SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Download to read offline
1
Policy Analysis on Development of Special
Border Economic Zones in Thailand
By
Choen Krainara
Policy and Plan Analyst, Professional Level
Central Economic and Social Development Office
Office of the National Economic and Social Development Board
(NESDB)
and
Ph.D. Candidate
Regional and Rural Development Planning Field of Study
School of Environment, Resources and Development
Asian Institute of Technology
Thailand
2 March 2016
To cite this article:
Choen Krainara.2016. Policy Analysis on Development of Special Border Economic Zones
in Thailand in Doctoral Dissertation entitled “Border Economic Zones and Development
Dynamics in Thailand: A Comparative Study of Bordering Countries (Cambodia, Lao PDR
and Myanmar)”, Phathumtani: Asian Institute of Technology.
2
Chapter 4
Policy Analysis: Development of Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand
This chapter presents policy analysis in Thailand conducive to development of special
border economic zones. It includes evolution and analysis of current special border
economic zone development policies. It seeks to understand why and how the policy is
developed at a particular time and the intended effects of those policies.
4.1 Evolution of Special Border Economic Zone Development Policies in Thailand
Thailand adopts 5-year national development plan to guide development paths. Over 54
years of national development planning, spatial development policies are continually
evolving in line with national and sectoral development progress, which can be classified
into 4 distinct periods. Each period characterized by specific spatial development
advancement. The first period (1961-1966) focused on developing key infrastructure
projects as backbone for national development, as well as, attracting private investments.
The second period (1967-1981) emphasized on promoting regional and rural development
including creating jobs and income distribution to peripheral regions. The third period
(1982-2001) adopted Area Approach planning for identifying development programs and
projects by promoting regional development, which concentrated on fostering regional
growth centers and the Eastern Seaboard Development Program. It also focused on urban,
rural and specific areas development. While the fourth period (2002-2015) recently shifted
towards upholding rural-urban relations and development of special border economic
zones (SBEZs) along the Greater Mekong Economic Corridors in order to grasp potential
of proliferating regional cooperation and integration programs particularly for the
Ayeyawady-Chao Phraya-Mekong Economic Cooperation Strategy (ACMECS), the
Greater Mekong Sub-region Economic Cooperation Program and the ASEAN Economic
Community as integral part of the ASEAN Community.
To materialize the concept of SBEZ, its ultimate goals were not only to reduce both inter-
regional and intra-regional disparities, but also to create production bases along border
areas, as well as coping border labor shortage. It also aims to minimize impacts of
continuing influx of illegal immigrant labor and low quality agricultural produce from
neighboring countries into Thailand. Yet, progress has been gradually made due to this
concept is truly new for Thailand. As a result, different efforts have been made in various
governments. Chronologically, the Thaksin Administration initially announced to promote
first SBEZs in both Chiang Rai and Tak provinces since 2003. However, it encountered
severe resistance from both local authorities and general public, who were aware of being
profoundly displaced their local administration function by new local authorities under the
proposed special border economic zone law. This subsequently generated wide criticism on
pros and cons of the SBEZ within Thai society. Coupled with political discontinuity, the
initiative to implement these two pilot SBEZs were consequently sluggish for almost 8
years.
As Thailand approached full entry into the ASEAN Community by the end of 2015, the
Abhisit Administration reapproved on October 19, 2010 to develop Maesod district in Tak
province as a pilot special border economic zone. On March 22, 2011, a total budget of
14.04 million Baht was then allocated to carry out a research for formulating development
plan of Maesod Special Border Economic Zone. In 2013, the Yingluck Administration
3
renewed support the scheme by setting up a mechanism so called Special Border Economic
Zone Development Policy Board. Subsequently, a strategic plan for promoting special
border economic zones was formulated in 2014 covering 5 cross-border regions across the
country. This consisted of 1) Northern border region comprised Maesai, Chaingsaen and
Chaingkhong districts in Chiang Rai province. 2) Northeastern border region consisted of
Mukdahan, Nakhon Phanom and Nongkhai provinces. 3) Eastern border region represented
Sakaeo and Trat provinces. 4) Western border region comprised Kanchanaburi province.
And 5) Southern border region included Sadao district of Song Khla province and
Narathiwat province. Presently, the Prayuth Administration promptly carried on hastening
the implementation process of these SBEZs.
There are several direct and indirect policies that influenced the special border economic
zones development in Thailand. The concise integrated policies are presented in Table
4.1.The detailed discussions are described in the following paragraphs.
4
Table 4.1 Brief Integrated Development Policies for Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand
Major Policies Major features Execution of Policies (Translated into
action)
Impacts/Implications for Thailand
vis-à-vis neighboring countries
Direct Policies
(Explicit Policies)
Policy 1:Special
Border Economic
Zone Development
Policy
It serves as core national policy in driving
SBEZ development. At present, the
Prayuth Administration is keenly
expediting implementation of 10 SBEZs
across Thailand dividing into 2 phases. On
January 15, 2015, the Prayuth Government
approved 5 pilot SBEZs urging to realize
early tangible progress by the end of 2015.
Totally, it covers a combined of 36 sub-
districts or 10 districts in 5 border
provinces with total land area of 2,932
Km2
. Recently, the Royal Thai
Government has approved the second
phase of SBEZs since March 16, 2015,
covering 5 provinces in a combined of 16
districts or 63 sub-districts.
A mechanism to run the SBEZs has been
set up by assigning 4 mains organizations
to oversee implementation process
comprising Office of the National
Economic and Social Development Board
(NESDB) Office of Board of Investment
(BOI), Ministry of Foreign Affairs and
Ministry of Interior. Then, the NESDB in
cooperation with the BOI and related
agencies were tasked to coordinate in
designing detailed investment targets in
the pilots SBEZs. Therefore, four
different sub-committees were formed at
national level. These are (1) Sub-
Committee on Identifying Physical
Boundary of SBEZs. (2) Sub-Committee
on Designing Investment Incentives,
Boundary and One Stop Service Center.
(3) Sub-Committee on Infrastructure and
Customs House. (4) Sub-Committee on
One Stop Service on Labor, Public Health
and National Security. An Act on
Development of Special Economic Zones
is being drafted and will take effect by
2016.
Fast progress for defining priority
development locations and setting up
of supportive mechanism for
implementing the targeted special
border economic zones.
5
Major Policies Major features Execution of Policies (Translated into
action)
Impacts/Implications for Thailand
vis-à-vis neighboring countries
Policy2:International
Trade and Cross-
Border Trade
Policies
Policy 3: Customs
Facilitation Policy
Policy 4: Border
Investment and
Industrial
Development Policies
The Royal Thai Government persistently
reaffirms policies to expand regional
cooperation particularly on trade at
different levels.
Thailand has already signed an Agreement
to Establish and Implement the ASEAN
Single Window since 2005 in order to
facilitate greater flow of international trade
between ASEAN member countries.
Within this agreement, ASEAN member
countries concurred to implement the
ASEAN Single Window Pilot Project
consisting of linkages of Certificate of
Origin under ASEAN Trade in Goods
Agreement (ATIGA Form D) and ASEAN
Customs Declaration Document (ACDD).
It aims to attract greater investments into
these border regions at 20 %, as well as,
being a part of preparation plan for entry
into ASEAN Economic Community by the
end of 2015.
The specific international trade policies at
different levels have been formulated.
These are at ASEAN level; GMS level
and Bilateral level.
The Royal Thai Customs Department has
fully executed e-Customs through the
National Single Window (NSW) since
2008. As of September 15, 2014, it can be
electronically linked data on licenses and
certificates via the NSW with a total of 21
relevant organizations. The Royal Thai
Customs Department has likewise
collaborated with licensing and certifying
organizations to set up database on
commodity codes that required to apply
for licenses and certificates, and can be
accessible online.
Attractive investment incentives have
been already put in place, which can be
classified into 2 slightly different types.
These are general and specific target
industries. The specific target productions
in the pilot SBEZs consisted of 13
industries covering 61 business activities.
Each pilot SBEZ may have specialization
in specific industry based on resource
endowments and complementarity with
adjacent SBEZs in neighboring countries.
Clear policies on international trade
and cross-border trade helped
increase regional and cross-border
trade flows.
Customs facilitation through
establishment of National Single
Window helped increase intensity of
cross-border-trade flows.
Investment incentives have still not
attracted enough interests of both
local and foreign direct investments.
As a result, some investors are
reluctant to invest in the targeted
special border economic zones.
6
Major Policies Major features Execution of Policies (Translated into
action)
Impacts/Implications for Thailand
vis-à-vis neighboring countries
Policy 5: National
and Cross-Border
Transport and
Logistics Policies
Policy 6: Labor,
Public Health and
National Security
Policies
Provides national railways linking between
Bangkok and regional growth centers and
border provinces in order to connect with
neighboring countries. It also aims to
promote cross-border land transport
networks and efficient logistics systems.
Permits daily movement of immigrant
labor from neighboring countries into pilot
SBEZs while also talking care their labor
right. Skill development should be
provided to both Thai national residing
along border and immigrant labor.
Immediate national security concern
should be prioritized and managed to
support cross-border development
cooperation via SBEZ.
As an alternative to the BOI’s tax breaks,
new investors could also choose
incentives granted by the Ministry of
Finance under “Thailand Plus One”
scheme, which would allow a reduction
of corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10
years.
Additional national railways linking
Bangkok with key border provinces are
being planned. Furthermore, improves
cross-border transport networks e.g.
international highways, Mekong river
bridges and river ports and logistics
systems linking with neighboring
countries. This can facilitate
transportation services, as well as
reducing logistics costs.
Daily movement of immigrant labor
within specified SBEZs is legally
permitted. One Stop Service for
Immigrant Labor is to be set up at the
pilot SBEZs.
Much progress is underway. It is
likely to facilitate greater cross-
border flows of goods, people and
vehicles.
Implementation for permitting daily
movement of immigrant labor is still
slow. There is existed of certain
restriction on cross-border
movement practice of immigrant
labor.
7
Major Policies Major features Execution of Policies (Translated into
action)
Impacts/Implications for Thailand
vis-à-vis neighboring countries
Indirect Policies
(Implicit Policies)
Policy 1: Tourism
and Visa Policies
Policy 2:
International
Relations, Regional
Cooperation and
Official Development
Assistance Policies
Promoting Thailand as a gateway to Asia.
Fosters closer both bilateral relations and
regional integration with neighboring
countries. Various forms of Official
Development Assistance should be
provided to neighboring countries in
support of SBEZs cooperation.
Thailand implemented regional tourism
cooperation schemes under GMS and
ACMECS. ACMECS single visa is an
important instrument in facilitating
greater people mobility between Thailand
and bordering countries. As a result,
implementation of a pilot ACMECS
single visa between Thailand and
Cambodia was made effective since
December 16, 2010.
Thailand continuously fosters closer
bilateral relations with neighboring
countries. It is implemented in the form of
cooperation at all levels ranging from
public, private, people and media sectors.
Also, official development assistances
from Thailand towards neighboring
countries.
The initiative helped facilitate
greater cross-border movement of
both people and vehicles.
Continuing regional integration and
official development assistances
from Thailand to bordering countries
helped bridge intra-GMS sub-region
development disparities.
8
4.2 Detailed Policy Analysis for Upholding Development of Special Border Economic
Zones SBEZ policies in Thailand are currently advancing towards rapid implementation of
pilot locations. The Prayuth Government has firmly committed in formulating integrated
policies, as well as, accelerating the implementation process. As a result, analysis of actual
integrated policies for upholding special border economic zone development is undertaken
employing qualitative analyses. It can be broadly categorized into 2 major groups of policies,
which are direct and indirect policies as follows:
4.2.1 Direct Policies or Explicit Policies intend to directly lay down strong foundation for
progressing development of pilot SBEZs. Features and progresses of these integrated policies
are as follows:
1) Special Border Economic Zone Development Policies
It served as core national policy in driving SBEZ development. At present, the Prayuth
Administration is keenly expediting implementation of 10 SBEZs across Thailand dividing
into 2 phases. It aims at attracting greater investments into these border regions at 20 %, as
well as, being a part of preparation plan for entry into ASEAN Community by the end of
2015. Therefore, on January 19, 2015, the Prayuth Government approved 5 designated pilot
SBEZs along with major infrastructure development plan and associated private investment
incentives. The Royal Thai Government guided to realize early tangible progress by the end
of 2015. Totally, it covers 5 border provinces in 10 districts or 36 sub-districts with a total
land area of 2,932 Km2
. This consisted of:
(1) Tak Special Border Economic Zone covers Maesod, Pobpra and Maeramad districts of
Tak province with total land area of 1,419 Km2
;
(2) Mukdahan Special Border Economic Zone comprises Muang Mukdahan, Wanyai and
Dontan districts in Mukdahan province with total land area of 578.50 Km2
;
(3) Sakaeo Special Border Economic Zone encompasses Aranyaprathet and Wattananakhon
districts in Sakaeo province with total land area of 332 Km2
;
(4) Trat Special Border Economic Zone covers Klong Yai district in Trat province with total
land area of 50.20 Km2
; and
(5) Songkhla Special Border Economic Zone includes Sadao district in Songkhla province
with total land area of 552.30 Km2
.
Recently, the Royal Thai Government has approved the second phase of SBEZs on March 16,
2015, covering 5 provinces in 16 districts or 63 sub-districts. These are:
(1) Nongkhai Special Border Economic Zone encompasses 5 districts or a combined of 22
sub-districts namely Muang Nongkhai; Srakrai; Ponpisai; Thabor and Srichiangmai districts
of Nongkhai province with a total land area of 144.78 Km2
;
(2) Nakhon Panom Special Border Economic Zone includes 2 districts or a combined
of 13 sub-districts, namely Muang Nakhon Panom and Tha-Uthain districts of Nakhon
Panom province;
(3) Chiang Rai Special Border Economic Zone involves 3 districts or a combined of
21 sub-districts namely Maesai; Chiangsaen and Chiang Khong districts of Chiang Rai
province;
(4) Kanchanaburi Special Border Economic Zone covers Muang Kanchanaburi
District with a combined of 2 sub-districts of Kanchanaburi province with a total land area of
260.78 Km2
; and
(5) Narathiwat Special Border Economic Zone comprises 5 districts or a combined of
5 sub-districts, namely Sungai Kolok, Takbai, Wang, Yi-Ngo and Muang Narathiwat districts
of Narathiwat province with a total land area of 209 Km2
.
9
The Royal Thai Government also set up a mechanism to run the SBEZs by assigning 4 mains
organizations to oversee implementation process comprising Office of the National Economic
and Social Development Board as a secretariat office of the National Special Border
Economic Zone Development Policy Board, Office of Board of Investment, Ministry of
Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Interior. Then, Office of the National Economic and Social
Development Board in cooperation with Office of Board of Investment and related agencies
were tasked to coordinate in designing detailed investment targets in the pilots SBEZs so that
prospective investors can propose investment projects as soon as possible. Therefore, four
different sub-committees were formed at national level. These are:
1) Sub-Committee on Identifying Physical Boundary of Special Border Economic Zones
chaired by Ministry of Interior. Its task was to consider target provincial proposals for
establishing as SBEZs along with public land acquisition for further private lease.
This is to solve problem on increasing land price arising from widespread local land
speculation;
2) Sub-Committee on Investment Incentives, Boundary and One Stop Service Center on
Investment chaired by Permanent Secretary of Finance together with Office of Board
of Investment, Office of Council of State, National Security Council, Department of
Forestry, Office of SMEs Promotion and concerned provinces, local organizations and
private sector;
3) Sub-Committee on Infrastructure and Customs House comprised
6 organizations namely Ministry of Transport (Department of Highways, Department
of Aviation and Marine Department) Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of
Agriculture and Cooperatives, Department of Customs, Office of Thailand
Immigration and Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand;
4) Sub-Committee on One Stop Service on Labor, Public Health and National Security
consisted of 10 organizations namely Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of
Interior, Ministry of Public Health, Department of Employment, Department of Skill
Development, Office of Thailand Immigration, Office of Social Security, Commission
of Vocational Education, Industrial Federation of Thailand and Thai Chamber of
Commerce.
To help facilitate rapid implementation of the 5 pilot SBEZs at provincial level, it is being
studied to set up a Special Border Economic Zone Administration Sub-Committee in each
pilot location. Moreover, the Royal Thai Government approved an infrastructure and customs
house development plan of the pilot SBEZs during the year 2015-2020 amounted 98,571
million Baht with total 185 projects for specific undertakings as follows:
 Tak SBEZ to be constructed the second Moei river bridge; Tak-Mae Sod
Highway; improvement of Mae Sod airport; new customs house and immigration offices;
Mae Sod industrial estate and Huei Mae Sod reservoir, etc.;
 Mukdahan SBEZ to be built provincial highway; border logistics
center; residential area of customs officials; Mukdahan Industrial Estate and pumping station
utilizing electricity, etc;
 Trat SBEZ to be developed Klongyai Port; border logistics center; customs
house and Trad industrial estate, etc;
 Sakaeo SBEZ to be constructed new customs house and Aranyaprathet
industrial estate, etc;
 Songkhla SBEZ to be built border logistics center; Songkhla Deep Seaport 2;
10
double railway track for Padang Besar-Hat Yai route; new Sadao customs house; Songkhla
industrial estate, etc.; and
 Nongkhai SBEZ to be constructed new highway Nongkhai-Ponpisai route;
new customs house and Ponswang industrial estate, etc.
An Act on Development of Special Economic Zones is being drafted and will take effect by
2016.Relating to urban development in the pilot SBEZs, principle city plans and design of
specific border town plans along with physical zoning and provision of public utilities are
being revised in response to the changing development potential and policies. It has been
physically planned at 3 different levels as follows:
 Creates provincial physical planning for border gateways linking with ASEAN
Community. It will identify potential development areas and then prepare these areas for
playing as both strategic trade gateways and SBEZs. It will also be formulated integrated
development programs for promoting both urban development and special border economic
zones;
 Develops both principle provincial, urban and community plans in order to
guide land use, transport and infrastructure development, which will be associated with
regulations to be corresponding with prospective SBEZs and integrated urban development;
 Designs specific plans of special border economic zones including detailed
design of urban architecture and zoning. It will likewise lay out public utilities system to be
corresponding with principle urban plan system comprising industrial zone, agricultural
warehouse, cross-border trade and new residential areas.
To counter prevalent local land speculation, on May 15, 2015, the Royal Thai Government
has expropriated degraded forest and public land in the designated SBEZs to rent out to
private investors in order to promote rapid starting up of industries and businesses.
2) International Trade and Cross-Border Trade Policies
Cross-border trade between Thailand and CLM has been periodically affected adversely by
political and diplomatic problems during periods of political differences (TDRI 1997). After
the end of cold war, Thailand has proclaimed a policy of turning “Indochina battlefields into
a marketplace” since 1988 in order to foster closer economic interdependence (Chandoevwit
et al., 2005). The Royal Thai Government persistently reaffirms policies to expand regional
cooperation particularly on trade at three different levels as follows (Thai Government
Statements 2008; 2009):
(1) ASEAN Level is a vital trading bloc for Thailand placing significant emphasis on
utilizing full advantage of AFTA through “ASEAN Hub” policy so as to sustain trading and
investment base particular in CLMV. It is implemented by means of establishment of
Thailand’s distribution centers and trading firms in CLMV.
(2) Greater Mekong Sub-region Level is very meaningful due to geopolitics of Thailand as
a strategic crossroad of the GMS. As a result, Thailand has focused on fostering greater flows
in order to increase volume and value of cross-border trade, as well as, facilitating both intra
and extra-GMS trade, investment and tourism through the implementation of CBTA.
Launches regional production networks by relocating specific investments to neighboring
countries. Keenly negotiates transit trade regime with neighboring countries e.g. China, Lao
PDR, Myanmar and Vietnam in order to facilitate free flow of goods to nearby neighboring
countries markets either in South East Asian, South Asian, or East Asian regions.
(3) Bilateral Level with Particular Emphasis on Cross-Border Trade Policy
11
Thailand places emphasis on common bilateral cross-border trade policies towards
neighboring countries particularly on trade facilitation along major economic corridors. It
correspondingly aims to improve facilities at key border checkpoints to meet international
standards. The Ministry of Commerce has set the targeted value for both cross-border trade
and transit trade to reach 1.50 trillion Baht or 48,387 million US$ by the year 2015.This plan
has been implemented through 4 strategies namely 1) development of competitiveness of
Thailand for enhancing trade value; 2) building capacity of personnel responsible for cross-
border trade; 3) promoting outward investment in neighboring countries; and 4) urgent
problem solving and utilization of regional trade agreements. Furthermore, local border
cooperatives are collectively strengthened to actively participate in cross-border trade of
agricultural produce aiming to help minimize the impact of illegal influx of low quality
agricultural produce from bordering countries into Thailand.
3) Customs Facilitation Policy
Thailand has already signed an Agreement to Establish and Implement the ASEAN Single
Window since 2005 in order to facilitate greater flow of international trade between ASEAN
member countries. Within this agreement, ASEAN member countries concurred to
implement the ASEAN Single Window Pilot Project consisting of linkages of Certificate of
Origin under ASEAN Trade in Goods Agreement (ATIGA Form D) and ASEAN Customs
Declaration Document (ACDD). In line with this agreement, the Royal Thai Customs
Department has fully executed e-Customs through the National Single Window (NSW) since
2008. As of September 15, 2014, it can be electronically linked data on licenses and
certificates via the NSW with a total of 21 relevant organizations. The Royal Thai Customs
Department has likewise collaborated with licensing and certifying organizations to set up
database on commodity codes that required to apply for licenses and certificates, and can be
accessible online.
4) Investment and Industrial Development Policies
Pertaining to investment policy, the Board of Investment (BOI) recently revealed the Seven-
Year Investment Promotion Strategies (2015-2021) built on both activities and merit-based
incentives. It also included investment promotion policy particularly for investment in special
border economic zones, which is equivalent to maximum incentives provided to the southern
border provinces. Applications must be submitted from January 1, 2015 to December 31,
2017. Detailed investment promotion can be classified into 2 slightly different types of
incentives as follows:
(1) General Industries
In case general activities are eligible for investment promotion, projects shall receive the
following incentives:
 3 additional years of corporate income tax (CIT) exemption;
 In case where projects are already granted an 8-year corporate income tax
exemption, an additional 5-year 50 % CIT exemption shall be grated instead;
 Double deductions from the costs of transportation, electricity and water
supply;
 Additional 25 % deduction of the cost of installation or construction of
facilities;
 Exemption of import duty for machinery;
 Exemption of import duty on raw materials and necessary components to be
produced for exports for 5 years;
 Other non-tax incentives; and
 Permission for employing unskilled immigrant labor.
12
(2) Specific Target Industries
In case of specific target activities for SBEZs as specified by the Special Border Economic
Zone Development Policy Board, projects shall receive the following incentives:
 8-year corporate income tax exemption and an additional 5-year 50 %
reduction of corporate income tax.
 Double tax deductions from the costs of transportation, electricity and water
supply for 30 years;
 Additional 25 % tax deduction for the cost of installation or construction of
facilities in addition to normal depreciation costs;
 Exemption of import duty for machinery;
 A 5-year exemption of import duty for raw materials and necessary
components to be produced for exports;
 Other non-tax incentives; and
 Permission for employing unskilled immigrant labor.
The BOI has also allowed promoted projects in the pilot SBEZ to use machinery older than 5
years but not exceeding 10 years. On general case, imported used machinery must not exceed
10 years. In case when a production base is relocated into Thailand, machinery over 10 years
old will be allowed to be used in the project. In both cases, no offer of import duty exemption
on machinery will be made and the project will be required to submit a performance
certificate issued by a trusted institute identifying the efficiency of the machinery, its
environmental impact, safety standard and energy usage, as well as its maintenance profile
and its fair value must be obtained.
As an alternative to the BOI’s tax breaks, new investors could also choose incentives granted
by the Ministry of Finance under “Thailand Plus One” scheme, which would allow a
reduction in corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years. “Thailand Plus One” would
supplement SBEZs investment projects. So, Thailand could forge greater relations with
neighboring countries. This means any ASEAN investor can invest in the SBEZs to receive
privileges from Thailand plus border countries such as Myanmar, Lao PDR, Cambodia and
Malaysia. Thailand Plus One is a strategic business model initiated by Japan’s corporations in
2012 to encourage investors to maintain their main operations in Thailand while diversifying
supporting productions in the supply chain to neighboring countries in order to gain benefits
from comparative advantages and regional production networks. Maesod and Aranyaprathet
SBEZs are pioneer areas in Thailand in fostering linkages with Myanmar and Cambodia.
Furthermore, a One Stop Service Center for Investment is to be set up in pilot provincial
halls. Concerning new local investors who did not hold BOI approval, they will not only
entitle for a reduction of corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years but also to gain an
access to soft loan at maximum credit limit of 20 million Baht provided by the Government
Saving Banks and warranted by Thai Credit Guarantee Corporation. This will play important
role for fast track implementation of SBEZs plan. In addition, the Department of Customs has
additionally provided investment incentives for establishment in both free zone and bonded
warehouse as follows:
 Exemption of import tax for machinery;
 Exemption of import tax for raw materials to be manufactured for export;
 Exemption of export tax;
 Exemption of disposal tax for materials;
13
 Exemption of value-added tax for raw materials to be manufactured for export;
 Exemption of value-added tax for import and export commodities; and
 Non-time limit for storage of goods in free zone. Whereas, it is allowed for storage of
goods for maximum 2 years in bonded warehouse.
In relation to prospective industries in the pilot SBEZs, the Board of Investment prioritized
specific target productions consisting of 13 major industries covering 61 business activities as
follows:
 Agro-industry, fishery and related businesses;
 Ceramics product manufacturing;
 Textile, clothing and leather manufacturing;
 Furniture manufacturing;
 Gems and jewelry manufacturing;
 Medical devices manufacturing;
 Automotive, machinery and parts manufacturing;
 Electronics and electrical appliances manufacturing;
 Plastics manufacturing;
 Pharmaceuticals manufacturing;
 Logistics businesses;
 Industrial zones or industrial estates; and
 Businesses that support tourism.
Regarding specific target industry in the 5 pilot SBEZs, the Board of Investment has
announced illegible industries and businesses as follows:
 Tak Special Border Economic Zone consists of agroindustry, textile and apparel,
wood and wood furniture and gems and jewelry. It will link with Myawaddy Border
Economic Zone in Kayin State of Myanmar;
 Mukdahan Special Border Economic Zone comprises electronics, warehouse,
wholesale, logistics and tourism. It will connect with Savan Seno Special Border
Economic Zone in Savannakhet province of Lao PDR;
 Sakaeo Special Border Economic Zone entails retail and wholesale, agro-processed
industry, warehouse and logistics. It will link with Poipet Oneang Special Border
Economic Zone in Bantay Meanchey province of Cambodia;
 Trat Special Border Economic Zone involves eco-tourism, duty free cross-border
trade, multimodal transport, warehouse and logistics. It will connect with Koh Kong
Special Economic Zone in Koh Kong province of Cambodia; and
 Songkhla Special Border Economic Zone consists of extended area of an industrial
estate for export, natural rubber processed industry, sea food and halal food. It will
cooperate with heavy industrial zone, rubber and halal industry in bordering Kedah
state of Malaysia.
So far, a number of Bangkok-based conglomerates expressed keen interest to invest in in a
particular SBEZ. For instance in Tak SBEZ, Charoen Pokpand (CP) Group may make
investment on logistics and real estate; while Central Pattana Group may invest in a
department store. Sahaphat Group may invest in high-end apparel. Thai Beverage Group may
capitalize distribution centers. And Amata Group may operate industrial estates. In
Mukdahan SBEZ, Bangkok Hospital Group may capitalize an international hospital. Central
Pattana Group may invest a hotel. A few Vietnamese companies may invest in rubber
industries. In Sakaeo SBEZ, Sahaphat Group may invest consumer goods. Charoen Pokpand
14
Group may finance agro-processing industry. As well, a few of Japan and Hong Kong
conglomerate interested to invest in the pilot SBEZS particularly in logistics. Likewise, it is
anticipated that these large private companies may attract a large number of their related
subsidiaries and supply chain networks into these pilot SBEZs. As a result, it will help
generate more job opportunities along targeted cross-border regions.
5) Labor, Public Health and National Security Policies
Daily movement of immigrant labor within specified SBEZs is legally permitted. One Stop
Service for Immigrant Labor is to be set up at the pilot SBEZs. Its function was to facilitate
permission of immigrant labor entering the country along with arranging medical check,
medical insurance and labor protection. Besides, it will be formulated skill development plan
to support both Thai nationals residing along border areas and immigrant labor working
within the SBEZs in response to the training needs of private sector. Provision of services on
public health, education and public safety are in planning stage. Concerning national security,
urgent matters, which should be taken in account, included border demarcation, monitoring
of immigrant labor and illegal immigrant, natural resources management and preparation of
knowledgeable border officials and necessary supporting equipments, etc.
6) National and Cross-Border Transport and Logistics Policies
Additional national railways linking Bangkok with key border provinces are being planned.
The major routes be jointly invested with Japan are between Bangkok and Chiangmai
province and between Tak province and Mukdahan province. In addition, railways links with
neighboring countries are being studied either between Kanchanaburi province and Bangkok;
Bangkok-Chacheongsao province-Aranyaprathet district and Bangkok-Chacheongsao
province-Lamchabang Deep Seaport. Once finished, only one chosen railway route will be
developed. Likewise, other major dual track routes be jointly invested with China are both
between Bangkok and Kangkoi (in Saraburi province) and between Kangkoi and Maptaphut
Deep Seaport. Feasibility studies of these two routes will be completed by September 2015.
Then, it will start constructing by October 2015, and it will take 30 months to finish. Further
connecting routes are both between Kangkoi and Nakhon Ratchasima province and between
Nakhon Ratchasima province and Nongkhai province. Feasibility studies of these two routes
will be concluded by December 2015. Then, it will start constructing by early of 2016, and
will take 36 months to accomplish.
Furthermore, improves cross-border transport networks e.g. international highways, Mekong
river bridges and river ports and logistics systems linking with neighboring countries. This
can facilitate transportation services, as well as reducing logistics costs. In addition, utilizes
both GMS and ASEAN connectivity towards promoting new production platforms with
special emphasis on development of provinces and clustering provinces along major
economic corridors. Additionally, supports wider transnational connectivity both under
ASEAN and Asian Highway Networks.
4.2.2 Indirect Policies or Implicit Policies aim to indirectly sustain development of SBEZs.
This included:
1) Tourism and Visa Policies
Thailand is strategically positioned as tourism gateway to Asia. Thailand also implemented
regional tourism cooperation schemes both under GMS and ACMECS. ACMECS single visa
is an important instrument in facilitating greater people mobility between Thailand and
bordering countries. It is a good illustration of south-south development cooperation. As a
15
result, implementation of a pilot ACMECS single visa between Thailand and Cambodia was
made effective since December 16, 2010.
2) International Relations, Regional Cooperation and Official Development Assistance
Policies
Pertaining to international relations policy, Thailand fosters closer bilateral relations with
neighboring countries. It is implemented in the form of cooperation at all levels ranging from
public, private, people and media sectors. This will strengthen better mutual understanding,
which will lead to intensify several cooperation aspects particularly under sub-regional
cooperation and ASEAN. Likewise, building public understanding on border problem and
impact of global change on Thailand will be promoted. Also, official development assistances
from Thailand towards neighboring countries focus on socio-economic development, regional
economic integration, human resources development and capacity building in the form of
exchange of best practices in various areas ranging from public health, education, agriculture
and poverty alleviation, etc.
As the stages of development between Thailand and Cambodia, Lao and Myanmar are starkly
different, the Office of Neighboring Countries Economic Development Cooperation Agency
(NEDA) of Thailand was established in 2005 aiming to foster development cooperation with
bordering countries. The NEDA, on behalf of Royal Thai Government, continuously
extended financial and technical assistances, as well as, supporting infrastructure
development in neighboring countries based on bilateral and regional cooperation program
e.g. GMS, ACMECS and ASEAN.As an emerging donor country, during 2005-2013,
Thailand has extended grant to CLM at a total of 283.94 US$ in order to develop cross-
border rail links, interprovincial roads and airports for enhancing sub-regional transport
integration and multimodal linkages (NEDA, 2013). Similarly, Thailand will extend technical
assistance to Myanmar on understanding rules and regulations of the World Trade
Organization.
Despite existence of both explicit and implicit development policies, prospective investors
are still reluctant to make real investments in the targeted special border economic zones as
they perceive that the granted investment incentives are not attractive enough.
4.3 Chapter Summary
This section highlights summary of the preceding policy analyses favorable for development
of special border economic zones in Thailand as follows:
4.3.1 Evolution of Special Border Economic Zone Development Policies in Thailand
Thailand adopts 5-year national development plan to guide development paths. Over 54 years
of national development planning, spatial development policies are continually evolving in
line with national and sectoral development progress, which can be classified into 4
distinguished periods. Each period characterized by specific spatial development
advancement. Especially during the fourth period (2002-2015), it recently shifted towards
upholding rural-urban relations and development of special border economic zones (SBEZs)
along the Greater Mekong Economic Corridors in order to grasp potential of emerging
regional cooperation and integration programs particularly for the Ayeyawady-Chao Phraya-
Mekong Economic Cooperation Strategy (ACMECS), Greater Mekong Sub-region Economic
Cooperation Program and the ASEAN Community.
To materialize the concept of SBEZ, its ultimate goals were not only to reduce inter-regional
and intra-regional disparities but also to create production bases along border areas and
16
minimize border labor shortage. It also aims to reduce impacts of continuing influx of illegal
immigrant labor and low quality agricultural produce from neighboring countries into
Thailand. Yet, progress has been gradually made due to this concept is truly new for
Thailand. Chronologically, the Thaksin Administration initially announced to promote first
SBEZs in both Chiang Rai and Tak provinces since 2003. However, it encountered severe
resistance from both local authorities and general public, who were aware of being
profoundly displaced their local administration function by new local authorities under the
proposed special border economic zone law. This subsequently generated wide criticism on
pros and cons of the SBEZ within Thai society. Coupled with political discontinuity, the
initiative to implement these two pilot SBEZs were consequently sluggish for almost 8 years.
As Thailand approached full entry into the ASEAN Community by the end of 2015, the
Abhisit Administration reapproved on October 19, 2010 to develop Maesod district in Tak
province as a pilot special border economic zone. In 2013, the Yingluck
Administration continued support the scheme by setting up a mechanism so called Special
Border Economic Zone Development Policy Board. Then, a strategic plan for promoting
special border economic zones was formulated in 2014 covering 5 cross-border regions. This
consisted of 1) Northern border region comprised Maesai, Chaingsaen and Chaingkhong
districts in Chiang Rai province. 2) Northeastern border region consisted of Mukdahan,
Nakhon Phanom and Nongkhai provinces. 3) Eastern border region represented Sakaeo and
Trat provinces. 4) Western border region comprised Kanchanaburi province. And 5) Southern
border region included Sadao district of Song Khla province and Narathiwat province.
Presently, the Prayuth Administration promptly carried on hastening the implementation
process of these pilot SBEZs.
4.3.2 Policy Analysis for Upholding Development of Special Border Economic Zones
SBEZ policies in Thailand are currently advancing towards rapid implementation of pilot
locations. The Prayuth Government has firmly committed strong leadership in formulating
integrated policies, as well as, accelerating the implementation process. As a result, analysis
of actual national integrated policies for upholding special border economic zone
development is undertaken employing qualitative analyses. It can be broadly categorized into
2 groups of policies, which are explicit and implicit policies as follows:
4.3.2.1 Direct Policies or Explicit Policies intend to directly lay down strong foundation for
progressing development of pilot SBEZs. Features of these integrated policies are as follows:
1) Special Border Economic Zone Development Policies
It served as core national policy in driving SBEZ development. Currently, the Prayuth
Administration is keenly expediting implementation of 10 SBEZs across Thailand dividing
into 2 phases. It aims at attracting greater investments into these border regions at 20 %, as
well as, being a part of preparation plan for entry into ASEAN Community by the end of
2015. Therefore, on January 19, 2015, the Prayuth Government approved 5 designated pilot
SBEZs along with major infrastructure development plan and associated private investment
incentives. The Royal Thai Government guided to realize early tangible progress by the end
of 2015. Totally, it covers 10 districts or 36 sub-districts in 5 border provinces with total
combined land area of 2,932 Km2
. This consisted of:
(1) Tak Special Border Economic Zone covered Maesod, Pobpra and Maeramad districts of
Tak province with total land area of 1,419 Km2
;
(2) Mukdahan Special Border Economic Zone comprised Muang Mukdahan, Wanyai and
Dontan districts in Mukdahan province with total land area of 578.50 Km2
;
(3) Sakaeo Special Border Economic Zone encompassed Aranyaprathet and Wattananakhon
districts in Sakaeo province with total land area of 332 Km2
;
17
(4) Trat Special Border Economic Zone covered Klong Yai district in Trat province with total
land area of 50.20 Km2
; and
(5) Songkhla Special Border Economic included Sadao district in Songkhla province with
total land area of 552.30 Km2
.
While locations in the second phase of SBEZs are being designated consisting of 5 areas
namely Chiang Rai, Nongkhai, Nakhonphanom, Kanchanaburi and Narathiwat provinces.
The Royal Thai Government also set up a mechanism to run the SBEZs by assigning 4 mains
organizations to oversee implementation process comprising Office of the National Economic
and Social Development Board as a secretariat office of the National Special Border
Economic Zone Development Policy Board, Office of Board of Investment, Ministry of
Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Interior. Then, Office of the National Economic and Social
Development Board in collaboration with Office of Board of Investment and related agencies
were tasked to coordinate in designing detailed investment targets in the pilots SBEZs so that
prospective investors can propose investment projects as soon as possible. Therefore, four
different sub-committees were formed at national level. These are:
1) Sub-Committee on Identifying Physical Boundary of Special Border Economic Zones
chaired by Ministry of Interior;
2) Sub-Committee on Investment Incentives, Boundary and One Stop Service Center on
Investment chaired by Permanent Secretary of Finance together with Office of Board
of Investment;
3) Sub-Committee on Infrastructure and Customs House comprised
6 relevant organizations;
4) Sub-Committee on One Stop Service on Labor, Public Health and National Security
consisted of 10 relevant organizations.
To help facilitate rapid implementation of the 5 pilot SBEZs at provincial level, it is being
studied to set up a Special Border Economic Zone Administration Sub-Committee in each
pilot location. Moreover, the Royal Thai Government approved in principle of an
infrastructure and customs house development plan of the pilot SBEZs through the year
2014-2022. During an urgent phase of development for these locations, it was allocated
investment budget amounted 10,546 million Baht with total 124 projects.
An Act on Development of Special Economic Zones is being drafted and will take effect by
2016.Relating to urban development in the pilot SBEZs, principle city plans and design of
specific border town plans along with physical zoning and provision of public utilities are
being revised in response to the changing development potential and policies. It has been
physically planned at 3 different levels consisting of (1) provincial physical planning for
border gateways linking with ASEAN Community; (2) principle provincial, urban and
community plans and (3) specific plans of special border economic zones including detailed
design of urban architecture and zoning.
2) International Trade and Cross-Border Trade Policies
Cross-border trade between Thailand and CLM has been periodically affected adversely by
political and diplomatic problems during periods of political differences. After the end of
cold war, Thailand has proclaimed a policy of turning “Indochina battlefields into a
marketplace” since 1988 in order to foster closer economic interdependence. The Royal Thai
Government persistently reaffirms policies to expand regional cooperation particularly on
trade at different levels as follows:
18
(1) ASEAN Level is a vital trading bloc for Thailand placing significant emphasis on
utilizing full advantage of AFTA through “ASEAN Hub” policy so as to sustain trading and
investment base particular in CLMV through establishment of Thailand’s distribution centers
and trading firms.
(2) Greater Mekong Sub-region Level is very meaningful due to geopolitics of Thailand as
a strategic crossroad of the GMS. As a result, Thailand has focused on fostering greater flows
in order to increase volume and value of cross-border trade, as well as, facilitating both intra
and extra-GMS trade, investment and tourism through the implementation of CBTA.
Launches regional production networks by relocating specific investments to neighboring
countries. Keenly negotiates transit trade regime with neighboring countries in order to
facilitate free flow of goods to nearby neighboring countries markets.
(3) Bilateral Level with Particular Emphasis on Cross-Border Trade Policy
The common bilateral cross-border trade polices of Thailand towards neighboring countries
center on trade facilitation along major economic corridors. It correspondingly aims to
improve facilities at key border checkpoints to meet international standards. In relation to
cross-border trade policy, the Ministry of Commerce has set the targeted value for both cross-
border trade and transit trade to reach 1.50 trillion Baht or 48,387 million US$ by the year
2015.This plan has been implemented through 4 strategies namely 1) strategy for
development of competitiveness of Thailand for enhancing trade value; 2) strategy for
building capacity of personnel responsible for cross-border trade; 3) strategy for outward
investment in neighboring countries; and 4) strategy for urgent problem solving and
utilization of regional cooperation agreements. Furthermore, local border cooperatives are
collectively strengthened to actively participate in cross-border trade of agricultural produce
aiming to help minimize the impact of illegal influx of low quality agricultural produce from
bordering countries into Thailand.
3) Border Investment and Industrial Development Policies
Pertaining to investment policy, the Board of Investment (BOI) recently revealed the Seven-
Year Investment Promotion Strategies (2015-2021) built on both activities and merit-based
incentives. It also included investment promotion policy particularly for investment in special
border economic zones, which is equivalent to maximum incentives provided to the southern
border provinces. Applications must be submitted from January 1, 2015 to December 31,
2017. Detailed investment promotion can be classified into 2 slightly different types of
incentives, which are general and specific target industries.
The BOI has also allowed promoted projects in the pilot SBEZ to use machinery older than 5
years but not exceeding 10 years. On general case, imported used machinery must not exceed
10 years. In case when a production base is relocated into Thailand, machinery over 10 years
old will be allowed to be used in the project. In both cases, no offer of import duty exemption
on machinery will be made and the project will be required to submit a performance
certificate issued by a trusted institute identifying the efficiency of the machinery, its
environmental impact, safety standard and energy usage, as well as, its maintenance profile
and its fair value must be obtained.
As an alternative to the BOI’s tax breaks, new investors could also choose incentives granted
by the Ministry of Finance under “Thailand Plus One” scheme, which would allow a
reduction in corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years. “Thailand Plus One” would
supplement SBEZs investment projects. So, Thailand could forge greater relations with
19
neighboring countries. This means any ASEAN investor can invest in the SBEZs to receive
privileges from Thailand plus border countries such as Myanmar, Lao PDR, Cambodia and
Malaysia. Thailand Plus One is a strategic business model initiated by Japan’s corporations in
2012 to encourage investors to maintain their main operations in Thailand while diversifying
supporting productions in the supply chain to neighboring countries in order to gain benefits
from comparative advantages and regional production networks. Maesod and Aranyaprathet
SBEZs are pioneer areas in Thailand in fostering linkages with Myanmar and Cambodia.
Furthermore, a One Stop Service Center for Investment is to be set up in pilot provincial
halls. Concerning new local investor who does not hold BOI approval, they will not only
entitle for a reduction of corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years but also to gain an
access to soft loan at maximum credit limit of 20 million Baht provided by the Government
Saving Banks and warranted by Thai Credit Guarantee Corporation. This will play important
role for fast track implementation of SBEZs plan. In addition, the Department of Customs has
additionally provided investment incentives for establishments in both free zone and bonded
warehouse.
In relation to prospective industries in the pilot SBEZs, the Board of Investment prioritized
specific target productions consisting of 13 major industries covering 61 business activities.
Each SBEZ may have specialization in a particular industry based on resource endowments
and complementarity with counterpart adjacent SBEZs in neighboring countries. So far, a
number of Bangkok-based conglomerates expressed keen interest to invest in in a particular
SBEZ. For instance in Tak SBEZ, Charoen Pokpand (CP) Group may make investment on
logistics and real estate; while Central Pattana Group may invest in a department store.
Sahaphat Group may invest in high-end apparel. Thai Beverage Group may capitalize
distribution centers. And Amata Group may operate industrial estates. In Mukdahan SBEZ,
Bangkok Hospital Group may capitalize an international hospital. Central Pattana Group may
invest a hotel. A few Vietnamese companies may engage in rubber industries. In Sakaeo
SBEZ, Sahaphat Group may invest consumer goods. Charoen Pokpand Group may finance
agro-processing industry. As well, a few of Japan and Hong Kong conglomerate interested to
invest in the pilot SBEZS particularly in logistics. Likewise, it is anticipated that these large
private companies may attract a large number of their related subsidiaries and supply chain
networks into these pilot SBEZs. As a result, it will help generate more job opportunities
along targeted cross-border regions.
4) Labor, Public Health and National Security Policies
Permits daily movement of immigrant labour within specified SBEZs. One Stop Service for
Immigrant Labour is to be set up at the pilot SBEZs. Its function was to facilitate permission
of immigrant labour entering the country along with arranging medical check, medical
insurance and labour protection. Besides, it will be formulated skill development plan to
support both Thai nationals residing along border areas and immigrant labour working within
the SBEZs in response to the training needs of private sector. Provision of services on public
health, education and public safety are in planning stage. Concerning national security, urgent
matters, which should seriously be taken in account, included border demarcation, monitoring
of immigrant labour and illegal immigrant, natural resources management and preparation of
knowledgeable border officials and necessary supporting equipments, etc.
5) National and Cross-Border Transport and Logistics Policies
Additional national railways linking Bangkok with key border provinces are being planned.
The major routes be jointly invested with Japan are between Bangkok and Chiangmai
20
province and between Tak province and Mukdahan province. In addition, railways links with
neighbouring countries are being studied either between Kanchanaburi province and
Bangkok; Bangkok-Chacheongsao province-Aranyaprathet district or Bangkok
Chacheongsao province-Lamchabang Deep Seaport. Once finished, only one chosen railway
route will be developed. Likewise, other major dual track routes be jointly invested with
China are both between Bangkok and Kangkoi (in Saraburi province) and between Kangkoi
and Maptaphut Deep Seaport. Feasibility studies of these two routes will be completed by
September 2015. Then, it will start constructing by October 2015, and it will take 30 months
to finish. Further connecting routes are both between Kangkoi and Nakhon Ratchasima
province and between Nakhon Ratchasima province and Nongkhai province. Feasibility
studies of these two routes will be concluded by December 2015. Then, it will start
constructing by early of 2016, and it will take 36 months to accomplish. Furthermore,
improves cross-border transport networks e.g. international highways, Mekong river bridges
and river ports and logistics systems linking with neighbouring countries. This can facilitate
transportation services, as well as, reducing cross-border logistics costs. In addition, utilizes
both GMS and ASEAN connectivity towards promoting new production platforms with
special emphasis on development of provinces and clustering provinces along major
economic corridors. Additionally, supports wider transnational connectivity both within
ASEAN and Asian Highway Networks.
4.3.2.2 Indirect Policies or Implicit Policies aim to indirectly sustain development of
SBEZs. This included:
1) Tourism and Visa Policies
Thailand is strategically positioned as tourism gateway to Asia. Thailand also implemented
regional tourism cooperation schemes under GMS and ACMECS. ACMECS single visa is an
important instrument in facilitating greater people mobility between Thailand and bordering
countries. It is a good illustration of south-south development cooperation. As a result,
implementation of a pilot ACMECS single visa between Thailand and Cambodia was made
effective since December 16, 2010.
2) International Relations, Regional Cooperation and Official Development Assistance
Policies
Pertaining to international relations policy, Thailand fosters closer bilateral relations with
neighbouring countries. It is implemented in the form of cooperation at all levels ranging
from public, private, people and media sectors. This will strengthen better mutual
understanding, which will lead to intensify several cooperation aspects particularly under
sub-regional cooperation and ASEAN. Likewise, building public understanding on border
problem and impact of global change on Thailand will be promoted. Also, official
development assistances from Thailand towards neighbouring countries focus on socio-
economic development, regional economic integration, human resources development and
capacity building in the form of exchange of best practices in various areas ranging from
public health, education, agriculture and poverty alleviation, etc.
As the stages of development between Thailand and Cambodia, Lao and Myanmar are starkly
different, the Office of Neighboring Countries Economic Development Cooperation Agency
(NEDA) was established in 2005 aiming to cultivate development cooperation with bordering
countries. The NEDA, on behalf of Royal Thai Government, continuously extended financial
and technical assistance, as well as supporting infrastructure development in neighbouring
countries based on bilateral and regional cooperation program e.g. GMS, ACMECS and
ASEAN.As an emerging donor country, during 2005-2013, Thailand has extended grant to
21
CLM at a total of 283.94 US$ in order to develop cross-border rail links, interprovincial
roads and airports for enhancing sub-regional transport integration and multimodal linkages
(NEDA, 2013). Similarly, Thailand will extend technical assistance to Myanmar regarding
understanding on rules and regulations of the World Trade Organization.
Despite existence of both explicit and implicit development policies, prospective investors
are still reluctant to make real investments in the targeted special border economic zones as
they perceive that the granted investment incentives are not attractive enough.

More Related Content

What's hot

The Review Analysis of China’s Economic Growth and the Correlations with Thai...
The Review Analysis of China’s Economic Growth and the Correlations with Thai...The Review Analysis of China’s Economic Growth and the Correlations with Thai...
The Review Analysis of China’s Economic Growth and the Correlations with Thai...Business, Management and Economics Research
 
5 prospect and-strategy-for-tourism-development
5 prospect and-strategy-for-tourism-development5 prospect and-strategy-for-tourism-development
5 prospect and-strategy-for-tourism-developmentNazmul Alam
 
Cafta china-asean free trade area, implications on trade and development
Cafta china-asean free trade area, implications on trade and developmentCafta china-asean free trade area, implications on trade and development
Cafta china-asean free trade area, implications on trade and developmentAlexander Decker
 
Ukraine. Turn to Growth. Investment Climate Outlook - Mid 2017
Ukraine. Turn to Growth. Investment Climate Outlook - Mid 2017Ukraine. Turn to Growth. Investment Climate Outlook - Mid 2017
Ukraine. Turn to Growth. Investment Climate Outlook - Mid 2017DIA_investment
 
N morocco profile
N morocco profileN morocco profile
N morocco profilemonendrak1
 
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growthImpact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growthIAEME Publication
 
Doing business in Vietnam EN
Doing business in Vietnam ENDoing business in Vietnam EN
Doing business in Vietnam ENOlga Bochet
 
Chinese Experience of Regulating and Encouraging Foreign Trade
Chinese Experience of Regulating and Encouraging Foreign TradeChinese Experience of Regulating and Encouraging Foreign Trade
Chinese Experience of Regulating and Encouraging Foreign Tradeijtsrd
 
H245258
H245258H245258
H245258aijbm
 
Assignment economics (ECON 1550)
Assignment economics (ECON 1550)Assignment economics (ECON 1550)
Assignment economics (ECON 1550)Ain Nur Syazwani
 
Assignment on Current Economic Conditions
Assignment on Current Economic ConditionsAssignment on Current Economic Conditions
Assignment on Current Economic ConditionsAnurag Verma
 
The foreign trade_of_bangladesh_its_comp
The foreign trade_of_bangladesh_its_compThe foreign trade_of_bangladesh_its_comp
The foreign trade_of_bangladesh_its_compEbneFahad
 
The Role of Banking Collaboration in Development of Pakistan and China Trade ...
The Role of Banking Collaboration in Development of Pakistan and China Trade ...The Role of Banking Collaboration in Development of Pakistan and China Trade ...
The Role of Banking Collaboration in Development of Pakistan and China Trade ...IOSR Journals
 

What's hot (19)

The Review Analysis of China’s Economic Growth and the Correlations with Thai...
The Review Analysis of China’s Economic Growth and the Correlations with Thai...The Review Analysis of China’s Economic Growth and the Correlations with Thai...
The Review Analysis of China’s Economic Growth and the Correlations with Thai...
 
Trade Diplomacy and Export Promotion
Trade Diplomacy and Export PromotionTrade Diplomacy and Export Promotion
Trade Diplomacy and Export Promotion
 
5 prospect and-strategy-for-tourism-development
5 prospect and-strategy-for-tourism-development5 prospect and-strategy-for-tourism-development
5 prospect and-strategy-for-tourism-development
 
Cafta china-asean free trade area, implications on trade and development
Cafta china-asean free trade area, implications on trade and developmentCafta china-asean free trade area, implications on trade and development
Cafta china-asean free trade area, implications on trade and development
 
Doing business in Vietnam_2015
Doing business in Vietnam_2015Doing business in Vietnam_2015
Doing business in Vietnam_2015
 
Thailand Investment Review, October 2014
Thailand Investment Review, October 2014Thailand Investment Review, October 2014
Thailand Investment Review, October 2014
 
Ukraine. Turn to Growth. Investment Climate Outlook - Mid 2017
Ukraine. Turn to Growth. Investment Climate Outlook - Mid 2017Ukraine. Turn to Growth. Investment Climate Outlook - Mid 2017
Ukraine. Turn to Growth. Investment Climate Outlook - Mid 2017
 
N morocco profile
N morocco profileN morocco profile
N morocco profile
 
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growthImpact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
 
Doing business in Vietnam EN
Doing business in Vietnam ENDoing business in Vietnam EN
Doing business in Vietnam EN
 
sunrisers
sunriserssunrisers
sunrisers
 
Chinese Experience of Regulating and Encouraging Foreign Trade
Chinese Experience of Regulating and Encouraging Foreign TradeChinese Experience of Regulating and Encouraging Foreign Trade
Chinese Experience of Regulating and Encouraging Foreign Trade
 
Further study on future development of the hk economy - cpu six new industries
Further study on future development of the hk economy  - cpu six new industriesFurther study on future development of the hk economy  - cpu six new industries
Further study on future development of the hk economy - cpu six new industries
 
H245258
H245258H245258
H245258
 
Assignment economics (ECON 1550)
Assignment economics (ECON 1550)Assignment economics (ECON 1550)
Assignment economics (ECON 1550)
 
Assignment on Current Economic Conditions
Assignment on Current Economic ConditionsAssignment on Current Economic Conditions
Assignment on Current Economic Conditions
 
The foreign trade_of_bangladesh_its_comp
The foreign trade_of_bangladesh_its_compThe foreign trade_of_bangladesh_its_comp
The foreign trade_of_bangladesh_its_comp
 
The Role of Banking Collaboration in Development of Pakistan and China Trade ...
The Role of Banking Collaboration in Development of Pakistan and China Trade ...The Role of Banking Collaboration in Development of Pakistan and China Trade ...
The Role of Banking Collaboration in Development of Pakistan and China Trade ...
 
Jharkhand State Report September 2017
Jharkhand State Report September 2017Jharkhand State Report September 2017
Jharkhand State Report September 2017
 

Viewers also liked

Special economic zone
Special economic zoneSpecial economic zone
Special economic zoneAakash Varma
 
ความก้าวหน้าการพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจและสังคมของเมืองชายแดนในจังหวัดกาญจนบุรีเชื่อมโยง...
ความก้าวหน้าการพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจและสังคมของเมืองชายแดนในจังหวัดกาญจนบุรีเชื่อมโยง...ความก้าวหน้าการพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจและสังคมของเมืองชายแดนในจังหวัดกาญจนบุรีเชื่อมโยง...
ความก้าวหน้าการพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจและสังคมของเมืองชายแดนในจังหวัดกาญจนบุรีเชื่อมโยง...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
การศึกษาการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ (A Study...
การศึกษาการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ (A Study...การศึกษาการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ (A Study...
การศึกษาการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ (A Study...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
สถานการณ์การแย่งยื้อ เปลี่ยนมือ ถือครองและการใช้ประโยชน์ที่ดินในพื้นที่ชายแดน...
สถานการณ์การแย่งยื้อ เปลี่ยนมือ ถือครองและการใช้ประโยชน์ที่ดินในพื้นที่ชายแดน...สถานการณ์การแย่งยื้อ เปลี่ยนมือ ถือครองและการใช้ประโยชน์ที่ดินในพื้นที่ชายแดน...
สถานการณ์การแย่งยื้อ เปลี่ยนมือ ถือครองและการใช้ประโยชน์ที่ดินในพื้นที่ชายแดน...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
การพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ
การพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ
การพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศDr.Choen Krainara
 
แนวทางการพัฒนาเมืองอุตสาหกรรมเชิงนิเวศในพื้นที่ภาคกลางในช่วงแผนพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจแ...
แนวทางการพัฒนาเมืองอุตสาหกรรมเชิงนิเวศในพื้นที่ภาคกลางในช่วงแผนพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจแ...แนวทางการพัฒนาเมืองอุตสาหกรรมเชิงนิเวศในพื้นที่ภาคกลางในช่วงแผนพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจแ...
แนวทางการพัฒนาเมืองอุตสาหกรรมเชิงนิเวศในพื้นที่ภาคกลางในช่วงแผนพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจแ...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
การพัฒนาเมืองภายใต้นโยบายเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษ: ชุมชนชายแดนด่านสะเดา
การพัฒนาเมืองภายใต้นโยบายเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษ: ชุมชนชายแดนด่านสะเดาการพัฒนาเมืองภายใต้นโยบายเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษ: ชุมชนชายแดนด่านสะเดา
การพัฒนาเมืองภายใต้นโยบายเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษ: ชุมชนชายแดนด่านสะเดาFURD_RSU
 
รูปแบบวิจัย 5 บท
รูปแบบวิจัย 5 บทรูปแบบวิจัย 5 บท
รูปแบบวิจัย 5 บทKannika Kerdsiri
 

Viewers also liked (10)

Special economic zone
Special economic zoneSpecial economic zone
Special economic zone
 
ความก้าวหน้าการพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจและสังคมของเมืองชายแดนในจังหวัดกาญจนบุรีเชื่อมโยง...
ความก้าวหน้าการพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจและสังคมของเมืองชายแดนในจังหวัดกาญจนบุรีเชื่อมโยง...ความก้าวหน้าการพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจและสังคมของเมืองชายแดนในจังหวัดกาญจนบุรีเชื่อมโยง...
ความก้าวหน้าการพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจและสังคมของเมืองชายแดนในจังหวัดกาญจนบุรีเชื่อมโยง...
 
การศึกษาการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ (A Study...
การศึกษาการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ (A Study...การศึกษาการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ (A Study...
การศึกษาการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ (A Study...
 
สถานการณ์การแย่งยื้อ เปลี่ยนมือ ถือครองและการใช้ประโยชน์ที่ดินในพื้นที่ชายแดน...
สถานการณ์การแย่งยื้อ เปลี่ยนมือ ถือครองและการใช้ประโยชน์ที่ดินในพื้นที่ชายแดน...สถานการณ์การแย่งยื้อ เปลี่ยนมือ ถือครองและการใช้ประโยชน์ที่ดินในพื้นที่ชายแดน...
สถานการณ์การแย่งยื้อ เปลี่ยนมือ ถือครองและการใช้ประโยชน์ที่ดินในพื้นที่ชายแดน...
 
การพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ
การพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศการพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ
การพัฒนาและการบริหารจัดการเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนในต่างประเทศ
 
แนวทางการพัฒนาเมืองอุตสาหกรรมเชิงนิเวศในพื้นที่ภาคกลางในช่วงแผนพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจแ...
แนวทางการพัฒนาเมืองอุตสาหกรรมเชิงนิเวศในพื้นที่ภาคกลางในช่วงแผนพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจแ...แนวทางการพัฒนาเมืองอุตสาหกรรมเชิงนิเวศในพื้นที่ภาคกลางในช่วงแผนพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจแ...
แนวทางการพัฒนาเมืองอุตสาหกรรมเชิงนิเวศในพื้นที่ภาคกลางในช่วงแผนพัฒนาเศรษฐกิจแ...
 
Sez
SezSez
Sez
 
การพัฒนาเมืองภายใต้นโยบายเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษ: ชุมชนชายแดนด่านสะเดา
การพัฒนาเมืองภายใต้นโยบายเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษ: ชุมชนชายแดนด่านสะเดาการพัฒนาเมืองภายใต้นโยบายเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษ: ชุมชนชายแดนด่านสะเดา
การพัฒนาเมืองภายใต้นโยบายเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษ: ชุมชนชายแดนด่านสะเดา
 
รูปแบบวิจัย 5 บท
รูปแบบวิจัย 5 บทรูปแบบวิจัย 5 บท
รูปแบบวิจัย 5 บท
 
SEZ in India
SEZ in IndiaSEZ in India
SEZ in India
 

Similar to Policy Analysis on Development of Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand (การวิเคราะห์นโยบายเกี่ยวกับการพัฒนาเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนใน

A Comparative Study of the National Strategic Plan of the Ministry of Commerc...
A Comparative Study of the National Strategic Plan of the Ministry of Commerc...A Comparative Study of the National Strategic Plan of the Ministry of Commerc...
A Comparative Study of the National Strategic Plan of the Ministry of Commerc...IJSRED
 
IJSRED-V2I5P49
IJSRED-V2I5P49IJSRED-V2I5P49
IJSRED-V2I5P49IJSRED
 
114_Ahmed_SEA_in_Planning_Process
114_Ahmed_SEA_in_Planning_Process114_Ahmed_SEA_in_Planning_Process
114_Ahmed_SEA_in_Planning_Processnaziazakir
 
MYANMAR DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE (MDI)
MYANMAR DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE (MDI)MYANMAR DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE (MDI)
MYANMAR DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE (MDI)MYO AUNG Myanmar
 
D572734.pdf
D572734.pdfD572734.pdf
D572734.pdfaijbm
 
Workshop on SDG Indicator 2.a.1, Turin, Italy, March 2018 - Challenges in com...
Workshop on SDG Indicator 2.a.1, Turin, Italy, March 2018 - Challenges in com...Workshop on SDG Indicator 2.a.1, Turin, Italy, March 2018 - Challenges in com...
Workshop on SDG Indicator 2.a.1, Turin, Italy, March 2018 - Challenges in com...FAO
 
Myanmar eiti annual activity report july 2015 ‐june 2016 meiti ( myanmar extr...
Myanmar eiti annual activity report july 2015 ‐june 2016 meiti ( myanmar extr...Myanmar eiti annual activity report july 2015 ‐june 2016 meiti ( myanmar extr...
Myanmar eiti annual activity report july 2015 ‐june 2016 meiti ( myanmar extr...MYO AUNG Myanmar
 
ASEAN Macroeconomic Trends_Malaysia Announces Budget Draft, Looks to Provide ...
ASEAN Macroeconomic Trends_Malaysia Announces Budget Draft, Looks to Provide ...ASEAN Macroeconomic Trends_Malaysia Announces Budget Draft, Looks to Provide ...
ASEAN Macroeconomic Trends_Malaysia Announces Budget Draft, Looks to Provide ...Kyna Tsai
 
Programme for Development of South-West Planning Region 2015-2019
Programme for Development of South-West Planning Region 2015-2019Programme for Development of South-West Planning Region 2015-2019
Programme for Development of South-West Planning Region 2015-2019Aleksandar Gumberovski
 
SOUTH EAST EUROPE 2020: JOBS AND PROSPERITY IN A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE
SOUTH EAST EUROPE 2020: JOBS AND PROSPERITY IN A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVESOUTH EAST EUROPE 2020: JOBS AND PROSPERITY IN A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE
SOUTH EAST EUROPE 2020: JOBS AND PROSPERITY IN A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVEAlbania Energy Association
 
Abstract for aseanwant_to_achieveitsgoal_of_asean_economic_community
Abstract for aseanwant_to_achieveitsgoal_of_asean_economic_communityAbstract for aseanwant_to_achieveitsgoal_of_asean_economic_community
Abstract for aseanwant_to_achieveitsgoal_of_asean_economic_communityRatha Chan
 
Abstract-ASEAN Want To Achieve Its Goal Of AEC 2015
Abstract-ASEAN Want To Achieve Its Goal Of AEC 2015Abstract-ASEAN Want To Achieve Its Goal Of AEC 2015
Abstract-ASEAN Want To Achieve Its Goal Of AEC 2015Ratha Chan
 
The role of the Mozambique and Southern Africa observatories in alleviating p...
The role of the Mozambique and Southern Africa observatories in alleviating p...The role of the Mozambique and Southern Africa observatories in alleviating p...
The role of the Mozambique and Southern Africa observatories in alleviating p...UNICEF Algérie
 
Donor board digest January-March 2018
Donor board digest January-March 2018Donor board digest January-March 2018
Donor board digest January-March 2018Decentralizationgovua
 

Similar to Policy Analysis on Development of Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand (การวิเคราะห์นโยบายเกี่ยวกับการพัฒนาเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนใน (20)

A Comparative Study of the National Strategic Plan of the Ministry of Commerc...
A Comparative Study of the National Strategic Plan of the Ministry of Commerc...A Comparative Study of the National Strategic Plan of the Ministry of Commerc...
A Comparative Study of the National Strategic Plan of the Ministry of Commerc...
 
IJSRED-V2I5P49
IJSRED-V2I5P49IJSRED-V2I5P49
IJSRED-V2I5P49
 
114_Ahmed_SEA_in_Planning_Process
114_Ahmed_SEA_in_Planning_Process114_Ahmed_SEA_in_Planning_Process
114_Ahmed_SEA_in_Planning_Process
 
MYANMAR DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE (MDI)
MYANMAR DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE (MDI)MYANMAR DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE (MDI)
MYANMAR DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE (MDI)
 
Thailand Investment Review, July 2015
Thailand Investment Review, July 2015Thailand Investment Review, July 2015
Thailand Investment Review, July 2015
 
Thailand's economic factsheet 2017
Thailand's economic factsheet 2017Thailand's economic factsheet 2017
Thailand's economic factsheet 2017
 
D572734.pdf
D572734.pdfD572734.pdf
D572734.pdf
 
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
 
Thailand Investment Review, May 2015
Thailand Investment Review, May 2015Thailand Investment Review, May 2015
Thailand Investment Review, May 2015
 
Workshop on SDG Indicator 2.a.1, Turin, Italy, March 2018 - Challenges in com...
Workshop on SDG Indicator 2.a.1, Turin, Italy, March 2018 - Challenges in com...Workshop on SDG Indicator 2.a.1, Turin, Italy, March 2018 - Challenges in com...
Workshop on SDG Indicator 2.a.1, Turin, Italy, March 2018 - Challenges in com...
 
Myanmar eiti annual activity report july 2015 ‐june 2016 meiti ( myanmar extr...
Myanmar eiti annual activity report july 2015 ‐june 2016 meiti ( myanmar extr...Myanmar eiti annual activity report july 2015 ‐june 2016 meiti ( myanmar extr...
Myanmar eiti annual activity report july 2015 ‐june 2016 meiti ( myanmar extr...
 
ASEAN Macroeconomic Trends_Malaysia Announces Budget Draft, Looks to Provide ...
ASEAN Macroeconomic Trends_Malaysia Announces Budget Draft, Looks to Provide ...ASEAN Macroeconomic Trends_Malaysia Announces Budget Draft, Looks to Provide ...
ASEAN Macroeconomic Trends_Malaysia Announces Budget Draft, Looks to Provide ...
 
Programme for Development of South-West Planning Region 2015-2019
Programme for Development of South-West Planning Region 2015-2019Programme for Development of South-West Planning Region 2015-2019
Programme for Development of South-West Planning Region 2015-2019
 
MTBiz July 2017
MTBiz July 2017 MTBiz July 2017
MTBiz July 2017
 
Thailand Investment Review, January 2015
Thailand Investment Review, January 2015Thailand Investment Review, January 2015
Thailand Investment Review, January 2015
 
SOUTH EAST EUROPE 2020: JOBS AND PROSPERITY IN A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE
SOUTH EAST EUROPE 2020: JOBS AND PROSPERITY IN A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVESOUTH EAST EUROPE 2020: JOBS AND PROSPERITY IN A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE
SOUTH EAST EUROPE 2020: JOBS AND PROSPERITY IN A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE
 
Abstract for aseanwant_to_achieveitsgoal_of_asean_economic_community
Abstract for aseanwant_to_achieveitsgoal_of_asean_economic_communityAbstract for aseanwant_to_achieveitsgoal_of_asean_economic_community
Abstract for aseanwant_to_achieveitsgoal_of_asean_economic_community
 
Abstract-ASEAN Want To Achieve Its Goal Of AEC 2015
Abstract-ASEAN Want To Achieve Its Goal Of AEC 2015Abstract-ASEAN Want To Achieve Its Goal Of AEC 2015
Abstract-ASEAN Want To Achieve Its Goal Of AEC 2015
 
The role of the Mozambique and Southern Africa observatories in alleviating p...
The role of the Mozambique and Southern Africa observatories in alleviating p...The role of the Mozambique and Southern Africa observatories in alleviating p...
The role of the Mozambique and Southern Africa observatories in alleviating p...
 
Donor board digest January-March 2018
Donor board digest January-March 2018Donor board digest January-March 2018
Donor board digest January-March 2018
 

More from Dr.Choen Krainara

Certificate of Completion in Cyber Risk Supervision
Certificate of Completion in Cyber Risk SupervisionCertificate of Completion in Cyber Risk Supervision
Certificate of Completion in Cyber Risk SupervisionDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Becoming an Effective Leader
Certificate of Completion in Becoming an Effective LeaderCertificate of Completion in Becoming an Effective Leader
Certificate of Completion in Becoming an Effective LeaderDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Project Management
Certificate of Completion in Project ManagementCertificate of Completion in Project Management
Certificate of Completion in Project ManagementDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Project Management Leadership
Certificate of Completion in Project Management LeadershipCertificate of Completion in Project Management Leadership
Certificate of Completion in Project Management LeadershipDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Risk Management
Certificate of Completion in Risk ManagementCertificate of Completion in Risk Management
Certificate of Completion in Risk ManagementDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Child Protection in Conflict Settings
Certificate of Completion in Child Protection in Conflict SettingsCertificate of Completion in Child Protection in Conflict Settings
Certificate of Completion in Child Protection in Conflict SettingsDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Operations Programme (HOP) Fundamen...
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Operations Programme (HOP) Fundamen...Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Operations Programme (HOP) Fundamen...
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Operations Programme (HOP) Fundamen...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Information Management, Communicati...
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Information Management, Communicati...Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Information Management, Communicati...
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Information Management, Communicati...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Finance and Budgets in Emergencies
Certificate of Completion in Finance and Budgets in EmergenciesCertificate of Completion in Finance and Budgets in Emergencies
Certificate of Completion in Finance and Budgets in EmergenciesDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Introduction to Human Resource Management in Hum...
Certificate of Completion in Introduction to Human Resource Management in Hum...Certificate of Completion in Introduction to Human Resource Management in Hum...
Certificate of Completion in Introduction to Human Resource Management in Hum...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in IRC Personal Safety and Security
Certificate of Completion in IRC Personal Safety and SecurityCertificate of Completion in IRC Personal Safety and Security
Certificate of Completion in IRC Personal Safety and SecurityDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Wellness and Resilience for Frontline Workers an...
Certificate of Completion in Wellness and Resilience for Frontline Workers an...Certificate of Completion in Wellness and Resilience for Frontline Workers an...
Certificate of Completion in Wellness and Resilience for Frontline Workers an...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Finanancial ...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Finanancial ...Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Finanancial ...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Finanancial ...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Green Public...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Green Public...Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Green Public...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Green Public...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Mitigation S...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Mitigation S...Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Mitigation S...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Mitigation S...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change: Science, Econo...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change: Science, Econo...Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change: Science, Econo...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change: Science, Econo...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Environment in Humanitarian Action
Certificate of Completion in Environment in Humanitarian ActionCertificate of Completion in Environment in Humanitarian Action
Certificate of Completion in Environment in Humanitarian ActionDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Working in Partnerships
Certificate of Completion in Working in PartnershipsCertificate of Completion in Working in Partnerships
Certificate of Completion in Working in PartnershipsDr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Basic Principles of Disability Inclusion in Huma...
Certificate of Completion in Basic Principles of Disability Inclusion in Huma...Certificate of Completion in Basic Principles of Disability Inclusion in Huma...
Certificate of Completion in Basic Principles of Disability Inclusion in Huma...Dr.Choen Krainara
 
Certificate of Completion in Safeguarding Essentials
Certificate of Completion in Safeguarding EssentialsCertificate of Completion in Safeguarding Essentials
Certificate of Completion in Safeguarding EssentialsDr.Choen Krainara
 

More from Dr.Choen Krainara (20)

Certificate of Completion in Cyber Risk Supervision
Certificate of Completion in Cyber Risk SupervisionCertificate of Completion in Cyber Risk Supervision
Certificate of Completion in Cyber Risk Supervision
 
Certificate of Completion in Becoming an Effective Leader
Certificate of Completion in Becoming an Effective LeaderCertificate of Completion in Becoming an Effective Leader
Certificate of Completion in Becoming an Effective Leader
 
Certificate of Completion in Project Management
Certificate of Completion in Project ManagementCertificate of Completion in Project Management
Certificate of Completion in Project Management
 
Certificate of Completion in Project Management Leadership
Certificate of Completion in Project Management LeadershipCertificate of Completion in Project Management Leadership
Certificate of Completion in Project Management Leadership
 
Certificate of Completion in Risk Management
Certificate of Completion in Risk ManagementCertificate of Completion in Risk Management
Certificate of Completion in Risk Management
 
Certificate of Completion in Child Protection in Conflict Settings
Certificate of Completion in Child Protection in Conflict SettingsCertificate of Completion in Child Protection in Conflict Settings
Certificate of Completion in Child Protection in Conflict Settings
 
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Operations Programme (HOP) Fundamen...
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Operations Programme (HOP) Fundamen...Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Operations Programme (HOP) Fundamen...
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Operations Programme (HOP) Fundamen...
 
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Information Management, Communicati...
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Information Management, Communicati...Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Information Management, Communicati...
Certificate of Completion in Humanitarian Information Management, Communicati...
 
Certificate of Completion in Finance and Budgets in Emergencies
Certificate of Completion in Finance and Budgets in EmergenciesCertificate of Completion in Finance and Budgets in Emergencies
Certificate of Completion in Finance and Budgets in Emergencies
 
Certificate of Completion in Introduction to Human Resource Management in Hum...
Certificate of Completion in Introduction to Human Resource Management in Hum...Certificate of Completion in Introduction to Human Resource Management in Hum...
Certificate of Completion in Introduction to Human Resource Management in Hum...
 
Certificate of Completion in IRC Personal Safety and Security
Certificate of Completion in IRC Personal Safety and SecurityCertificate of Completion in IRC Personal Safety and Security
Certificate of Completion in IRC Personal Safety and Security
 
Certificate of Completion in Wellness and Resilience for Frontline Workers an...
Certificate of Completion in Wellness and Resilience for Frontline Workers an...Certificate of Completion in Wellness and Resilience for Frontline Workers an...
Certificate of Completion in Wellness and Resilience for Frontline Workers an...
 
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Finanancial ...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Finanancial ...Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Finanancial ...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Finanancial ...
 
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Green Public...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Green Public...Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Green Public...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Green Public...
 
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Mitigation S...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Mitigation S...Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Mitigation S...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change on Mitigation S...
 
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change: Science, Econo...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change: Science, Econo...Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change: Science, Econo...
Certificate of Completion in Macroeconomics of Climate Change: Science, Econo...
 
Certificate of Completion in Environment in Humanitarian Action
Certificate of Completion in Environment in Humanitarian ActionCertificate of Completion in Environment in Humanitarian Action
Certificate of Completion in Environment in Humanitarian Action
 
Certificate of Completion in Working in Partnerships
Certificate of Completion in Working in PartnershipsCertificate of Completion in Working in Partnerships
Certificate of Completion in Working in Partnerships
 
Certificate of Completion in Basic Principles of Disability Inclusion in Huma...
Certificate of Completion in Basic Principles of Disability Inclusion in Huma...Certificate of Completion in Basic Principles of Disability Inclusion in Huma...
Certificate of Completion in Basic Principles of Disability Inclusion in Huma...
 
Certificate of Completion in Safeguarding Essentials
Certificate of Completion in Safeguarding EssentialsCertificate of Completion in Safeguarding Essentials
Certificate of Completion in Safeguarding Essentials
 

Recently uploaded

20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdfAdnet Communications
 
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...ssifa0344
 
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxOAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxhiddenlevers
 
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptxDividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptxanshikagoel52
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfGale Pooley
 
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingQuarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingMaristelaRamos12
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...ssifa0344
 
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdfFinTech Belgium
 
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School DesignsInstant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School Designsegoetzinger
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escortsranjana rawat
 
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesQ3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesMarketing847413
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfGale Pooley
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
(ANIKA) Budhwar Peth Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANIKA) Budhwar Peth Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(ANIKA) Budhwar Peth Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANIKA) Budhwar Peth Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...ranjana rawat
 
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...Suhani Kapoor
 

Recently uploaded (20)

20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
 
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
TEST BANK For Corporate Finance, 13th Edition By Stephen Ross, Randolph Weste...
 
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxOAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
 
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptxDividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
 
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingQuarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
 
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
 
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
03_Emmanuel Ndiaye_Degroof Petercam.pptx
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School DesignsInstant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesQ3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - April 2024
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - April 2024Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - April 2024
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - April 2024
 
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
02_Fabio Colombo_Accenture_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
 
(ANIKA) Budhwar Peth Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANIKA) Budhwar Peth Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(ANIKA) Budhwar Peth Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(ANIKA) Budhwar Peth Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
 
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
 

Policy Analysis on Development of Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand (การวิเคราะห์นโยบายเกี่ยวกับการพัฒนาเขตเศรษฐกิจพิเศษชายแดนใน

  • 1. 1 Policy Analysis on Development of Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand By Choen Krainara Policy and Plan Analyst, Professional Level Central Economic and Social Development Office Office of the National Economic and Social Development Board (NESDB) and Ph.D. Candidate Regional and Rural Development Planning Field of Study School of Environment, Resources and Development Asian Institute of Technology Thailand 2 March 2016 To cite this article: Choen Krainara.2016. Policy Analysis on Development of Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand in Doctoral Dissertation entitled “Border Economic Zones and Development Dynamics in Thailand: A Comparative Study of Bordering Countries (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Myanmar)”, Phathumtani: Asian Institute of Technology.
  • 2. 2 Chapter 4 Policy Analysis: Development of Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand This chapter presents policy analysis in Thailand conducive to development of special border economic zones. It includes evolution and analysis of current special border economic zone development policies. It seeks to understand why and how the policy is developed at a particular time and the intended effects of those policies. 4.1 Evolution of Special Border Economic Zone Development Policies in Thailand Thailand adopts 5-year national development plan to guide development paths. Over 54 years of national development planning, spatial development policies are continually evolving in line with national and sectoral development progress, which can be classified into 4 distinct periods. Each period characterized by specific spatial development advancement. The first period (1961-1966) focused on developing key infrastructure projects as backbone for national development, as well as, attracting private investments. The second period (1967-1981) emphasized on promoting regional and rural development including creating jobs and income distribution to peripheral regions. The third period (1982-2001) adopted Area Approach planning for identifying development programs and projects by promoting regional development, which concentrated on fostering regional growth centers and the Eastern Seaboard Development Program. It also focused on urban, rural and specific areas development. While the fourth period (2002-2015) recently shifted towards upholding rural-urban relations and development of special border economic zones (SBEZs) along the Greater Mekong Economic Corridors in order to grasp potential of proliferating regional cooperation and integration programs particularly for the Ayeyawady-Chao Phraya-Mekong Economic Cooperation Strategy (ACMECS), the Greater Mekong Sub-region Economic Cooperation Program and the ASEAN Economic Community as integral part of the ASEAN Community. To materialize the concept of SBEZ, its ultimate goals were not only to reduce both inter- regional and intra-regional disparities, but also to create production bases along border areas, as well as coping border labor shortage. It also aims to minimize impacts of continuing influx of illegal immigrant labor and low quality agricultural produce from neighboring countries into Thailand. Yet, progress has been gradually made due to this concept is truly new for Thailand. As a result, different efforts have been made in various governments. Chronologically, the Thaksin Administration initially announced to promote first SBEZs in both Chiang Rai and Tak provinces since 2003. However, it encountered severe resistance from both local authorities and general public, who were aware of being profoundly displaced their local administration function by new local authorities under the proposed special border economic zone law. This subsequently generated wide criticism on pros and cons of the SBEZ within Thai society. Coupled with political discontinuity, the initiative to implement these two pilot SBEZs were consequently sluggish for almost 8 years. As Thailand approached full entry into the ASEAN Community by the end of 2015, the Abhisit Administration reapproved on October 19, 2010 to develop Maesod district in Tak province as a pilot special border economic zone. On March 22, 2011, a total budget of 14.04 million Baht was then allocated to carry out a research for formulating development plan of Maesod Special Border Economic Zone. In 2013, the Yingluck Administration
  • 3. 3 renewed support the scheme by setting up a mechanism so called Special Border Economic Zone Development Policy Board. Subsequently, a strategic plan for promoting special border economic zones was formulated in 2014 covering 5 cross-border regions across the country. This consisted of 1) Northern border region comprised Maesai, Chaingsaen and Chaingkhong districts in Chiang Rai province. 2) Northeastern border region consisted of Mukdahan, Nakhon Phanom and Nongkhai provinces. 3) Eastern border region represented Sakaeo and Trat provinces. 4) Western border region comprised Kanchanaburi province. And 5) Southern border region included Sadao district of Song Khla province and Narathiwat province. Presently, the Prayuth Administration promptly carried on hastening the implementation process of these SBEZs. There are several direct and indirect policies that influenced the special border economic zones development in Thailand. The concise integrated policies are presented in Table 4.1.The detailed discussions are described in the following paragraphs.
  • 4. 4 Table 4.1 Brief Integrated Development Policies for Special Border Economic Zones in Thailand Major Policies Major features Execution of Policies (Translated into action) Impacts/Implications for Thailand vis-à-vis neighboring countries Direct Policies (Explicit Policies) Policy 1:Special Border Economic Zone Development Policy It serves as core national policy in driving SBEZ development. At present, the Prayuth Administration is keenly expediting implementation of 10 SBEZs across Thailand dividing into 2 phases. On January 15, 2015, the Prayuth Government approved 5 pilot SBEZs urging to realize early tangible progress by the end of 2015. Totally, it covers a combined of 36 sub- districts or 10 districts in 5 border provinces with total land area of 2,932 Km2 . Recently, the Royal Thai Government has approved the second phase of SBEZs since March 16, 2015, covering 5 provinces in a combined of 16 districts or 63 sub-districts. A mechanism to run the SBEZs has been set up by assigning 4 mains organizations to oversee implementation process comprising Office of the National Economic and Social Development Board (NESDB) Office of Board of Investment (BOI), Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Interior. Then, the NESDB in cooperation with the BOI and related agencies were tasked to coordinate in designing detailed investment targets in the pilots SBEZs. Therefore, four different sub-committees were formed at national level. These are (1) Sub- Committee on Identifying Physical Boundary of SBEZs. (2) Sub-Committee on Designing Investment Incentives, Boundary and One Stop Service Center. (3) Sub-Committee on Infrastructure and Customs House. (4) Sub-Committee on One Stop Service on Labor, Public Health and National Security. An Act on Development of Special Economic Zones is being drafted and will take effect by 2016. Fast progress for defining priority development locations and setting up of supportive mechanism for implementing the targeted special border economic zones.
  • 5. 5 Major Policies Major features Execution of Policies (Translated into action) Impacts/Implications for Thailand vis-à-vis neighboring countries Policy2:International Trade and Cross- Border Trade Policies Policy 3: Customs Facilitation Policy Policy 4: Border Investment and Industrial Development Policies The Royal Thai Government persistently reaffirms policies to expand regional cooperation particularly on trade at different levels. Thailand has already signed an Agreement to Establish and Implement the ASEAN Single Window since 2005 in order to facilitate greater flow of international trade between ASEAN member countries. Within this agreement, ASEAN member countries concurred to implement the ASEAN Single Window Pilot Project consisting of linkages of Certificate of Origin under ASEAN Trade in Goods Agreement (ATIGA Form D) and ASEAN Customs Declaration Document (ACDD). It aims to attract greater investments into these border regions at 20 %, as well as, being a part of preparation plan for entry into ASEAN Economic Community by the end of 2015. The specific international trade policies at different levels have been formulated. These are at ASEAN level; GMS level and Bilateral level. The Royal Thai Customs Department has fully executed e-Customs through the National Single Window (NSW) since 2008. As of September 15, 2014, it can be electronically linked data on licenses and certificates via the NSW with a total of 21 relevant organizations. The Royal Thai Customs Department has likewise collaborated with licensing and certifying organizations to set up database on commodity codes that required to apply for licenses and certificates, and can be accessible online. Attractive investment incentives have been already put in place, which can be classified into 2 slightly different types. These are general and specific target industries. The specific target productions in the pilot SBEZs consisted of 13 industries covering 61 business activities. Each pilot SBEZ may have specialization in specific industry based on resource endowments and complementarity with adjacent SBEZs in neighboring countries. Clear policies on international trade and cross-border trade helped increase regional and cross-border trade flows. Customs facilitation through establishment of National Single Window helped increase intensity of cross-border-trade flows. Investment incentives have still not attracted enough interests of both local and foreign direct investments. As a result, some investors are reluctant to invest in the targeted special border economic zones.
  • 6. 6 Major Policies Major features Execution of Policies (Translated into action) Impacts/Implications for Thailand vis-à-vis neighboring countries Policy 5: National and Cross-Border Transport and Logistics Policies Policy 6: Labor, Public Health and National Security Policies Provides national railways linking between Bangkok and regional growth centers and border provinces in order to connect with neighboring countries. It also aims to promote cross-border land transport networks and efficient logistics systems. Permits daily movement of immigrant labor from neighboring countries into pilot SBEZs while also talking care their labor right. Skill development should be provided to both Thai national residing along border and immigrant labor. Immediate national security concern should be prioritized and managed to support cross-border development cooperation via SBEZ. As an alternative to the BOI’s tax breaks, new investors could also choose incentives granted by the Ministry of Finance under “Thailand Plus One” scheme, which would allow a reduction of corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years. Additional national railways linking Bangkok with key border provinces are being planned. Furthermore, improves cross-border transport networks e.g. international highways, Mekong river bridges and river ports and logistics systems linking with neighboring countries. This can facilitate transportation services, as well as reducing logistics costs. Daily movement of immigrant labor within specified SBEZs is legally permitted. One Stop Service for Immigrant Labor is to be set up at the pilot SBEZs. Much progress is underway. It is likely to facilitate greater cross- border flows of goods, people and vehicles. Implementation for permitting daily movement of immigrant labor is still slow. There is existed of certain restriction on cross-border movement practice of immigrant labor.
  • 7. 7 Major Policies Major features Execution of Policies (Translated into action) Impacts/Implications for Thailand vis-à-vis neighboring countries Indirect Policies (Implicit Policies) Policy 1: Tourism and Visa Policies Policy 2: International Relations, Regional Cooperation and Official Development Assistance Policies Promoting Thailand as a gateway to Asia. Fosters closer both bilateral relations and regional integration with neighboring countries. Various forms of Official Development Assistance should be provided to neighboring countries in support of SBEZs cooperation. Thailand implemented regional tourism cooperation schemes under GMS and ACMECS. ACMECS single visa is an important instrument in facilitating greater people mobility between Thailand and bordering countries. As a result, implementation of a pilot ACMECS single visa between Thailand and Cambodia was made effective since December 16, 2010. Thailand continuously fosters closer bilateral relations with neighboring countries. It is implemented in the form of cooperation at all levels ranging from public, private, people and media sectors. Also, official development assistances from Thailand towards neighboring countries. The initiative helped facilitate greater cross-border movement of both people and vehicles. Continuing regional integration and official development assistances from Thailand to bordering countries helped bridge intra-GMS sub-region development disparities.
  • 8. 8 4.2 Detailed Policy Analysis for Upholding Development of Special Border Economic Zones SBEZ policies in Thailand are currently advancing towards rapid implementation of pilot locations. The Prayuth Government has firmly committed in formulating integrated policies, as well as, accelerating the implementation process. As a result, analysis of actual integrated policies for upholding special border economic zone development is undertaken employing qualitative analyses. It can be broadly categorized into 2 major groups of policies, which are direct and indirect policies as follows: 4.2.1 Direct Policies or Explicit Policies intend to directly lay down strong foundation for progressing development of pilot SBEZs. Features and progresses of these integrated policies are as follows: 1) Special Border Economic Zone Development Policies It served as core national policy in driving SBEZ development. At present, the Prayuth Administration is keenly expediting implementation of 10 SBEZs across Thailand dividing into 2 phases. It aims at attracting greater investments into these border regions at 20 %, as well as, being a part of preparation plan for entry into ASEAN Community by the end of 2015. Therefore, on January 19, 2015, the Prayuth Government approved 5 designated pilot SBEZs along with major infrastructure development plan and associated private investment incentives. The Royal Thai Government guided to realize early tangible progress by the end of 2015. Totally, it covers 5 border provinces in 10 districts or 36 sub-districts with a total land area of 2,932 Km2 . This consisted of: (1) Tak Special Border Economic Zone covers Maesod, Pobpra and Maeramad districts of Tak province with total land area of 1,419 Km2 ; (2) Mukdahan Special Border Economic Zone comprises Muang Mukdahan, Wanyai and Dontan districts in Mukdahan province with total land area of 578.50 Km2 ; (3) Sakaeo Special Border Economic Zone encompasses Aranyaprathet and Wattananakhon districts in Sakaeo province with total land area of 332 Km2 ; (4) Trat Special Border Economic Zone covers Klong Yai district in Trat province with total land area of 50.20 Km2 ; and (5) Songkhla Special Border Economic Zone includes Sadao district in Songkhla province with total land area of 552.30 Km2 . Recently, the Royal Thai Government has approved the second phase of SBEZs on March 16, 2015, covering 5 provinces in 16 districts or 63 sub-districts. These are: (1) Nongkhai Special Border Economic Zone encompasses 5 districts or a combined of 22 sub-districts namely Muang Nongkhai; Srakrai; Ponpisai; Thabor and Srichiangmai districts of Nongkhai province with a total land area of 144.78 Km2 ; (2) Nakhon Panom Special Border Economic Zone includes 2 districts or a combined of 13 sub-districts, namely Muang Nakhon Panom and Tha-Uthain districts of Nakhon Panom province; (3) Chiang Rai Special Border Economic Zone involves 3 districts or a combined of 21 sub-districts namely Maesai; Chiangsaen and Chiang Khong districts of Chiang Rai province; (4) Kanchanaburi Special Border Economic Zone covers Muang Kanchanaburi District with a combined of 2 sub-districts of Kanchanaburi province with a total land area of 260.78 Km2 ; and (5) Narathiwat Special Border Economic Zone comprises 5 districts or a combined of 5 sub-districts, namely Sungai Kolok, Takbai, Wang, Yi-Ngo and Muang Narathiwat districts of Narathiwat province with a total land area of 209 Km2 .
  • 9. 9 The Royal Thai Government also set up a mechanism to run the SBEZs by assigning 4 mains organizations to oversee implementation process comprising Office of the National Economic and Social Development Board as a secretariat office of the National Special Border Economic Zone Development Policy Board, Office of Board of Investment, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Interior. Then, Office of the National Economic and Social Development Board in cooperation with Office of Board of Investment and related agencies were tasked to coordinate in designing detailed investment targets in the pilots SBEZs so that prospective investors can propose investment projects as soon as possible. Therefore, four different sub-committees were formed at national level. These are: 1) Sub-Committee on Identifying Physical Boundary of Special Border Economic Zones chaired by Ministry of Interior. Its task was to consider target provincial proposals for establishing as SBEZs along with public land acquisition for further private lease. This is to solve problem on increasing land price arising from widespread local land speculation; 2) Sub-Committee on Investment Incentives, Boundary and One Stop Service Center on Investment chaired by Permanent Secretary of Finance together with Office of Board of Investment, Office of Council of State, National Security Council, Department of Forestry, Office of SMEs Promotion and concerned provinces, local organizations and private sector; 3) Sub-Committee on Infrastructure and Customs House comprised 6 organizations namely Ministry of Transport (Department of Highways, Department of Aviation and Marine Department) Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives, Department of Customs, Office of Thailand Immigration and Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand; 4) Sub-Committee on One Stop Service on Labor, Public Health and National Security consisted of 10 organizations namely Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Public Health, Department of Employment, Department of Skill Development, Office of Thailand Immigration, Office of Social Security, Commission of Vocational Education, Industrial Federation of Thailand and Thai Chamber of Commerce. To help facilitate rapid implementation of the 5 pilot SBEZs at provincial level, it is being studied to set up a Special Border Economic Zone Administration Sub-Committee in each pilot location. Moreover, the Royal Thai Government approved an infrastructure and customs house development plan of the pilot SBEZs during the year 2015-2020 amounted 98,571 million Baht with total 185 projects for specific undertakings as follows:  Tak SBEZ to be constructed the second Moei river bridge; Tak-Mae Sod Highway; improvement of Mae Sod airport; new customs house and immigration offices; Mae Sod industrial estate and Huei Mae Sod reservoir, etc.;  Mukdahan SBEZ to be built provincial highway; border logistics center; residential area of customs officials; Mukdahan Industrial Estate and pumping station utilizing electricity, etc;  Trat SBEZ to be developed Klongyai Port; border logistics center; customs house and Trad industrial estate, etc;  Sakaeo SBEZ to be constructed new customs house and Aranyaprathet industrial estate, etc;  Songkhla SBEZ to be built border logistics center; Songkhla Deep Seaport 2;
  • 10. 10 double railway track for Padang Besar-Hat Yai route; new Sadao customs house; Songkhla industrial estate, etc.; and  Nongkhai SBEZ to be constructed new highway Nongkhai-Ponpisai route; new customs house and Ponswang industrial estate, etc. An Act on Development of Special Economic Zones is being drafted and will take effect by 2016.Relating to urban development in the pilot SBEZs, principle city plans and design of specific border town plans along with physical zoning and provision of public utilities are being revised in response to the changing development potential and policies. It has been physically planned at 3 different levels as follows:  Creates provincial physical planning for border gateways linking with ASEAN Community. It will identify potential development areas and then prepare these areas for playing as both strategic trade gateways and SBEZs. It will also be formulated integrated development programs for promoting both urban development and special border economic zones;  Develops both principle provincial, urban and community plans in order to guide land use, transport and infrastructure development, which will be associated with regulations to be corresponding with prospective SBEZs and integrated urban development;  Designs specific plans of special border economic zones including detailed design of urban architecture and zoning. It will likewise lay out public utilities system to be corresponding with principle urban plan system comprising industrial zone, agricultural warehouse, cross-border trade and new residential areas. To counter prevalent local land speculation, on May 15, 2015, the Royal Thai Government has expropriated degraded forest and public land in the designated SBEZs to rent out to private investors in order to promote rapid starting up of industries and businesses. 2) International Trade and Cross-Border Trade Policies Cross-border trade between Thailand and CLM has been periodically affected adversely by political and diplomatic problems during periods of political differences (TDRI 1997). After the end of cold war, Thailand has proclaimed a policy of turning “Indochina battlefields into a marketplace” since 1988 in order to foster closer economic interdependence (Chandoevwit et al., 2005). The Royal Thai Government persistently reaffirms policies to expand regional cooperation particularly on trade at three different levels as follows (Thai Government Statements 2008; 2009): (1) ASEAN Level is a vital trading bloc for Thailand placing significant emphasis on utilizing full advantage of AFTA through “ASEAN Hub” policy so as to sustain trading and investment base particular in CLMV. It is implemented by means of establishment of Thailand’s distribution centers and trading firms in CLMV. (2) Greater Mekong Sub-region Level is very meaningful due to geopolitics of Thailand as a strategic crossroad of the GMS. As a result, Thailand has focused on fostering greater flows in order to increase volume and value of cross-border trade, as well as, facilitating both intra and extra-GMS trade, investment and tourism through the implementation of CBTA. Launches regional production networks by relocating specific investments to neighboring countries. Keenly negotiates transit trade regime with neighboring countries e.g. China, Lao PDR, Myanmar and Vietnam in order to facilitate free flow of goods to nearby neighboring countries markets either in South East Asian, South Asian, or East Asian regions. (3) Bilateral Level with Particular Emphasis on Cross-Border Trade Policy
  • 11. 11 Thailand places emphasis on common bilateral cross-border trade policies towards neighboring countries particularly on trade facilitation along major economic corridors. It correspondingly aims to improve facilities at key border checkpoints to meet international standards. The Ministry of Commerce has set the targeted value for both cross-border trade and transit trade to reach 1.50 trillion Baht or 48,387 million US$ by the year 2015.This plan has been implemented through 4 strategies namely 1) development of competitiveness of Thailand for enhancing trade value; 2) building capacity of personnel responsible for cross- border trade; 3) promoting outward investment in neighboring countries; and 4) urgent problem solving and utilization of regional trade agreements. Furthermore, local border cooperatives are collectively strengthened to actively participate in cross-border trade of agricultural produce aiming to help minimize the impact of illegal influx of low quality agricultural produce from bordering countries into Thailand. 3) Customs Facilitation Policy Thailand has already signed an Agreement to Establish and Implement the ASEAN Single Window since 2005 in order to facilitate greater flow of international trade between ASEAN member countries. Within this agreement, ASEAN member countries concurred to implement the ASEAN Single Window Pilot Project consisting of linkages of Certificate of Origin under ASEAN Trade in Goods Agreement (ATIGA Form D) and ASEAN Customs Declaration Document (ACDD). In line with this agreement, the Royal Thai Customs Department has fully executed e-Customs through the National Single Window (NSW) since 2008. As of September 15, 2014, it can be electronically linked data on licenses and certificates via the NSW with a total of 21 relevant organizations. The Royal Thai Customs Department has likewise collaborated with licensing and certifying organizations to set up database on commodity codes that required to apply for licenses and certificates, and can be accessible online. 4) Investment and Industrial Development Policies Pertaining to investment policy, the Board of Investment (BOI) recently revealed the Seven- Year Investment Promotion Strategies (2015-2021) built on both activities and merit-based incentives. It also included investment promotion policy particularly for investment in special border economic zones, which is equivalent to maximum incentives provided to the southern border provinces. Applications must be submitted from January 1, 2015 to December 31, 2017. Detailed investment promotion can be classified into 2 slightly different types of incentives as follows: (1) General Industries In case general activities are eligible for investment promotion, projects shall receive the following incentives:  3 additional years of corporate income tax (CIT) exemption;  In case where projects are already granted an 8-year corporate income tax exemption, an additional 5-year 50 % CIT exemption shall be grated instead;  Double deductions from the costs of transportation, electricity and water supply;  Additional 25 % deduction of the cost of installation or construction of facilities;  Exemption of import duty for machinery;  Exemption of import duty on raw materials and necessary components to be produced for exports for 5 years;  Other non-tax incentives; and  Permission for employing unskilled immigrant labor.
  • 12. 12 (2) Specific Target Industries In case of specific target activities for SBEZs as specified by the Special Border Economic Zone Development Policy Board, projects shall receive the following incentives:  8-year corporate income tax exemption and an additional 5-year 50 % reduction of corporate income tax.  Double tax deductions from the costs of transportation, electricity and water supply for 30 years;  Additional 25 % tax deduction for the cost of installation or construction of facilities in addition to normal depreciation costs;  Exemption of import duty for machinery;  A 5-year exemption of import duty for raw materials and necessary components to be produced for exports;  Other non-tax incentives; and  Permission for employing unskilled immigrant labor. The BOI has also allowed promoted projects in the pilot SBEZ to use machinery older than 5 years but not exceeding 10 years. On general case, imported used machinery must not exceed 10 years. In case when a production base is relocated into Thailand, machinery over 10 years old will be allowed to be used in the project. In both cases, no offer of import duty exemption on machinery will be made and the project will be required to submit a performance certificate issued by a trusted institute identifying the efficiency of the machinery, its environmental impact, safety standard and energy usage, as well as its maintenance profile and its fair value must be obtained. As an alternative to the BOI’s tax breaks, new investors could also choose incentives granted by the Ministry of Finance under “Thailand Plus One” scheme, which would allow a reduction in corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years. “Thailand Plus One” would supplement SBEZs investment projects. So, Thailand could forge greater relations with neighboring countries. This means any ASEAN investor can invest in the SBEZs to receive privileges from Thailand plus border countries such as Myanmar, Lao PDR, Cambodia and Malaysia. Thailand Plus One is a strategic business model initiated by Japan’s corporations in 2012 to encourage investors to maintain their main operations in Thailand while diversifying supporting productions in the supply chain to neighboring countries in order to gain benefits from comparative advantages and regional production networks. Maesod and Aranyaprathet SBEZs are pioneer areas in Thailand in fostering linkages with Myanmar and Cambodia. Furthermore, a One Stop Service Center for Investment is to be set up in pilot provincial halls. Concerning new local investors who did not hold BOI approval, they will not only entitle for a reduction of corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years but also to gain an access to soft loan at maximum credit limit of 20 million Baht provided by the Government Saving Banks and warranted by Thai Credit Guarantee Corporation. This will play important role for fast track implementation of SBEZs plan. In addition, the Department of Customs has additionally provided investment incentives for establishment in both free zone and bonded warehouse as follows:  Exemption of import tax for machinery;  Exemption of import tax for raw materials to be manufactured for export;  Exemption of export tax;  Exemption of disposal tax for materials;
  • 13. 13  Exemption of value-added tax for raw materials to be manufactured for export;  Exemption of value-added tax for import and export commodities; and  Non-time limit for storage of goods in free zone. Whereas, it is allowed for storage of goods for maximum 2 years in bonded warehouse. In relation to prospective industries in the pilot SBEZs, the Board of Investment prioritized specific target productions consisting of 13 major industries covering 61 business activities as follows:  Agro-industry, fishery and related businesses;  Ceramics product manufacturing;  Textile, clothing and leather manufacturing;  Furniture manufacturing;  Gems and jewelry manufacturing;  Medical devices manufacturing;  Automotive, machinery and parts manufacturing;  Electronics and electrical appliances manufacturing;  Plastics manufacturing;  Pharmaceuticals manufacturing;  Logistics businesses;  Industrial zones or industrial estates; and  Businesses that support tourism. Regarding specific target industry in the 5 pilot SBEZs, the Board of Investment has announced illegible industries and businesses as follows:  Tak Special Border Economic Zone consists of agroindustry, textile and apparel, wood and wood furniture and gems and jewelry. It will link with Myawaddy Border Economic Zone in Kayin State of Myanmar;  Mukdahan Special Border Economic Zone comprises electronics, warehouse, wholesale, logistics and tourism. It will connect with Savan Seno Special Border Economic Zone in Savannakhet province of Lao PDR;  Sakaeo Special Border Economic Zone entails retail and wholesale, agro-processed industry, warehouse and logistics. It will link with Poipet Oneang Special Border Economic Zone in Bantay Meanchey province of Cambodia;  Trat Special Border Economic Zone involves eco-tourism, duty free cross-border trade, multimodal transport, warehouse and logistics. It will connect with Koh Kong Special Economic Zone in Koh Kong province of Cambodia; and  Songkhla Special Border Economic Zone consists of extended area of an industrial estate for export, natural rubber processed industry, sea food and halal food. It will cooperate with heavy industrial zone, rubber and halal industry in bordering Kedah state of Malaysia. So far, a number of Bangkok-based conglomerates expressed keen interest to invest in in a particular SBEZ. For instance in Tak SBEZ, Charoen Pokpand (CP) Group may make investment on logistics and real estate; while Central Pattana Group may invest in a department store. Sahaphat Group may invest in high-end apparel. Thai Beverage Group may capitalize distribution centers. And Amata Group may operate industrial estates. In Mukdahan SBEZ, Bangkok Hospital Group may capitalize an international hospital. Central Pattana Group may invest a hotel. A few Vietnamese companies may invest in rubber industries. In Sakaeo SBEZ, Sahaphat Group may invest consumer goods. Charoen Pokpand
  • 14. 14 Group may finance agro-processing industry. As well, a few of Japan and Hong Kong conglomerate interested to invest in the pilot SBEZS particularly in logistics. Likewise, it is anticipated that these large private companies may attract a large number of their related subsidiaries and supply chain networks into these pilot SBEZs. As a result, it will help generate more job opportunities along targeted cross-border regions. 5) Labor, Public Health and National Security Policies Daily movement of immigrant labor within specified SBEZs is legally permitted. One Stop Service for Immigrant Labor is to be set up at the pilot SBEZs. Its function was to facilitate permission of immigrant labor entering the country along with arranging medical check, medical insurance and labor protection. Besides, it will be formulated skill development plan to support both Thai nationals residing along border areas and immigrant labor working within the SBEZs in response to the training needs of private sector. Provision of services on public health, education and public safety are in planning stage. Concerning national security, urgent matters, which should be taken in account, included border demarcation, monitoring of immigrant labor and illegal immigrant, natural resources management and preparation of knowledgeable border officials and necessary supporting equipments, etc. 6) National and Cross-Border Transport and Logistics Policies Additional national railways linking Bangkok with key border provinces are being planned. The major routes be jointly invested with Japan are between Bangkok and Chiangmai province and between Tak province and Mukdahan province. In addition, railways links with neighboring countries are being studied either between Kanchanaburi province and Bangkok; Bangkok-Chacheongsao province-Aranyaprathet district and Bangkok-Chacheongsao province-Lamchabang Deep Seaport. Once finished, only one chosen railway route will be developed. Likewise, other major dual track routes be jointly invested with China are both between Bangkok and Kangkoi (in Saraburi province) and between Kangkoi and Maptaphut Deep Seaport. Feasibility studies of these two routes will be completed by September 2015. Then, it will start constructing by October 2015, and it will take 30 months to finish. Further connecting routes are both between Kangkoi and Nakhon Ratchasima province and between Nakhon Ratchasima province and Nongkhai province. Feasibility studies of these two routes will be concluded by December 2015. Then, it will start constructing by early of 2016, and will take 36 months to accomplish. Furthermore, improves cross-border transport networks e.g. international highways, Mekong river bridges and river ports and logistics systems linking with neighboring countries. This can facilitate transportation services, as well as reducing logistics costs. In addition, utilizes both GMS and ASEAN connectivity towards promoting new production platforms with special emphasis on development of provinces and clustering provinces along major economic corridors. Additionally, supports wider transnational connectivity both under ASEAN and Asian Highway Networks. 4.2.2 Indirect Policies or Implicit Policies aim to indirectly sustain development of SBEZs. This included: 1) Tourism and Visa Policies Thailand is strategically positioned as tourism gateway to Asia. Thailand also implemented regional tourism cooperation schemes both under GMS and ACMECS. ACMECS single visa is an important instrument in facilitating greater people mobility between Thailand and bordering countries. It is a good illustration of south-south development cooperation. As a
  • 15. 15 result, implementation of a pilot ACMECS single visa between Thailand and Cambodia was made effective since December 16, 2010. 2) International Relations, Regional Cooperation and Official Development Assistance Policies Pertaining to international relations policy, Thailand fosters closer bilateral relations with neighboring countries. It is implemented in the form of cooperation at all levels ranging from public, private, people and media sectors. This will strengthen better mutual understanding, which will lead to intensify several cooperation aspects particularly under sub-regional cooperation and ASEAN. Likewise, building public understanding on border problem and impact of global change on Thailand will be promoted. Also, official development assistances from Thailand towards neighboring countries focus on socio-economic development, regional economic integration, human resources development and capacity building in the form of exchange of best practices in various areas ranging from public health, education, agriculture and poverty alleviation, etc. As the stages of development between Thailand and Cambodia, Lao and Myanmar are starkly different, the Office of Neighboring Countries Economic Development Cooperation Agency (NEDA) of Thailand was established in 2005 aiming to foster development cooperation with bordering countries. The NEDA, on behalf of Royal Thai Government, continuously extended financial and technical assistances, as well as, supporting infrastructure development in neighboring countries based on bilateral and regional cooperation program e.g. GMS, ACMECS and ASEAN.As an emerging donor country, during 2005-2013, Thailand has extended grant to CLM at a total of 283.94 US$ in order to develop cross- border rail links, interprovincial roads and airports for enhancing sub-regional transport integration and multimodal linkages (NEDA, 2013). Similarly, Thailand will extend technical assistance to Myanmar on understanding rules and regulations of the World Trade Organization. Despite existence of both explicit and implicit development policies, prospective investors are still reluctant to make real investments in the targeted special border economic zones as they perceive that the granted investment incentives are not attractive enough. 4.3 Chapter Summary This section highlights summary of the preceding policy analyses favorable for development of special border economic zones in Thailand as follows: 4.3.1 Evolution of Special Border Economic Zone Development Policies in Thailand Thailand adopts 5-year national development plan to guide development paths. Over 54 years of national development planning, spatial development policies are continually evolving in line with national and sectoral development progress, which can be classified into 4 distinguished periods. Each period characterized by specific spatial development advancement. Especially during the fourth period (2002-2015), it recently shifted towards upholding rural-urban relations and development of special border economic zones (SBEZs) along the Greater Mekong Economic Corridors in order to grasp potential of emerging regional cooperation and integration programs particularly for the Ayeyawady-Chao Phraya- Mekong Economic Cooperation Strategy (ACMECS), Greater Mekong Sub-region Economic Cooperation Program and the ASEAN Community. To materialize the concept of SBEZ, its ultimate goals were not only to reduce inter-regional and intra-regional disparities but also to create production bases along border areas and
  • 16. 16 minimize border labor shortage. It also aims to reduce impacts of continuing influx of illegal immigrant labor and low quality agricultural produce from neighboring countries into Thailand. Yet, progress has been gradually made due to this concept is truly new for Thailand. Chronologically, the Thaksin Administration initially announced to promote first SBEZs in both Chiang Rai and Tak provinces since 2003. However, it encountered severe resistance from both local authorities and general public, who were aware of being profoundly displaced their local administration function by new local authorities under the proposed special border economic zone law. This subsequently generated wide criticism on pros and cons of the SBEZ within Thai society. Coupled with political discontinuity, the initiative to implement these two pilot SBEZs were consequently sluggish for almost 8 years. As Thailand approached full entry into the ASEAN Community by the end of 2015, the Abhisit Administration reapproved on October 19, 2010 to develop Maesod district in Tak province as a pilot special border economic zone. In 2013, the Yingluck Administration continued support the scheme by setting up a mechanism so called Special Border Economic Zone Development Policy Board. Then, a strategic plan for promoting special border economic zones was formulated in 2014 covering 5 cross-border regions. This consisted of 1) Northern border region comprised Maesai, Chaingsaen and Chaingkhong districts in Chiang Rai province. 2) Northeastern border region consisted of Mukdahan, Nakhon Phanom and Nongkhai provinces. 3) Eastern border region represented Sakaeo and Trat provinces. 4) Western border region comprised Kanchanaburi province. And 5) Southern border region included Sadao district of Song Khla province and Narathiwat province. Presently, the Prayuth Administration promptly carried on hastening the implementation process of these pilot SBEZs. 4.3.2 Policy Analysis for Upholding Development of Special Border Economic Zones SBEZ policies in Thailand are currently advancing towards rapid implementation of pilot locations. The Prayuth Government has firmly committed strong leadership in formulating integrated policies, as well as, accelerating the implementation process. As a result, analysis of actual national integrated policies for upholding special border economic zone development is undertaken employing qualitative analyses. It can be broadly categorized into 2 groups of policies, which are explicit and implicit policies as follows: 4.3.2.1 Direct Policies or Explicit Policies intend to directly lay down strong foundation for progressing development of pilot SBEZs. Features of these integrated policies are as follows: 1) Special Border Economic Zone Development Policies It served as core national policy in driving SBEZ development. Currently, the Prayuth Administration is keenly expediting implementation of 10 SBEZs across Thailand dividing into 2 phases. It aims at attracting greater investments into these border regions at 20 %, as well as, being a part of preparation plan for entry into ASEAN Community by the end of 2015. Therefore, on January 19, 2015, the Prayuth Government approved 5 designated pilot SBEZs along with major infrastructure development plan and associated private investment incentives. The Royal Thai Government guided to realize early tangible progress by the end of 2015. Totally, it covers 10 districts or 36 sub-districts in 5 border provinces with total combined land area of 2,932 Km2 . This consisted of: (1) Tak Special Border Economic Zone covered Maesod, Pobpra and Maeramad districts of Tak province with total land area of 1,419 Km2 ; (2) Mukdahan Special Border Economic Zone comprised Muang Mukdahan, Wanyai and Dontan districts in Mukdahan province with total land area of 578.50 Km2 ; (3) Sakaeo Special Border Economic Zone encompassed Aranyaprathet and Wattananakhon districts in Sakaeo province with total land area of 332 Km2 ;
  • 17. 17 (4) Trat Special Border Economic Zone covered Klong Yai district in Trat province with total land area of 50.20 Km2 ; and (5) Songkhla Special Border Economic included Sadao district in Songkhla province with total land area of 552.30 Km2 . While locations in the second phase of SBEZs are being designated consisting of 5 areas namely Chiang Rai, Nongkhai, Nakhonphanom, Kanchanaburi and Narathiwat provinces. The Royal Thai Government also set up a mechanism to run the SBEZs by assigning 4 mains organizations to oversee implementation process comprising Office of the National Economic and Social Development Board as a secretariat office of the National Special Border Economic Zone Development Policy Board, Office of Board of Investment, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Interior. Then, Office of the National Economic and Social Development Board in collaboration with Office of Board of Investment and related agencies were tasked to coordinate in designing detailed investment targets in the pilots SBEZs so that prospective investors can propose investment projects as soon as possible. Therefore, four different sub-committees were formed at national level. These are: 1) Sub-Committee on Identifying Physical Boundary of Special Border Economic Zones chaired by Ministry of Interior; 2) Sub-Committee on Investment Incentives, Boundary and One Stop Service Center on Investment chaired by Permanent Secretary of Finance together with Office of Board of Investment; 3) Sub-Committee on Infrastructure and Customs House comprised 6 relevant organizations; 4) Sub-Committee on One Stop Service on Labor, Public Health and National Security consisted of 10 relevant organizations. To help facilitate rapid implementation of the 5 pilot SBEZs at provincial level, it is being studied to set up a Special Border Economic Zone Administration Sub-Committee in each pilot location. Moreover, the Royal Thai Government approved in principle of an infrastructure and customs house development plan of the pilot SBEZs through the year 2014-2022. During an urgent phase of development for these locations, it was allocated investment budget amounted 10,546 million Baht with total 124 projects. An Act on Development of Special Economic Zones is being drafted and will take effect by 2016.Relating to urban development in the pilot SBEZs, principle city plans and design of specific border town plans along with physical zoning and provision of public utilities are being revised in response to the changing development potential and policies. It has been physically planned at 3 different levels consisting of (1) provincial physical planning for border gateways linking with ASEAN Community; (2) principle provincial, urban and community plans and (3) specific plans of special border economic zones including detailed design of urban architecture and zoning. 2) International Trade and Cross-Border Trade Policies Cross-border trade between Thailand and CLM has been periodically affected adversely by political and diplomatic problems during periods of political differences. After the end of cold war, Thailand has proclaimed a policy of turning “Indochina battlefields into a marketplace” since 1988 in order to foster closer economic interdependence. The Royal Thai Government persistently reaffirms policies to expand regional cooperation particularly on trade at different levels as follows:
  • 18. 18 (1) ASEAN Level is a vital trading bloc for Thailand placing significant emphasis on utilizing full advantage of AFTA through “ASEAN Hub” policy so as to sustain trading and investment base particular in CLMV through establishment of Thailand’s distribution centers and trading firms. (2) Greater Mekong Sub-region Level is very meaningful due to geopolitics of Thailand as a strategic crossroad of the GMS. As a result, Thailand has focused on fostering greater flows in order to increase volume and value of cross-border trade, as well as, facilitating both intra and extra-GMS trade, investment and tourism through the implementation of CBTA. Launches regional production networks by relocating specific investments to neighboring countries. Keenly negotiates transit trade regime with neighboring countries in order to facilitate free flow of goods to nearby neighboring countries markets. (3) Bilateral Level with Particular Emphasis on Cross-Border Trade Policy The common bilateral cross-border trade polices of Thailand towards neighboring countries center on trade facilitation along major economic corridors. It correspondingly aims to improve facilities at key border checkpoints to meet international standards. In relation to cross-border trade policy, the Ministry of Commerce has set the targeted value for both cross- border trade and transit trade to reach 1.50 trillion Baht or 48,387 million US$ by the year 2015.This plan has been implemented through 4 strategies namely 1) strategy for development of competitiveness of Thailand for enhancing trade value; 2) strategy for building capacity of personnel responsible for cross-border trade; 3) strategy for outward investment in neighboring countries; and 4) strategy for urgent problem solving and utilization of regional cooperation agreements. Furthermore, local border cooperatives are collectively strengthened to actively participate in cross-border trade of agricultural produce aiming to help minimize the impact of illegal influx of low quality agricultural produce from bordering countries into Thailand. 3) Border Investment and Industrial Development Policies Pertaining to investment policy, the Board of Investment (BOI) recently revealed the Seven- Year Investment Promotion Strategies (2015-2021) built on both activities and merit-based incentives. It also included investment promotion policy particularly for investment in special border economic zones, which is equivalent to maximum incentives provided to the southern border provinces. Applications must be submitted from January 1, 2015 to December 31, 2017. Detailed investment promotion can be classified into 2 slightly different types of incentives, which are general and specific target industries. The BOI has also allowed promoted projects in the pilot SBEZ to use machinery older than 5 years but not exceeding 10 years. On general case, imported used machinery must not exceed 10 years. In case when a production base is relocated into Thailand, machinery over 10 years old will be allowed to be used in the project. In both cases, no offer of import duty exemption on machinery will be made and the project will be required to submit a performance certificate issued by a trusted institute identifying the efficiency of the machinery, its environmental impact, safety standard and energy usage, as well as, its maintenance profile and its fair value must be obtained. As an alternative to the BOI’s tax breaks, new investors could also choose incentives granted by the Ministry of Finance under “Thailand Plus One” scheme, which would allow a reduction in corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years. “Thailand Plus One” would supplement SBEZs investment projects. So, Thailand could forge greater relations with
  • 19. 19 neighboring countries. This means any ASEAN investor can invest in the SBEZs to receive privileges from Thailand plus border countries such as Myanmar, Lao PDR, Cambodia and Malaysia. Thailand Plus One is a strategic business model initiated by Japan’s corporations in 2012 to encourage investors to maintain their main operations in Thailand while diversifying supporting productions in the supply chain to neighboring countries in order to gain benefits from comparative advantages and regional production networks. Maesod and Aranyaprathet SBEZs are pioneer areas in Thailand in fostering linkages with Myanmar and Cambodia. Furthermore, a One Stop Service Center for Investment is to be set up in pilot provincial halls. Concerning new local investor who does not hold BOI approval, they will not only entitle for a reduction of corporate tax from 20 % to 10 % for 10 years but also to gain an access to soft loan at maximum credit limit of 20 million Baht provided by the Government Saving Banks and warranted by Thai Credit Guarantee Corporation. This will play important role for fast track implementation of SBEZs plan. In addition, the Department of Customs has additionally provided investment incentives for establishments in both free zone and bonded warehouse. In relation to prospective industries in the pilot SBEZs, the Board of Investment prioritized specific target productions consisting of 13 major industries covering 61 business activities. Each SBEZ may have specialization in a particular industry based on resource endowments and complementarity with counterpart adjacent SBEZs in neighboring countries. So far, a number of Bangkok-based conglomerates expressed keen interest to invest in in a particular SBEZ. For instance in Tak SBEZ, Charoen Pokpand (CP) Group may make investment on logistics and real estate; while Central Pattana Group may invest in a department store. Sahaphat Group may invest in high-end apparel. Thai Beverage Group may capitalize distribution centers. And Amata Group may operate industrial estates. In Mukdahan SBEZ, Bangkok Hospital Group may capitalize an international hospital. Central Pattana Group may invest a hotel. A few Vietnamese companies may engage in rubber industries. In Sakaeo SBEZ, Sahaphat Group may invest consumer goods. Charoen Pokpand Group may finance agro-processing industry. As well, a few of Japan and Hong Kong conglomerate interested to invest in the pilot SBEZS particularly in logistics. Likewise, it is anticipated that these large private companies may attract a large number of their related subsidiaries and supply chain networks into these pilot SBEZs. As a result, it will help generate more job opportunities along targeted cross-border regions. 4) Labor, Public Health and National Security Policies Permits daily movement of immigrant labour within specified SBEZs. One Stop Service for Immigrant Labour is to be set up at the pilot SBEZs. Its function was to facilitate permission of immigrant labour entering the country along with arranging medical check, medical insurance and labour protection. Besides, it will be formulated skill development plan to support both Thai nationals residing along border areas and immigrant labour working within the SBEZs in response to the training needs of private sector. Provision of services on public health, education and public safety are in planning stage. Concerning national security, urgent matters, which should seriously be taken in account, included border demarcation, monitoring of immigrant labour and illegal immigrant, natural resources management and preparation of knowledgeable border officials and necessary supporting equipments, etc. 5) National and Cross-Border Transport and Logistics Policies Additional national railways linking Bangkok with key border provinces are being planned. The major routes be jointly invested with Japan are between Bangkok and Chiangmai
  • 20. 20 province and between Tak province and Mukdahan province. In addition, railways links with neighbouring countries are being studied either between Kanchanaburi province and Bangkok; Bangkok-Chacheongsao province-Aranyaprathet district or Bangkok Chacheongsao province-Lamchabang Deep Seaport. Once finished, only one chosen railway route will be developed. Likewise, other major dual track routes be jointly invested with China are both between Bangkok and Kangkoi (in Saraburi province) and between Kangkoi and Maptaphut Deep Seaport. Feasibility studies of these two routes will be completed by September 2015. Then, it will start constructing by October 2015, and it will take 30 months to finish. Further connecting routes are both between Kangkoi and Nakhon Ratchasima province and between Nakhon Ratchasima province and Nongkhai province. Feasibility studies of these two routes will be concluded by December 2015. Then, it will start constructing by early of 2016, and it will take 36 months to accomplish. Furthermore, improves cross-border transport networks e.g. international highways, Mekong river bridges and river ports and logistics systems linking with neighbouring countries. This can facilitate transportation services, as well as, reducing cross-border logistics costs. In addition, utilizes both GMS and ASEAN connectivity towards promoting new production platforms with special emphasis on development of provinces and clustering provinces along major economic corridors. Additionally, supports wider transnational connectivity both within ASEAN and Asian Highway Networks. 4.3.2.2 Indirect Policies or Implicit Policies aim to indirectly sustain development of SBEZs. This included: 1) Tourism and Visa Policies Thailand is strategically positioned as tourism gateway to Asia. Thailand also implemented regional tourism cooperation schemes under GMS and ACMECS. ACMECS single visa is an important instrument in facilitating greater people mobility between Thailand and bordering countries. It is a good illustration of south-south development cooperation. As a result, implementation of a pilot ACMECS single visa between Thailand and Cambodia was made effective since December 16, 2010. 2) International Relations, Regional Cooperation and Official Development Assistance Policies Pertaining to international relations policy, Thailand fosters closer bilateral relations with neighbouring countries. It is implemented in the form of cooperation at all levels ranging from public, private, people and media sectors. This will strengthen better mutual understanding, which will lead to intensify several cooperation aspects particularly under sub-regional cooperation and ASEAN. Likewise, building public understanding on border problem and impact of global change on Thailand will be promoted. Also, official development assistances from Thailand towards neighbouring countries focus on socio- economic development, regional economic integration, human resources development and capacity building in the form of exchange of best practices in various areas ranging from public health, education, agriculture and poverty alleviation, etc. As the stages of development between Thailand and Cambodia, Lao and Myanmar are starkly different, the Office of Neighboring Countries Economic Development Cooperation Agency (NEDA) was established in 2005 aiming to cultivate development cooperation with bordering countries. The NEDA, on behalf of Royal Thai Government, continuously extended financial and technical assistance, as well as supporting infrastructure development in neighbouring countries based on bilateral and regional cooperation program e.g. GMS, ACMECS and ASEAN.As an emerging donor country, during 2005-2013, Thailand has extended grant to
  • 21. 21 CLM at a total of 283.94 US$ in order to develop cross-border rail links, interprovincial roads and airports for enhancing sub-regional transport integration and multimodal linkages (NEDA, 2013). Similarly, Thailand will extend technical assistance to Myanmar regarding understanding on rules and regulations of the World Trade Organization. Despite existence of both explicit and implicit development policies, prospective investors are still reluctant to make real investments in the targeted special border economic zones as they perceive that the granted investment incentives are not attractive enough.