Se ha denunciado esta presentación.
Se está descargando tu SlideShare. ×

review on condition monitoring.docx

Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Anuncio
Cargando en…3
×

Eche un vistazo a continuación

1 de 6 Anuncio

Más Contenido Relacionado

Similares a review on condition monitoring.docx (20)

Anuncio

Más reciente (20)

review on condition monitoring.docx

  1. 1. 1.1 Introduction Machine condition monitoring is an important part of condition-based maintenance (CBM), which is becoming recognized as the most efficient strategy for carrying out maintenance in a wide variety of industries. Machines were originally ‘run to break’, which ensured maximum operating time between shutdowns, but meant that breakdowns were occasionally catastrophic, with serious consequences for safety, production loss and repair cost. The first response was ‘preventive maintenance’, where maintenance is carried out at intervals such that there is a very small likelihood of failure between repairs. However, this result in much greater use of spare parts, as well as more maintenance works than necessary. Condition monitoring of machinery is the measurement of various parameters related to the mechanical condition of the machinery (such as vibration, bearing temperature, oil pressure, oil debris, and performance), which makes it possible to determine whether the machinery is in good or bad mechanical condition. If the mechanical condition is bad, then condition monitoring makes it possible to determine the cause of the problem.1,2 Condition monitoring is used in conjunction with predictive maintenance, i.e., maintenance of machinery based on an indication that a problem is about to occur. In many plants predictive maintenance is replacing run-to-breakdown maintenance and preventive maintenance (in which mechanical parts are replaced periodically at fixed time intervals regardless of the machinery’s mechanical condition). Predictive maintenance of machinery:  Avoids unexpected catastrophic breakdowns with expensive or dangerous consequences.  Reduces the number of overhauls on machines to a minimum, thereby reducing maintenance costs.  Eliminates unnecessary interventions with the consequent risk of introducing faults on smoothly operating machines.  Allows spare parts to be ordered in time and thus eliminates costly inventories.  Reduces the intervention time, thereby minimizing production loss. Because the fault to be repaired is known in advance, overhauls can be scheduled when most convenient. This chapter describes the use of vibration measurements for monitoring the condition of machinery. Vibration is the parameter which can be used to predict the broadest range of faults in machinery most successfully. This description includes:  Selection of an appropriate type of monitoring system (permanent or periodic)  Establishment of a condition monitoring program  Fault detection  Spectrum interpretation and fault diagnosis  Special analysis techniques  Trend analysis  The use of computers in condition monitoring programs. Condition Monitoring Methods Condition monitoring is based on being able to monitor the current condition and predict the future condition of machines while in operation. Thus it means that information must be obtained externally about internal effects while the machines are in operation. The two main techniques for obtaining information about internal conditions are:
  2. 2. 1. Vibration Analysis. A machine in standard condition has a certain vibration signature. Fault development changes that signature in a way that can be related to the fault. This has given rise to the term ‘mechanical signature analysis’ [9]. 2. Lubricant Analysis. The lubricant also carries information from the inside to the outside of operating machines in the form of wear particles, chemical contaminants, and so on. Its use is mainly confined to circulating oil lubricating systems, although some analysis can be carried out on grease lubricants. Each of these is discussed in a little more detail in the following, along with a couple of other methods, performance analysis and thermography, that have more specialized applications. 1.3.1 Vibration Analysis Even in good condition, machines generate vibrations. Many such vibrations are directly linked to periodic events in the machine’s operation, such as rotating shafts, meshing gear teeth, rotating electric fields, and so on. The frequency with which such events repeat often gives a direct indication of the source and thus many powerful diagnostic techniques are based on frequency analysis. Some vibrations are due to events that are not completely phase locked to shaft rotations, such as combustion in IC (internal combustion) engines, but where a fixed number of combustion events occur each engine cycle, even though not completely repeatable. As will be seen, this can even be an advantage, as it allows such phenomena to be separated from perfectly periodic ones. Other vibrations are linked to fluid flow, as in pumps and gas turbines, and these also have particular, quite often unique, characteristics. The term ‘vibration’ can be interpreted in different ways, however, and one of the purposes of this chapter is to clarify the differences between them and the various transducers used to convert the vibration into electrical signals that can be recorded and analysed. One immediate difference is between the absolute vibration of machine housing and the relative vibration between a shaft and the housing, in particular where the bearing separating the two is a fluid film or journal bearing. Both types of vibration measurement are used extensively in machine condition monitoring, so it is important to understand the different information they provide. Another type of vibration which carries diagnostic information is torsional vibration, that is, angular velocity fluctuations of the shafts and components such as gears and rotor discs. All three types of vibration are discussed in this chapter, and the rest of the book is devoted to analysing the resulting vibration signals, though overwhelmingly from accelerometers (acceleration transducers) mounted on the machine casing. It should perhaps be mentioned that a related technique, based on measurement of acoustic emission (AE), has received some attention and is still being studied. The name derives from high-frequency solid-borne rather than airborne acoustic signals from developing cracks and other permanent deformation, bursts of stress waves being emitted as the crack grows, but not necessarily otherwise. The frequency range for metallic components is typically 100 kHz to 1MHz, this being detected by piezoelectric transducers attached to the surface. One of the first applications to machine diagnostics was to detection of cracks in rotor components (shafts and blades) in steam turbines, initiated by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) in the USA [10]. Even though EPRI claimed some success in detecting such faults on the external housing of fluid film bearings, the application does not appear to have been developed further. AE monitoring of gear fault development was reported in [11], where it was compared with vibration monitoring. The conclusion was that indications of crack initiation were occasionally detected a day earlier (in a 14 day test) than symptoms in the vibration signals, but the latter persisted because they were due to the presence of actual spalls, while the AE was only present during crack growth. Because of the extremely high sampling rate required for AE, huge amounts of data would have to be collected to
  3. 3. capture the rare burst events, unless recording were based on event triggering. In [12], AE signals are compared with vibration signals (and oil analysis) for gear fault diagnostics and prognostics, but the AE sensors had to be mounted on the rotating components and signals extracted via slip rings. Because of the difficulty of application of AE monitoring to machine condition monitoring, it is not discussed further in this book, although new developments may change the situation. 1.3.2 Oil Analysis This can once again be divided into a number of different categories: 1. Chip Detectors. Filters and magnetic plugs are designed to retain chips and other debris in circulating lubricant systems and these are analysed for quantity, type, shape, size, and so on. Alternatively, suspended particles can be detected in flow past a window. 2. Spectrographic Oil Analysis Procedures (SOAP). Here, the lubricant is sampled at regular intervals and subjected to spectrographic chemical analysis. Detection of trace elements can tell of wear of special materials such as alloying elements in special steels, white metal or bronze bearings, and so on. Another case applies to oil from engine crankcases, where the presence of water leaks can be indicated by a growth in NaCl or other chemicals coming from the cooling water. Oil analysis also includes analysis of wear debris, contaminants and additives, and measurement of viscosity and degradation. Simpler devices measure total iron content. 3. Ferrography. This represents the microscopic investigation and analysis of debris retained magnetically (hence the name) but which can contain non-magnetic particles caught up with the magnetic ones. Quantity, shape and size of the wear particles are all important factors in pointing to the type and location of failure. Successful use of oil analysis requires that oil sampling, changing and top-up procedures are all well defined and documented. It is much more difficult to apply lubricant analysis to grease lubricated machines, but grease sampling kits are now available to make the process more reliable. 1.3.3 Performance Analysis With certain types of machines, performance analysis (e.g. stage efficiency) is an effective way of determining whether a machine is functioning correctly. One example is given by reciprocating compressors, where changes in suction pressure can point to filter blockage, valve leakage could cause reductions in volumetric efficiency, and so on. Another is in gas turbine engines, where there are many permanently mounted transducers for process parameters such as temperatures, pressures and flow rates, and it is possible to calculate various efficiencies and compare them with the normal condition, so-called ‘flow path analysis’. With modern IC engine control systems, for example for diesel locos, electronic injection control means that the fuel supply to a particular cylinder can be cut off and the resulting drop in power compared with the theoretical. 1.3.4 Thermography Sensitive instruments are now available for remotely measuring even small temperature changes, in particular in comparison with a standard condition. At this time, thermography is used principally in quasi-static situations, such as with electrical switchboards, to detect local hot spots, and to detect faulty refractory linings in containers for hot fluids such as molten metal. So-called ‘hot box detectors’ have been used to detect faulty bearings in rail vehicles, by measuring the temperature of bearings on trains passing the wayside monitoring point. These are not very efficient, as they must not be separated by more than 50 km or so, because a substantial rise in temperature of a bearing only occurs in the last stages of life, essentially when ‘rolling’ elements are sliding. Monitoring based on vibration and/or acoustic measurements appears to give much more advance warning of impending failure.
  4. 4. 1.4 Types and Benefits of Vibration Analysis 1.4.1 Benefits Compared with Other Methods Vibration analysis is by far the most prevalent method for machine condition monitoring because it has a number of advantages compared with the other methods. It reacts immediately to change and can therefore be used for permanent as well as intermittent monitoring. With oil analysis for example, several days often elapse between the collection of samples and their analysis, although some online systems do exist. Also in comparison with oil analysis, vibration analysis is more likely to point to the actual faulty component, as many bearings, for example, will contain metals with the same chemical composition, whereas only the faulty one will exhibit increased vibration. Most importantly, many powerful signal processing techniques can be applied to vibration signals to extract even very weak fault indications from noise and other masking signals. REVIEW on literature survey GEORGE B. FOSTER “Recent Developments in Machine Vibration Monitoring”. Electronic vibration monitoring devices are spreading to a wide variety of industrial machinery applications. Present monitor designs are capable of predictive signalling of impending mechanical problems in many classes of prime movers and loads. The established limits of allowable vibration are in the process of change, both in units of measurement as well as values. Velocity measurement is gaining acceptance over mils and g units. Manufacturers of machinery are incorporating vibration levels into their warranty conditions. Noncontact devices for measuring shaft vibration are undergoing rapid development. Their need is well established in large journal bearing machines and holds promise for additional applications in axial turbine designs. Initial experience is being gained with computer trend monitoring. Coupled with procedures of mechanical impedance analysis, this data gives promise of achieving a greatly improved reliability factor in industrial process machinery, as well as permitting closer design of future equipment. 1986 P.A.L. Ham. “Trends and future scope in the monitoring of large steam turbine generators” Current practices in the monitoring of large steam turbine generators are briefly discussed, consideration being given to the traditional range of turbine supervisory equipment, and the more extended facilities which are sometimes now associated with rotating machinery, such as vibration monitoring, together with the more generalised data logging systems now specified by some Utilities. Consideration is given to the possible range of parameters and equipment areas which may now be incorporated into a monitoring scheme, and attention is drawn to the advances in display technology and operator interfaces which are now possible at moderate cost. In a concluding section, a range of monitoring functions which could be of wide general application in the field of steam turbine generators is discussed. 1993 Israel E. Alguindigue, Anna Loskiewicz-Buczak, and Robert E. Uhrig “Monitoring and Diagnosis of Rolling Element Bearings Using Artificial Neural Networks” Vibration monitoring of components in manufacturing plants involves the collection of vibration data from plant components and detailed analysis to detect features that reflect the operational state of the machinery. The analysis leads to the identification of potential failures and their causes and makes it possible to perform efficient preventive maintenance. This paper documents our work on the design of a vibration monitoring methodology for rolling element bearings (REB) based on neural network technology. This technology provides an attractive complement to traditional vibration analysis because of the potential
  5. 5. of neural networks to operate in real-time mode and to handle data that may be distorted or noisy. The significance of this work relies of the fact that REB failures are responsible for a large fraction of the malfunctions in manufacturing equipment. The technique enhances traditional vibration analysis and provides a means of automating the monitoring and diagnosis of vibrating equipment. 1999 Gary Y. Yen Kuo-Chung Lin “Wavelet Packet Feature Extraction for Vibration Monitoring”. Condition monitoring of dynamic systems based on vibration signatures has generally relied upon Fourier based analysis as a means of translating vibration signals in time domain into the frequency domain. However, Fourier analysis provided a poor representation of signals well localized in time. In this case, it is difficult to detect and identify the signal pattern from their expansion coefficients because the information is diluted across the whole basis. The wavelet packet transform is introduced as an alternative means of extracting time frequency information from vibration signature. Moreover, with the aid of statistical based feature selection criteria, a lot of feature components containing little discriminant information could be discarded resulting in a feature subset with reduced number of parameters. This significantly reduces the long training time that is often associated with neural network classifier and increases the generalization ability of the neural network classifier. 2004 Lingam Kanth “Preventive Maintenance of Spring Switchgear Applying Vibration Diagnostic Tool- A Malaysian Experience”. Broad ranges of spring switchgears have been extensively used in most of Malaysian substations. Condition monitoring of hydraulic and spring switchgears have been a critical problem since the conventional methods applied failed to alert prior occurrence of faults. Recent routine reports of TNB Malaysia highlight an occurrence of 20% failures over a period of 5 year. This has lead to greater loss and high expenditure in replacing these switchgears. One of the major contributing factors in failure of hydraulic switchgears is occurrence of mechanical faults, which the conventional method of monitoring failed to detect and locate. However the recent vibration testing prevents and minimizes the breakdowns due to mechanical faults. This current vibration analysis is a non-invasive diagnostic tool applied in comprehensive monitoring of HV switchgears. This method of investigation is well ventured in many countries in Europe and USA but not yet in Malaysia. TNB Malaysia is taking the stepping stone is venturing this technology in line with our objective of seeking predictive maintenance, cost effective and reliable diagnostic tool. This paper will explore in depth the possible mechanical faults that contribute to spring switchgears failures applying vibration analysis. This paper will further interpret the results of vibration testing on 118 spring switchgears 132 kV. This preliminary study involves interpreting the vibration signal during the event of close and open only to better understand the movement of the mechanical component during .operation time enabling us to distinguish which component contributes to the fault of the switchgear. 2005 E. F. Simas F., L. A. L. de Almeida and Antonio C. de C. Lima. “Vibration Monitoring of On-Load Tap Changers Using a Genetic Algorithm” On Load Tap Changers (OLTC) are widely used for voltage regulation in electricity networks. Non-invasive vibration methods for condition monitoring of internal electrical contacts have been recently proposed in the literature. The vibration signals emitted during the tap changes are usually recorded and post-processed using spectral analysis and some pattern classier technique. To reduce the complexity of the classier, a new technique based on Genetic Algorithm is proposed in this paper. A description of the data acquisition system and the corresponding collected experimental data are presented. The proposed technique is detailed and preliminary experimental results are discussed. 2006 Theodor D. Popescu “New Approach for Machine Vibration Analysis and health monitoring” The paper presents a new approach for machine vibration analysis and health monitoring combining blind source separation (BSS) and change detection in source signals. So, the problem is translated from the space of the measurements to the space of independent sources, where the reduced number of components will simplify the monitoring problem and where the change detection methods will be
  6. 6. applied for scalar signals. The approach has been tested in simulation and the assessment on a real machine is presented in the last part of the paper. 2007 John Demcko & John Velotta “Generator End Turn Vibration Monitoring a Case Study”. APS and WEC have long been exploiting both preventive and predictive maintenance technologies as a means of increasing generation reliability. This paper documents the dea1s of the successful application of one such technology, which facilitated operating both steam turbine generators (STGs) at Redhawk Power Plant through the summer 2003 peak as well as monitoring the performance of subsequent modifications. 2008 B. Sreejith, A.K. Verma and A. Srividya “Fault diagnosis of rolling element bearing using time- domain features and neural networks” Rolling element bearings are critical mechanical components in rotating machinery. Fault detection and diagnosis in the early stages of damage is necessary to prevent their malfunctioning and failure during operation. Vibration monitoring is the most widely used and cost-effective monitoring technique to detect, locate and distinguish faults in rolling element bearings. This paper presents an algorithm using feed forward neural network for automated diagnosis of localized faults in rolling element bearings. Normal negative log-likelihood value and kurtosis value extracted from time-domain vibration signals are used as input features for the neural network. Trained neural networks are able to classify different states of the bearing with 100% accuracy. The proposed procedure requires only a few input features, resulting in simple preprocessing and faster training. Effectiveness of the proposed method is illustrated using the bearing vibration data obtained experimentally. Pang Peilin, Ding Guangbin “Wavelet-based Diagnostic Model for Rotating Machinery Subject to Vibration Monitoring”. This paper proposes a new diagnosis method based on the wavelet transform with fuzzy theory in order to improve the limitation of applying traditional fault diagnosis method to the diagnosis of multi-concurrent vibrant faults of turbo-generator sets. To increase the signal-noise- ratio, a novel method based on the statistic rule is brought forward to determine the threshold of each order of wavelet space and the decomposition level adaptively. The binary discrete wavelet transform is used to acquire effective eigenvectors. The fuzzy diagnosis equation based on correlation matrix is used to classify the fault modes. The network structure is obtained by establishing the fault diagnosis model of turbo-generator set and using the improved least squares algorithm. Also the robustness of fault diagnosis equation is discussed in this paper. The faults are input into the trained diagnosis equation by means of choosing enough samples to train the fault diagnosis equation and the information representing. The type of fault can be determined according to the output result. The experiment results show that multi-concurrent fault for stator temperature fluctuation and rotor vibration can be diagnosed effectively by this new method and the diagnosis result is correct. M.Todd, S.D.J.McArthur, G.M.West, J.R.McDonald, S.J.Shaw. J.A.Hart “The design of a decision support system for the vibration monitoring of turbine generators”. Condition Monitoring (CM) systems monitor the health of expensive plant items such as turbine generators. They interpret turbine parameters by signalling an alarm when pre-defined limits are breached. Often these alarms have no further operational consequence but still require investigation by an expert. This is a time consuming and laborious process due to the volume of data interpreted for each alarm. In order to reduce the burden of alarm assessment, a Decision Support System (DSS) is proposed. The DSS will feature a Routine Alarm Assessment (RAA) module which provides an initial analysis of the alarms, highlighting those with no further operational consequence and enabling the expert to focus on those which indicate a genuine problem with the turbine. The structured approach taken to capture and document the expert knowledge on RAA along with the generation of a module specification and the selected IS techniques are outlined. The implementation of an RAA prototype is discussed along with how this will act as a foundation for a full alarm interpretation and fault diagnostic system.

×