SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Making History Work for Tolerance:
main findings from Latvia
Linda Curika,
Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
Brussels, 31.01.2014
Legislation
• One Standart for teaching History for all schoola
• Teachers have creative freedom
• Since the end of the transition period in school
year 2012/2013 Latvian and World History in
basic education are taught as two separate
subjects
• One of the objectives of the subject „History of
Latvia” is to promote the sense of affiliation to
the Latvian State and patriotism.
Schools and teachers
• Teacher from minority school in interview:
– «We teach history bilingually, according to state standards. But students in my
school say they would like to study more about world history, to have a
broader look on what is happening in the world. For example, to understand
what is currently happening in Arab countries. From my opinion, history of
Latvia is being taught too much during 3 years...»
• Teacher in interview:
– «Students now have a better knowledge about Latvian history, but they cannot
connect events in Latvia and in the World history. Their knowledge about
World history is worse than it used to be. Now students do not have a feeling
that history – it is a connected process.»
• In public discourse it is possible to find stories about teachers from
minority schools, who use history textbooks, which have been printed in
Russian federation. Those teachers are shamed on press and National
television for bringing the “wrong version of history into schools”.
Students
• Students do not recognize how history teaching
could be connected to Tolerance
• Students: „history textbooks just give us
uninteresting facts, that are boring”.
• Students sometimes hear different stories about
history at home
• Student in interview:
– «History is boring and it is just another subject that is
based on learning facts. For me the hardest part is
remembering correct dates, I would really need some
help with that.»
Political discourse
• Pressure on patriotic upbringing, not tolerance and
inclusion, quotes that divide society into “us” and
“them” and depict “otherness” as something bad for
society can be seen throughout everyday political
discourse.
– «I am happy that ministry of Culture has agreed to national
union and that there is a certain guarantee, that these
Latvian values, Latvian identity will be made a priority and
that “Unity”’s previous ministers, let’s call them, genetic
attempts with slogan “You do not need to be born a
Latvian, you can become one!”… this fake continuation of
latvianism maybe will now be re-evaluated.» (I.Cepane,
coalition party Vienotiba, speech in parliament)
Recomendations
• Raise awareness about cultural diversity in the society and to
increase understanding about diverse cultural legacies
• To maintain good knowledge of the cultural history of the
world’s other regions and civilisations in the general context
of globalisation whilst simultaneously maintaining an
appropriate focus on national history through teaching it as a
separate subject
• Encourage and increase cooperation by all the stakeholders
and institutions that assist in the teaching of history and
foster development of joint projects, initiatives, events and
reflection
Thank you for your attention!
Linda Curika
linda.curika@providus.lv
www.providus.lv

More Related Content

What's hot

WiLSWorld 2019 Lightning Talks: Community Engagement Showcase
WiLSWorld 2019 Lightning Talks: Community Engagement ShowcaseWiLSWorld 2019 Lightning Talks: Community Engagement Showcase
WiLSWorld 2019 Lightning Talks: Community Engagement ShowcaseWiLS
 
CHIRS and NNLM-MCR: Your Partners in Health Information
CHIRS and NNLM-MCR: Your Partners in Health InformationCHIRS and NNLM-MCR: Your Partners in Health Information
CHIRS and NNLM-MCR: Your Partners in Health InformationNebraska Library Commission
 
Work life partners for community development
Work life partners for community developmentWork life partners for community development
Work life partners for community developmentEarly Artis
 
Our school - second online meeting
Our school - second online meetingOur school - second online meeting
Our school - second online meetingShareMyEmotionsBulga
 
9th northumbria collection development as a political process
9th northumbria collection development as a political process9th northumbria collection development as a political process
9th northumbria collection development as a political processJannicke Røgler
 

What's hot (6)

WiLSWorld 2019 Lightning Talks: Community Engagement Showcase
WiLSWorld 2019 Lightning Talks: Community Engagement ShowcaseWiLSWorld 2019 Lightning Talks: Community Engagement Showcase
WiLSWorld 2019 Lightning Talks: Community Engagement Showcase
 
CHIRS and NNLM-MCR: Your Partners in Health Information
CHIRS and NNLM-MCR: Your Partners in Health InformationCHIRS and NNLM-MCR: Your Partners in Health Information
CHIRS and NNLM-MCR: Your Partners in Health Information
 
Work life partners for community development
Work life partners for community developmentWork life partners for community development
Work life partners for community development
 
Our school - second online meeting
Our school - second online meetingOur school - second online meeting
Our school - second online meeting
 
9th northumbria collection development as a political process
9th northumbria collection development as a political process9th northumbria collection development as a political process
9th northumbria collection development as a political process
 
Slovak national revival
Slovak national revivalSlovak national revival
Slovak national revival
 

Viewers also liked

Early Prevention of Youth Crime in Latvia: Multi-Disciplinary Cooperation and...
Early Prevention of Youth Crime in Latvia: Multi-Disciplinary Cooperation and...Early Prevention of Youth Crime in Latvia: Multi-Disciplinary Cooperation and...
Early Prevention of Youth Crime in Latvia: Multi-Disciplinary Cooperation and...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
ES likumdošana un rīcībpolitika migrācijas un imigrantu integrācijas jomā
ES likumdošana un rīcībpolitika migrācijas un imigrantu integrācijas jomāES likumdošana un rīcībpolitika migrācijas un imigrantu integrācijas jomā
ES likumdošana un rīcībpolitika migrācijas un imigrantu integrācijas jomāCentre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Cietušā tiesības, to nodrošināšanas garantijas Latvijas kriminālprocesā
Cietušā tiesības, to nodrošināšanas garantijas Latvijas kriminālprocesāCietušā tiesības, to nodrošināšanas garantijas Latvijas kriminālprocesā
Cietušā tiesības, to nodrošināšanas garantijas Latvijas kriminālprocesāCentre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva..."Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Aktualitātes bērnu tiesību nodrošināšanā izglītības iestādēs
Aktualitātes bērnu tiesību nodrošināšanā izglītības iestādēsAktualitātes bērnu tiesību nodrošināšanā izglītības iestādēs
Aktualitātes bērnu tiesību nodrošināšanā izglītības iestādēsCentre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva..."Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva..."Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
KONCEPTUĀLĀS DILEMMAS EIROPAS POLITIKAS INICIATĪVĀM BRĪVAS DARBASPĒKA KUSTĪBA...
KONCEPTUĀLĀS DILEMMAS EIROPAS POLITIKAS INICIATĪVĀM BRĪVAS DARBASPĒKA KUSTĪBA...KONCEPTUĀLĀS DILEMMAS EIROPAS POLITIKAS INICIATĪVĀM BRĪVAS DARBASPĒKA KUSTĪBA...
KONCEPTUĀLĀS DILEMMAS EIROPAS POLITIKAS INICIATĪVĀM BRĪVAS DARBASPĒKA KUSTĪBA...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Radot bērniem un jauniešiem labvēlīgu vidi. Ilona Kronberga
Radot bērniem un jauniešiem labvēlīgu vidi. Ilona KronbergaRadot bērniem un jauniešiem labvēlīgu vidi. Ilona Kronberga
Radot bērniem un jauniešiem labvēlīgu vidi. Ilona KronbergaCentre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis
Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķisNoziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis
Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Early Prevention of Youth Crime in Latvia: Multi-Disciplinary Cooperation and...
Early Prevention of Youth Crime in Latvia: Multi-Disciplinary Cooperation and...Early Prevention of Youth Crime in Latvia: Multi-Disciplinary Cooperation and...
Early Prevention of Youth Crime in Latvia: Multi-Disciplinary Cooperation and...
 
ES valstu pieredze ar konsultatīvajiem mehānismiem
ES valstu pieredze ar konsultatīvajiem mehānismiemES valstu pieredze ar konsultatīvajiem mehānismiem
ES valstu pieredze ar konsultatīvajiem mehānismiem
 
NVO pieredze - LOSP
NVO pieredze - LOSPNVO pieredze - LOSP
NVO pieredze - LOSP
 
Social media for policy change
Social media for policy changeSocial media for policy change
Social media for policy change
 
Governance of state-owned enterprises in Estonia
Governance of state-owned enterprises in EstoniaGovernance of state-owned enterprises in Estonia
Governance of state-owned enterprises in Estonia
 
ES likumdošana un rīcībpolitika migrācijas un imigrantu integrācijas jomā
ES likumdošana un rīcībpolitika migrācijas un imigrantu integrācijas jomāES likumdošana un rīcībpolitika migrācijas un imigrantu integrācijas jomā
ES likumdošana un rīcībpolitika migrācijas un imigrantu integrācijas jomā
 
Konsultatīvie mehānismi - Īrijas piemērs
Konsultatīvie mehānismi - Īrijas piemērsKonsultatīvie mehānismi - Īrijas piemērs
Konsultatīvie mehānismi - Īrijas piemērs
 
Cietušā tiesības, to nodrošināšanas garantijas Latvijas kriminālprocesā
Cietušā tiesības, to nodrošināšanas garantijas Latvijas kriminālprocesāCietušā tiesības, to nodrošināšanas garantijas Latvijas kriminālprocesā
Cietušā tiesības, to nodrošināšanas garantijas Latvijas kriminālprocesā
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva..."Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
 
Kronberga ilona 21_10_2014_prokurori
Kronberga ilona 21_10_2014_prokuroriKronberga ilona 21_10_2014_prokurori
Kronberga ilona 21_10_2014_prokurori
 
Aktualitātes bērnu tiesību nodrošināšanā izglītības iestādēs
Aktualitātes bērnu tiesību nodrošināšanā izglītības iestādēsAktualitātes bērnu tiesību nodrošināšanā izglītības iestādēs
Aktualitātes bērnu tiesību nodrošināšanā izglītības iestādēs
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva..."Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva..."Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
"Prezentācija nodarbību "Projektu attīstīšanas un plānošanas darbnīcas" ietva...
 
Raising an Effective Watchdog
Raising an Effective WatchdogRaising an Effective Watchdog
Raising an Effective Watchdog
 
KONCEPTUĀLĀS DILEMMAS EIROPAS POLITIKAS INICIATĪVĀM BRĪVAS DARBASPĒKA KUSTĪBA...
KONCEPTUĀLĀS DILEMMAS EIROPAS POLITIKAS INICIATĪVĀM BRĪVAS DARBASPĒKA KUSTĪBA...KONCEPTUĀLĀS DILEMMAS EIROPAS POLITIKAS INICIATĪVĀM BRĪVAS DARBASPĒKA KUSTĪBA...
KONCEPTUĀLĀS DILEMMAS EIROPAS POLITIKAS INICIATĪVĀM BRĪVAS DARBASPĒKA KUSTĪBA...
 
Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzdalības rīki
Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzdalības rīkiLīdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzdalības rīki
Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzdalības rīki
 
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 1.daļa
Mentoringa programma.Projektu vadība. 1.daļaMentoringa programma.Projektu vadība. 1.daļa
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 1.daļa
 
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 2.daļa
Mentoringa programma.Projektu vadība. 2.daļaMentoringa programma.Projektu vadība. 2.daļa
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 2.daļa
 
Radot bērniem un jauniešiem labvēlīgu vidi. Ilona Kronberga
Radot bērniem un jauniešiem labvēlīgu vidi. Ilona KronbergaRadot bērniem un jauniešiem labvēlīgu vidi. Ilona Kronberga
Radot bērniem un jauniešiem labvēlīgu vidi. Ilona Kronberga
 
Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis
Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķisNoziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis
Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis
 

Similar to Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis

Intangible cultural heritage in education
Intangible cultural heritage in educationIntangible cultural heritage in education
Intangible cultural heritage in educationKuPeKasvatus
 
Intangible cultural heritage in education
Intangible cultural heritage in educationIntangible cultural heritage in education
Intangible cultural heritage in educationIra Vihreälehto
 
Elizabeth Worden Anderson 'Teachers, Citizenship, and Memory: Implications fo...
Elizabeth Worden Anderson 'Teachers, Citizenship, and Memory: Implications fo...Elizabeth Worden Anderson 'Teachers, Citizenship, and Memory: Implications fo...
Elizabeth Worden Anderson 'Teachers, Citizenship, and Memory: Implications fo...UNESCO Centre NI
 
The role of the youth in cultural heritage - supporting engagement and partic...
The role of the youth in cultural heritage - supporting engagement and partic...The role of the youth in cultural heritage - supporting engagement and partic...
The role of the youth in cultural heritage - supporting engagement and partic...Ira Vihreälehto
 
Esitys Madridissa 11/2018
Esitys Madridissa 11/2018Esitys Madridissa 11/2018
Esitys Madridissa 11/2018KuPeKasvatus
 
Athina Basha - information literacy and albanian libraries (OSCAL2014)
Athina Basha - information  literacy and albanian libraries (OSCAL2014)Athina Basha - information  literacy and albanian libraries (OSCAL2014)
Athina Basha - information literacy and albanian libraries (OSCAL2014)Open Labs Albania
 
Buckingham Uni PGCE Feb 2017 Teaching culture
Buckingham Uni PGCE Feb 2017 Teaching culture Buckingham Uni PGCE Feb 2017 Teaching culture
Buckingham Uni PGCE Feb 2017 Teaching culture Steve Smith
 
Cooperating for a better education
Cooperating for a better educationCooperating for a better education
Cooperating for a better educationopetuskokkola
 
Scottish school libraries and citizenship
Scottish school libraries and citizenship Scottish school libraries and citizenship
Scottish school libraries and citizenship CILIPScotland
 
Culture leap - Educational programme
Culture leap - Educational programmeCulture leap - Educational programme
Culture leap - Educational programmeIra Vihreälehto
 
Conversations in the International Librarian Networking Program: USA and Lith...
Conversations in the International Librarian Networking Program: USA and Lith...Conversations in the International Librarian Networking Program: USA and Lith...
Conversations in the International Librarian Networking Program: USA and Lith...IRRT ILNP
 
Frei joão promoting reading 11th october
Frei joão promoting reading 11th octoberFrei joão promoting reading 11th october
Frei joão promoting reading 11th octobermalex86
 
Tolerance as a key to social integration into European dimension for young ci...
Tolerance as a key to social integration into European dimension for young ci...Tolerance as a key to social integration into European dimension for young ci...
Tolerance as a key to social integration into European dimension for young ci...thefun
 
Annamaria Capra - Sara Coccolo Referees for Special Needs Education, Social I...
Annamaria Capra - Sara Coccolo Referees for Special Needs Education, Social I...Annamaria Capra - Sara Coccolo Referees for Special Needs Education, Social I...
Annamaria Capra - Sara Coccolo Referees for Special Needs Education, Social I...James Vincent
 
The integration of multicultural education
The integration of multicultural educationThe integration of multicultural education
The integration of multicultural educationLupita De Loa
 
Case of Learner-centred, project-based course
Case of Learner-centred, project-based courseCase of Learner-centred, project-based course
Case of Learner-centred, project-based courseEsko Lius
 
Workshop patriotism final results
Workshop patriotism final resultsWorkshop patriotism final results
Workshop patriotism final resultsAnna Maria Machaj
 
Francene Kennedy TESOL Powerpoint Cultural Community Outreach Program Proposal
Francene Kennedy TESOL Powerpoint Cultural Community Outreach Program ProposalFrancene Kennedy TESOL Powerpoint Cultural Community Outreach Program Proposal
Francene Kennedy TESOL Powerpoint Cultural Community Outreach Program Proposalfrankenn123
 
Final concept note theme 4
Final concept note theme 4Final concept note theme 4
Final concept note theme 4Annika af Trolle
 

Similar to Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis (20)

Intangible cultural heritage in education
Intangible cultural heritage in educationIntangible cultural heritage in education
Intangible cultural heritage in education
 
Intangible cultural heritage in education
Intangible cultural heritage in educationIntangible cultural heritage in education
Intangible cultural heritage in education
 
Elizabeth Worden Anderson 'Teachers, Citizenship, and Memory: Implications fo...
Elizabeth Worden Anderson 'Teachers, Citizenship, and Memory: Implications fo...Elizabeth Worden Anderson 'Teachers, Citizenship, and Memory: Implications fo...
Elizabeth Worden Anderson 'Teachers, Citizenship, and Memory: Implications fo...
 
The role of the youth in cultural heritage - supporting engagement and partic...
The role of the youth in cultural heritage - supporting engagement and partic...The role of the youth in cultural heritage - supporting engagement and partic...
The role of the youth in cultural heritage - supporting engagement and partic...
 
Esitys Madridissa 11/2018
Esitys Madridissa 11/2018Esitys Madridissa 11/2018
Esitys Madridissa 11/2018
 
Athina Basha - information literacy and albanian libraries (OSCAL2014)
Athina Basha - information  literacy and albanian libraries (OSCAL2014)Athina Basha - information  literacy and albanian libraries (OSCAL2014)
Athina Basha - information literacy and albanian libraries (OSCAL2014)
 
Buckingham Uni PGCE Feb 2017 Teaching culture
Buckingham Uni PGCE Feb 2017 Teaching culture Buckingham Uni PGCE Feb 2017 Teaching culture
Buckingham Uni PGCE Feb 2017 Teaching culture
 
Cooperating for a better education
Cooperating for a better educationCooperating for a better education
Cooperating for a better education
 
Scottish school libraries and citizenship
Scottish school libraries and citizenship Scottish school libraries and citizenship
Scottish school libraries and citizenship
 
Culture leap - Educational programme
Culture leap - Educational programmeCulture leap - Educational programme
Culture leap - Educational programme
 
Conversations in the International Librarian Networking Program: USA and Lith...
Conversations in the International Librarian Networking Program: USA and Lith...Conversations in the International Librarian Networking Program: USA and Lith...
Conversations in the International Librarian Networking Program: USA and Lith...
 
Frei joão promoting reading 11th october
Frei joão promoting reading 11th octoberFrei joão promoting reading 11th october
Frei joão promoting reading 11th october
 
Tolerance as a key to social integration into European dimension for young ci...
Tolerance as a key to social integration into European dimension for young ci...Tolerance as a key to social integration into European dimension for young ci...
Tolerance as a key to social integration into European dimension for young ci...
 
Key Features of the Education System in Italy
Key Features of the Education System in ItalyKey Features of the Education System in Italy
Key Features of the Education System in Italy
 
Annamaria Capra - Sara Coccolo Referees for Special Needs Education, Social I...
Annamaria Capra - Sara Coccolo Referees for Special Needs Education, Social I...Annamaria Capra - Sara Coccolo Referees for Special Needs Education, Social I...
Annamaria Capra - Sara Coccolo Referees for Special Needs Education, Social I...
 
The integration of multicultural education
The integration of multicultural educationThe integration of multicultural education
The integration of multicultural education
 
Case of Learner-centred, project-based course
Case of Learner-centred, project-based courseCase of Learner-centred, project-based course
Case of Learner-centred, project-based course
 
Workshop patriotism final results
Workshop patriotism final resultsWorkshop patriotism final results
Workshop patriotism final results
 
Francene Kennedy TESOL Powerpoint Cultural Community Outreach Program Proposal
Francene Kennedy TESOL Powerpoint Cultural Community Outreach Program ProposalFrancene Kennedy TESOL Powerpoint Cultural Community Outreach Program Proposal
Francene Kennedy TESOL Powerpoint Cultural Community Outreach Program Proposal
 
Final concept note theme 4
Final concept note theme 4Final concept note theme 4
Final concept note theme 4
 

More from Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS

Do law enforcement agencies have an obligation to communicate?
Do law enforcement agencies have an obligation to communicate?Do law enforcement agencies have an obligation to communicate?
Do law enforcement agencies have an obligation to communicate?Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību mācību kursa "Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzd...
"Prezentācija nodarbību mācību kursa "Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzd..."Prezentācija nodarbību mācību kursa "Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzd...
"Prezentācija nodarbību mācību kursa "Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzd...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību cikla "Projektu vadība" ietvaros projektā "Daudzpusīg...
"Prezentācija nodarbību cikla "Projektu vadība" ietvaros projektā "Daudzpusīg..."Prezentācija nodarbību cikla "Projektu vadība" ietvaros projektā "Daudzpusīg...
"Prezentācija nodarbību cikla "Projektu vadība" ietvaros projektā "Daudzpusīg...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
On the experience gained in introduction of the project “Reducing prison popu...
On the experience gained in introduction of the project “Reducing prison popu...On the experience gained in introduction of the project “Reducing prison popu...
On the experience gained in introduction of the project “Reducing prison popu...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Keeping children away from crime: Early prevention as a method for social inc...
Keeping children away from crime: Early prevention as a method for social inc...Keeping children away from crime: Early prevention as a method for social inc...
Keeping children away from crime: Early prevention as a method for social inc...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Kirgizstānas tiesībsargājošo iestāžu iepazīstināšana ar LR krimināltiesību un...
Kirgizstānas tiesībsargājošo iestāžu iepazīstināšana ar LR krimināltiesību un...Kirgizstānas tiesībsargājošo iestāžu iepazīstināšana ar LR krimināltiesību un...
Kirgizstānas tiesībsargājošo iestāžu iepazīstināšana ar LR krimināltiesību un...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Latvijas nepilsoņu integrācijas procesa analīze: IZPĒTE, PROGNOZES, RISINĀJUM...
Latvijas nepilsoņu integrācijas procesa analīze: IZPĒTE, PROGNOZES, RISINĀJUM...Latvijas nepilsoņu integrācijas procesa analīze: IZPĒTE, PROGNOZES, RISINĀJUM...
Latvijas nepilsoņu integrācijas procesa analīze: IZPĒTE, PROGNOZES, RISINĀJUM...Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Viola Korpa: Ģimenei draudzīgas darbavietas. PROVIDUS seminārs
Viola Korpa: Ģimenei draudzīgas darbavietas. PROVIDUS seminārsViola Korpa: Ģimenei draudzīgas darbavietas. PROVIDUS seminārs
Viola Korpa: Ģimenei draudzīgas darbavietas. PROVIDUS seminārsCentre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Pārmaiņu skola - kopienas skola: iespēja labāku attiecību radīšanai
Pārmaiņu skola - kopienas skola: iespēja labāku attiecību radīšanaiPārmaiņu skola - kopienas skola: iespēja labāku attiecību radīšanai
Pārmaiņu skola - kopienas skola: iespēja labāku attiecību radīšanaiCentre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Projekts “Bērnu antisociālās uzvedības mazināšana: agrīnās prevencijas modeļi”
Projekts “Bērnu antisociālās uzvedības mazināšana: agrīnās prevencijas modeļi”Projekts “Bērnu antisociālās uzvedības mazināšana: agrīnās prevencijas modeļi”
Projekts “Bērnu antisociālās uzvedības mazināšana: agrīnās prevencijas modeļi”Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 
Sākotnējā kontakta nozīme saskarsmē ar cietušo - Valsts policijas prakse
Sākotnējā kontakta nozīme saskarsmē ar cietušo - Valsts policijas prakseSākotnējā kontakta nozīme saskarsmē ar cietušo - Valsts policijas prakse
Sākotnējā kontakta nozīme saskarsmē ar cietušo - Valsts policijas prakseCentre for Public Policy PROVIDUS
 

More from Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS (17)

Do law enforcement agencies have an obligation to communicate?
Do law enforcement agencies have an obligation to communicate?Do law enforcement agencies have an obligation to communicate?
Do law enforcement agencies have an obligation to communicate?
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību mācību kursa "Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzd...
"Prezentācija nodarbību mācību kursa "Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzd..."Prezentācija nodarbību mācību kursa "Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzd...
"Prezentācija nodarbību mācību kursa "Līdzdalības iespējas un interneta līdzd...
 
"Prezentācija nodarbību cikla "Projektu vadība" ietvaros projektā "Daudzpusīg...
"Prezentācija nodarbību cikla "Projektu vadība" ietvaros projektā "Daudzpusīg..."Prezentācija nodarbību cikla "Projektu vadība" ietvaros projektā "Daudzpusīg...
"Prezentācija nodarbību cikla "Projektu vadība" ietvaros projektā "Daudzpusīg...
 
Ievads mentoringa pieejā 2
Ievads mentoringa pieejā 2Ievads mentoringa pieejā 2
Ievads mentoringa pieejā 2
 
Ievads mentoringa pieejā. 1.daļa
Ievads mentoringa pieejā. 1.daļaIevads mentoringa pieejā. 1.daļa
Ievads mentoringa pieejā. 1.daļa
 
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 4.daļa
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 4.daļaMentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 4.daļa
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 4.daļa
 
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 3.daļa
Mentoringa programma.Projektu vadība. 3.daļaMentoringa programma.Projektu vadība. 3.daļa
Mentoringa programma. Projektu vadība. 3.daļa
 
On the experience gained in introduction of the project “Reducing prison popu...
On the experience gained in introduction of the project “Reducing prison popu...On the experience gained in introduction of the project “Reducing prison popu...
On the experience gained in introduction of the project “Reducing prison popu...
 
Keeping children away from crime: Early prevention as a method for social inc...
Keeping children away from crime: Early prevention as a method for social inc...Keeping children away from crime: Early prevention as a method for social inc...
Keeping children away from crime: Early prevention as a method for social inc...
 
Kirgizstānas tiesībsargājošo iestāžu iepazīstināšana ar LR krimināltiesību un...
Kirgizstānas tiesībsargājošo iestāžu iepazīstināšana ar LR krimināltiesību un...Kirgizstānas tiesībsargājošo iestāžu iepazīstināšana ar LR krimināltiesību un...
Kirgizstānas tiesībsargājošo iestāžu iepazīstināšana ar LR krimināltiesību un...
 
What is social entrepreneurship?
What is social entrepreneurship?What is social entrepreneurship?
What is social entrepreneurship?
 
Latvijas nepilsoņu integrācijas procesa analīze: IZPĒTE, PROGNOZES, RISINĀJUM...
Latvijas nepilsoņu integrācijas procesa analīze: IZPĒTE, PROGNOZES, RISINĀJUM...Latvijas nepilsoņu integrācijas procesa analīze: IZPĒTE, PROGNOZES, RISINĀJUM...
Latvijas nepilsoņu integrācijas procesa analīze: IZPĒTE, PROGNOZES, RISINĀJUM...
 
Viola Korpa: Ģimenei draudzīgas darbavietas. PROVIDUS seminārs
Viola Korpa: Ģimenei draudzīgas darbavietas. PROVIDUS seminārsViola Korpa: Ģimenei draudzīgas darbavietas. PROVIDUS seminārs
Viola Korpa: Ģimenei draudzīgas darbavietas. PROVIDUS seminārs
 
Pārmaiņu skola - kopienas skola: iespēja labāku attiecību radīšanai
Pārmaiņu skola - kopienas skola: iespēja labāku attiecību radīšanaiPārmaiņu skola - kopienas skola: iespēja labāku attiecību radīšanai
Pārmaiņu skola - kopienas skola: iespēja labāku attiecību radīšanai
 
Projekts “Bērnu antisociālās uzvedības mazināšana: agrīnās prevencijas modeļi”
Projekts “Bērnu antisociālās uzvedības mazināšana: agrīnās prevencijas modeļi”Projekts “Bērnu antisociālās uzvedības mazināšana: agrīnās prevencijas modeļi”
Projekts “Bērnu antisociālās uzvedības mazināšana: agrīnās prevencijas modeļi”
 
Sākotnējā kontakta nozīme saskarsmē ar cietušo - Valsts policijas prakse
Sākotnējā kontakta nozīme saskarsmē ar cietušo - Valsts policijas prakseSākotnējā kontakta nozīme saskarsmē ar cietušo - Valsts policijas prakse
Sākotnējā kontakta nozīme saskarsmē ar cietušo - Valsts policijas prakse
 
Izlīgums ar cietušo - nozīme, būtība un aktivitātes
Izlīgums ar cietušo - nozīme, būtība un aktivitātesIzlīgums ar cietušo - nozīme, būtība un aktivitātes
Izlīgums ar cietušo - nozīme, būtība un aktivitātes
 

Recently uploaded

一比一原版(UM毕业证书)美国密歇根大学安娜堡分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UM毕业证书)美国密歇根大学安娜堡分校毕业证如何办理一比一原版(UM毕业证书)美国密歇根大学安娜堡分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UM毕业证书)美国密歇根大学安娜堡分校毕业证如何办理A AA
 
一比一原版(JCU毕业证书)詹姆斯库克大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(JCU毕业证书)詹姆斯库克大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(JCU毕业证书)詹姆斯库克大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(JCU毕业证书)詹姆斯库克大学毕业证如何办理Airst S
 
COPYRIGHTS - PPT 01.12.2023 part- 2.pptx
COPYRIGHTS - PPT 01.12.2023 part- 2.pptxCOPYRIGHTS - PPT 01.12.2023 part- 2.pptx
COPYRIGHTS - PPT 01.12.2023 part- 2.pptxRRR Chambers
 
PowerPoint - Legal Citation Form 1 - Case Law.pptx
PowerPoint - Legal Citation Form 1 - Case Law.pptxPowerPoint - Legal Citation Form 1 - Case Law.pptx
PowerPoint - Legal Citation Form 1 - Case Law.pptxca2or2tx
 
一比一原版(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证如何办理A AA
 
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam TakersPhilippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam TakersJillianAsdala
 
Analysis of R V Kelkar's Criminal Procedure Code ppt- chapter 1 .pptx
Analysis of R V Kelkar's Criminal Procedure Code ppt- chapter 1 .pptxAnalysis of R V Kelkar's Criminal Procedure Code ppt- chapter 1 .pptx
Analysis of R V Kelkar's Criminal Procedure Code ppt- chapter 1 .pptxadvabhayjha2627
 
Shubh_Burden of proof_Indian Evidence Act.pptx
Shubh_Burden of proof_Indian Evidence Act.pptxShubh_Burden of proof_Indian Evidence Act.pptx
Shubh_Burden of proof_Indian Evidence Act.pptxShubham Wadhonkar
 
The Active Management Value Ratio: The New Science of Benchmarking Investment...
The Active Management Value Ratio: The New Science of Benchmarking Investment...The Active Management Value Ratio: The New Science of Benchmarking Investment...
The Active Management Value Ratio: The New Science of Benchmarking Investment...James Watkins, III JD CFP®
 
一比一原版曼彻斯特城市大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版曼彻斯特城市大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版曼彻斯特城市大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版曼彻斯特城市大学毕业证如何办理Airst S
 
一比一原版(CQU毕业证书)中央昆士兰大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(CQU毕业证书)中央昆士兰大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(CQU毕业证书)中央昆士兰大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(CQU毕业证书)中央昆士兰大学毕业证如何办理Airst S
 
IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016)-IOD - PPT.pptx
IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016)-IOD - PPT.pptxIBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016)-IOD - PPT.pptx
IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016)-IOD - PPT.pptxRRR Chambers
 
Navigating the Legal and Ethical Landscape of Blockchain Investigation.pdf
Navigating the Legal and Ethical Landscape of Blockchain Investigation.pdfNavigating the Legal and Ethical Landscape of Blockchain Investigation.pdf
Navigating the Legal and Ethical Landscape of Blockchain Investigation.pdfMilind Agarwal
 
Navigating Employment Law - Term Project.pptx
Navigating Employment Law - Term Project.pptxNavigating Employment Law - Term Project.pptx
Navigating Employment Law - Term Project.pptxelysemiller87
 
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURYA SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURYJulian Scutts
 
8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptx
8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptx8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptx
8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptxPamelaAbegailMonsant2
 
Clarifying Land Donation Issues Memo for
Clarifying Land Donation Issues Memo forClarifying Land Donation Issues Memo for
Clarifying Land Donation Issues Memo forRoger Valdez
 
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Nangli Wazidpur Sector 135 ( Noida)
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Nangli Wazidpur Sector 135 ( Noida)WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Nangli Wazidpur Sector 135 ( Noida)
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Nangli Wazidpur Sector 135 ( Noida)Delhi Call girls
 
一比一原版(RMIT毕业证书)皇家墨尔本理工大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(RMIT毕业证书)皇家墨尔本理工大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(RMIT毕业证书)皇家墨尔本理工大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(RMIT毕业证书)皇家墨尔本理工大学毕业证如何办理ss
 
一比一原版(QUT毕业证书)昆士兰科技大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(QUT毕业证书)昆士兰科技大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(QUT毕业证书)昆士兰科技大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(QUT毕业证书)昆士兰科技大学毕业证如何办理bd2c5966a56d
 

Recently uploaded (20)

一比一原版(UM毕业证书)美国密歇根大学安娜堡分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UM毕业证书)美国密歇根大学安娜堡分校毕业证如何办理一比一原版(UM毕业证书)美国密歇根大学安娜堡分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(UM毕业证书)美国密歇根大学安娜堡分校毕业证如何办理
 
一比一原版(JCU毕业证书)詹姆斯库克大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(JCU毕业证书)詹姆斯库克大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(JCU毕业证书)詹姆斯库克大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(JCU毕业证书)詹姆斯库克大学毕业证如何办理
 
COPYRIGHTS - PPT 01.12.2023 part- 2.pptx
COPYRIGHTS - PPT 01.12.2023 part- 2.pptxCOPYRIGHTS - PPT 01.12.2023 part- 2.pptx
COPYRIGHTS - PPT 01.12.2023 part- 2.pptx
 
PowerPoint - Legal Citation Form 1 - Case Law.pptx
PowerPoint - Legal Citation Form 1 - Case Law.pptxPowerPoint - Legal Citation Form 1 - Case Law.pptx
PowerPoint - Legal Citation Form 1 - Case Law.pptx
 
一比一原版(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证如何办理
 
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam TakersPhilippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
Philippine FIRE CODE REVIEWER for Architecture Board Exam Takers
 
Analysis of R V Kelkar's Criminal Procedure Code ppt- chapter 1 .pptx
Analysis of R V Kelkar's Criminal Procedure Code ppt- chapter 1 .pptxAnalysis of R V Kelkar's Criminal Procedure Code ppt- chapter 1 .pptx
Analysis of R V Kelkar's Criminal Procedure Code ppt- chapter 1 .pptx
 
Shubh_Burden of proof_Indian Evidence Act.pptx
Shubh_Burden of proof_Indian Evidence Act.pptxShubh_Burden of proof_Indian Evidence Act.pptx
Shubh_Burden of proof_Indian Evidence Act.pptx
 
The Active Management Value Ratio: The New Science of Benchmarking Investment...
The Active Management Value Ratio: The New Science of Benchmarking Investment...The Active Management Value Ratio: The New Science of Benchmarking Investment...
The Active Management Value Ratio: The New Science of Benchmarking Investment...
 
一比一原版曼彻斯特城市大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版曼彻斯特城市大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版曼彻斯特城市大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版曼彻斯特城市大学毕业证如何办理
 
一比一原版(CQU毕业证书)中央昆士兰大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(CQU毕业证书)中央昆士兰大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(CQU毕业证书)中央昆士兰大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(CQU毕业证书)中央昆士兰大学毕业证如何办理
 
IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016)-IOD - PPT.pptx
IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016)-IOD - PPT.pptxIBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016)-IOD - PPT.pptx
IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016)-IOD - PPT.pptx
 
Navigating the Legal and Ethical Landscape of Blockchain Investigation.pdf
Navigating the Legal and Ethical Landscape of Blockchain Investigation.pdfNavigating the Legal and Ethical Landscape of Blockchain Investigation.pdf
Navigating the Legal and Ethical Landscape of Blockchain Investigation.pdf
 
Navigating Employment Law - Term Project.pptx
Navigating Employment Law - Term Project.pptxNavigating Employment Law - Term Project.pptx
Navigating Employment Law - Term Project.pptx
 
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURYA SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
A SHORT HISTORY OF LIBERTY'S PROGREE THROUGH HE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
 
8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptx
8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptx8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptx
8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptx
 
Clarifying Land Donation Issues Memo for
Clarifying Land Donation Issues Memo forClarifying Land Donation Issues Memo for
Clarifying Land Donation Issues Memo for
 
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Nangli Wazidpur Sector 135 ( Noida)
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Nangli Wazidpur Sector 135 ( Noida)WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Nangli Wazidpur Sector 135 ( Noida)
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Nangli Wazidpur Sector 135 ( Noida)
 
一比一原版(RMIT毕业证书)皇家墨尔本理工大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(RMIT毕业证书)皇家墨尔本理工大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(RMIT毕业证书)皇家墨尔本理工大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(RMIT毕业证书)皇家墨尔本理工大学毕业证如何办理
 
一比一原版(QUT毕业证书)昆士兰科技大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(QUT毕业证书)昆士兰科技大学毕业证如何办理一比一原版(QUT毕业证书)昆士兰科技大学毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(QUT毕业证书)昆士兰科技大学毕业证如何办理
 

Noziedzīgu nodarījumu prevencija, kā kriminālsoda mērķis

  • 1. Making History Work for Tolerance: main findings from Latvia Linda Curika, Centre for Public Policy PROVIDUS Brussels, 31.01.2014
  • 2. Legislation • One Standart for teaching History for all schoola • Teachers have creative freedom • Since the end of the transition period in school year 2012/2013 Latvian and World History in basic education are taught as two separate subjects • One of the objectives of the subject „History of Latvia” is to promote the sense of affiliation to the Latvian State and patriotism.
  • 3. Schools and teachers • Teacher from minority school in interview: – «We teach history bilingually, according to state standards. But students in my school say they would like to study more about world history, to have a broader look on what is happening in the world. For example, to understand what is currently happening in Arab countries. From my opinion, history of Latvia is being taught too much during 3 years...» • Teacher in interview: – «Students now have a better knowledge about Latvian history, but they cannot connect events in Latvia and in the World history. Their knowledge about World history is worse than it used to be. Now students do not have a feeling that history – it is a connected process.» • In public discourse it is possible to find stories about teachers from minority schools, who use history textbooks, which have been printed in Russian federation. Those teachers are shamed on press and National television for bringing the “wrong version of history into schools”.
  • 4. Students • Students do not recognize how history teaching could be connected to Tolerance • Students: „history textbooks just give us uninteresting facts, that are boring”. • Students sometimes hear different stories about history at home • Student in interview: – «History is boring and it is just another subject that is based on learning facts. For me the hardest part is remembering correct dates, I would really need some help with that.»
  • 5. Political discourse • Pressure on patriotic upbringing, not tolerance and inclusion, quotes that divide society into “us” and “them” and depict “otherness” as something bad for society can be seen throughout everyday political discourse. – «I am happy that ministry of Culture has agreed to national union and that there is a certain guarantee, that these Latvian values, Latvian identity will be made a priority and that “Unity”’s previous ministers, let’s call them, genetic attempts with slogan “You do not need to be born a Latvian, you can become one!”… this fake continuation of latvianism maybe will now be re-evaluated.» (I.Cepane, coalition party Vienotiba, speech in parliament)
  • 6. Recomendations • Raise awareness about cultural diversity in the society and to increase understanding about diverse cultural legacies • To maintain good knowledge of the cultural history of the world’s other regions and civilisations in the general context of globalisation whilst simultaneously maintaining an appropriate focus on national history through teaching it as a separate subject • Encourage and increase cooperation by all the stakeholders and institutions that assist in the teaching of history and foster development of joint projects, initiatives, events and reflection
  • 7. Thank you for your attention! Linda Curika linda.curika@providus.lv www.providus.lv

Editor's Notes

  1. In 2010 in Latvia, the Cabinet of Ministers adopted legislation that divided history teaching into two subjects in primary schools, which was a change promoted by nationalistic politicians. Main aim of this legislation was to use history as a tool for patriotic upbringing in Latvian schools. Students’ knowledge on history events and dates is frequently tested by the media, so teachers constantly feel pressurized to address this demand. Although teachers in Latvia have creative freedom to use materials and methods they find appropriate, it is obvious that they feel pressured by the media to teach according to the political agenda, which can be subject to change.
  2. history teaching in different schools taught by different teachers will be different. It might teach tolerance, it might teach being hateful towards „others” as well. Even though textbooks lately have tried to include stories of all nationalities living in Latvia, teachers can still stress out specific struggles of Latvians or specific wrongdoing of „others”. There will be teachers who will teach patriotism, there will be teachers, who will not be able to teach it.
  3. For the context of this policy brief, it is crucial to take into consideration that the unique historical narratives of the region are still very much present in the current day Latvia and provides a significant backdrop against which many of the decisions are made. However, many of the more controversial and xenophobic/intolerant views are not voiced out loudly in the public sphere and are instead reserved for private conversation in families and in some cases, schools as well. Since direct, aggressive xenophobic discourse surfaces rarely, media content and discourse analysis is not particularly helpful for this type of analysis, as it does not fully describe the situation in the country. At the same time, political discourse can in certain cases be useful in this regard as it serves as a reflection of the ‘general will’, so to speak.