SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 15
Reading ability influences perceptual
learning of talker-specific phonetic detail
Katlyn Salvador1,2, Shayna Marmon1, and Rachel M. Theodore1
1Department of Speech, Language, and Hearing Sciences
University of Connecticut
2Department of Psychology
University of Connecticut
Introduction
 The acoustic signal of speech cues content of the message,
in addition to identity of the talker (Murray & Arnott, 1993)
 Research indicates a tight link between the perception of
“who is talking” and “what is being said”
 Comprehension benefits are shown for familiar talkers in
comparison to unfamiliar talkers (Nygaard et al., 1994)
 Voices in a listener’s native language are easier to discriminate
than voices heard in a nonnative language (Perrachione &
Wong, 2007)
Introduction
 Phonological knowledge, knowledge about a language’s sound
structure, mediates the native language benefit for talker recognition
 Adults with reading disability (i.e., dyslexia) show poor talker
identification even in their native language (Perrachione, Del Tufo, &
Gabriei, 2011)
 Even among unimpaired readers, reading ability shows a gradient
influence on talker identification for native and non-native speakers
(Kadam, Orena, Theodore, & Polka, in preparation)
Does reading ability influence the talker familiarity
effect for word recognition?
Methods: Participants
 30 adults (11 males, 19 females), 18 – 23 years old
 Native, monolingual speakers of American English with no
history of speech, language, or hearing disorders
 Each completed a standardized assessment battery to
examine nonverbal intelligence, memory, reading sub-
skills, and reading comprehension
 Assigned to either the “average” reading group or the
“advanced” reading group based on a median split of
composite reading scores
Methods: Auditory Stimuli
The lists were arranged so that half the words were presented during both training and test
sessions, while the other half were only presented during test
All items were equated
for root-mean-square
amplitude
Methods: Visual Stimuli
Procedure
Results: Training
• Mean percent correct talker identification was
calculated separately for each training session,
collapsing over the six talkers presented during
training (Figure 1)
• Performance improved over the three training sessions
for each reading group
• The rate of talker learning was faster for the advanced
readers compared to the average readers.
• Performance did not differ between the two groups on
the last day of training
Figure 1
Results: Test
• For pre-test and post-test, mean percent correct word
identification was calculated separately for trained and novel
items (Figure 2)
• Results of an ANOVA showed a significant 2-way interaction
between reading group and test time (Figure 3), but no 3-
way interaction between reading group, test time, and trial
type
• The two groups did not differ at pre-test, but at post-test the
advanced readers showed improved word recognition
compared to the average readers
• The degree of improvement at post-test was correlated with
the composite reading score (Figure 4)
Figure 2
Figure 3
Figure 4
Conclusions
• Compared to average readers, advanced readers
showed faster talker learning rate during training and
greater talker familiarity effects on word recognition at
test
• These findings suggest that some individual variation
in talker-specific perceptual learning reflects
differences in skills related to reading ability
• Future work should address the neural basis of
interactions between voice recognition and language
comprehension abilities
References
Kadam, M., Orena, A.J., Theodore, R. M., & Polka, L. (In press). Gradient effects of reading
ability on native and non-native talker identification. Proceedings of the 18th
International Congress of Phonetic Sciences.
Murray, I. R., Arnott, J. L. (1993). Toward the simulation of emotion in synthetic speech: A
review of the literature on human vocal emotion. Journal of the Acoustical Society
of America, 93,1097-1108.
Nygaard, L. C., Sommers, M. S., & Pisoni, D. B. (1994). Speech perception as a talker-
contingent process. Psychological Science, 5, 42 – 46.
Perrachione, T. K., Del Tufo, S. N., & Gabrieli, J. D. E. (2011). Human voice recognition
depends on language ability. Science, 29, 545.
Perrachione, T. K., & Wong, P. C. M. (2007) Learning to recognize speakers of a non-native
language: Implications for the functional organization of human auditory cortex.
Neuropsychologia, 45,1899-1910.

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Diminishing Speaking anxiety in English classroom
Diminishing Speaking anxiety in English classroomDiminishing Speaking anxiety in English classroom
Diminishing Speaking anxiety in English classroomuzairahmohdali
 
Definition, elements and process of communication
Definition, elements and process of communicationDefinition, elements and process of communication
Definition, elements and process of communicationMadhura Date
 
Communication and its elements
Communication and its elementsCommunication and its elements
Communication and its elementsBilal Muhammad
 
The Correlation of Reading Comprehension Ability of Persian and English Langu...
The Correlation of Reading Comprehension Ability of Persian and English Langu...The Correlation of Reading Comprehension Ability of Persian and English Langu...
The Correlation of Reading Comprehension Ability of Persian and English Langu...inventionjournals
 
Changing Contexts And Shifting Paradigms In Pronunciation Teaching
Changing Contexts And Shifting Paradigms In Pronunciation TeachingChanging Contexts And Shifting Paradigms In Pronunciation Teaching
Changing Contexts And Shifting Paradigms In Pronunciation Teachingenglishonecfl
 
Technologyreshma
TechnologyreshmaTechnologyreshma
Technologyreshmathaj8
 
Communication Apprehension among Nilai College Students Article masters
Communication Apprehension among Nilai College Students Article mastersCommunication Apprehension among Nilai College Students Article masters
Communication Apprehension among Nilai College Students Article mastersuzairahmohdali
 
The process of communication and the elements of communication
The process of communication and the elements of communicationThe process of communication and the elements of communication
The process of communication and the elements of communicationDA Victoria
 
The affective filter in second language acquisition
The affective filter in second language acquisitionThe affective filter in second language acquisition
The affective filter in second language acquisitionericortiz24
 

La actualidad más candente (14)

Diminishing Speaking anxiety in English classroom
Diminishing Speaking anxiety in English classroomDiminishing Speaking anxiety in English classroom
Diminishing Speaking anxiety in English classroom
 
Definition, elements and process of communication
Definition, elements and process of communicationDefinition, elements and process of communication
Definition, elements and process of communication
 
Communication and its elements
Communication and its elementsCommunication and its elements
Communication and its elements
 
The Correlation of Reading Comprehension Ability of Persian and English Langu...
The Correlation of Reading Comprehension Ability of Persian and English Langu...The Correlation of Reading Comprehension Ability of Persian and English Langu...
The Correlation of Reading Comprehension Ability of Persian and English Langu...
 
Communication Cycle Notes
Communication Cycle NotesCommunication Cycle Notes
Communication Cycle Notes
 
Changing Contexts And Shifting Paradigms In Pronunciation Teaching
Changing Contexts And Shifting Paradigms In Pronunciation TeachingChanging Contexts And Shifting Paradigms In Pronunciation Teaching
Changing Contexts And Shifting Paradigms In Pronunciation Teaching
 
David Berlo's Model of Communication
David Berlo's Model of CommunicationDavid Berlo's Model of Communication
David Berlo's Model of Communication
 
Krashen monitor model
Krashen monitor modelKrashen monitor model
Krashen monitor model
 
communication
communicationcommunication
communication
 
Technologyreshma
TechnologyreshmaTechnologyreshma
Technologyreshma
 
Communication Apprehension among Nilai College Students Article masters
Communication Apprehension among Nilai College Students Article mastersCommunication Apprehension among Nilai College Students Article masters
Communication Apprehension among Nilai College Students Article masters
 
The process of communication and the elements of communication
The process of communication and the elements of communicationThe process of communication and the elements of communication
The process of communication and the elements of communication
 
test
testtest
test
 
The affective filter in second language acquisition
The affective filter in second language acquisitionThe affective filter in second language acquisition
The affective filter in second language acquisition
 

Destacado

Ag final met ball 2014 yolonda thomas
Ag final met ball 2014 yolonda thomasAg final met ball 2014 yolonda thomas
Ag final met ball 2014 yolonda thomasYolonda Thomas
 
SFT CSP 2014-2015 FINAL
SFT CSP 2014-2015 FINALSFT CSP 2014-2015 FINAL
SFT CSP 2014-2015 FINALAmy Xia
 
2015 spring summer fashion forecast
2015 spring summer fashion forecast2015 spring summer fashion forecast
2015 spring summer fashion forecastYolonda Thomas
 
Subir al internet trabajo
Subir al internet trabajoSubir al internet trabajo
Subir al internet trabajoaribetyfranko
 
Assistive technology week 2
Assistive technology week 2Assistive technology week 2
Assistive technology week 2ketina
 
siba grades attachment (21)
siba grades attachment (21)siba grades attachment (21)
siba grades attachment (21)Yolonda Thomas
 
2014 Buddhist Philosophy Syllabus
2014 Buddhist Philosophy Syllabus2014 Buddhist Philosophy Syllabus
2014 Buddhist Philosophy SyllabusJustin Whitaker
 
Freddy torrealba presentacion
Freddy torrealba presentacionFreddy torrealba presentacion
Freddy torrealba presentacionskaylam
 
FA14-PHI205851_JWhitaker_syllabus
FA14-PHI205851_JWhitaker_syllabusFA14-PHI205851_JWhitaker_syllabus
FA14-PHI205851_JWhitaker_syllabusJustin Whitaker
 
Islam Ahmed Ali ELsawy
Islam Ahmed Ali ELsawyIslam Ahmed Ali ELsawy
Islam Ahmed Ali ELsawyIslam ELsawi
 
Assistive Technology
Assistive TechnologyAssistive Technology
Assistive Technologyketina
 

Destacado (18)

Ag final met ball 2014 yolonda thomas
Ag final met ball 2014 yolonda thomasAg final met ball 2014 yolonda thomas
Ag final met ball 2014 yolonda thomas
 
SFT CSP 2014-2015 FINAL
SFT CSP 2014-2015 FINALSFT CSP 2014-2015 FINAL
SFT CSP 2014-2015 FINAL
 
2015 spring summer fashion forecast
2015 spring summer fashion forecast2015 spring summer fashion forecast
2015 spring summer fashion forecast
 
Subir al internet trabajo
Subir al internet trabajoSubir al internet trabajo
Subir al internet trabajo
 
Assistive technology week 2
Assistive technology week 2Assistive technology week 2
Assistive technology week 2
 
Marianos (1)
Marianos (1)Marianos (1)
Marianos (1)
 
Equestrio_Adrian Landon
Equestrio_Adrian LandonEquestrio_Adrian Landon
Equestrio_Adrian Landon
 
Coloquio Administración Rural II
Coloquio Administración Rural IIColoquio Administración Rural II
Coloquio Administración Rural II
 
siba grades attachment (21)
siba grades attachment (21)siba grades attachment (21)
siba grades attachment (21)
 
Мова. Прырода душы
Мова. Прырода душыМова. Прырода душы
Мова. Прырода душы
 
2014 Buddhist Philosophy Syllabus
2014 Buddhist Philosophy Syllabus2014 Buddhist Philosophy Syllabus
2014 Buddhist Philosophy Syllabus
 
Freddy torrealba presentacion
Freddy torrealba presentacionFreddy torrealba presentacion
Freddy torrealba presentacion
 
FA14-PHI205851_JWhitaker_syllabus
FA14-PHI205851_JWhitaker_syllabusFA14-PHI205851_JWhitaker_syllabus
FA14-PHI205851_JWhitaker_syllabus
 
Islam Ahmed Ali ELsawy
Islam Ahmed Ali ELsawyIslam Ahmed Ali ELsawy
Islam Ahmed Ali ELsawy
 
Different types of curriculum
Different types of curriculumDifferent types of curriculum
Different types of curriculum
 
Assistive Technology
Assistive TechnologyAssistive Technology
Assistive Technology
 
Obserbasyon Sa Isang Klasrum
Obserbasyon Sa Isang KlasrumObserbasyon Sa Isang Klasrum
Obserbasyon Sa Isang Klasrum
 
Чарнобыль: 30 год пасьля
Чарнобыль: 30 год пасьляЧарнобыль: 30 год пасьля
Чарнобыль: 30 год пасьля
 

Similar a How Reading Ability Affects Talker-Specific Phonetic Learning

NSCI 539 Rita Barakat Presentation Feb 2nd 2017
NSCI 539 Rita Barakat Presentation Feb 2nd 2017 NSCI 539 Rita Barakat Presentation Feb 2nd 2017
NSCI 539 Rita Barakat Presentation Feb 2nd 2017 Rita Barakat
 
Hanks_Final Research Paper
Hanks_Final Research PaperHanks_Final Research Paper
Hanks_Final Research PaperAmanda Hanks
 
Memory & Cognition2002, 30 (4), 583-593Spoken word recog.docx
Memory & Cognition2002, 30 (4), 583-593Spoken word recog.docxMemory & Cognition2002, 30 (4), 583-593Spoken word recog.docx
Memory & Cognition2002, 30 (4), 583-593Spoken word recog.docxandreecapon
 
The effect of authentic/inauthentic materials in EFL classroom
The effect of authentic/inauthentic materials in EFL classroomThe effect of authentic/inauthentic materials in EFL classroom
The effect of authentic/inauthentic materials in EFL classroomfirdausabdmunir85
 
What do phonological processing errors tell about students' skills in reading...
What do phonological processing errors tell about students' skills in reading...What do phonological processing errors tell about students' skills in reading...
What do phonological processing errors tell about students' skills in reading...Dowon 최도원
 
Pre-Reading Inventory of Phonological Awareness (PIPA).doc
Pre-Reading Inventory of Phonological Awareness (PIPA).docPre-Reading Inventory of Phonological Awareness (PIPA).doc
Pre-Reading Inventory of Phonological Awareness (PIPA).docAschalewAsnake
 
Research Proposal.edited
Research Proposal.editedResearch Proposal.edited
Research Proposal.editedKendrik Jones
 
listening Skills Handout -converted-converted.pptx
listening Skills Handout -converted-converted.pptxlistening Skills Handout -converted-converted.pptx
listening Skills Handout -converted-converted.pptxBayissaBekele
 
Learner Views Of Using Authentic Audio To Aid Pronunciation You Can Just Grab...
Learner Views Of Using Authentic Audio To Aid Pronunciation You Can Just Grab...Learner Views Of Using Authentic Audio To Aid Pronunciation You Can Just Grab...
Learner Views Of Using Authentic Audio To Aid Pronunciation You Can Just Grab...englishonecfl
 
Intelligibility And The Listener The Role Of Lexical Stress
Intelligibility And The Listener The Role Of Lexical StressIntelligibility And The Listener The Role Of Lexical Stress
Intelligibility And The Listener The Role Of Lexical Stressenglishonecfl
 
Support for foreign language listeners: Its effectiveness and limitations
Support for foreign language listeners: Its effectiveness and limitationsSupport for foreign language listeners: Its effectiveness and limitations
Support for foreign language listeners: Its effectiveness and limitationsCindy Shen
 
Example of journal
Example of journalExample of journal
Example of journalamirahjuned
 
The effect of films with and without subtitles on listening comprehension of ...
The effect of films with and without subtitles on listening comprehension of ...The effect of films with and without subtitles on listening comprehension of ...
The effect of films with and without subtitles on listening comprehension of ...amirahjuned
 
Development and Standardization of a Semantic Comprehension Assessment Tool f...
Development and Standardization of a Semantic Comprehension Assessment Tool f...Development and Standardization of a Semantic Comprehension Assessment Tool f...
Development and Standardization of a Semantic Comprehension Assessment Tool f...iosrjce
 
Cog, metacog,affective
Cog, metacog,affectiveCog, metacog,affective
Cog, metacog,affectiveHamizah Osman
 
An Evaluation Of The Oral Reading Fluency Of 4Th Graders With Respect To Pros...
An Evaluation Of The Oral Reading Fluency Of 4Th Graders With Respect To Pros...An Evaluation Of The Oral Reading Fluency Of 4Th Graders With Respect To Pros...
An Evaluation Of The Oral Reading Fluency Of 4Th Graders With Respect To Pros...Emma Burke
 

Similar a How Reading Ability Affects Talker-Specific Phonetic Learning (20)

NSCI 539 Rita Barakat Presentation Feb 2nd 2017
NSCI 539 Rita Barakat Presentation Feb 2nd 2017 NSCI 539 Rita Barakat Presentation Feb 2nd 2017
NSCI 539 Rita Barakat Presentation Feb 2nd 2017
 
Graduate Research Poster
Graduate Research PosterGraduate Research Poster
Graduate Research Poster
 
SFR poster 2016
SFR poster 2016SFR poster 2016
SFR poster 2016
 
Hanks_Final Research Paper
Hanks_Final Research PaperHanks_Final Research Paper
Hanks_Final Research Paper
 
Memory & Cognition2002, 30 (4), 583-593Spoken word recog.docx
Memory & Cognition2002, 30 (4), 583-593Spoken word recog.docxMemory & Cognition2002, 30 (4), 583-593Spoken word recog.docx
Memory & Cognition2002, 30 (4), 583-593Spoken word recog.docx
 
The effect of authentic/inauthentic materials in EFL classroom
The effect of authentic/inauthentic materials in EFL classroomThe effect of authentic/inauthentic materials in EFL classroom
The effect of authentic/inauthentic materials in EFL classroom
 
What do phonological processing errors tell about students' skills in reading...
What do phonological processing errors tell about students' skills in reading...What do phonological processing errors tell about students' skills in reading...
What do phonological processing errors tell about students' skills in reading...
 
Pre-Reading Inventory of Phonological Awareness (PIPA).doc
Pre-Reading Inventory of Phonological Awareness (PIPA).docPre-Reading Inventory of Phonological Awareness (PIPA).doc
Pre-Reading Inventory of Phonological Awareness (PIPA).doc
 
Research Proposal.edited
Research Proposal.editedResearch Proposal.edited
Research Proposal.edited
 
listening Skills Handout -converted-converted.pptx
listening Skills Handout -converted-converted.pptxlistening Skills Handout -converted-converted.pptx
listening Skills Handout -converted-converted.pptx
 
Learner Views Of Using Authentic Audio To Aid Pronunciation You Can Just Grab...
Learner Views Of Using Authentic Audio To Aid Pronunciation You Can Just Grab...Learner Views Of Using Authentic Audio To Aid Pronunciation You Can Just Grab...
Learner Views Of Using Authentic Audio To Aid Pronunciation You Can Just Grab...
 
Intelligibility And The Listener The Role Of Lexical Stress
Intelligibility And The Listener The Role Of Lexical StressIntelligibility And The Listener The Role Of Lexical Stress
Intelligibility And The Listener The Role Of Lexical Stress
 
Support for foreign language listeners: Its effectiveness and limitations
Support for foreign language listeners: Its effectiveness and limitationsSupport for foreign language listeners: Its effectiveness and limitations
Support for foreign language listeners: Its effectiveness and limitations
 
Example of journal
Example of journalExample of journal
Example of journal
 
The effect of films with and without subtitles on listening comprehension of ...
The effect of films with and without subtitles on listening comprehension of ...The effect of films with and without subtitles on listening comprehension of ...
The effect of films with and without subtitles on listening comprehension of ...
 
Reference 2
Reference 2Reference 2
Reference 2
 
Development and Standardization of a Semantic Comprehension Assessment Tool f...
Development and Standardization of a Semantic Comprehension Assessment Tool f...Development and Standardization of a Semantic Comprehension Assessment Tool f...
Development and Standardization of a Semantic Comprehension Assessment Tool f...
 
Cog, metacog,affective
Cog, metacog,affectiveCog, metacog,affective
Cog, metacog,affective
 
teaching-listening.pdf
teaching-listening.pdfteaching-listening.pdf
teaching-listening.pdf
 
An Evaluation Of The Oral Reading Fluency Of 4Th Graders With Respect To Pros...
An Evaluation Of The Oral Reading Fluency Of 4Th Graders With Respect To Pros...An Evaluation Of The Oral Reading Fluency Of 4Th Graders With Respect To Pros...
An Evaluation Of The Oral Reading Fluency Of 4Th Graders With Respect To Pros...
 

How Reading Ability Affects Talker-Specific Phonetic Learning

  • 1. Reading ability influences perceptual learning of talker-specific phonetic detail Katlyn Salvador1,2, Shayna Marmon1, and Rachel M. Theodore1 1Department of Speech, Language, and Hearing Sciences University of Connecticut 2Department of Psychology University of Connecticut
  • 2. Introduction  The acoustic signal of speech cues content of the message, in addition to identity of the talker (Murray & Arnott, 1993)  Research indicates a tight link between the perception of “who is talking” and “what is being said”  Comprehension benefits are shown for familiar talkers in comparison to unfamiliar talkers (Nygaard et al., 1994)  Voices in a listener’s native language are easier to discriminate than voices heard in a nonnative language (Perrachione & Wong, 2007)
  • 3. Introduction  Phonological knowledge, knowledge about a language’s sound structure, mediates the native language benefit for talker recognition  Adults with reading disability (i.e., dyslexia) show poor talker identification even in their native language (Perrachione, Del Tufo, & Gabriei, 2011)  Even among unimpaired readers, reading ability shows a gradient influence on talker identification for native and non-native speakers (Kadam, Orena, Theodore, & Polka, in preparation) Does reading ability influence the talker familiarity effect for word recognition?
  • 4. Methods: Participants  30 adults (11 males, 19 females), 18 – 23 years old  Native, monolingual speakers of American English with no history of speech, language, or hearing disorders  Each completed a standardized assessment battery to examine nonverbal intelligence, memory, reading sub- skills, and reading comprehension  Assigned to either the “average” reading group or the “advanced” reading group based on a median split of composite reading scores
  • 5. Methods: Auditory Stimuli The lists were arranged so that half the words were presented during both training and test sessions, while the other half were only presented during test All items were equated for root-mean-square amplitude
  • 8. Results: Training • Mean percent correct talker identification was calculated separately for each training session, collapsing over the six talkers presented during training (Figure 1) • Performance improved over the three training sessions for each reading group • The rate of talker learning was faster for the advanced readers compared to the average readers. • Performance did not differ between the two groups on the last day of training
  • 10. Results: Test • For pre-test and post-test, mean percent correct word identification was calculated separately for trained and novel items (Figure 2) • Results of an ANOVA showed a significant 2-way interaction between reading group and test time (Figure 3), but no 3- way interaction between reading group, test time, and trial type • The two groups did not differ at pre-test, but at post-test the advanced readers showed improved word recognition compared to the average readers • The degree of improvement at post-test was correlated with the composite reading score (Figure 4)
  • 14. Conclusions • Compared to average readers, advanced readers showed faster talker learning rate during training and greater talker familiarity effects on word recognition at test • These findings suggest that some individual variation in talker-specific perceptual learning reflects differences in skills related to reading ability • Future work should address the neural basis of interactions between voice recognition and language comprehension abilities
  • 15. References Kadam, M., Orena, A.J., Theodore, R. M., & Polka, L. (In press). Gradient effects of reading ability on native and non-native talker identification. Proceedings of the 18th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences. Murray, I. R., Arnott, J. L. (1993). Toward the simulation of emotion in synthetic speech: A review of the literature on human vocal emotion. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 93,1097-1108. Nygaard, L. C., Sommers, M. S., & Pisoni, D. B. (1994). Speech perception as a talker- contingent process. Psychological Science, 5, 42 – 46. Perrachione, T. K., Del Tufo, S. N., & Gabrieli, J. D. E. (2011). Human voice recognition depends on language ability. Science, 29, 545. Perrachione, T. K., & Wong, P. C. M. (2007) Learning to recognize speakers of a non-native language: Implications for the functional organization of human auditory cortex. Neuropsychologia, 45,1899-1910.

Notas del editor

  1. If voice recognition abilities influence talker-specific perceptual learning for comprehension, then advanced readers will show greater familiarity effects compared to average readers