SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 29
Causal pluralism and
medical diagnosis
Federica Russo
Philosophy & ILLC, University of Amsterdam
Science&Technology Studies, University College London
http://russofederica.wordpress.com | @federicarusso
Overview
• Phil Med
• From ethics to methodology (and back)
• Relocating evidence
• Evidential pluralism in the framework of causal pluralism
• The causal challenges of medical diagnosis: a causal mosaic approach
• Zoom in: technological construction of diagnostic tests
2
The scope of Phil Med
3
From ethics to methodology
Originally, Phil Med is about the ethical challenges arising in the field
Gradually, and since the early 2000s, Phil Med has opened up to
questions about methodology
As we speak, philosophers of science working on Medicine increasingly
discuss methodology and epistemology with ethics
4
A core question of
medical methodology
5
Causes and effects of health and disease
C causes E
Red meat consumption causes cancer
Breathing glyphosate causes cancer
Statins lower cholesterol
Exercising reduces cardiovascular disease
…
How do we know that?
What makes a causal claim true /versus/ What evidence supports a causal claim
6
Evidential pluralism
To establish a causal claim we need multiple sources of evidence:
That C makes a difference to E
Correlations, counterfactuals, …
That C produces E
Mechanisms, processes, …
A collaborative enterprise:
Russo & Williamson >> Clarke, Gillies, Illari, Russo, Williamson >> EBM+ >> …
Perspectives: historical, practical, underexplored areas (e.g. sport studies), …
7
Relocating
the debate on evidence
8
A plurality of causes
Phil Med in the Philosophy of Science in Practice tradition:
“medicine” in the broadest possible terms to include all clinical, scientific, and political
forms of engagement with health and disease”
“our medicine is a disunion, with the consequence that our definition might well
include forms of practice that not all would recognize as medicine in some more
restrictive way”
Epidodes of medical causation show that even if we can formulate a problem
as “Does C cause E?”, they rarely reduce to this exact formulation
How to make justise to the variety and diversity of ways of understanding,
studying, establishing causal relations in medicine?
9
The mosaic of causal theory
10
Causal pluralism
11
Causality cannot be reduced to one single concept
but has to be analysed using several concepts
5 philosophical questions
Metaphysics
What is causality? What kind of things are
causes and effects?
Semantics
What does it mean that A causes B?
Epistemology
What notions guide causal reasoning?
Methodology
How to establish whether A causes B? Or
how much of A causes B?
Use
What to do once we know that A causes B?
5 scientific problems
Inference
Does A cause B? To what extent?
Prediction
What to expect if A does (not) cause B?
Explanation
How does A cause or prevent B?
Control
What factors to hold fixed to study the
relation between A and B?
Reasoning
What considerations enter in establishing
whether / how / to what extent A causes B?
12
Use
Metaphysics
Semantics Epistemology
Methodology
13
The causal mosaic
14
Tiles for the Causal
Mosaic
…
necessary and sufficient;
levels; evidence;
probabilistic causality; counterfactuals;
manipulation and invariance; processes;
mechanisms; information; dispositions;
exogeneity; Simpson’s paradox;
regularity; variation;
action; inference;
validity; truth;
…
To be arranged by:
Philosophical Questions
Metaphysics, Semantics,
Epistemology, Methodology, Use
Scientific Problems
Inference, Prediction, Explanation,
Control, Reasoning
15
A causal mosaic
A picture made of tiles
Each tile has a role that
Is determined by the scientific problem / philosophical question it addresses
Stands in a relation with neighbouring concepts
A causal mosaic is dynamic, partly depends on scientists’ /
philosophers’ perspectives
16
What about medical diagnosis?
17
Causal challenge Description Philosophical Question Scientific Problem
levels of causation How to infer token causes of disease from
generic knowledge.
How to generate generic medical knowledge
from token instantiations of disease and
from population level data
Epistemology
Use
Reasoning (Abduction)
Inference
Control
types of causes How to explain disease using biological and
/ or social factors
Metaphysics Explanation
Control
causal narrative How to choose the most effective way to
explain disease
- from doctor’s perspective (diagnosis,
prognosis)
- from patient’s perspective (self diagnosis)
- from different worldview perspectives
(Western medicine vs Eastern vs indigenous
knowledge)
Epistemology
Metaphysics
Explanation
Prediction
Control
evidential pluralism How to select diagnostic tests and to
combine results of several diagnostic tests
Epistemology
Use
Inference
Explanation
Control
Reasoning
construction Diagnostic tests do not always give direct
epistemic access to the ‘disease’
phenomenon, but involve an element of
(technological) construction (e.g. x-rays,
FMRI, …)
Epistemology
Metaphysics
Inference
Reasoning
Explanation
definition of disease How to disentangle symptoms, causes,
effects …
Semantics
Metaphysics
Inference
Control
Reasoning 18
The construction of diagnosis
19
What nobody would disagree with
There is a whole range of diagnositc tests
Diagnositic tests involve analysis through instruments of various
degrees of sophistication
A simple termother
…
A Positron emission tomography
20
What we often forget
From the simple termomether to the sophisticated PET scan, diagnosis
involves elements of construction
Epistemic
Technological
21
The technological construction of diagnosis
Epistemology, Metaphysics
Gathering evidence to establish some
causal claim
Confront symptoms and evidence with
generic medical knowledge
What causes disease
Inference, reasoning, explanation
Inferring causes from effects
Inferring causal relations in the single
case from generic medical knowledge /
protocols
Supporting causal reasoning with
evidence
Explaining symptoms
22
Why does it matter?
23
Recalibrating certainty
How certain are scientific claims / results?
And for the matter, claims about diagnosis
How to walk the thin line between
We know that we can’t claim absolute certainty (see history of science)
We do have some basis to make decision and take action (however fallible and
uncertain)
24
Returning the argument on its head?
Phil Sci / Phil Med
Instead of talking about certaining, the ‘best’ evidence, ‘gold standards’
Consider:
How fragile is evidence and causal reasoning? What makes it so fragile? Can we distinguish
proper epistemic from sociological reasons for this fragility? …
Where to make this narrative shift?
Phil Sci / Phil Med
Science and Medicine
Doctor – Patient communication
Schools
25
Rethinking doctor-patient communication
Convey the idea of construction, to give a sense of the difficulty of coming up with
diagnosis
See e.g. work by Annamaria Carusi & collaborators, studying interdisciplinary groups in
hospitals examining diagnostic tests
Relatedly, descronstruct the idea of certainty and of direct epistemic access to the
causes of disease and illness
Lots of work ahead for Phil Sci and Phil Tech
Regain a holistic understanding of the aetiology of health and disease
The diagnostic tests may explain part of the aetiology (the biological one), but certainly not the
whole of socio-cultural part
26
In sum
27
Medical diagnosis is a fascinating and underexplored area in Phil Med
Medical diagnosis is a multifaceted form of inference from effects to
causes
By adopting the pluralistic approach of causal mosaic we can study
many of these dimensions, moving freely across ontological and
epistemological levels
By detailing the ways in which inference and reasoning are
(technologically) constructed, we are invited to re-think doctor-patient
communication, inter alia
28
Causal pluralism and
medical diagnosis
Federica Russo
Philosophy & ILLC, University of Amsterdam
Science&Technology Studies, University College London
http://russofederica.wordpress.com | @federicarusso
Thanks for your
attention!

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Causal pluralism and medical diagnosis

Barriers To Evidence-Based Practices
Barriers To Evidence-Based PracticesBarriers To Evidence-Based Practices
Barriers To Evidence-Based PracticesKatrina Green
 
Epistemic lenses and virtues, beyond evidence-based medicine
Epistemic lenses and virtues, beyond evidence-based medicine Epistemic lenses and virtues, beyond evidence-based medicine
Epistemic lenses and virtues, beyond evidence-based medicine CILIP
 
ARTÍCULO_Epidemiology the foundation of public health (Inglés) autor Roger De...
ARTÍCULO_Epidemiology the foundation of public health (Inglés) autor Roger De...ARTÍCULO_Epidemiology the foundation of public health (Inglés) autor Roger De...
ARTÍCULO_Epidemiology the foundation of public health (Inglés) autor Roger De...Hilda Santos Padrón
 
Is Cranberry Juice Effective For Preventing And Treating...
Is Cranberry Juice Effective For Preventing And Treating...Is Cranberry Juice Effective For Preventing And Treating...
Is Cranberry Juice Effective For Preventing And Treating...Kelly Lindemann
 
Metaphors to Think about Technological Tools and Patients Care in Family Medi...
Metaphors to Think about Technological Tools and Patients Care in Family Medi...Metaphors to Think about Technological Tools and Patients Care in Family Medi...
Metaphors to Think about Technological Tools and Patients Care in Family Medi...CrimsonpublishersMedical
 

Similar a Causal pluralism and medical diagnosis (20)

Russo Madrid Medicine Oct07
Russo Madrid Medicine Oct07Russo Madrid Medicine Oct07
Russo Madrid Medicine Oct07
 
Barriers To Evidence-Based Practices
Barriers To Evidence-Based PracticesBarriers To Evidence-Based Practices
Barriers To Evidence-Based Practices
 
Introduction to research
Introduction to researchIntroduction to research
Introduction to research
 
Russo bielefed dec11
Russo bielefed dec11Russo bielefed dec11
Russo bielefed dec11
 
Research methodology
Research methodology Research methodology
Research methodology
 
Epistemic lenses and virtues, beyond evidence-based medicine
Epistemic lenses and virtues, beyond evidence-based medicine Epistemic lenses and virtues, beyond evidence-based medicine
Epistemic lenses and virtues, beyond evidence-based medicine
 
The mosaic of causal theory
The mosaic of causal theoryThe mosaic of causal theory
The mosaic of causal theory
 
On the political dimension of scientific evidence
On the political dimension of scientific evidenceOn the political dimension of scientific evidence
On the political dimension of scientific evidence
 
On the political dimension of scientific evidence
On the political dimension of scientific evidenceOn the political dimension of scientific evidence
On the political dimension of scientific evidence
 
Phil med kings
Phil med kingsPhil med kings
Phil med kings
 
ARTÍCULO_Epidemiology the foundation of public health (Inglés) autor Roger De...
ARTÍCULO_Epidemiology the foundation of public health (Inglés) autor Roger De...ARTÍCULO_Epidemiology the foundation of public health (Inglés) autor Roger De...
ARTÍCULO_Epidemiology the foundation of public health (Inglés) autor Roger De...
 
Is Cranberry Juice Effective For Preventing And Treating...
Is Cranberry Juice Effective For Preventing And Treating...Is Cranberry Juice Effective For Preventing And Treating...
Is Cranberry Juice Effective For Preventing And Treating...
 
Evidence and causality in the social and medical sciences
Evidence and causality in the social and medical sciencesEvidence and causality in the social and medical sciences
Evidence and causality in the social and medical sciences
 
What kind of thing is a biomarker?
What kind of thing is a biomarker?What kind of thing is a biomarker?
What kind of thing is a biomarker?
 
Productive causality in technoscientific research
Productive causality in technoscientific researchProductive causality in technoscientific research
Productive causality in technoscientific research
 
Russo Variation Epidemiology
Russo Variation EpidemiologyRusso Variation Epidemiology
Russo Variation Epidemiology
 
Many ways to say cause
Many ways to say causeMany ways to say cause
Many ways to say cause
 
An Informational Approach to Evidence
An Informational Approach to EvidenceAn Informational Approach to Evidence
An Informational Approach to Evidence
 
Causality Epidemiology
Causality EpidemiologyCausality Epidemiology
Causality Epidemiology
 
Metaphors to Think about Technological Tools and Patients Care in Family Medi...
Metaphors to Think about Technological Tools and Patients Care in Family Medi...Metaphors to Think about Technological Tools and Patients Care in Family Medi...
Metaphors to Think about Technological Tools and Patients Care in Family Medi...
 

Más de University of Amsterdam and University College London

Más de University of Amsterdam and University College London (20)

Socio-markers and information transmission
Socio-markers and information transmissionSocio-markers and information transmission
Socio-markers and information transmission
 
Disease causation and public health interventions
Disease causation and public health interventionsDisease causation and public health interventions
Disease causation and public health interventions
 
The life-world of health and disease and the design of public health interven...
The life-world of health and disease and the design of public health interven...The life-world of health and disease and the design of public health interven...
The life-world of health and disease and the design of public health interven...
 
Towards and epistemological and ethical XAI
Towards and epistemological and ethical XAITowards and epistemological and ethical XAI
Towards and epistemological and ethical XAI
 
Value-promoting concepts in the health sciences and public health
Value-promoting concepts in the health sciences and public healthValue-promoting concepts in the health sciences and public health
Value-promoting concepts in the health sciences and public health
 
Connecting the epistemology and ethics of AI
Connecting the epistemology and ethics of AIConnecting the epistemology and ethics of AI
Connecting the epistemology and ethics of AI
 
How is Who. Empowering evidence for sustainability and public health interven...
How is Who. Empowering evidence for sustainability and public health interven...How is Who. Empowering evidence for sustainability and public health interven...
How is Who. Empowering evidence for sustainability and public health interven...
 
High technologized justice – The road map for policy & regulation. Legaltech ...
High technologized justice – The road map for policy & regulation. Legaltech ...High technologized justice – The road map for policy & regulation. Legaltech ...
High technologized justice – The road map for policy & regulation. Legaltech ...
 
Connecting the epistemology and ethics of AI
Connecting the epistemology and ethics of AIConnecting the epistemology and ethics of AI
Connecting the epistemology and ethics of AI
 
Science and values. A two-way relations
Science and values. A two-way relationsScience and values. A two-way relations
Science and values. A two-way relations
 
How is Who. Evidence as clues for action in participatory approaches.
How is Who. Evidence as clues for action in participatory approaches.How is Who. Evidence as clues for action in participatory approaches.
How is Who. Evidence as clues for action in participatory approaches.
 
Poiêsis. How human and artificial agents co-produce techno-scientific knowledge
Poiêsis. How human and artificial agents co-produce techno-scientific knowledgePoiêsis. How human and artificial agents co-produce techno-scientific knowledge
Poiêsis. How human and artificial agents co-produce techno-scientific knowledge
 
Towards a Philosophy of Techno-Science
Towards a Philosophy of Techno-ScienceTowards a Philosophy of Techno-Science
Towards a Philosophy of Techno-Science
 
Book presentation ‘Techno-Scientific Practices’
Book presentation ‘Techno-Scientific Practices’Book presentation ‘Techno-Scientific Practices’
Book presentation ‘Techno-Scientific Practices’
 
Causality and empirical methods in the social sciences
Causality and empirical methods in the social sciencesCausality and empirical methods in the social sciences
Causality and empirical methods in the social sciences
 
The epistemic values at work in epidemiology and public health
The epistemic values at work in epidemiology and public healthThe epistemic values at work in epidemiology and public health
The epistemic values at work in epidemiology and public health
 
The ‘lifeworld’ of health & disease and the design of public health intervent...
The ‘lifeworld’ of health & disease and the design of public health intervent...The ‘lifeworld’ of health & disease and the design of public health intervent...
The ‘lifeworld’ of health & disease and the design of public health intervent...
 
Information transmission and the mosaic of causal theory
Information transmission and the mosaic of causal theoryInformation transmission and the mosaic of causal theory
Information transmission and the mosaic of causal theory
 
Teaching Philosophy of Science and Technology. Some reflections on how to mak...
Teaching Philosophy of Science and Technology. Some reflections on how to mak...Teaching Philosophy of Science and Technology. Some reflections on how to mak...
Teaching Philosophy of Science and Technology. Some reflections on how to mak...
 
Causality in the sciences: the conceptual toolbox for organisational diagnosis
Causality in the sciences: the conceptual toolbox for organisational diagnosisCausality in the sciences: the conceptual toolbox for organisational diagnosis
Causality in the sciences: the conceptual toolbox for organisational diagnosis
 

Último

How to Use api.constrains ( ) in Odoo 17
How to Use api.constrains ( ) in Odoo 17How to Use api.constrains ( ) in Odoo 17
How to Use api.constrains ( ) in Odoo 17Celine George
 
P4C x ELT = P4ELT: Its Theoretical Background (Kanazawa, 2024 March).pdf
P4C x ELT = P4ELT: Its Theoretical Background (Kanazawa, 2024 March).pdfP4C x ELT = P4ELT: Its Theoretical Background (Kanazawa, 2024 March).pdf
P4C x ELT = P4ELT: Its Theoretical Background (Kanazawa, 2024 March).pdfYu Kanazawa / Osaka University
 
The basics of sentences session 10pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 10pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 10pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 10pptx.pptxheathfieldcps1
 
How to Manage Cross-Selling in Odoo 17 Sales
How to Manage Cross-Selling in Odoo 17 SalesHow to Manage Cross-Selling in Odoo 17 Sales
How to Manage Cross-Selling in Odoo 17 SalesCeline George
 
Clinical Pharmacy Introduction to Clinical Pharmacy, Concept of clinical pptx
Clinical Pharmacy  Introduction to Clinical Pharmacy, Concept of clinical pptxClinical Pharmacy  Introduction to Clinical Pharmacy, Concept of clinical pptx
Clinical Pharmacy Introduction to Clinical Pharmacy, Concept of clinical pptxraviapr7
 
The Singapore Teaching Practice document
The Singapore Teaching Practice documentThe Singapore Teaching Practice document
The Singapore Teaching Practice documentXsasf Sfdfasd
 
Benefits & Challenges of Inclusive Education
Benefits & Challenges of Inclusive EducationBenefits & Challenges of Inclusive Education
Benefits & Challenges of Inclusive EducationMJDuyan
 
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptxEducation and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptxraviapr7
 
In - Vivo and In - Vitro Correlation.pptx
In - Vivo and In - Vitro Correlation.pptxIn - Vivo and In - Vitro Correlation.pptx
In - Vivo and In - Vitro Correlation.pptxAditiChauhan701637
 
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdfDiploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdfMohonDas
 
Philosophy of Education and Educational Philosophy
Philosophy of Education  and Educational PhilosophyPhilosophy of Education  and Educational Philosophy
Philosophy of Education and Educational PhilosophyShuvankar Madhu
 
Quality Assurance_GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICE
Quality Assurance_GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICEQuality Assurance_GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICE
Quality Assurance_GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICESayali Powar
 
Ultra structure and life cycle of Plasmodium.pptx
Ultra structure and life cycle of Plasmodium.pptxUltra structure and life cycle of Plasmodium.pptx
Ultra structure and life cycle of Plasmodium.pptxDr. Asif Anas
 
UKCGE Parental Leave Discussion March 2024
UKCGE Parental Leave Discussion March 2024UKCGE Parental Leave Discussion March 2024
UKCGE Parental Leave Discussion March 2024UKCGE
 
AUDIENCE THEORY -- FANDOM -- JENKINS.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY -- FANDOM -- JENKINS.pptxAUDIENCE THEORY -- FANDOM -- JENKINS.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY -- FANDOM -- JENKINS.pptxiammrhaywood
 
How to Add a many2many Relational Field in Odoo 17
How to Add a many2many Relational Field in Odoo 17How to Add a many2many Relational Field in Odoo 17
How to Add a many2many Relational Field in Odoo 17Celine George
 
M-2- General Reactions of amino acids.pptx
M-2- General Reactions of amino acids.pptxM-2- General Reactions of amino acids.pptx
M-2- General Reactions of amino acids.pptxDr. Santhosh Kumar. N
 
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17Celine George
 
Practical Research 1 Lesson 9 Scope and delimitation.pptx
Practical Research 1 Lesson 9 Scope and delimitation.pptxPractical Research 1 Lesson 9 Scope and delimitation.pptx
Practical Research 1 Lesson 9 Scope and delimitation.pptxKatherine Villaluna
 

Último (20)

How to Use api.constrains ( ) in Odoo 17
How to Use api.constrains ( ) in Odoo 17How to Use api.constrains ( ) in Odoo 17
How to Use api.constrains ( ) in Odoo 17
 
P4C x ELT = P4ELT: Its Theoretical Background (Kanazawa, 2024 March).pdf
P4C x ELT = P4ELT: Its Theoretical Background (Kanazawa, 2024 March).pdfP4C x ELT = P4ELT: Its Theoretical Background (Kanazawa, 2024 March).pdf
P4C x ELT = P4ELT: Its Theoretical Background (Kanazawa, 2024 March).pdf
 
The basics of sentences session 10pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 10pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 10pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 10pptx.pptx
 
How to Manage Cross-Selling in Odoo 17 Sales
How to Manage Cross-Selling in Odoo 17 SalesHow to Manage Cross-Selling in Odoo 17 Sales
How to Manage Cross-Selling in Odoo 17 Sales
 
Clinical Pharmacy Introduction to Clinical Pharmacy, Concept of clinical pptx
Clinical Pharmacy  Introduction to Clinical Pharmacy, Concept of clinical pptxClinical Pharmacy  Introduction to Clinical Pharmacy, Concept of clinical pptx
Clinical Pharmacy Introduction to Clinical Pharmacy, Concept of clinical pptx
 
The Singapore Teaching Practice document
The Singapore Teaching Practice documentThe Singapore Teaching Practice document
The Singapore Teaching Practice document
 
Benefits & Challenges of Inclusive Education
Benefits & Challenges of Inclusive EducationBenefits & Challenges of Inclusive Education
Benefits & Challenges of Inclusive Education
 
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptxEducation and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
 
In - Vivo and In - Vitro Correlation.pptx
In - Vivo and In - Vitro Correlation.pptxIn - Vivo and In - Vitro Correlation.pptx
In - Vivo and In - Vitro Correlation.pptx
 
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdfDiploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
 
Personal Resilience in Project Management 2 - TV Edit 1a.pdf
Personal Resilience in Project Management 2 - TV Edit 1a.pdfPersonal Resilience in Project Management 2 - TV Edit 1a.pdf
Personal Resilience in Project Management 2 - TV Edit 1a.pdf
 
Philosophy of Education and Educational Philosophy
Philosophy of Education  and Educational PhilosophyPhilosophy of Education  and Educational Philosophy
Philosophy of Education and Educational Philosophy
 
Quality Assurance_GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICE
Quality Assurance_GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICEQuality Assurance_GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICE
Quality Assurance_GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICE
 
Ultra structure and life cycle of Plasmodium.pptx
Ultra structure and life cycle of Plasmodium.pptxUltra structure and life cycle of Plasmodium.pptx
Ultra structure and life cycle of Plasmodium.pptx
 
UKCGE Parental Leave Discussion March 2024
UKCGE Parental Leave Discussion March 2024UKCGE Parental Leave Discussion March 2024
UKCGE Parental Leave Discussion March 2024
 
AUDIENCE THEORY -- FANDOM -- JENKINS.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY -- FANDOM -- JENKINS.pptxAUDIENCE THEORY -- FANDOM -- JENKINS.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY -- FANDOM -- JENKINS.pptx
 
How to Add a many2many Relational Field in Odoo 17
How to Add a many2many Relational Field in Odoo 17How to Add a many2many Relational Field in Odoo 17
How to Add a many2many Relational Field in Odoo 17
 
M-2- General Reactions of amino acids.pptx
M-2- General Reactions of amino acids.pptxM-2- General Reactions of amino acids.pptx
M-2- General Reactions of amino acids.pptx
 
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
 
Practical Research 1 Lesson 9 Scope and delimitation.pptx
Practical Research 1 Lesson 9 Scope and delimitation.pptxPractical Research 1 Lesson 9 Scope and delimitation.pptx
Practical Research 1 Lesson 9 Scope and delimitation.pptx
 

Causal pluralism and medical diagnosis

  • 1. Causal pluralism and medical diagnosis Federica Russo Philosophy & ILLC, University of Amsterdam Science&Technology Studies, University College London http://russofederica.wordpress.com | @federicarusso
  • 2. Overview • Phil Med • From ethics to methodology (and back) • Relocating evidence • Evidential pluralism in the framework of causal pluralism • The causal challenges of medical diagnosis: a causal mosaic approach • Zoom in: technological construction of diagnostic tests 2
  • 3. The scope of Phil Med 3
  • 4. From ethics to methodology Originally, Phil Med is about the ethical challenges arising in the field Gradually, and since the early 2000s, Phil Med has opened up to questions about methodology As we speak, philosophers of science working on Medicine increasingly discuss methodology and epistemology with ethics 4
  • 5. A core question of medical methodology 5
  • 6. Causes and effects of health and disease C causes E Red meat consumption causes cancer Breathing glyphosate causes cancer Statins lower cholesterol Exercising reduces cardiovascular disease … How do we know that? What makes a causal claim true /versus/ What evidence supports a causal claim 6
  • 7. Evidential pluralism To establish a causal claim we need multiple sources of evidence: That C makes a difference to E Correlations, counterfactuals, … That C produces E Mechanisms, processes, … A collaborative enterprise: Russo & Williamson >> Clarke, Gillies, Illari, Russo, Williamson >> EBM+ >> … Perspectives: historical, practical, underexplored areas (e.g. sport studies), … 7
  • 9. A plurality of causes Phil Med in the Philosophy of Science in Practice tradition: “medicine” in the broadest possible terms to include all clinical, scientific, and political forms of engagement with health and disease” “our medicine is a disunion, with the consequence that our definition might well include forms of practice that not all would recognize as medicine in some more restrictive way” Epidodes of medical causation show that even if we can formulate a problem as “Does C cause E?”, they rarely reduce to this exact formulation How to make justise to the variety and diversity of ways of understanding, studying, establishing causal relations in medicine? 9
  • 10. The mosaic of causal theory 10
  • 11. Causal pluralism 11 Causality cannot be reduced to one single concept but has to be analysed using several concepts
  • 12. 5 philosophical questions Metaphysics What is causality? What kind of things are causes and effects? Semantics What does it mean that A causes B? Epistemology What notions guide causal reasoning? Methodology How to establish whether A causes B? Or how much of A causes B? Use What to do once we know that A causes B? 5 scientific problems Inference Does A cause B? To what extent? Prediction What to expect if A does (not) cause B? Explanation How does A cause or prevent B? Control What factors to hold fixed to study the relation between A and B? Reasoning What considerations enter in establishing whether / how / to what extent A causes B? 12
  • 15. Tiles for the Causal Mosaic … necessary and sufficient; levels; evidence; probabilistic causality; counterfactuals; manipulation and invariance; processes; mechanisms; information; dispositions; exogeneity; Simpson’s paradox; regularity; variation; action; inference; validity; truth; … To be arranged by: Philosophical Questions Metaphysics, Semantics, Epistemology, Methodology, Use Scientific Problems Inference, Prediction, Explanation, Control, Reasoning 15
  • 16. A causal mosaic A picture made of tiles Each tile has a role that Is determined by the scientific problem / philosophical question it addresses Stands in a relation with neighbouring concepts A causal mosaic is dynamic, partly depends on scientists’ / philosophers’ perspectives 16
  • 17. What about medical diagnosis? 17
  • 18. Causal challenge Description Philosophical Question Scientific Problem levels of causation How to infer token causes of disease from generic knowledge. How to generate generic medical knowledge from token instantiations of disease and from population level data Epistemology Use Reasoning (Abduction) Inference Control types of causes How to explain disease using biological and / or social factors Metaphysics Explanation Control causal narrative How to choose the most effective way to explain disease - from doctor’s perspective (diagnosis, prognosis) - from patient’s perspective (self diagnosis) - from different worldview perspectives (Western medicine vs Eastern vs indigenous knowledge) Epistemology Metaphysics Explanation Prediction Control evidential pluralism How to select diagnostic tests and to combine results of several diagnostic tests Epistemology Use Inference Explanation Control Reasoning construction Diagnostic tests do not always give direct epistemic access to the ‘disease’ phenomenon, but involve an element of (technological) construction (e.g. x-rays, FMRI, …) Epistemology Metaphysics Inference Reasoning Explanation definition of disease How to disentangle symptoms, causes, effects … Semantics Metaphysics Inference Control Reasoning 18
  • 19. The construction of diagnosis 19
  • 20. What nobody would disagree with There is a whole range of diagnositc tests Diagnositic tests involve analysis through instruments of various degrees of sophistication A simple termother … A Positron emission tomography 20
  • 21. What we often forget From the simple termomether to the sophisticated PET scan, diagnosis involves elements of construction Epistemic Technological 21
  • 22. The technological construction of diagnosis Epistemology, Metaphysics Gathering evidence to establish some causal claim Confront symptoms and evidence with generic medical knowledge What causes disease Inference, reasoning, explanation Inferring causes from effects Inferring causal relations in the single case from generic medical knowledge / protocols Supporting causal reasoning with evidence Explaining symptoms 22
  • 23. Why does it matter? 23
  • 24. Recalibrating certainty How certain are scientific claims / results? And for the matter, claims about diagnosis How to walk the thin line between We know that we can’t claim absolute certainty (see history of science) We do have some basis to make decision and take action (however fallible and uncertain) 24
  • 25. Returning the argument on its head? Phil Sci / Phil Med Instead of talking about certaining, the ‘best’ evidence, ‘gold standards’ Consider: How fragile is evidence and causal reasoning? What makes it so fragile? Can we distinguish proper epistemic from sociological reasons for this fragility? … Where to make this narrative shift? Phil Sci / Phil Med Science and Medicine Doctor – Patient communication Schools 25
  • 26. Rethinking doctor-patient communication Convey the idea of construction, to give a sense of the difficulty of coming up with diagnosis See e.g. work by Annamaria Carusi & collaborators, studying interdisciplinary groups in hospitals examining diagnostic tests Relatedly, descronstruct the idea of certainty and of direct epistemic access to the causes of disease and illness Lots of work ahead for Phil Sci and Phil Tech Regain a holistic understanding of the aetiology of health and disease The diagnostic tests may explain part of the aetiology (the biological one), but certainly not the whole of socio-cultural part 26
  • 28. Medical diagnosis is a fascinating and underexplored area in Phil Med Medical diagnosis is a multifaceted form of inference from effects to causes By adopting the pluralistic approach of causal mosaic we can study many of these dimensions, moving freely across ontological and epistemological levels By detailing the ways in which inference and reasoning are (technologically) constructed, we are invited to re-think doctor-patient communication, inter alia 28
  • 29. Causal pluralism and medical diagnosis Federica Russo Philosophy & ILLC, University of Amsterdam Science&Technology Studies, University College London http://russofederica.wordpress.com | @federicarusso Thanks for your attention!

Notas del editor

  1. Here sketch the way the philosophical debate has framed questions about causality, i.e. in terms of truth of causal claims. One shift consists in looking at the *evidence* that support said claims, rather than their truth. This doesn’t mean that questions about truth are dismissed, rather they are reconceptualised (but I will not discuss in the talk, I leave it to Q&A). If needed, background of this shift: see Illari and Russo 2014
  2. Present evidential pluralism. An epistemological thesis. Surely, metaphysical implications (but here these are orthogonal to the argument). Instead: the epistemological thesis has, arguably, direct bearing on methods for causal assessment and for decision making. Highlight: The collaboration grew (Russo & Williamson >> Clarke, Gillies, Illari, Russo, Williamson >> AHRC project Evaluating Evidence in Medicine) Consequently, the project also grew in terms of interests, perspectives, case studies, etc Some perspectives are more historically oriented (e.g. Gillies), others more practically oriented (see e.g. Kelly, former director of NICE, UK; Straif, current head of IARC monographs )