This document summarizes a study on an authoring and peer reviewing activity conducted with master's students in an online elearning pedagogy program. The activity aimed to emulate the process of publishing in a peer-reviewed journal. Students were divided into peer reviewer teams and tasked with writing articles and reviewing each other's work. The study analyzed student discourse and products to understand perspectives and knowledge gains. Results showed the activity promoted teamwork, multi-tasking, academic writing and familiarity with research literature, though it presented complex challenges. Further investigation of team formation factors and the peer review process was suggested.