Practical solutions to barrier easement - Stuart Brabbs

Scottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre
Scottish Fisheries Co Ordination CentreScottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre
Practical solutions to barrier
easement
Stuart Brabbs
Ayrshire Rivers Trust
1 Gibbsyard,
Auchincruive
Ayr KA6 5HW
stuart@ayrshireriverstrust.org
01292 737300
A technical solution but with
hindsight, was it the best
option?
Cost £550K (including
design, ground
investigations, site clearance
and construction)
Other alternatives were
considered and rejected
including removal, partial
removal and rock ramp
Practical solutions to barrier easement - Stuart Brabbs
Practical solutions to barrier easement - Stuart Brabbs
Increased depth, reduced velocity
Hagg Burn culvert prior to easement
Concentrated flow to attract fish
Installing oak Baffles
Tulloch Burn/Gower Water (excellent habitat
and water quality in the upper catchment)
This barrier lies at the very top of the River
Irvine catchment and consists of a steep
bridge apron and natural waterfall that was
modified by the roads department around
2008 (concrete and rock armour added).
Since 2008 it has been impassable to
salmonids.
ART designed the fish pass and
assisted contractors on site to
ensure a flexible approach was
taken. Trial and error achieved the
end result.
It still requires a bit of ‘tinkering’
here or there, but it’s certainly no
worse than before.
Trout were seen entering the fish
pass this winter but no salmon. ART
will monitor results over the next
few years
Two minor alterations will be
completed this summer that should
improve the performance
The case of the incredible vanishing baulks
Skeldon weir is passable. However a
new hydro development in 2017 led
to reduced flow over the weir.
The developer applied to SEPA for
permission to add timber baulks to
assist salmonid migration (on our
recommendation). This was granted.
A local resident complained and SEPA
instructed them to be removed
Funding barrier easement is
challenging when funding is lacking
or unavailable.
ART are creative and look for new
ways to deliver results with limited
budgets (or none on occasions).
Here’s practical recycling at work!
Taking a proven solution that
originated in New Zealand, ART
decided to attempt to make our own
flexible baffles for use in a culvert
(crucially at no cost).
The aim was to prove the concept
using a new material and three baffles
were fabricated & installed
temporarily to assess results (now
removed until CAR issued)
Bed cutting down after removing weir
Redundant weir
Pottery found in exposed substrates
Grubbing it out
A76 Culvert on the Glaisnock Water
ART provided guidance to Scotland
Transerve on fish passage at this
culvert . They took our advice and
installed simple concrete baffles to
produce a fish pass.
For the first time in 30 years, fish can
again move upstream
Top right: Another simple solution
to assist migration over a weir
Bottom: Pre assembling eel brushes
to a HDPE backing board that will be
bolted to a curved face on a dam
Ness Falls on the
Water of Coyle.
A long term barrier to
migration created when
concrete was added to
the crest of the falls
to allow abstraction
to power a sawmill
ART have asked SEPA to
prioritise this easement
as it should open up
over 25km of habitat to
migratory salmonids
ART estimate this
barrier could be eased
for around £5K
Practical solutions to barrier easement - Stuart Brabbs
1 de 17

Recomendados

Coastal landscapes por
Coastal landscapesCoastal landscapes
Coastal landscapesScott Handy
171 vistas20 diapositivas
2014pp por
2014pp2014pp
2014ppLuke Anderson
281 vistas18 diapositivas
Coastal structure presentation_usace por
Coastal structure presentation_usaceCoastal structure presentation_usace
Coastal structure presentation_usacekumarrec
185 vistas72 diapositivas
GM Symposium 2016: Brendhan Zubricki, Essex por
GM Symposium 2016: Brendhan Zubricki, EssexGM Symposium 2016: Brendhan Zubricki, Essex
GM Symposium 2016: Brendhan Zubricki, Essexgreenbelt82
580 vistas26 diapositivas
Microsoft PowerPoint - EBA Mid_Year Energy Forum2016 por
Microsoft PowerPoint - EBA Mid_Year Energy Forum2016Microsoft PowerPoint - EBA Mid_Year Energy Forum2016
Microsoft PowerPoint - EBA Mid_Year Energy Forum2016Brian Benito Jr.
213 vistas5 diapositivas
Elko Lake Beach Presentation por
Elko Lake Beach PresentationElko Lake Beach Presentation
Elko Lake Beach Presentationnacona
200 vistas10 diapositivas

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Trazar Astley-Reid, Suffolk Coast and Heaths AONB Partnership, Suffolk Estuar... por
Trazar Astley-Reid, Suffolk Coast and Heaths AONB Partnership, Suffolk Estuar...Trazar Astley-Reid, Suffolk Coast and Heaths AONB Partnership, Suffolk Estuar...
Trazar Astley-Reid, Suffolk Coast and Heaths AONB Partnership, Suffolk Estuar...NAAONB landscapesforlife
616 vistas30 diapositivas
167 multi purpose-reefs_final por
167 multi purpose-reefs_final167 multi purpose-reefs_final
167 multi purpose-reefs_finalAlys Spillman
391 vistas33 diapositivas
AIA Rose Bay_presentation board_Rev 5 por
AIA Rose Bay_presentation board_Rev 5AIA Rose Bay_presentation board_Rev 5
AIA Rose Bay_presentation board_Rev 5Wayne Krygsman
101 vistas1 diapositiva
Sequalitchew Creek Watershed Council por
Sequalitchew Creek Watershed CouncilSequalitchew Creek Watershed Council
Sequalitchew Creek Watershed CouncilSequalitchew Creek Watershed Council
436 vistas16 diapositivas
Selectmen meeting 021014 final por
Selectmen meeting 021014 finalSelectmen meeting 021014 final
Selectmen meeting 021014 finalKristi Armstrong
387 vistas17 diapositivas
Realities of Beach Restoration in Quogue por
Realities of Beach Restoration in QuogueRealities of Beach Restoration in Quogue
Realities of Beach Restoration in QuogueQuogueBeaches
201 vistas1 diapositiva

La actualidad más candente(14)

Trazar Astley-Reid, Suffolk Coast and Heaths AONB Partnership, Suffolk Estuar... por NAAONB landscapesforlife
Trazar Astley-Reid, Suffolk Coast and Heaths AONB Partnership, Suffolk Estuar...Trazar Astley-Reid, Suffolk Coast and Heaths AONB Partnership, Suffolk Estuar...
Trazar Astley-Reid, Suffolk Coast and Heaths AONB Partnership, Suffolk Estuar...
167 multi purpose-reefs_final por Alys Spillman
167 multi purpose-reefs_final167 multi purpose-reefs_final
167 multi purpose-reefs_final
Alys Spillman391 vistas
AIA Rose Bay_presentation board_Rev 5 por Wayne Krygsman
AIA Rose Bay_presentation board_Rev 5AIA Rose Bay_presentation board_Rev 5
AIA Rose Bay_presentation board_Rev 5
Wayne Krygsman101 vistas
Realities of Beach Restoration in Quogue por QuogueBeaches
Realities of Beach Restoration in QuogueRealities of Beach Restoration in Quogue
Realities of Beach Restoration in Quogue
QuogueBeaches201 vistas
Ala moana 9 point plan por Crowdbrite
Ala moana 9 point plan Ala moana 9 point plan
Ala moana 9 point plan
Crowdbrite553 vistas
Martecchini great marsh symposium presentation duxbury beach - 11-13-2014 por greenbelt82
Martecchini great marsh symposium presentation   duxbury beach - 11-13-2014Martecchini great marsh symposium presentation   duxbury beach - 11-13-2014
Martecchini great marsh symposium presentation duxbury beach - 11-13-2014
greenbelt82467 vistas
Cumulative Impact Summary 1997-2010 HPAs por BSH Admin
Cumulative Impact Summary 1997-2010 HPAsCumulative Impact Summary 1997-2010 HPAs
Cumulative Impact Summary 1997-2010 HPAs
BSH Admin205 vistas
Westward ho fieldtrip 2010 por pberry5082
Westward ho fieldtrip 2010Westward ho fieldtrip 2010
Westward ho fieldtrip 2010
pberry50822.9K vistas
ICLR Friday Forum: Tantramar Marshes Flooding (March 19, 2021) por glennmcgillivray
ICLR Friday Forum: Tantramar Marshes Flooding (March 19, 2021)ICLR Friday Forum: Tantramar Marshes Flooding (March 19, 2021)
ICLR Friday Forum: Tantramar Marshes Flooding (March 19, 2021)
glennmcgillivray119 vistas

Similar a Practical solutions to barrier easement - Stuart Brabbs

When Relationships Go Wrong - sea defences por
When Relationships Go Wrong - sea defencesWhen Relationships Go Wrong - sea defences
When Relationships Go Wrong - sea defencesMark Ollis
498 vistas26 diapositivas
Abergeldie Marine por
Abergeldie MarineAbergeldie Marine
Abergeldie MarineAbergeldie Complex Infrastructure
245 vistas5 diapositivas
WRT CaBA/CRF Conference 02/12/14 - Adrian Dowding por
WRT CaBA/CRF Conference 02/12/14 - Adrian DowdingWRT CaBA/CRF Conference 02/12/14 - Adrian Dowding
WRT CaBA/CRF Conference 02/12/14 - Adrian DowdingWestcountry Rivers Trust
351 vistas18 diapositivas
Restoring Westmeadows Meander por
Restoring Westmeadows MeanderRestoring Westmeadows Meander
Restoring Westmeadows MeanderTony Smith
234 vistas35 diapositivas
Mackay Bluewater Trail Projects por
Mackay Bluewater Trail Projects Mackay Bluewater Trail Projects
Mackay Bluewater Trail Projects guest387c76
374 vistas21 diapositivas
Flood Recovery: Lessons Learned Along the Way por
Flood Recovery: Lessons Learned Along the WayFlood Recovery: Lessons Learned Along the Way
Flood Recovery: Lessons Learned Along the WayCary Institute of Ecosystem Studies
430 vistas107 diapositivas

Similar a Practical solutions to barrier easement - Stuart Brabbs(20)

When Relationships Go Wrong - sea defences por Mark Ollis
When Relationships Go Wrong - sea defencesWhen Relationships Go Wrong - sea defences
When Relationships Go Wrong - sea defences
Mark Ollis498 vistas
Restoring Westmeadows Meander por Tony Smith
Restoring Westmeadows MeanderRestoring Westmeadows Meander
Restoring Westmeadows Meander
Tony Smith234 vistas
Mackay Bluewater Trail Projects por guest387c76
Mackay Bluewater Trail Projects Mackay Bluewater Trail Projects
Mackay Bluewater Trail Projects
guest387c76374 vistas
Styles_Phil_Geotech (long) 20151222 por Phil Styles
Styles_Phil_Geotech (long) 20151222Styles_Phil_Geotech (long) 20151222
Styles_Phil_Geotech (long) 20151222
Phil Styles233 vistas
Artificial Reef 2001 Anglers Club por Cindy Sullivan
Artificial Reef 2001 Anglers ClubArtificial Reef 2001 Anglers Club
Artificial Reef 2001 Anglers Club
Cindy Sullivan914 vistas
7. Energy sources ( Tidal energy( Ocean Energy) history ) A Series of Prese... por Mr.Allah Dad Khan
7. Energy sources  ( Tidal energy( Ocean Energy) history ) A  Series of Prese...7. Energy sources  ( Tidal energy( Ocean Energy) history ) A  Series of Prese...
7. Energy sources ( Tidal energy( Ocean Energy) history ) A Series of Prese...
Mr.Allah Dad Khan88 vistas
Shetland Court Outfall Restoration por Fairfax County
Shetland Court Outfall RestorationShetland Court Outfall Restoration
Shetland Court Outfall Restoration
Fairfax County129 vistas
Dannenbaum Engineering - River Update 9-19-2015 por law138
Dannenbaum Engineering - River Update 9-19-2015Dannenbaum Engineering - River Update 9-19-2015
Dannenbaum Engineering - River Update 9-19-2015
law1382.3K vistas
2008 04 Flooding: The Forecast Nick Lyness, Environment Agency por SevernEstuary
2008 04 Flooding: The Forecast Nick Lyness, Environment Agency 2008 04 Flooding: The Forecast Nick Lyness, Environment Agency
2008 04 Flooding: The Forecast Nick Lyness, Environment Agency
SevernEstuary329 vistas
Rainwater Harvesting Systems - Case Studies por D4Z
Rainwater Harvesting Systems - Case StudiesRainwater Harvesting Systems - Case Studies
Rainwater Harvesting Systems - Case Studies
D4Z3.5K vistas
Robert W. Fairbanks and Richard N. St. Jean, Coastal Shoreline Protection Usi... por riseagrant
Robert W. Fairbanks and Richard N. St. Jean, Coastal Shoreline Protection Usi...Robert W. Fairbanks and Richard N. St. Jean, Coastal Shoreline Protection Usi...
Robert W. Fairbanks and Richard N. St. Jean, Coastal Shoreline Protection Usi...
riseagrant2.9K vistas

Más de Scottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre

Wester Ross por
Wester RossWester Ross
Wester RossScottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre
38 vistas14 diapositivas
Galloway por
Galloway Galloway
Galloway Scottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre
40 vistas4 diapositivas
Kyle of Sutherland por
Kyle of SutherlandKyle of Sutherland
Kyle of SutherlandScottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre
37 vistas6 diapositivas
Ayrshire por
Ayrshire Ayrshire
Ayrshire Scottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre
44 vistas8 diapositivas
Deveron por
DeveronDeveron
DeveronScottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre
40 vistas13 diapositivas

Más de Scottish Fisheries Co Ordination Centre(20)

Último

Green Technology.pdf por
Green Technology.pdfGreen Technology.pdf
Green Technology.pdfrishithakre12
11 vistas38 diapositivas
Smart Homes por
Smart  HomesSmart  Homes
Smart HomesDr. Salem Baidas
30 vistas25 diapositivas
Urban Design for a Greener & Healthier City Antipolo City.pdf por
Urban Design for a Greener & Healthier City Antipolo City.pdfUrban Design for a Greener & Healthier City Antipolo City.pdf
Urban Design for a Greener & Healthier City Antipolo City.pdfPeraltaSheena1
6 vistas23 diapositivas
climate and the world por
climate and the worldclimate and the world
climate and the worldBasel Ahmed
32 vistas12 diapositivas
Endangered-Species (1).ppt por
Endangered-Species (1).pptEndangered-Species (1).ppt
Endangered-Species (1).pptEmilyRStraderYesterd
20 vistas18 diapositivas
A study of the causes of climate change - a master’s thesis in philosophy of ... por
A study of the causes of climate change - a master’s thesis in philosophy of ...A study of the causes of climate change - a master’s thesis in philosophy of ...
A study of the causes of climate change - a master’s thesis in philosophy of ...Piotr Gawlicki
7 vistas34 diapositivas

Último(20)

Urban Design for a Greener & Healthier City Antipolo City.pdf por PeraltaSheena1
Urban Design for a Greener & Healthier City Antipolo City.pdfUrban Design for a Greener & Healthier City Antipolo City.pdf
Urban Design for a Greener & Healthier City Antipolo City.pdf
PeraltaSheena16 vistas
climate and the world por Basel Ahmed
climate and the worldclimate and the world
climate and the world
Basel Ahmed32 vistas
A study of the causes of climate change - a master’s thesis in philosophy of ... por Piotr Gawlicki
A study of the causes of climate change - a master’s thesis in philosophy of ...A study of the causes of climate change - a master’s thesis in philosophy of ...
A study of the causes of climate change - a master’s thesis in philosophy of ...
Piotr Gawlicki7 vistas
Plantation Festival - Photo Journey.pdf por Anil G
Plantation Festival - Photo Journey.pdfPlantation Festival - Photo Journey.pdf
Plantation Festival - Photo Journey.pdf
Anil G5 vistas
Citizen science of the Great Barrier Reef and Coral Sea Expedition por Dr Adam Smith
Citizen science of the Great Barrier Reef and Coral Sea ExpeditionCitizen science of the Great Barrier Reef and Coral Sea Expedition
Citizen science of the Great Barrier Reef and Coral Sea Expedition
Dr Adam Smith40 vistas
Towards a just and regenerative aquaculture system por Martin Koehring
Towards a just and regenerative aquaculture systemTowards a just and regenerative aquaculture system
Towards a just and regenerative aquaculture system
Martin Koehring10 vistas
Impact of Climate Change on Groundwater Resources por C. P. Kumar
Impact of Climate Change on Groundwater ResourcesImpact of Climate Change on Groundwater Resources
Impact of Climate Change on Groundwater Resources
C. P. Kumar15 vistas
Green House Effect.pdf por DrHafizKosar
Green House Effect.pdfGreen House Effect.pdf
Green House Effect.pdf
DrHafizKosar72 vistas
Hydrology Project-Shiundu (Soft-copy ready).pdf por Ignatius Shiundu
Hydrology Project-Shiundu (Soft-copy ready).pdfHydrology Project-Shiundu (Soft-copy ready).pdf
Hydrology Project-Shiundu (Soft-copy ready).pdf
Ignatius Shiundu20 vistas

Practical solutions to barrier easement - Stuart Brabbs

  • 1. Practical solutions to barrier easement Stuart Brabbs Ayrshire Rivers Trust 1 Gibbsyard, Auchincruive Ayr KA6 5HW stuart@ayrshireriverstrust.org 01292 737300
  • 2. A technical solution but with hindsight, was it the best option? Cost £550K (including design, ground investigations, site clearance and construction) Other alternatives were considered and rejected including removal, partial removal and rock ramp
  • 5. Increased depth, reduced velocity Hagg Burn culvert prior to easement Concentrated flow to attract fish Installing oak Baffles
  • 6. Tulloch Burn/Gower Water (excellent habitat and water quality in the upper catchment) This barrier lies at the very top of the River Irvine catchment and consists of a steep bridge apron and natural waterfall that was modified by the roads department around 2008 (concrete and rock armour added). Since 2008 it has been impassable to salmonids.
  • 7. ART designed the fish pass and assisted contractors on site to ensure a flexible approach was taken. Trial and error achieved the end result. It still requires a bit of ‘tinkering’ here or there, but it’s certainly no worse than before.
  • 8. Trout were seen entering the fish pass this winter but no salmon. ART will monitor results over the next few years Two minor alterations will be completed this summer that should improve the performance
  • 9. The case of the incredible vanishing baulks
  • 10. Skeldon weir is passable. However a new hydro development in 2017 led to reduced flow over the weir. The developer applied to SEPA for permission to add timber baulks to assist salmonid migration (on our recommendation). This was granted. A local resident complained and SEPA instructed them to be removed
  • 11. Funding barrier easement is challenging when funding is lacking or unavailable. ART are creative and look for new ways to deliver results with limited budgets (or none on occasions). Here’s practical recycling at work!
  • 12. Taking a proven solution that originated in New Zealand, ART decided to attempt to make our own flexible baffles for use in a culvert (crucially at no cost). The aim was to prove the concept using a new material and three baffles were fabricated & installed temporarily to assess results (now removed until CAR issued)
  • 13. Bed cutting down after removing weir Redundant weir Pottery found in exposed substrates Grubbing it out
  • 14. A76 Culvert on the Glaisnock Water ART provided guidance to Scotland Transerve on fish passage at this culvert . They took our advice and installed simple concrete baffles to produce a fish pass. For the first time in 30 years, fish can again move upstream
  • 15. Top right: Another simple solution to assist migration over a weir Bottom: Pre assembling eel brushes to a HDPE backing board that will be bolted to a curved face on a dam
  • 16. Ness Falls on the Water of Coyle. A long term barrier to migration created when concrete was added to the crest of the falls to allow abstraction to power a sawmill ART have asked SEPA to prioritise this easement as it should open up over 25km of habitat to migratory salmonids ART estimate this barrier could be eased for around £5K