The document discusses social media and social capital. It defines social capital as the resources from relationships and networks. It explores how Pierre Bourdieu viewed social capital as reproducing social relationships and mutual recognition. The document also examines how students use social media strategically to connect with potential employers and find placements or jobs in the media industry through platforms like Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and LinkedIn. Students recognize the need to curate separate personal and professional profiles online.
2. How being social connects us together and
the role Social Media plays in that.
– Social Capital
– The Networked Audience
– How students use Social Media
7. “Social capital is the sum of the resources,
actual or virtual, that accrue to an individual
or a group by virtue of possessing a durable
network of more or less institutionalized
relationships of mutual acquaintance and
recognition.”
(Bourdieu, in Bourdieu & Wacquant, 1992: 119)
8. Bourdieu
Groups are formed from social norms
Aimed at reproducing or establishing social
relationships “implying durable obligations
subjectively felt”
Produces mutual knowledge and recognition
10. Social Capital as a civic good
“social capital is a resource based on trust
and shared values, and develops from the
weaving-together of people in communities”
(Gaunlett on Coleman 2011)
11. Social Capital enhancing economic capital
“If you burn social capital to get a few more
people into your community, what good is
that? Ask yourself seriously whether you’re
being humble and honest” – Chris Brogan
15. Granovetter / Putnam
Granovetter (1973): ‘Weak ties’
indispensible to individuals’ opportunities
and their integration into communities. (P1378)
Putnam (2000): ‘bridging’ social capital can
generate reciprocity. “Distant acquaintances
in different circles” (P23)
16.
17. How my twitter followers
follow each other – who is
influential?
http://blog.ouseful.info/2011/06/11/a-map-of-my-twitter-follower-network/
18. Recent mentions of @daveharte
on twitter
How people are connected to
each other
http://ouseful.open.ac.uk/twitter/friendviz.html?q=daveharte&typ=q
21. Social Capital and the web
Our networks as a resource
You have to give a bit to get something out
22. Measuring Social Capital online
“It might be more accurate to characterize
the individual activities of ranking, rating or
social networking, then, as moments of
experiential re-structuring”
Alison Hearn 2010
28. Someone working alone, with really
cheap tools, has a reasonable hope of
carving out enough of the cognitive
surplus, enough of the desire to
participate, enough of the collective
goodwill of the citizens, to create a
resource you couldn't have imagined
existing even five years ago.”
Clay Shirky
Cognitive
Surplus
32. MAC / Rodarte
Make-up inspired by Mexico
Nail Polish named after Juarez – known for the
disappearance of hundreds of women who
have been raped and murdered.
Beauty bloggers get a bit upset
Collaborated to respond simultaneously on a
single topic
Consumers as networked activists
33. MAC / Rodarte
Blogs
Free platforms (wordpress.com)
Link to others with similar interests
Create conversations
The media is listening
34. Gap
New logo
Some people didn’t like it
Said so on twitter #gaplogo
Soon, everyone didn’t like it….
Got changed back
35. Gap
Twitter hashtags #
Connecting the highly
networked and the less highly networked
Simple, text-based
Coolest networking tool out there
39. Students
Some things we learned from studying
Media students
How are students using social media to
network with the media industry?
40. Questionnaire
320 respondents (from about 400 possible
respondents)
Undergraduate Year 1 41.7%
Undergraduate Year 2 24.7%
Undergraduate Year 3 24%
Post graduate 9.6%
49. Finding Placements
24% had been successful in finding
placements or paid work, fairly equally
split between years
50. Qualitative Research
Personal versus Professional
‘ I tend to use Facebook for the more social side
of it, and Twitter for the more professional side
of it. My profile on Twitter and Facebook are
really different’ (1 Year)
st
51. Online Etiquette
‘if there’s an opportunity for a placement or a job,
that you do that formally through email or writing in
to them, that you don’t send an in-box message
and say, hi, do you remember me and can I have
that placement or whatever, because that isn’t
considered the done thing.’ (MA student)
52. Negative posts
‘He slagged him off quite a lot, said he was
addicted to drugs and stuff, which was all untrue.
He then spoke to someone at Radio 1, to try and
get some work experience. They saw that he was
on Twitter, went on that, saw a link to his blog,
went on that, read the blog and basically told him
where to go’. (2 Year)
nd
53. Creating rather than Consuming
‘if you’re interesting then people will follow you,
and if you’re not, no one will care’. (3 Year)
rd
‘it’s quite novel for people in industry at the
moment to see how we’re emerging as the sort of
digital native, that are used to this platform and
know how to interact with people on it.’ (2 Year)
nd
54. Bonding and Bridging Social Capital
Bonding social capital - Facebook:
‘really useful for Uni stuff, because everybody uses
it, so even if they don’t text you back, they will
look on Facebook. It’s easier to talk as a group
rather than individuals.’ (2 Year)
nd
56. Summary
The social web is about relationships, not
technology or apps or websites.
We need to invest time into maintaining those
relationships (building our ‘Social Capital’)
It’s terrifying, exciting and moving very very
quickly
Students are savvy and strategic
W hich is what is what I’d like to you about today. ‘how being social connect us together and w ha t that’s got to do with social media.
This is what we should try not to be – technologically determinist. The desire to be social isn’t created by the emergence of social media. Social contexts aren’t affected by these technologies. But the pace and the manner at which groups that use such technologies can cooperate and coordinate is shaped by these technologies. In t he examples we look at later, examples where there is resistance on display. The desire to resist isn ’ t as a result of the technology, but is the manner of the resistance, and its level of impact, is as a result of the technology. p19
This is what we should try not to be – technologically determinist. The desire to be social isn’t created by the emergence of social media. Social contexts aren’t affected by these technologies. But the pace and the manner at which groups that use such technologies can cooperate and coordinate is shaped by these technologies. In t he examples we look at later, examples where there is resistance on display. The desire to resist isn ’ t as a result of the technology, but is the manner of the resistance, and its level of impact, is as a result of the technology. p19
Let’s begin with a dead French Marxist.
Bourdieu, Pierre, and Wacquant, Loic J. D. (1992), An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Groups are formed from social norms They require investment Aimed at reproducing or establishing social relationships “implying durable obligations subjectively felt” Requires the ‘alchemy of consecration’ through exchange (of words, gifts, labor etc.) Produces mutual knowledge and recognition
This is how Bordieu viewed the concept but it’s been viewed in different ways by different commentators.
Taken from: http://www.makingisconnecting.org/gauntlett2011-extract-sc.pdf I can’t sell you my social capital. The trust I’ve built up can’t be passed on. Coleman saw the creation of social capital as a largely unintentional process, which arises from activities intended for other purposes.
F rom: http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=8AEzmaZsQ2M
“ In this age of reputational transparency, companies must expand their social networks and cultivate meaningful quality relationships with the people in those networks. They can do this, according to Hunt, by going above and beyond their profit driven mission and finding a ‘high end’, authentic, commitment to community (Hunt, 2009)” (in ‘Structuring feeling: Web 2.0, online ranking and rating, and the digital ‘reputation’ economy’ Alison Hearn www.ephemeraweb.org volume 10(3/4): 421-438
Tara Hunt 2009 – Cory Doctorow (2003) “ The operations of Disney World, in this glimpse into the near future, are administered by "ad-hocs", volunteer groups devoted to retaining the old-fashioned charms of the amusement park in a society that has otherwise undergone radical change. Now that you can back up the contents of your brain and download it into a fresh clone, death has become obsolete. And rather than acquiring wealth, people are concerned with earning Whuffie, a measure of good will and admiration among your fellow immortals.”
Jon Hickman – let me have his useful literature review. charts its uptake in US and UK policy.
Robert Putnam (looking scary) – Bowling Alone
Tony Hirst – Communications and Systems - OU
SMEs Colleagues No ‘real’ friends http://blog.ouseful.info/2011/04/12/using-protovis-to-visualise-connections-between-people-tweeting-a-particular-term/ - notes in the above M ore tools: http://mc539.posterous.com/45227147
I Tweet Honestly, I Tweet Passionately: Twitter Users, Context Collapse, and the Imagined Audience. published online 7 July 2010 New Media Society Alice E. Marwick and danah boyd - http://nms.sagepub.com/content/early/2010/06/22/1461444810365313 “ Lisa Ede and Andrea Lunsford (1984) distinguished further between the audience addressed – the actual readers of a piece of writing – and audience invoked, the audience constructed by the writer. Published writers are often told to tailor books to particular demographics; these ‘future readers’ are a fiction about the audience addressed.”
For Shirky a resource like wikipedia is the ultimate example of the power of that network.
https://docs.google.com/document/pub?id=1knTaNYIB8xZvOisopRfMpn18AyFXgF_Eh2OAfKqwC88 - list of blog posts about the MAC/Rodarte controversy
From http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5YGc4zOqozo 11 million views (150k on first day) Full Story: http://www.davecarrollmusic.com/story/united-breaks-guitars - In the spring of 2008, Sons of Maxwell were traveling to Nebraska for a one-week tour and my Taylor guitar was witnessed being thrown by United Airlines baggage handlers in Chicago. So I promised the last person to finally say no to compensation (Ms. Irlweg) that I would write and produce three songs about my experience with United Airlines and make videos for each to be viewed online by anyone in the world. Made 3 songs. First one widely covered by media. Eventually compensated not before United stock price dropped 10%
Videos: Carter2: 1:20 – 3:40 Kids – all Tim Berners-lee 9:12 – 11: 26 Phone review kid: start to 1:13 Ed Richards (PSB): 1:57 – 3:29 Shirky – 1:47 – 3:23