SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 40
Descargar para leer sin conexión
GOVERNANCE
      FOE?
 FRIEND OR
           #abcfriendorfoe

        An Energized Work Production
  Agile Business Conference / 11 Oct 2012
Simon Baker / @energizr
            




                                             Gus Power / @guspower
                                                       
                                          {first name}@energizedwork.com
                                                                 
                                                                 
                                                          #abcfriendorfoe




LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   2
✪ GOVERNANCE – FRIEND OR FOE?

Let’s try to reimagine governance.

Get past “if only…” 

Explore the “what if’s…” 

Ask “why the hell not?”


Think of it as an experiment.






  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   3
✪ AT THE END

/ Connect our experiences. 

/ Explore our own situations with others.

/ Discover the right questions to ask about governance.

/ Learn new insights we can take back to our workplaces. 

/ Establish links with people that last beyond this afternoon.






  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   4
Photo: http://www.flickr.com/photos/itupictures/
✪ WORLD CAFÉ




 LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   5
✪ THE POWER OF CONVERSATION

This is a workshop, so please talk to those around you. 

The plan is to have 4 conversations on different topics. 

If you think you know everything, or you just want to disagree then
it's not going to be beneficial to you. It’s not about winning or losing. 




  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   6
✪ SCHEDULE

14:55 – Introduction.

15:00 – Gambling.

15:20 – Value (discussion).

15:35 – Coffee.

15:50 – Value (rotation).

15:55 – People.

16:15 – Questions / Open discussion. 



  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   7
✪ 1. SET THE CONTEXT

/ 5 minutes.
/ We'll share our thinking on the topic, maybe pose some questions.
/ See the handout for a reminder.





  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   8
✪ 2. BEGIN THE CONVERSATION

/ 10 minutes.
/ Doodle and discuss.
/ Build up a picture.
/ Focus on what matters.





  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   9
✪ 3. MOVE TO ANOTHER TABLE

/ 5 minutes.
/ 1 or 2 hosts stay with the table.
/ The rest move to other tables.
/ Hosts present what was discussed. 





  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   10
http://www.flickr.com/photos/texaselephant/
✪ GAMBLING




 LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   11
✪ PURPOSE OF GOVERNANCE

The accepted purpose of governance is largely to monitor,
report on, and ensure that the specified requirements will
be delivered in the agreed timeframe and within the
agreed budget to realize the benefits stipulated in the
business case.




  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   12
✪ PURPOSE OF GOVERNANCE

And in so doing, to ensure processes are followed correctly,
standards are adhered to, and the software is produced to
an acceptable level of quality.





Gating and approving / Ensuring compliance to processes and standards / Controlling
budgets and headcount / Auditing and quality assurance reviews / Monitoring progress /
Reporting status / Managing issues and risks / Managing stakeholders




   LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   13
✪ UNDERSTAND THE GAMBLE

Capital investments are made in IT                                                                       £
projects on the merits of business cases
built on assumptions.
                                                                                                                      t

When we build a feature and delay
validating it with customers we’re
making a bet that it’s “right”. What if
we’re wrong? 

Every feature done this way ups the ante
                                                                                                                   Increasing inventory
until we’re betting the budget on a                                                                                Increasing investment
big-bang release.
                                                                                                 Bigger and bigger bet




  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM    14
✪ MORE CONTROL DOESN’T REDUCE THE BET

Optimizing productivity so that projects aren’t late or over budget doesn’t
address the big risks in the following assumptions:

/ The requirements define the right solution.
/ All requirements must be delivered before any value can be realized 
  (all or nothing).
/ If all requirements are delivered, the value will be realized.








  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   15
✪ SMALL BETS

Can we deliver less without delivering too little?

Why not make smaller bets and find out?

Bet what we can afford to lose 
        £
and get faster feedback to
prove earlier what’s valuable 
and what’s not valuable.
                                                                                                                    t

Let’s be a bit more scientific.


                                          Less inventory; regular releases

                                          Series of small investments
                                           Small bets




  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM        16
✪ INCREMENTAL INVESTMENTS

Why not make smaller incremental capital and operational
investments based on business measurements? 

/ Business service cash flows.
       £
/ Portfolio performance.
/ Risk exposure.
/ Impending obsolescence.
                                                     Profitable
/ Cost of delay.

                                                                       t
Use fast actuals, flash forecasts 
                                                           Break-even
and moving averages in a rolling
review to inform continuous 
re-evaluation and prioritization.
       Self-funding




 LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   17
✪ MORE BENEFICIAL GOVERNANCE

The compelling opportunity for governance is to help business
investors make investments that maximize business performance. 

The portfolio is of business services and not IT projects.







  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   18
✪ BLOWING YOURSELF UP

1. 
No edge.
2. 
No planning.
3. 
Wrong bet size.
4. 
No risk management.
5. 
Mistiming exits.
6. 
Out of control.
7. 
Not in tune with the market.
8. 
Running before walking.
9. 
Emotionally unstable.
10. 
Not taking responsibility.

Source: The Financial Spread Betting Handbook by Malcolm Pryor.




    LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   19
✪ VALUE




 LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   20
✪ TIME, COST, SCOPE, QUALITY. VALUE?

The word ‘value’ is used extensively. And
                                                                                                                                  Scope
ambiguously. 

Value needs to be defined, quantified
and measured. When it’s not we’re left in                                                                                  Compromise
                                                                                                                             Quality
a subjective argument about scope and
cost – “delivery should be quicker,                                                                       Cost
                             Time
cheaper; more features should be
                                                                                                                             Vary Scope
delivered in the same time-frame for the
same cost.”

Backlogs have become the new functional
                                                                                                                                 Quality
specification.



 LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM           21
✪ FIT FOR PURPOSE AND FIT FOR USE

The focus is on functionality but how well are the functions performed?



                 Condition




                                                                                                                                            Condition
                                Resource
                              FUNCTION                             Performance




                                                                         Design
                                                                      (Architecture)
                                                         Source: Competitive Engineering, Tom Gilb




  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM                22
✪ QUALITY CAN ONLY TAKE SO MUCH ABUSE

To meet unrealistic time and                                                                                  Availability
cost constraints corners are     Workload
cut, especially on those          Capacity
                                                                                                 Resilience
qualities not being measured
or easily determined. 

                            Resource
                                                                                                           Flexibility
                                                                          Saving



                                                                                Usability
                                                  Interoperability

                                                                                                          Upgradeability


                                                                                                                   Expected
                                                                                                                   Actual


  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM                 23
✪ KNOWLEDGE WORKER PRODUCTIVITY

A commonly held assumption is that to get the most out of your
investment utilization needs to be at or as near to 100% as possible.
Idle resources, equipment or people are wasted investment. 

Effort is often confused with progress. Progress is often confused
with value.

Knowledge workers are described as people who “think for a living”. 
How do you measure thinking?







  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   24
✪ KEEP THE PORTFOLIO RELEVANT

Governance must ensure the portfolio stays relevant. 

We have to innovate to stay relevant – to continue to solve problems
that people will pay to have solved.

If the medium and long terms are 18 months and 5 years we face a
problem when the typical employee tenure is less than this. 

Not only does our knowledge become obsolete as markets and
technologies change, but knowledge literally walks out the door.




  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   25
http://www.flickr.com/photos/75724809@N05/
✪ PEOPLE




 LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   26
✪ CREATING REALITY MISMATCHES

Governance attempts to manage the portfolio day-to-day and balance
business investors’ perceptions and situations in the delivery teams.

With the best will in the world, trying to protect both sides, we can end
up creating a mismatch. When we do so we become over-responsible.




  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   27
✪ RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT?

/ Responsible for the successful delivery of the projects in the portfolio? 
/ Answerable to business investors and stakeholders for the actual value
realized? 
/ Accountable to delivery teams for providing sufficient resources to
enable them to be successful?
/ Responsible for risk management and mitigation?

Can we design ways to equitably share the risk and responsibility
between governance, stakeholders and delivery teams?





  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   28
✪ COMPLEXITY IS NOISY

Getting a clear view and tangible
                                                                                                                    Stakeholder
measures of what’s happening                                                                                        perception
across a portfolio is hard.
                                                                     Time to

                                                                                                market
                                                                                                                                             Team
Just getting the mechanics done,                                                     Adherence
                     Stakeholders
like forecasting, budgeting and                                                         to plan
                                                  Morale
staffing, is a full-time job. And the                                              Objectives
                                                                                                                Plans
 Requirements
 Production
amount of data generated with                                                                                                        incidents
                                                                                     Budget /
varying quality can get                                                              burn rate
overwhelming.
                                                                                                          Designs
                                                                                                                                                 Defects
                                                                                        Technology

                                                                                                                                            Operating cost
Can governance help reduce the                                                          Dependencies
noise?
                                                                                                                Legacy
                                                                                                                    integrations



  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM                     29
✪ CLASH OR GAPS?

/ Trust people to get the job done.
/ Working software is the primary measure of progress.
/ The best means of communication is via face-to-face conversations.
/ The best architectures and designs emerge from self-organizing teams.

Are agile principles practical, even applicable for governance?

How practical is it to value “individuals and interactions over processes
and tools” when the portfolio ‘employs’ 10,000 people? 





  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   30
✪ OPERATING AT SCALE

An individual can only handle so many interactions. In a portfolio that
‘employs’ 10,000 people, we have to limit the number of people we
work with day-to-day. 

We end up relying on activity reports and assurances from individuals
representing groups of people, like project managers representing
delivery teams.

Scale pushes governance further away from the work.






  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   31
✪ CONTINUOUSLY IMPROVING GOVERNANCE

How can we measure the value and effectiveness of governance? 

How do we improve it? 

This is expected of operational and delivery teams. Why are the same
standards not applied to governance?




  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   32
✪ DISCUSSION
                                                                    Questions?
                                                                                 Share your thoughts.




 LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   33
Thank you for participating.
                                         
               If you’d be interested in a second café workshop
            looking at the financial and risk elements of governance 
         please leave your business card or name and email address.
                                         
                                         
                                         
                                 #abcfriendorfoe
                             @energizr / @guspower




LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   34
Limited
Governance – Friend or Foe by Energized Work Limited is licensed under
  a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License
                                                            License.

                                                   You are free:
                                                     
                                                   To share – to copy, distribute and transmit the work
                                                   
                                                   To remix – to adapt the work
                                                   
                                                   Under the following conditions:
                                                   
                                                   Attribution – You must attribute the work in the 
                                                   manner specified by Energized Work (but not in any 
                                                   way that suggests that Energized Work endorse 
                                                   you or your use of the work).
                                                   
                                                   Share Alike – If you alter, transform, or build upon 
                                                   this work, you may distribute the resulting work only 
                                                   under the same or similar license to this one. 

  LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   35
✪ WELCOME TO THE WORLD CAFE

1
   SET THE CONTEXT
                                                                   3
    MOVE TO ANOTHER TABLE
     / 5 minutes.
                                                                             / 5 minutes.
     / Speakers share their thinking 
                                                         / 1 or 2 hosts stay with the table.
       on a topic and ask questions.
                                                          / The rest move to other tables.
     / See handout for a reminder.
                                                            / Hosts present what was 
                                                                                                 discussed. 
                                                                                               

2
   BEGIN THE CONVERSATION
     / 10 minutes.
     / Doodle and discuss.
     / Build up a picture.
     / Focus on what matters.




 LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM   36
✪ GAMBLING
PURPOSE OF GOVERNANCE
                    UNDERSTAND THE GAMBLE
                         SMALL BETS
                                   INCREMENTAL INVESTMENTS
The accepted purpose of                   Capital investments are made                   Betting the budget on a big-                  / Business service cash flows.
governance is largely to monitor,         in IT projects on the merits of                bang release is like betting all              / Portfolio performance.
report on, and ensure that the            business cases built on                        our money on hitting a hole-in-               / Risk exposure.
specified requirements will be             assumptions. When we build a                   one. Can we do less without                   / Impending obsolescence.
delivered in the agreed                   feature and delay validating it                doing too little? 
                           / Cost of delay.
timeframe and within the agreed           with customers we’re making a                  
                                             
budget to realize the benefits             bet that the feature is “right”.               
 £
                                          
stipulated in the business case.
         What if we’re wrong? 
                         
                                             
 £

                                         
    £
                                        
                                             
                                                                                                                                 t
And in so doing, to ensure                
                                              
                                             
processes are followed correctly,         
                                              
                                             
               Profitable
                                                                           t
standards are adhered to, and             
                                              
                                             
the software is produced to an            
                                              
     Less inventory; regular releases
       
                                t
                                                                                               Series of small investments
acceptable level of quality.
             
                                              
     Small bets
                             
                      Break-even

                                         
                                              
                                             
MORE BENEFICIAL                           
                                              
                                             
GOVERANCE
                                
                                              Make small bets based on what                 
      Self-funding
The compelling opportunity for            
         Increasing inventory
                we can afford to lose to prove                
governance is to help business            
         Increasing investment
               earlier what’s valuable and                   Use fast actuals, flash forecasts
                                                    Bigger and bigger bet
investors make investments that           
                                              what’s not valuable.
                         and moving averages in a rolling
maximize business                         
                                                                                            review to inform continuous re-
performance. This requires the            Every feature done this way ups                                                              evaluation and prioritization.
portfolio to be of business               the ante until we’re betting the
services and not IT projects.
            budget on a big-bang

                                         release.

                                                                                                       COMMON SPREAD BETTING ERRORS
CONTROL DOESN’T GUARANTEE VALUE

                                                                                                        
Optimizing productivity so that projects aren’t late or over budget doesn’t

                                                                                                                               6. Out of control.
                                                                                                        1. No edge.
address the big risks in these assumptions:

                                                                                                       2. No planning.
        7. Not in tune with the market.
/ The requirements define the right solution.
                                                           3. Wrong bet size.
     8. Running before walking.
/ All requirements must be delivered before any value can be realized 
                                 4. No risk management.
 9. Emotionally unstable.
  (all or nothing).
                                                                                    5. Mistiming exits.
    10. Not taking responsibility.
/ If all requirements are delivered, the value will be realized.
                                       

     LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM                          37
✪ VALUE
TIME, COST, SCOPE, QUALITY.                 FIT FOR PURPOSE. FIT FOR USE
                                                                 KNOWLEDGE WORKER
VALUE?
                                     The focus is on functionality but how well are the functions performed?
                      PRODUCTIVITY
The word ‘value’ is used                    
                                                                                             A commonly held assumption is
extensively. And ambiguously. 
             
                                                                                             that to get the most out of your

                                           
                                                                                             investment utilization needs to be




                                             Condition




                                                                                                                             Condition
Value needs to be defined,                                                                                                                 at or as near to 100% as possible.
quantified and measured. When                                Resource
               FUNCTION             Performance
                     Idle resources, equipment or
it’s not we’re left in a subjective                                                                                                       people are wasted investment.
argument about scope and cost –                                                                                                           Effort is often confused with
“delivery should be quicker,                                                                                                              p ro g re s s . P ro g re s s i s o f t e n
cheaper; more features should be                                                      Design                                              confused with value.
delivered in the same time-frame                                                   (Architecture)                                         
for the same cost.”
                                                   Source: Competitive Engineering, Tom Gilb                          Knowledge workers are described

                                                                                                                                         as people who “think for a living”.
Backlogs have become the new                                                                                                              How can you tell if someone is
functional specification.
                   QUALITY CAN ONLY TAKE SO MUCH ABUSE
                                                          thinking? How do you measure it?

                                           To meet unrealistic time and cost constraints corners are cut,                                

                                           especially on those qualities not being measured or easily                                    
                                                                                                                                          KEEP THE PORTFOLIO

              Scope
                                                                                                                     
                                            determined. 
                                                                                 RELEVANT
                                            
                                                                                             
                                                                                                                                          Governance must ensure the
                                            
                    Availability
                                                            
                                                                                                 Expected
                                portfolio stays relevant. We have to
                                            
    Workload
                                                                                                                                          
                                                                                                                                          innovate to stay relevant – to
                                                                                               Resilience
         Actual
                
            Compromise                                    Capacity
                                                                       continue to solve problems that
              Quality
                                                                                                                    
                                                                                                                                          people will pay to have solved.
                                                                                                                                          
   Cost
                        Time
                                                                                                     If the medium and long terms are
                                            Resource
                                               Flexibility
                                              Saving
                                                                                                                                          18 months and 5 years we face a
             Vary Scope
                                                                                                                  problem when the typical employee
                                                                                                                                          tenure is less than this. Not only
                                                                                                                                          does our knowledge become
                                                          Usability
                          Interoperability
                           obsolete as markets and
                                                                                                                                          technologies change, but
                                                                           Upgradeability
                                                knowledge literally walks out
                Quality
                                                                                                                                          the door.

                                                                                                                                          
     LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM                                        38
✪ PEOPLE
CREATING REALITY                         COMPLEXITY IS NOISY
                                           Stakeholder
MISMATCHES
                              Getting a clear view and tangible                               perception
Governance attempts to                   measures of what’s happening                      Time to
                                                                                            market
manage the portfolio day-to-day          across a portfolio is hard. Just                                                Team
and balance business investors’          getting the mechanics done, like            Adherence
         Stakeholders
perceptions and situations in the        forecasting, budgeting and                     to plan
                                 Morale
delivery teams.
                         staffing, is a full-time job. And

                                        the amount of data generated              Objectives
                                                                                                      Plans
 Requirements
       Production
With the best will in the world,         with varying quality can get                                                            incidents
trying to protect both sides, we         overwhelming.
                             Budget /
                                                                                    burn rate
can end up creating a mismatch.          
                                                                                    Defects
When we do so we become                  Can governance help reduce the               Technology
                                                                                                          Designs
over-responsible.
                       noise?
                                                                                                                        Operating cost
                                         
                                                                                       Dependencies
RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT?
                   
                                         CLASH OR GAPS?
                                                              Legacy
/ Responsible for the successful         / Trust people to get the job                                             integrations
delivery of the projects in the          done.
portfolio? 
                             / Working software is the primary
                                                                                            OPERATING AT SCALE
/ Answerable to business                 measure of progress.
                                                                                            An individual can only handle so many interactions. In a portfolio
investors and stakeholders for           / The best means of
the actual value realized? 
             communication is via face-to-                      that ‘employs’ 10,000 people, we have to limit the number of
/ Accountable to delivery teams          face conversations.
                               people we work with day-to-day. We end up relying on activity
for providing sufficient resources        / The best architectures and                       reports and assurances from individuals representing groups of
to enable them to be                     designs emerge from self-                          people, like project managers representing delivery teams.
successful?
                             organizing teams.
                                 
/ Responsible for risk                   
                                                  Scale pushes governance further away from the work.
management and mitigation?
              Are agile principles practical,                    

                                        even applicable for governance?
                   
Can we design ways to                    
                                                  CONTINUOUSLY IMPROVING GOVERNANCE
equitably share the risk and             How practical is it to value                       How can we measure the value and effectiveness of governance?
responsibility between                   “individuals and interactions over                 How do we improve it? 
governance, stakeholders and             processes and tools” when the                      
delivery teams?
                         portfolio ‘employs’ 10,000                         This is expected of operational and delivery teams. Why are the

                                        people? 
                                          same standards not applied to governance?

                                        

     LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM                    39
Energized Work Ltd
                                                                                                                                          HMS President
                                                                                                                                          Victoria Embankment
                                                                                                                                          London EC4Y 0HJ
                                                                                                                                          www.energizedwork.com
LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM                        40

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Governance - Friend or Foe?

In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewN_Duffield
 
InTechnology Overview
InTechnology OverviewInTechnology Overview
InTechnology Overviewmerlinjenks
 
In Technology Company Overview
In Technology   Company OverviewIn Technology   Company Overview
In Technology Company OverviewRomzan
 
In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overviewgregc65x
 
In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overviewcarlmortimer
 
Startup funding options for Student Entrepreneurs
Startup funding options for Student EntrepreneursStartup funding options for Student Entrepreneurs
Startup funding options for Student EntrepreneursJohn Spindler
 
VC from the inside - a techie's perspective - Adrian Colyer
VC from the inside - a techie's perspective - Adrian ColyerVC from the inside - a techie's perspective - Adrian Colyer
VC from the inside - a techie's perspective - Adrian ColyerJAXLondon_Conference
 
K3 - John Spindler (CEO of Capital Enterprise)
K3 - John Spindler (CEO of Capital Enterprise)K3 - John Spindler (CEO of Capital Enterprise)
K3 - John Spindler (CEO of Capital Enterprise)pranavtulsian
 
The Clothesline Paradox and the Sharing Economy (Keynote file)
The Clothesline Paradox and the Sharing Economy (Keynote file)The Clothesline Paradox and the Sharing Economy (Keynote file)
The Clothesline Paradox and the Sharing Economy (Keynote file)Tim O'Reilly
 
MEGS-KT Lecture 2 Chris Newman Parity Projects 24th October 2012
MEGS-KT Lecture 2 Chris Newman Parity Projects 24th October 2012MEGS-KT Lecture 2 Chris Newman Parity Projects 24th October 2012
MEGS-KT Lecture 2 Chris Newman Parity Projects 24th October 2012Andrea Wheeler
 
Stratified medicine - How Can We Help Each Other
Stratified medicine  - How Can We Help Each OtherStratified medicine  - How Can We Help Each Other
Stratified medicine - How Can We Help Each OtherSpace IDEAS Hub
 
Webinar Economics of Scrum | 29th May 2020 | Xebia
Webinar Economics of Scrum | 29th May 2020 | XebiaWebinar Economics of Scrum | 29th May 2020 | Xebia
Webinar Economics of Scrum | 29th May 2020 | XebiaIrene de Kok
 
Open innovation in a globalized world @ IBM
Open innovation in a globalized world @ IBMOpen innovation in a globalized world @ IBM
Open innovation in a globalized world @ IBMAnders Quitzau
 
In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overviewscottamc26
 
In technology overview
In technology overviewIn technology overview
In technology overviewGareth Huxall
 
In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overviewscottamc26
 
Introduction to financial voodoo for startups
Introduction to financial voodoo for startupsIntroduction to financial voodoo for startups
Introduction to financial voodoo for startupsMichalGromek
 
Top Tips for a Successful 2016 in Construction Contract Management
Top Tips for a Successful 2016 in Construction Contract ManagementTop Tips for a Successful 2016 in Construction Contract Management
Top Tips for a Successful 2016 in Construction Contract ManagementEque2 Ltd
 

Similar a Governance - Friend or Foe? (20)

In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overview
 
InTechnology Overview
InTechnology OverviewInTechnology Overview
InTechnology Overview
 
In Technology Company Overview
In Technology   Company OverviewIn Technology   Company Overview
In Technology Company Overview
 
In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overview
 
In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overview
 
Startup funding options for Student Entrepreneurs
Startup funding options for Student EntrepreneursStartup funding options for Student Entrepreneurs
Startup funding options for Student Entrepreneurs
 
VC from the inside - a techie's perspective - Adrian Colyer
VC from the inside - a techie's perspective - Adrian ColyerVC from the inside - a techie's perspective - Adrian Colyer
VC from the inside - a techie's perspective - Adrian Colyer
 
K3 - John Spindler (CEO of Capital Enterprise)
K3 - John Spindler (CEO of Capital Enterprise)K3 - John Spindler (CEO of Capital Enterprise)
K3 - John Spindler (CEO of Capital Enterprise)
 
The Clothesline Paradox and the Sharing Economy (Keynote file)
The Clothesline Paradox and the Sharing Economy (Keynote file)The Clothesline Paradox and the Sharing Economy (Keynote file)
The Clothesline Paradox and the Sharing Economy (Keynote file)
 
MEGS-KT Lecture 2 Chris Newman Parity Projects 24th October 2012
MEGS-KT Lecture 2 Chris Newman Parity Projects 24th October 2012MEGS-KT Lecture 2 Chris Newman Parity Projects 24th October 2012
MEGS-KT Lecture 2 Chris Newman Parity Projects 24th October 2012
 
Stratified medicine - How Can We Help Each Other
Stratified medicine  - How Can We Help Each OtherStratified medicine  - How Can We Help Each Other
Stratified medicine - How Can We Help Each Other
 
CIPR Social Summer - 'Comms in Tight Times' Nick Jones, COI
CIPR Social Summer - 'Comms in Tight Times' Nick Jones, COICIPR Social Summer - 'Comms in Tight Times' Nick Jones, COI
CIPR Social Summer - 'Comms in Tight Times' Nick Jones, COI
 
Webinar Economics of Scrum | 29th May 2020 | Xebia
Webinar Economics of Scrum | 29th May 2020 | XebiaWebinar Economics of Scrum | 29th May 2020 | Xebia
Webinar Economics of Scrum | 29th May 2020 | Xebia
 
VENTACY
VENTACYVENTACY
VENTACY
 
Open innovation in a globalized world @ IBM
Open innovation in a globalized world @ IBMOpen innovation in a globalized world @ IBM
Open innovation in a globalized world @ IBM
 
In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overview
 
In technology overview
In technology overviewIn technology overview
In technology overview
 
In Technology Overview
In Technology OverviewIn Technology Overview
In Technology Overview
 
Introduction to financial voodoo for startups
Introduction to financial voodoo for startupsIntroduction to financial voodoo for startups
Introduction to financial voodoo for startups
 
Top Tips for a Successful 2016 in Construction Contract Management
Top Tips for a Successful 2016 in Construction Contract ManagementTop Tips for a Successful 2016 in Construction Contract Management
Top Tips for a Successful 2016 in Construction Contract Management
 

Más de Energized Work

Agile Practitioners Feedback to improve teams
Agile Practitioners Feedback to improve teamsAgile Practitioners Feedback to improve teams
Agile Practitioners Feedback to improve teamsEnergized Work
 
Experience report on agile tools for management teams
Experience report on agile tools for management teamsExperience report on agile tools for management teams
Experience report on agile tools for management teamsEnergized Work
 
Business model innovation by experimentation
Business model innovation by experimentationBusiness model innovation by experimentation
Business model innovation by experimentationEnergized Work
 
Debugging Grails Database Performance
Debugging Grails Database PerformanceDebugging Grails Database Performance
Debugging Grails Database PerformanceEnergized Work
 
MTBF / MTTR - Energized Work TekTalk, Mar 2012
MTBF / MTTR - Energized Work TekTalk, Mar 2012MTBF / MTTR - Energized Work TekTalk, Mar 2012
MTBF / MTTR - Energized Work TekTalk, Mar 2012Energized Work
 
Energized Work: Software that means business
Energized Work: Software that means businessEnergized Work: Software that means business
Energized Work: Software that means businessEnergized Work
 
Product Development in the Land of the Free - Energized Work Presentation
Product Development in the Land of the Free - Energized Work PresentationProduct Development in the Land of the Free - Energized Work Presentation
Product Development in the Land of the Free - Energized Work PresentationEnergized Work
 
Leaning - Energized Work Presentation
Leaning - Energized Work PresentationLeaning - Energized Work Presentation
Leaning - Energized Work PresentationEnergized Work
 

Más de Energized Work (9)

Agile Practitioners Feedback to improve teams
Agile Practitioners Feedback to improve teamsAgile Practitioners Feedback to improve teams
Agile Practitioners Feedback to improve teams
 
Surviving SOA
Surviving SOASurviving SOA
Surviving SOA
 
Experience report on agile tools for management teams
Experience report on agile tools for management teamsExperience report on agile tools for management teams
Experience report on agile tools for management teams
 
Business model innovation by experimentation
Business model innovation by experimentationBusiness model innovation by experimentation
Business model innovation by experimentation
 
Debugging Grails Database Performance
Debugging Grails Database PerformanceDebugging Grails Database Performance
Debugging Grails Database Performance
 
MTBF / MTTR - Energized Work TekTalk, Mar 2012
MTBF / MTTR - Energized Work TekTalk, Mar 2012MTBF / MTTR - Energized Work TekTalk, Mar 2012
MTBF / MTTR - Energized Work TekTalk, Mar 2012
 
Energized Work: Software that means business
Energized Work: Software that means businessEnergized Work: Software that means business
Energized Work: Software that means business
 
Product Development in the Land of the Free - Energized Work Presentation
Product Development in the Land of the Free - Energized Work PresentationProduct Development in the Land of the Free - Energized Work Presentation
Product Development in the Land of the Free - Energized Work Presentation
 
Leaning - Energized Work Presentation
Leaning - Energized Work PresentationLeaning - Energized Work Presentation
Leaning - Energized Work Presentation
 

Último

Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Servicecallgirls2057
 
Cyber Security Training in Office Environment
Cyber Security Training in Office EnvironmentCyber Security Training in Office Environment
Cyber Security Training in Office Environmentelijahj01012
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024Adnet Communications
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckHajeJanKamps
 
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdfShaun Heinrichs
 
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.Anamaria Contreras
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFGuide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFChandresh Chudasama
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxappkodes
 
Entrepreneurship lessons in Philippines
Entrepreneurship lessons in  PhilippinesEntrepreneurship lessons in  Philippines
Entrepreneurship lessons in PhilippinesDavidSamuel525586
 
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Americas Got Grants
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaoncallgirls2057
 
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737Riya Pathan
 

Último (20)

Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
 
Cyber Security Training in Office Environment
Cyber Security Training in Office EnvironmentCyber Security Training in Office Environment
Cyber Security Training in Office Environment
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
 
Call Us ➥9319373153▻Call Girls In North Goa
Call Us ➥9319373153▻Call Girls In North GoaCall Us ➥9319373153▻Call Girls In North Goa
Call Us ➥9319373153▻Call Girls In North Goa
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
 
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
 
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
 
No-1 Call Girls In Goa 93193 VIP 73153 Escort service In North Goa Panaji, Ca...
No-1 Call Girls In Goa 93193 VIP 73153 Escort service In North Goa Panaji, Ca...No-1 Call Girls In Goa 93193 VIP 73153 Escort service In North Goa Panaji, Ca...
No-1 Call Girls In Goa 93193 VIP 73153 Escort service In North Goa Panaji, Ca...
 
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information TechnologyCorporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
 
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFGuide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
 
Entrepreneurship lessons in Philippines
Entrepreneurship lessons in  PhilippinesEntrepreneurship lessons in  Philippines
Entrepreneurship lessons in Philippines
 
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCREnjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
 
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
 
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
 

Governance - Friend or Foe?

  • 1. GOVERNANCE FOE? FRIEND OR #abcfriendorfoe An Energized Work Production Agile Business Conference / 11 Oct 2012
  • 2. Simon Baker / @energizr Gus Power / @guspower {first name}@energizedwork.com #abcfriendorfoe LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 2
  • 3. ✪ GOVERNANCE – FRIEND OR FOE? Let’s try to reimagine governance. Get past “if only…” Explore the “what if’s…” Ask “why the hell not?” Think of it as an experiment. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 3
  • 4. ✪ AT THE END / Connect our experiences. / Explore our own situations with others. / Discover the right questions to ask about governance. / Learn new insights we can take back to our workplaces. / Establish links with people that last beyond this afternoon. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 4
  • 5. Photo: http://www.flickr.com/photos/itupictures/ ✪ WORLD CAFÉ LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 5
  • 6. ✪ THE POWER OF CONVERSATION This is a workshop, so please talk to those around you. The plan is to have 4 conversations on different topics. If you think you know everything, or you just want to disagree then it's not going to be beneficial to you. It’s not about winning or losing. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 6
  • 7. ✪ SCHEDULE 14:55 – Introduction. 15:00 – Gambling. 15:20 – Value (discussion). 15:35 – Coffee. 15:50 – Value (rotation). 15:55 – People. 16:15 – Questions / Open discussion. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 7
  • 8. ✪ 1. SET THE CONTEXT / 5 minutes. / We'll share our thinking on the topic, maybe pose some questions. / See the handout for a reminder. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 8
  • 9. ✪ 2. BEGIN THE CONVERSATION / 10 minutes. / Doodle and discuss. / Build up a picture. / Focus on what matters. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 9
  • 10. ✪ 3. MOVE TO ANOTHER TABLE / 5 minutes. / 1 or 2 hosts stay with the table. / The rest move to other tables. / Hosts present what was discussed. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 10
  • 11. http://www.flickr.com/photos/texaselephant/ ✪ GAMBLING LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 11
  • 12. ✪ PURPOSE OF GOVERNANCE The accepted purpose of governance is largely to monitor, report on, and ensure that the specified requirements will be delivered in the agreed timeframe and within the agreed budget to realize the benefits stipulated in the business case. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 12
  • 13. ✪ PURPOSE OF GOVERNANCE And in so doing, to ensure processes are followed correctly, standards are adhered to, and the software is produced to an acceptable level of quality. Gating and approving / Ensuring compliance to processes and standards / Controlling budgets and headcount / Auditing and quality assurance reviews / Monitoring progress / Reporting status / Managing issues and risks / Managing stakeholders LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 13
  • 14. ✪ UNDERSTAND THE GAMBLE Capital investments are made in IT £ projects on the merits of business cases built on assumptions. t When we build a feature and delay validating it with customers we’re making a bet that it’s “right”. What if we’re wrong? Every feature done this way ups the ante Increasing inventory until we’re betting the budget on a Increasing investment big-bang release. Bigger and bigger bet LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 14
  • 15. ✪ MORE CONTROL DOESN’T REDUCE THE BET Optimizing productivity so that projects aren’t late or over budget doesn’t address the big risks in the following assumptions: / The requirements define the right solution. / All requirements must be delivered before any value can be realized (all or nothing). / If all requirements are delivered, the value will be realized. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 15
  • 16. ✪ SMALL BETS Can we deliver less without delivering too little? Why not make smaller bets and find out? Bet what we can afford to lose £ and get faster feedback to prove earlier what’s valuable and what’s not valuable. t Let’s be a bit more scientific. Less inventory; regular releases Series of small investments Small bets LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 16
  • 17. ✪ INCREMENTAL INVESTMENTS Why not make smaller incremental capital and operational investments based on business measurements? / Business service cash flows. £ / Portfolio performance. / Risk exposure. / Impending obsolescence. Profitable / Cost of delay. t Use fast actuals, flash forecasts Break-even and moving averages in a rolling review to inform continuous re-evaluation and prioritization. Self-funding LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 17
  • 18. ✪ MORE BENEFICIAL GOVERNANCE The compelling opportunity for governance is to help business investors make investments that maximize business performance. The portfolio is of business services and not IT projects. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 18
  • 19. ✪ BLOWING YOURSELF UP 1. No edge. 2. No planning. 3. Wrong bet size. 4. No risk management. 5. Mistiming exits. 6. Out of control. 7. Not in tune with the market. 8. Running before walking. 9. Emotionally unstable. 10. Not taking responsibility. Source: The Financial Spread Betting Handbook by Malcolm Pryor. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 19
  • 20. ✪ VALUE LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 20
  • 21. ✪ TIME, COST, SCOPE, QUALITY. VALUE? The word ‘value’ is used extensively. And Scope ambiguously. Value needs to be defined, quantified and measured. When it’s not we’re left in Compromise Quality a subjective argument about scope and cost – “delivery should be quicker, Cost Time cheaper; more features should be Vary Scope delivered in the same time-frame for the same cost.” Backlogs have become the new functional Quality specification. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 21
  • 22. ✪ FIT FOR PURPOSE AND FIT FOR USE The focus is on functionality but how well are the functions performed? Condition Condition Resource FUNCTION Performance Design (Architecture) Source: Competitive Engineering, Tom Gilb LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 22
  • 23. ✪ QUALITY CAN ONLY TAKE SO MUCH ABUSE To meet unrealistic time and Availability cost constraints corners are Workload cut, especially on those Capacity Resilience qualities not being measured or easily determined. Resource Flexibility Saving Usability Interoperability Upgradeability Expected Actual LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 23
  • 24. ✪ KNOWLEDGE WORKER PRODUCTIVITY A commonly held assumption is that to get the most out of your investment utilization needs to be at or as near to 100% as possible. Idle resources, equipment or people are wasted investment. Effort is often confused with progress. Progress is often confused with value. Knowledge workers are described as people who “think for a living”. How do you measure thinking? LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 24
  • 25. ✪ KEEP THE PORTFOLIO RELEVANT Governance must ensure the portfolio stays relevant. We have to innovate to stay relevant – to continue to solve problems that people will pay to have solved. If the medium and long terms are 18 months and 5 years we face a problem when the typical employee tenure is less than this. Not only does our knowledge become obsolete as markets and technologies change, but knowledge literally walks out the door. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 25
  • 26. http://www.flickr.com/photos/75724809@N05/ ✪ PEOPLE LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 26
  • 27. ✪ CREATING REALITY MISMATCHES Governance attempts to manage the portfolio day-to-day and balance business investors’ perceptions and situations in the delivery teams. With the best will in the world, trying to protect both sides, we can end up creating a mismatch. When we do so we become over-responsible. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 27
  • 28. ✪ RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT? / Responsible for the successful delivery of the projects in the portfolio? / Answerable to business investors and stakeholders for the actual value realized? / Accountable to delivery teams for providing sufficient resources to enable them to be successful? / Responsible for risk management and mitigation? Can we design ways to equitably share the risk and responsibility between governance, stakeholders and delivery teams? LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 28
  • 29. ✪ COMPLEXITY IS NOISY Getting a clear view and tangible Stakeholder measures of what’s happening perception across a portfolio is hard. Time to market Team Just getting the mechanics done, Adherence Stakeholders like forecasting, budgeting and to plan Morale staffing, is a full-time job. And the Objectives Plans Requirements Production amount of data generated with incidents Budget / varying quality can get burn rate overwhelming. Designs Defects Technology Operating cost Can governance help reduce the Dependencies noise? Legacy integrations LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 29
  • 30. ✪ CLASH OR GAPS? / Trust people to get the job done. / Working software is the primary measure of progress. / The best means of communication is via face-to-face conversations. / The best architectures and designs emerge from self-organizing teams. Are agile principles practical, even applicable for governance? How practical is it to value “individuals and interactions over processes and tools” when the portfolio ‘employs’ 10,000 people? LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 30
  • 31. ✪ OPERATING AT SCALE An individual can only handle so many interactions. In a portfolio that ‘employs’ 10,000 people, we have to limit the number of people we work with day-to-day. We end up relying on activity reports and assurances from individuals representing groups of people, like project managers representing delivery teams. Scale pushes governance further away from the work. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 31
  • 32. ✪ CONTINUOUSLY IMPROVING GOVERNANCE How can we measure the value and effectiveness of governance? How do we improve it? This is expected of operational and delivery teams. Why are the same standards not applied to governance? LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 32
  • 33. ✪ DISCUSSION Questions? Share your thoughts. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 33
  • 34. Thank you for participating. If you’d be interested in a second café workshop looking at the financial and risk elements of governance please leave your business card or name and email address. #abcfriendorfoe @energizr / @guspower LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 34
  • 35. Limited Governance – Friend or Foe by Energized Work Limited is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License License. You are free: To share – to copy, distribute and transmit the work To remix – to adapt the work Under the following conditions: Attribution – You must attribute the work in the manner specified by Energized Work (but not in any way that suggests that Energized Work endorse you or your use of the work). Share Alike – If you alter, transform, or build upon this work, you may distribute the resulting work only under the same or similar license to this one. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 35
  • 36. ✪ WELCOME TO THE WORLD CAFE 1 SET THE CONTEXT 3 MOVE TO ANOTHER TABLE / 5 minutes. / 5 minutes. / Speakers share their thinking / 1 or 2 hosts stay with the table. on a topic and ask questions. / The rest move to other tables. / See handout for a reminder. / Hosts present what was discussed. 2 BEGIN THE CONVERSATION / 10 minutes. / Doodle and discuss. / Build up a picture. / Focus on what matters. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 36
  • 37. ✪ GAMBLING PURPOSE OF GOVERNANCE UNDERSTAND THE GAMBLE SMALL BETS INCREMENTAL INVESTMENTS The accepted purpose of Capital investments are made Betting the budget on a big- / Business service cash flows. governance is largely to monitor, in IT projects on the merits of bang release is like betting all / Portfolio performance. report on, and ensure that the business cases built on our money on hitting a hole-in- / Risk exposure. specified requirements will be assumptions. When we build a one. Can we do less without / Impending obsolescence. delivered in the agreed feature and delay validating it doing too little? / Cost of delay. timeframe and within the agreed with customers we’re making a budget to realize the benefits bet that the feature is “right”. £ stipulated in the business case. What if we’re wrong? £ £ t And in so doing, to ensure processes are followed correctly, Profitable t standards are adhered to, and the software is produced to an Less inventory; regular releases t Series of small investments acceptable level of quality. Small bets Break-even MORE BENEFICIAL GOVERANCE Make small bets based on what Self-funding The compelling opportunity for Increasing inventory we can afford to lose to prove governance is to help business Increasing investment earlier what’s valuable and Use fast actuals, flash forecasts Bigger and bigger bet investors make investments that what’s not valuable. and moving averages in a rolling maximize business review to inform continuous re- performance. This requires the Every feature done this way ups evaluation and prioritization. portfolio to be of business the ante until we’re betting the services and not IT projects. budget on a big-bang release. COMMON SPREAD BETTING ERRORS CONTROL DOESN’T GUARANTEE VALUE Optimizing productivity so that projects aren’t late or over budget doesn’t 6. Out of control. 1. No edge. address the big risks in these assumptions: 2. No planning. 7. Not in tune with the market. / The requirements define the right solution. 3. Wrong bet size. 8. Running before walking. / All requirements must be delivered before any value can be realized 4. No risk management. 9. Emotionally unstable. (all or nothing). 5. Mistiming exits. 10. Not taking responsibility. / If all requirements are delivered, the value will be realized. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 37
  • 38. ✪ VALUE TIME, COST, SCOPE, QUALITY. FIT FOR PURPOSE. FIT FOR USE KNOWLEDGE WORKER VALUE? The focus is on functionality but how well are the functions performed? PRODUCTIVITY The word ‘value’ is used A commonly held assumption is extensively. And ambiguously. that to get the most out of your investment utilization needs to be Condition Condition Value needs to be defined, at or as near to 100% as possible. quantified and measured. When Resource FUNCTION Performance Idle resources, equipment or it’s not we’re left in a subjective people are wasted investment. argument about scope and cost – Effort is often confused with “delivery should be quicker, p ro g re s s . P ro g re s s i s o f t e n cheaper; more features should be Design confused with value. delivered in the same time-frame (Architecture) for the same cost.” Source: Competitive Engineering, Tom Gilb Knowledge workers are described as people who “think for a living”. Backlogs have become the new How can you tell if someone is functional specification. QUALITY CAN ONLY TAKE SO MUCH ABUSE thinking? How do you measure it? To meet unrealistic time and cost constraints corners are cut, especially on those qualities not being measured or easily KEEP THE PORTFOLIO Scope determined. RELEVANT Governance must ensure the Availability Expected portfolio stays relevant. We have to Workload innovate to stay relevant – to Resilience Actual Compromise Capacity continue to solve problems that Quality people will pay to have solved. Cost Time If the medium and long terms are Resource Flexibility Saving 18 months and 5 years we face a Vary Scope problem when the typical employee tenure is less than this. Not only does our knowledge become Usability Interoperability obsolete as markets and technologies change, but Upgradeability knowledge literally walks out Quality the door. LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 38
  • 39. ✪ PEOPLE CREATING REALITY COMPLEXITY IS NOISY Stakeholder MISMATCHES Getting a clear view and tangible perception Governance attempts to measures of what’s happening Time to market manage the portfolio day-to-day across a portfolio is hard. Just Team and balance business investors’ getting the mechanics done, like Adherence Stakeholders perceptions and situations in the forecasting, budgeting and to plan Morale delivery teams. staffing, is a full-time job. And the amount of data generated Objectives Plans Requirements Production With the best will in the world, with varying quality can get incidents trying to protect both sides, we overwhelming. Budget / burn rate can end up creating a mismatch. Defects When we do so we become Can governance help reduce the Technology Designs over-responsible. noise? Operating cost Dependencies RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT? CLASH OR GAPS? Legacy / Responsible for the successful / Trust people to get the job integrations delivery of the projects in the done. portfolio? / Working software is the primary OPERATING AT SCALE / Answerable to business measure of progress. An individual can only handle so many interactions. In a portfolio investors and stakeholders for / The best means of the actual value realized? communication is via face-to- that ‘employs’ 10,000 people, we have to limit the number of / Accountable to delivery teams face conversations. people we work with day-to-day. We end up relying on activity for providing sufficient resources / The best architectures and reports and assurances from individuals representing groups of to enable them to be designs emerge from self- people, like project managers representing delivery teams. successful? organizing teams. / Responsible for risk Scale pushes governance further away from the work. management and mitigation? Are agile principles practical, even applicable for governance? Can we design ways to CONTINUOUSLY IMPROVING GOVERNANCE equitably share the risk and How practical is it to value How can we measure the value and effectiveness of governance? responsibility between “individuals and interactions over How do we improve it? governance, stakeholders and processes and tools” when the delivery teams? portfolio ‘employs’ 10,000 This is expected of operational and delivery teams. Why are the people? same standards not applied to governance? LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 39
  • 40. Energized Work Ltd HMS President Victoria Embankment London EC4Y 0HJ www.energizedwork.com LICENSED UNDER CREATIVE COMMONS BY ENERGIZED WORK LIMITED | HMS PRESIDENT, VICTORIA EMBANKMENT, LONDON, EC4 0HJ | WWW.ENERGIZEDWORK.COM 40

Notas del editor

  1. For each conversation …
  2. Senior managers often have stronger psychological attachment to bigger projects .They’re assumed to have a bigger payback over the long term.Unfortunately, the bigger the investment, the less likely it will be questioned. Business cases get treated as statements of fact by those responsible for delivery.People get carried away on the expectations of gains.Governance should be should be asking what can we afford to lose?
  3. How can we truly know?We can find that the ideas made sense, technology was great and the plans were well executed, but the project still failed.There’s no way to reliably predict what will be valuable and what won’t.It feels like governance has become more concerned with maintaining control than delivering value. It has become about doing the wrong things righter, to use John Seddon’s words.
  4. By making small bets we create multiple, repeating opportunities to test for value. We’re enabling massive flexibility to achieve business objectives. We’re building capability through learning about customers.We’re folding innovation into delivery through creative discovery and experimentation.Making small bets doesn’t mean there’s no bold ambition.
  5. Extending the idea of small bets, why not make incremental investments based on concrete and measured performance of business services.With this information we can stop investing early when enough value has been realized. This way we don’t waste money on features that won’t be used.We can continue investing, making small bets to test for further value.Or we can exit.We can stop investing in punts that aren’t delivering any value.We can stop investing in systems approaching their sell-by date.By sensing impending obsolescence, letting something become a legacy can be made an explicit portfolio decision based on risk, rather than it just happening in the background.Today’s projects are tomorrow’s legacies.
  6. To do this we need end-to-end cross-functional IT capabilities on the front-line in business services. Lean calls this product-orientation.
  7. NO EDGEA method, repeated over time, that’s expected to net a profit./ Superior market entry./ Superior market exit./ Superior money./ Risk management./ Stand aside – don't enter the market.NO PLANNINGWinners don't rely on tips or hunches. Tips and hunches only suggest a market entry. What about the exit, money management and risk management?Winners usually have:/ An annual plan./ A detailed short-term plan – next week, next day./ A written method and rules.WRONG BET SIZEThe amount you stand to lose should not exceed 2% of your account.Beware overtrading – having too many bets, one bet too big, betting too frequently.NO RISK MANAGEMENTManage the downside as well as the upside. Stop a single loss getting out of control. Keep the total exposure in the portfolio under control./ Where you will enter the market?/ Where you will get out if taking a loss?/ How much will you bet?/ Where is your initial profit target?MISTIMING EXITSRide your wins and cut your losses. People have the tendency to get out too early on winners and hold their losses.OUT OF CONTROLYou can either win, lose or break even, and you can't know the outcome in advance. If you’re running on gut feel and don't frequently recheck your positions against what you expect, then you're out of control.NOT IN TUNE WITH THE MARKETMost people have a bias to the long side (increase in value) but markets go up and down. A lot of people lose money because they don't adjust their approach to the change in market conditions and direction.RUNNING BEFORE WALKINGIt can take a year to become proficient. There's no substitute for experience and practice. In the end the real teacher is the market.EMOTIONALLY UNSTABLEYou can do everything right and still lose. Your idea can be well thought through, executed exactly as planned but the market moves against you and you lose. If you can't handle this or it takes too much of a toll on your life, do something else.NOT TAKING RESPONSIBILITYExcuses and blame cover up the real issue – how can we improve based on the failures experienced? The result is down to you.
  8. Kent Beck describes the four key variables for software development as being time, scope, cost and quality.The idea behind much of the agile ethos is to avoid fixed time fixed scope fixed cost endeavours as the only remaining free variable is quality - a variable that can only take so much abuse (to which much of the history of software development can attest).Instead the approach is to fix the time, cost and quality (i.e. don't cut corners) and, using a 'backlog' of items broken down to a manageable size and prioritized by value, deliver the maximum value possible in the allotted time by delivering the highest value items first.There's an implicit link between scope items and value.If the value of something is unknown or difficult to determine (i.e. it takes a long time to find out) - if the link between value and the work is missing or severed - then we are on treacherous ground. Why is this work happening? Why should we continue to invest in it? Without being able to clearly demonstrate the value we are delivering, we are left with a subjective argument around why delivery should be quicker, cheaper, or why more should be delivered in the same time-frame for the same cost.
  9. Quality levels drop - especially on those qualities that are not being measured or easily determined (e.g. usability, security) - as corners are cut to meet unrealistic time and cost constraints. The result is a product that maybe fit for purpose but certainly not fit for use.Should a role of governance be to ensure that this doesn't happen?
  10. Does governance try to create measures to ensure that people are productive? Could this possibly work?/ If someone isn't skilled enough, they will remain so./ If someone isn't committed, would these measures make them so?Approaches to this can take a variety of forms - timesheet tracking, cost code allocation.Using what was specified (often by someone else) to determine what gets done rather than what the people doing the work think the right thing is to do in the given circumstances. Function takes precedence over quality.
  11. Ideas are free and timeless != Opportunities are hard to seize, perishable and resource dependent. Opportunities come from:/ Large scale trends/ Experience or observation/ Research and development/ Adapt, replicate, modifyInnovation has different levels: / Brand new / Semi-radical / Rework or extend
  12. It's easy for people in governance to become over-responsible. The uncertain nature of software development can make us feel like we need to improve our control over the current situation. There can be a lot at stake and we tend make more errors when we are time pressured and feel forced to make decisions. There are numerous pitfalls and potential conflicts of interest in the realm of governance. Consider two major fears you may have if you work in governance:1) The delivery teams are not able to deliver what was expected to the business (for whatever reason)2) The business has unrealistic expectations of what will be delivered, for how much and whenIn the first instance we really want the delivery teams to be successful. We've built a good working relationship with them and, of course, their performance reflects on us. Therefore we might adopt the strategy to play down any bad news and try to intervene and sort things out ourselves. We create a reality mismatch between the investors and those doing the work.In the second instance - that of unrealistic expectations - we may have the unpleasant job of curbing the enthusiasm of senior executives. We don't want to appear like typical IT departments do: too slow, too expensive, black box, out of touch and business inhibiting. We want to come across as competitive and competent. Maybe we choose to leave some ambiguity in the discussion. Again, we create a reality mismatch between the investors and those doing the work.Local concerns usually outweigh programme or portfolio needs - it can be difficult to get stakeholders and delivery teams to adjust so that other stakeholder needs - needs beyond their immediate business area - are also satisfied.
  13. Much of the language around governance relates to the concept of responsibility. What should governance be responsible for? -Should governance be responsible for the successful delivery of the projects in the portfolio? - Should governance be answerable to senior business stakeholders concerning the actual value delivered? - Should governance be accountable to delivery teams for providing sufficient resources to enable them to deliver successfully?- Should governance be responsible for risk management and be able to decide how those risks are mitigated?It's worth noting that responsibility doesn't have to be all or nothing. The book "The Responsibility Virus" describes a tool called the "responsibility ladder" with which people can agree to take one of six levels of responsibility in a given situation:1. consider options and make decision, inform superior afterwards2. provide options to superior with own recommendation3. generate options for superior and ask superior to make choice4. describe problem to superior and ask for help in structuring it5. give problem to superior, watch and learn for next time6. drop problem on superior's desk and indicate helplessnessCan we design ways to equitably share the risk and responsibility between governance, stakeholders and delivery teams?
  14. Governance people can view agile delivery teams as "gung-ho", reckless or worse. Agile delivery teams can view governance as a bureaucracy, inhibiting and out-of-touch.We're looking at a clash of approaches and a gap in understanding. Let's take a closer look.The Agile manifesto asks people to value "individuals and interactions over processes and tools". If you're governing a portfolio which comprises of 10,000 people, how are you supposed to apply this? It's no surprise the topic of how to "scale agile" continuously crops up at conferences, on blogs and LinkedIn groups. Along with that is a lot of widely recognized experience and wisdom that strongly recommends avoiding big team sizes. If we followed this advice while maintaining the same level of investment, a major part of which went towards labor costs, we would end up with lots of small teams. Do we now have a different problem? How would these numerous smaller teams work together and not work against each other? According to the world academy online, the reason for management is to handle the situation whereby people find that they couldn't perform all the work personally and need to delegate to others. However if you have a large portfolio, you can't manage all the projects personally either - the reason for governance. If we can only handle so many interactions we can reduce our exposure to the number of individuals involved through use of representatives (e.g. project managers) or reduce the number of interactions required by introducing some other mechanism (e.g. numerical measure, report). Can this reality and approach remain consistent with "individuals and interactions over processes and tools"?
  15. Many governance processes may be legacy and of little or no value – they could be waste.