Dynamic Analysis at the U.S. Congressional Budget OfficeCongressional Budget Office
 
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...Congressional Budget Office
 
Ready for the next recession? Assessing the UK’s macroeconomic framework
Ready for the next recession? Assessing the UK’s macroeconomic frameworkReady for the next recession? Assessing the UK’s macroeconomic framework
Ready for the next recession? Assessing the UK’s macroeconomic frameworkResolutionFoundation
 
CBO's Use of Evidence in Analysis of Budget and Economic Policies
CBO's Use of Evidence in Analysis of Budget and Economic PoliciesCBO's Use of Evidence in Analysis of Budget and Economic Policies
CBO's Use of Evidence in Analysis of Budget and Economic PoliciesCongressional Budget Office
 
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...Congressional Budget Office
 
An Overview of The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029
An Overview of The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029An Overview of The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029
An Overview of The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029Congressional Budget Office
 
Econ606 chapter 33 2020
Econ606 chapter 33 2020Econ606 chapter 33 2020
Econ606 chapter 33 2020sakanor
 
AS Macro: The Effectiveness of UK Macro-Economic Policies
AS Macro: The Effectiveness of UK Macro-Economic PoliciesAS Macro: The Effectiveness of UK Macro-Economic Policies
AS Macro: The Effectiveness of UK Macro-Economic Policiestutor2u
 
Monetary and fiscal policy of india
Monetary and fiscal policy of indiaMonetary and fiscal policy of india
Monetary and fiscal policy of indiaBharathi Raj
 

Similar a Dynamic Analysis at CBO (20)

Dynamic Analysis at the U.S. Congressional Budget Office
Dynamic Analysis at the U.S. Congressional Budget OfficeDynamic Analysis at the U.S. Congressional Budget Office
Dynamic Analysis at the U.S. Congressional Budget Office
 
An Overview of CBO's Life-Cycle Growth Model
An Overview of CBO's Life-Cycle Growth ModelAn Overview of CBO's Life-Cycle Growth Model
An Overview of CBO's Life-Cycle Growth Model
 
Baseline Budget Projections
Baseline Budget ProjectionsBaseline Budget Projections
Baseline Budget Projections
 
CBO’s Policy Growth Model
CBO’s Policy Growth ModelCBO’s Policy Growth Model
CBO’s Policy Growth Model
 
CBO’s 10-Year Budget and Economic Projections
CBO’s 10-Year Budget and Economic ProjectionsCBO’s 10-Year Budget and Economic Projections
CBO’s 10-Year Budget and Economic Projections
 
Baseline Budget Projections
Baseline Budget ProjectionsBaseline Budget Projections
Baseline Budget Projections
 
CBO’s Economic and Budget Projections
CBO’s Economic and Budget ProjectionsCBO’s Economic and Budget Projections
CBO’s Economic and Budget Projections
 
CBO’s 10-Year Budget and Economic Projections
CBO’s 10-Year Budget and Economic ProjectionsCBO’s 10-Year Budget and Economic Projections
CBO’s 10-Year Budget and Economic Projections
 
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
 
Revenue Neutral Carbon Tax
Revenue Neutral Carbon TaxRevenue Neutral Carbon Tax
Revenue Neutral Carbon Tax
 
Ready for the next recession? Assessing the UK’s macroeconomic framework
Ready for the next recession? Assessing the UK’s macroeconomic frameworkReady for the next recession? Assessing the UK’s macroeconomic framework
Ready for the next recession? Assessing the UK’s macroeconomic framework
 
CBO's Use of Evidence in Analysis of Budget and Economic Policies
CBO's Use of Evidence in Analysis of Budget and Economic PoliciesCBO's Use of Evidence in Analysis of Budget and Economic Policies
CBO's Use of Evidence in Analysis of Budget and Economic Policies
 
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
How CBO Develops the Economic Projections Underlying Its Long-Term Budget Pro...
 
Transparency at CBO
Transparency at CBOTransparency at CBO
Transparency at CBO
 
An Overview of The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029
An Overview of The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029An Overview of The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029
An Overview of The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029
 
Econ606 chapter 33 2020
Econ606 chapter 33 2020Econ606 chapter 33 2020
Econ606 chapter 33 2020
 
AS Macro: The Effectiveness of UK Macro-Economic Policies
AS Macro: The Effectiveness of UK Macro-Economic PoliciesAS Macro: The Effectiveness of UK Macro-Economic Policies
AS Macro: The Effectiveness of UK Macro-Economic Policies
 
Monetary and fiscal policy of india
Monetary and fiscal policy of indiaMonetary and fiscal policy of india
Monetary and fiscal policy of india
 
Fiscal and Monetary Macroeconomic Policy
Fiscal and Monetary Macroeconomic PolicyFiscal and Monetary Macroeconomic Policy
Fiscal and Monetary Macroeconomic Policy
 
Macroeconomic Analysis at CBO
Macroeconomic Analysis at CBOMacroeconomic Analysis at CBO
Macroeconomic Analysis at CBO
 

Más de Congressional Budget Office

CBO’s Approach to Estimating the Budgetary Effects of the No Surprises Act of...
CBO’s Approach to Estimating the Budgetary Effects of the No Surprises Act of...CBO’s Approach to Estimating the Budgetary Effects of the No Surprises Act of...
CBO’s Approach to Estimating the Budgetary Effects of the No Surprises Act of...Congressional Budget Office
 
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing SlidesThe Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing SlidesCongressional Budget Office
 
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 SlidesThe Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 SlidesCongressional Budget Office
 
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of TaxpayersUsing Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of TaxpayersCongressional Budget Office
 
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding PlanPerspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding PlanCongressional Budget Office
 
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher CostsThe 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher CostsCongressional Budget Office
 
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the BudgetExploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the BudgetCongressional Budget Office
 
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCongressional Budget Office
 
Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
 Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of UnemploymentCongressional Budget Office
 
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary OutlookCBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary OutlookCongressional Budget Office
 
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...Congressional Budget Office
 
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the CongressCBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the CongressCongressional Budget Office
 
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020Congressional Budget Office
 
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeThe Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeCongressional Budget Office
 
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeThe Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeCongressional Budget Office
 

Más de Congressional Budget Office (20)

CBO’s Approach to Estimating the Budgetary Effects of the No Surprises Act of...
CBO’s Approach to Estimating the Budgetary Effects of the No Surprises Act of...CBO’s Approach to Estimating the Budgetary Effects of the No Surprises Act of...
CBO’s Approach to Estimating the Budgetary Effects of the No Surprises Act of...
 
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing SlidesThe Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
 
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 SlidesThe Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
 
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of TaxpayersUsing Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
 
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding PlanPerspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
 
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher CostsThe 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
 
CBO’s Use of GitHub
CBO’s Use of GitHubCBO’s Use of GitHub
CBO’s Use of GitHub
 
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the BudgetExploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
 
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
 
Atlas of Military Compensation
Atlas of Military CompensationAtlas of Military Compensation
Atlas of Military Compensation
 
Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
 Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
 
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary OutlookCBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
 
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
 
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the CongressCBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
 
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
 
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeThe Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
 
Health Care and the Federal Budget
Health Care and the Federal Budget Health Care and the Federal Budget
Health Care and the Federal Budget
 
How CBO Projects Corporate Income Tax Revenues
How CBO Projects Corporate Income Tax RevenuesHow CBO Projects Corporate Income Tax Revenues
How CBO Projects Corporate Income Tax Revenues
 
CBO’s 2023 Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s 2023 Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCBO’s 2023 Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s 2023 Long-Term Budget Projections
 
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeThe Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
 

Último

2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 142024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14JSchaus & Associates
 
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...JSchaus & Associates
 
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomFlagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomSUNWayResearchandInn
 
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................SUNWayResearchandInn
 
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and WildlifeLivewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and WildlifeRandy Myers
 
Cyclone Idai Exhibition Final - Re-living Disaster in Manicaland
Cyclone Idai Exhibition Final - Re-living Disaster in ManicalandCyclone Idai Exhibition Final - Re-living Disaster in Manicaland
Cyclone Idai Exhibition Final - Re-living Disaster in ManicalandBervenMavhima1
 
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 EditionHadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 EditionHadleyWood Association
 
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptxNSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptxDheerajKL1
 
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdfCanadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdfAndrew Griffith
 
Millions of Homeless Children's in world
Millions of Homeless Children's in worldMillions of Homeless Children's in world
Millions of Homeless Children's in worldSERUDS INDIA
 
Women paying the health cost of the climate crisis
Women paying the health cost of the climate crisisWomen paying the health cost of the climate crisis
Women paying the health cost of the climate crisisIIED
 
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.SUNWayResearchandInn
 
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish CouncillorsUnderstanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish CouncillorsScribe
 
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSESTHEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSESLouis Malaybalay
 
Importance of child education kurnool.docx
Importance of child education kurnool.docxImportance of child education kurnool.docx
Importance of child education kurnool.docxSERUDS INDIA
 
Behaviour_Change_Climate_Emergency_Papies_UKSBM_2024_slides.pptx
Behaviour_Change_Climate_Emergency_Papies_UKSBM_2024_slides.pptxBehaviour_Change_Climate_Emergency_Papies_UKSBM_2024_slides.pptx
Behaviour_Change_Climate_Emergency_Papies_UKSBM_2024_slides.pptxestherpapies
 

Último (20)

2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 142024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
 
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
 
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomFlagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
 
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF in Ukraine.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF in Ukraine.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF in Ukraine.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF in Ukraine.pdf
 
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and WildlifeLivewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
 
Cyclone Idai Exhibition Final - Re-living Disaster in Manicaland
Cyclone Idai Exhibition Final - Re-living Disaster in ManicalandCyclone Idai Exhibition Final - Re-living Disaster in Manicaland
Cyclone Idai Exhibition Final - Re-living Disaster in Manicaland
 
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 EditionHadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Serbia CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Serbia CAF.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Serbia CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Serbia CAF.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - North Macedonia CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - North Macedonia CAF.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - North Macedonia CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - North Macedonia CAF.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Montenegro CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Montenegro CAF.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Montenegro CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Montenegro CAF.pdf
 
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptxNSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
 
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdfCanadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
 
Millions of Homeless Children's in world
Millions of Homeless Children's in worldMillions of Homeless Children's in world
Millions of Homeless Children's in world
 
Women paying the health cost of the climate crisis
Women paying the health cost of the climate crisisWomen paying the health cost of the climate crisis
Women paying the health cost of the climate crisis
 
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
 
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish CouncillorsUnderstanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
 
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSESTHEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
 
Importance of child education kurnool.docx
Importance of child education kurnool.docxImportance of child education kurnool.docx
Importance of child education kurnool.docx
 
Behaviour_Change_Climate_Emergency_Papies_UKSBM_2024_slides.pptx
Behaviour_Change_Climate_Emergency_Papies_UKSBM_2024_slides.pptxBehaviour_Change_Climate_Emergency_Papies_UKSBM_2024_slides.pptx
Behaviour_Change_Climate_Emergency_Papies_UKSBM_2024_slides.pptx
 

Dynamic Analysis at CBO

  • 1. Congressional Budget Office The University of Chicago Booth School of Business Chicago, Illinois March 7, 2016 Wendy Edelberg Associate Director for Economic Analysis For additional information, see Congressional Budget Office, “Dynamic Analysis,” www.cbo.gov/topics/dynamic-analysis. Dynamic Analysis at CBO
  • 2. 1CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Overview ■ New requirement for dynamic scoring ■ CBO’s approach to dynamic analysis ■ Case study: A dynamic estimate of repealing the Affordable Care Act
  • 3. 2CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE The New Requirement for Dynamic Scoring
  • 4. 3CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Main Points ■ Conventional cost estimates already incorporate behavioral responses but not changes in broad economic variables. ■ The requirement to estimate the budgetary feedback of macroeconomic effects applies to major legislation. ■ CBO has estimated the budgetary feedback of macroeconomic effects but generally not for cost estimates for legislation.
  • 5. 4CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Behavioral Responses Addressed in Conventional Cost Estimates ■ If proposed policies would affect people’s behavior in ways that would affect the budget, those effects are incorporated in CBO’s conventional estimates. ■ By long-standing convention, CBO’s cost estimates generally have not reflected changes in behavior that would affect total output in the economy, such as any changes in labor supply or private investment resulting from changes in fiscal policy.
  • 6. 5CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE How CBO Complies With the 2016 Budget Resolution ■ To the greatest extent practicable, CBO and the staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) incorporate the budgetary effects of changes in macroeconomic variables resulting from legislation with one of two characteristics. – Has a gross budgetary effect of 0.25 percent of GDP (excluding macroeconomic feedback) in any year over the next 10 years (an amount equal to about $47 billion in 2016) – Is designated by one of the Chairmen of the Budget Committees ■ CBO and JCT compute the gross budgetary effect by summing the absolute values of the budgetary effects of the provisions and their interactions.
  • 7. 6CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE How CBO Complies With the 2016 Budget Resolution (Continued) ■ Estimates also include a qualitative assessment of the budgetary effects (including macroeconomic effects) for the subsequent 20-year period. ■ Appropriation acts are excluded. ■ CBO and JCT coordinate on legislation that significantly affects both spending and tax policies.
  • 8. 7CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE The New Requirement Extends Previous Analyses by CBO ■ CBO has routinely produced estimates of the macroeconomic effects of fiscal policies and of the feedback from those macroeconomic changes to the federal budget. – Analysis of the President’s budget – Annual long-term budget and economic outlook – Analyses of illustrative fiscal policy scenarios ■ CBO has generally not produced such estimates for specific legislation prior to the 2016 budget resolution (one exception, in 2013, was S. 744, the Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act).
  • 9. 8CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE The New Requirement Extends Previous Analyses by CBO (Continued) ■ Because S. 744 would have significantly increased the size of the U.S. labor force, CBO and JCT incorporated in the cost estimate their projections of the direct effects of the act on the U.S. population, employment, and taxable compensation. ■ CBO separately published an analysis of additional economic effects and their feedback to the budget.
  • 10. 9CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Some Recent Dynamic Analysis by CBO ■ Proposal to repeal the Affordable Care Act (June 2015) ■ Restoring Americans’ Healthcare Freedom Reconciliation Act of 2015 (multiple estimates, October-December, 2015)
  • 11. 10CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE CBO’s Approach to Dynamic Analysis
  • 12. 11CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE CBO’s Approach to Analyzing Economic Effects of Fiscal Policies ■ Short term: Changes in fiscal policies affect the overall economy primarily by influencing the demand for goods and services, which leads to changes in output relative to potential (maximum sustainable) output. ■ Long term: Changes in fiscal policies affect output primarily by altering national saving, foreign investment in the U.S., federal investment, and people’s incentives to work and save, as well as businesses’ incentives to invest—thereby changing potential output.
  • 13. 12CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Central Estimates and Ranges ■ CBO’s estimates of effects are based on parameters such as the extent to which national saving is altered by changes in fiscal policies. ■ In most cases, CBO estimates economic effects (and feedback to the budget) using a range of parameter estimates reflecting the consensus in the economic literature. ■ To arrive at its estimate of the economic effects, CBO uses the central estimates for those parameters.
  • 14. 13CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Short-Term Effects From Changes in Demand ■ Changes in purchases by federal agencies and by those who receive federal payments and pay taxes directly contribute to aggregate demand. ■ The change in output for each dollar of direct contribution to demand (the “demand multiplier”) varies with the response of monetary policy.
  • 15. 14CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Short-Term Effects From Changes in Demand: CBO’s Estimates of the Demand Multiplier ■ When the monetary policy response is likely to be limited, the demand multiplier over four quarters ranges from 0.5 to 2.5, with a central estimate of 1.5. ■ When the monetary policy response is likely to be stronger, the demand multiplier over four quarters ranges from 0.4 to 1.9, with a central estimate of 1.2; over eight quarters, it ranges from 0.2 to 0.8, with a central estimate of 0.5.
  • 16. 15CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Short-Term Effects From Changes in Labor Supply ■ Effects on the supply of labor lead to changes in employment, depending on the amount of slack in the labor market.
  • 17. 16CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Long-Term Effects ■ CBO uses two models of potential output to estimate the effects of changes in fiscal policies on the overall economy over the long term. – Solow-type growth model – Life-cycle growth model ■ Potential output depends on three major factors. – Amount and quality of labor and capital (which depend on work, saving, and investment) – Productivity of the labor and capital inputs (which depends in part on federal investment) – Amount of national saving (which depends in part on federal borrowing)
  • 18. 17CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE The Role of Expectations About Fiscal Policy: Solow-Type Growth Model ■ People base their decisions about working and saving primarily on current economic conditions, including government policies. ■ Decisions reflect people’s anticipation of future policies in a general way but not their responses to specific future developments.
  • 19. 18CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE The Role of Expectations About Fiscal Policy: Life-Cycle Growth Model ■ People make choices about working and saving in response to both current economic conditions and their explicit expectations of future economic conditions. ■ The model requires specification of future fiscal policies that put federal debt on a sustainable path over the long run because forward-looking households would not hold government bonds if the households expected that debt as a percentage of GDP would rise without limit.
  • 20. 19CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE How Labor Supply Responds to Changes in Fiscal Policy in the Solow-Type Growth Model ■ The overall effects of a policy change on the labor supply can be expressed as an elasticity, which is the percentage change in the labor supply resulting from a 1 percent change in after- tax income. – Substitution effect: Increased after-tax compensation for an additional hour of work makes work more valuable relative to other uses of a person’s time. – Income effect: Increased after-tax income from a given amount of work allows people to maintain the same standard of living while working fewer hours.
  • 21. 20CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE How Labor Supply Responds to Changes in Fiscal Policy in the Solow-Type Growth Model (Continued) ■ CBO’s central estimate corresponds to an earnings-weighted total wage elasticity for all earners of 0.19 (composed of a substitution elasticity of 0.24 and an income elasticity of -0.05). ■ For some proposals, income and substitution effects may not offset each other (for example, if the proposal would increase after-tax wages but reduce income). ■ CBO estimates that the substitution elasticity could range from a low estimate of about 0.16 to a high estimate of about 0.32; the income elasticity could range from about -0.10 to about 0.
  • 22. 21CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Other Key Aspects of the Solow-Type Growth Model ■ When the deficit increases by one dollar, private saving is estimated to rise by 43 cents (national saving falls by 57 cents), and net capital inflows rise by 24 cents, ultimately leaving a decline of 33 cents in investment. – Range of estimates: The decline in investment ranges from 15 cents to 50 cents ■ Additional federal investment is estimated to yield half of the typical return on investment completed by the private sector. – The range of estimates goes from no return on investment to the typical return on investment completed by the private sector.
  • 23. 22CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Key Aspects of the Life-Cycle Growth Model ■ Labor supply and private saving are influenced by the current values and future anticipated values of the after-tax rate of return on saving, the after-tax wage, and households’ disposable income, among other factors. ■ The elasticity with respect to a one-time temporary change in wages (the so-called Frisch elasticity) is 0.40, according to CBO’s central estimates, with a range from 0.27 to 0.53. – Frisch elasticity is calibrated to be consistent with CBO’s estimate of the total wage elasticity. ■ Because of the uncertainty that households face about their future income, households in the life-cycle growth model take the precaution of holding additional savings as a buffer against potential drops in income.
  • 24. 23CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Range of Estimates Within the Life-Cycle Growth Model ■ Results are shown assuming a small open economy (in which wages and interest rates are determined by world markets) and assuming a closed economy (in which wages and interest rates are determined domestically). ■ Because the model is forward-looking, it requires offsetting policy changes that stabilize government debt. ■ Different specifications of future fiscal policies put federal debt on a sustainable path; beginning in 15 years, those policies are assumed to phase in over 10 years. – Reduced spending (half from government purchases and half from transfers) – Increased taxes(halffrommarginal rate changesandhalfinlump-sum amounts) – Both of those closure rules are reported, and results generally are similar
  • 25. 24CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Uncertainty in Budgetary Outcomes ■ When practicable and informative, CBO will report the estimated range of budgetary outcomes owing to the uncertainty of macroeconomic effects. ■ Whether that range is informative depends in part on CBO’s assessment of the uncertainty of the estimated feedback relative to the uncertainty of the conventional cost estimate.
  • 26. 25CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE How CBO Reported the Range of Macroeconomic Estimates in the Analysis of the President’s 2016 Budget ■ In its analysis of the President’s budget, CBO reported the range of Solow-type growth model estimates. ■ Differences between Solow model and life-cycle model results reflect model uncertainty rather than parameter uncertainty; those differences complicate interpretation.
  • 27. 26CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE How CBO Reported the Range of Macroeconomic Estimates in the Analysis of the President’s 2016 Budget (Continued) ■ The likelihood that all parameters would simultaneously be at the ends of their ranges is smaller than the likelihood that any single parameter would be at the end of its range. – CBO focused on uncertainty about the two parameters that had the largest budgetary effects. – CBO examined estimates resulting from cases in which two parameters were at the ends of their ranges and other parameters were equal to central estimates. ■ The agency reported cases that showed the most favorable and least favorable budgetary outcomes.
  • 28. 27CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Presentation of Macroeconomic Analyses in Cost Estimates ■ Presentation will probably evolve over time as CBO learns what is most useful. ■ Estimates show all of the information that traditionally would be included if macroeconomic effects were not incorporated and identify the macroeconomic effects separately. ■ Estimates provide information related to the uncertainty of the macroeconomic effects.
  • 29. 28CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Case Study: A Dynamic Estimate of Repealing the Affordable Care Act
  • 30. 29CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE CBO’s Analysis of Repealing the Affordable Care Act ■ At the request of the Chairman of the Senate Budget Committee, CBO and JCT analyzed the budgetary cost of repealing the ACA, including macroeconomic feedback. ■ With that feedback, CBO and JCT estimate that repealing the ACA would increase federal budget deficits by $137 billion over the 2016–2025 period. – Excluding feedback, deficits would increase by $353 billion. – Feedback reduces projected deficits by $216 billion.
  • 31. 30CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE CBO’s Analysis of Repealing the Affordable Care Act (Continued) ■ Over the 2026–2035 period, repealing the ACA would increase deficits, with or without macroeconomic effects, CBO and JCT estimate. ■ The estimates include a high degree of uncertainty. – Over the 2016–2025 period, repeal could reduce deficits or increase them by much more than estimated. – Over the 2026–2035 period, repeal would probably not reduce deficits, even given great uncertainty. ■ ACA repeal would cause large and partially offsetting changes to spending and revenues.
  • 32. 31CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Effects of Repeal of the Affordable Care Act on Labor Markets: The Six Most Significant Provisions ■ Subsidies that phase out with increasing income would be eliminated, raising work incentives and therefore labor supply. ■ Eliminating subsidies and the Medicaid expansion would reduce people’s available resources, increasing labor supply. ■ Repealing provisions that lower the cost of health insurance plans offered to older workers outside the workplace would cause some workers to delay retirement, increasing labor supply.
  • 33. 32CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Effects of Repeal of the Affordable Care Act on Labor Markets: The Six Most Significant Provisions (Continued) ■ Eliminating exchange subsidies would decrease the incentive to work for many low-income people because of interactions with Medicaid eligibility requirements, reducing labor supply. ■ Employer mandate would be eliminated, raising labor demand in the short run and labor supply in the long run as wages adjust. ■ Increased HI payroll tax for high earners and high-premium excise tax would be eliminated, increasing work incentives and therefore labor supply.
  • 34. 33CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Estimated Effects of Repeal of the Affordable Care Act on Labor Markets ■ Overall, repeal of the ACA is estimated to increase aggregate hours worked by about 1.5 percent between 2021 and 2025. – Previous estimate was about 1.5 percent to 2 percent ■ That increase in hours translates into an increase in aggregate compensation of between 0.8 percent and 0.9 percent over the same period. – Previous estimate was about 1 percent ■ Hours worked would rise by more than compensation because lower-wage workers would be most strongly affected by the repeal, so they would change labor supply the most.
  • 35. 34CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Other Macroeconomic Effects of Repealing the Affordable Care Act ■ Aggregate demand would be slightly lower in the short run. – Redistribution from lower-income benefit recipients to higher-income taxpayers and medical care providers ■ Larger labor supply would lead to increased investment and a larger capital stock. – Effect offset somewhat by increased deficits, which crowd out capital – Longer-term effects estimated with the Solow-type growth model ■ Outputwouldberoughlyunchangedin2016buthigherinlateryears. ■ Interest rates would be higher. – Capital-labor ratio would fall with larger labor supply, increasing the marginal product of capital and therefore interest rates
  • 36. 35CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Macroeconomic Feedback Effects of Repealing the Affordable Care Act ■ Higher output would increase revenues and modestly increase primary spending. – Revenues depend on taxable income of different types with different effective marginal tax rates. – Outlays depend more on prices than real output. ■ Higher interest rates would increase federal interest payments on the national debt. ■ Feedback effects would lower deficits throughout the 2016–2025 period.
  • 37. 36CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Macroeconomic Feedback Effects of Repealing the Affordable Care Act (Continued) ■ Feedback effects would increase for some time because the effects of the ACA, and therefore repeal, phase in over time but feedback effects would ultimately decline as the effects of higher deficits became more important. ■ In CBO’s analyses of other policies, macroeconomic feedback has been less significant relative to the estimated cost without macroeconomic feedback.
  • 38. 37CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Summary of Estimated Effects on Direct Spending and Revenues of Repealing the Affordable Care Act Billions of Dollars, by Fiscal Year 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Total, 2016– 2020 Total, 2016– 2025 Estimated Changes Without Macroeconomic Feedback Effects on Outlays -10 -107 -106 -100 -93 -88 -77 -71 -65 -43 -477 -821 Effects on Revenues -66 -79 -99 -107 -115 -123 -132 -142 -152 -161 -466 -1,174 Effects on the Deficit -5 -28 -7 7 21 35 55 70 87 118 -12 353 Estimated Budgetary Impact of Macroeconomic Feedback Effects on Outlays * -2 -3 -2 -1 1 2 4 5 6 -8 9 Effects on Revenues 3 11 21 26 27 27 28 28 27 26 88 255 Effects on the Deficit -4 -13 -24 -29 -28 -26 -26 -24 -23 -20 -97 -216 Estimated Changes With Macroeconomic Feedback Effects on Outlays -71 -109 -109 -103 -94 -87 -75 -68 -60 -37 -486 -812 Effects on Revenues -63 -67 -78 -81 -88 -96 -104 -114 -124 -135 -377 -949 Effects on the Deficit -8 -42 -31 -22 -6 9 29 46 64 98 -108 137
  • 39. 38CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Estimated Effects on Deficits of Repealing the Affordable Care Act Billions of Dollars, by Fiscal Year 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 -50 -25 0 25 50 75 100 125 150 Without Macroeconomic Feedback With Macroeconomic Feedback
  • 40. 39CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Notes For more information about CBO’s analysis of the Affordable Care Act under current law and the effects of proposals to change the law, see the following: ■ Congressional Budget Office, “Affordable Care Act,” www.cbo.gov/topics/health-care/affordable-care-act. ■ Congressional Budget Office, Budgetary and Economic Effects of Repealing the Affordable Care Act (June 2015), www.cbo.gov/publication/50252. ■ Edward Harris and Shannon Mok, How CBO Estimates the Effects of the Affordable Care Act on the Labor Market, Working Paper 2015-09 (Congressional Budget Office, December 7, 2015), www.cbo.gov/publication/51065.