SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 13
Descargar para leer sin conexión
WWW.VAISHNAVISM.ORG




    In defence of Sri Rama
       A study of the greatness of Sri Rama
                             D. Harish Kumar




1   www.vaishnavism.org
Copyright


The contents of this book can be freely distributed as long as the original source is mentioned.




      2   www.vaishnavism.org
Preface


This work was compiled to clarify certain questions raised by the secularists concerning the epic
Ramayana and the noble character of Sri Rama. This great Indian figure, revered by millions of
devout hindus has been the target of periodic attacks by secularists and other anti-hindu forces
who are out to defame hindu heroes, hindu history and hindu mythos. Their aim is to
systematically degrade heroes whom the hindusamaj has held in high esteem, to debunk them
and demoralize the hindu society, inject feelings of guilt, and present a caricature of hindu
religion and culture to its ardent lovers and admirers. Clearly, this trend needs to be countered by
the right thinking members and this work is an effort in that direction.



In this brief work, I present some of the topics raised by the anti-hindu forces to “prove” Sri
Rama was less than noble and in the process attack the foundations of our dharma. These mainly
relate to the incidents of Agni Pariksha of Sita, the killing of Vaali/Bali and Shambuka. I present
the counter-arguments, and expose the tactic of the secularists, which is taking things out of
context, and view the events of yore through the prism of modern values/sensibilities.



I have primarily relied on the exposition of the Epic by Madhva, among the traditional Vedantic
exponents and Sri Aurobindo, amongst the modern exponents. In fact, Sri Aurobindo himself
enters into a spirited defence of Rama in his characteristic fashion, combining yogic insight with
plain commonsense. He does an admirable job of knocking down the debunkers.



The author can be contacted at harishkumar09@yahoo.co.in




      3   www.vaishnavism.org
Contents


COPYRIGHT                         2


PREFACE                           3


CONTENTS                          4


INTRODUCTION                      5


THE AGNI PARIKSHA OF SITA         5


HIS TREATMENT OF BALI             8


THE KILLING OF SHAMBUKA          10


EPILOGUE                         11


GLOSSARY                         13




     4     www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama



Introduction

I find that as far as the Ramayana is concerned there are three points that are repeatedly raised to
prove that Lord Rama was not infallible and had many faults and many of his actions are not
acceptable to modern sensibilities. They are:


      1. His suspecting of his wife’s chastity,
      2. His killing of Shambuka who was doing penance and lastly,
      3. His deceitful killing of Vaali.


   All these are given as examples of his less than noble conduct and are often compared with
  Ravana’s noble character, for he never violated Sita when she was in his custody.




The Agni Pariksha of Sita

  The First one is of course regarding the Agni Pariksha. Before we go further we should know
  the story of Ramayana. Rama is the avatar of Lord Vishnu and he came to this world as Rama
  to set an example to human kind. And in the case of the Avatar, his consort Sri Lakshmi also
  descends to aid the Lord in his divine works. She had incarnated as Sita to fulfill His plan. As
  the omnipotent Lord , Rama certainly knows that Sita was untouched. Neither can Sita be
  touched by any mortal or immortal, asura or rakshasha or man as she is the adhipathi of this
  universe. Thus the concept of his suspecting is wife here is a meaningless one. Clearly Rama
  was eager to establish that his wife was pure and fit for the throne of Ayodhya. And it was to
  this end that he asked her to undergo the Agni Pariksha which was meant to elevate the status
  of Sita amongst his subjects. Thus he actually shows how an ideal King should be, one who
  keeps the feelings of the public in mind. We must realize that in those days much was
  expected of kings, quite unlike today’s elected democratic rulers whose misdemeanor we have
  come to expect. Rama has thus established the code of conduct for an ideal king and by his act
  becomes flawless and worthy of respect.




      5   www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama




Madhva states that at the time of abduction, the soul of Lakshmi Devi left her body and it was
occupied by Indra, the Lord of the Heavens. After the return of Sita, Agni Pariksha was used
as an opportunity to burn down the temporary body of Sita, which was then replaced by the
permanent one.


Aurobindo commenting on Lord Rama:


It was his business to be not necessarily a perfect, but a largely representative sattwic Man, a
faithful husband and a lover, a loving and obedient son, a tender and perfect brother, father,
friend—he is friend of all kinds of people, friend of the outcast Guhaka, friend of the Animal
leaders, Sugriva, Hanuman, friend of the vulture Jatayu, friend of even Rakshasa Vibhishana.
All that he was in a brilliant, striking but above all spontaneous and inevitable way, not with
forcing of this note or that like Harishchandra or Shivi, but with a certain harmonious
completeness. But most of all, it was his business to typify and establish the things on which
the social idea and its stability depend, truth and honour, the sense of Dharma, public spirit
and the sense of order. To the first, to truth and honour, much more than to his filial love and
obedience to his father—though to that also—he sacrificed his personal rights as the elect of
the King and the assembly and fourteen of the best years of his life and went into exile in the
forests. To his public spirit and his sense of public order (the great and supreme civic virtue in
the eyes of the ancient Indians, Greeks, Romans, for at that time the maintenance of the
ordered community, not the separate development and satisfaction of the individual was the
pressing need of the human evolution) he sacrificed his own happiness and domestic life and
the happiness of Sita. In that he was at one with the moral sense of all the antique races,
though at variance with the later romantic individualistic sentimental morality of the modern
man who can afford to have that less stern morality just because the ancients sacrificed the
individual in order to make the world safe for the spirit of social order. Finally, it was Rama's
business to make the world safe for the ideal of the sattwic human being by destroying the
sovereignty of Ravana, the Rakshasa menace. All this he did with such a divine afflatus in his
personality and action that his figure has been stamped for more than two millenniums on the
mind of Indian culture, and what he stood for has dominated the reason and idealising mind of




   6   www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama




man in all countries, and in spite of the constant revolt of the human vital, is likely to continue
to do so until a greater ideal arises. And you say in spite of all these that he was no Avatar? If
you like—but at any rate he stands among the few greatest Vibhutis. You may dethrone him
now—for man is no longer satisfied with the sattwic ideal and is seeking for something
more—but his work and meaning remain stamped on the past of the earth's evolving race.
When I spoke of the gap that would be left by his absence, I did not mean a gap among the
prophets and intellectuals, but a gap in the scheme of Avatarhood—there was somebody who
was the Avatar of the sattwic Human as Krishna was the Avatar of the overmental
Superman—I can see no one but Rama who can fill the place.


In Aurobindo’s view Rama came to complete an evolutionary task , the establishment of an
orderly society where a sattwic type was established firmly over and above the Rakshashic
type. And also social order and ethics were more important than the individual freedom. So
that on this stable foundation future races can enjoy individual freedom (with which they
criticize Rama himself).


One should understand the circumstances in which Rama came to this world. The society was
dominated by rakshasic people whose primary aim in life was self-gratification. The vitalisic
part of the being was the most dominant. In such society characterized by disorder, he had the
task of bringing in order and discipline. It is thanks to His work, today we can afford to have
all the freedoms and rights, because He and His people sacrificed their rights and freedoms to
create a stable society. If today, modern women have the freedom to live as they want and
criticize Rama for his treatment of Sita, they have to thank Rama first for creating the stable
society, which enabled the future races to focus on individual development and give freedom
of speech/action to one and all. Modern women, more than anybody else, owe a debt of
gratitude to Sri Rama, for he created a stable society which gave the modern races the
confidence to experiment with new ideas such as women’s liberation, gender equality and
other such ideals.




   7   www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama


His treatment of Bali

  The Second issue on which Rama is criticized is his treatment of Vaali/Bali. He was the
  monkey king who usurped the throne of Sugriva.


  Madhva states that it is adharmic to kill sinners in a dharmic fashion. It is a sin to kill a sinner
  dharmically. It is dharmic to kill a sinners in an adharmic fashion. Sinners don’t deserve a
  dharmic death. Madhva lays great emphasis on yogyata or deservedness of individuals.


  A deva or a daivic person has the yogyata to be treated respectfully or fairly especially at the
  time of his death. But an asuric or a Rakshashic individual cannot claim similar status.


  Vaali was a sinner so he did not deserve to be killed from the front. He was therefore killed
  from behind. But on the other hand Ravana was one of the dvarapalakas of Vaikuntha who
  was cursed thrice to be born on earth and battle the Lord so he was basically of a divine
  nature. So Rama faces him squarely and defeats him and disarms and even asks him to come
  back tomorrow well armed. The humiliation of Ravana is recorded by the tamil poet
  Kambar “ Kadanpattarnenjam pol kalanginaanyelangaivendhan , indru poi
  naalaivaaendruvittane” (Ravana felt humiliated, when Rama asked him to return „morrow
  armed with better weapons). When the Avatar descends, it first of all frees the earth of all evil
  doers and creates an atmosphere suitable for Yoga. Vishnu also uses this opportunity to take
  back all his closest devotees and especially the great souls who had been cursed to be born on
  earth to fulfill his plan for the cosmos.


  Aurobindo on the killing of Vaali/Bali by Rama:


  Volume: 12 [CWSA] (Essays Divine and Human), Page: 495 Ravana's mind thought it was
  hungering after universal sovereignty and victory over Rama; but the aim his soul kept its
  vision fixed upon all the time was to get back to its heaven as soon as possible & be again
  God's menial. Therefore, as the shortest way, it hurled itself against God in a furious clasp of
  enmity.



     8   www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama




At any rate Rama has proved his bravery in his fight against Ravana and also in his fight
against the demons who tried to thwart the yajna of Vishwamitra. There was no need to prove
it against an underserving infra human like Vaali.


Volume: 22-23-24 [SABCL] (Letters on Yoga), Page: 415 No, certainly not—an Avatar is not
at all bound to be a spiritual prophet—he is never in fact merely a prophet, he is a realiser, an
establisher—not of outward things only, though he does realise something in the outward also,
but, as I have said, of something essential and radical needed for the terrestrial evolution
which is the evolution of the embodied spirit through successive stages towards the Divine.


It was not at all Rama's business to establish the spiritual stage of that evolution—so he did
not at all concern himself with that. His business was to destroy Ravana and to establish the
Rama-rajya—in other words, to fix for the future the possibility of an order proper to the
sattwic civilised human being who governs his life by the reason, the finer emotions, morality,
or at least moral ideals, such as truth, obedience, co-operation and harmony, the sense of
domestic and public order,—to establish this in a world still occupied by anarchic forces, the
Animal mind and the powers of the vital Ego making its own satisfaction the rule of life, in
other words, the Vanara and Rakshasa. This is the meaning of Rama and his life-work and it
is according as he fulfilled it or not that he must be judged as Avatar or no Avatar. It was not
his business to play the comedy of the chivalrous Kshatriya with the formidable brute beast
that was Bali, it was his business to kill him and get the Animal under his control.


If we judge Rama by our human standards , bullets for karsevaks and biriyani for terrorists ,
Rama certainly does not come out very well. But Rama belongs to the divine world and in that
world there is a difference between divine and demonic , the two are not equal (never equal
according to Madhva) and the treatment is different for both of them.


Vishnu as both Rama and Krishna upheld the divine law. As Rama he upheld it by his actions
and as Krishna he did not directly participate in the wars but he always advised his servants to




   9   www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama




 kill the asuras by deceit and trickery. Thus Bhimasena was advised by Krishna to hit
 Duryodhana below the waist and kill him which also helped fulfill Bhimasena’s vow that he
 would shatter the sinner’s thighs. Also when killing Keechaka ,Arjuna dresses as a lady to
 seduce the rakshasha, and once inside the trap , he is eliminated by Bhima . Again
 Bhimasena, after killing Dushashana tears up his body to pieces. When Bhishma objects to
 this as an act of barbarism Krishna comes to the defence of Bhima and states that a sinner like
 Dushashana only deserved that kind of a death, he deserves to be torn apart and scatterd in the
 battlefield and not given a decent treatment. But when it came to Shishupala, the reincarnation
 of Ravana , or more precisely the dvarapalaka , Krishna allows him to abuse him a hundred
 times and after that kills him with his Chakra.




The Killing of Shambuka

 The Third issue on which Rama is often attacked is his killing of Shambuka. We are told that
 Shambuka was a shudra who was doing penance to attain salvation and he did not like the
 shudra aspiring for salvation so he was killed off. But the real reason was that Shambuka was
 an asura and he was aspiring for Indra’s position and he was doing penance for that. It was to
 protect devas from the asura that Rama destroyed his penance. Also let us not forget Rama ate
 the half-eaten fruits given to him by Shabari who was aspiring for salvation. Do you mean to
 say Rama loves Scheduled Tribes but hates Shudras? This is really funny to say the least !




   10   www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama




Epilogue


I cannot think of a better closing than quoting Aurobindo:


Volume: 22-23-24 [SABCL] (Letters on Yoga), Page: 413


I have no intention of entering into a supreme defence of Rama—I only entered into the points
about Bali etc. because these are usually employed nowadays to belittle him as a great
personality on the usual level. But from the point of view of Avatarhood I would no more think
of defending his moral perfection according to modern standards than I would think of defending
Napoleon or Caesar against the moralists or the democratic critics or the debunkers in order to
prove that they were Vibhutis. Vibhuti, Avatar are terms which have their own meaning and
scope, and they are not concerned with morality or immorality, perfection or imperfection
according to small human standards or setting an example to men or showing new moral
attitudes or giving new spiritual teachings. These may or may not be done, but they are not at all
the essence of the matter.


Also, I do not consider your method of dealing with the human personality of Rama to be the
right one. It has to be taken as a whole in the setting that Valmiki gave it (not treated as if it were
the story of a modern man) and with the significance that he gave to his hero's personality, deeds
and works. If it is pulled out of its setting and analyzed under the dissecting knife of a modern
ethical mind, it loses all its significance at once. Krishna so treated becomes a debauchee and
trickster who no doubt did great things in politics—but so did Rama in war. Achilles and
Odysseus pulled out of their setting become, one a furious egoistic savage, and the other a cruel
and cunning savage. I consider myself under an obligation to enter into the spirit, significance,
atmosphere of the Mahabharata, Iliad, Ramayana and identify myself with their time-spirit
before I can feel what their heroes were in themselves apart from the details of their outer action.


As for the Avatarhood, I accept it for Rama because he fills a place in the scheme—and seems to
me to fill it rightly—and because when I read the Ramayana I feel a great afflatus which I



     11   www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama




recognise and which makes of its story—mere faery-tale though it seems—a parable of a great
critical transitional event that happened in the terrestrial evolution and gives to the main
character's personality and action a significance of the large typical cosmic kind which these
actions would not have had if they had been done by another man in another scheme of events.
The Avatar is not bound to do extraordinary actions, but he is bound to give his acts or his work
or what he is—any of these or all—a significance and an effective power that are part of
something essential to be done in the history of the earth and its races.


All the same, if anybody does not see as I do and wants to eject Rama from his place, I have no
objection—I have no particular partiality for Rama—provided somebody is put in who can
worthily fill up the gap his absence leaves. There was somebody there, Valmiki's Rama or
another Rama or somebody not Rama. Also I do not mean that I admit the validity of your
remarks about Rama, even taken as a piecemeal criticism, but that I have no time for today. I
maintain my position about the killing of Bali and the banishment of Sita in spite of Bali's
preliminary objection to the procedure, afterwards retracted, and in spite of the opinion of
Rama's relatives, necessarily from the point of view of the antique dharma—not from that of any
universal moral standard—which besides does not exist, since the standard changes according to
clime or age.


Volume: 22-23-24 [SABCL] (Letters on Yoga), Page: 419


I am afraid your picture of him is quite out of focus—you efface the main lines of the characters,
belittle and brush out all the lights to which Valmiki gave so much value and prominence and
hammer always at some details and some parts of shadow which you turn into the larger part of
Rama. That is what the debunkers do—but a debunked figure is not the true figure.




     12   www.vaishnavism.org
In defence of Sri Rama




Glossary

Asura – A being which distorts the truth and projects falsehood in the mental plane

Agni Pariksha – Trial by fire

Avatar – Descent. Refers to the descent into earth plane of the Supreme Godhead Vishnu

Adhipathi– One who owns and presides

Dharma – Law (of nature), intrinsic quality

Deva – A divine being

Daivic – of a divine nature

Dvarapalakas– door keepers

Kshatriya – One who defends the divine law with his physical and administrative strength

Karsevak– One who offers worship prior to the construction of a temple

Rama-rajya– Rule of Rama, considered the ideal rule

Rakshasha – A being which operates in the lower vital planes and is prone to lust, anger and violence.

Sattwic– Pure. One of the three modes of nature, the other two being passion and inertia.

Vanara– of the type of an ape

Vibhuti – A great achiever or realiser.

Vaikuntha – literally, no anxiety, the residence of Vishnu

Yogyata – deservedness

Yoga – Union (with the divine)

Yajna – worship, also a particular ritual of worship, involving offering ghee into a fire-altar




     13    www.vaishnavism.org

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Boloji version of the indian zero (april 2006)
Boloji version of the indian zero (april 2006)Boloji version of the indian zero (april 2006)
Boloji version of the indian zero (april 2006)Kamesh Aiyer
 
Gandhiyan Philosophy in Raja Rao's Novel Kanthapura
Gandhiyan Philosophy in Raja Rao's Novel KanthapuraGandhiyan Philosophy in Raja Rao's Novel Kanthapura
Gandhiyan Philosophy in Raja Rao's Novel KanthapuraProf.Ravindra Borse
 
Book Review on Asura:The Tale of the vanquished
Book Review on Asura:The Tale of the vanquishedBook Review on Asura:The Tale of the vanquished
Book Review on Asura:The Tale of the vanquishedAtul Gupta
 
Life of Vivekananda by Romain Rolland
Life of Vivekananda by Romain RollandLife of Vivekananda by Romain Rolland
Life of Vivekananda by Romain RollandAnimesh Mishra
 
Hindu tantra tradition ( from google.com )
Hindu tantra tradition ( from google.com )Hindu tantra tradition ( from google.com )
Hindu tantra tradition ( from google.com )Som-Deepak Kumar-Sawant
 
What attracted me in mythological stories
What attracted me in mythological  storiesWhat attracted me in mythological  stories
What attracted me in mythological storiesKIRTISHDUDWADKAR
 
Indian Mythology and Modern Technology
Indian Mythology and Modern Technology  Indian Mythology and Modern Technology
Indian Mythology and Modern Technology Kuna Yellamma
 
A Critical survey of the Mahabharta
A Critical survey of the MahabhartaA Critical survey of the Mahabharta
A Critical survey of the Mahabhartainventionjournals
 
Oh terrifying mother
Oh terrifying motherOh terrifying mother
Oh terrifying motherAthira Reghu
 
An Analysis of the Inherent Realism Prevalent in the Novels of R K Narayan
An Analysis of the Inherent Realism Prevalent in the Novels of R K NarayanAn Analysis of the Inherent Realism Prevalent in the Novels of R K Narayan
An Analysis of the Inherent Realism Prevalent in the Novels of R K Narayanpaperpublications3
 
Love and Chivalry in Iranian Old Stories
Love and Chivalry in Iranian Old StoriesLove and Chivalry in Iranian Old Stories
Love and Chivalry in Iranian Old StoriesMaryam Musharraf
 
Rudra shiva of devrani temple by indrajit bandyopadhyay .
Rudra shiva of devrani temple  by indrajit bandyopadhyay  .Rudra shiva of devrani temple  by indrajit bandyopadhyay  .
Rudra shiva of devrani temple by indrajit bandyopadhyay .Deepak Somaji-Sawant
 
Kabir's reflection: self-analysis and social Intervention in Indian context
Kabir's reflection: self-analysis and social Intervention in Indian contextKabir's reflection: self-analysis and social Intervention in Indian context
Kabir's reflection: self-analysis and social Intervention in Indian contextSlideshare by NBD (naorem binita devi)
 
Sri bhagavatham questions with answers
Sri bhagavatham questions with answers Sri bhagavatham questions with answers
Sri bhagavatham questions with answers Anand Dayanidhi
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Boloji version of the indian zero (april 2006)
Boloji version of the indian zero (april 2006)Boloji version of the indian zero (april 2006)
Boloji version of the indian zero (april 2006)
 
Vahanas 2
Vahanas 2Vahanas 2
Vahanas 2
 
Gandhiyan Philosophy in Raja Rao's Novel Kanthapura
Gandhiyan Philosophy in Raja Rao's Novel KanthapuraGandhiyan Philosophy in Raja Rao's Novel Kanthapura
Gandhiyan Philosophy in Raja Rao's Novel Kanthapura
 
Oral Epics in India
Oral Epics in IndiaOral Epics in India
Oral Epics in India
 
Book Review on Asura:The Tale of the vanquished
Book Review on Asura:The Tale of the vanquishedBook Review on Asura:The Tale of the vanquished
Book Review on Asura:The Tale of the vanquished
 
Life of Vivekananda by Romain Rolland
Life of Vivekananda by Romain RollandLife of Vivekananda by Romain Rolland
Life of Vivekananda by Romain Rolland
 
Hindu tantra tradition ( from google.com )
Hindu tantra tradition ( from google.com )Hindu tantra tradition ( from google.com )
Hindu tantra tradition ( from google.com )
 
What attracted me in mythological stories
What attracted me in mythological  storiesWhat attracted me in mythological  stories
What attracted me in mythological stories
 
Indian Mythology and Modern Technology
Indian Mythology and Modern Technology  Indian Mythology and Modern Technology
Indian Mythology and Modern Technology
 
A Critical survey of the Mahabharta
A Critical survey of the MahabhartaA Critical survey of the Mahabharta
A Critical survey of the Mahabharta
 
Oh terrifying mother
Oh terrifying motherOh terrifying mother
Oh terrifying mother
 
The Hindu Pantheon
The Hindu PantheonThe Hindu Pantheon
The Hindu Pantheon
 
Hinduism
HinduismHinduism
Hinduism
 
An Analysis of the Inherent Realism Prevalent in the Novels of R K Narayan
An Analysis of the Inherent Realism Prevalent in the Novels of R K NarayanAn Analysis of the Inherent Realism Prevalent in the Novels of R K Narayan
An Analysis of the Inherent Realism Prevalent in the Novels of R K Narayan
 
Love and Chivalry in Iranian Old Stories
Love and Chivalry in Iranian Old StoriesLove and Chivalry in Iranian Old Stories
Love and Chivalry in Iranian Old Stories
 
VARNA DHARMA
VARNA DHARMAVARNA DHARMA
VARNA DHARMA
 
Rudra shiva of devrani temple by indrajit bandyopadhyay .
Rudra shiva of devrani temple  by indrajit bandyopadhyay  .Rudra shiva of devrani temple  by indrajit bandyopadhyay  .
Rudra shiva of devrani temple by indrajit bandyopadhyay .
 
Kabir's reflection: self-analysis and social Intervention in Indian context
Kabir's reflection: self-analysis and social Intervention in Indian contextKabir's reflection: self-analysis and social Intervention in Indian context
Kabir's reflection: self-analysis and social Intervention in Indian context
 
Sri bhagavatham questions with answers
Sri bhagavatham questions with answers Sri bhagavatham questions with answers
Sri bhagavatham questions with answers
 
Symbolism of a lion and understanding of ancient history
Symbolism of a lion and understanding of ancient historySymbolism of a lion and understanding of ancient history
Symbolism of a lion and understanding of ancient history
 

Destacado

A Top NS Men in Singapore Polytechnic
A Top NS Men in Singapore PolytechnicA Top NS Men in Singapore Polytechnic
A Top NS Men in Singapore PolytechnicSerene Leong
 
Qtp Mock Test1
Qtp Mock Test1Qtp Mock Test1
Qtp Mock Test1User1test
 
Bioastronomy - Craig Brown
Bioastronomy - Craig BrownBioastronomy - Craig Brown
Bioastronomy - Craig Brownandrew.r.smith
 
Hw to factor
Hw to factorHw to factor
Hw to factor41142391
 
Temporal Knowledge Acquisition and Modeling
Temporal Knowledge Acquisition and ModelingTemporal Knowledge Acquisition and Modeling
Temporal Knowledge Acquisition and ModelingCyril Faucher
 
Formulación inorgánica
Formulación inorgánicaFormulación inorgánica
Formulación inorgánicabesteiroalonso
 
Lectionline xv domenica del t o anno a_13 luglio
Lectionline xv domenica del t o  anno a_13 luglioLectionline xv domenica del t o  anno a_13 luglio
Lectionline xv domenica del t o anno a_13 luglioMaike Loes
 
Kozma Szilárd karma- és családasztrológusAz anyag titka
Kozma Szilárd karma- és családasztrológusAz anyag titkaKozma Szilárd karma- és családasztrológusAz anyag titka
Kozma Szilárd karma- és családasztrológusAz anyag titkaVioletta Joó
 
Microprocesadores[1]
Microprocesadores[1]Microprocesadores[1]
Microprocesadores[1]Javier Santos
 
Watch my doc
Watch my docWatch my doc
Watch my docstoliros
 
Content Analysis
Content AnalysisContent Analysis
Content Analysisstoliros
 
Study skillsppt
Study skillspptStudy skillsppt
Study skillspptrnesbit
 
Vasse presentation stephen lee
Vasse presentation stephen leeVasse presentation stephen lee
Vasse presentation stephen leeVasseSep2010
 
Lectionline esaltazione della croce anno a
Lectionline esaltazione della croce anno aLectionline esaltazione della croce anno a
Lectionline esaltazione della croce anno aMaike Loes
 
Cor animatore-missionario-04
Cor animatore-missionario-04Cor animatore-missionario-04
Cor animatore-missionario-04Maike Loes
 
LU fakultāšu Domnieku seminars
LU fakultāšu Domnieku seminarsLU fakultāšu Domnieku seminars
LU fakultāšu Domnieku seminarsPeteris Jurcenko
 
Af Group Consulting Company Profile
Af Group Consulting Company ProfileAf Group Consulting Company Profile
Af Group Consulting Company Profilemarcoferrari
 
Home Rule: The Case for Blue Island
Home Rule: The Case for Blue IslandHome Rule: The Case for Blue Island
Home Rule: The Case for Blue Islandourhomeourfuture
 

Destacado (20)

модель сотрудничества
модель сотрудничествамодель сотрудничества
модель сотрудничества
 
A Top NS Men in Singapore Polytechnic
A Top NS Men in Singapore PolytechnicA Top NS Men in Singapore Polytechnic
A Top NS Men in Singapore Polytechnic
 
Qtp Mock Test1
Qtp Mock Test1Qtp Mock Test1
Qtp Mock Test1
 
Bioastronomy - Craig Brown
Bioastronomy - Craig BrownBioastronomy - Craig Brown
Bioastronomy - Craig Brown
 
Hw to factor
Hw to factorHw to factor
Hw to factor
 
Temporal Knowledge Acquisition and Modeling
Temporal Knowledge Acquisition and ModelingTemporal Knowledge Acquisition and Modeling
Temporal Knowledge Acquisition and Modeling
 
Formulación inorgánica
Formulación inorgánicaFormulación inorgánica
Formulación inorgánica
 
Lectionline xv domenica del t o anno a_13 luglio
Lectionline xv domenica del t o  anno a_13 luglioLectionline xv domenica del t o  anno a_13 luglio
Lectionline xv domenica del t o anno a_13 luglio
 
Kozma Szilárd karma- és családasztrológusAz anyag titka
Kozma Szilárd karma- és családasztrológusAz anyag titkaKozma Szilárd karma- és családasztrológusAz anyag titka
Kozma Szilárd karma- és családasztrológusAz anyag titka
 
Microprocesadores[1]
Microprocesadores[1]Microprocesadores[1]
Microprocesadores[1]
 
Watch my doc
Watch my docWatch my doc
Watch my doc
 
Content Analysis
Content AnalysisContent Analysis
Content Analysis
 
Study skillsppt
Study skillspptStudy skillsppt
Study skillsppt
 
Vasse presentation stephen lee
Vasse presentation stephen leeVasse presentation stephen lee
Vasse presentation stephen lee
 
Lectionline esaltazione della croce anno a
Lectionline esaltazione della croce anno aLectionline esaltazione della croce anno a
Lectionline esaltazione della croce anno a
 
Cor animatore-missionario-04
Cor animatore-missionario-04Cor animatore-missionario-04
Cor animatore-missionario-04
 
Ppt voorprogrammas
Ppt voorprogrammasPpt voorprogrammas
Ppt voorprogrammas
 
LU fakultāšu Domnieku seminars
LU fakultāšu Domnieku seminarsLU fakultāšu Domnieku seminars
LU fakultāšu Domnieku seminars
 
Af Group Consulting Company Profile
Af Group Consulting Company ProfileAf Group Consulting Company Profile
Af Group Consulting Company Profile
 
Home Rule: The Case for Blue Island
Home Rule: The Case for Blue IslandHome Rule: The Case for Blue Island
Home Rule: The Case for Blue Island
 

Similar a In Defence of Sri Rama

Lecture on ramayana (afro asian lit)
Lecture on ramayana (afro asian lit)Lecture on ramayana (afro asian lit)
Lecture on ramayana (afro asian lit)Jesullyna Manuel
 
Essay On Sitna In Ramayana
Essay On Sitna In RamayanaEssay On Sitna In Ramayana
Essay On Sitna In RamayanaCarla Jardine
 
The Theme Of Dharma Can Be Found Throughout The Ramayana
The Theme Of Dharma Can Be Found Throughout The RamayanaThe Theme Of Dharma Can Be Found Throughout The Ramayana
The Theme Of Dharma Can Be Found Throughout The RamayanaLaura Hall
 
Concept Concepts Of Feminine Power Essay
Concept Concepts Of Feminine Power EssayConcept Concepts Of Feminine Power Essay
Concept Concepts Of Feminine Power EssayJennifer Campbell
 
Lakshmana Research Paper
Lakshmana Research PaperLakshmana Research Paper
Lakshmana Research PaperCindy Collins
 
The Ramayana Family Role
The Ramayana Family RoleThe Ramayana Family Role
The Ramayana Family RoleNicole Dixon
 
Characterization Of Ramayana Ram
Characterization Of Ramayana RamCharacterization Of Ramayana Ram
Characterization Of Ramayana RamMarcy Gilman
 
Essay About Bram Stokers &Quot;Dracula&Quot;
Essay About Bram Stokers &Quot;Dracula&Quot;Essay About Bram Stokers &Quot;Dracula&Quot;
Essay About Bram Stokers &Quot;Dracula&Quot;Liz Sims
 
Patriarchy Of Ancient Indian Women
Patriarchy Of Ancient Indian WomenPatriarchy Of Ancient Indian Women
Patriarchy Of Ancient Indian WomenLeslie Lee
 
Submission And Action Of Religious Heroines
Submission And Action Of Religious HeroinesSubmission And Action Of Religious Heroines
Submission And Action Of Religious HeroinesElizabeth Temburu
 
Ramayana Ascetic Viswamirtha
Ramayana Ascetic ViswamirthaRamayana Ascetic Viswamirtha
Ramayana Ascetic ViswamirthaVictoria Leon
 

Similar a In Defence of Sri Rama (20)

Essay On Ramayana
Essay On RamayanaEssay On Ramayana
Essay On Ramayana
 
Ramayana
RamayanaRamayana
Ramayana
 
Lecture on ramayana (afro asian lit)
Lecture on ramayana (afro asian lit)Lecture on ramayana (afro asian lit)
Lecture on ramayana (afro asian lit)
 
The Ramayana Essay
The Ramayana EssayThe Ramayana Essay
The Ramayana Essay
 
The Concept Of Karma In The Ramayana
The Concept Of Karma In The RamayanaThe Concept Of Karma In The Ramayana
The Concept Of Karma In The Ramayana
 
Essay On Sitna In Ramayana
Essay On Sitna In RamayanaEssay On Sitna In Ramayana
Essay On Sitna In Ramayana
 
The Theme Of Dharma Can Be Found Throughout The Ramayana
The Theme Of Dharma Can Be Found Throughout The RamayanaThe Theme Of Dharma Can Be Found Throughout The Ramayana
The Theme Of Dharma Can Be Found Throughout The Ramayana
 
Concept Concepts Of Feminine Power Essay
Concept Concepts Of Feminine Power EssayConcept Concepts Of Feminine Power Essay
Concept Concepts Of Feminine Power Essay
 
Ramayana Analysis Essay
Ramayana Analysis EssayRamayana Analysis Essay
Ramayana Analysis Essay
 
The Story Of The Ramayana
The Story Of The RamayanaThe Story Of The Ramayana
The Story Of The Ramayana
 
Lakshmana Research Paper
Lakshmana Research PaperLakshmana Research Paper
Lakshmana Research Paper
 
The Ramayana By R.K. Narayan Essay
The Ramayana By R.K. Narayan EssayThe Ramayana By R.K. Narayan Essay
The Ramayana By R.K. Narayan Essay
 
The Ramayana Family Role
The Ramayana Family RoleThe Ramayana Family Role
The Ramayana Family Role
 
Characterization Of Ramayana Ram
Characterization Of Ramayana RamCharacterization Of Ramayana Ram
Characterization Of Ramayana Ram
 
Essay About Bram Stokers &Quot;Dracula&Quot;
Essay About Bram Stokers &Quot;Dracula&Quot;Essay About Bram Stokers &Quot;Dracula&Quot;
Essay About Bram Stokers &Quot;Dracula&Quot;
 
What Is The Love Of Ramayana
What Is The Love Of RamayanaWhat Is The Love Of Ramayana
What Is The Love Of Ramayana
 
Patriarchy Of Ancient Indian Women
Patriarchy Of Ancient Indian WomenPatriarchy Of Ancient Indian Women
Patriarchy Of Ancient Indian Women
 
Submission And Action Of Religious Heroines
Submission And Action Of Religious HeroinesSubmission And Action Of Religious Heroines
Submission And Action Of Religious Heroines
 
Ramayana Ascetic Viswamirtha
Ramayana Ascetic ViswamirthaRamayana Ascetic Viswamirtha
Ramayana Ascetic Viswamirtha
 
Samskara
SamskaraSamskara
Samskara
 

Último

All About Zakah for Muslim Americans - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidance...
All About Zakah for Muslim Americans - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidance...All About Zakah for Muslim Americans - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidance...
All About Zakah for Muslim Americans - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidance...iqra tube
 
DP & Nostradamus-Fatima-Bailey-Branham-Ford - Short vers
DP & Nostradamus-Fatima-Bailey-Branham-Ford - Short versDP & Nostradamus-Fatima-Bailey-Branham-Ford - Short vers
DP & Nostradamus-Fatima-Bailey-Branham-Ford - Short versBengt & Maarit de Paulis
 
Old Age but fruitful and meaningful.pptx
Old Age but fruitful and meaningful.pptxOld Age but fruitful and meaningful.pptx
Old Age but fruitful and meaningful.pptxInnovator Marbun
 
The Mormon & Quaker Moons of Lancashire: Stories of Religious Conversion & Mi...
The Mormon & Quaker Moons of Lancashire: Stories of Religious Conversion & Mi...The Mormon & Quaker Moons of Lancashire: Stories of Religious Conversion & Mi...
The Mormon & Quaker Moons of Lancashire: Stories of Religious Conversion & Mi...Cometan
 
Free eBook ~Short Inspirational Stories - The Benefits.pdf
Free eBook ~Short Inspirational Stories - The Benefits.pdfFree eBook ~Short Inspirational Stories - The Benefits.pdf
Free eBook ~Short Inspirational Stories - The Benefits.pdfOH TEIK BIN
 
DP & Jesus Marriage - 2 potential candidates
DP & Jesus Marriage - 2 potential candidatesDP & Jesus Marriage - 2 potential candidates
DP & Jesus Marriage - 2 potential candidatesBengt & Maarit de Paulis
 
Indications of Rebirth ~ My Reflections (English & Chinese).pptx
Indications of  Rebirth ~ My Reflections (English & Chinese).pptxIndications of  Rebirth ~ My Reflections (English & Chinese).pptx
Indications of Rebirth ~ My Reflections (English & Chinese).pptxOH TEIK BIN
 
Easter Apocalypse_Palm Sunday_Rev. 7.pptx
Easter Apocalypse_Palm Sunday_Rev. 7.pptxEaster Apocalypse_Palm Sunday_Rev. 7.pptx
Easter Apocalypse_Palm Sunday_Rev. 7.pptxStephen Palm
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 3 24 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 3 24 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 3 24 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 3 24 24deerfootcoc
 
April 2024 Calendar of Events Hope Lutheran Church Floodwood
April 2024 Calendar of Events Hope Lutheran Church FloodwoodApril 2024 Calendar of Events Hope Lutheran Church Floodwood
April 2024 Calendar of Events Hope Lutheran Church FloodwoodFloodwoodvern
 
365 Days of Thanking God_ Cultivating a Heart of Thanksgiving Everyday (Revis...
365 Days of Thanking God_ Cultivating a Heart of Thanksgiving Everyday (Revis...365 Days of Thanking God_ Cultivating a Heart of Thanksgiving Everyday (Revis...
365 Days of Thanking God_ Cultivating a Heart of Thanksgiving Everyday (Revis...Eizijesu Obahaiye
 
SERPENT COIL: THE AWAKENING OF KUNDALINI
SERPENT COIL: THE AWAKENING OF KUNDALINISERPENT COIL: THE AWAKENING OF KUNDALINI
SERPENT COIL: THE AWAKENING OF KUNDALINISantanu Das
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_93_Fear God
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_93_Fear GodThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_93_Fear God
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_93_Fear GodNetwork Bible Fellowship
 
Islamic Finance 101 - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidancecollege.org/]
Islamic Finance 101 - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidancecollege.org/]Islamic Finance 101 - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidancecollege.org/]
Islamic Finance 101 - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidancecollege.org/]iqra tube
 

Último (15)

English - The 1st Book of Adam and Eve.pdf
English - The 1st Book of Adam and Eve.pdfEnglish - The 1st Book of Adam and Eve.pdf
English - The 1st Book of Adam and Eve.pdf
 
All About Zakah for Muslim Americans - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidance...
All About Zakah for Muslim Americans - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidance...All About Zakah for Muslim Americans - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidance...
All About Zakah for Muslim Americans - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidance...
 
DP & Nostradamus-Fatima-Bailey-Branham-Ford - Short vers
DP & Nostradamus-Fatima-Bailey-Branham-Ford - Short versDP & Nostradamus-Fatima-Bailey-Branham-Ford - Short vers
DP & Nostradamus-Fatima-Bailey-Branham-Ford - Short vers
 
Old Age but fruitful and meaningful.pptx
Old Age but fruitful and meaningful.pptxOld Age but fruitful and meaningful.pptx
Old Age but fruitful and meaningful.pptx
 
The Mormon & Quaker Moons of Lancashire: Stories of Religious Conversion & Mi...
The Mormon & Quaker Moons of Lancashire: Stories of Religious Conversion & Mi...The Mormon & Quaker Moons of Lancashire: Stories of Religious Conversion & Mi...
The Mormon & Quaker Moons of Lancashire: Stories of Religious Conversion & Mi...
 
Free eBook ~Short Inspirational Stories - The Benefits.pdf
Free eBook ~Short Inspirational Stories - The Benefits.pdfFree eBook ~Short Inspirational Stories - The Benefits.pdf
Free eBook ~Short Inspirational Stories - The Benefits.pdf
 
DP & Jesus Marriage - 2 potential candidates
DP & Jesus Marriage - 2 potential candidatesDP & Jesus Marriage - 2 potential candidates
DP & Jesus Marriage - 2 potential candidates
 
Indications of Rebirth ~ My Reflections (English & Chinese).pptx
Indications of  Rebirth ~ My Reflections (English & Chinese).pptxIndications of  Rebirth ~ My Reflections (English & Chinese).pptx
Indications of Rebirth ~ My Reflections (English & Chinese).pptx
 
Easter Apocalypse_Palm Sunday_Rev. 7.pptx
Easter Apocalypse_Palm Sunday_Rev. 7.pptxEaster Apocalypse_Palm Sunday_Rev. 7.pptx
Easter Apocalypse_Palm Sunday_Rev. 7.pptx
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 3 24 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 3 24 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 3 24 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 3 24 24
 
April 2024 Calendar of Events Hope Lutheran Church Floodwood
April 2024 Calendar of Events Hope Lutheran Church FloodwoodApril 2024 Calendar of Events Hope Lutheran Church Floodwood
April 2024 Calendar of Events Hope Lutheran Church Floodwood
 
365 Days of Thanking God_ Cultivating a Heart of Thanksgiving Everyday (Revis...
365 Days of Thanking God_ Cultivating a Heart of Thanksgiving Everyday (Revis...365 Days of Thanking God_ Cultivating a Heart of Thanksgiving Everyday (Revis...
365 Days of Thanking God_ Cultivating a Heart of Thanksgiving Everyday (Revis...
 
SERPENT COIL: THE AWAKENING OF KUNDALINI
SERPENT COIL: THE AWAKENING OF KUNDALINISERPENT COIL: THE AWAKENING OF KUNDALINI
SERPENT COIL: THE AWAKENING OF KUNDALINI
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_93_Fear God
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_93_Fear GodThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_93_Fear God
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_93_Fear God
 
Islamic Finance 101 - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidancecollege.org/]
Islamic Finance 101 - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidancecollege.org/]Islamic Finance 101 - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidancecollege.org/]
Islamic Finance 101 - Dr. Main Alqudah [https://www.guidancecollege.org/]
 

In Defence of Sri Rama

  • 1. WWW.VAISHNAVISM.ORG In defence of Sri Rama A study of the greatness of Sri Rama D. Harish Kumar 1 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 2. Copyright The contents of this book can be freely distributed as long as the original source is mentioned. 2 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 3. Preface This work was compiled to clarify certain questions raised by the secularists concerning the epic Ramayana and the noble character of Sri Rama. This great Indian figure, revered by millions of devout hindus has been the target of periodic attacks by secularists and other anti-hindu forces who are out to defame hindu heroes, hindu history and hindu mythos. Their aim is to systematically degrade heroes whom the hindusamaj has held in high esteem, to debunk them and demoralize the hindu society, inject feelings of guilt, and present a caricature of hindu religion and culture to its ardent lovers and admirers. Clearly, this trend needs to be countered by the right thinking members and this work is an effort in that direction. In this brief work, I present some of the topics raised by the anti-hindu forces to “prove” Sri Rama was less than noble and in the process attack the foundations of our dharma. These mainly relate to the incidents of Agni Pariksha of Sita, the killing of Vaali/Bali and Shambuka. I present the counter-arguments, and expose the tactic of the secularists, which is taking things out of context, and view the events of yore through the prism of modern values/sensibilities. I have primarily relied on the exposition of the Epic by Madhva, among the traditional Vedantic exponents and Sri Aurobindo, amongst the modern exponents. In fact, Sri Aurobindo himself enters into a spirited defence of Rama in his characteristic fashion, combining yogic insight with plain commonsense. He does an admirable job of knocking down the debunkers. The author can be contacted at harishkumar09@yahoo.co.in 3 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 4. Contents COPYRIGHT 2 PREFACE 3 CONTENTS 4 INTRODUCTION 5 THE AGNI PARIKSHA OF SITA 5 HIS TREATMENT OF BALI 8 THE KILLING OF SHAMBUKA 10 EPILOGUE 11 GLOSSARY 13 4 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 5. In defence of Sri Rama Introduction I find that as far as the Ramayana is concerned there are three points that are repeatedly raised to prove that Lord Rama was not infallible and had many faults and many of his actions are not acceptable to modern sensibilities. They are: 1. His suspecting of his wife’s chastity, 2. His killing of Shambuka who was doing penance and lastly, 3. His deceitful killing of Vaali. All these are given as examples of his less than noble conduct and are often compared with Ravana’s noble character, for he never violated Sita when she was in his custody. The Agni Pariksha of Sita The First one is of course regarding the Agni Pariksha. Before we go further we should know the story of Ramayana. Rama is the avatar of Lord Vishnu and he came to this world as Rama to set an example to human kind. And in the case of the Avatar, his consort Sri Lakshmi also descends to aid the Lord in his divine works. She had incarnated as Sita to fulfill His plan. As the omnipotent Lord , Rama certainly knows that Sita was untouched. Neither can Sita be touched by any mortal or immortal, asura or rakshasha or man as she is the adhipathi of this universe. Thus the concept of his suspecting is wife here is a meaningless one. Clearly Rama was eager to establish that his wife was pure and fit for the throne of Ayodhya. And it was to this end that he asked her to undergo the Agni Pariksha which was meant to elevate the status of Sita amongst his subjects. Thus he actually shows how an ideal King should be, one who keeps the feelings of the public in mind. We must realize that in those days much was expected of kings, quite unlike today’s elected democratic rulers whose misdemeanor we have come to expect. Rama has thus established the code of conduct for an ideal king and by his act becomes flawless and worthy of respect. 5 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 6. In defence of Sri Rama Madhva states that at the time of abduction, the soul of Lakshmi Devi left her body and it was occupied by Indra, the Lord of the Heavens. After the return of Sita, Agni Pariksha was used as an opportunity to burn down the temporary body of Sita, which was then replaced by the permanent one. Aurobindo commenting on Lord Rama: It was his business to be not necessarily a perfect, but a largely representative sattwic Man, a faithful husband and a lover, a loving and obedient son, a tender and perfect brother, father, friend—he is friend of all kinds of people, friend of the outcast Guhaka, friend of the Animal leaders, Sugriva, Hanuman, friend of the vulture Jatayu, friend of even Rakshasa Vibhishana. All that he was in a brilliant, striking but above all spontaneous and inevitable way, not with forcing of this note or that like Harishchandra or Shivi, but with a certain harmonious completeness. But most of all, it was his business to typify and establish the things on which the social idea and its stability depend, truth and honour, the sense of Dharma, public spirit and the sense of order. To the first, to truth and honour, much more than to his filial love and obedience to his father—though to that also—he sacrificed his personal rights as the elect of the King and the assembly and fourteen of the best years of his life and went into exile in the forests. To his public spirit and his sense of public order (the great and supreme civic virtue in the eyes of the ancient Indians, Greeks, Romans, for at that time the maintenance of the ordered community, not the separate development and satisfaction of the individual was the pressing need of the human evolution) he sacrificed his own happiness and domestic life and the happiness of Sita. In that he was at one with the moral sense of all the antique races, though at variance with the later romantic individualistic sentimental morality of the modern man who can afford to have that less stern morality just because the ancients sacrificed the individual in order to make the world safe for the spirit of social order. Finally, it was Rama's business to make the world safe for the ideal of the sattwic human being by destroying the sovereignty of Ravana, the Rakshasa menace. All this he did with such a divine afflatus in his personality and action that his figure has been stamped for more than two millenniums on the mind of Indian culture, and what he stood for has dominated the reason and idealising mind of 6 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 7. In defence of Sri Rama man in all countries, and in spite of the constant revolt of the human vital, is likely to continue to do so until a greater ideal arises. And you say in spite of all these that he was no Avatar? If you like—but at any rate he stands among the few greatest Vibhutis. You may dethrone him now—for man is no longer satisfied with the sattwic ideal and is seeking for something more—but his work and meaning remain stamped on the past of the earth's evolving race. When I spoke of the gap that would be left by his absence, I did not mean a gap among the prophets and intellectuals, but a gap in the scheme of Avatarhood—there was somebody who was the Avatar of the sattwic Human as Krishna was the Avatar of the overmental Superman—I can see no one but Rama who can fill the place. In Aurobindo’s view Rama came to complete an evolutionary task , the establishment of an orderly society where a sattwic type was established firmly over and above the Rakshashic type. And also social order and ethics were more important than the individual freedom. So that on this stable foundation future races can enjoy individual freedom (with which they criticize Rama himself). One should understand the circumstances in which Rama came to this world. The society was dominated by rakshasic people whose primary aim in life was self-gratification. The vitalisic part of the being was the most dominant. In such society characterized by disorder, he had the task of bringing in order and discipline. It is thanks to His work, today we can afford to have all the freedoms and rights, because He and His people sacrificed their rights and freedoms to create a stable society. If today, modern women have the freedom to live as they want and criticize Rama for his treatment of Sita, they have to thank Rama first for creating the stable society, which enabled the future races to focus on individual development and give freedom of speech/action to one and all. Modern women, more than anybody else, owe a debt of gratitude to Sri Rama, for he created a stable society which gave the modern races the confidence to experiment with new ideas such as women’s liberation, gender equality and other such ideals. 7 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 8. In defence of Sri Rama His treatment of Bali The Second issue on which Rama is criticized is his treatment of Vaali/Bali. He was the monkey king who usurped the throne of Sugriva. Madhva states that it is adharmic to kill sinners in a dharmic fashion. It is a sin to kill a sinner dharmically. It is dharmic to kill a sinners in an adharmic fashion. Sinners don’t deserve a dharmic death. Madhva lays great emphasis on yogyata or deservedness of individuals. A deva or a daivic person has the yogyata to be treated respectfully or fairly especially at the time of his death. But an asuric or a Rakshashic individual cannot claim similar status. Vaali was a sinner so he did not deserve to be killed from the front. He was therefore killed from behind. But on the other hand Ravana was one of the dvarapalakas of Vaikuntha who was cursed thrice to be born on earth and battle the Lord so he was basically of a divine nature. So Rama faces him squarely and defeats him and disarms and even asks him to come back tomorrow well armed. The humiliation of Ravana is recorded by the tamil poet Kambar “ Kadanpattarnenjam pol kalanginaanyelangaivendhan , indru poi naalaivaaendruvittane” (Ravana felt humiliated, when Rama asked him to return „morrow armed with better weapons). When the Avatar descends, it first of all frees the earth of all evil doers and creates an atmosphere suitable for Yoga. Vishnu also uses this opportunity to take back all his closest devotees and especially the great souls who had been cursed to be born on earth to fulfill his plan for the cosmos. Aurobindo on the killing of Vaali/Bali by Rama: Volume: 12 [CWSA] (Essays Divine and Human), Page: 495 Ravana's mind thought it was hungering after universal sovereignty and victory over Rama; but the aim his soul kept its vision fixed upon all the time was to get back to its heaven as soon as possible & be again God's menial. Therefore, as the shortest way, it hurled itself against God in a furious clasp of enmity. 8 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 9. In defence of Sri Rama At any rate Rama has proved his bravery in his fight against Ravana and also in his fight against the demons who tried to thwart the yajna of Vishwamitra. There was no need to prove it against an underserving infra human like Vaali. Volume: 22-23-24 [SABCL] (Letters on Yoga), Page: 415 No, certainly not—an Avatar is not at all bound to be a spiritual prophet—he is never in fact merely a prophet, he is a realiser, an establisher—not of outward things only, though he does realise something in the outward also, but, as I have said, of something essential and radical needed for the terrestrial evolution which is the evolution of the embodied spirit through successive stages towards the Divine. It was not at all Rama's business to establish the spiritual stage of that evolution—so he did not at all concern himself with that. His business was to destroy Ravana and to establish the Rama-rajya—in other words, to fix for the future the possibility of an order proper to the sattwic civilised human being who governs his life by the reason, the finer emotions, morality, or at least moral ideals, such as truth, obedience, co-operation and harmony, the sense of domestic and public order,—to establish this in a world still occupied by anarchic forces, the Animal mind and the powers of the vital Ego making its own satisfaction the rule of life, in other words, the Vanara and Rakshasa. This is the meaning of Rama and his life-work and it is according as he fulfilled it or not that he must be judged as Avatar or no Avatar. It was not his business to play the comedy of the chivalrous Kshatriya with the formidable brute beast that was Bali, it was his business to kill him and get the Animal under his control. If we judge Rama by our human standards , bullets for karsevaks and biriyani for terrorists , Rama certainly does not come out very well. But Rama belongs to the divine world and in that world there is a difference between divine and demonic , the two are not equal (never equal according to Madhva) and the treatment is different for both of them. Vishnu as both Rama and Krishna upheld the divine law. As Rama he upheld it by his actions and as Krishna he did not directly participate in the wars but he always advised his servants to 9 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 10. In defence of Sri Rama kill the asuras by deceit and trickery. Thus Bhimasena was advised by Krishna to hit Duryodhana below the waist and kill him which also helped fulfill Bhimasena’s vow that he would shatter the sinner’s thighs. Also when killing Keechaka ,Arjuna dresses as a lady to seduce the rakshasha, and once inside the trap , he is eliminated by Bhima . Again Bhimasena, after killing Dushashana tears up his body to pieces. When Bhishma objects to this as an act of barbarism Krishna comes to the defence of Bhima and states that a sinner like Dushashana only deserved that kind of a death, he deserves to be torn apart and scatterd in the battlefield and not given a decent treatment. But when it came to Shishupala, the reincarnation of Ravana , or more precisely the dvarapalaka , Krishna allows him to abuse him a hundred times and after that kills him with his Chakra. The Killing of Shambuka The Third issue on which Rama is often attacked is his killing of Shambuka. We are told that Shambuka was a shudra who was doing penance to attain salvation and he did not like the shudra aspiring for salvation so he was killed off. But the real reason was that Shambuka was an asura and he was aspiring for Indra’s position and he was doing penance for that. It was to protect devas from the asura that Rama destroyed his penance. Also let us not forget Rama ate the half-eaten fruits given to him by Shabari who was aspiring for salvation. Do you mean to say Rama loves Scheduled Tribes but hates Shudras? This is really funny to say the least ! 10 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 11. In defence of Sri Rama Epilogue I cannot think of a better closing than quoting Aurobindo: Volume: 22-23-24 [SABCL] (Letters on Yoga), Page: 413 I have no intention of entering into a supreme defence of Rama—I only entered into the points about Bali etc. because these are usually employed nowadays to belittle him as a great personality on the usual level. But from the point of view of Avatarhood I would no more think of defending his moral perfection according to modern standards than I would think of defending Napoleon or Caesar against the moralists or the democratic critics or the debunkers in order to prove that they were Vibhutis. Vibhuti, Avatar are terms which have their own meaning and scope, and they are not concerned with morality or immorality, perfection or imperfection according to small human standards or setting an example to men or showing new moral attitudes or giving new spiritual teachings. These may or may not be done, but they are not at all the essence of the matter. Also, I do not consider your method of dealing with the human personality of Rama to be the right one. It has to be taken as a whole in the setting that Valmiki gave it (not treated as if it were the story of a modern man) and with the significance that he gave to his hero's personality, deeds and works. If it is pulled out of its setting and analyzed under the dissecting knife of a modern ethical mind, it loses all its significance at once. Krishna so treated becomes a debauchee and trickster who no doubt did great things in politics—but so did Rama in war. Achilles and Odysseus pulled out of their setting become, one a furious egoistic savage, and the other a cruel and cunning savage. I consider myself under an obligation to enter into the spirit, significance, atmosphere of the Mahabharata, Iliad, Ramayana and identify myself with their time-spirit before I can feel what their heroes were in themselves apart from the details of their outer action. As for the Avatarhood, I accept it for Rama because he fills a place in the scheme—and seems to me to fill it rightly—and because when I read the Ramayana I feel a great afflatus which I 11 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 12. In defence of Sri Rama recognise and which makes of its story—mere faery-tale though it seems—a parable of a great critical transitional event that happened in the terrestrial evolution and gives to the main character's personality and action a significance of the large typical cosmic kind which these actions would not have had if they had been done by another man in another scheme of events. The Avatar is not bound to do extraordinary actions, but he is bound to give his acts or his work or what he is—any of these or all—a significance and an effective power that are part of something essential to be done in the history of the earth and its races. All the same, if anybody does not see as I do and wants to eject Rama from his place, I have no objection—I have no particular partiality for Rama—provided somebody is put in who can worthily fill up the gap his absence leaves. There was somebody there, Valmiki's Rama or another Rama or somebody not Rama. Also I do not mean that I admit the validity of your remarks about Rama, even taken as a piecemeal criticism, but that I have no time for today. I maintain my position about the killing of Bali and the banishment of Sita in spite of Bali's preliminary objection to the procedure, afterwards retracted, and in spite of the opinion of Rama's relatives, necessarily from the point of view of the antique dharma—not from that of any universal moral standard—which besides does not exist, since the standard changes according to clime or age. Volume: 22-23-24 [SABCL] (Letters on Yoga), Page: 419 I am afraid your picture of him is quite out of focus—you efface the main lines of the characters, belittle and brush out all the lights to which Valmiki gave so much value and prominence and hammer always at some details and some parts of shadow which you turn into the larger part of Rama. That is what the debunkers do—but a debunked figure is not the true figure. 12 www.vaishnavism.org
  • 13. In defence of Sri Rama Glossary Asura – A being which distorts the truth and projects falsehood in the mental plane Agni Pariksha – Trial by fire Avatar – Descent. Refers to the descent into earth plane of the Supreme Godhead Vishnu Adhipathi– One who owns and presides Dharma – Law (of nature), intrinsic quality Deva – A divine being Daivic – of a divine nature Dvarapalakas– door keepers Kshatriya – One who defends the divine law with his physical and administrative strength Karsevak– One who offers worship prior to the construction of a temple Rama-rajya– Rule of Rama, considered the ideal rule Rakshasha – A being which operates in the lower vital planes and is prone to lust, anger and violence. Sattwic– Pure. One of the three modes of nature, the other two being passion and inertia. Vanara– of the type of an ape Vibhuti – A great achiever or realiser. Vaikuntha – literally, no anxiety, the residence of Vishnu Yogyata – deservedness Yoga – Union (with the divine) Yajna – worship, also a particular ritual of worship, involving offering ghee into a fire-altar 13 www.vaishnavism.org