ith the widespread adoption of 4G cellular technology as well as the growing availability of 5G products and services for remote industrial applications around the world, it is no longer a matter of if but rather a matter of when 2G and 3G services are being turned off.
But don't panic, we are here to help. In this short webinar, technical engineers Wesley Nel and Ant Lane walk you through what the phase out of 2G and 3G cellular communications mean, and most importantly, how you can prepare for it.
3. 3
Introduction
Who we are and what we do
Westermo products are used for
creating the most reliable networks
possible for critical control systems
Solutions to industrial challenges
Westermo has specifically developed
solutions to meet the extreme
requirements for mission critical
industrial control systems
The most reliable products on the market
Westermo products are designed for
use in harsh environments and allow
you to build cost-effective, reliable,
secure industrial networks
4. 4
What and where is 2G & 3G?
What is the 2G/3G sunset?
Challenges of a sunset
Recommendations
What's next?
Technical overview of cellular communication
What is RSSI, RSRP and RSRQ
Installing cellular
System impact
Are you prepared for a switch off?
Todays topics
5. 5
What is 2G and 3G?
It is the 2nd and 3rd
generation of cellular
technology
Just like 4G & 5G are the 4th
and 5th
With each generation, different technology,
frequencies and modulations are used
Usually increase bandwidth and coverage
Lower latency
6. 6
Where is 2G and 3G?
It is everywhere!
Water
Energy
Trackside
Industrial Automation
8. 8
What is the 2G/3G sunset?
Mobile Network Operators
(MNO) are planning to turn
services off
Free up the radio spectrum
for other technologies
MNO’s can focus on more
advanced technologies
rather than maintaining
older, aging systems
It won’t happen overnight
3G may go before 2G
9. 9
Challenges of a Sunset
There are many devices still using 2G/3G
Millions of smart meters in the UK with an
expected service life of 15 years
For an MNO to sunset/shutdown a
cellular generation the user base should
be below 1%
KT (South Korea)
Softbank and NTT Docomo (Japan)
The 2G network still carries a lot of voice
traffic
Universal coverage
Despite advance warnings, systems will
fail if not prepared
10. 10
Check with your local mobile network operator
Recommendation 1
MNO’s will advise when services are
being turned off
Check the source of the information
Speculation can lead to decisions being
made in haste
2G/3G sunset is location dependent
Australia switched of 2G in 2018
Germany planning to turn 3G off in 2021
Currently no date in the UK
Examples
PSTN sunset in UK. Ofcom & BT both
outlining timescales
2018 ISDN shutdown in Germany
Customer had time to prepare for
shutdown
Replacement infrastructure enabled
migration to alternative technology
11. 11
Option to still use legacy equipment
with 4G enabled devices
Serial over IP
Only need to upgrade communications
equipment, not the whole system
Understand the impact of the shutdown
on your system
Recommendation 2
Changing over many devices can be
time consuming, difficult and costly
4G enabled devices enable support
for 2G/3G whilst it is still available
4G brings higher data rates,
bandwidth and lower latency
12. 12
Understanding the technology
Recommendation 3
4G has far exceeded 2G/3G expectation
Lower frequencies enabled coverage in
previously inaccessible areas
Higher frequencies enabled support for
high dense environments
4G User Equipment (UE) Categories
define how equipment communicate
UE Category Data Rate
CAT-1 Up to 10Mbit/s
CAT-4 Up to 100Mbit/s
CAT-12 Up to 600Mbit/s
CAT-19 Up to 1566 Mbit/s
13. 13
Next generation technology
4G is still a great choice and current
Cellular technologies will coexist
5G is on its way
High bandwidth
Low latency
Private LTE
LTE450
14. 14
Sunsetting a technology is no easy task
Keep up to date with official statements from
MNOs & regulators
Find out how much your system could be
impacted with a technology sunset
Understanding the technology can help you
choose the right replacement product
Key takeaways
15. 15
What is RSSI, RSRP and RSRQ?
Installing cellular - Considerations
System Impact
Technical breakdown
16. 16
RSSI – Received Signal Strength Indicator
What is RSSI, RSRP and RSRQ
RSSI indicates the power level that is being received after any possible loss at the antenna
and cable and is measure in dBm. This value can be used as a measurement of how well a
receiver can “hear” a signal form a sender. Reporting range is 0 to -120dBm (0 best, -120
worst)
2G/3G/4G
-65dBm -75dBm -85dBm -95dBm -110dBm
17. 17
RSRP – Reference Signal Received Power
What is RSSI, RSRP and RSRQ
-70dBm -80dBm -90dBm -100dBm > -100dBm
18. 18
RSRQ – Reference Signal Received Quality
What is RSSI, RSRP and RSRQ
-5 to -10dB
-10 to -15dB
-15 to -20
-20 to -25dB
>-5dB
<-25dB
19. 19
Installing cellular – Things to consider
Installation
Product
Antenna
Cable run
Low loss coaxial cables (short)
Ethernet cables (longer)
Know your site
Site Survey
Antenna diversity
20. 21
System Impact
“If its not broken, then don’t fix it”
Installation
How much does it cost if it doesn’t work?
What is the cost of poor installation? Callouts
Total cost of ownership
Why you shouldn’t put the antenna inside
Sometimes customers can not mount them inside
Warranty/Ingress Protection (IP) rating
Increase signal by 10dB
21. 22
Signal Indicators – RSSI, RSRP & RSRQ
Things to consider - cellular installations
System impact
Key Points
22. 23
Are you prepared for a switch off?
2G/3G will be shut off globally
2G, 4G and 5G will operate in combination with each other
Check the facts! Sourcing valid information
Cellular communications requires a good signal strength and quality
23. 24
Summary
The sun is setting
for 2G & 3G
cellular
technologies
Check with your
MNO and local
regulator for next
steps
RSSI is not the
only factor with
mobile
connections.
RSRP & RSRQ play
a vital role
It is about giving
mobile networks
the best
opportunity
Westermo can
help
Be prepared,
don’t be
caught out
Manufacturer and vendor of Industrial data communications products for mission-critical systems in harsh environments.
Soo.. What is this 2g 3g sunset everyone is talking about?
GDW-11 was a successful product for Westermo – In the UK we are still replacing this unit and still get the odd request for this product (which we can fulfill in most cases with our other product ranges)
One example is the rollout out of smart meters in the UK. Smart meters give consumers (business & personal) near real time information on energy use displayed in GBP. Two version of Smart Meters (SMERTS 1 & 2) both communicate using the existing 2G network on previously negotiated cellular contracts
The service life of smart meter was agreed in 2013, that the devices be communicate either using the 2G or 3G network for 15 years (ending in 2029). However, the rollout has been delayed, extending in to 2024, four more years than previously planned, again with an expectation of 15 years service life. Currently there is no 4G model and the devices search for a 3G network first, then if unavailable uses 2G. If the 3G network is disabled nationwide, communication will need to rely on the 2G infrastructure.
And this is just one example!
Furthermore, for a sunset to happen, the user base is recommended to be below 1%
https://www.commsupdate.com/articles/2011/12/08/2g-or-not-2g-korean-courts-orders-kt-to-continue-service/
On the other hand Japanese cellular provides (Softbank and NTT Docomo) successfully reduced 2G coverage to 0.3% to turn of 2G in 2017
https://www.smartcitiesworld.net/news/news/not-so-fast-2g-switch-off-could-impact-smart-meters-the-elderly-and-critical-services-4701
For context eCall is a emergency call service either automatically or manually activated if a vehicle is in an accident. It provides voice communication between emergency services and the persons in the incident
There is also no full 4G cover to replace the 2G/3G network if it is turned off. “Dark spots” or “Not Spots” especially in rural areas rely on 2G connectivity for remote access. In the UK, there are ongoing talks between MNOs to collectively create coverage for remote areas to ensure coverage on a technology sunset
San Francisco’s Muni (Metro System) used GPS via NextBus on AT&T’s 2G network for real time location data
AT&T announced in 2012, that by 2017 this system would be turned off
San Fran Transport Authority, SFMTA did not prepare and had problems with access over two thirds of it’s fleet
For the public switched telephone network (PSTN) switch-off in the UK, BT (an internet service provider) itself had provided an official press release, supported by Ofcom, outlining that PSTNs will be switched off by 2025.
Germany switched off its ISDN network in 2018 to create the way for an all IP network. To ensure that users still had access to ‘analogue lines’, boxes on the street supplied an IP backbone to the ISP, with the last meters kept as a connection for existing telephones. This has enabled customers to prepare for a ‘switch-off’ and migrate to a fixed line replacement (ADSL/VDSL https://business.bt.com/insights/digital-transformation/uk-pstn-switch-off/
https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0032/137966/future-fixed-telephone-services.pdf
https://www.telekom.com/en/company/details/five-facts-about-the-ip-migration-596110
Bridge over to why 4G is a good replacement
5G is blowing this out of the water
4G does not = good
Reference to wes giving some insight
Why is 4g is important – view from using a good technology
Most of us are familiar with RSSI which relates to the Received Signal and SINR/SNR of the given Signal, but RSRP and RSRQ are relatively New and were introduced with the implementation of LTE/4G.
All of these Signal indicators or Signal Reference indicators are a measure of power.
RSSI – measures the Received signal of the whole band and is quite commonly used as a reference point for what is a good or bad signal. So why are RSRP and RSRQ relevant?
LTE or FTN block has certain amount of resource blocks and you also sometimes have more than one antenna so you need to measure specifically the power essentially the base station reference signals which is always there. The other signals come and go as people are using it. So that is why we need to measure the LTE Specific reference signal and they do relate to RSSI and SNR.
RSRP – RSRP is a RSSI type of measurement, as follows there are some definition of it and some details as well. It is the power of the LTE Reference Signals spread over the full bandwidth and narrowband. A minimum of -20 dB SINR (of the S-Synch channel) is needed to detect RSRP/RSRQ
RSRQ – Quality considering also RSSI and the number of used Resource Blocks (N) RSRQ = (N * RSRP) / RSSI measured over the same bandwidth. RSRQ is a C/I type of measurement and it indicates the quality of the received reference signal. The RSRQ measurement provides additional information when RSRP is not sufficient to make a reliable handover or cell reselection decision.
RSRP – RSRP is a measure of signal strength. It is the average power of the LTE Resource Elements that carry cell specific Reference Signals spread over the entire bandwidth. Its important for cell selection and reselection process and is reported to the network to aid in the handover procedure. Reporting range is -44 to -140dBm
The 3GPP spec description for RSRP is determined for a considered cell as the linear average over the power contributions (watts) of the resource elements that they carry. Cell specific Reference Signals within the considered measurement for frequency bandwidth.
It is the average power of the LTE Resource Elements that carry cell specific Reference Signals spread over the entire bandwidth. Its important for cell selection and reselection process and is reported to the network to aid in the handover procedure. Reporting range is -44 to -140dBm
https://www.twilio.com/docs/iot/supersim/how-determine-good-cellular-signal-strength
RSRQ – RSRQ provides an indication of signal Quality. RSRQ is a calculated value from RSRP and RSSI is measure of signal and interference. Less interference means better quality. The closer to -3dB the higher the speeds. Reporting range is -3 to -20dB
In past it was 2 different networks, primary & backup
Unsteered are like Mobius, WL or Arkessa, Emnify – don’t have a network but re sell and configure sims for customers.
Replacing 2G could be expensive exercise.
Most Industrial routers come with Serial/IP interface.
Weather
Humidity
A water company
Every 3dB is a double. 10dB offers loads. Pander to legacy view
There is no global schedule
Countries/companies are doing this at different rates
3G being turned off is very likely with 2G most likely being kept online. Think we are going to see 2G live longer than we expected