SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 46
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Холакратия:
достоинства и недостатки
Артем Сердюк
fb.com/ekartem | @ek_artem
Сильные стороны иерархий:
1) Четкие и понятные роли
2) Стабильность, устойчивость
3) Масштабируемость
Сильные стороны иерархий:
1) Четкие и понятные роли
2) Стабильность, устойчивость
3) Масштабируемость
4) Менеджеры
Проблемы иерархий:
1) Тормозят!
Проблемы иерархий:
1) Тормозят!
2) Люди недовольны
Проблемы иерархий:
1) Тормозят!
2) Люди недовольны
3) Как-то все становится напряженно
Холакратия
Holacracy
Брайан
Робертсон
И что,
что-то изменилось к лучшему?
Холакратия:
достоинства и недостатки
Артем Сердюк
fb.com/ekartem | @ek_artem
1 котября 2016 года

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

"Query Execution: Expectation - Reality (Level 300)" Денис Резник
"Query Execution: Expectation - Reality (Level 300)" Денис Резник"Query Execution: Expectation - Reality (Level 300)" Денис Резник
"Query Execution: Expectation - Reality (Level 300)" Денис РезникFwdays
 
Швейцарія, масштабування Scrum і розподілені команди от Романа Сахарова
Швейцарія, масштабування Scrum і розподілені команди от Романа СахароваШвейцарія, масштабування Scrum і розподілені команди от Романа Сахарова
Швейцарія, масштабування Scrum і розподілені команди от Романа СахароваFwdays
 
Алексей Волков "Интерактивные декларативные графики на React+D3"
Алексей Волков "Интерактивные декларативные графики на React+D3"Алексей Волков "Интерактивные декларативные графики на React+D3"
Алексей Волков "Интерактивные декларативные графики на React+D3"Fwdays
 
Fighting Fat Models (Богдан Гусев)
Fighting Fat Models (Богдан Гусев)Fighting Fat Models (Богдан Гусев)
Fighting Fat Models (Богдан Гусев)Fwdays
 
Анастасия Войтова: "Building profanity filters on mobile: clbuttic sh!t"
Анастасия Войтова: "Building profanity filters on mobile: clbuttic sh!t"Анастасия Войтова: "Building profanity filters on mobile: clbuttic sh!t"
Анастасия Войтова: "Building profanity filters on mobile: clbuttic sh!t"Fwdays
 
Трансформация команды: от инди разработки к играм с коммерческой успешностью
Трансформация команды: от инди разработки к играм с коммерческой успешностьюТрансформация команды: от инди разработки к играм с коммерческой успешностью
Трансформация команды: от инди разработки к играм с коммерческой успешностьюFwdays
 
Michael North "The Road to Native Web Components"
Michael North "The Road to Native Web Components"Michael North "The Road to Native Web Components"
Michael North "The Road to Native Web Components"Fwdays
 
Евгений Обрезков "Behind the terminal"
Евгений Обрезков "Behind the terminal"Евгений Обрезков "Behind the terminal"
Евгений Обрезков "Behind the terminal"Fwdays
 
"Красная книга веб-разработчика" Виктор Полищук
"Красная книга веб-разработчика" Виктор Полищук"Красная книга веб-разработчика" Виктор Полищук
"Красная книга веб-разработчика" Виктор ПолищукFwdays
 
Андрей Шумада | Tank.ly
Андрей Шумада | Tank.ly Андрей Шумада | Tank.ly
Андрей Шумада | Tank.ly Fwdays
 
Анатолий Попель: "Формы оплаты и платёжные шлюзы"
Анатолий Попель: "Формы оплаты и платёжные шлюзы"Анатолий Попель: "Формы оплаты и платёжные шлюзы"
Анатолий Попель: "Формы оплаты и платёжные шлюзы"Fwdays
 
Алексей Рыбаков: "Wearable OS год спустя: Apple Watch 2.0, Android Wear 5.1.1...
Алексей Рыбаков: "Wearable OS год спустя: Apple Watch 2.0, Android Wear 5.1.1...Алексей Рыбаков: "Wearable OS год спустя: Apple Watch 2.0, Android Wear 5.1.1...
Алексей Рыбаков: "Wearable OS год спустя: Apple Watch 2.0, Android Wear 5.1.1...Fwdays
 
Александр Воронов | Building CLI with Swift
Александр Воронов | Building CLI with SwiftАлександр Воронов | Building CLI with Swift
Александр Воронов | Building CLI with SwiftFwdays
 
Павел Тайкало: "Optimistic Approach : How to show results instead spinners wi...
Павел Тайкало: "Optimistic Approach : How to show results instead spinners wi...Павел Тайкало: "Optimistic Approach : How to show results instead spinners wi...
Павел Тайкало: "Optimistic Approach : How to show results instead spinners wi...Fwdays
 
Светлана Старикова "Building a self-managing team: why you should not have e...
 Светлана Старикова "Building a self-managing team: why you should not have e... Светлана Старикова "Building a self-managing team: why you should not have e...
Светлана Старикова "Building a self-managing team: why you should not have e...Fwdays
 
"После OOD: как моделировать предметную область в пост-объектном мире" Руслан...
"После OOD: как моделировать предметную область в пост-объектном мире" Руслан..."После OOD: как моделировать предметную область в пост-объектном мире" Руслан...
"После OOD: как моделировать предметную область в пост-объектном мире" Руслан...Fwdays
 
Евгений Жарков AngularJS: Good parts
Евгений Жарков AngularJS: Good partsЕвгений Жарков AngularJS: Good parts
Евгений Жарков AngularJS: Good partsFwdays
 
Сергей Яковлев "Phalcon 2 - стабилизация и производительность"
Сергей Яковлев "Phalcon 2 - стабилизация и производительность"Сергей Яковлев "Phalcon 2 - стабилизация и производительность"
Сергей Яковлев "Phalcon 2 - стабилизация и производительность"Fwdays
 

Destacado (19)

"Query Execution: Expectation - Reality (Level 300)" Денис Резник
"Query Execution: Expectation - Reality (Level 300)" Денис Резник"Query Execution: Expectation - Reality (Level 300)" Денис Резник
"Query Execution: Expectation - Reality (Level 300)" Денис Резник
 
Швейцарія, масштабування Scrum і розподілені команди от Романа Сахарова
Швейцарія, масштабування Scrum і розподілені команди от Романа СахароваШвейцарія, масштабування Scrum і розподілені команди от Романа Сахарова
Швейцарія, масштабування Scrum і розподілені команди от Романа Сахарова
 
Алексей Волков "Интерактивные декларативные графики на React+D3"
Алексей Волков "Интерактивные декларативные графики на React+D3"Алексей Волков "Интерактивные декларативные графики на React+D3"
Алексей Волков "Интерактивные декларативные графики на React+D3"
 
Fighting Fat Models (Богдан Гусев)
Fighting Fat Models (Богдан Гусев)Fighting Fat Models (Богдан Гусев)
Fighting Fat Models (Богдан Гусев)
 
Designing for Privacy
Designing for PrivacyDesigning for Privacy
Designing for Privacy
 
Анастасия Войтова: "Building profanity filters on mobile: clbuttic sh!t"
Анастасия Войтова: "Building profanity filters on mobile: clbuttic sh!t"Анастасия Войтова: "Building profanity filters on mobile: clbuttic sh!t"
Анастасия Войтова: "Building profanity filters on mobile: clbuttic sh!t"
 
Трансформация команды: от инди разработки к играм с коммерческой успешностью
Трансформация команды: от инди разработки к играм с коммерческой успешностьюТрансформация команды: от инди разработки к играм с коммерческой успешностью
Трансформация команды: от инди разработки к играм с коммерческой успешностью
 
Michael North "The Road to Native Web Components"
Michael North "The Road to Native Web Components"Michael North "The Road to Native Web Components"
Michael North "The Road to Native Web Components"
 
Евгений Обрезков "Behind the terminal"
Евгений Обрезков "Behind the terminal"Евгений Обрезков "Behind the terminal"
Евгений Обрезков "Behind the terminal"
 
"Красная книга веб-разработчика" Виктор Полищук
"Красная книга веб-разработчика" Виктор Полищук"Красная книга веб-разработчика" Виктор Полищук
"Красная книга веб-разработчика" Виктор Полищук
 
Андрей Шумада | Tank.ly
Андрей Шумада | Tank.ly Андрей Шумада | Tank.ly
Андрей Шумада | Tank.ly
 
Анатолий Попель: "Формы оплаты и платёжные шлюзы"
Анатолий Попель: "Формы оплаты и платёжные шлюзы"Анатолий Попель: "Формы оплаты и платёжные шлюзы"
Анатолий Попель: "Формы оплаты и платёжные шлюзы"
 
Алексей Рыбаков: "Wearable OS год спустя: Apple Watch 2.0, Android Wear 5.1.1...
Алексей Рыбаков: "Wearable OS год спустя: Apple Watch 2.0, Android Wear 5.1.1...Алексей Рыбаков: "Wearable OS год спустя: Apple Watch 2.0, Android Wear 5.1.1...
Алексей Рыбаков: "Wearable OS год спустя: Apple Watch 2.0, Android Wear 5.1.1...
 
Александр Воронов | Building CLI with Swift
Александр Воронов | Building CLI with SwiftАлександр Воронов | Building CLI with Swift
Александр Воронов | Building CLI with Swift
 
Павел Тайкало: "Optimistic Approach : How to show results instead spinners wi...
Павел Тайкало: "Optimistic Approach : How to show results instead spinners wi...Павел Тайкало: "Optimistic Approach : How to show results instead spinners wi...
Павел Тайкало: "Optimistic Approach : How to show results instead spinners wi...
 
Светлана Старикова "Building a self-managing team: why you should not have e...
 Светлана Старикова "Building a self-managing team: why you should not have e... Светлана Старикова "Building a self-managing team: why you should not have e...
Светлана Старикова "Building a self-managing team: why you should not have e...
 
"После OOD: как моделировать предметную область в пост-объектном мире" Руслан...
"После OOD: как моделировать предметную область в пост-объектном мире" Руслан..."После OOD: как моделировать предметную область в пост-объектном мире" Руслан...
"После OOD: как моделировать предметную область в пост-объектном мире" Руслан...
 
Евгений Жарков AngularJS: Good parts
Евгений Жарков AngularJS: Good partsЕвгений Жарков AngularJS: Good parts
Евгений Жарков AngularJS: Good parts
 
Сергей Яковлев "Phalcon 2 - стабилизация и производительность"
Сергей Яковлев "Phalcon 2 - стабилизация и производительность"Сергей Яковлев "Phalcon 2 - стабилизация и производительность"
Сергей Яковлев "Phalcon 2 - стабилизация и производительность"
 

Más de Fwdays

"How Preply reduced ML model development time from 1 month to 1 day",Yevhen Y...
"How Preply reduced ML model development time from 1 month to 1 day",Yevhen Y..."How Preply reduced ML model development time from 1 month to 1 day",Yevhen Y...
"How Preply reduced ML model development time from 1 month to 1 day",Yevhen Y...Fwdays
 
"GenAI Apps: Our Journey from Ideas to Production Excellence",Danil Topchii
"GenAI Apps: Our Journey from Ideas to Production Excellence",Danil Topchii"GenAI Apps: Our Journey from Ideas to Production Excellence",Danil Topchii
"GenAI Apps: Our Journey from Ideas to Production Excellence",Danil TopchiiFwdays
 
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks..."LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...Fwdays
 
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr LapshynFwdays
 
"What is a RAG system and how to build it",Dmytro Spodarets
"What is a RAG system and how to build it",Dmytro Spodarets"What is a RAG system and how to build it",Dmytro Spodarets
"What is a RAG system and how to build it",Dmytro SpodaretsFwdays
 
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii SoldatenkoFwdays
 
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
"ML in Production",Oleksandr BaganFwdays
 
"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek Schlawack
"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek Schlawack"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek Schlawack
"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek SchlawackFwdays
 
"Distributed graphs and microservices in Prom.ua", Maksym Kindritskyi
"Distributed graphs and microservices in Prom.ua",  Maksym Kindritskyi"Distributed graphs and microservices in Prom.ua",  Maksym Kindritskyi
"Distributed graphs and microservices in Prom.ua", Maksym KindritskyiFwdays
 
"Rethinking the existing data loading and processing process as an ETL exampl...
"Rethinking the existing data loading and processing process as an ETL exampl..."Rethinking the existing data loading and processing process as an ETL exampl...
"Rethinking the existing data loading and processing process as an ETL exampl...Fwdays
 
"How Ukrainian IT specialist can go on vacation abroad without crossing the T...
"How Ukrainian IT specialist can go on vacation abroad without crossing the T..."How Ukrainian IT specialist can go on vacation abroad without crossing the T...
"How Ukrainian IT specialist can go on vacation abroad without crossing the T...Fwdays
 
"The Strength of Being Vulnerable: the experience from CIA, Tesla and Uber", ...
"The Strength of Being Vulnerable: the experience from CIA, Tesla and Uber", ..."The Strength of Being Vulnerable: the experience from CIA, Tesla and Uber", ...
"The Strength of Being Vulnerable: the experience from CIA, Tesla and Uber", ...Fwdays
 
"[QUICK TALK] Radical candor: how to achieve results faster thanks to a cultu...
"[QUICK TALK] Radical candor: how to achieve results faster thanks to a cultu..."[QUICK TALK] Radical candor: how to achieve results faster thanks to a cultu...
"[QUICK TALK] Radical candor: how to achieve results faster thanks to a cultu...Fwdays
 
"[QUICK TALK] PDP Plan, the only one door to raise your salary and boost care...
"[QUICK TALK] PDP Plan, the only one door to raise your salary and boost care..."[QUICK TALK] PDP Plan, the only one door to raise your salary and boost care...
"[QUICK TALK] PDP Plan, the only one door to raise your salary and boost care...Fwdays
 
"4 horsemen of the apocalypse of working relationships (+ antidotes to them)"...
"4 horsemen of the apocalypse of working relationships (+ antidotes to them)"..."4 horsemen of the apocalypse of working relationships (+ antidotes to them)"...
"4 horsemen of the apocalypse of working relationships (+ antidotes to them)"...Fwdays
 
"Reconnecting with Purpose: Rediscovering Job Interest after Burnout", Anast...
"Reconnecting with Purpose: Rediscovering Job Interest after Burnout",  Anast..."Reconnecting with Purpose: Rediscovering Job Interest after Burnout",  Anast...
"Reconnecting with Purpose: Rediscovering Job Interest after Burnout", Anast...Fwdays
 
"Mentoring 101: How to effectively invest experience in the success of others...
"Mentoring 101: How to effectively invest experience in the success of others..."Mentoring 101: How to effectively invest experience in the success of others...
"Mentoring 101: How to effectively invest experience in the success of others...Fwdays
 
"Mission (im) possible: How to get an offer in 2024?", Oleksandra Myronova
"Mission (im) possible: How to get an offer in 2024?",  Oleksandra Myronova"Mission (im) possible: How to get an offer in 2024?",  Oleksandra Myronova
"Mission (im) possible: How to get an offer in 2024?", Oleksandra MyronovaFwdays
 
"Why have we learned how to package products, but not how to 'package ourselv...
"Why have we learned how to package products, but not how to 'package ourselv..."Why have we learned how to package products, but not how to 'package ourselv...
"Why have we learned how to package products, but not how to 'package ourselv...Fwdays
 
"How to tame the dragon, or leadership with imposter syndrome", Oleksandr Zin...
"How to tame the dragon, or leadership with imposter syndrome", Oleksandr Zin..."How to tame the dragon, or leadership with imposter syndrome", Oleksandr Zin...
"How to tame the dragon, or leadership with imposter syndrome", Oleksandr Zin...Fwdays
 

Más de Fwdays (20)

"How Preply reduced ML model development time from 1 month to 1 day",Yevhen Y...
"How Preply reduced ML model development time from 1 month to 1 day",Yevhen Y..."How Preply reduced ML model development time from 1 month to 1 day",Yevhen Y...
"How Preply reduced ML model development time from 1 month to 1 day",Yevhen Y...
 
"GenAI Apps: Our Journey from Ideas to Production Excellence",Danil Topchii
"GenAI Apps: Our Journey from Ideas to Production Excellence",Danil Topchii"GenAI Apps: Our Journey from Ideas to Production Excellence",Danil Topchii
"GenAI Apps: Our Journey from Ideas to Production Excellence",Danil Topchii
 
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks..."LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
"LLMs for Python Engineers: Advanced Data Analysis and Semantic Kernel",Oleks...
 
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
 
"What is a RAG system and how to build it",Dmytro Spodarets
"What is a RAG system and how to build it",Dmytro Spodarets"What is a RAG system and how to build it",Dmytro Spodarets
"What is a RAG system and how to build it",Dmytro Spodarets
 
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
"Debugging python applications inside k8s environment", Andrii Soldatenko
 
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
"ML in Production",Oleksandr Bagan
 
"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek Schlawack
"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek Schlawack"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek Schlawack
"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek Schlawack
 
"Distributed graphs and microservices in Prom.ua", Maksym Kindritskyi
"Distributed graphs and microservices in Prom.ua",  Maksym Kindritskyi"Distributed graphs and microservices in Prom.ua",  Maksym Kindritskyi
"Distributed graphs and microservices in Prom.ua", Maksym Kindritskyi
 
"Rethinking the existing data loading and processing process as an ETL exampl...
"Rethinking the existing data loading and processing process as an ETL exampl..."Rethinking the existing data loading and processing process as an ETL exampl...
"Rethinking the existing data loading and processing process as an ETL exampl...
 
"How Ukrainian IT specialist can go on vacation abroad without crossing the T...
"How Ukrainian IT specialist can go on vacation abroad without crossing the T..."How Ukrainian IT specialist can go on vacation abroad without crossing the T...
"How Ukrainian IT specialist can go on vacation abroad without crossing the T...
 
"The Strength of Being Vulnerable: the experience from CIA, Tesla and Uber", ...
"The Strength of Being Vulnerable: the experience from CIA, Tesla and Uber", ..."The Strength of Being Vulnerable: the experience from CIA, Tesla and Uber", ...
"The Strength of Being Vulnerable: the experience from CIA, Tesla and Uber", ...
 
"[QUICK TALK] Radical candor: how to achieve results faster thanks to a cultu...
"[QUICK TALK] Radical candor: how to achieve results faster thanks to a cultu..."[QUICK TALK] Radical candor: how to achieve results faster thanks to a cultu...
"[QUICK TALK] Radical candor: how to achieve results faster thanks to a cultu...
 
"[QUICK TALK] PDP Plan, the only one door to raise your salary and boost care...
"[QUICK TALK] PDP Plan, the only one door to raise your salary and boost care..."[QUICK TALK] PDP Plan, the only one door to raise your salary and boost care...
"[QUICK TALK] PDP Plan, the only one door to raise your salary and boost care...
 
"4 horsemen of the apocalypse of working relationships (+ antidotes to them)"...
"4 horsemen of the apocalypse of working relationships (+ antidotes to them)"..."4 horsemen of the apocalypse of working relationships (+ antidotes to them)"...
"4 horsemen of the apocalypse of working relationships (+ antidotes to them)"...
 
"Reconnecting with Purpose: Rediscovering Job Interest after Burnout", Anast...
"Reconnecting with Purpose: Rediscovering Job Interest after Burnout",  Anast..."Reconnecting with Purpose: Rediscovering Job Interest after Burnout",  Anast...
"Reconnecting with Purpose: Rediscovering Job Interest after Burnout", Anast...
 
"Mentoring 101: How to effectively invest experience in the success of others...
"Mentoring 101: How to effectively invest experience in the success of others..."Mentoring 101: How to effectively invest experience in the success of others...
"Mentoring 101: How to effectively invest experience in the success of others...
 
"Mission (im) possible: How to get an offer in 2024?", Oleksandra Myronova
"Mission (im) possible: How to get an offer in 2024?",  Oleksandra Myronova"Mission (im) possible: How to get an offer in 2024?",  Oleksandra Myronova
"Mission (im) possible: How to get an offer in 2024?", Oleksandra Myronova
 
"Why have we learned how to package products, but not how to 'package ourselv...
"Why have we learned how to package products, but not how to 'package ourselv..."Why have we learned how to package products, but not how to 'package ourselv...
"Why have we learned how to package products, but not how to 'package ourselv...
 
"How to tame the dragon, or leadership with imposter syndrome", Oleksandr Zin...
"How to tame the dragon, or leadership with imposter syndrome", Oleksandr Zin..."How to tame the dragon, or leadership with imposter syndrome", Oleksandr Zin...
"How to tame the dragon, or leadership with imposter syndrome", Oleksandr Zin...
 

Артем Сердюк "Холакратия: достоинства и недостатки"