SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 28
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Energy-options, savings and
infrastructure
Martin van der Jagt; 24 jan 2014
(Translation of a Dutch presentation)
I prepared this presentation first in Dutch.
In the Netherlands the Government has stimulated several energy systems:
• Combined Heat and Power (CHP) in combination with District Heating
• District Heating with Combined Cycle Plants (in Dutch STEG)
• Electrical Heat Pumps (EHP’s)
In most cases the energy saving of these systems was exaggerated by
using the false reference or choosing the wrong system boundary.
In this presentation I try to find the truth. And I present the Smart Boiler
Room System (SBR)
If you have remarks or questions you can mail me:
martin.vd.jagt@gmail.com
Martin F.G. Van der Jagt
Apeldoorn, 9 feb 2015
Netherlands
Subjects
1. Possible options when the “Slochteren”gas was
discovered
2. The effect of the chosen System boundaries
3. Manipulation by choosing a reference
4. Effect of H/P ratio of the demand side
5. Why is CHP a bad option
6. Why are electrical heatpumps a bad option:
Problems at “De Teuge Zutphen ”
7. The “Not More Than Gas principle”
8. What is good: The Smart Boiler Room Concept
9. Conclusions
Gas
Gas
380 kV
Extreme options for the use of Slochteren Gas
for E-production
None of the presented options was
chosen, WHY?
Electricity production in Slochteren only was not
possible at that time: The E-GRID was not
engineered for that possibility.
The second option was not possible, while
decentralized E-production in a dwelling was not
possible at that time.
Nevertheless is it strange that in the Netherlands
never is tried to find optimal Energy
Infrastructures with Operation Research
Producing more electricity than the
consumption in the district
In the next slide a STEG is used for district heating in a new city
area of Utrecht(UTR): Leidsche Rijn(LR). For the consumption
of the over production of electricity 3 dwellings with a gas boiler
are needed.
So for the calculation of the real energy saving you have to
include the dwellings with the gas boilers!
So the real primary energy use for 1 dwelling is; 20.9 / 4 = 5.2
The false reproach calculates only 3.4 primary energy use!
Choice of System Boundary
E= Electricity
W = Heat
STEG with district heating and separated
generation
Electrical Heat pumps Gas Heat pumps
Systems Primary Energy Saving [%]
STEG +Districtheating
REMU
3.4 41
STEG +Districtheating
NOVEM
1.7 71
STEG +Districtheating
GCN
5.2 10(good calculated
value!)
Separated Production 5.8 0
STEG + EHP’s 4.7 19
GAS HP’s 4.7 19
Choice of Reference
When calculating the savings of CHP:
Where is CHP a sustitute for?;
• A Coal fired Powerstation
• Windturbines
• PV
• A Gasfired STEG With 60% efficiency
Effect of the H/P ratio from the demand
side
Savings of EHP’s Powerstation
efficiency = 51 %(W/K=H/P)
Savings of CHP and CHP with EHP’s
Why is CHP a suboptimal choice?
1. CHP ⇒ There is still need for nearly the
same number of Central Powerstations
2. Only little CO2
reduction
3. Increase NOx
emission
4. CH4
emission
5. Financial result very dependant of
electricity prices: Heat Demand Controlled
Disadvantages of Electrical Heat
Pumps
● Expensive Grid
● Expensive installation in the building: extra heating surface.
● Expensive heatsource
● Peakinstallation is a problem
In the next slide a summary of the differences in costs:
EHP<>Gas Boiler; Then some slides in Dutch with more
detailed numbers.
Problems with Electrical Heat Pumps in
Zutphen (Netherlands)
•High electricity notes
•A lot glitches
•No CO2
reduction: 39 % more than gas boiler heating!
•It took years to solve the problems!
Difference in Costs:
Gas Boiler Heatpump
Costs
Gas
Costs
HP Gas/HP
m3/year kWh/year kwh/year
kwh/year
HP €/y €/y [-]
Overall 1.304 3.380 7.970 4.590 835 1.102 32%
Bron: presentatie Alliander (site: http://deteuge2.nl/rapporten-
alliander/)
Bron: presentatie Alliander (site: http://deteuge2.nl/rapporten-
alliander/)
Bron: presentatie Alliander (site: http://deteuge2.nl/rapporten-
alliander/)
The Not More Than Gas Principle
● This is promised to users of
districtheating
● Is Not Maintained by The Government
● Conflicts residents>energy company:
○ Houten Zuid: Foundation
GIGAJoule<>Eneco
○ Almere: Community<>NUON
(Eneco and NUON are Energy Distribution
Companies)
Smart Boiler Room System
WK = CHP, EWP= Electrical Heat Pump, CV= Gas Boiler,
Buffer= Heat Storage
Advantages SBR-Concept(1)
•Gas > Heat
•Gas > Electricity
•Electricity > Heat
So based on energy market prices you
choose the production method!
Heat demand driven systems will have problems with extreme
electricity prices.
CHP’s must run when there is heat demand and the market price for
electricity is low.
EHP’s must run when the market price for electricity is high.
The SBR can make the choice “Make or Buy”.
In a SBR the CHP’s are electrical balanced with the EHP’s. So when the
electricity prices are normal the electricity of the CHP’s is used to drive
the EHP’s.
When electricity is cheap (during nights) you can buy an amount of
electricity for the EHP’s and storage the produced heat.
When the electricity price is high you can sell the CHP’s electricity on
the market.
This is to complex for the Dutch Government!
Advantages of SBR-Concept(2)
● Reasonable CO2
reduction
● The price of electricity is not dominant
● Technology is available
● Suitable for portfolio management
● Positive influence on Central Power
Stations
● Cheaper electricity grids than CHP and
EHP’s
19 timber frame dwellings Veenendaal
with SBR constructed in 1998
In 2011still in operation
Conclusions:
Important for the calculation of savings:
•Choice of system boundary
•Choice of reference system
CHP’s and EHP’s: suboptimal choice
It’s a pity that SBR is rarely applied
People have right on maintenance of the
“Not More Than Gas Principle”
Privatization has prevented optimization of
the energy infrastructure in the Netherlands

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Economies Of Industrial Cogeneration
Economies Of Industrial CogenerationEconomies Of Industrial Cogeneration
Economies Of Industrial CogenerationSurraya Mehbub Malik
 
IRJET - An Experimental Evaluation of Automobile Waste Heat Recovery System u...
IRJET - An Experimental Evaluation of Automobile Waste Heat Recovery System u...IRJET - An Experimental Evaluation of Automobile Waste Heat Recovery System u...
IRJET - An Experimental Evaluation of Automobile Waste Heat Recovery System u...IRJET Journal
 
A case study on total Energy Conservation opportunities in a Solar power assi...
A case study on total Energy Conservation opportunities in a Solar power assi...A case study on total Energy Conservation opportunities in a Solar power assi...
A case study on total Energy Conservation opportunities in a Solar power assi...Ambika Prasanna Dhal
 
Cogeneration (chp)
Cogeneration (chp)Cogeneration (chp)
Cogeneration (chp)Saeed Saleem
 
Oasis heat presentation v3
Oasis heat presentation v3Oasis heat presentation v3
Oasis heat presentation v3Todd Hixon
 
case study on energy conservation and utilization.
case study on energy conservation and utilization.case study on energy conservation and utilization.
case study on energy conservation and utilization.tamboliameer
 
Energy storage in urban multi-energy systems | Marco Carlo Masoero
Energy storage in urban multi-energy systems | Marco Carlo MasoeroEnergy storage in urban multi-energy systems | Marco Carlo Masoero
Energy storage in urban multi-energy systems | Marco Carlo Masoeroicarb
 
Optimising Energy Storage Within Micro-grid Systems | Edward Owens
 Optimising Energy Storage Within Micro-grid Systems | Edward Owens Optimising Energy Storage Within Micro-grid Systems | Edward Owens
Optimising Energy Storage Within Micro-grid Systems | Edward Owensicarb
 
Energy conservation by application of heat pump in process line at automobile...
Energy conservation by application of heat pump in process line at automobile...Energy conservation by application of heat pump in process line at automobile...
Energy conservation by application of heat pump in process line at automobile...Shivraj Nalawade
 
Occupant Behavior of a Plus-Energy Building Regarding Monitoring and Standard...
Occupant Behavior of a Plus-Energy Building Regarding Monitoring and Standard...Occupant Behavior of a Plus-Energy Building Regarding Monitoring and Standard...
Occupant Behavior of a Plus-Energy Building Regarding Monitoring and Standard...SimulationX
 
Green Heat - renewable energies for appropriate applications
Green Heat - renewable energies for appropriate applicationsGreen Heat - renewable energies for appropriate applications
Green Heat - renewable energies for appropriate applicationsBill Eggertson
 
Energy Auditing Final Phase
Energy Auditing Final PhaseEnergy Auditing Final Phase
Energy Auditing Final PhaseSanjush Suresh
 
Internship Report on Cogeneration
Internship Report on Cogeneration Internship Report on Cogeneration
Internship Report on Cogeneration Mohan Patil
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Economies Of Industrial Cogeneration
Economies Of Industrial CogenerationEconomies Of Industrial Cogeneration
Economies Of Industrial Cogeneration
 
IRJET - An Experimental Evaluation of Automobile Waste Heat Recovery System u...
IRJET - An Experimental Evaluation of Automobile Waste Heat Recovery System u...IRJET - An Experimental Evaluation of Automobile Waste Heat Recovery System u...
IRJET - An Experimental Evaluation of Automobile Waste Heat Recovery System u...
 
A case study on total Energy Conservation opportunities in a Solar power assi...
A case study on total Energy Conservation opportunities in a Solar power assi...A case study on total Energy Conservation opportunities in a Solar power assi...
A case study on total Energy Conservation opportunities in a Solar power assi...
 
Cogeneration (chp)
Cogeneration (chp)Cogeneration (chp)
Cogeneration (chp)
 
Topic cogeneration
Topic cogeneration Topic cogeneration
Topic cogeneration
 
Cogeneration
CogenerationCogeneration
Cogeneration
 
Oasis heat presentation v3
Oasis heat presentation v3Oasis heat presentation v3
Oasis heat presentation v3
 
case study on energy conservation and utilization.
case study on energy conservation and utilization.case study on energy conservation and utilization.
case study on energy conservation and utilization.
 
Cogeneration
CogenerationCogeneration
Cogeneration
 
Energy storage in urban multi-energy systems | Marco Carlo Masoero
Energy storage in urban multi-energy systems | Marco Carlo MasoeroEnergy storage in urban multi-energy systems | Marco Carlo Masoero
Energy storage in urban multi-energy systems | Marco Carlo Masoero
 
Ethp Explaination Summary
Ethp Explaination SummaryEthp Explaination Summary
Ethp Explaination Summary
 
Optimising Energy Storage Within Micro-grid Systems | Edward Owens
 Optimising Energy Storage Within Micro-grid Systems | Edward Owens Optimising Energy Storage Within Micro-grid Systems | Edward Owens
Optimising Energy Storage Within Micro-grid Systems | Edward Owens
 
A1
A1A1
A1
 
Energy conservation by application of heat pump in process line at automobile...
Energy conservation by application of heat pump in process line at automobile...Energy conservation by application of heat pump in process line at automobile...
Energy conservation by application of heat pump in process line at automobile...
 
Occupant Behavior of a Plus-Energy Building Regarding Monitoring and Standard...
Occupant Behavior of a Plus-Energy Building Regarding Monitoring and Standard...Occupant Behavior of a Plus-Energy Building Regarding Monitoring and Standard...
Occupant Behavior of a Plus-Energy Building Regarding Monitoring and Standard...
 
Katrina phruksukarn solar thermal
Katrina phruksukarn solar thermalKatrina phruksukarn solar thermal
Katrina phruksukarn solar thermal
 
Group 1 TenCate Presentation FINAL
Group 1 TenCate Presentation FINALGroup 1 TenCate Presentation FINAL
Group 1 TenCate Presentation FINAL
 
Green Heat - renewable energies for appropriate applications
Green Heat - renewable energies for appropriate applicationsGreen Heat - renewable energies for appropriate applications
Green Heat - renewable energies for appropriate applications
 
Energy Auditing Final Phase
Energy Auditing Final PhaseEnergy Auditing Final Phase
Energy Auditing Final Phase
 
Internship Report on Cogeneration
Internship Report on Cogeneration Internship Report on Cogeneration
Internship Report on Cogeneration
 

Destacado

Exergiebeschouwing en kansrijke opties voor VINEX-locaties
Exergiebeschouwing en kansrijke opties voor VINEX-locatiesExergiebeschouwing en kansrijke opties voor VINEX-locaties
Exergiebeschouwing en kansrijke opties voor VINEX-locatiesMartin van der Jagt
 
Alternatief voor WK en elektrische warmtepompen
Alternatief voor WK en elektrische warmtepompenAlternatief voor WK en elektrische warmtepompen
Alternatief voor WK en elektrische warmtepompenMartin van der Jagt
 
Energieopties, besparingen en infrastructuur
Energieopties, besparingen en infrastructuurEnergieopties, besparingen en infrastructuur
Energieopties, besparingen en infrastructuurMartin van der Jagt
 

Destacado (6)

Exergiebeschouwing en kansrijke opties voor VINEX-locaties
Exergiebeschouwing en kansrijke opties voor VINEX-locatiesExergiebeschouwing en kansrijke opties voor VINEX-locaties
Exergiebeschouwing en kansrijke opties voor VINEX-locaties
 
Micro en Mini Wk + EWP
Micro en Mini Wk + EWPMicro en Mini Wk + EWP
Micro en Mini Wk + EWP
 
Alternatief voor WK en elektrische warmtepompen
Alternatief voor WK en elektrische warmtepompenAlternatief voor WK en elektrische warmtepompen
Alternatief voor WK en elektrische warmtepompen
 
Energieopties, besparingen en infrastructuur
Energieopties, besparingen en infrastructuurEnergieopties, besparingen en infrastructuur
Energieopties, besparingen en infrastructuur
 
Wind energie, waarom en hoe?
Wind energie, waarom en hoe?Wind energie, waarom en hoe?
Wind energie, waarom en hoe?
 
Solar Ice Production
Solar Ice ProductionSolar Ice Production
Solar Ice Production
 

Similar a Energy options, savings and infrastructure

Energyes division ener termopac line 2015 ev v02
Energyes division ener termopac line 2015 ev v02Energyes division ener termopac line 2015 ev v02
Energyes division ener termopac line 2015 ev v02Christian Moreau
 
Energyes Division EnerTermoPac Line 2015 EV V02
Energyes Division EnerTermoPac Line 2015 EV V02Energyes Division EnerTermoPac Line 2015 EV V02
Energyes Division EnerTermoPac Line 2015 EV V02Christian Moreau
 
Latest energy efficient technology - MICRO CHP
Latest energy efficient technology - MICRO CHPLatest energy efficient technology - MICRO CHP
Latest energy efficient technology - MICRO CHPTarun Dhiraj Parmar
 
Energy for Housing - Andy Frew, NI Housing Executive
Energy for Housing - Andy Frew, NI Housing ExecutiveEnergy for Housing - Andy Frew, NI Housing Executive
Energy for Housing - Andy Frew, NI Housing ExecutiveInvest Northern Ireland
 
VET4SBO Level 2 module 3 - unit 1 - v1.0 en
VET4SBO Level 2   module 3 - unit 1 - v1.0 enVET4SBO Level 2   module 3 - unit 1 - v1.0 en
VET4SBO Level 2 module 3 - unit 1 - v1.0 enKarel Van Isacker
 
NESEA Building Energy 2015: PV and Heat Pumps
NESEA Building Energy 2015: PV and Heat PumpsNESEA Building Energy 2015: PV and Heat Pumps
NESEA Building Energy 2015: PV and Heat Pumpsfortunatmueller
 
APPLICATIONS OF MICRO CHP IN HOSPITALS
APPLICATIONS OF MICRO CHP IN HOSPITALSAPPLICATIONS OF MICRO CHP IN HOSPITALS
APPLICATIONS OF MICRO CHP IN HOSPITALSHarshad Desai
 
HEAT PUMP BY ER SOHEL R SHEIKH
HEAT PUMP BY ER SOHEL R SHEIKHHEAT PUMP BY ER SOHEL R SHEIKH
HEAT PUMP BY ER SOHEL R SHEIKHEr Sohel R Sheikh
 
Irem presentation final
Irem presentation   finalIrem presentation   final
Irem presentation finalKepler
 
Holistic District Heating Grid Design with SimulationX & Green City
Holistic District Heating Grid Design with SimulationX & Green CityHolistic District Heating Grid Design with SimulationX & Green City
Holistic District Heating Grid Design with SimulationX & Green CitySimulationX
 
Electric technologies in dwellings - potential for achieving EU emission targets
Electric technologies in dwellings - potential for achieving EU emission targetsElectric technologies in dwellings - potential for achieving EU emission targets
Electric technologies in dwellings - potential for achieving EU emission targetsLeonardo ENERGY
 
Using Farm Waste to Benefit from Government Incentives
Using Farm Waste to Benefit from Government IncentivesUsing Farm Waste to Benefit from Government Incentives
Using Farm Waste to Benefit from Government IncentivesENERGplc
 
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)The SEAM Centre
 

Similar a Energy options, savings and infrastructure (20)

Energyes division ener termopac line 2015 ev v02
Energyes division ener termopac line 2015 ev v02Energyes division ener termopac line 2015 ev v02
Energyes division ener termopac line 2015 ev v02
 
Energyes Division EnerTermoPac Line 2015 EV V02
Energyes Division EnerTermoPac Line 2015 EV V02Energyes Division EnerTermoPac Line 2015 EV V02
Energyes Division EnerTermoPac Line 2015 EV V02
 
Latest energy efficient technology - MICRO CHP
Latest energy efficient technology - MICRO CHPLatest energy efficient technology - MICRO CHP
Latest energy efficient technology - MICRO CHP
 
Europe needs a Smart Energy System
Europe needs a Smart Energy SystemEurope needs a Smart Energy System
Europe needs a Smart Energy System
 
Energy for Housing - Andy Frew, NI Housing Executive
Energy for Housing - Andy Frew, NI Housing ExecutiveEnergy for Housing - Andy Frew, NI Housing Executive
Energy for Housing - Andy Frew, NI Housing Executive
 
VET4SBO Level 2 module 3 - unit 1 - v1.0 en
VET4SBO Level 2   module 3 - unit 1 - v1.0 enVET4SBO Level 2   module 3 - unit 1 - v1.0 en
VET4SBO Level 2 module 3 - unit 1 - v1.0 en
 
NESEA Building Energy 2015: PV and Heat Pumps
NESEA Building Energy 2015: PV and Heat PumpsNESEA Building Energy 2015: PV and Heat Pumps
NESEA Building Energy 2015: PV and Heat Pumps
 
APPLICATIONS OF MICRO CHP IN HOSPITALS
APPLICATIONS OF MICRO CHP IN HOSPITALSAPPLICATIONS OF MICRO CHP IN HOSPITALS
APPLICATIONS OF MICRO CHP IN HOSPITALS
 
HEAT PUMP BY ER SOHEL R SHEIKH
HEAT PUMP BY ER SOHEL R SHEIKHHEAT PUMP BY ER SOHEL R SHEIKH
HEAT PUMP BY ER SOHEL R SHEIKH
 
Irem presentation final
Irem presentation   finalIrem presentation   final
Irem presentation final
 
Europe’s Future Energy System: Local, Smart & 100% Renewable
Europe’s Future Energy System: Local, Smart & 100% Renewable Europe’s Future Energy System: Local, Smart & 100% Renewable
Europe’s Future Energy System: Local, Smart & 100% Renewable
 
Towards a decarbonised heating and cooling sector in Europe – Unlocking the ...
 Towards a decarbonised heating and cooling sector in Europe – Unlocking the ... Towards a decarbonised heating and cooling sector in Europe – Unlocking the ...
Towards a decarbonised heating and cooling sector in Europe – Unlocking the ...
 
Fuel Cells Residential Workshop
Fuel Cells Residential WorkshopFuel Cells Residential Workshop
Fuel Cells Residential Workshop
 
Holistic District Heating Grid Design with SimulationX & Green City
Holistic District Heating Grid Design with SimulationX & Green CityHolistic District Heating Grid Design with SimulationX & Green City
Holistic District Heating Grid Design with SimulationX & Green City
 
Heatreflex
HeatreflexHeatreflex
Heatreflex
 
Cogeneration Concept
Cogeneration ConceptCogeneration Concept
Cogeneration Concept
 
Electric technologies in dwellings - potential for achieving EU emission targets
Electric technologies in dwellings - potential for achieving EU emission targetsElectric technologies in dwellings - potential for achieving EU emission targets
Electric technologies in dwellings - potential for achieving EU emission targets
 
Using Farm Waste to Benefit from Government Incentives
Using Farm Waste to Benefit from Government IncentivesUsing Farm Waste to Benefit from Government Incentives
Using Farm Waste to Benefit from Government Incentives
 
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
 
Heat pump presentation
Heat pump presentationHeat pump presentation
Heat pump presentation
 

Último

Governors ppt.pdf .
Governors ppt.pdf                              .Governors ppt.pdf                              .
Governors ppt.pdf .happycocoman
 
introduction to python, fundamentals and basics
introduction to python, fundamentals and basicsintroduction to python, fundamentals and basics
introduction to python, fundamentals and basicsKNaveenKumarECE
 
pulse modulation technique (Pulse code modulation).pptx
pulse modulation technique (Pulse code modulation).pptxpulse modulation technique (Pulse code modulation).pptx
pulse modulation technique (Pulse code modulation).pptxNishanth Asmi
 
Artificial organ courses Hussein L1-C2.pptx
Artificial organ courses Hussein  L1-C2.pptxArtificial organ courses Hussein  L1-C2.pptx
Artificial organ courses Hussein L1-C2.pptxHusseinMishbak
 
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptxssuser886c55
 
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structures
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structuresSupport nodes for large-span coal storage structures
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structureswendy cai
 
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 JournalResearch paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 JournalDr. Manjunatha. P
 
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdf architecture engineering
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdf architecture engineeringعناصر نباتية PDF.pdf architecture engineering
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdf architecture engineeringmennamohamed200y
 
Field Report on present condition of Ward 1 and Ward 2 of Pabna Municipality
Field Report on present condition of Ward 1 and Ward 2 of Pabna MunicipalityField Report on present condition of Ward 1 and Ward 2 of Pabna Municipality
Field Report on present condition of Ward 1 and Ward 2 of Pabna MunicipalityMorshed Ahmed Rahath
 
This chapter gives an outline of the security.
This chapter gives an outline of the security.This chapter gives an outline of the security.
This chapter gives an outline of the security.RoshniIsrani1
 
Final PPT.ppt about human detection and counting
Final PPT.ppt  about human detection and countingFinal PPT.ppt  about human detection and counting
Final PPT.ppt about human detection and countingArbazAhmad25
 
NIPORT Home Economics Questions Solution 2024.pdf
NIPORT Home Economics Questions Solution 2024.pdfNIPORT Home Economics Questions Solution 2024.pdf
NIPORT Home Economics Questions Solution 2024.pdfMohonDas
 
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)GDSCNiT
 
EJECTOR REFRIGERATION CYCLE WITH THE INJECTION OF A HIGH DENSITY FLUID INTO A...
EJECTOR REFRIGERATION CYCLE WITH THE INJECTION OF A HIGH DENSITY FLUID INTO A...EJECTOR REFRIGERATION CYCLE WITH THE INJECTION OF A HIGH DENSITY FLUID INTO A...
EJECTOR REFRIGERATION CYCLE WITH THE INJECTION OF A HIGH DENSITY FLUID INTO A...marijomiljkovic1
 
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slideFirst Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slideMonika860882
 
Searching and Sorting Algorithms
Searching and Sorting AlgorithmsSearching and Sorting Algorithms
Searching and Sorting AlgorithmsAshutosh Satapathy
 
Introduction to Data Structures .
Introduction to Data Structures        .Introduction to Data Structures        .
Introduction to Data Structures .Ashutosh Satapathy
 
Wave Energy Technologies Overtopping 1 - Tom Thorpe.pdf
Wave Energy Technologies Overtopping 1 - Tom Thorpe.pdfWave Energy Technologies Overtopping 1 - Tom Thorpe.pdf
Wave Energy Technologies Overtopping 1 - Tom Thorpe.pdfErik Friis-Madsen
 

Último (20)

Governors ppt.pdf .
Governors ppt.pdf                              .Governors ppt.pdf                              .
Governors ppt.pdf .
 
introduction to python, fundamentals and basics
introduction to python, fundamentals and basicsintroduction to python, fundamentals and basics
introduction to python, fundamentals and basics
 
pulse modulation technique (Pulse code modulation).pptx
pulse modulation technique (Pulse code modulation).pptxpulse modulation technique (Pulse code modulation).pptx
pulse modulation technique (Pulse code modulation).pptx
 
Artificial organ courses Hussein L1-C2.pptx
Artificial organ courses Hussein  L1-C2.pptxArtificial organ courses Hussein  L1-C2.pptx
Artificial organ courses Hussein L1-C2.pptx
 
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
0950_Rodriguez_200520_Work_done-GEOGalicia_ELAB-converted.pptx
 
FOREST FIRE USING IoT-A Visual to UG students
FOREST FIRE USING IoT-A Visual to UG studentsFOREST FIRE USING IoT-A Visual to UG students
FOREST FIRE USING IoT-A Visual to UG students
 
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structures
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structuresSupport nodes for large-span coal storage structures
Support nodes for large-span coal storage structures
 
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 JournalResearch paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
Research paper publications: Meaning of Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Journal
 
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdf architecture engineering
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdf architecture engineeringعناصر نباتية PDF.pdf architecture engineering
عناصر نباتية PDF.pdf architecture engineering
 
Field Report on present condition of Ward 1 and Ward 2 of Pabna Municipality
Field Report on present condition of Ward 1 and Ward 2 of Pabna MunicipalityField Report on present condition of Ward 1 and Ward 2 of Pabna Municipality
Field Report on present condition of Ward 1 and Ward 2 of Pabna Municipality
 
This chapter gives an outline of the security.
This chapter gives an outline of the security.This chapter gives an outline of the security.
This chapter gives an outline of the security.
 
Final PPT.ppt about human detection and counting
Final PPT.ppt  about human detection and countingFinal PPT.ppt  about human detection and counting
Final PPT.ppt about human detection and counting
 
NIPORT Home Economics Questions Solution 2024.pdf
NIPORT Home Economics Questions Solution 2024.pdfNIPORT Home Economics Questions Solution 2024.pdf
NIPORT Home Economics Questions Solution 2024.pdf
 
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
Road to GDSC (Become the next GDSC lead)
 
EJECTOR REFRIGERATION CYCLE WITH THE INJECTION OF A HIGH DENSITY FLUID INTO A...
EJECTOR REFRIGERATION CYCLE WITH THE INJECTION OF A HIGH DENSITY FLUID INTO A...EJECTOR REFRIGERATION CYCLE WITH THE INJECTION OF A HIGH DENSITY FLUID INTO A...
EJECTOR REFRIGERATION CYCLE WITH THE INJECTION OF A HIGH DENSITY FLUID INTO A...
 
Caltrans view on recycling of in-place asphalt pavements
Caltrans view on recycling of in-place asphalt pavementsCaltrans view on recycling of in-place asphalt pavements
Caltrans view on recycling of in-place asphalt pavements
 
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slideFirst Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
First Review Group 1 PPT.pptx with slide
 
Searching and Sorting Algorithms
Searching and Sorting AlgorithmsSearching and Sorting Algorithms
Searching and Sorting Algorithms
 
Introduction to Data Structures .
Introduction to Data Structures        .Introduction to Data Structures        .
Introduction to Data Structures .
 
Wave Energy Technologies Overtopping 1 - Tom Thorpe.pdf
Wave Energy Technologies Overtopping 1 - Tom Thorpe.pdfWave Energy Technologies Overtopping 1 - Tom Thorpe.pdf
Wave Energy Technologies Overtopping 1 - Tom Thorpe.pdf
 

Energy options, savings and infrastructure

  • 1. Energy-options, savings and infrastructure Martin van der Jagt; 24 jan 2014 (Translation of a Dutch presentation)
  • 2. I prepared this presentation first in Dutch. In the Netherlands the Government has stimulated several energy systems: • Combined Heat and Power (CHP) in combination with District Heating • District Heating with Combined Cycle Plants (in Dutch STEG) • Electrical Heat Pumps (EHP’s) In most cases the energy saving of these systems was exaggerated by using the false reference or choosing the wrong system boundary. In this presentation I try to find the truth. And I present the Smart Boiler Room System (SBR) If you have remarks or questions you can mail me: martin.vd.jagt@gmail.com Martin F.G. Van der Jagt Apeldoorn, 9 feb 2015 Netherlands
  • 3. Subjects 1. Possible options when the “Slochteren”gas was discovered 2. The effect of the chosen System boundaries 3. Manipulation by choosing a reference 4. Effect of H/P ratio of the demand side 5. Why is CHP a bad option 6. Why are electrical heatpumps a bad option: Problems at “De Teuge Zutphen ” 7. The “Not More Than Gas principle” 8. What is good: The Smart Boiler Room Concept 9. Conclusions
  • 4. Gas Gas 380 kV Extreme options for the use of Slochteren Gas for E-production
  • 5. None of the presented options was chosen, WHY? Electricity production in Slochteren only was not possible at that time: The E-GRID was not engineered for that possibility. The second option was not possible, while decentralized E-production in a dwelling was not possible at that time. Nevertheless is it strange that in the Netherlands never is tried to find optimal Energy Infrastructures with Operation Research
  • 6. Producing more electricity than the consumption in the district In the next slide a STEG is used for district heating in a new city area of Utrecht(UTR): Leidsche Rijn(LR). For the consumption of the over production of electricity 3 dwellings with a gas boiler are needed. So for the calculation of the real energy saving you have to include the dwellings with the gas boilers! So the real primary energy use for 1 dwelling is; 20.9 / 4 = 5.2 The false reproach calculates only 3.4 primary energy use!
  • 7. Choice of System Boundary E= Electricity W = Heat
  • 8. STEG with district heating and separated generation
  • 9. Electrical Heat pumps Gas Heat pumps
  • 10. Systems Primary Energy Saving [%] STEG +Districtheating REMU 3.4 41 STEG +Districtheating NOVEM 1.7 71 STEG +Districtheating GCN 5.2 10(good calculated value!) Separated Production 5.8 0 STEG + EHP’s 4.7 19 GAS HP’s 4.7 19
  • 11. Choice of Reference When calculating the savings of CHP: Where is CHP a sustitute for?; • A Coal fired Powerstation • Windturbines • PV • A Gasfired STEG With 60% efficiency
  • 12. Effect of the H/P ratio from the demand side
  • 13. Savings of EHP’s Powerstation efficiency = 51 %(W/K=H/P)
  • 14. Savings of CHP and CHP with EHP’s
  • 15. Why is CHP a suboptimal choice? 1. CHP ⇒ There is still need for nearly the same number of Central Powerstations 2. Only little CO2 reduction 3. Increase NOx emission 4. CH4 emission 5. Financial result very dependant of electricity prices: Heat Demand Controlled
  • 16. Disadvantages of Electrical Heat Pumps ● Expensive Grid ● Expensive installation in the building: extra heating surface. ● Expensive heatsource ● Peakinstallation is a problem In the next slide a summary of the differences in costs: EHP<>Gas Boiler; Then some slides in Dutch with more detailed numbers.
  • 17. Problems with Electrical Heat Pumps in Zutphen (Netherlands) •High electricity notes •A lot glitches •No CO2 reduction: 39 % more than gas boiler heating! •It took years to solve the problems! Difference in Costs: Gas Boiler Heatpump Costs Gas Costs HP Gas/HP m3/year kWh/year kwh/year kwh/year HP €/y €/y [-] Overall 1.304 3.380 7.970 4.590 835 1.102 32%
  • 18. Bron: presentatie Alliander (site: http://deteuge2.nl/rapporten- alliander/)
  • 19. Bron: presentatie Alliander (site: http://deteuge2.nl/rapporten- alliander/)
  • 20. Bron: presentatie Alliander (site: http://deteuge2.nl/rapporten- alliander/)
  • 21. The Not More Than Gas Principle ● This is promised to users of districtheating ● Is Not Maintained by The Government ● Conflicts residents>energy company: ○ Houten Zuid: Foundation GIGAJoule<>Eneco ○ Almere: Community<>NUON (Eneco and NUON are Energy Distribution Companies)
  • 22. Smart Boiler Room System WK = CHP, EWP= Electrical Heat Pump, CV= Gas Boiler, Buffer= Heat Storage
  • 23. Advantages SBR-Concept(1) •Gas > Heat •Gas > Electricity •Electricity > Heat So based on energy market prices you choose the production method!
  • 24. Heat demand driven systems will have problems with extreme electricity prices. CHP’s must run when there is heat demand and the market price for electricity is low. EHP’s must run when the market price for electricity is high. The SBR can make the choice “Make or Buy”. In a SBR the CHP’s are electrical balanced with the EHP’s. So when the electricity prices are normal the electricity of the CHP’s is used to drive the EHP’s. When electricity is cheap (during nights) you can buy an amount of electricity for the EHP’s and storage the produced heat. When the electricity price is high you can sell the CHP’s electricity on the market. This is to complex for the Dutch Government!
  • 25. Advantages of SBR-Concept(2) ● Reasonable CO2 reduction ● The price of electricity is not dominant ● Technology is available ● Suitable for portfolio management ● Positive influence on Central Power Stations ● Cheaper electricity grids than CHP and EHP’s
  • 26. 19 timber frame dwellings Veenendaal with SBR constructed in 1998
  • 27. In 2011still in operation
  • 28. Conclusions: Important for the calculation of savings: •Choice of system boundary •Choice of reference system CHP’s and EHP’s: suboptimal choice It’s a pity that SBR is rarely applied People have right on maintenance of the “Not More Than Gas Principle” Privatization has prevented optimization of the energy infrastructure in the Netherlands

Notas del editor

  1. E = eleltricity W = heat