SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Examine the causes of income and wealth inequality in the UK or any country
of your choice. (20 Marks)
Mark Scheme
Causes could include:
• Education
• Skills and training
• Experience/age
• Type of employment
• Ownership of assets
• Inheritance
• Pension rights
Evaluation:
• Prioritisation of factors
• Significance of each factor
• Level and quality of education e.g. degree, subject, class
• Pension rights e.g. final salary schemes
• Conclusion
In the 2009 budget the UK government announced that a new 50% rate of
income tax would be introduced in 2010. This creates three marginal tax
rates of 20%, 40% and 50%, instead of two. Evaluate the likely economic
effects of this change in the tax structure. (30 Marks)
Mark Scheme
Effects include:
• Disincentive to work: could be analysed using income and substitution effects
• Tax revenues- use of Laffer curve analysis
• Tax evasion (illegal)
• Tax avoidance (legal) e.g. working fewer hours taking income in form of share option
(CGT only 18%)
• Tax exiles – move to Switzerland
• Distribution of income – more even: analysis of progressive taxation
• Impact on AD and associated analysis
Evaluation could include:
• Extent of disincentive effects of 50% tax rate
• Ease of avoiding 50% tax rate
• Number of people affected by new tax rate
• Extent of tax evasion
• Significance of impact on different sectors of the economy e.g. on financial services
• Impact on income distribution might be offset be other factors e.g. increasing
unemployment
Examiners Report
This was the least popular of the three essay questions and responses were generally weaker
than on the other essays.
Better answers to part (a) were able to examine some valid causes of inequality such as
inheritance, education, pension rights and ownership of assets. However, others struggled to
develop more than one point or wrote generalised answers relating to wages.
Answers to part (b) were more convincing with some discussion of the possible impact on tax
revenues, disincentives and the effect on aggregate demand. However, evaluation was often
surprisingly weak, given the topical nature of this question.

More Related Content

What's hot

Session Five: Future Work Of The Fiscal Network, Meeting 2018
Session Five: Future Work Of The Fiscal Network, Meeting 2018Session Five: Future Work Of The Fiscal Network, Meeting 2018
Session Five: Future Work Of The Fiscal Network, Meeting 2018OECDtax
 
Mary murphy nui maynooth post budget seminar slides 19 oct 16
Mary murphy nui maynooth post budget seminar slides 19 oct 16Mary murphy nui maynooth post budget seminar slides 19 oct 16
Mary murphy nui maynooth post budget seminar slides 19 oct 16NevinInstitute
 
OECD Regulatory Policy Review of Korea - Key Findings
OECD Regulatory Policy Review of Korea - Key FindingsOECD Regulatory Policy Review of Korea - Key Findings
OECD Regulatory Policy Review of Korea - Key FindingsJustin Kavanagh
 
Comments by Dr. Markus Sovala: Economic Policy Council's 2019 Report
Comments by Dr. Markus Sovala: Economic Policy Council's 2019 ReportComments by Dr. Markus Sovala: Economic Policy Council's 2019 Report
Comments by Dr. Markus Sovala: Economic Policy Council's 2019 ReportVATT Institute for Economic Research
 
Getting Institutions Right for Productivity Enhancing Policies: A French View...
Getting Institutions Right for Productivity Enhancing Policies: A French View...Getting Institutions Right for Productivity Enhancing Policies: A French View...
Getting Institutions Right for Productivity Enhancing Policies: A French View...Structuralpolicyanalysis
 
2013.11.15_OECD-ECLAC Regional Consultation_teresa ter minassian
2013.11.15_OECD-ECLAC Regional Consultation_teresa ter minassian2013.11.15_OECD-ECLAC Regional Consultation_teresa ter minassian
2013.11.15_OECD-ECLAC Regional Consultation_teresa ter minassianOECD_Inclusivegrowth
 
Barra Roantree, IFS, London - NERI Seminar presentation slides July 2016
Barra Roantree, IFS, London - NERI Seminar presentation slides July 2016Barra Roantree, IFS, London - NERI Seminar presentation slides July 2016
Barra Roantree, IFS, London - NERI Seminar presentation slides July 2016NevinInstitute
 
Session Five: Making Decentralisation Work A Handbook For Policy Makers, Meet...
Session Five: Making Decentralisation Work A Handbook For Policy Makers, Meet...Session Five: Making Decentralisation Work A Handbook For Policy Makers, Meet...
Session Five: Making Decentralisation Work A Handbook For Policy Makers, Meet...OECDtax
 

What's hot (10)

Session Five: Future Work Of The Fiscal Network, Meeting 2018
Session Five: Future Work Of The Fiscal Network, Meeting 2018Session Five: Future Work Of The Fiscal Network, Meeting 2018
Session Five: Future Work Of The Fiscal Network, Meeting 2018
 
U.S. Tax System
U.S. Tax SystemU.S. Tax System
U.S. Tax System
 
Mary murphy nui maynooth post budget seminar slides 19 oct 16
Mary murphy nui maynooth post budget seminar slides 19 oct 16Mary murphy nui maynooth post budget seminar slides 19 oct 16
Mary murphy nui maynooth post budget seminar slides 19 oct 16
 
Pension systems in Mexico: Main findings and recommendations from a review by...
Pension systems in Mexico: Main findings and recommendations from a review by...Pension systems in Mexico: Main findings and recommendations from a review by...
Pension systems in Mexico: Main findings and recommendations from a review by...
 
OECD Regulatory Policy Review of Korea - Key Findings
OECD Regulatory Policy Review of Korea - Key FindingsOECD Regulatory Policy Review of Korea - Key Findings
OECD Regulatory Policy Review of Korea - Key Findings
 
Comments by Dr. Markus Sovala: Economic Policy Council's 2019 Report
Comments by Dr. Markus Sovala: Economic Policy Council's 2019 ReportComments by Dr. Markus Sovala: Economic Policy Council's 2019 Report
Comments by Dr. Markus Sovala: Economic Policy Council's 2019 Report
 
Getting Institutions Right for Productivity Enhancing Policies: A French View...
Getting Institutions Right for Productivity Enhancing Policies: A French View...Getting Institutions Right for Productivity Enhancing Policies: A French View...
Getting Institutions Right for Productivity Enhancing Policies: A French View...
 
2013.11.15_OECD-ECLAC Regional Consultation_teresa ter minassian
2013.11.15_OECD-ECLAC Regional Consultation_teresa ter minassian2013.11.15_OECD-ECLAC Regional Consultation_teresa ter minassian
2013.11.15_OECD-ECLAC Regional Consultation_teresa ter minassian
 
Barra Roantree, IFS, London - NERI Seminar presentation slides July 2016
Barra Roantree, IFS, London - NERI Seminar presentation slides July 2016Barra Roantree, IFS, London - NERI Seminar presentation slides July 2016
Barra Roantree, IFS, London - NERI Seminar presentation slides July 2016
 
Session Five: Making Decentralisation Work A Handbook For Policy Makers, Meet...
Session Five: Making Decentralisation Work A Handbook For Policy Makers, Meet...Session Five: Making Decentralisation Work A Handbook For Policy Makers, Meet...
Session Five: Making Decentralisation Work A Handbook For Policy Makers, Meet...
 

Viewers also liked

Structured as micro mc question practice
Structured as micro mc question practiceStructured as micro mc question practice
Structured as micro mc question practicemattbentley34
 
6. Constitution and Government 2
6. Constitution and Government 26. Constitution and Government 2
6. Constitution and Government 2mattbentley34
 
Departmental select committees_(factsheet)[1]
Departmental select committees_(factsheet)[1]Departmental select committees_(factsheet)[1]
Departmental select committees_(factsheet)[1]mattbentley34
 
Jun 10 question, answer & report
Jun 10   question, answer & reportJun 10   question, answer & report
Jun 10 question, answer & reportmattbentley34
 
3. teacher notes mp's and hm opposition
3. teacher notes mp's and hm opposition3. teacher notes mp's and hm opposition
3. teacher notes mp's and hm oppositionmattbentley34
 
7. constitution and government 3
7. constitution and government 37. constitution and government 3
7. constitution and government 3mattbentley34
 
Public bill committees handout
Public bill committees handoutPublic bill committees handout
Public bill committees handoutmattbentley34
 
Unit 3: Examiners Report - Jan 12
Unit 3: Examiners Report - Jan 12Unit 3: Examiners Report - Jan 12
Unit 3: Examiners Report - Jan 12mattbentley34
 
Back bench mp q, answer, mark scheme jun 12
Back bench mp q, answer, mark scheme jun 12Back bench mp q, answer, mark scheme jun 12
Back bench mp q, answer, mark scheme jun 12mattbentley34
 
5. Constitution and Government
5. Constitution and Government5. Constitution and Government
5. Constitution and Governmentmattbentley34
 
Trying to make sense of the UK budget deficit
Trying to make sense of the UK budget deficit Trying to make sense of the UK budget deficit
Trying to make sense of the UK budget deficit mattbentley34
 
Five days that changed britain bbc documentary (student question sheet)
Five days that changed britain   bbc documentary (student question sheet)Five days that changed britain   bbc documentary (student question sheet)
Five days that changed britain bbc documentary (student question sheet)mattbentley34
 
Jun 11 Q10 c mark scheme
Jun 11 Q10 c mark schemeJun 11 Q10 c mark scheme
Jun 11 Q10 c mark schememattbentley34
 
Past questions on ministerial power
Past questions on ministerial powerPast questions on ministerial power
Past questions on ministerial powermattbentley34
 
A model paper - 120 ums Unit 4 June 2010
A model paper - 120 ums Unit 4 June 2010A model paper - 120 ums Unit 4 June 2010
A model paper - 120 ums Unit 4 June 2010mattbentley34
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Jun 11
Jun 11Jun 11
Jun 11
 
Structured as micro mc question practice
Structured as micro mc question practiceStructured as micro mc question practice
Structured as micro mc question practice
 
6. Constitution and Government 2
6. Constitution and Government 26. Constitution and Government 2
6. Constitution and Government 2
 
Jan 07 old syllabus
Jan 07 old syllabusJan 07 old syllabus
Jan 07 old syllabus
 
Departmental select committees_(factsheet)[1]
Departmental select committees_(factsheet)[1]Departmental select committees_(factsheet)[1]
Departmental select committees_(factsheet)[1]
 
Jan 07 old syllabus
Jan 07 old syllabusJan 07 old syllabus
Jan 07 old syllabus
 
Jun 10 question, answer & report
Jun 10   question, answer & reportJun 10   question, answer & report
Jun 10 question, answer & report
 
3. teacher notes mp's and hm opposition
3. teacher notes mp's and hm opposition3. teacher notes mp's and hm opposition
3. teacher notes mp's and hm opposition
 
7. constitution and government 3
7. constitution and government 37. constitution and government 3
7. constitution and government 3
 
Public bill committees handout
Public bill committees handoutPublic bill committees handout
Public bill committees handout
 
Jan 08
Jan 08Jan 08
Jan 08
 
Unit 3: Examiners Report - Jan 12
Unit 3: Examiners Report - Jan 12Unit 3: Examiners Report - Jan 12
Unit 3: Examiners Report - Jan 12
 
Unit 3 - Jun 11
Unit 3 - Jun 11Unit 3 - Jun 11
Unit 3 - Jun 11
 
Back bench mp q, answer, mark scheme jun 12
Back bench mp q, answer, mark scheme jun 12Back bench mp q, answer, mark scheme jun 12
Back bench mp q, answer, mark scheme jun 12
 
5. Constitution and Government
5. Constitution and Government5. Constitution and Government
5. Constitution and Government
 
Trying to make sense of the UK budget deficit
Trying to make sense of the UK budget deficit Trying to make sense of the UK budget deficit
Trying to make sense of the UK budget deficit
 
Five days that changed britain bbc documentary (student question sheet)
Five days that changed britain   bbc documentary (student question sheet)Five days that changed britain   bbc documentary (student question sheet)
Five days that changed britain bbc documentary (student question sheet)
 
Jun 11 Q10 c mark scheme
Jun 11 Q10 c mark schemeJun 11 Q10 c mark scheme
Jun 11 Q10 c mark scheme
 
Past questions on ministerial power
Past questions on ministerial powerPast questions on ministerial power
Past questions on ministerial power
 
A model paper - 120 ums Unit 4 June 2010
A model paper - 120 ums Unit 4 June 2010A model paper - 120 ums Unit 4 June 2010
A model paper - 120 ums Unit 4 June 2010
 

Similar to Jun 10 q1 mark scheme & examiners report

Edexcel Unit 4 essays mark schemes 2010-2013
Edexcel Unit 4 essays mark schemes 2010-2013Edexcel Unit 4 essays mark schemes 2010-2013
Edexcel Unit 4 essays mark schemes 2010-2013tutor2u
 
Testimony -taxreform--pres budget commission5
Testimony -taxreform--pres budget commission5Testimony -taxreform--pres budget commission5
Testimony -taxreform--pres budget commission5Urban Institute
 
Taxation and fiscal policy in Latin America
Taxation and fiscal policy in Latin AmericaTaxation and fiscal policy in Latin America
Taxation and fiscal policy in Latin AmericaChristian Daude
 
Does employment protection law protect jobs
Does employment protection law protect jobsDoes employment protection law protect jobs
Does employment protection law protect jobsMark Beatson
 
Financing | Web-desiging | CVS surveyors
Financing | Web-desiging | CVS surveyorsFinancing | Web-desiging | CVS surveyors
Financing | Web-desiging | CVS surveyorsCVSSurveyors701
 
Reforming Taxes as Part of Budget Reform
Reforming Taxes as Part of  Budget ReformReforming Taxes as Part of  Budget Reform
Reforming Taxes as Part of Budget ReformUrban Institute
 
Traditional tax incentives public sector
Traditional tax incentives   public sectorTraditional tax incentives   public sector
Traditional tax incentives public sectorpublic_group12
 
Making fundamental tax reform happen_Brys
Making fundamental tax reform happen_BrysMaking fundamental tax reform happen_Brys
Making fundamental tax reform happen_BrysBert Brys
 
Revealing the Risks Associated with Global Compensation Programs (with Ernst ...
Revealing the Risks Associated with Global Compensation Programs (with Ernst ...Revealing the Risks Associated with Global Compensation Programs (with Ernst ...
Revealing the Risks Associated with Global Compensation Programs (with Ernst ...HRsoft - Talent Management Software
 
AS Macro - Unemployment and the Labour Market
AS Macro - Unemployment and the Labour MarketAS Macro - Unemployment and the Labour Market
AS Macro - Unemployment and the Labour Markettutor2u
 
International-Evidence-Executive-Summary-
International-Evidence-Executive-Summary-International-Evidence-Executive-Summary-
International-Evidence-Executive-Summary-Linda Christie
 
AS Macro Revision: Fiscal Policy
AS Macro Revision: Fiscal PolicyAS Macro Revision: Fiscal Policy
AS Macro Revision: Fiscal Policytutor2u
 
Tax Foundation University 2017, Part 2: Understanding How Fiscal Changes Impa...
Tax Foundation University 2017, Part 2: Understanding How Fiscal Changes Impa...Tax Foundation University 2017, Part 2: Understanding How Fiscal Changes Impa...
Tax Foundation University 2017, Part 2: Understanding How Fiscal Changes Impa...Tax Foundation
 
Public sector productivity - Peter van de Ven, OECD
Public sector productivity - Peter van de Ven, OECDPublic sector productivity - Peter van de Ven, OECD
Public sector productivity - Peter van de Ven, OECDOECD Governance
 
From idea to experiment - Notes on the Finnish basic income experiment study
From idea to experiment - Notes on the Finnish basic income experiment studyFrom idea to experiment - Notes on the Finnish basic income experiment study
From idea to experiment - Notes on the Finnish basic income experiment studyKelan tutkimus / Research at Kela
 
Tax Expenditures - Scott Showalter, FASAB, United States
Tax Expenditures - Scott Showalter, FASAB, United StatesTax Expenditures - Scott Showalter, FASAB, United States
Tax Expenditures - Scott Showalter, FASAB, United StatesOECD Governance
 
SlidesUnit01FullSize.pdf
SlidesUnit01FullSize.pdfSlidesUnit01FullSize.pdf
SlidesUnit01FullSize.pdfissackmohamed3
 

Similar to Jun 10 q1 mark scheme & examiners report (20)

Edexcel Unit 4 essays mark schemes 2010-2013
Edexcel Unit 4 essays mark schemes 2010-2013Edexcel Unit 4 essays mark schemes 2010-2013
Edexcel Unit 4 essays mark schemes 2010-2013
 
Testimony -taxreform--pres budget commission5
Testimony -taxreform--pres budget commission5Testimony -taxreform--pres budget commission5
Testimony -taxreform--pres budget commission5
 
Taxation and fiscal policy in Latin America
Taxation and fiscal policy in Latin AmericaTaxation and fiscal policy in Latin America
Taxation and fiscal policy in Latin America
 
Tax and Governance Case Study - ICTD Learning Portal.pptx
Tax and Governance Case Study - ICTD Learning Portal.pptxTax and Governance Case Study - ICTD Learning Portal.pptx
Tax and Governance Case Study - ICTD Learning Portal.pptx
 
Does employment protection law protect jobs
Does employment protection law protect jobsDoes employment protection law protect jobs
Does employment protection law protect jobs
 
Financing | Web-desiging | CVS surveyors
Financing | Web-desiging | CVS surveyorsFinancing | Web-desiging | CVS surveyors
Financing | Web-desiging | CVS surveyors
 
Reforming Taxes as Part of Budget Reform
Reforming Taxes as Part of  Budget ReformReforming Taxes as Part of  Budget Reform
Reforming Taxes as Part of Budget Reform
 
Traditional tax incentives public sector
Traditional tax incentives   public sectorTraditional tax incentives   public sector
Traditional tax incentives public sector
 
Making fundamental tax reform happen_Brys
Making fundamental tax reform happen_BrysMaking fundamental tax reform happen_Brys
Making fundamental tax reform happen_Brys
 
Revealing the Risks Associated with Global Compensation Programs (with Ernst ...
Revealing the Risks Associated with Global Compensation Programs (with Ernst ...Revealing the Risks Associated with Global Compensation Programs (with Ernst ...
Revealing the Risks Associated with Global Compensation Programs (with Ernst ...
 
AS Macro - Unemployment and the Labour Market
AS Macro - Unemployment and the Labour MarketAS Macro - Unemployment and the Labour Market
AS Macro - Unemployment and the Labour Market
 
Designing labor policy simulation approach
Designing labor policy simulation approach Designing labor policy simulation approach
Designing labor policy simulation approach
 
International-Evidence-Executive-Summary-
International-Evidence-Executive-Summary-International-Evidence-Executive-Summary-
International-Evidence-Executive-Summary-
 
AS Macro Revision: Fiscal Policy
AS Macro Revision: Fiscal PolicyAS Macro Revision: Fiscal Policy
AS Macro Revision: Fiscal Policy
 
Tax Foundation University 2017, Part 2: Understanding How Fiscal Changes Impa...
Tax Foundation University 2017, Part 2: Understanding How Fiscal Changes Impa...Tax Foundation University 2017, Part 2: Understanding How Fiscal Changes Impa...
Tax Foundation University 2017, Part 2: Understanding How Fiscal Changes Impa...
 
Public sector productivity - Peter van de Ven, OECD
Public sector productivity - Peter van de Ven, OECDPublic sector productivity - Peter van de Ven, OECD
Public sector productivity - Peter van de Ven, OECD
 
From idea to experiment - Notes on the Finnish basic income experiment study
From idea to experiment - Notes on the Finnish basic income experiment studyFrom idea to experiment - Notes on the Finnish basic income experiment study
From idea to experiment - Notes on the Finnish basic income experiment study
 
Tax Expenditures - Scott Showalter, FASAB, United States
Tax Expenditures - Scott Showalter, FASAB, United StatesTax Expenditures - Scott Showalter, FASAB, United States
Tax Expenditures - Scott Showalter, FASAB, United States
 
Frameworks for Distributional Analyses
Frameworks for Distributional AnalysesFrameworks for Distributional Analyses
Frameworks for Distributional Analyses
 
SlidesUnit01FullSize.pdf
SlidesUnit01FullSize.pdfSlidesUnit01FullSize.pdf
SlidesUnit01FullSize.pdf
 

More from mattbentley34

Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemSlide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemmattbentley34
 
Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019mattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsBehavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsmattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics extra resources
Behavioural economics   extra resourcesBehavioural economics   extra resources
Behavioural economics extra resourcesmattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics
Behavioural economicsBehavioural economics
Behavioural economicsmattbentley34
 
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)mattbentley34
 
The labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationThe labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationmattbentley34
 
Specimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertSpecimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertmattbentley34
 
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannerAQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannermattbentley34
 
The Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedThe Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedmattbentley34
 
Model answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismModel answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismmattbentley34
 
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam adviceEdexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam advicemattbentley34
 
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & RacialismModel answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & Racialismmattbentley34
 
Voting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsVoting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsmattbentley34
 
Political representation and democracy
Political representation and democracyPolitical representation and democracy
Political representation and democracymattbentley34
 
Political participation
Political participationPolitical participation
Political participationmattbentley34
 
Political ideologies
Political ideologiesPolitical ideologies
Political ideologiesmattbentley34
 

More from mattbentley34 (20)

Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemSlide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
 
Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019
 
Behavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsBehavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key terms
 
Behavioural economics extra resources
Behavioural economics   extra resourcesBehavioural economics   extra resources
Behavioural economics extra resources
 
Behavioural economics
Behavioural economicsBehavioural economics
Behavioural economics
 
Jan 13
Jan 13Jan 13
Jan 13
 
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
 
The labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationThe labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determination
 
Specimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertSpecimen paper insert
Specimen paper insert
 
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannerAQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
 
The Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedThe Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explained
 
Economic review
Economic reviewEconomic review
Economic review
 
Model answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismModel answers nationalism
Model answers nationalism
 
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam adviceEdexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
 
Monetary policy
Monetary policyMonetary policy
Monetary policy
 
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & RacialismModel answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
 
Voting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsVoting systems in elections
Voting systems in elections
 
Political representation and democracy
Political representation and democracyPolitical representation and democracy
Political representation and democracy
 
Political participation
Political participationPolitical participation
Political participation
 
Political ideologies
Political ideologiesPolitical ideologies
Political ideologies
 

Jun 10 q1 mark scheme & examiners report

  • 1. Examine the causes of income and wealth inequality in the UK or any country of your choice. (20 Marks) Mark Scheme Causes could include: • Education • Skills and training • Experience/age • Type of employment • Ownership of assets • Inheritance • Pension rights Evaluation: • Prioritisation of factors • Significance of each factor • Level and quality of education e.g. degree, subject, class • Pension rights e.g. final salary schemes • Conclusion In the 2009 budget the UK government announced that a new 50% rate of income tax would be introduced in 2010. This creates three marginal tax rates of 20%, 40% and 50%, instead of two. Evaluate the likely economic effects of this change in the tax structure. (30 Marks) Mark Scheme Effects include: • Disincentive to work: could be analysed using income and substitution effects • Tax revenues- use of Laffer curve analysis • Tax evasion (illegal) • Tax avoidance (legal) e.g. working fewer hours taking income in form of share option (CGT only 18%) • Tax exiles – move to Switzerland • Distribution of income – more even: analysis of progressive taxation • Impact on AD and associated analysis
  • 2. Evaluation could include: • Extent of disincentive effects of 50% tax rate • Ease of avoiding 50% tax rate • Number of people affected by new tax rate • Extent of tax evasion • Significance of impact on different sectors of the economy e.g. on financial services • Impact on income distribution might be offset be other factors e.g. increasing unemployment Examiners Report This was the least popular of the three essay questions and responses were generally weaker than on the other essays. Better answers to part (a) were able to examine some valid causes of inequality such as inheritance, education, pension rights and ownership of assets. However, others struggled to develop more than one point or wrote generalised answers relating to wages. Answers to part (b) were more convincing with some discussion of the possible impact on tax revenues, disincentives and the effect on aggregate demand. However, evaluation was often surprisingly weak, given the topical nature of this question.