SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
MANAGING ORGANIZATIONS

            Session 13: Organizational Change




                                                Sourav Mukherji
PGP 2012-14 Section C & E
                                                Associate Professor of Organization & Strategy
Term 1:June-September 2012                      Indian Institute of Management Bangalore, India
2
REVISITING APPEX CORPORATION




  Why did Shikhar Ghosh make so many structural changes in Apex Corporation ?
  Were all the changes in structure necessary ?
  What did he achieve or fail to achieve with so many changes ?




                                                                © S Mukherji
3
STRUCTURAL CHANGES AT VFM SOLUTIONS




   If VFM solution decides to sell computers to corporate customers
        (option 1), what kind of change should it bring about in its
        organization structure ?




                                                            © S Mukherji
4
CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 1

                   VIKAS




      MANISH                    FRANCIS


                                     PARTHA




                             SOHO             CALL
                             SALES            CENTRE




                                                       © S Mukherji
5
CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 1

                   VIKAS




       MANISH                    FRANCIS



                                     PARTHA
                                                       NEW
                                                       APPOINTEE


                                                                   CORPORATE
                                                                   SALES

                             SOHO             CALL
                             SALES            CENTRE




                                                           © S Mukherji
6
CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 2

                   VIKAS




       MANISH                    FRANCIS



                                     PARTHA            NEW APPOINTEE



                                                                  CORPORATE
                                                                  SALES



                             SOHO             CALL
                             SALES            CENTRE




                                                             © S Mukherji
7
CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 3

                   VIKAS




       MANISH                    FRANCIS



                                NEW APPOINTEE     PARTHA



                                                           CORPORATE
                                                           SALES



                             SOHO        CALL
                             SALES       CENTRE




                                                     © S Mukherji
8
CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 4

                   VIKAS




       MANISH                    FRANCIS


                                                       NEW
                                     PARTHA            APPOINTEE


                                                                   CORPORATE
                                                                   SALES



                             SOHO             CALL
                             SALES            CENTRE




                                                           © S Mukherji
9
CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 5                      ADVANTAGES
                                               1. No senior level appointment
                                                  Less risky, less resources
                  VIKAS                        2. Using existing resources, knowledge
                                               3. Promotion for Partha
                                                  Succession planning



     MANISH                       FRANCIS       DOUBTS / CHALLENGES

                                                1. Is Partha ready for this role yet ?
                                                2. Does he need to be trained ?
                                                3. What is the size of opportunity ?
                                   PARTHA
                                                4. Will the new opportunity get
                                                   adequate focus from VFM ?




                          SOHO      CALL     CORPORATE
                          SALES     CENTRE   SALES


                                                              © S Mukherji
THREE DIMENSIONS FOR CONSIDERATION                                                        10

DURING STRUCTURAL CHANGES

 1   Strategic Objective   • What is the size of proposed business ?
                           • How does the proposed change enable / facilitate
                             the objective of the organization / business unit
                           • Is the change consistent with business objective ?


                           • What are the interdependencies with current job ?
                             Are there any conflict of interests ?
 2    Job Content            Are there complementarities ?
                           • Can the new job be done through existing set of
                             skill sets and competencies ?
                           • What is the extent of education and training necessary
                             for existing employees to make this transition ?


                           • Have we addressed the aspirations and apprehensions
 3   Human dimension of
                              of existing employees ?
     change                • Has there been adequate communication to set expectations?
                           • What are the implications for political and informal
                              relations in the organization ?
                           • What is likely to be the relationship between new recruits
                             and existing employees of the organization ?



                                                                       © S Mukherji
11
SERVICES – VARIOUS OPTIONS

                    VIKAS




       MANISH                    FRANCIS



                                     PARTHA


                                                       SERVICE
                                                       MANAGERS


                                                                  SERVICE
                             SOHO             CALL                ENGINEERS
                             SALES            CENTRE




                                                           © S Mukherji
12
SERVICES – VIABLE OPTION ?                                     ADVANTAGES
                                                              1. Less conflict of interest
                                                              2. Similar nature of job / role
                            VIKAS                             3. Manish has capacity to take
                                                                additional responsibility




       MANISH                           FRANCIS                DOUBTS / CHALLENGES

                                                               1. Integration between sales
                                                                  & service
                                                               2. Conflict resolution
                                            PARTHA




                                    SOHO             CALL
                        SERVICE
                                    SALES            CENTRE
                        MANAGERS

                SERVICE
                ENGINEERS



                                                                             © S Mukherji
13
A PROCESS MODEL OF ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE


                                       Integrate as regular
                                       organizational practices
               INSTITUTIONALIZATION    Evaluate, monitor impact
                                       Fine tuning
                                       Refreeze

 Level of                              Planning specific steps
 Support for   IMPLEMENTATION          Identify change agents
 Change                                Identify potential resistance
                                       Address apprehensions
                                       Preparation for hardships

               PREPARATION             Creating the need for change
                                       Unfreeze
                                       Disturbing the status quo



                          Time




                                              © S Mukherji
14
ORGANIZATIONS AND INDIVIDUALS SEEM TO RESIST CHANGE
                                             INTERDEPENDENT
                                             SUBSYSTEMS
                                                          STRUCTURAL
                                                          INERTIA
  SECURITY /               HABIT
  ECONOMIC FACTORS                  GROUP NORMS



             Individual                            Organizational
             resistance                            resistance to
             to change                             change



   SELECTIVE              FEAR OF
   INFORMATION            UNKNOWN      THREAT TO
                                       POSITION                  THREAT TO
   PROCESSING
                                       OF POWER                  EXPERTISE

                                                     THREAT TO
                                                     RESOURCE
                                                     ALLOCATION




                                                          © S Mukherji
OVERCOMING RESISTANCE IS CRITICAL FOR                                                    15
MANAGING CHANGE

                Different ways of overcoming resistance to change

    Evangelize and communication
         Address apprehensions, increase transparency, articulate rational,
          temporary sacrifice / inconvenience for greater good
    Participation
         Increases “felt-need”, collective responsibility, process fairness, means to
          a desired goal
    Facilitation and support
         Education, training, re-skilling, counseling
    Negotiation
         Addresses the power equations, reward packages
    Cooptation
    Peer pressure
    Coercion

                                                                        © S Mukherji

More Related Content

What's hot

Mahindra & mahindra
Mahindra & mahindraMahindra & mahindra
Mahindra & mahindra
BHAVIN GALA
 
Man org session 8 org conflict power and politics 19th july 2012
Man org session 8 org conflict power and politics 19th july 2012Man org session 8 org conflict power and politics 19th july 2012
Man org session 8 org conflict power and politics 19th july 2012
vivek_shaw
 

What's hot (20)

Mansa-building-case
Mansa-building-caseMansa-building-case
Mansa-building-case
 
Janalakshmi financial services
 Janalakshmi financial services Janalakshmi financial services
Janalakshmi financial services
 
Clique Pens - Case Study Solution by Kamal Allazov (Essay type)
Clique Pens - Case Study Solution by Kamal Allazov (Essay type)Clique Pens - Case Study Solution by Kamal Allazov (Essay type)
Clique Pens - Case Study Solution by Kamal Allazov (Essay type)
 
Thomas Green Case Study Presentation.
Thomas Green Case Study Presentation.Thomas Green Case Study Presentation.
Thomas Green Case Study Presentation.
 
D.Light Design Case Study Ananlysis
D.Light Design Case Study AnanlysisD.Light Design Case Study Ananlysis
D.Light Design Case Study Ananlysis
 
Wal-Mart Stores in 2003 (HBS Case 9-704-430)
Wal-Mart Stores in 2003 (HBS Case 9-704-430)Wal-Mart Stores in 2003 (HBS Case 9-704-430)
Wal-Mart Stores in 2003 (HBS Case 9-704-430)
 
Henry Tam and the MGI Team
Henry Tam and the MGI TeamHenry Tam and the MGI Team
Henry Tam and the MGI Team
 
Case study on Goodyear: The Aquatred launch
Case study on Goodyear: The Aquatred launchCase study on Goodyear: The Aquatred launch
Case study on Goodyear: The Aquatred launch
 
Pople management fiasco in HMSI case analysis
Pople management fiasco in HMSI case analysisPople management fiasco in HMSI case analysis
Pople management fiasco in HMSI case analysis
 
ACME or OMEGA - case analysis
ACME or OMEGA - case analysis ACME or OMEGA - case analysis
ACME or OMEGA - case analysis
 
NIKHIL YADAV- MAHINDRA IN SOUTH AFRICA CASE STUDY
NIKHIL YADAV- MAHINDRA IN SOUTH AFRICA  CASE STUDYNIKHIL YADAV- MAHINDRA IN SOUTH AFRICA  CASE STUDY
NIKHIL YADAV- MAHINDRA IN SOUTH AFRICA CASE STUDY
 
Case analysis of EMC
Case analysis of EMCCase analysis of EMC
Case analysis of EMC
 
Goodyear: The Aquatred Launch : Harvard Case Analysis
Goodyear: The Aquatred Launch : Harvard Case AnalysisGoodyear: The Aquatred Launch : Harvard Case Analysis
Goodyear: The Aquatred Launch : Harvard Case Analysis
 
Atlantic Computers: A Bundle of Pricing Options
Atlantic Computers: A Bundle of Pricing OptionsAtlantic Computers: A Bundle of Pricing Options
Atlantic Computers: A Bundle of Pricing Options
 
Apex corporation case study
Apex corporation case studyApex corporation case study
Apex corporation case study
 
Vora & Co. detailed Case analysis
Vora & Co. detailed Case analysisVora & Co. detailed Case analysis
Vora & Co. detailed Case analysis
 
Recruitment of a Star
Recruitment of a StarRecruitment of a Star
Recruitment of a Star
 
Mahindra & mahindra
Mahindra & mahindraMahindra & mahindra
Mahindra & mahindra
 
CASE STUDY : The Treadway Tire Company
CASE STUDY : The Treadway Tire CompanyCASE STUDY : The Treadway Tire Company
CASE STUDY : The Treadway Tire Company
 
Man org session 8 org conflict power and politics 19th july 2012
Man org session 8 org conflict power and politics 19th july 2012Man org session 8 org conflict power and politics 19th july 2012
Man org session 8 org conflict power and politics 19th july 2012
 

More from vivek_shaw

Lecture 11 market structure- perfect competition
Lecture 11  market structure- perfect competitionLecture 11  market structure- perfect competition
Lecture 11 market structure- perfect competition
vivek_shaw
 
Lecture 9 costs
Lecture 9  costsLecture 9  costs
Lecture 9 costs
vivek_shaw
 
Lecture 8 production, optimal inputs
Lecture 8  production, optimal inputsLecture 8  production, optimal inputs
Lecture 8 production, optimal inputs
vivek_shaw
 
Lecture 8 production, optimal inputs (1)
Lecture 8  production, optimal inputs (1)Lecture 8  production, optimal inputs (1)
Lecture 8 production, optimal inputs (1)
vivek_shaw
 
Lecture 3 dds sand elasticity
Lecture 3  dds sand elasticityLecture 3  dds sand elasticity
Lecture 3 dds sand elasticity
vivek_shaw
 
Consumertheory1
Consumertheory1Consumertheory1
Consumertheory1
vivek_shaw
 
Consumer theory 2
Consumer theory 2Consumer theory 2
Consumer theory 2
vivek_shaw
 
Class2 market, demand and supply
Class2  market, demand and supplyClass2  market, demand and supply
Class2 market, demand and supply
vivek_shaw
 
Policy implications
Policy implicationsPolicy implications
Policy implications
vivek_shaw
 
Man org session 3-org and technology_5th july 2012
Man org session 3-org and technology_5th july 2012Man org session 3-org and technology_5th july 2012
Man org session 3-org and technology_5th july 2012
vivek_shaw
 
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
vivek_shaw
 
Man org session 12_org learning_3rd august 2012
Man org session 12_org learning_3rd august 2012Man org session 12_org learning_3rd august 2012
Man org session 12_org learning_3rd august 2012
vivek_shaw
 
Man org session 11 interorganizational relationships_2nd august 2012
Man org session 11 interorganizational relationships_2nd august 2012Man org session 11 interorganizational relationships_2nd august 2012
Man org session 11 interorganizational relationships_2nd august 2012
vivek_shaw
 
Man org session 10_org control_27th july 2012
Man org session 10_org control_27th july 2012Man org session 10_org control_27th july 2012
Man org session 10_org control_27th july 2012
vivek_shaw
 

More from vivek_shaw (20)

Lecture 11 market structure- perfect competition
Lecture 11  market structure- perfect competitionLecture 11  market structure- perfect competition
Lecture 11 market structure- perfect competition
 
Lecture 9 costs
Lecture 9  costsLecture 9  costs
Lecture 9 costs
 
Lecture 8 production, optimal inputs
Lecture 8  production, optimal inputsLecture 8  production, optimal inputs
Lecture 8 production, optimal inputs
 
Lecture 8 production, optimal inputs (1)
Lecture 8  production, optimal inputs (1)Lecture 8  production, optimal inputs (1)
Lecture 8 production, optimal inputs (1)
 
Lecture 3 dds sand elasticity
Lecture 3  dds sand elasticityLecture 3  dds sand elasticity
Lecture 3 dds sand elasticity
 
Game theory 3
Game theory 3Game theory 3
Game theory 3
 
Game theory 1
Game theory 1Game theory 1
Game theory 1
 
Game theory 2
Game theory 2Game theory 2
Game theory 2
 
Ford motors
Ford motorsFord motors
Ford motors
 
Consumertheory1
Consumertheory1Consumertheory1
Consumertheory1
 
Consumer theory 2
Consumer theory 2Consumer theory 2
Consumer theory 2
 
Class2 market, demand and supply
Class2  market, demand and supplyClass2  market, demand and supply
Class2 market, demand and supply
 
Auctions 1
Auctions 1Auctions 1
Auctions 1
 
Costs2
Costs2Costs2
Costs2
 
Policy implications
Policy implicationsPolicy implications
Policy implications
 
Man org session 3-org and technology_5th july 2012
Man org session 3-org and technology_5th july 2012Man org session 3-org and technology_5th july 2012
Man org session 3-org and technology_5th july 2012
 
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
 
Man org session 12_org learning_3rd august 2012
Man org session 12_org learning_3rd august 2012Man org session 12_org learning_3rd august 2012
Man org session 12_org learning_3rd august 2012
 
Man org session 11 interorganizational relationships_2nd august 2012
Man org session 11 interorganizational relationships_2nd august 2012Man org session 11 interorganizational relationships_2nd august 2012
Man org session 11 interorganizational relationships_2nd august 2012
 
Man org session 10_org control_27th july 2012
Man org session 10_org control_27th july 2012Man org session 10_org control_27th july 2012
Man org session 10_org control_27th july 2012
 

Man org session 13_org change_9th august 2012

  • 1. MANAGING ORGANIZATIONS Session 13: Organizational Change Sourav Mukherji PGP 2012-14 Section C & E Associate Professor of Organization & Strategy Term 1:June-September 2012 Indian Institute of Management Bangalore, India
  • 2. 2 REVISITING APPEX CORPORATION Why did Shikhar Ghosh make so many structural changes in Apex Corporation ? Were all the changes in structure necessary ? What did he achieve or fail to achieve with so many changes ? © S Mukherji
  • 3. 3 STRUCTURAL CHANGES AT VFM SOLUTIONS If VFM solution decides to sell computers to corporate customers (option 1), what kind of change should it bring about in its organization structure ? © S Mukherji
  • 4. 4 CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 1 VIKAS MANISH FRANCIS PARTHA SOHO CALL SALES CENTRE © S Mukherji
  • 5. 5 CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 1 VIKAS MANISH FRANCIS PARTHA NEW APPOINTEE CORPORATE SALES SOHO CALL SALES CENTRE © S Mukherji
  • 6. 6 CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 2 VIKAS MANISH FRANCIS PARTHA NEW APPOINTEE CORPORATE SALES SOHO CALL SALES CENTRE © S Mukherji
  • 7. 7 CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 3 VIKAS MANISH FRANCIS NEW APPOINTEE PARTHA CORPORATE SALES SOHO CALL SALES CENTRE © S Mukherji
  • 8. 8 CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 4 VIKAS MANISH FRANCIS NEW PARTHA APPOINTEE CORPORATE SALES SOHO CALL SALES CENTRE © S Mukherji
  • 9. 9 CORPORATE SALES – OPTION 5 ADVANTAGES 1. No senior level appointment Less risky, less resources VIKAS 2. Using existing resources, knowledge 3. Promotion for Partha Succession planning MANISH FRANCIS DOUBTS / CHALLENGES 1. Is Partha ready for this role yet ? 2. Does he need to be trained ? 3. What is the size of opportunity ? PARTHA 4. Will the new opportunity get adequate focus from VFM ? SOHO CALL CORPORATE SALES CENTRE SALES © S Mukherji
  • 10. THREE DIMENSIONS FOR CONSIDERATION 10 DURING STRUCTURAL CHANGES 1 Strategic Objective • What is the size of proposed business ? • How does the proposed change enable / facilitate the objective of the organization / business unit • Is the change consistent with business objective ? • What are the interdependencies with current job ? Are there any conflict of interests ? 2 Job Content Are there complementarities ? • Can the new job be done through existing set of skill sets and competencies ? • What is the extent of education and training necessary for existing employees to make this transition ? • Have we addressed the aspirations and apprehensions 3 Human dimension of of existing employees ? change • Has there been adequate communication to set expectations? • What are the implications for political and informal relations in the organization ? • What is likely to be the relationship between new recruits and existing employees of the organization ? © S Mukherji
  • 11. 11 SERVICES – VARIOUS OPTIONS VIKAS MANISH FRANCIS PARTHA SERVICE MANAGERS SERVICE SOHO CALL ENGINEERS SALES CENTRE © S Mukherji
  • 12. 12 SERVICES – VIABLE OPTION ? ADVANTAGES 1. Less conflict of interest 2. Similar nature of job / role VIKAS 3. Manish has capacity to take additional responsibility MANISH FRANCIS DOUBTS / CHALLENGES 1. Integration between sales & service 2. Conflict resolution PARTHA SOHO CALL SERVICE SALES CENTRE MANAGERS SERVICE ENGINEERS © S Mukherji
  • 13. 13 A PROCESS MODEL OF ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE Integrate as regular organizational practices INSTITUTIONALIZATION Evaluate, monitor impact Fine tuning Refreeze Level of Planning specific steps Support for IMPLEMENTATION Identify change agents Change Identify potential resistance Address apprehensions Preparation for hardships PREPARATION Creating the need for change Unfreeze Disturbing the status quo Time © S Mukherji
  • 14. 14 ORGANIZATIONS AND INDIVIDUALS SEEM TO RESIST CHANGE INTERDEPENDENT SUBSYSTEMS STRUCTURAL INERTIA SECURITY / HABIT ECONOMIC FACTORS GROUP NORMS Individual Organizational resistance resistance to to change change SELECTIVE FEAR OF INFORMATION UNKNOWN THREAT TO POSITION THREAT TO PROCESSING OF POWER EXPERTISE THREAT TO RESOURCE ALLOCATION © S Mukherji
  • 15. OVERCOMING RESISTANCE IS CRITICAL FOR 15 MANAGING CHANGE Different ways of overcoming resistance to change  Evangelize and communication  Address apprehensions, increase transparency, articulate rational, temporary sacrifice / inconvenience for greater good  Participation  Increases “felt-need”, collective responsibility, process fairness, means to a desired goal  Facilitation and support  Education, training, re-skilling, counseling  Negotiation  Addresses the power equations, reward packages  Cooptation  Peer pressure  Coercion © S Mukherji