Towards Optimal Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
•Download as PPTX, PDF•
0 likes•913 views
HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) enables high-quality streaming of video content. In HAS, videos are divided into short intervals called segments, and each segment is encoded at various quality/bitrates to adapt to the available bandwidth. Multiple encodings of the same content impose high costs for video content providers. To reduce the time-complexity of encoding multiple representations, state-of-the-art methods typically encode the highest quality representation first and reuse the information gathered during its encoding to accelerate the encoding of the remaining representations. As encoding the highest quality representation requires the highest time-complexity compared to the lower quality representations, it would be a bottleneck in parallel encoding scenarios and the overall time-complexity will be limited to the time-complexity of the highest quality representation. In this paper and to address this problem, we consider all representations from the highest to the lowest quality representation as a potential, single reference to accelerate the encoding of the other, dependent representations. We formulate a set of encoding modes and assess their performance in terms of BD-Rate and time-complexity, using both VMAF and PSNR as objective metrics. Experimental results show that encoding a middle quality representation as a reference, can significantly reduce the maximum en-coding complexity and hence it is an efficient way of encoding multiple representations in parallel. Based on this fact, a fast multirate encoding method is proposed which utilizes depth and prediction mode of a middle quality representation to accelerate the encoding of the dependent representations.
Report
Share
Report
Share
Recommended
HTTP Adaptive Streaming(HAS) is the most common approach for delivering video content over the Internet. Therequirement to encode the same content at different quality levels(i.e., representations) in HAS is a challenging problem for content providers. Fast multirate encoding approaches try to accelerate this process by reusing information from previously encoded representations. In this paper, we propose to use convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to speed up the encoding of multiple representations with a specific focus on parallel encoding. In parallel encoding, the overall time-complexity is limited to the maximum time-complexity of one of the representations that are encoded in parallel. Therefore, instead of reducing the time-complexity for all representations, the highest time-complexities are reduced. Experimental results show that FaME-ML achieves significant time-complexity savings in parallel encoding scenarios(41%in average) with a slight increase in bitrate and quality degradation compared to the HEVC reference software.FaME-ML: Fast Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Using Machine Le...
FaME-ML: Fast Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Using Machine Le...Alpen-Adria-Universität
HTTP/2 has been explored widely for video streaming, but still suffers from Head-of-Line blocking and three-way hand-shake delay due to TCP. Meanwhile, QUIC running on top of UDP can tackle these issues. In addition, although many adaptive bitrate (ABR) algorithms have been proposed for scalable and non-scalable video streaming, the literature lacks an algorithm designed for both types of video streaming approaches. In this paper, we investigate the impact of quick and HTTP/2 on the performance of adaptive bitrate (ABR) algorithms in terms of different metrics. Moreover, we propose an efficient approach for utilizing scalable video coding formats for adaptive video streaming that combines a traditional video streaming approach (based on non-scalable video coding formats) and a retransmission technique. The experimental results show that QUIC benefits significantly from our proposed method in the context of packet loss and retransmission. Compared to HTTP/2, it improves the average video quality and also provides a smoother adaptation behavior. Finally, we demonstrate that our proposed method originally designed for non-scalable video codecs also works efficiently for scalable videos such as Scalable High EfficiencyVideo Coding (SHVC).Scalable High Efficiency Video Coding based HTTP Adaptive Streaming over QUIC...
Scalable High Efficiency Video Coding based HTTP Adaptive Streaming over QUIC...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Recommended
HTTP Adaptive Streaming(HAS) is the most common approach for delivering video content over the Internet. Therequirement to encode the same content at different quality levels(i.e., representations) in HAS is a challenging problem for content providers. Fast multirate encoding approaches try to accelerate this process by reusing information from previously encoded representations. In this paper, we propose to use convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to speed up the encoding of multiple representations with a specific focus on parallel encoding. In parallel encoding, the overall time-complexity is limited to the maximum time-complexity of one of the representations that are encoded in parallel. Therefore, instead of reducing the time-complexity for all representations, the highest time-complexities are reduced. Experimental results show that FaME-ML achieves significant time-complexity savings in parallel encoding scenarios(41%in average) with a slight increase in bitrate and quality degradation compared to the HEVC reference software.FaME-ML: Fast Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Using Machine Le...
FaME-ML: Fast Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Using Machine Le...Alpen-Adria-Universität
HTTP/2 has been explored widely for video streaming, but still suffers from Head-of-Line blocking and three-way hand-shake delay due to TCP. Meanwhile, QUIC running on top of UDP can tackle these issues. In addition, although many adaptive bitrate (ABR) algorithms have been proposed for scalable and non-scalable video streaming, the literature lacks an algorithm designed for both types of video streaming approaches. In this paper, we investigate the impact of quick and HTTP/2 on the performance of adaptive bitrate (ABR) algorithms in terms of different metrics. Moreover, we propose an efficient approach for utilizing scalable video coding formats for adaptive video streaming that combines a traditional video streaming approach (based on non-scalable video coding formats) and a retransmission technique. The experimental results show that QUIC benefits significantly from our proposed method in the context of packet loss and retransmission. Compared to HTTP/2, it improves the average video quality and also provides a smoother adaptation behavior. Finally, we demonstrate that our proposed method originally designed for non-scalable video codecs also works efficiently for scalable videos such as Scalable High EfficiencyVideo Coding (SHVC).Scalable High Efficiency Video Coding based HTTP Adaptive Streaming over QUIC...
Scalable High Efficiency Video Coding based HTTP Adaptive Streaming over QUIC...Alpen-Adria-Universität
With the increasing demand for video streaming applications, HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) technology has become the dominant video delivery technique over the Internet. Current HAS solutions only consider either client- or server-side optimization, which causes many problems in achieving high-quality video, leading to sub-optimal users’ experience and network resource utilization. Recent studies have revealed that network-assisted HAS techniques, by providing a comprehensive view of the network, can lead to more significant gains in HAS system performance. In this paper, we leverage the capability of Software-Define Networking (SDN), Network Function Virtualization (NFV), and edge computing to introduce a CDN-Aware QoE Optimization in SDN-Assisted Adaptive Video Streaming framework called CSDN. We employ virtualized edge entities to collect various information items (e.g., user-, client, CDN- and network-level information) in a time-slotted method. These components then run an optimization model with a new server/segment selection approach in a time-slotted fashion to serve the clients’ requests by selecting optimal cache servers (in terms of fetch and transcoding times). In case of a cache miss, a client’s request is served (i) by an optimal replacement quality (only better quality levels with minimum deviation) from a cache server, (ii) by a quality transcoded from an optimal replacement quality at the edge, or (iii) by the originally requested quality level from the origin server. By means of comprehensive experiments conducted on a real-world large-scale testbed, we demonstrate that CSDN outperforms the state-of-the-art in terms of playback bitrate, the number of quality switches, the number of stalls, and bandwidth usage by at least 7.5%, 19%, 19%, and 63%, respectively.CSDN: CDN-Aware QoE Optimization in SDN-Assisted HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming
CSDN: CDN-Aware QoE Optimization in SDN-Assisted HTTP Adaptive Video StreamingAlpen-Adria-Universität
HTTP Adaptive Streaming of video content is becoming an integral part of the Internet and accounts for the majority of today’s traffic. Although Internet bandwidth is constantly increasing, video compression technology plays an important role and the major challenge is to select and set up multiple video codecs, each with hundreds of transcoding parameters. Additionally, the transcoding speed depends directly on the selected transcoding parameters and the infrastructure used. Predicting transcoding time for multiple transcoding parameters with different codecs and processing units is a challenging task, as it depends on many factors. This paper provides a novel and considerably fast method for transcoding time prediction using video content classification and neural network prediction. Our artificial neural network (ANN) model predicts the transcoding times of video segments for state-of-the-art video codecs based on transcoding parameters and content complexity. We evaluated our method for two video codecs/implementations (AVC/x264 and HEVC/x265) as part of large-scale HTTP Adaptive Streaming services. The ANN model of our method is able to predict the transcoding time by minimizing the mean absolute error (MAE) to 1.37 and 2.67 for x264 and x265 codecs, respectively. For x264, this is an improvement of 22% compared to the state of the art.ComplexCTTP: Complexity Class Based Transcoding Time Prediction for Video Seq...
ComplexCTTP: Complexity Class Based Transcoding Time Prediction for Video Seq...Alpen-Adria-Universität
ICIP 2018 Innovation Program: Bringing Industry to ICIP: https://2018.ieeeicip.org/InnovationProgram.aspVideo Coding for Large-Scale HTTP Adaptive Streaming Deployments: State of th...
Video Coding for Large-Scale HTTP Adaptive Streaming Deployments: State of th...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Attempting to cope with fluctuations of network conditions in terms of available bandwidth, latency and packet loss, and to deliver the highest quality of video (and audio) content to users, research on adaptive video streaming has attracted intense efforts from the research community and huge investments from technology giants. How successful these efforts and investments are, is a question that needs precise measurements of the results of those technological advancements. HTTP-based Adaptive Streaming (HAS) algorithms, which seek to improve video streaming over the Internet, introduce video bitrate adaptivity in a way that is scalable and efficient.
However, how each HAS implementation takes into account the wide spectrum of variables and configuration options, brings a high complexity to the task of measuring the results and visualizing the statistics of the performance and quality of experience.
In this paper, we introduce CAdViSE, our Cloud-based Adaptive
Video Streaming Evaluation framework for the automated testing
of adaptive media players. The paper aims to demonstrate a test
environment which can be instantiated in a cloud infrastructure,
examines multiple media players with different network attributes
at defined points of the experiment time, and finally concludes the
evaluation with visualized statistics and insights into the results.CAdViSE: Cloud based Adaptive Video Streaming Evaluation Framework for the Au...
CAdViSE: Cloud based Adaptive Video Streaming Evaluation Framework for the Au...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Live User Generated Content (UGC) has become very popular in today’s video streaming applications, in particular with gaming and e-sport. However, streaming UGC presents unique challenges for video delivery. When dealing with the technical complexity of managing hundreds or thousands of concurrent streams that are geographically distributed, UGCsystems are forces to made difficult trade-offs with video quality and latency. To bridge this gap, this paper presents a fully distributed architecture for UGC delivery over the Internet, termed QuaLA(joint Quality-Latency Architecture). The proposed architecture aims to jointly optimize video quality and latency for a better user experience and fairness. By using the proximal Jacobi alternating direction method of multipliers(ProxJ-ADMM) technique, QuaLA proposes a fully distributed mechanism to achieve an optimal solution. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed architecture through real-world experiments using the CloudLAB testbed. Experimental results show the outperformance ofQuaLAin achieving high quality with more than 57% improvement while preserving a good level of fairness and respecting a given target latency among all clients compared to conventional client-driven solutionsA Distributed Delivery Architecture for User Generated Content Live Streaming...
A Distributed Delivery Architecture for User Generated Content Live Streaming...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Video streaming became an undivided part of the Internet. To efficiently utilise the limited network bandwidth it is essential to encode the video content. However, encoding is a computationally intensive task, involving high-performance resources provided by private infrastructures or public clouds. Public clouds, such as Amazon EC2, provide a large portfolio of services and instances optimized for specific purposes and budgets. The majority of Amazon’s instances use x86 processors, such as Intel Xeon or AMD EPYC. However, following the recent trends in computer architecture, Amazon introduced Arm based instances that promise up to 40% better cost performance
ratio than comparable x86 instances for specific workloads. We evaluate in this paper the video encoding performance of x86 and Arm instances of four instance families using the latest FFmpeg version and two video codecs. We examine the impact of the encoding parameters, such as different presets and bitrates, on the time and cost for encoding. Our experiments reveal that Arm instances show high time and cost saving potential of up to
33.63% for specific bitrates and presets, especially for the x264 codec. However, the x86 instances are more general and achieve low encoding times, regardless of the codec.Where to Encode: A Performance Analysis of Intel x86 and Arm-based Amazon EC2...
Where to Encode: A Performance Analysis of Intel x86 and Arm-based Amazon EC2...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Omnidirectional video (ODV) streaming applica- tions are becoming increasingly popular. They enable a highly immersive experience as the user can freely choose her/his field of view within the 360-degree environment. Current deployments are fairly simple but viewport-agnostic which inevitably results in high storage/bandwidth requirements and low Quality of Experience (QoE). A promising solution is referred to as tile- based streaming which allows to have higher quality within the user’s viewport while quality outside the user’s viewport could be lower. However, empirical QoE assessment studies in this domain are still rare. Thus, this paper investigates the impact of different tile-based streaming approaches and configurations on the QoE of ODV. We present the results of a lab-based subjective evaluation in which participants evaluated 8K omnidirectional video QoE as influenced by different (i) tile-based streaming approaches (full vs. partial delivery), (ii) content types (static vs. moving camera), and (iii) tile encoding quality levels determined by different quantization parameters. Our experimental setup is character- ized by high reproducibility since relevant media delivery aspects (including the user’s head movements and dynamic tile quality adaptation) are already rendered into the respective processed video sequences. Additionally, we performed a complementary objective evaluation of the different test sequences focusing on bandwidth efficiency and objective quality metrics. The results are presented in this paper and discussed in detail which confirm that tile-based streaming of ODV improves visual quality while reducing bandwidth requirements.Tile-based Streaming of 8K Omnidirectional Video: Subjective and Objective Qo...
Tile-based Streaming of 8K Omnidirectional Video: Subjective and Objective Qo...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Video streaming is one of the top traffic contributors in the Internet and a frequent research subject. It is expected that streaming traffic will grow 4-fold for video globally and 9-fold for mobile video between 2017 and 2022. In this paper, we present an automatized measurement framework for evaluating video streaming QoE in operational broadband networks, using headless streaming with a Docker-based client, and a server-side implementation allowing for the use of multiple video players and adaptation algorithms. Our framework allows for integration with the MONROE testbed and Bitmovin Analytics, which bring on the possibility to conduct large-scale measurements in different networks, including mobility scenarios, and monitor different parameters in the application, transport, network, and physical layers in real-time. Docker-Based Evaluation Framework for Video Streaming QoE in Broadband Networks
Docker-Based Evaluation Framework for Video Streaming QoE in Broadband NetworksAlpen-Adria-Universität
Recently, HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) has become the dominant video delivery technology over the Internet. In HAS, clients have full control over the media streaming and adaptation processes. Lack of coordination among the clients and lack of awareness of the network conditions may lead to sub-optimal user experience, and resource utilization in a pure client-based HAS adaptation scheme. Software-Defined Networking (SDN) has recently been considered to enhance the video streaming process. In this paper, we leverage the capability of SDN and Network Function Virtualization (NFV) to introduce an edge- and SDN-assisted video streaming framework called ES-HAS. We employ virtualized edge components to collect HAS clients’ requests and retrieve networking information in a time-slotted manner. These components then perform an optimization model in a time-slotted manner to efficiently serve clients’ requests by selecting an optimal cache server (with the shortest fetch time). In case of a cache miss, a client’s request is served (i) by an optimal replacement quality (only better quality levels with minimum deviation) from a cache server, or (ii) by the originally requested quality level from the origin server. This approach is validated through experiments on a large-scale testbed, and the performance of our framework is compared to pure client-based strategies and the SABR system [11]. Although SABR and ES-HAS show (almost) identical performance in the number of quality switches, ES-HAS outperforms SABR in terms of playback bitrate and the number of stalls by at least 70% and 40%, respectively.ES-HAS: An Edge- and SDN-Assisted Framework for HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming
ES-HAS: An Edge- and SDN-Assisted Framework for HTTP Adaptive Video StreamingAlpen-Adria-Universität
More Related Content
What's hot
With the increasing demand for video streaming applications, HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) technology has become the dominant video delivery technique over the Internet. Current HAS solutions only consider either client- or server-side optimization, which causes many problems in achieving high-quality video, leading to sub-optimal users’ experience and network resource utilization. Recent studies have revealed that network-assisted HAS techniques, by providing a comprehensive view of the network, can lead to more significant gains in HAS system performance. In this paper, we leverage the capability of Software-Define Networking (SDN), Network Function Virtualization (NFV), and edge computing to introduce a CDN-Aware QoE Optimization in SDN-Assisted Adaptive Video Streaming framework called CSDN. We employ virtualized edge entities to collect various information items (e.g., user-, client, CDN- and network-level information) in a time-slotted method. These components then run an optimization model with a new server/segment selection approach in a time-slotted fashion to serve the clients’ requests by selecting optimal cache servers (in terms of fetch and transcoding times). In case of a cache miss, a client’s request is served (i) by an optimal replacement quality (only better quality levels with minimum deviation) from a cache server, (ii) by a quality transcoded from an optimal replacement quality at the edge, or (iii) by the originally requested quality level from the origin server. By means of comprehensive experiments conducted on a real-world large-scale testbed, we demonstrate that CSDN outperforms the state-of-the-art in terms of playback bitrate, the number of quality switches, the number of stalls, and bandwidth usage by at least 7.5%, 19%, 19%, and 63%, respectively.CSDN: CDN-Aware QoE Optimization in SDN-Assisted HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming
CSDN: CDN-Aware QoE Optimization in SDN-Assisted HTTP Adaptive Video StreamingAlpen-Adria-Universität
HTTP Adaptive Streaming of video content is becoming an integral part of the Internet and accounts for the majority of today’s traffic. Although Internet bandwidth is constantly increasing, video compression technology plays an important role and the major challenge is to select and set up multiple video codecs, each with hundreds of transcoding parameters. Additionally, the transcoding speed depends directly on the selected transcoding parameters and the infrastructure used. Predicting transcoding time for multiple transcoding parameters with different codecs and processing units is a challenging task, as it depends on many factors. This paper provides a novel and considerably fast method for transcoding time prediction using video content classification and neural network prediction. Our artificial neural network (ANN) model predicts the transcoding times of video segments for state-of-the-art video codecs based on transcoding parameters and content complexity. We evaluated our method for two video codecs/implementations (AVC/x264 and HEVC/x265) as part of large-scale HTTP Adaptive Streaming services. The ANN model of our method is able to predict the transcoding time by minimizing the mean absolute error (MAE) to 1.37 and 2.67 for x264 and x265 codecs, respectively. For x264, this is an improvement of 22% compared to the state of the art.ComplexCTTP: Complexity Class Based Transcoding Time Prediction for Video Seq...
ComplexCTTP: Complexity Class Based Transcoding Time Prediction for Video Seq...Alpen-Adria-Universität
ICIP 2018 Innovation Program: Bringing Industry to ICIP: https://2018.ieeeicip.org/InnovationProgram.aspVideo Coding for Large-Scale HTTP Adaptive Streaming Deployments: State of th...
Video Coding for Large-Scale HTTP Adaptive Streaming Deployments: State of th...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Attempting to cope with fluctuations of network conditions in terms of available bandwidth, latency and packet loss, and to deliver the highest quality of video (and audio) content to users, research on adaptive video streaming has attracted intense efforts from the research community and huge investments from technology giants. How successful these efforts and investments are, is a question that needs precise measurements of the results of those technological advancements. HTTP-based Adaptive Streaming (HAS) algorithms, which seek to improve video streaming over the Internet, introduce video bitrate adaptivity in a way that is scalable and efficient.
However, how each HAS implementation takes into account the wide spectrum of variables and configuration options, brings a high complexity to the task of measuring the results and visualizing the statistics of the performance and quality of experience.
In this paper, we introduce CAdViSE, our Cloud-based Adaptive
Video Streaming Evaluation framework for the automated testing
of adaptive media players. The paper aims to demonstrate a test
environment which can be instantiated in a cloud infrastructure,
examines multiple media players with different network attributes
at defined points of the experiment time, and finally concludes the
evaluation with visualized statistics and insights into the results.CAdViSE: Cloud based Adaptive Video Streaming Evaluation Framework for the Au...
CAdViSE: Cloud based Adaptive Video Streaming Evaluation Framework for the Au...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Live User Generated Content (UGC) has become very popular in today’s video streaming applications, in particular with gaming and e-sport. However, streaming UGC presents unique challenges for video delivery. When dealing with the technical complexity of managing hundreds or thousands of concurrent streams that are geographically distributed, UGCsystems are forces to made difficult trade-offs with video quality and latency. To bridge this gap, this paper presents a fully distributed architecture for UGC delivery over the Internet, termed QuaLA(joint Quality-Latency Architecture). The proposed architecture aims to jointly optimize video quality and latency for a better user experience and fairness. By using the proximal Jacobi alternating direction method of multipliers(ProxJ-ADMM) technique, QuaLA proposes a fully distributed mechanism to achieve an optimal solution. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed architecture through real-world experiments using the CloudLAB testbed. Experimental results show the outperformance ofQuaLAin achieving high quality with more than 57% improvement while preserving a good level of fairness and respecting a given target latency among all clients compared to conventional client-driven solutionsA Distributed Delivery Architecture for User Generated Content Live Streaming...
A Distributed Delivery Architecture for User Generated Content Live Streaming...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Video streaming became an undivided part of the Internet. To efficiently utilise the limited network bandwidth it is essential to encode the video content. However, encoding is a computationally intensive task, involving high-performance resources provided by private infrastructures or public clouds. Public clouds, such as Amazon EC2, provide a large portfolio of services and instances optimized for specific purposes and budgets. The majority of Amazon’s instances use x86 processors, such as Intel Xeon or AMD EPYC. However, following the recent trends in computer architecture, Amazon introduced Arm based instances that promise up to 40% better cost performance
ratio than comparable x86 instances for specific workloads. We evaluate in this paper the video encoding performance of x86 and Arm instances of four instance families using the latest FFmpeg version and two video codecs. We examine the impact of the encoding parameters, such as different presets and bitrates, on the time and cost for encoding. Our experiments reveal that Arm instances show high time and cost saving potential of up to
33.63% for specific bitrates and presets, especially for the x264 codec. However, the x86 instances are more general and achieve low encoding times, regardless of the codec.Where to Encode: A Performance Analysis of Intel x86 and Arm-based Amazon EC2...
Where to Encode: A Performance Analysis of Intel x86 and Arm-based Amazon EC2...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Omnidirectional video (ODV) streaming applica- tions are becoming increasingly popular. They enable a highly immersive experience as the user can freely choose her/his field of view within the 360-degree environment. Current deployments are fairly simple but viewport-agnostic which inevitably results in high storage/bandwidth requirements and low Quality of Experience (QoE). A promising solution is referred to as tile- based streaming which allows to have higher quality within the user’s viewport while quality outside the user’s viewport could be lower. However, empirical QoE assessment studies in this domain are still rare. Thus, this paper investigates the impact of different tile-based streaming approaches and configurations on the QoE of ODV. We present the results of a lab-based subjective evaluation in which participants evaluated 8K omnidirectional video QoE as influenced by different (i) tile-based streaming approaches (full vs. partial delivery), (ii) content types (static vs. moving camera), and (iii) tile encoding quality levels determined by different quantization parameters. Our experimental setup is character- ized by high reproducibility since relevant media delivery aspects (including the user’s head movements and dynamic tile quality adaptation) are already rendered into the respective processed video sequences. Additionally, we performed a complementary objective evaluation of the different test sequences focusing on bandwidth efficiency and objective quality metrics. The results are presented in this paper and discussed in detail which confirm that tile-based streaming of ODV improves visual quality while reducing bandwidth requirements.Tile-based Streaming of 8K Omnidirectional Video: Subjective and Objective Qo...
Tile-based Streaming of 8K Omnidirectional Video: Subjective and Objective Qo...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Video streaming is one of the top traffic contributors in the Internet and a frequent research subject. It is expected that streaming traffic will grow 4-fold for video globally and 9-fold for mobile video between 2017 and 2022. In this paper, we present an automatized measurement framework for evaluating video streaming QoE in operational broadband networks, using headless streaming with a Docker-based client, and a server-side implementation allowing for the use of multiple video players and adaptation algorithms. Our framework allows for integration with the MONROE testbed and Bitmovin Analytics, which bring on the possibility to conduct large-scale measurements in different networks, including mobility scenarios, and monitor different parameters in the application, transport, network, and physical layers in real-time. Docker-Based Evaluation Framework for Video Streaming QoE in Broadband Networks
Docker-Based Evaluation Framework for Video Streaming QoE in Broadband NetworksAlpen-Adria-Universität
Recently, HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) has become the dominant video delivery technology over the Internet. In HAS, clients have full control over the media streaming and adaptation processes. Lack of coordination among the clients and lack of awareness of the network conditions may lead to sub-optimal user experience, and resource utilization in a pure client-based HAS adaptation scheme. Software-Defined Networking (SDN) has recently been considered to enhance the video streaming process. In this paper, we leverage the capability of SDN and Network Function Virtualization (NFV) to introduce an edge- and SDN-assisted video streaming framework called ES-HAS. We employ virtualized edge components to collect HAS clients’ requests and retrieve networking information in a time-slotted manner. These components then perform an optimization model in a time-slotted manner to efficiently serve clients’ requests by selecting an optimal cache server (with the shortest fetch time). In case of a cache miss, a client’s request is served (i) by an optimal replacement quality (only better quality levels with minimum deviation) from a cache server, or (ii) by the originally requested quality level from the origin server. This approach is validated through experiments on a large-scale testbed, and the performance of our framework is compared to pure client-based strategies and the SABR system [11]. Although SABR and ES-HAS show (almost) identical performance in the number of quality switches, ES-HAS outperforms SABR in terms of playback bitrate and the number of stalls by at least 70% and 40%, respectively.ES-HAS: An Edge- and SDN-Assisted Framework for HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming
ES-HAS: An Edge- and SDN-Assisted Framework for HTTP Adaptive Video StreamingAlpen-Adria-Universität
What's hot (20)
EADAS: Edge Assisted Adaptation Scheme for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
EADAS: Edge Assisted Adaptation Scheme for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
CSDN: CDN-Aware QoE Optimization in SDN-Assisted HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming
CSDN: CDN-Aware QoE Optimization in SDN-Assisted HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming
ComplexCTTP: Complexity Class Based Transcoding Time Prediction for Video Seq...
ComplexCTTP: Complexity Class Based Transcoding Time Prediction for Video Seq...
CAdViSE or how to find the Sweet Spots of ABR Systems
CAdViSE or how to find the Sweet Spots of ABR Systems
Video Coding Enhancements for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
Video Coding Enhancements for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
Video Coding for Large-Scale HTTP Adaptive Streaming Deployments: State of th...
Video Coding for Large-Scale HTTP Adaptive Streaming Deployments: State of th...
CAdViSE: Cloud based Adaptive Video Streaming Evaluation Framework for the Au...
CAdViSE: Cloud based Adaptive Video Streaming Evaluation Framework for the Au...
A Distributed Delivery Architecture for User Generated Content Live Streaming...
A Distributed Delivery Architecture for User Generated Content Live Streaming...
Where to Encode: A Performance Analysis of Intel x86 and Arm-based Amazon EC2...
Where to Encode: A Performance Analysis of Intel x86 and Arm-based Amazon EC2...
Tile-based Streaming of 8K Omnidirectional Video: Subjective and Objective Qo...
Tile-based Streaming of 8K Omnidirectional Video: Subjective and Objective Qo...
Bandwidth Prediction in Low-Latency Chunked Streaming
Bandwidth Prediction in Low-Latency Chunked Streaming
MiPSO: Multi-Period Per-Scene Optimization For HTTP Adaptive Streaming
MiPSO: Multi-Period Per-Scene Optimization For HTTP Adaptive Streaming
WISH: User-centric Bitrate Adaptation for HTTP Adaptive Streaming on Mobile D...
WISH: User-centric Bitrate Adaptation for HTTP Adaptive Streaming on Mobile D...
Docker-Based Evaluation Framework for Video Streaming QoE in Broadband Networks
Docker-Based Evaluation Framework for Video Streaming QoE in Broadband Networks
ES-HAS: An Edge- and SDN-Assisted Framework for HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming
ES-HAS: An Edge- and SDN-Assisted Framework for HTTP Adaptive Video Streaming
Similar to Towards Optimal Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
Similar to Towards Optimal Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming (20)
QoE- and Energy-aware Content Consumption for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
QoE- and Energy-aware Content Consumption for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
MMSys'21 - Multi-access edge computing for adaptive bitrate video streaming
MMSys'21 - Multi-access edge computing for adaptive bitrate video streaming
LwTE-Live: Light-weight Transcoding at the Edge for Live Streaming
LwTE-Live: Light-weight Transcoding at the Edge for Live Streaming
Adaptive Streaming of Traditional and Omnidirectional Media
Adaptive Streaming of Traditional and Omnidirectional Media
Video Coding Enhancements for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Using Machine Learning
Video Coding Enhancements for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Using Machine Learning
Video Coding Enhancements for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Using Machine Learning
Video Coding Enhancements for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Using Machine Learning
Bitmovin LIVE Tech Talks: Data Driven Video Workflows
Bitmovin LIVE Tech Talks: Data Driven Video Workflows
How to Optimize Dynamic Adaptive Video Streaming? Challenges and Solutions
How to Optimize Dynamic Adaptive Video Streaming? Challenges and Solutions
The Perfect Storm MPEG DASH with H.265 (HEVC) with HTML5
The Perfect Storm MPEG DASH with H.265 (HEVC) with HTML5
Online Bitrate ladder prediction for Adaptive VVC Streaming
Online Bitrate ladder prediction for Adaptive VVC Streaming
The impact of jitter on the HEVC video streaming with Multiple Coding
The impact of jitter on the HEVC video streaming with Multiple Coding
The next generation of protocols and APIs that could change streaming video
The next generation of protocols and APIs that could change streaming video
More from Alpen-Adria-Universität
In HTTP adaptive live streaming applications, video segments are encoded at a fixed set of bitrate-resolution pairs known as bitrate ladder. Live encoders use the fastest available encoding configuration, referred to as preset, to ensure the minimum possible latency in video encoding. However, an optimized preset and optimized number of CPU threads for each encoding instance may result in (i) increased quality and (ii) efficient CPU utilization while encoding. For low latency live encoders, the encoding speed is expected to be more than or equal to the video framerate. To this light, this paper introduces a Just Noticeable Difference (JND)-Aware Low latency Encoding Scheme (JALE), which uses random forest-based models to jointly determine the optimized encoder preset and thread count for each representation, based on video complexity features, the target encoding speed, the total number of available CPU threads, and the target encoder. Experimental results show that, on average, JALE yield a quality improvement of 1.32 dB PSNR and 5.38 VMAF points with the same bitrate, compared to the fastest preset encoding of the HTTP Live Streaming (HLS) bitrate ladder using x265 HEVC open-source encoder with eight CPU threads used for each representation. These enhancements are achieved while maintaining the desired encoding speed. Furthermore, on average, JALE results in an overall storage reduction of 72.70%, a reduction in the total number of CPU threads used by 63.83%, and a 37.87% reduction in the overall encoding time, considering a JND of six VMAF points.Optimal Quality and Efficiency in Adaptive Live Streaming with JND-Aware Low ...
Optimal Quality and Efficiency in Adaptive Live Streaming with JND-Aware Low ...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Quality of Experience (QoE) and QoE models are of an increasing importance to networked systems. The traditional QoE modeling for video streaming applications builds a one-size-fits-all QoE model that underserves atypical viewers who perceive QoE differently. To address the problem of atypical viewers, this paper proposes iQoE (individualized QoE), a method that employs explicit, expressible, and actionable feedback from a viewer to construct a personalized QoE model for this viewer. The iterative iQoE design exercises active learning and combines a novel sampler with a modeler. The chief emphasis of our paper is on making iQoE sample-efficient and accurate.
By leveraging the Microworkers crowdsourcing platform, we conduct studies with 120 subjects who provide 14,400 individual scores. According to the subjective studies, a session of about 22 minutes empowers a viewer to construct a personalized QoE model that, compared to the best of the 10 baseline models, delivers the average accuracy improvement of at least 42% for all viewers and at least 85% for the atypical viewers. The large-scale simulations based on a new technique of synthetic profiling expand the evaluation scope by exploring iQoE design choices, parameter sensitivity, and generalizability.Empowerment of Atypical Viewers via Low-Effort Personalized Modeling of Video...
Empowerment of Atypical Viewers via Low-Effort Personalized Modeling of Video...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Quality of Experience (QoE) and QoE models are of an increasing importance to networked systems. The traditional QoE modeling for video streaming applications builds a one-size-fits-all QoE model that underserves atypical viewers who perceive QoE differently. To address the problem of atypical viewers, this paper proposes iQoE (individualized QoE), a method that employs explicit, expressible, and actionable feedback from a viewer to construct a personalized QoE model for this viewer. The iterative iQoE design exercises active learning and combines a novel sampler with a modeler. The chief emphasis of our paper is on making iQoE sample-efficient and accurate.
By leveraging the Microworkers crowdsourcing platform, we conduct studies with 120 subjects who provide 14,400 individual scores. According to the subjective studies, a session of about 22 minutes empowers a viewer to construct a personalized QoE model that, compared to the best of the 10 baseline models, delivers the average accuracy improvement of at least 42% for all viewers and at least 85% for the atypical viewers. The large-scale simulations based on a new technique of synthetic profiling expand the evaluation scope by exploring iQoE design choices, parameter sensitivity, and generalizability.Empowerment of Atypical Viewers via Low-Effort Personalized Modeling of Vid...
Empowerment of Atypical Viewers via Low-Effort Personalized Modeling of Vid...Alpen-Adria-Universität
HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) methods divide a video into smaller segments, encoded at multiple pre-defined bitrates to construct a bitrate ladder. Bitrate ladders are usually optimized per title over several dimensions, such as bitrate, resolution, and framerate. This paper adds a new dimension to the bitrate ladder by considering the energy consumption of the encoding process. Video encoders often have multiple pre-defined presets to balance the trade-off between encoding time, energy consumption, and compression efficiency. Faster presets disable certain coding tools defined by the codec to reduce the encoding time at the cost of reduced compression efficiency. Firstly, this paper evaluates the energy consumption and compression efficiency of different x265 presets for 500 video sequences. Secondly, optimized presets are selected for various representations in a bitrate ladder based on the results to guarantee a minimal drop in video quality while saving energy. Finally, a new per-title model, which optimizes the trade-off between compression efficiency and energy consumption, is proposed. The experimental results show that decreasing the VMAF score by 0.15 and 0.39 while choosing an optimized preset results in encoding energy savings of 70% and 83%, respectively.Optimizing Video Streaming for Sustainability and Quality: The Role of Prese...
Optimizing Video Streaming for Sustainability and Quality: The Role of Prese...Alpen-Adria-Universität
With the emergence of multiple modern video codecs, streaming service providers are forced to encode, store, and transmit bitrate ladders of multiple codecs separately, consequently suffering from additional energy costs for encoding, storage, and transmission.
To tackle this issue, we introduce an online energy-efficient Multi-Codec Bitrate ladder Estimation scheme (MCBE) for adaptive video streaming applications. In MCBE, quality representations within the bitrate ladder of new-generation codecs (e.g., HEVC, AV1) that lie below the predicted rate-distortion curve of the AVC codec are removed. Moreover, perceptual redundancy between representations of the bitrate ladders of the considered codecs is also minimized based on a Just Noticeable Difference (JND) threshold. Therefore, random forest-based models predict the VMAF of bitrate ladder representations of each codec. In a live streaming session where all clients support the decoding of AVC, HEVC, and AV1, MCBE achieves impressive results, reducing cumulative encoding energy by 56.45%, storage energy usage by 94.99%, and transmission energy usage by 77.61% (considering a JND of six VMAF points). These energy reductions are in comparison to a baseline bitrate ladder encoding based on current industry practice.Energy-Efficient Multi-Codec Bitrate-Ladder Estimation for Adaptive Video Str...
Energy-Efficient Multi-Codec Bitrate-Ladder Estimation for Adaptive Video Str...Alpen-Adria-Universität
This paper presents UtilML, a novel approach for tackling resource utilization prediction challenges in the computing continuum. UtilML leverages Long-Short-Term Memory (LSTM) neural networks, a machine learning technique, to forecast resource utilization accurately. The effectiveness of UtilML is demonstrated through its evaluation of data extracted from a real GPU cluster in a computing continuum infrastructure comprising more than 1800 computing devices. To assess the performance of UtilML, we compared it with two related approaches that utilize a Baseline-LSTM model. Furthermore, we analyzed the LSTM results against User-Predicted values provided by GPU cluster owners for task deployment with estimated allocation values. The results indicate that UtilML outperformed user predictions by 2% to 27% for CPU utilization prediction. For memory prediction, UtilML variants excelled, showing improvements of 17% to 20% compared to user predictions.Machine Learning Based Resource Utilization Prediction in the Computing Conti...
Machine Learning Based Resource Utilization Prediction in the Computing Conti...Alpen-Adria-Universität
Multimedia applications, mainly video streaming services, are currently the dominant source of network load worldwide. In recent Video-on-Demand (VoD) and live video streaming services, traditional streaming delivery techniques have been replaced by adaptive solutions based on the HTTP protocol. Current trends toward high-resolution (e.g., 8K) and/or low- latency VoD and live video streaming pose new challenges to end-to-end (E2E) bandwidth demand and have stringent delay requirements. To do this, video providers typically rely on Content Delivery Networks (CDNs) to ensure that they provide scalable video streaming services. To support future streaming scenarios involving millions of users, it is necessary to increase the CDNs’ efficiency. It is widely agreed that these requirements may be satisfied by adopting emerging networking techniques to present Network-Assisted Video Streaming (NAVS) methods. Motivated by this, this thesis goes one step beyond traditional pure client- based HAS algorithms by incorporating (an) in-network component(s) with a broader view of the network to present completely transparent NAVS solutions for HAS clients.Network-Assisted Delivery of Adaptive Video Streaming Services through CDN, S...
Network-Assisted Delivery of Adaptive Video Streaming Services through CDN, S...Alpen-Adria-Universität
The considerable surge in energy consumption within data centers can be attributed to the exponential rise in demand for complex computing workflows and storage resources. Video streaming applications are both compute and storage-intensive and account for the majority of today’s internet services. In this work, we designed a video encoding application consisting of codec, bitrate, and resolution set for encoding a video segment. Then, we propose VE-Match, a matching-based method to schedule video encoding applications on both Cloud and Edge resources to optimize costs and energy consumption. Evaluation results on a real computing testbed federated between Amazon Web Services (AWS) EC2 Cloud instances and the Alpen-Adria University (AAU) Edge server reveal that VE-Match achieves lower costs by 17%-78% in the cost-optimized scenarios compared to the energy-optimized and tradeoff between cost and energy. Moreover, VE-Match improves the video encoding energy consumption by 38%-45% and gCO2 emission by up to 80 % in the energy-optimized scenarios compared to the cost-optimized and tradeoff between cost and energy.VE-Match: Video Encoding Matching-based Model for Cloud and Edge Computing In...
VE-Match: Video Encoding Matching-based Model for Cloud and Edge Computing In...Alpen-Adria-Universität
The rapid growth of video streaming usage is a significant source of energy consumption, driven by improved internet connections and service offerings, the quick development of video entertainment, the deployment of Ultra High-Definition, Virtual and Augmented Reality, as well as an increasing number of video surveillance and IoT applications. To address this challenge, it is essential to understand the various components involved in energy consumption during video streaming, ranging from video encoding to decoding and displaying the video on the end user’s screen. Then, it is critical to measure energy consumption for each component accurately and conduct an in-depth analysis to develop energy-efficient strategies that optimize video streaming [1, 2, 3]. These components are classified into three categories [4]: (i) data centers, which include encoding, packaging, and storage on cloud data centers; (ii) networks, which include core network and access networks; and (iii) end-user devices which involve decoding, players, hardware, etc.
In addition to identifying the primary components of video streaming that affect energy consumption, it is important to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the entire video streaming. It is also essential to balance energy optimization and service quality to ensure that energyefficient strategies are implemented without sacrificing the quality of video streaming services.
This talk aims to provide insights into the components of video streaming that contribute to energy consumption and highlight the challenges associated with measuring their energy usage. I will also introduce the tools that can be used for energy measurements for those components and the possible and associated strategies that lie within energy efficiency. By accurately measuring energy consumption, digital media companies can effectively monitor and control their energy usage, ultimately leading to cost savings and improved sustainability.Energy Consumption in Video Streaming: Components, Measurements, and Strategies
Energy Consumption in Video Streaming: Components, Measurements, and StrategiesAlpen-Adria-Universität
The rapid growth of video streaming usage is a significant source of energy consumption, driven by improved internet connections and service offerings, the quick development of video entertainment, the deployment of Ultra High-Definition, Virtual and Augmented Reality, as well as an increasing number of video surveillance and IoT applications. However, it is essential to note that these advancements come at the cost of energy consumption. To address this challenge, it is essential to understand the various components involved in energy consumption during video streaming, ranging from video encoding to decoding and displaying the video on the end user’s screen. Then, it is critical to accurately measure energy consumption for each component and conduct an in-depth analysis to develop energy-efficient strategies that optimize video streaming. I categorize these components into three categories: (i) data centers, (ii) networks, and (iii) end-user devices.
In this talk, my objective is to provide insights into the components of video streaming that contribute to energy consumption and highlight the challenges associated with measuring their energy usage. I will also introduce the tools that can be used for energy measurements for those components and the possible and associated strategies that lie within energy efficiency. By accurately measuring energy consumption, digital media companies can effectively monitor and control their energy usage, ultimately leading to cost savings and improved sustainability.Exploring the Energy Consumption of Video Streaming: Components, Challenges, ...
Exploring the Energy Consumption of Video Streaming: Components, Challenges, ...Alpen-Adria-Universität
More from Alpen-Adria-Universität (20)
VEED: Video Encoding Energy and CO2 Emissions Dataset for AWS EC2 instances
VEED: Video Encoding Energy and CO2 Emissions Dataset for AWS EC2 instances
GREEM: An Open-Source Energy Measurement Tool for Video Processing
GREEM: An Open-Source Energy Measurement Tool for Video Processing
Optimal Quality and Efficiency in Adaptive Live Streaming with JND-Aware Low ...
Optimal Quality and Efficiency in Adaptive Live Streaming with JND-Aware Low ...
VEEP: Video Encoding Energy and CO₂ Emission Prediction
VEEP: Video Encoding Energy and CO₂ Emission Prediction
Content-adaptive Video Coding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
Content-adaptive Video Coding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
Empowerment of Atypical Viewers via Low-Effort Personalized Modeling of Video...
Empowerment of Atypical Viewers via Low-Effort Personalized Modeling of Video...
Empowerment of Atypical Viewers via Low-Effort Personalized Modeling of Vid...
Empowerment of Atypical Viewers via Low-Effort Personalized Modeling of Vid...
Optimizing Video Streaming for Sustainability and Quality: The Role of Prese...
Optimizing Video Streaming for Sustainability and Quality: The Role of Prese...
Energy-Efficient Multi-Codec Bitrate-Ladder Estimation for Adaptive Video Str...
Energy-Efficient Multi-Codec Bitrate-Ladder Estimation for Adaptive Video Str...
Machine Learning Based Resource Utilization Prediction in the Computing Conti...
Machine Learning Based Resource Utilization Prediction in the Computing Conti...
Evaluation of Quality of Experience of ABR Schemes in Gaming Stream
Evaluation of Quality of Experience of ABR Schemes in Gaming Stream
Network-Assisted Delivery of Adaptive Video Streaming Services through CDN, S...
Network-Assisted Delivery of Adaptive Video Streaming Services through CDN, S...
Multi-access Edge Computing for Adaptive Video Streaming
Multi-access Edge Computing for Adaptive Video Streaming
Policy-Driven Dynamic HTTP Adaptive Streaming Player Environment
Policy-Driven Dynamic HTTP Adaptive Streaming Player Environment
VE-Match: Video Encoding Matching-based Model for Cloud and Edge Computing In...
VE-Match: Video Encoding Matching-based Model for Cloud and Edge Computing In...
Energy Consumption in Video Streaming: Components, Measurements, and Strategies
Energy Consumption in Video Streaming: Components, Measurements, and Strategies
Exploring the Energy Consumption of Video Streaming: Components, Challenges, ...
Exploring the Energy Consumption of Video Streaming: Components, Challenges, ...
Optimizing QoE and Latency of Live Video Streaming Using Edge Computing a...
Optimizing QoE and Latency of Live Video Streaming Using Edge Computing a...
SARENA: SFC-Enabled Architecture for Adaptive Video Streaming Applications
SARENA: SFC-Enabled Architecture for Adaptive Video Streaming Applications
Immersive Video Delivery: From Omnidirectional Video to Holography
Immersive Video Delivery: From Omnidirectional Video to Holography
Recently uploaded
Recently uploaded (20)
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine KG and Vector search for enhanced R...
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine KG and Vector search for enhanced R...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
Strategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot Takeoff
Strategize a Smooth Tenant-to-tenant Migration and Copilot Takeoff
Understanding Discord NSFW Servers A Guide for Responsible Users.pdf
Understanding Discord NSFW Servers A Guide for Responsible Users.pdf
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Civil Lines Women Seeking Men
Strategies for Landing an Oracle DBA Job as a Fresher
Strategies for Landing an Oracle DBA Job as a Fresher
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Friends Colony Women Seeking Men
Towards Optimal Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming
- 1. All rights reserved. ©2020 All rights reserved. ©2020 Towards Optimal Multirate Encoding for HTTP Adaptive Streaming Hadi Amirpour, Ekrem Çetinkaya, Christian Timmerer, and Mohammad Ghanbari June 2021 1 27th International Conference on Multimedia Modeling
- 2. All rights reserved. ©2020 ● Introduction ● HTTP adaptive streaming ● Fast multirate encoding ● Experimental results ● Conclusion All rights reserved. ©2020 2
- 3. Introduction In HAS: ● a video source is split into segments ● each segment is encoded at multiple bitrates ● compatibility with network condition is increased 3
- 5. Introduction ● HEVC improve the encoding efficiency compared to AVC ● This improvement is achieved at a cost of significant increased time-complexity ● This is even more crucial for DASH-based content providers as it requires to encode multiple representations of the same video content. 5
- 6. Fast multirate encoding Double-bound [1] [1] H. Amirpour, E. Çetinkaya, C. Timmerer and M. Ghanbari, "Fast Multi-rate Encoding for Adaptive HTTP Streaming," In Proceedings of the 2020 Data Compression Conference (DCC), Snowbird, UT, USA, 2020, pp. 358-358. 6 reference dependent reference dependent
- 7. Fast multirate encoding 7 reference dependent