Card sorting is one of the most powerful techniques for improving the information architecture and taxonomy that you create. In this session we'll put card sorting in context and show you how to use them to create meaningful metadata.
You can download this presentation now by visiting https://www.thorprojects.com/connect/gifts/presentations/card-sorting-your-way-to-meaningful-metadata.
5. Meet Alice
• Just joined the company as a
field service rep
• Mother of three toddlers
• Experienced professional
6. Suffer with Alice
• Alice needs to know where to
find:
• Employee Handbook
• Vacation Request Form
• Expense Report Form
• Sales Training
• She wants to find:
• How to get connected to the
organization
• What her benefits are
7. Expense Report Form
• Who owns it?
• Accounting
• Payroll
• Human Resources
• What are the rules?
• When do I have to turn it in?
• What is (and isn’t allowed)?
8. Sales Training
• Learning Management System
• Where is it?
• What does it have (and not have)
in it?
• PowerPoint Templates
• Where are they?
• Are there template decks?
• Resources
• Where are they?
10. Creator Versus Consumer
• Creators are interested in EASE to
STORE.
• Consumers are interested in EASE to
RETRIEVE.
• Departmental taxonomies focus on EASE
to STORE.
• Functional taxonomies focus on EASE to
RETRIEVE.
11. Departmental Structures
• Most common intranet
organizational structure
• Easy for the CREATOR
• Difficult for the Consumer
12. Functional
Structures
• My “Organization”
• Benefits
• Payroll
• Health
• Retirement
• Facilities
• Physical Access
• Cleanliness
• Technology
• PC
• Remote Access
• At “Organization”
13. Folders Versus Metadata
• SharePoint has the capability
to transform folders (location)
and metadata back and forth.
• Use folders for security and
familiarity.
• Use metadata for flexibility.
14. Search vs. Navigation
• 50% of users Navigate, 50% of
users Search
• Users are interested in the
results – not the path
• Highly relevant search may be
faster than navigation
15. Words Are Not Meaning
• Staff
• Died
• Organ
• Seal
• Dust
• Weather
• Strike
• Workshop
• Sanction
• Bi-weekly
16. Pogo-Sticking Problem
• Rapidly clicking on search results
and clicking back to results /
Clicking sub-categories then
back to the higher level
• Users aren’t getting what they
want
• May indicate poor information
scent
17. Information Scent
• From 1970s optimal foraging
theory
• Cue to indicate whether the
information sought is in this
direction
• Ambient / environmental feel
18. Folksonomy
• Collaborative Tagging
• Free Vocabulary
• Emergent
• Issues
• Synonyms – multiple tags, same concept
• Homonymy – same tag, different
meaning
• Polysemy – same tag, multiple related
meanings
• Specificity – level of details
• Examples
• Delicious
• Flicker
19. First, Taxonomy then
Navigation
• Creating a taxonomy is
understanding the order and
nature of the content
• Navigation is trying to solve the
findability problem
• You can not solve a problem you
don’t understand
21. Content Inventory
• Collect classes of documents
• Identify those classes which are
“important”
• Frequently used
• Required/Important
• Identify metadata
23. Information Architecture Questions
Goals
What are the
goals of the
organization?
Scope
What is
included and
excluded?
Content
What
information
is being
managed?
Process
What is being
done with
the content?
Metadata
What are the
values and
ranges?
Visuals
26. Types of Metadata
• Intrinsic
• File Size
• Item Type
• Derived
• Created By
• Created Date
• Modified By
• Modified Date
• Declared
• List/Library Fields
• Terms
• Document Properties
27. Metadata Options and Values
• Gender (Singular, M/F,?)
• Age (Singular, Number)
• Experience (Singular, Choice)
• Software Version (Multiple, Choice)
• Role (Multiple, Choice)
• Industry (Multiple, Lookup)
• Height (Singular, Text? Number?)
• Name (Singular, Text)
• Organization (Singular,
Text/Lookup)
28. Staffing an Information
Architecture Project
• Phases
• Content Inventory
• IA leading BAs
• Card Sorting
• IA leading, 1 BA supporting
• Fine Tuning
• IA Performs / Leads
• Depends on
• Experience
• Quality desired
29. Card Sorting
• The most effective exercise for
creating a taxonomy
• Often need to nudge/push out
of current thinking
• Need clarity of audience and
purpose
30. Card Sorting - Open
• Get multiple groups of 2-5 to
process separately
• Hand them “cards” of categories
of documents
• Ask them to create categories to
organize “cards”
31.
32. Taxonomy Validation
• Intuitive – Easy to navigate and
use
• Unambiguous – Doesn’t offer
alternatives
• Hospitable – Can accommodate
all content
• Consistent and Predictable –
provides context / follows a
single model
33. Card Sorting - Closed
• Different people than used for
Open Card Sort
• Hand them the “cards” and the
categories
• Ask them to put “cards” into
categories
• Score
• -1 for “cards” they can’t file
• -2 for “cards” they put in the
wrong spot
Time: 1 minute
“Lets get ready to rumble…”
Fights with relatively easy answers
Time: 3 minutes
Common Question: “… but how do we organize if we don’t organize by department”?
Time: 5 minutes
Information Architect purists will say always use metadata – except when you can’t
Why metadata – Men vs. Women buying shoes
Time: 1 minute
Internet navigation… Type a company name in search rather than trying to guess their web site address
Time: 3 minutes
Staff
Stick
Employees
Infection
Died
Colored
Death
Organ
Musical Instrument
Body Part
Seal
Marine Mammal
Navy Special Operations
Dust
To remove
To Cover
Weather
To withstand a storm
To wear away
Strike
To Hit
To Miss
Workshop
A place where work is done
A place where you learn hands on
Time: 1 minute
Look for it.
Frustrating experience
Time: 1 minute
Optimal foraging theory – animals want to expend the minimum energy with the greatest chance of return. (Kind of like a teenager that wants to do the minimum)
You would be amazed at what we get from the ambient environment.
Time: 3 minutes
Net: “Individual Results may vary, past performance is not guarantee of future returns, void where prohibited, etc.”
Note: Requires “largish communities”
Story: Nursing …
Samuel Langley – Studied physics of flight (aerodynamics) but not as intently or correctly as the Wright brothers.
Time: 2 minutes
The context of IA evaluation is what is the user doing?
REMEMBER: Our goal is to make it easy to find things – thus how we represent it visually maters
Time: 2 minutes
Time: 2 minutes
Metadata in SharePoint is exposed as column data in lists and libraries. There are three main types of metadata: Intrinsic, Derived and Declared.
Intrinsic metadata is comprised of properties associated with the underlying object type. A document, for example, will have a file type and size, the values for which are not supplied by the user.
Derived metadata is information about the item that is captured or set automatically, such as the creation date, author, modification date, workflow associations, etc. These values may be modified programmatically or promoted from document properties but are not directly editable by the user.
Declared metadata is any information associated with an item that may be supplied by the user. It can be entered manually, created automatically based on document properties, or set programmatically in workflows or code.
Declared metadata is the most common type of information used in classification and taxonomy. It can vary greatly from list to list or site to site and is often grouped together in content types. Structured metadata can be defined on a global level within a term store and shared between site collections or declared locally for use within a specific site. Unstructured metadata in the form of social tags and ratings is supplied directly by users on an ad-hoc basis.
Time: 5 minutes
Open Card Sort
Closed Card Sort
Getting the right name for a category is difficult.