Richmond, Virginia franchise attorney Eric Perkins is a frequent author and speaker on franchising issues, and in 2014 he organized two "boot camp" workshops to provide those thinking about buying a franchised business an overview of franchising. This presentation is a summary of the topics discussed during the workshop. Additional handouts were provided to workshop attendees and are available upon request.
Nuts and Bolts of Forming For-Profit and Nonprofit Entities in Virginia
Prospective Franchisee Boot Camp Cummary (Perkins Law, October 2014)
1. ERIC C. PERKINS, ESQ.
PERKINS LAW, PLLC
4870 SADLER ROAD
SUITE 300
GLEN ALLEN, VA 23060
WWW.ERICPERKINSLAW.COM
(804) 205 - 5162
Prospective Franchisee
Boot Camp
October 24, 2014
2. Franchise System
Experience
(Zor or Zee):
SMARTBOX Portable Self Storage
- sweetFrog Premium Frozen
Yogurt - Super Cuts - The Grout
Geeks - 9Round - 1-800-GOT
JUNK - The Sparkling Image - Jet
Black - Anytime Fitness – Zoup! –
Michelle Lea Massage Therapy –
ComForcare Senior Services–
Tropical Smoothie Café – The
Entrepreneur’s Source – Apple
Spice Junction – Dominic’s of New
York – Sparkling Image – The
Cleaning Authority – Edible
Arrangements – Faces Cosmetics –
Wild Birds Unlimited – Copper
Penny - Omega Learning Center –
LA Boxing – Pure Barre – CKO
Kick Boxing – Jump Bunch –
Baskin Robbins – Spring-Green
Lawn Care – Five Star Painting –
Money Mailer – The Alternative
Board – Dream Dinners – Salad
Creations – Salsarita’s Fresh
Cantina – Minuteman Press – etc.
3. Three Definitions of Franchising
Common Sense Definition
Definition by Example
Legal Definition
4. Three Great Things About Franchising
You don’t have to reinvent the wheel
You benefit from a built-in support
structure
You have special laws to protect you
5. Three Things About You
Can I afford this?
Can I follow someone else’s rules?
Am I good with people?
Internal leader/manager
External Sales
6. Three Bad Things About Franchising
Failure is possible
Your long term success is still largely up
to you (and other factors beyond your
control)
It is not cheap
7. Three Things to Know About the
Legal Side of Franchising
It’s a contract
Federal law regulates franchising
State law regulates franchising
8. Three Things to Look for in the FA
Exclusive/Protected Territory
Term and Renewal
Transfer Restrictions
9. Three Reasons Zees Fail
They make emotional decisions, not
business decisions
They have unrealistic expectations
They were undercapitalized
10. Three Reasons Zees Succeed
They do their homework
They budget conservatively
They follow the system
11. Three Great Sources of Information
International Franchise Association
www.franchise.org
Blue Mau Mau
www.bluemaumau.org
Entrepreneur
www.entrepreneur.com
12. Dissecting the FDD
Item 1: The Franchisor and any
Parents, Predecessors, and Affiliates
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Several years of franchising experience
13. Dissecting the FDD
Item 2: Business Experience
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Stability in management team and franchising
experience
14. Dissecting the FDD
Item 3: Litigation
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
The volume and type of litigation with which the
franchisor is involved
15. Dissecting the FDD
Item 4: Bankruptcy
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Check for any bankruptcy filings of the franchisors
affiliates, officers, or directors in the last ten years
16. Dissecting the FDD
Item 5: Initial Fees
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Initial costs will vary greatly depending on:
Term of the franchise
Services offered by the franchisor
Protected territory
17. Dissecting the FDD
Item 6: Other Fees
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Frees the franchisor will collect from the franchisee for
itself or third parties on an ongoing basis
Operating royalties
Advertising fund royalties
Lease Negotiation
Site Selection
Permitting fees
Training fees
Audit fees
Transfer fees
Renewal fees
18. Dissecting the FDD
Item 7: Estimated Initial Investment
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Budget conservatively, these numbers are
notorious for being too optimistic
19. Dissecting the FDD
Item 8: Restrictions on Sources of
Products and Services
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Does the franchisor make more money from
operating its own units or from selling stuff to its
franchisees?
Are the purchase terms competitive?
20. Dissecting the FDD
Item 9: Franchisee’s Obligations
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Compare and contrast what is written in the FDD
and Franchise Agreement versus how franchisees
rate their relationship with the franchisor
(validation process);
sticklers vs. collaborators
21. Dissecting the FDD
Item 10: Financing
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Franchisor leases equipment to franchisees
22. Dissecting the FDD
Item 11: Franchisor’s Assistance,
Advertising, Computer Systems and
Training
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Services franchisor will provide for the franchisee
during term of agreement
Franchisor’s initial training and ongoing assistance
programs
23. Dissecting the FDD
Item 12: Territory
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Exclusions, exemptions, and exceptions to the
notion of exclusivity
24. Dissecting the FDD
Item 13: Trademarks
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
USPTO Registration Status
25. Dissecting the FDD
Item 14: Patents, Copyrights, and
Proprietary Information
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Copyright protections for operations manuals and
computer software
Trade secrets and proprietary information
26. Dissecting the FDD
Item 15: Obligation to Participate in
the Annual Operation of the Franchised
Business
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Active vs. Passive Ownership
27. Dissecting the FDD
Item 16: Restrictions on What the
Franchisee May Sell
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Necessary to preserve the uniformity, consistency
and integrity of the franchise system
28. Dissecting the FDD
Item 17: Renewal, Termination, Transfer,
and Dispute Resolution
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Franchisees have very limited rights when
terminating franchise agreement before expiration
date
All disputes must be submitted for mediation or
arbitration in franchisor's home state
Fees and Flexibility
29. Dissecting the FDD
Item 18: Public Figures
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Relationship must be described in the FDD
30. Dissecting the FDD
Item 19: Financial Performance
Representations
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Are the numbers validated by the Franchisees?
How will the numbers translate to your market?
31. Dissecting the FDD
Item 20: Outlets and Franchisee
Information
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Trends
Is the system growing or contracting?
What is the closure rate in recent years?
32. Dissecting the FDD
Item 21: Financial Statements
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Liquidity/Cash on Hand
Long-Term Debt
Cash Flow
Balance Sheet
33. Dissecting the FDD
Item 22: Contracts
WHAT TO WATCH FOR:
Standard contracts the franchisor requires of the
franchisee
Leases
Guarantees
Promissory Notes
The difference between a license and a franchise (the sweetFrog story)
You hopefully will be in a position to avoid many (but NOT ALL) of the mistakes startup businesses make…you’ll have a smoother start and benefit from a system that has proven successful over the course of time and a brand that either has already generated significant recognition and goodwill or is an emerging brand with upside potential.
Federal and state regulation of franchising: disclosure laws, registration alws, and relationship laws
--Franchise opportunities come in all sizes, from required startup outlays of $50,000 on up to $1 million and higher…..wherever you fall along that spectrum, it is important that you budget conservatively…things will inevitably be more expensive and take longer than you initially hope or expect, so give yourself plenty of cushion.
--I’ve seen a number of brilliant, technical professionals who came out of the corporate world thinking because they were smart and disciplined that they would be successful franchise owners…but they lacked fundamental people skills and suffered as a result.
WARNING: Don’t fall into the trap of thinking you’re just buying yourself a job…that’s a bit short-sighted and puts extra pressure on you to do it all….so take stock of what you’rr strenths and weaknesses are and be sure to fill in the gaps on your team—either through a business partner or manager.
--You need some entrepreneurial spirit to go into business for yourself under any circumstances—franchise or not—however, it is possible to be so entrepreneurial, creative, and independent that you’re not well suited to being a franchisee and being required to follow someone else’s rules and not having the freedom to do what you want, when you want.
--No matter what business you’re in, sales/marketing, and customer service are going to be key drivers of your success (and survival)…so you have to have superior people skills (or partner up with someone who does).
For many prospective franchisees a great resource is a franchise consultant aka broker aka lead generator…what they do is help you better understand what franchising is all about, help you assess whether you’re a good fit for franchising, and help you narrow down you search for the right franchise. They get paid by the franchisor if and only if you sign a franchise agreement…hats the good news, on the other hand, they will only share franchise opportunities that happen to be in their company’s portfolio, so you’re looking at a limited universe of franchises…pitch for Tom and Gus.
--Pitch for SCORE and SBDC
Franchising is no guarantee of success—franchisees fail every day (so do franchisors)…there have been grown men break down in tears in this very room as a result of a failed attempt at being a franchise owner.
There’s a point in the life of your business at which the franchisor lets go and whether you succeed or fail is in your hands.
Like everything else in life, every franchise system is a bell curve—some zees are all-stars and enjoy great success, the majority fall in the middle category of doing OK, and the bottom 10% struggle no matter hat they try and ultimately drop off the face of the earth.
Things under your control: Costs, hiring and firing, choosing a location and negotiating a lease, setting up employee benefits, complying with applicable laws, deciding ho best to market and advertise, motivating your employees, developing customer loyalty and brand awareness within your community.
Franchising offers many benefits, but rest assured, there’s no lunch…you’re paying for everything you get….and at some point all franchisees have second thoughts as to whether what they are getting from the franchisor is worth what they are being charged each month---initial fee, operating royalty, advertising royalty, and other fees and expenses….it all adds up and it can be demoralizing at times.
But don’t lose sight of the fact that you’re using someone else’s stuff…you don’t own it, you’re just borrowing it and when your agreement expires, you gotta give it all back
Probably the most important contract you’ll ever sign—long term (10 years), significant investment of money (your life savings?)—and it is by and large a one sided agreement to protect the franchisor and preserve consistency throughout the system---uniformity and consistency is a hallmark of franchising.
NOTE: Franchise Agreements are negotiable (to a degree)
Federal law—FTC Franchise Rule—Disclosure—FDD—23 items of disclosure—14 day waiting period…samples available online for free—California, Minnesota, Washington, Wisconsin, freefranchisedocs.com, go downtown to SCC to view documents on file for free (there is a charge for copies).
State law—registration laws and relationship laws
“Exclusivity” is a bit of a misnomer...lots of carveouts and potential exceptions…the size of territory is often a topic of negotiation.
Term is typically 10 years, with one or more renewal options…but there are always a number of renewal conditions and hoops you have to jump through to renew…some of which are arguably not fair to the franchisee, but have become fairly standard in franchising
You won; be able to freely sell your business if you want out….any sale of a franchised business is essentially a three-party transaction.
Approach the process in a businesslike fashion, gather as much relevant information as you can, Don’t count on taking a salary for the first year…be prepared for it to take up to 12-18 months for you to reach break-even point.
Understanding the franchise sales process: initial questionnaire and telephone/email discussion, more detailed application, Discovery Day, signing (16 week average cycle from first contact to contract signing)…don’t pay any initial deposits.
Expect to work very hard, this will not be easy under any circumstances
budget conservatively (for both the new business and your personal/family situation)
Be proactive and get to know your franchisor and fellow franchisees
Lots of franchising info online…some better than others.