This document discusses two examples of downscaling information systems for education. The first involves creating a decentralized research information ecosystem using layered ontologies to share data about academic institutions and researchers. The second involves enabling social interaction and data sharing between students using low-cost laptops without internet access by turning each laptop into a self-contained linked data publisher and consumer.
Take control of your SAP testing with UiPath Test Suite
Downscaling information systems for education
1. Data Archiving and Networked Services
Downscaling
information systems
for education
Christophe Guéret (@cgueret)
DANS is een instituut van KNAW en NWO
2. What do you mean "Downscaling" ?
● Alternative to up/out scaling platforms when
the cost of doing it becomes too high
● "Cost" in the wide sense
○ Loss of expressivity via harmonization
○ Loss of privacy
○ Loss of consistency / incompatible semantics
○ Hardware costs
○ Infrastructural costs
○ Cultural incompatibility
○ ...
3. Up / out scaling
● Get more and more data into one system
● Scale vertically (up) or horizontally (out)
4. Down scaling
● Instead of one big (cluster) system, use a
swarm of smaller systems
● Aim at highest meaningful granularity
5. 2 downscaled systems for education
● Information system for researchers willing to
study Worldwide academic activity
● ~2M young learners willing to go social with
digital media, but without Internet
7. Context
● Millions of researchers active Worldwide
● Represents lot of information about
○ Positions
○ Teaching activities
○ Equipment
○ Discoveries
○ ...
● Potential high value in sharing all that data
and mining it
8. Problems
● Lots of name-centric, thus highly ambiguous,
data sets
● Different conceptual spaces
● Different positions that not always
correspond
○ "Maître de conférences" ~ "Universitair Docent" ~
"Assistant professor" ?
9. Towards THE information system (?)
● Try to be the "Facebook for researchers"
● Eventual focus on sub-parts of the data
10. or THE ontology (?)
● Focus on the terminology, allow for different
data stack (including non Web based)
11. Users end-up with a tough choice
● Do you prefer too specific or too generic ?
● Workaround: formats roundtripping
12. But data does not travel well...
● Publications from Frank van Harmelen
● Decreasing number from system to system
148 38 13
13. Downscaling RIS
● Some of the harmonization high costs
○ Large ontologies are hard to design
○ Tradeoff coverage VS expressivity
○ Large amount of data
○ Lack of incentives to update one platform + branding
and reporting issues playing against
● Alternative
○ Rely on a data ecosystem
○ Use several, layered ontologies
17. Context
● XO laptop given to 2M
kids aged 6-12
● Low-end hardware
(~ old smartphone)
● Educational software
based on
constructivism
● Communication via
Mesh-networking
19. Activities in Sugar
● A Sugar activity combines the concepts of
“document” and “application” into a single
object
● Activities can be easily shared between
neighbouring computers
● Activity instances are associated with the
document they let the user work on
22. Limitations of current data stack
● Data sharing limited to synchronous
interaction
● Data isolated in silos
● No remote access to data created within a
Sugar instance
● Social activity bounded by the classroom
23. Let's improve this, Web 2.0 way !
● Create a central server on the Cloud and
define an API
● Create activities interacting via the API
● Add a Web frontend for authentication and
adjust ACLs for the API
+ + =
24. Won't work because...
● Lack of stable, cheap, connection to Internet
● Lack of relevant content on the Web to
justify getting a connection
● Issues with having kids on social networks
● (Besides, potentially hard to find a business
model for sharing kids' work)
25. Downscaled alternative
● Turn every XO into a self-contained data
publisher/consumer
● Apply Linked Data principles to achieve
decentralised data integration
26. More information
● Collection of presentation about this and
other topics
○ http://www.slideshare.net/cgueret
● Blog about making data sharing a reality for
everyone
○ https://worldwidesemanticweb.wordpress.com/
● christophe.gueret@dans.knaw.nl