SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 26
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Evoking human agency and autonomy
where interpretation
meets indeterminacy
Michael Bach
Canadian Association for Community Living
&
IRIS –
Institute for Research and Development on Inclusion & Society
Presentation to Essex Autonomy Project Conference:
“Is there a conception of autonomy that is: Defensible in Theory and Workable in Practice?”
London, 15th -16th March 2013
March 2013
ARTICLE 12
EQUAL RECOGNITION BEFORE THE LAW
1. right to recognition everywhere as persons before
the law.
2. enjoy legal capacity on an equal basis with
others in all aspects of life.
3. shall have access to the support they may
require in exercising their legal capacity.
4. all measures related to exercise of legal capacity
shall have safeguards (proportional, tailored,
respect will and preferences, time-limited,
reviewable, etc.)
5. measures to ensure equal right to own and inherit
property, control financial affairs, access credit.
Legal Capacity Defined
“legal capacity includes the ‘capacity to act’,
intended as the capacity [capability?] and power
to engage in a particular undertaking or
transaction, to maintain a particular status or
relationship with another individual, and more
in general to create, modify or extinguish legal
relationships.”
(‘Background Paper on Legal Capacity’ – Office of the UN High Commissioner
for Human Rights)
Legal Capacity: ‘power to create, modify, or
extinguish legal relationships’
Health Care Decisions
CRPD Articles: 15, 25, 26
Personal Life Decisions (where to live,
relationships, participation, access,
employment, mobility and supports) CRPD
Articles: 13, 14, 15, 18, 19, 20, 23, 25, 26,
27, 28, 29, 30
Financial/Property Decisions
(purchase, sale, credit, investment, will) -
CRPD Articles: 12(5),28
Key Concepts
• Intentional action – actions by a subject for
which there are recognizable reasons related
to beliefs and desires/pro-attitudes, under
some description
• Agency – intentional action the reasons for
which are recognized to have both
‘correspondence’ and ‘coherence’
• Will – general capacity to have desires and
beliefs and act upon them
• Preferences – particular desires/pro-attitudes
that attach to an intentional action
CRPD Provides a new formula for legal
capacity
Unique d-m
abilities
Supports
Reasonable
accommodation
legal status
Decision-
making
capability
[capacity]
Usual criteria for recognizing decision-
making capability necessary for legal
capacity (and for recognizing
autonomous subjects)
On his/her own, or ‘independently’, an adult,
with supports and accommodation as needed
has the ability to:
• Understand information relevant to a decision
• Appreciate reasonably foreseeable
consequences
• Communicate the decision to others
• At a minimum, communicate recognizable
reasons for actions (i.e. intentionality)
But there are other decision-
making abilities which can
ground recognition of and
respect for legal capacity
Ability for intentional action (based on
recognizable reasons – in descriptions
provided by others)
I want
to…
I don’t
want
to…
Ability to be known by others
as being the same person through time – with a
life story that others weave and tell…
…
Evoking human agency and autonomy where interpretation meets indeterminacy
Ways to Exercise Legal Capacity
Supported
Independent•community
Representative
Facilitated
In the formula…
• D-M Abilities mental capacity (and all
individuals have some decision-making
abilities)
• Mental capacity Legal Capacity
• DM Capability Capacity (for strategic reasons)
• DM Capability is the necessary condition for
full legal capacity
• The state has obligations to ensure decision-
making capability is in place for all (on a ‘
‘progressive realization basis’ both for society
as a whole and in particular cases)
Inclusive Test of Decision-making
Capability (Capacity)
• means that the understanding of the
information relevant to the decision to be made
and the appreciation of the reasonably
foreseeable consequences of such decision or
lack of such decision, may rest either
a) within the adult herself or himself, and with
decision-making supports and reasonable
accommodations as needed; or
b) within the understanding and appreciation of the
person(s) appointed to support the adult in
exercising his or her legal capacity;
(c) Where capacity falls within the purview of (b) there
shall be a requirement that the decision be guided by a
support person(s)' best interpretation of the adult's
intentions, will and preferences and how these are to
be applied to a specific decision(s);
(e) Where an adult’s intentions cannot yet be
reasonably determined for the purposes of a decision,
a facilitator is appointed for arriving at the best
interpretation of a person’s will and preferences as they
should apply to the decision or set of decisions in the
circumstances;
(d) In applying subsections (c) and (d),
(i) “best interpretation” means the
interpretation that seems most reasonably justified in
the circumstances; and
(ii) decision-making supporters must be able to
provide a reasonable account of how this interpretation
was arrived at;
Ways to exercise legal capacity
• Legally independently
– ‘Appreciate and understand test’ with support and
accommodation as needed
• Supported decision making
– Appointment of supporter(s) by the individual
– Others may apply to be appointed, where a person has a
‘profound’ intellectual disability, for e.g.
• Representative decision making
– Person appoints a legal representative to make decisions on behalf of a
person (advance directive, power of attorney)
• Facilitated decision making (no other adult can
recognize or support a person to act on his/her will
and preferences)
– Person appointed to facilitate process for arriving at ‘best
interpretation’ of will and preferences as they should apply
in the circumstances and to a particular decision or set of
decisions.
What is ‘supported decision making?
• Legal right to have certain others recognized in
the decision-making process to enter legal
relationships – who are in a demonstrated
trusting relationship of personal knowledge
and commitment
• Legal requirement that recognized supporters
meet certain duties
• Legal requirement that 3rd parties (physicians,
etc.) respect and accommodate such decision-
making processes
What are supporters actually doing?
• Witnessing another’s consciousness
• Ascribing intentional action to another
• Narrating personal identity of another
• Orchestrating and narrating intention-directed
consequences (see slide)
• Claiming equal moral status for another
A theory of personal identity &
human agency
Consequence
Consequence
Will and
Preferences
(Intention)
We do not transfer agency from one event to
another, or infer that the man was agent not only
of one action but of two [i.e. of putting his foot
on the brake and stopping the car]. We may
indeed extend responsibility or liability for an
action to responsibility or liability for its
consequences, but this we do, not by saddling the
agent with a new action, but by pointing out that
his original action had those results… there are
no further actions, only further descriptions
Donald Davidson
The Accordion Effect – Joel Feinberg
Claiming equal
moral status
Guidance principles for functional
‘decision-making communities’,
‘communities of personal knowers’
‘communities of interpreters’
Guidance principles
1. Personal, experiential knowledge based on
trusting relationships with the adult must be
given a priority status in sources of knowledge
about a person.
2. Narrate the identity of the subject, co-
constructed with others.
• Bear witness to and recover the past.
• Practice an “empathic capacity” in imagining
and identifying with those different to us.
• Challenge official stories and accounts with
the “unofficial” and “dissenting” ones .
Guidance principles
4. Share in and narrate the reflective capacity of
the intending subject
5. Practice a “moral-transformatory”
communicate ethics to manage conflicting
perspectives, which meet a standard of
“epistemic responsibility.”
6. Communities of knowers/interpreters share
critical stories about the application of
technologies for assessing decision-making
capabilities – e.g. capacity to consent.
7. Place ethics before epistemology.

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Evoking human agency and autonomy where interpretation meets indeterminacy

CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS AND IT’S CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITIES.pptx
CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS AND IT’S CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITIES.pptxCIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS AND IT’S CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITIES.pptx
CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS AND IT’S CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITIES.pptxRIZALEAHSAMANIEGO
 
CCher Nicholson Supported decision-making – the South Australian experience
CCher Nicholson Supported decision-making – the South Australian experience CCher Nicholson Supported decision-making – the South Australian experience
CCher Nicholson Supported decision-making – the South Australian experience legislation
 
Ethically presenting mitigation evidence
Ethically presenting mitigation evidenceEthically presenting mitigation evidence
Ethically presenting mitigation evidenceAdam Tebrugge
 
Supported Decision Making SDM
Supported Decision Making SDMSupported Decision Making SDM
Supported Decision Making SDMJack Benke
 
Taking Stock Conference 2014: Court of Protection & MCA: Capacity to Change
Taking Stock Conference 2014: Court of Protection & MCA: Capacity to ChangeTaking Stock Conference 2014: Court of Protection & MCA: Capacity to Change
Taking Stock Conference 2014: Court of Protection & MCA: Capacity to ChangeAnselm Eldergill
 
Bioethics Schools of Thought
Bioethics Schools of ThoughtBioethics Schools of Thought
Bioethics Schools of ThoughtJofred Martinez
 
The Legal Profession Of England And Wales
The Legal Profession Of England And WalesThe Legal Profession Of England And Wales
The Legal Profession Of England And WalesAriana Davis
 
Assisted-Decision Making Bill 2013 (Republic of Ireland)
Assisted-Decision Making Bill 2013 (Republic of Ireland)Assisted-Decision Making Bill 2013 (Republic of Ireland)
Assisted-Decision Making Bill 2013 (Republic of Ireland)Anselm Eldergill
 
Ppt perception and individual Decision Making
Ppt perception and individual Decision MakingPpt perception and individual Decision Making
Ppt perception and individual Decision MakingDeni Triyanto
 
Deontological Paper
Deontological PaperDeontological Paper
Deontological PaperTina Marie
 
Week 11 Ethical Decision Making (1).pdf
Week 11 Ethical Decision Making (1).pdfWeek 11 Ethical Decision Making (1).pdf
Week 11 Ethical Decision Making (1).pdfARVINCRUZ16
 
Making ethical decisions
Making ethical decisionsMaking ethical decisions
Making ethical decisionsrstrickland6
 

Similar a Evoking human agency and autonomy where interpretation meets indeterminacy (20)

CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS AND IT’S CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITIES.pptx
CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS AND IT’S CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITIES.pptxCIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS AND IT’S CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITIES.pptx
CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS AND IT’S CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITIES.pptx
 
CCher Nicholson Supported decision-making – the South Australian experience
CCher Nicholson Supported decision-making – the South Australian experience CCher Nicholson Supported decision-making – the South Australian experience
CCher Nicholson Supported decision-making – the South Australian experience
 
Kongress 2015
Kongress 2015Kongress 2015
Kongress 2015
 
Mediating personal injury claims
Mediating personal injury claimsMediating personal injury claims
Mediating personal injury claims
 
Ethically presenting mitigation evidence
Ethically presenting mitigation evidenceEthically presenting mitigation evidence
Ethically presenting mitigation evidence
 
Supported Decision Making SDM
Supported Decision Making SDMSupported Decision Making SDM
Supported Decision Making SDM
 
Rights and duties jothisj
Rights and duties jothisjRights and duties jothisj
Rights and duties jothisj
 
MCA 2005/ DoLs Briefing
MCA 2005/ DoLs BriefingMCA 2005/ DoLs Briefing
MCA 2005/ DoLs Briefing
 
chapter02
 chapter02 chapter02
chapter02
 
Taking Stock Conference 2014: Court of Protection & MCA: Capacity to Change
Taking Stock Conference 2014: Court of Protection & MCA: Capacity to ChangeTaking Stock Conference 2014: Court of Protection & MCA: Capacity to Change
Taking Stock Conference 2014: Court of Protection & MCA: Capacity to Change
 
MCA 2005 DoLs Briefing
MCA 2005 DoLs BriefingMCA 2005 DoLs Briefing
MCA 2005 DoLs Briefing
 
Bioethics Schools of Thought
Bioethics Schools of ThoughtBioethics Schools of Thought
Bioethics Schools of Thought
 
The Legal Profession Of England And Wales
The Legal Profession Of England And WalesThe Legal Profession Of England And Wales
The Legal Profession Of England And Wales
 
Assisted-Decision Making Bill 2013 (Republic of Ireland)
Assisted-Decision Making Bill 2013 (Republic of Ireland)Assisted-Decision Making Bill 2013 (Republic of Ireland)
Assisted-Decision Making Bill 2013 (Republic of Ireland)
 
Ppt perception and individual Decision Making
Ppt perception and individual Decision MakingPpt perception and individual Decision Making
Ppt perception and individual Decision Making
 
Deontological Paper
Deontological PaperDeontological Paper
Deontological Paper
 
Category 1 ethic
Category 1 ethicCategory 1 ethic
Category 1 ethic
 
Week 11 Ethical Decision Making (1).pdf
Week 11 Ethical Decision Making (1).pdfWeek 11 Ethical Decision Making (1).pdf
Week 11 Ethical Decision Making (1).pdf
 
Making ethical decisions
Making ethical decisionsMaking ethical decisions
Making ethical decisions
 
Qualities of a judge
Qualities of a judgeQualities of a judge
Qualities of a judge
 

Último

World Happiness Report 2024- Full Report
World Happiness Report 2024- Full ReportWorld Happiness Report 2024- Full Report
World Happiness Report 2024- Full ReportEnergy for One World
 
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements PowerpointPPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpointahcitycouncil
 
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.Christina Parmionova
 
Managing Planning and Development of Citie- 26-2-24.docx
Managing Planning and  Development of  Citie-  26-2-24.docxManaging Planning and  Development of  Citie-  26-2-24.docx
Managing Planning and Development of Citie- 26-2-24.docxJIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Leveraging Water for Peace - World Water Day 2024
Leveraging Water for Peace - World Water Day 2024Leveraging Water for Peace - World Water Day 2024
Leveraging Water for Peace - World Water Day 2024Christina Parmionova
 
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New ResearchCBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New ResearchCongressional Budget Office
 
OECD Webinar - ESG to deliver well-being in resource-rich regions: the role o...
OECD Webinar - ESG to deliver well-being in resource-rich regions: the role o...OECD Webinar - ESG to deliver well-being in resource-rich regions: the role o...
OECD Webinar - ESG to deliver well-being in resource-rich regions: the role o...OECDregions
 
Parents can give charity ideas for kids.
Parents can give charity ideas for kids.Parents can give charity ideas for kids.
Parents can give charity ideas for kids.SERUDS INDIA
 
What Teenagers Have to Say about the Grandparents
What Teenagers Have to Say about the GrandparentsWhat Teenagers Have to Say about the Grandparents
What Teenagers Have to Say about the GrandparentsSERUDS INDIA
 
Living life to the full: How can we make our longer lives healthier, happier ...
Living life to the full: How can we make our longer lives healthier, happier ...Living life to the full: How can we make our longer lives healthier, happier ...
Living life to the full: How can we make our longer lives healthier, happier ...ResolutionFoundation
 
Water and peace go hand-in hand. World Water Day 2024
Water and peace go hand-in hand. World Water Day 2024Water and peace go hand-in hand. World Water Day 2024
Water and peace go hand-in hand. World Water Day 2024Christina Parmionova
 
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.ahcitycouncil
 
O Conselho Estadual de Cultura e o Incentivo à Cultura no RS: relato de expe...
O Conselho Estadual de Cultura e o Incentivo à Cultura no RS:  relato de expe...O Conselho Estadual de Cultura e o Incentivo à Cultura no RS:  relato de expe...
O Conselho Estadual de Cultura e o Incentivo à Cultura no RS: relato de expe...Alvaro Santi
 
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.ahcitycouncil
 
Yes!? We can end TB - World Tuberculosis Day 2024.
Yes!? We can end TB - World Tuberculosis Day 2024.Yes!? We can end TB - World Tuberculosis Day 2024.
Yes!? We can end TB - World Tuberculosis Day 2024.Christina Parmionova
 
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM MinutesItem # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutesahcitycouncil
 
Water for Prosperity and peace - United Nations World Water Development Repo...
Water for Prosperity and peace -  United Nations World Water Development Repo...Water for Prosperity and peace -  United Nations World Water Development Repo...
Water for Prosperity and peace - United Nations World Water Development Repo...Christina Parmionova
 
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptxDB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptxNAP Global Network
 
Parents give a charity ideas for children
Parents give a charity ideas for childrenParents give a charity ideas for children
Parents give a charity ideas for childrenSERUDS INDIA
 

Último (20)

World Happiness Report 2024- Full Report
World Happiness Report 2024- Full ReportWorld Happiness Report 2024- Full Report
World Happiness Report 2024- Full Report
 
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements PowerpointPPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
 
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
For World Water Day 2024, we promote the vital link between water and peace.
 
Managing Planning and Development of Citie- 26-2-24.docx
Managing Planning and  Development of  Citie-  26-2-24.docxManaging Planning and  Development of  Citie-  26-2-24.docx
Managing Planning and Development of Citie- 26-2-24.docx
 
Leveraging Water for Peace - World Water Day 2024
Leveraging Water for Peace - World Water Day 2024Leveraging Water for Peace - World Water Day 2024
Leveraging Water for Peace - World Water Day 2024
 
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New ResearchCBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
CBO’s Work on Health Care and a Call for New Research
 
OECD Webinar - ESG to deliver well-being in resource-rich regions: the role o...
OECD Webinar - ESG to deliver well-being in resource-rich regions: the role o...OECD Webinar - ESG to deliver well-being in resource-rich regions: the role o...
OECD Webinar - ESG to deliver well-being in resource-rich regions: the role o...
 
How to Save a Place: Become an Advocate.
How to Save a Place: Become an Advocate.How to Save a Place: Become an Advocate.
How to Save a Place: Become an Advocate.
 
Parents can give charity ideas for kids.
Parents can give charity ideas for kids.Parents can give charity ideas for kids.
Parents can give charity ideas for kids.
 
What Teenagers Have to Say about the Grandparents
What Teenagers Have to Say about the GrandparentsWhat Teenagers Have to Say about the Grandparents
What Teenagers Have to Say about the Grandparents
 
Living life to the full: How can we make our longer lives healthier, happier ...
Living life to the full: How can we make our longer lives healthier, happier ...Living life to the full: How can we make our longer lives healthier, happier ...
Living life to the full: How can we make our longer lives healthier, happier ...
 
Water and peace go hand-in hand. World Water Day 2024
Water and peace go hand-in hand. World Water Day 2024Water and peace go hand-in hand. World Water Day 2024
Water and peace go hand-in hand. World Water Day 2024
 
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
PPT Item # 5-6 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
 
O Conselho Estadual de Cultura e o Incentivo à Cultura no RS: relato de expe...
O Conselho Estadual de Cultura e o Incentivo à Cultura no RS:  relato de expe...O Conselho Estadual de Cultura e o Incentivo à Cultura no RS:  relato de expe...
O Conselho Estadual de Cultura e o Incentivo à Cultura no RS: relato de expe...
 
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
Item # 5&6 - 218 Canyon Drive replat prop.
 
Yes!? We can end TB - World Tuberculosis Day 2024.
Yes!? We can end TB - World Tuberculosis Day 2024.Yes!? We can end TB - World Tuberculosis Day 2024.
Yes!? We can end TB - World Tuberculosis Day 2024.
 
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM MinutesItem # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
Item # 1a - March 18, 2024 Special CCM Minutes
 
Water for Prosperity and peace - United Nations World Water Development Repo...
Water for Prosperity and peace -  United Nations World Water Development Repo...Water for Prosperity and peace -  United Nations World Water Development Repo...
Water for Prosperity and peace - United Nations World Water Development Repo...
 
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptxDB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
DB9_BTR_Webinar_Slidedeck_20230320 (1).pptx
 
Parents give a charity ideas for children
Parents give a charity ideas for childrenParents give a charity ideas for children
Parents give a charity ideas for children
 

Evoking human agency and autonomy where interpretation meets indeterminacy

  • 1. Evoking human agency and autonomy where interpretation meets indeterminacy Michael Bach Canadian Association for Community Living & IRIS – Institute for Research and Development on Inclusion & Society Presentation to Essex Autonomy Project Conference: “Is there a conception of autonomy that is: Defensible in Theory and Workable in Practice?” London, 15th -16th March 2013 March 2013
  • 2. ARTICLE 12 EQUAL RECOGNITION BEFORE THE LAW 1. right to recognition everywhere as persons before the law. 2. enjoy legal capacity on an equal basis with others in all aspects of life. 3. shall have access to the support they may require in exercising their legal capacity. 4. all measures related to exercise of legal capacity shall have safeguards (proportional, tailored, respect will and preferences, time-limited, reviewable, etc.) 5. measures to ensure equal right to own and inherit property, control financial affairs, access credit.
  • 3. Legal Capacity Defined “legal capacity includes the ‘capacity to act’, intended as the capacity [capability?] and power to engage in a particular undertaking or transaction, to maintain a particular status or relationship with another individual, and more in general to create, modify or extinguish legal relationships.” (‘Background Paper on Legal Capacity’ – Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights)
  • 4. Legal Capacity: ‘power to create, modify, or extinguish legal relationships’ Health Care Decisions CRPD Articles: 15, 25, 26 Personal Life Decisions (where to live, relationships, participation, access, employment, mobility and supports) CRPD Articles: 13, 14, 15, 18, 19, 20, 23, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30 Financial/Property Decisions (purchase, sale, credit, investment, will) - CRPD Articles: 12(5),28
  • 5. Key Concepts • Intentional action – actions by a subject for which there are recognizable reasons related to beliefs and desires/pro-attitudes, under some description • Agency – intentional action the reasons for which are recognized to have both ‘correspondence’ and ‘coherence’ • Will – general capacity to have desires and beliefs and act upon them • Preferences – particular desires/pro-attitudes that attach to an intentional action
  • 6. CRPD Provides a new formula for legal capacity Unique d-m abilities Supports Reasonable accommodation legal status Decision- making capability [capacity]
  • 7. Usual criteria for recognizing decision- making capability necessary for legal capacity (and for recognizing autonomous subjects) On his/her own, or ‘independently’, an adult, with supports and accommodation as needed has the ability to: • Understand information relevant to a decision • Appreciate reasonably foreseeable consequences • Communicate the decision to others • At a minimum, communicate recognizable reasons for actions (i.e. intentionality)
  • 8. But there are other decision- making abilities which can ground recognition of and respect for legal capacity
  • 9. Ability for intentional action (based on recognizable reasons – in descriptions provided by others) I want to… I don’t want to…
  • 10. Ability to be known by others as being the same person through time – with a life story that others weave and tell… …
  • 12. Ways to Exercise Legal Capacity Supported Independent•community Representative Facilitated
  • 13. In the formula… • D-M Abilities mental capacity (and all individuals have some decision-making abilities) • Mental capacity Legal Capacity • DM Capability Capacity (for strategic reasons) • DM Capability is the necessary condition for full legal capacity • The state has obligations to ensure decision- making capability is in place for all (on a ‘ ‘progressive realization basis’ both for society as a whole and in particular cases)
  • 14. Inclusive Test of Decision-making Capability (Capacity) • means that the understanding of the information relevant to the decision to be made and the appreciation of the reasonably foreseeable consequences of such decision or lack of such decision, may rest either a) within the adult herself or himself, and with decision-making supports and reasonable accommodations as needed; or b) within the understanding and appreciation of the person(s) appointed to support the adult in exercising his or her legal capacity;
  • 15. (c) Where capacity falls within the purview of (b) there shall be a requirement that the decision be guided by a support person(s)' best interpretation of the adult's intentions, will and preferences and how these are to be applied to a specific decision(s); (e) Where an adult’s intentions cannot yet be reasonably determined for the purposes of a decision, a facilitator is appointed for arriving at the best interpretation of a person’s will and preferences as they should apply to the decision or set of decisions in the circumstances;
  • 16. (d) In applying subsections (c) and (d), (i) “best interpretation” means the interpretation that seems most reasonably justified in the circumstances; and (ii) decision-making supporters must be able to provide a reasonable account of how this interpretation was arrived at;
  • 17. Ways to exercise legal capacity • Legally independently – ‘Appreciate and understand test’ with support and accommodation as needed • Supported decision making – Appointment of supporter(s) by the individual – Others may apply to be appointed, where a person has a ‘profound’ intellectual disability, for e.g. • Representative decision making – Person appoints a legal representative to make decisions on behalf of a person (advance directive, power of attorney) • Facilitated decision making (no other adult can recognize or support a person to act on his/her will and preferences) – Person appointed to facilitate process for arriving at ‘best interpretation’ of will and preferences as they should apply in the circumstances and to a particular decision or set of decisions.
  • 18. What is ‘supported decision making? • Legal right to have certain others recognized in the decision-making process to enter legal relationships – who are in a demonstrated trusting relationship of personal knowledge and commitment • Legal requirement that recognized supporters meet certain duties • Legal requirement that 3rd parties (physicians, etc.) respect and accommodate such decision- making processes
  • 19. What are supporters actually doing? • Witnessing another’s consciousness • Ascribing intentional action to another • Narrating personal identity of another • Orchestrating and narrating intention-directed consequences (see slide) • Claiming equal moral status for another
  • 20. A theory of personal identity & human agency Consequence Consequence Will and Preferences (Intention)
  • 21. We do not transfer agency from one event to another, or infer that the man was agent not only of one action but of two [i.e. of putting his foot on the brake and stopping the car]. We may indeed extend responsibility or liability for an action to responsibility or liability for its consequences, but this we do, not by saddling the agent with a new action, but by pointing out that his original action had those results… there are no further actions, only further descriptions Donald Davidson
  • 22. The Accordion Effect – Joel Feinberg
  • 24. Guidance principles for functional ‘decision-making communities’, ‘communities of personal knowers’ ‘communities of interpreters’
  • 25. Guidance principles 1. Personal, experiential knowledge based on trusting relationships with the adult must be given a priority status in sources of knowledge about a person. 2. Narrate the identity of the subject, co- constructed with others. • Bear witness to and recover the past. • Practice an “empathic capacity” in imagining and identifying with those different to us. • Challenge official stories and accounts with the “unofficial” and “dissenting” ones .
  • 26. Guidance principles 4. Share in and narrate the reflective capacity of the intending subject 5. Practice a “moral-transformatory” communicate ethics to manage conflicting perspectives, which meet a standard of “epistemic responsibility.” 6. Communities of knowers/interpreters share critical stories about the application of technologies for assessing decision-making capabilities – e.g. capacity to consent. 7. Place ethics before epistemology.