SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 9
Download to read offline
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 1
Big Data & Intellectual Property Rights in the
Health & Life Sciences
2016 Annual Conference: Big Data, Health Law, and Bioethics
Harvard Law School
Prof. Dr. Timo Minssen
Centre for Information and Innovation Law (CIIR)
University of Copenhagen (DK)
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 2
Introduction
• Big Data = challenges & opportunities for health & life sciences
• Sharing is caring: Paradigm shift demands co-operation & data sharing
• IPRs relevant when R&D translated into ”real world”- applications
• Availability, benefits & draw-backs of IPRs? Re-calibration required?
• Different choices for different areas of Big Data Science
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 3
Agenda
1. Most relevant IP &
”sui generis” rights in Big Data
2. 5 selected problematic ares
in health and life scieces
3. Potential remedies
4. Conclusions
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 4
6 overlapping IPRs & ”sui generis”
IPs relevant for Big Data
PATENTS Copyrights TRADEMARKS
Data Base
Protection
Trade Secets Regulatory
Exclusivities
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 5
5 overlapping problems at the interface
of Big Data & IPRs in health & life science
1.IPRs, standardization
& competition law
2. Large research
infrastructures
3. Public involvement &
IPRs
4. IPRs, data transparency &
sharing initiatives
5. R&D incentives in
Precision Medicine
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 6
Potential remedies
•Transparency, better patent-search tools & high quality patents
•Better training and involvement of scientific community
•Clarify research exemptions & open innovation-platforms
•User-generated models (FRAND, pat-pools & clearing houses)
P1-Standards &
competition
•See above- plus case-dependent IP user-modalities
•Clear IP & data policy (cf. ESS-ERIC & BBMRI-Eric)
•Grant-back clauses, non excl. & non-discr. licensing
•Clarify international guidelines on co-authorship & data transfer
P2-Research
Infrastructure
•Coherency between open data policies & public IPR ownship
•Case-by-case decisions on (1) Pure Open Data models, (2)
Conditioned models & Properietary models.
•Better sharing platforms.
P3-Public Involv.
•Re-consider interplay between transparency with IPRs & TS
•Facilitate complementary & alternative incentives
•Safe-guards with regard to misuse & privacy
•Improved fair use clauses & research exemptions
•New licensing regimes & better tools for FTO analysis
P4–Transparency
& sharing
•Changes in patent law unlikely.
•Alternative incentives for data-sets, algorytms & validation.
•US data base protection
•More flexibility with regard to reg. exclusivities & prizes
P5-Incentives in
precision medicine
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 7
Conclusions
• Many different IP relevant to Big Data
• Paradigm shift results in overlapping IP challenges on different levels
• Interplay between IPRs, new policies & business strategies requires further
studies
• Trad. IP system fails to support Big Data due to law, business & tech. changes
• Flaws results in both IP lack of incentives & potential blocking effect due to new IP
strategies.
• Re-calibration of substantial & procedural IP rules + governance
• Need for cross (Atlantic)-fertilization , studies
& alignment of strategies
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 8
• Utilization of Big Data only sustainable if Privacy, Competition,
Regulation of test-services, sharing tools & data quality are addressed
&….
• Legislation is supported by public (erosion of gate-keeper barriers)
• Education & sufficient transparency
are the key
´
-/14,
Conclusions II
Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 9
Questions or Suggestions?
Thanks for your attention !
E-mail: Timo.Minssen@jur.ku.dk
Reseach page: http://jura.ku.dk/ciir/ansatte/?pure=da/persons/381631

More Related Content

What's hot

HRB_Data_Summary_FINAL (2)
HRB_Data_Summary_FINAL (2)HRB_Data_Summary_FINAL (2)
HRB_Data_Summary_FINAL (2)
Rosalyn Moran
 
pc15257_brochure original
pc15257_brochure originalpc15257_brochure original
pc15257_brochure original
Daria Binder
 
Open Data: Barriers, Risks, and Opportunities
Open Data: Barriers, Risks, and OpportunitiesOpen Data: Barriers, Risks, and Opportunities
Open Data: Barriers, Risks, and Opportunities
Slim Turki, Dr.
 
Legal and regulatory challenges to data sharing for clinical genetics and ge...
Legal and regulatory challenges to  data sharing for clinical genetics and ge...Legal and regulatory challenges to  data sharing for clinical genetics and ge...
Legal and regulatory challenges to data sharing for clinical genetics and ge...
Human Variome Project
 

What's hot (20)

Donna Gitter, "Informed Consent and Privacy of De-Identified and Estimated Da...
Donna Gitter, "Informed Consent and Privacy of De-Identified and Estimated Da...Donna Gitter, "Informed Consent and Privacy of De-Identified and Estimated Da...
Donna Gitter, "Informed Consent and Privacy of De-Identified and Estimated Da...
 
Liza Dawson, "The Common Rule and Research with Data, Big and Small"
Liza Dawson, "The Common Rule and Research with Data, Big and Small"Liza Dawson, "The Common Rule and Research with Data, Big and Small"
Liza Dawson, "The Common Rule and Research with Data, Big and Small"
 
Big Data Analytics government healthcare
Big Data Analytics government healthcareBig Data Analytics government healthcare
Big Data Analytics government healthcare
 
Towards an ecosystem for privacy respecting analysis of distributed health data
Towards an ecosystem for privacy respecting analysis of distributed health data Towards an ecosystem for privacy respecting analysis of distributed health data
Towards an ecosystem for privacy respecting analysis of distributed health data
 
Kraaij infrastructures for secure data analytics def brussel 2017
Kraaij infrastructures for secure data analytics def brussel 2017Kraaij infrastructures for secure data analytics def brussel 2017
Kraaij infrastructures for secure data analytics def brussel 2017
 
Data Sharing and Release Legislation
Data Sharing and Release Legislation   Data Sharing and Release Legislation
Data Sharing and Release Legislation
 
HRB_Data_Summary_FINAL (2)
HRB_Data_Summary_FINAL (2)HRB_Data_Summary_FINAL (2)
HRB_Data_Summary_FINAL (2)
 
The role of the FAIR Guiding Principles in a Learning Health System
The role of the FAIR Guiding Principles in a Learning Health SystemThe role of the FAIR Guiding Principles in a Learning Health System
The role of the FAIR Guiding Principles in a Learning Health System
 
pc15257_brochure original
pc15257_brochure originalpc15257_brochure original
pc15257_brochure original
 
BDE SC1 Workshop 3 - iASiS (Guillermo Palma)
BDE SC1 Workshop 3 - iASiS (Guillermo Palma)BDE SC1 Workshop 3 - iASiS (Guillermo Palma)
BDE SC1 Workshop 3 - iASiS (Guillermo Palma)
 
DATA PRIVACY IN AN AGE OF INCREASINGLY SPECIFIC AND PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATA: ...
DATA PRIVACY IN AN AGE OF INCREASINGLY SPECIFIC AND PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATA: ...DATA PRIVACY IN AN AGE OF INCREASINGLY SPECIFIC AND PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATA: ...
DATA PRIVACY IN AN AGE OF INCREASINGLY SPECIFIC AND PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATA: ...
 
The Role of the FAIR Guiding Principles for an effective Learning Health System
The Role of the FAIR Guiding Principles for an effective Learning Health SystemThe Role of the FAIR Guiding Principles for an effective Learning Health System
The Role of the FAIR Guiding Principles for an effective Learning Health System
 
Open Data: Barriers, Risks, and Opportunities
Open Data: Barriers, Risks, and OpportunitiesOpen Data: Barriers, Risks, and Opportunities
Open Data: Barriers, Risks, and Opportunities
 
Blockchain in Health Research Overview - Manion
Blockchain in Health Research Overview - ManionBlockchain in Health Research Overview - Manion
Blockchain in Health Research Overview - Manion
 
The life sciences industry in 2018
The life sciences industry in 2018The life sciences industry in 2018
The life sciences industry in 2018
 
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspective
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspectiveInvestigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspective
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspective
 
Legal and regulatory challenges to data sharing for clinical genetics and ge...
Legal and regulatory challenges to  data sharing for clinical genetics and ge...Legal and regulatory challenges to  data sharing for clinical genetics and ge...
Legal and regulatory challenges to data sharing for clinical genetics and ge...
 
CASCON 2009 - Talk on Interoperability
CASCON 2009 - Talk on InteroperabilityCASCON 2009 - Talk on Interoperability
CASCON 2009 - Talk on Interoperability
 
Blockchain and Patient-Centered Outcomes Measures - Goldwater
Blockchain and Patient-Centered Outcomes Measures - GoldwaterBlockchain and Patient-Centered Outcomes Measures - Goldwater
Blockchain and Patient-Centered Outcomes Measures - Goldwater
 
EU data protection and security update COCIR annual meeting 2016
EU data protection and security update COCIR annual meeting 2016EU data protection and security update COCIR annual meeting 2016
EU data protection and security update COCIR annual meeting 2016
 

Viewers also liked

Intellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property RightsIntellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property Rights
harshhanu
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Sharona Hoffman, "Big Data and the Americans with Disabilities Act: Amending ...
Sharona Hoffman, "Big Data and the Americans with Disabilities Act: Amending ...Sharona Hoffman, "Big Data and the Americans with Disabilities Act: Amending ...
Sharona Hoffman, "Big Data and the Americans with Disabilities Act: Amending ...
 
Introduction to ph 11.01.2016
Introduction to ph  11.01.2016Introduction to ph  11.01.2016
Introduction to ph 11.01.2016
 
Catherine M. Hammack, "Thought Leader Perspectives on Risks and Protections i...
Catherine M. Hammack, "Thought Leader Perspectives on Risks and Protections i...Catherine M. Hammack, "Thought Leader Perspectives on Risks and Protections i...
Catherine M. Hammack, "Thought Leader Perspectives on Risks and Protections i...
 
Isaac Kohane, "A Data Perspective on Autonomy, Human Rights, and the End of N...
Isaac Kohane, "A Data Perspective on Autonomy, Human Rights, and the End of N...Isaac Kohane, "A Data Perspective on Autonomy, Human Rights, and the End of N...
Isaac Kohane, "A Data Perspective on Autonomy, Human Rights, and the End of N...
 
Big Data: Big Issues for IP
Big Data: Big Issues for IPBig Data: Big Issues for IP
Big Data: Big Issues for IP
 
Intellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property RightsIntellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property Rights
 

Similar to Timo Minssen, "Big Data and Intellectual Property Rights in the Health and Life Sciences"

Managing Your Research Data for Maximum Impact -Rob Daley 300616_Shared
Managing Your Research Data for Maximum Impact -Rob Daley 300616_SharedManaging Your Research Data for Maximum Impact -Rob Daley 300616_Shared
Managing Your Research Data for Maximum Impact -Rob Daley 300616_Shared
Rob Daley
 

Similar to Timo Minssen, "Big Data and Intellectual Property Rights in the Health and Life Sciences" (20)

Legal barriers to better use of health data to deliver pharmaceutical innovation
Legal barriers to better use of health data to deliver pharmaceutical innovationLegal barriers to better use of health data to deliver pharmaceutical innovation
Legal barriers to better use of health data to deliver pharmaceutical innovation
 
Data Sharing Principles and Legal Interoperability for Essential Biodiversity...
Data Sharing Principles and Legal Interoperability for Essential Biodiversity...Data Sharing Principles and Legal Interoperability for Essential Biodiversity...
Data Sharing Principles and Legal Interoperability for Essential Biodiversity...
 
FAIR vs GDPR: which will win?
FAIR vs GDPR: which will win?FAIR vs GDPR: which will win?
FAIR vs GDPR: which will win?
 
Preparing Research Data for Sharing
Preparing Research Data for SharingPreparing Research Data for Sharing
Preparing Research Data for Sharing
 
HCF 2016: Jake Sanderson
HCF 2016: Jake SandersonHCF 2016: Jake Sanderson
HCF 2016: Jake Sanderson
 
Information Security Forum (ISF) Congress 2013
Information Security Forum (ISF) Congress 2013 Information Security Forum (ISF) Congress 2013
Information Security Forum (ISF) Congress 2013
 
"Legal implementation barriers of privacy-preserving technologies" eLAW prese...
"Legal implementation barriers of privacy-preserving technologies" eLAW prese..."Legal implementation barriers of privacy-preserving technologies" eLAW prese...
"Legal implementation barriers of privacy-preserving technologies" eLAW prese...
 
Making your research data open
Making your research data openMaking your research data open
Making your research data open
 
Making your research data open
Making your research data openMaking your research data open
Making your research data open
 
'Connected healthcare - connected to legality?'
'Connected healthcare - connected to legality?''Connected healthcare - connected to legality?'
'Connected healthcare - connected to legality?'
 
big-data-and-data-sharing_ethical-issues.pdf
big-data-and-data-sharing_ethical-issues.pdfbig-data-and-data-sharing_ethical-issues.pdf
big-data-and-data-sharing_ethical-issues.pdf
 
Connecting the Data Wires
Connecting the Data WiresConnecting the Data Wires
Connecting the Data Wires
 
Managing Your Research Data for Maximum Impact -Rob Daley 300616_Shared
Managing Your Research Data for Maximum Impact -Rob Daley 300616_SharedManaging Your Research Data for Maximum Impact -Rob Daley 300616_Shared
Managing Your Research Data for Maximum Impact -Rob Daley 300616_Shared
 
Lessons from Journal Research Data Policy Registry Pilot
Lessons from Journal Research Data Policy Registry PilotLessons from Journal Research Data Policy Registry Pilot
Lessons from Journal Research Data Policy Registry Pilot
 
20160719 23 Research Data Things
20160719 23 Research Data Things20160719 23 Research Data Things
20160719 23 Research Data Things
 
ICCESOMAR International Code
ICCESOMAR International CodeICCESOMAR International Code
ICCESOMAR International Code
 
Beyond Privacy: Learning Data Ethics - European Big Data Community Forum 2019...
Beyond Privacy: Learning Data Ethics - European Big Data Community Forum 2019...Beyond Privacy: Learning Data Ethics - European Big Data Community Forum 2019...
Beyond Privacy: Learning Data Ethics - European Big Data Community Forum 2019...
 
Beyond Privacy: Learning Data Ethics - European Big Data Community Forum 2019...
Beyond Privacy: Learning Data Ethics - European Big Data Community Forum 2019...Beyond Privacy: Learning Data Ethics - European Big Data Community Forum 2019...
Beyond Privacy: Learning Data Ethics - European Big Data Community Forum 2019...
 
R A Longhorn Presentation at Taiwan Open Data Forum, Taipei, 9 July 2014
R A Longhorn Presentation at Taiwan Open Data Forum, Taipei, 9 July 2014R A Longhorn Presentation at Taiwan Open Data Forum, Taipei, 9 July 2014
R A Longhorn Presentation at Taiwan Open Data Forum, Taipei, 9 July 2014
 
Open Science Governance and Regulation/Simon Hodson
Open Science Governance and Regulation/Simon HodsonOpen Science Governance and Regulation/Simon Hodson
Open Science Governance and Regulation/Simon Hodson
 

More from The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics

Robert Yates, "Hospital Detentions For Non-Payment of Fees A Denial of Rights...
Robert Yates, "Hospital Detentions For Non-Payment of Fees A Denial of Rights...Robert Yates, "Hospital Detentions For Non-Payment of Fees A Denial of Rights...
Robert Yates, "Hospital Detentions For Non-Payment of Fees A Denial of Rights...
The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics
 
Ranak Trivedi, "Bridging the Gap Between Artificial Intelligence and Natural ...
Ranak Trivedi, "Bridging the Gap Between Artificial Intelligence and Natural ...Ranak Trivedi, "Bridging the Gap Between Artificial Intelligence and Natural ...
Ranak Trivedi, "Bridging the Gap Between Artificial Intelligence and Natural ...
The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics
 
Noll Campbell,"Artificial Intelligence & Disabilities: Cognitive Impairment a...
Noll Campbell,"Artificial Intelligence & Disabilities: Cognitive Impairment a...Noll Campbell,"Artificial Intelligence & Disabilities: Cognitive Impairment a...
Noll Campbell,"Artificial Intelligence & Disabilities: Cognitive Impairment a...
The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics
 
Dov Fox, "Birth Rights & Wrongs: How Medicine and Technology Are Remaking Rep...
Dov Fox, "Birth Rights & Wrongs: How Medicine and Technology Are Remaking Rep...Dov Fox, "Birth Rights & Wrongs: How Medicine and Technology Are Remaking Rep...
Dov Fox, "Birth Rights & Wrongs: How Medicine and Technology Are Remaking Rep...
The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics
 
Katherine L. Kraschel, "What Doesn't Kill Your Tort Only Makes It Stronger --...
Katherine L. Kraschel, "What Doesn't Kill Your Tort Only Makes It Stronger --...Katherine L. Kraschel, "What Doesn't Kill Your Tort Only Makes It Stronger --...
Katherine L. Kraschel, "What Doesn't Kill Your Tort Only Makes It Stronger --...
The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics
 

More from The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics (20)

Christine Mitchell, Ethical Dilemmas in Mask and Equipment Shortages: Health ...
Christine Mitchell, Ethical Dilemmas in Mask and Equipment Shortages: Health ...Christine Mitchell, Ethical Dilemmas in Mask and Equipment Shortages: Health ...
Christine Mitchell, Ethical Dilemmas in Mask and Equipment Shortages: Health ...
 
Robert Yates, "Hospital Detentions For Non-Payment of Fees A Denial of Rights...
Robert Yates, "Hospital Detentions For Non-Payment of Fees A Denial of Rights...Robert Yates, "Hospital Detentions For Non-Payment of Fees A Denial of Rights...
Robert Yates, "Hospital Detentions For Non-Payment of Fees A Denial of Rights...
 
Ranak Trivedi, "Bridging the Gap Between Artificial Intelligence and Natural ...
Ranak Trivedi, "Bridging the Gap Between Artificial Intelligence and Natural ...Ranak Trivedi, "Bridging the Gap Between Artificial Intelligence and Natural ...
Ranak Trivedi, "Bridging the Gap Between Artificial Intelligence and Natural ...
 
Noll Campbell,"Artificial Intelligence & Disabilities: Cognitive Impairment a...
Noll Campbell,"Artificial Intelligence & Disabilities: Cognitive Impairment a...Noll Campbell,"Artificial Intelligence & Disabilities: Cognitive Impairment a...
Noll Campbell,"Artificial Intelligence & Disabilities: Cognitive Impairment a...
 
Emily M. Broad Leib, Policies to Reduce Sugar Consumption: The Battleground
Emily M. Broad Leib, Policies to Reduce Sugar Consumption: The BattlegroundEmily M. Broad Leib, Policies to Reduce Sugar Consumption: The Battleground
Emily M. Broad Leib, Policies to Reduce Sugar Consumption: The Battleground
 
Steven Gortmaker, Sugar Sweetened Beverage Taxes: Impact on Health, Health Ca...
Steven Gortmaker, Sugar Sweetened Beverage Taxes: Impact on Health, Health Ca...Steven Gortmaker, Sugar Sweetened Beverage Taxes: Impact on Health, Health Ca...
Steven Gortmaker, Sugar Sweetened Beverage Taxes: Impact on Health, Health Ca...
 
Justin T. Baker, Into the Deep
Justin T. Baker, Into the DeepJustin T. Baker, Into the Deep
Justin T. Baker, Into the Deep
 
Nzovu Ulenga, Tanzania HIV/AIDS Progress: Successes, Challenges, and Lessons ...
Nzovu Ulenga, Tanzania HIV/AIDS Progress: Successes, Challenges, and Lessons ...Nzovu Ulenga, Tanzania HIV/AIDS Progress: Successes, Challenges, and Lessons ...
Nzovu Ulenga, Tanzania HIV/AIDS Progress: Successes, Challenges, and Lessons ...
 
Prosper Okonkwo, 15+ Years of PEPFAR - The Nigeria Experience
Prosper Okonkwo, 15+ Years of PEPFAR - The Nigeria ExperienceProsper Okonkwo, 15+ Years of PEPFAR - The Nigeria Experience
Prosper Okonkwo, 15+ Years of PEPFAR - The Nigeria Experience
 
Maureen Luba Milambe, A 15 Year Review of PEPFAR Support to Malawi: How Has i...
Maureen Luba Milambe, A 15 Year Review of PEPFAR Support to Malawi: How Has i...Maureen Luba Milambe, A 15 Year Review of PEPFAR Support to Malawi: How Has i...
Maureen Luba Milambe, A 15 Year Review of PEPFAR Support to Malawi: How Has i...
 
Phyllis J. Kanki, 15+ Years of PEPFAR: Getting to Zero
Phyllis J. Kanki, 15+ Years of PEPFAR: Getting to ZeroPhyllis J. Kanki, 15+ Years of PEPFAR: Getting to Zero
Phyllis J. Kanki, 15+ Years of PEPFAR: Getting to Zero
 
Shahin Lockman, Botswana: Arc of and Response to the HIV Epidemic
Shahin Lockman, Botswana: Arc of and Response to the HIV EpidemicShahin Lockman, Botswana: Arc of and Response to the HIV Epidemic
Shahin Lockman, Botswana: Arc of and Response to the HIV Epidemic
 
Charles Holmes, 2009-2013 From an Emergency Response to Local Ownership and S...
Charles Holmes, 2009-2013 From an Emergency Response to Local Ownership and S...Charles Holmes, 2009-2013 From an Emergency Response to Local Ownership and S...
Charles Holmes, 2009-2013 From an Emergency Response to Local Ownership and S...
 
Anthony S. Fauci, The Birth of PEPFAR
Anthony S. Fauci, The Birth of PEPFARAnthony S. Fauci, The Birth of PEPFAR
Anthony S. Fauci, The Birth of PEPFAR
 
Dov Fox, "Birth Rights & Wrongs: How Medicine and Technology Are Remaking Rep...
Dov Fox, "Birth Rights & Wrongs: How Medicine and Technology Are Remaking Rep...Dov Fox, "Birth Rights & Wrongs: How Medicine and Technology Are Remaking Rep...
Dov Fox, "Birth Rights & Wrongs: How Medicine and Technology Are Remaking Rep...
 
Katherine L. Kraschel, "What Doesn't Kill Your Tort Only Makes It Stronger --...
Katherine L. Kraschel, "What Doesn't Kill Your Tort Only Makes It Stronger --...Katherine L. Kraschel, "What Doesn't Kill Your Tort Only Makes It Stronger --...
Katherine L. Kraschel, "What Doesn't Kill Your Tort Only Makes It Stronger --...
 
Vardit Ravitsky, "Prenatal Genome Sequencing: Ethical and Regulatory Implicat...
Vardit Ravitsky, "Prenatal Genome Sequencing: Ethical and Regulatory Implicat...Vardit Ravitsky, "Prenatal Genome Sequencing: Ethical and Regulatory Implicat...
Vardit Ravitsky, "Prenatal Genome Sequencing: Ethical and Regulatory Implicat...
 
Liza Vertinsky, "Genetic Paparazzi vs. Genetic Privacy"
Liza Vertinsky, "Genetic Paparazzi vs. Genetic Privacy"Liza Vertinsky, "Genetic Paparazzi vs. Genetic Privacy"
Liza Vertinsky, "Genetic Paparazzi vs. Genetic Privacy"
 
Scott Schweikart, "Human Genome Editing: An Ethical Analysis and Arguments fo...
Scott Schweikart, "Human Genome Editing: An Ethical Analysis and Arguments fo...Scott Schweikart, "Human Genome Editing: An Ethical Analysis and Arguments fo...
Scott Schweikart, "Human Genome Editing: An Ethical Analysis and Arguments fo...
 
Emily Qian, "Physician-Mediated Elective Whole Genome Sequencing Tests"
Emily Qian, "Physician-Mediated Elective Whole Genome Sequencing Tests"Emily Qian, "Physician-Mediated Elective Whole Genome Sequencing Tests"
Emily Qian, "Physician-Mediated Elective Whole Genome Sequencing Tests"
 

Recently uploaded

Escorts Lahore || 🔞 03274100048 || Escort service in Lahore
Escorts Lahore || 🔞 03274100048 || Escort service in LahoreEscorts Lahore || 🔞 03274100048 || Escort service in Lahore
Escorts Lahore || 🔞 03274100048 || Escort service in Lahore
Deny Daniel
 
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in LahoreBest Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Deny Daniel
 
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Sheetaleventcompany
 
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call GirlsPunjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
@Chandigarh #call #Girls 9053900678 @Call #Girls in @Punjab 9053900678
 
9316020077📞Majorda Beach Call Girls Numbers, Call Girls Whatsapp Numbers Ma...
9316020077📞Majorda Beach Call Girls  Numbers, Call Girls  Whatsapp Numbers Ma...9316020077📞Majorda Beach Call Girls  Numbers, Call Girls  Whatsapp Numbers Ma...
9316020077📞Majorda Beach Call Girls Numbers, Call Girls Whatsapp Numbers Ma...
Goa cutee sexy top girl
 
Call Girl in Indore 8827247818 {Low Price}👉 Meghna Indore Call Girls * DXZ...
Call Girl in Indore 8827247818 {Low Price}👉   Meghna Indore Call Girls  * DXZ...Call Girl in Indore 8827247818 {Low Price}👉   Meghna Indore Call Girls  * DXZ...
Call Girl in Indore 8827247818 {Low Price}👉 Meghna Indore Call Girls * DXZ...
mahaiklolahd
 
Call Girls in Udaipur Girija Udaipur Call Girl ✔ VQRWTO ❤️ 100% offer with...
Call Girls in Udaipur  Girija  Udaipur Call Girl  ✔ VQRWTO ❤️ 100% offer with...Call Girls in Udaipur  Girija  Udaipur Call Girl  ✔ VQRWTO ❤️ 100% offer with...
Call Girls in Udaipur Girija Udaipur Call Girl ✔ VQRWTO ❤️ 100% offer with...
mahaiklolahd
 
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetErnakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Call Girls Chandigarh
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Escorts Lahore || 🔞 03274100048 || Escort service in Lahore
Escorts Lahore || 🔞 03274100048 || Escort service in LahoreEscorts Lahore || 🔞 03274100048 || Escort service in Lahore
Escorts Lahore || 🔞 03274100048 || Escort service in Lahore
 
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in LahoreBest Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
Best Lahore Escorts 😮‍💨03250114445 || VIP escorts in Lahore
 
AECS Layout Escorts (Bangalore) 9352852248 Women seeking Men Real Service
AECS Layout Escorts (Bangalore) 9352852248 Women seeking Men Real ServiceAECS Layout Escorts (Bangalore) 9352852248 Women seeking Men Real Service
AECS Layout Escorts (Bangalore) 9352852248 Women seeking Men Real Service
 
Dehradun Call Girls 8854095900 Call Girl in Dehradun Uttrakhand
Dehradun Call Girls 8854095900 Call Girl in Dehradun  UttrakhandDehradun Call Girls 8854095900 Call Girl in Dehradun  Uttrakhand
Dehradun Call Girls 8854095900 Call Girl in Dehradun Uttrakhand
 
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
Top 20 Famous Indian Female Pornstars Name List 2024
 
Kochi call girls Mallu escort girls available 7877702510
Kochi call girls Mallu escort girls available 7877702510Kochi call girls Mallu escort girls available 7877702510
Kochi call girls Mallu escort girls available 7877702510
 
Vip Call Girls Makarba 👙 6367187148 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Vip Call Girls Makarba 👙 6367187148 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetVip Call Girls Makarba 👙 6367187148 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Vip Call Girls Makarba 👙 6367187148 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
Kolkata Call Girls Miss Inaaya ❤️ at @30% discount Everyday Call girl
Kolkata Call Girls Miss Inaaya ❤️ at @30% discount Everyday Call girlKolkata Call Girls Miss Inaaya ❤️ at @30% discount Everyday Call girl
Kolkata Call Girls Miss Inaaya ❤️ at @30% discount Everyday Call girl
 
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call GirlsPunjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
Punjab Call Girls Contact Number +919053,900,678 Punjab Call Girls
 
9316020077📞Majorda Beach Call Girls Numbers, Call Girls Whatsapp Numbers Ma...
9316020077📞Majorda Beach Call Girls  Numbers, Call Girls  Whatsapp Numbers Ma...9316020077📞Majorda Beach Call Girls  Numbers, Call Girls  Whatsapp Numbers Ma...
9316020077📞Majorda Beach Call Girls Numbers, Call Girls Whatsapp Numbers Ma...
 
Call Girl in Indore 8827247818 {Low Price}👉 Meghna Indore Call Girls * DXZ...
Call Girl in Indore 8827247818 {Low Price}👉   Meghna Indore Call Girls  * DXZ...Call Girl in Indore 8827247818 {Low Price}👉   Meghna Indore Call Girls  * DXZ...
Call Girl in Indore 8827247818 {Low Price}👉 Meghna Indore Call Girls * DXZ...
 
Call Girls in Udaipur Girija Udaipur Call Girl ✔ VQRWTO ❤️ 100% offer with...
Call Girls in Udaipur  Girija  Udaipur Call Girl  ✔ VQRWTO ❤️ 100% offer with...Call Girls in Udaipur  Girija  Udaipur Call Girl  ✔ VQRWTO ❤️ 100% offer with...
Call Girls in Udaipur Girija Udaipur Call Girl ✔ VQRWTO ❤️ 100% offer with...
 
(Big Boobs Indian Girls) 💓 9257276172 💓High Profile Call Girls Jaipur You Can...
(Big Boobs Indian Girls) 💓 9257276172 💓High Profile Call Girls Jaipur You Can...(Big Boobs Indian Girls) 💓 9257276172 💓High Profile Call Girls Jaipur You Can...
(Big Boobs Indian Girls) 💓 9257276172 💓High Profile Call Girls Jaipur You Can...
 
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real MeetErnakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
Ernakulam Call Girls 👙 6297143586 👙 Genuine WhatsApp Number for Real Meet
 
Rishikesh Call Girls Service 6398383382 Real Russian Girls Looking Models
Rishikesh Call Girls Service 6398383382 Real Russian Girls Looking ModelsRishikesh Call Girls Service 6398383382 Real Russian Girls Looking Models
Rishikesh Call Girls Service 6398383382 Real Russian Girls Looking Models
 
❤️Ludhiana Call Girls ☎️98157-77685☎️ Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludhiana...
❤️Ludhiana Call Girls ☎️98157-77685☎️ Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludhiana...❤️Ludhiana Call Girls ☎️98157-77685☎️ Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludhiana...
❤️Ludhiana Call Girls ☎️98157-77685☎️ Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludhiana...
 
Independent Call Girls Service Chandigarh | 8868886958 | Call Girl Service Nu...
Independent Call Girls Service Chandigarh | 8868886958 | Call Girl Service Nu...Independent Call Girls Service Chandigarh | 8868886958 | Call Girl Service Nu...
Independent Call Girls Service Chandigarh | 8868886958 | Call Girl Service Nu...
 
Sexy Call Girl Villupuram Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Villupuram Escort Service
Sexy Call Girl Villupuram Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Villupuram Escort ServiceSexy Call Girl Villupuram Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Villupuram Escort Service
Sexy Call Girl Villupuram Arshi 💚9058824046💚 Villupuram Escort Service
 
Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali Punjab
Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali PunjabGorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali Punjab
Gorgeous Call Girls Mohali {7435815124} ❤️VVIP ANGEL Call Girls in Mohali Punjab
 
Independent Call Girls Service Chandigarh Sector 17 | 8868886958 | Call Girl ...
Independent Call Girls Service Chandigarh Sector 17 | 8868886958 | Call Girl ...Independent Call Girls Service Chandigarh Sector 17 | 8868886958 | Call Girl ...
Independent Call Girls Service Chandigarh Sector 17 | 8868886958 | Call Girl ...
 

Timo Minssen, "Big Data and Intellectual Property Rights in the Health and Life Sciences"

  • 1. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 1 Big Data & Intellectual Property Rights in the Health & Life Sciences 2016 Annual Conference: Big Data, Health Law, and Bioethics Harvard Law School Prof. Dr. Timo Minssen Centre for Information and Innovation Law (CIIR) University of Copenhagen (DK)
  • 2. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 2 Introduction • Big Data = challenges & opportunities for health & life sciences • Sharing is caring: Paradigm shift demands co-operation & data sharing • IPRs relevant when R&D translated into ”real world”- applications • Availability, benefits & draw-backs of IPRs? Re-calibration required? • Different choices for different areas of Big Data Science
  • 3. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 3 Agenda 1. Most relevant IP & ”sui generis” rights in Big Data 2. 5 selected problematic ares in health and life scieces 3. Potential remedies 4. Conclusions
  • 4. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 4 6 overlapping IPRs & ”sui generis” IPs relevant for Big Data PATENTS Copyrights TRADEMARKS Data Base Protection Trade Secets Regulatory Exclusivities
  • 5. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 5 5 overlapping problems at the interface of Big Data & IPRs in health & life science 1.IPRs, standardization & competition law 2. Large research infrastructures 3. Public involvement & IPRs 4. IPRs, data transparency & sharing initiatives 5. R&D incentives in Precision Medicine
  • 6. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 6 Potential remedies •Transparency, better patent-search tools & high quality patents •Better training and involvement of scientific community •Clarify research exemptions & open innovation-platforms •User-generated models (FRAND, pat-pools & clearing houses) P1-Standards & competition •See above- plus case-dependent IP user-modalities •Clear IP & data policy (cf. ESS-ERIC & BBMRI-Eric) •Grant-back clauses, non excl. & non-discr. licensing •Clarify international guidelines on co-authorship & data transfer P2-Research Infrastructure •Coherency between open data policies & public IPR ownship •Case-by-case decisions on (1) Pure Open Data models, (2) Conditioned models & Properietary models. •Better sharing platforms. P3-Public Involv. •Re-consider interplay between transparency with IPRs & TS •Facilitate complementary & alternative incentives •Safe-guards with regard to misuse & privacy •Improved fair use clauses & research exemptions •New licensing regimes & better tools for FTO analysis P4–Transparency & sharing •Changes in patent law unlikely. •Alternative incentives for data-sets, algorytms & validation. •US data base protection •More flexibility with regard to reg. exclusivities & prizes P5-Incentives in precision medicine
  • 7. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 7 Conclusions • Many different IP relevant to Big Data • Paradigm shift results in overlapping IP challenges on different levels • Interplay between IPRs, new policies & business strategies requires further studies • Trad. IP system fails to support Big Data due to law, business & tech. changes • Flaws results in both IP lack of incentives & potential blocking effect due to new IP strategies. • Re-calibration of substantial & procedural IP rules + governance • Need for cross (Atlantic)-fertilization , studies & alignment of strategies
  • 8. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 8 • Utilization of Big Data only sustainable if Privacy, Competition, Regulation of test-services, sharing tools & data quality are addressed &…. • Legislation is supported by public (erosion of gate-keeper barriers) • Education & sufficient transparency are the key ´ -/14, Conclusions II
  • 9. Centre for Information and Innovation LawMay 6th, 2016 9 Questions or Suggestions? Thanks for your attention ! E-mail: Timo.Minssen@jur.ku.dk Reseach page: http://jura.ku.dk/ciir/ansatte/?pure=da/persons/381631