A Lecture on Green Economy PSU, Urdaneta City

1. Republic of the Philippines
Pangasinan State University
GRADUATE SCHOOL
Urdaneta City
GLOBAL GREEN ECONOMY INDEX
An Analytic Tool Measuring
National Green Reputations & Performance
By : Jeremy Tamanini
Founder, Dual Citizen Inc.
Federico C. Aquino Jr.
Reporter
ME 201- Strategic Mgt. of Engineering Enterprise

2. The 1st Global Green Economy Index
A Project MeAsuring nAtionAl green
rePutAtions
The first-ever survey measuring by expert practitioner perceptions on
the green reputations of 27 countries around the world was
conducted by Dual Citizen Inc. last 2010.
Respondents were pre-selected based on their known professional
affiliation and were limited to one response to the full survey.
Around one third of survey respondents were then contacted directly
with follow-up questions.
Jeremy Tamanini
Founder, Dual Citizen Inc.

3. The report assesses national green leadership
in the following 27 countries
Argentina Japan
Australia Mexico
Brazil Netherlands
Canada New Zealand
China Norway
Denmark South Africa
Finland South Korea
France Spain
Germany Sweden
Iceland Turkey
India United Arab Emirates
Israel United Kingdom
Indonesia United States
Italy

4. Four Areas with Large Impact on Defining National Green Reputations.
1. To what extent are nations and their leaders 2. From the perspective of a clean energy technology
associated with green leadership on the international investment fund, which country presents the best
stage? investment target over the next 10 years?
3. Which country has the most effective domestic policies 4. Which country shows the strongest commitment
in place to foster the development of clean energy to promoting green tourism in country?
technologies?

5. I. INTERNATIONAL LEADERSHIP
28% 17% 13% 7% 6% 4% 3% 3% 3% 2%
GERMANY DENMARK SWEDEN NORWAY NETHERLANDS BRAZIL ICELAND SPAIN JAPAN United kingdom
Germany’s active role in both international climate diplomacy and more local clean
tech innovation has produced dividends as survey respondents view Germany as
demonstrating the strongest green leadership among the 27 countries surveyed.
The research indicated that the United States, China, Israel and South Korea were
nations under recognized for their green leadership.

6. II. CLEAN ENERGY
INVESTMENT
31% 18% 14% 13% 4%
UNITED
CHINA STATES INDIA BRAZIL GERMANY
China’s centralized decision-making apparatus and its aggressive dedication of
stimulus funds and a feed-in tariff to the alternative energy sector make it the most
attractive investment target over the next ten years for a clean tech venture fund.
The demands for energy from these countries are huge and growing while the
infrastructure is weak. This could be a perfect storm for clean tech investors.

7. III.DOMESTIC POLICY INCENTIVES
30% 16% 10% 8% 6%
UNITED
GERMANY DENMARK STATES CHINA SWEDEN
Germany once again leads other countries as having the right mix of policies in place
to foster the future development of clean energy technology.

8. IV.TOURISM
32% 10% 9% 6% 5%
NEW ZEALAND AUSTRALIA BRAZIL GERMANY/NORWAY ICELAND
New Zealand is the undisputed leader in the realm of promoting green tourism
within its borders and an examination of the efforts of Tourism. New Zealand
reveals that this result is no coincidence.
Through advertising, an accreditation system, visitor feedback and internal focus on
the environment, New Zealand is the best practice case in promoting green tourism.

9. THE 2011
Global Green Economy
Index
The 2011 Global Green Economy Index (GGEI) is a comprehensive
analytic tool offering stakeholders in the green economy a
robust system to track, analyze and improve upon both the
Perceptions and Performance of national green economies.
Jeremy Tamanini
Founder, Dual Citizen Inc.

10. The 2011 Global Green Economy Index includes 4 primary
dimensions, 12 sub-categories
1. LEADERSHIP- International Forums, Global Media Coverage, and National
Institutions
2. DOMESTIC POLICY – Clean Energy Policies, Renewable Targets, and
Emission Trending
3. CLEANTECH INVESTMENTS- Investment Volume, Sector Vitality, and
Investment Facilitation.
4. GREEN TOURISM – Ministry Evaluation, Accreditation and Competitiveness.

11. R E SU L T S
I. INTERNATIONAL LEADERSHIP
PercePtion PerForMAnce
1 GERMANY 1 NEW ZEALAND
2 SWEDEN 2 ICELAND
3 DENMARK 3 DENMARK
4 NORWAY 4 SOUTH AFRICA
UNITED
5 NETHERLANDS 5 KINGDOM
6 UNITED KINGDOM 6 SWEDEN
7 CANADA 7 BRAZIL
8 NEW ZEALAND MEXICO
8
9 BRAZIL FINLAND
9
10 UNITED STATES
10 GERMANY

12. PERCEPTION
A block of northern European countries dominate the leadership category as judged by
our expert survey as leaders and institutions in these nations continue to proactively
brand themselves green.
PERFORMANCE
Our index confirms the leadership value to nations hosting the annual Conference of the
Parties (COP) summit (ie. Denmark, Mexico and South Africa) and the ability of smaller
green economies (ie. New Zealand and Iceland) to make a big impact on the global stage.
Conferences of the Parties
1992:RIO DE JANIERO"UN Framework Convention on Climate
Change" 2003: COP 9, Milan, Italy
1995: COP 1, The Berlin Mandate 2004: COP 10, Buenos Aires, Argentina
1996: COP 2, Geneva, Switzerland 2005: COP 11/MOP 1, Montreal, Canada
1997: COP 3, The Kyoto Protocol on Climate Change 2006: COP 12/MOP 2, Nairobi, Kenya
1998: COP 4, Buenos Aires, Argentina 2007: COP 13/MOP 3, Bali, Indonesia
1999: COP 5, Bonn, Germany 2008: COP 14/MOP 4, Poznań, Poland
2009: COP 15/MOP 5, Copenhagen,
2000: COP 6, The Hague, Netherlands Denmark
2001: COP 6, Bonn, Germany 2010: COP 16/MOP 6, Cancún, Mexico
2011: COP 17/MOP 7, Durban, South
2001: COP 7, Marrakech, Morocco Africa
2002: COP 8, New Delhi, India 2012: COP 18/MOP 8, Qatar

13. II. DOMESTIC POLICY
PercePtion PerForMAnce
GERMANY 1 NORWAY
1
DENMARK 2 ICELAND
2
3 SWEDEN 3 BRAZIL
4 CHINA 4 NEW ZEALAND
5 NETHERLANDS 5 SWEDEN
6 SPAIN 6 CANADA
7 NORWAY 7 FINLAND
8 UNITED STATES 8 DENMARK
9 ICELAND 9 GERMANY
10 UNITED KINGDOM 10 MEXICO

14. PERCEPTION
Experts continue to recognize northern European nations on the policy
dimension but highlight China’s merits and credit the United States with an
overall improvement, particularly at the state level.
PERFORMANCE
Nations with a high reliance on renewable energy sources today perform well
in our index, as do nations with concrete success at lowering their overall and
per capita greenhouse gas emissions.
GENERAL
Our expert survey reveals confidence that the world’s largest economies have
the right policies in place to promote renewable energy yet these same nations
lack concrete improvements in lowering their GHG emissions.

15. List of Top 20 Countries estimates
World Top 10
CO2 Emissions - 2010
Renewable Electricity
Producers Hydroelectricity,
Wind Power, Biomass, Solar, Geothermal Country CO2 emissions
(METRIC
Rank Country
TONNES)
1 European Union[5]
China 8,240,958
2 China
United States 5,492,170
3 United States
India 2,069,738
4 Brazil
5 Canada Russia 1,688,688
6 Russia Japan 1,138,432
7 India Germany 762,543
8 Norway Iran 574,667
9 Germany South Korea 563,126
10 Japan Canada 518,475
Saudi Arabia 493,726

16. III. CLEANTECH INVESTMENT
PercePtion PerForMAnce
1 CHINA 1 DENMARK
2 UNITED STATES 2 GERMANY
3 GERMANY SWEDEN
3
4 BRAZIL 4 ISRAEL
5 INDIA 5 CANADA
6 JAPAN 6 NEW ZEALAND
7 CANADA 7 AUSTRALIA
UNITED
8 KINGDOM 8 NORWAY
9 DENMARK 9 FINLAND
10 SWEDEN 10 UNITED STATES

17. PERCEPTION
Large high-tech economies and their counterparts are judged by experts to
be the most attractive cleantech investment targets over the next ten years.
PERFORMANCE
Highly developed European economies dominate the top of our cleantech
investment index because their cleantech sectors are relatively evolved, well
financed and linked to fast-growing international markets
GENERAL
Cleantech markets are geographically nuanced and characterized by a wide
array of financing mechanisms and differing levels of government investment.

18. IV.GREEN TOURISM
PercePtion PerForMAnce
1 NEW ZEALAND 1 NEW ZEALAND
2 ICELAND 2 UNITED KINGDOM
3 AUSTRALIA 3 SOUTH AFRICA
4 CANADA 4 DENMARK
5 BRAZIL 5 SWEDEN
6 NORWAY 6 NETHERLANDS
7 GERMANY 7 GERMANY
8 SWEDEN 8 JAPAN
9 SOUTH AFRICA 9 ITALY
10 DENMARK 10 AUSTRALIA

19. PERCEPTION & PERFORMANCE
New Zealand is again the global best practice case for promoting green tourism, a
fact receiving significant recognition from our experts and index alike.
GENERAL
Most nations we cover have failed to formalize green tourism accreditation
schemes, reinforcing the notion that green tourism is an abstract, hard to quantify
activity.
Opportunities exist to better integrate national tourism bodies and
transportation sectors for the purpose of furthering responsible tourism
globally.

20. GGEI SURVEY RESULTS
2010 AND 2011
2010 2011
PERCEPTIO PERFORMAN
AREAS N CE
1 LEADERSHIP GERMANY GERMANY NEW ZEALAND
2 CLEANTECH INVESTMENTS CHINA CHINA DENMARK
3 DOMESTIC POLICY GERMANY GERMANY NORWAY
4 GREEN TOURISM NEW ZEALAND NEW ZEALAND NEW ZEALAND

21. References:
http://www.dualcitizeninc.com
http://unfccc.int/kyoto_protocol
http://www.alternate-energy-sources.com/Kyoto-Protocol
http://globalwarming.com