Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)

Geospatial Narrative
Perspectives from the humanities,
cartography and GIScience
Center for Interdisciplinary Digital Research (CIDR)
Center for Spatial and Textual Analysis (CESTA)
May 7, 2015
panelists
• David O’Sullivan
– Professor of Geography, UC Berkeley
• Anne Knowles (w/Levi Westerveld)
– Professor of Geography, Middlebury College
• Erik Steiner
– Cartographer, Geographer; Creative Director, Spatial History Project
• Nicole Coleman
– Research Director, Humanities + Design
• Nicholas Bauch
– Geographer, Postdoc @ Spatial History
• Karl Grossner
– Geographer, DH Developer @ CIDR
questions
• Does historical simulation open significant untapped
avenues for new historical spatial narratives or is it too
reductionist to be accepted by/useful to humanists?
• Is there a place for performative art in the spatial
humanities? Or does art lack the empirical and
representational rigor that is necessary to comprehend
data and derive meaning?
• what does “spatial narrative” mean?
• how does it differ from verbal narrative: is that even a
meaningful distinction? a genuine binary?
• what’s missing or inadequate in existing tools, models,
methods?
Center for Interdisciplinary
Digital Research (CIDR)
• The Academic Technology Specialist team, working directly in and with
selected academic departments to improve teaching, learning, and
research by implementing and developing new technologies.
• Social Science Data and Software offers data, software, workshops, and
consultations for data-based social science research and teaching.
• Digital humanities research developers provide focused project support
for the Stanford scholarly community via an annual call for proposals. The
DH developer team maintains a rich gallery of projects both already
published and in-progress.
• The Humanities Text Service (hText) provides access to textual and other
digital resources for research and teaching.
Narrative
• account, story, tale, chronicle
• “An account of a series of events, facts, etc., given
in order and with the establishing of connections
between them”
• “A representation of a history, biography, process,
etc., in which a sequence of events has been
constructed into a story in accordance with a
particular ideology”
• geospatial narrative: one product of the practice
of both spatial history and historical geography
Spatial History Project
Spatial History Project
Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)
SPACE
TIME
THEME
The Geographic Matrix
Approaches to Regional Analysis: A Synthesis
Brian J. L. Berry, Univ. of Chicago, 1964
Perspectives and definitions
space
time
theme
“…the intersection of qualitative geographic information
systems (GIS), narrative analysis, 3D GIS-based time-
geographic methods, and computer-aided qualitative
data analysis.”
“I suggest that the more successful examples
of critically informed GIS are those where
researchers informed by social theory have
been willing to engage with the technology,
rather than to criticize from the outside.”
Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)
Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)
Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)
Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)
Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)
questions
• Does historical simulation open significant untapped
avenues for new historical spatial narratives or is it too
reductionist to be accepted by/useful to humanists?
• Is there a place for performative art in the spatial
humanities? Or does art lack the empirical and
representational rigor that is necessary to comprehend
data and derive meaning?
• what does “spatial narrative” mean?
• how does it differ from verbal narrative: is that even a
meaningful distinction? a genuine binary?
• what’s missing or inadequate in existing tools, models,
methods?
1 de 18

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

Dstu b v.2 7-8-94Dstu b v.2 7-8-94
Dstu b v.2 7-8-94braga william
217 vistas18 diapositivas
Jim styles CV  May 2015Jim styles CV  May 2015
Jim styles CV May 2015james styles
398 vistas3 diapositivas
Dstu b v.2.7 181 2009Dstu b v.2.7 181 2009
Dstu b v.2.7 181 2009braga william
263 vistas35 diapositivas
Biology 2Biology 2
Biology 2taylakellyx
417 vistas56 diapositivas

Destacado(16)

Dstu b v.2 7-8-94Dstu b v.2 7-8-94
Dstu b v.2 7-8-94
braga william217 vistas
Jim styles CV  May 2015Jim styles CV  May 2015
Jim styles CV May 2015
james styles398 vistas
Dstu b v.2.7 181 2009Dstu b v.2.7 181 2009
Dstu b v.2.7 181 2009
braga william263 vistas
Biology 2Biology 2
Biology 2
taylakellyx417 vistas
осень в простоквашиноосень в простоквашино
осень в простоквашино
virtualtaganrog563 vistas
s2130495s2130495
s2130495
uploadpdfbooks90 vistas
ResultsResults
Results
DIDI1998sdf192 vistas
C-LEVEL EXECUTIVE DAVIDSON BRIEF CV and CL 06-2015C-LEVEL EXECUTIVE DAVIDSON BRIEF CV and CL 06-2015
C-LEVEL EXECUTIVE DAVIDSON BRIEF CV and CL 06-2015
Dr. Daniel Shane Sheibani Davidson MD MBA ND FAACS257 vistas
Profe davidProfe david
Profe david
estrellitas2189 vistas

Similar a Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)(20)

Qualitative methods in CSCW researchQualitative methods in CSCW research
Qualitative methods in CSCW research
Luigina Ciolfi251 vistas
Gieseking - Personal/Political/Feminist Maps: Reflections on Spatial Methods ...Gieseking - Personal/Political/Feminist Maps: Reflections on Spatial Methods ...
Gieseking - Personal/Political/Feminist Maps: Reflections on Spatial Methods ...
Department of Geography, University of Kentucky1.6K vistas
Fl ph d_pres_pj(4)Fl ph d_pres_pj(4)
Fl ph d_pres_pj(4)
Penny Johnston207 vistas
HASTAC2011HASTAC2011
HASTAC2011
skacord255 vistas
The Virtual Research Environment and LibrariesThe Virtual Research Environment and Libraries
The Virtual Research Environment and Libraries
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)403 vistas
Dh presentation helig 2014Dh presentation helig 2014
Dh presentation helig 2014
HELIGLIASA698 vistas
Studying young people’s online social practicesStudying young people’s online social practices
Studying young people’s online social practices
Malene Charlotte Larsen4.6K vistas
Ess ds chiaraEss ds chiara
Ess ds chiara
Digital Sociology Mini-Conference928 vistas
Common Method of GeographyCommon Method of Geography
Common Method of Geography
Tarlac State University3.7K vistas
Learning from games  At the DH campsiteLearning from games  At the DH campsite
Learning from games At the DH campsite
University of South Australlia727 vistas

Último(20)

STERILITY TEST.pptxSTERILITY TEST.pptx
STERILITY TEST.pptx
Anupkumar Sharma102 vistas
Narration lesson plan.docxNarration lesson plan.docx
Narration lesson plan.docx
Tariq KHAN90 vistas
231112 (WR) v1  ChatGPT OEB 2023.pdf231112 (WR) v1  ChatGPT OEB 2023.pdf
231112 (WR) v1 ChatGPT OEB 2023.pdf
WilfredRubens.com100 vistas
GSoC 2024GSoC 2024
GSoC 2024
DeveloperStudentClub1049 vistas
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY UNIT 1 { PART-1}ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY UNIT 1 { PART-1}
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY UNIT 1 { PART-1}
DR .PALLAVI PATHANIA156 vistas
Psychology KS4Psychology KS4
Psychology KS4
WestHatch52 vistas
Women from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue DoeWomen from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue Doe
Women from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue Doe
History of Stoke Newington103 vistas
Dance KS5 BreakdownDance KS5 Breakdown
Dance KS5 Breakdown
WestHatch52 vistas
Material del tarjetero LEES Travesías.docxMaterial del tarjetero LEES Travesías.docx
Material del tarjetero LEES Travesías.docx
Norberto Millán Muñoz57 vistas
Sociology KS5Sociology KS5
Sociology KS5
WestHatch50 vistas
Classification of crude drugs.pptxClassification of crude drugs.pptx
Classification of crude drugs.pptx
GayatriPatra1449 vistas
Structure and Functions of Cell.pdfStructure and Functions of Cell.pdf
Structure and Functions of Cell.pdf
Nithya Murugan142 vistas
Class 10 English  lesson plansClass 10 English  lesson plans
Class 10 English lesson plans
Tariq KHAN172 vistas
Industry4wrd.pptxIndustry4wrd.pptx
Industry4wrd.pptx
BC Chew153 vistas
CWP_23995_2013_17_11_2023_FINAL_ORDER.pdfCWP_23995_2013_17_11_2023_FINAL_ORDER.pdf
CWP_23995_2013_17_11_2023_FINAL_ORDER.pdf
SukhwinderSingh895865467 vistas

Geospatial Narrative workshop intro (7 May 2015, Stanford)

  • 1. Geospatial Narrative Perspectives from the humanities, cartography and GIScience Center for Interdisciplinary Digital Research (CIDR) Center for Spatial and Textual Analysis (CESTA) May 7, 2015
  • 2. panelists • David O’Sullivan – Professor of Geography, UC Berkeley • Anne Knowles (w/Levi Westerveld) – Professor of Geography, Middlebury College • Erik Steiner – Cartographer, Geographer; Creative Director, Spatial History Project • Nicole Coleman – Research Director, Humanities + Design • Nicholas Bauch – Geographer, Postdoc @ Spatial History • Karl Grossner – Geographer, DH Developer @ CIDR
  • 3. questions • Does historical simulation open significant untapped avenues for new historical spatial narratives or is it too reductionist to be accepted by/useful to humanists? • Is there a place for performative art in the spatial humanities? Or does art lack the empirical and representational rigor that is necessary to comprehend data and derive meaning? • what does “spatial narrative” mean? • how does it differ from verbal narrative: is that even a meaningful distinction? a genuine binary? • what’s missing or inadequate in existing tools, models, methods?
  • 4. Center for Interdisciplinary Digital Research (CIDR) • The Academic Technology Specialist team, working directly in and with selected academic departments to improve teaching, learning, and research by implementing and developing new technologies. • Social Science Data and Software offers data, software, workshops, and consultations for data-based social science research and teaching. • Digital humanities research developers provide focused project support for the Stanford scholarly community via an annual call for proposals. The DH developer team maintains a rich gallery of projects both already published and in-progress. • The Humanities Text Service (hText) provides access to textual and other digital resources for research and teaching.
  • 5. Narrative • account, story, tale, chronicle • “An account of a series of events, facts, etc., given in order and with the establishing of connections between them” • “A representation of a history, biography, process, etc., in which a sequence of events has been constructed into a story in accordance with a particular ideology” • geospatial narrative: one product of the practice of both spatial history and historical geography
  • 9. SPACE TIME THEME The Geographic Matrix Approaches to Regional Analysis: A Synthesis Brian J. L. Berry, Univ. of Chicago, 1964
  • 11. “…the intersection of qualitative geographic information systems (GIS), narrative analysis, 3D GIS-based time- geographic methods, and computer-aided qualitative data analysis.”
  • 12. “I suggest that the more successful examples of critically informed GIS are those where researchers informed by social theory have been willing to engage with the technology, rather than to criticize from the outside.”
  • 18. questions • Does historical simulation open significant untapped avenues for new historical spatial narratives or is it too reductionist to be accepted by/useful to humanists? • Is there a place for performative art in the spatial humanities? Or does art lack the empirical and representational rigor that is necessary to comprehend data and derive meaning? • what does “spatial narrative” mean? • how does it differ from verbal narrative: is that even a meaningful distinction? a genuine binary? • what’s missing or inadequate in existing tools, models, methods?

Notas del editor

  1. On May 7, 2015 Stanford Libraries’ Center for Interdisciplinary Digital Research (CIDR) hosted a 4 hour panel discussion on the topic of Geospatial Narrative. The panel coincided with a visit by UC Berkeley geographer David O’Sullivan, who gave a guest lecture later in the day, “Simple spatial models: Building blocks for process-based GIS?”
  2. Only one non-geographer (most welcome of course) in the panel
  3. Prior to the event a list of questions to be considered was developed by the panelists
  4. The Center for Interdisciplinary Digital Research (CIDR) is a new organization within Stanford Libraries, which has brought together several existing groups supporting faculty-led research in the Humanities and Social Sciences
  5. A few definitions from OED and elsewhere. There are several distinct senses of the term “narrative.”
  6. The setting for the panel was CESTA, which includes Stanford’s Spatial History Project. Faculty, postdocs, and student researchers have produced dozens of geospatial narratives there over the last decade.
  7. One important enabler of the work at Spatial History has been the Flash/Flex technical platform developed by Erik Steiner and refined over the years. While the rest of the world was waiting for web-based mapping to catch up, Spatial History folks were building great geospatial narrative applications. Now that web mapping has caught up, the technical platforms choices have expanded dramatically, and this form of scholarly production is available to many more people.
  8. The application pattern for telling stories with maps has several prominent examples. Each has allows joining maps, timelines, text and imagery in interactive displays.
  9. The pattern of “space, time, and theme” as the principle dimensions of geographic information was theorized and modeled by Berry 50 years ago.
  10. And Berry’s matrix is reflected in all modern mapping narrative platforms listed earlier.
  11. One of my current interests, and a motivation for organizing the panel, is a desire to see further interaction between humanities scholars exploring spatial (i.e. geographic) perspectives on their questions and practitioners of Geographic Information Science (GIScience), of which I am one. In fact there has been a steady, if narrow, stream of qualitative and quantitative narrative work by geographers in the last couple of decades, for example by Mei-Po Kwan
  12. Our guest is in his own words, “sitting at the boundary between quantitative and qualitative methods.” He is renowned for spatial analysis and simulation, as well as Critical GIS.
  13. There is a discussion between humanities scholars and GIScientists, as in this day-long meeting several years ago, but it is minimal halting.
  14. Some topics of interest to humanists, e.g. Place, have been of interest in GIScience…not hugely, but a steady stream. The concept of Place and “placial” is gaining traction in fact.
  15. A few GIScience types – like May Yuan can be found (ir)regularly at DH and historical GIS venues
  16. The Alliance of Digital Humanities Organizations (ADHO) recently encouraged formation of Special Interest Groups, and I co-found GeoHumanities SIG with Kathy Weimer, a map and geospatial data librarian, now at Rice University. The Association of Amrican Geographers (AAG) recently launched a new journal titled GeoHumanities, and the 2015 conference had GeoHumanities as a featured track, with 40+ relevant paper sessions
  17. Back to the questions. Some of what was discussed will be found in the blog post these slides are situated in.